
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Today’s guest is recently retired and is excited to have more time to read in this chapter of life. She wants to find good books and, in particular, long books that she can really sink into, but her library holds keep wreaking havoc with her well-laid plans. When Amy Czuba wrote into our submissions page with this plea for help, we could not say no.
After wrapping up her career as a global HR leader, Amy said goodbye to Massachusetts after living there for nearly 40 years and moved to Charleston, South Carolina, where she’s now enjoying soaking up the history of her new hometown.
Amy is here today seeking ideas for those long books that she’s craving. She would especially enjoy a book that teaches her about a topic she might not otherwise learn about. Amy also has a goal to read more books from her as-yet-unread pile of titles that she already owns, but she cannot resist a shiny new library book that’s available for checkout at her local branch, and this is keeping her from reading through her owned titles. I have ideas to share.
We’d love to hear your library holds list strategies: please share those with Amy and all of us by leaving a comment below.
Our eighth annual Fall Book Preview releases on Thursday, September 17th to members of Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club and our Patreon All-Inclusive and Bonuses & Events tiers, plus our a la carte ticket holders. The Fall Book Preview experience includes our 12-page digital PDF lookbook and an invitation to our live Unboxing event happening at 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time on September 17th. This year we are also offering a printed, delivered by snail mail lookbook that is available as an add-on to your Fall Book Preview experience order or as a standalone purchase. This year’s lookbook is different from past editions in several ways, including its format: it’s 6 by 9 inches, 12 pages, and designed as a professionally printed, genuinely useful, delightful little zine kind of lookbook that will ship straight to your mailbox for around 10 bucks, including shipping. We hope the lower cost makes it easy to say yes to our lookbook this year. Mark your calendars, get your a la carte ticket, or just get more information at modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp.
AMY CZUBA: I have to tell you, like I said, I just went to the DMV in South Carolina to get my license, and it's been really, really hard not to drive myself immediately over to the local library and get a library card. I know I will do it, but I'm trying really hard not to do it right away.
ANNE BOGEL: Because why?
AMY: Well, because then I'll be back in the problem of getting all the library books.
ANNE: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading, and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:54] Readers, we are airing this conversation on September 1st, which means fall is nearly here, and that means one thing at What Should I Read Next? HQ. It is almost time for our Fall Book Preview. Our eighth annual fall preview releases on Thursday, September 17th to members of Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club and our Patreon all-inclusive and bonuses and events tiers, plus our à la carte ticket holders.
Once again, our Fall Book Preview experience includes our 12-page digital PDF lookbook and an invitation to our live unboxing event happening at 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time that night, September 17th, plus our unboxing video recording. This year we are also offering a printed, delivered by snail mail lookbook that is available as an add-on to your Fall Book Preview experience order or as a standalone purchase.
[00:01:43] This year's lookbook is different from past editions in two big ways. Maybe three ways, actually. The first is that to a greater extent than in any of our previous spring and fall previews, I wanted this year's lookbook to stand alone and be useful apart from unboxing. And unboxing is fabulous and useful and will do great things for your fall reading life, and I hope you will come. But fall is busy, and if you don't feel like you have time for that, get the lookbook. It's great. It's 6 by 9 inches, 12 pages. It has an inky, kinda hand-stamped, zine-inspired, pleasantly packed with readerly goodness kinda feel, and it's more than a list of titles. I clearly lay out the four and five-star reads I've already enjoyed for the season to come.
And I gotta tell you, this section is a lot bigger than I initially thought it would be before I started reading from the just astounding selections that are on offer this fall. Plus, in the lookbook, there are dozens more of my most anticipated titles and short descriptions, and I do mean short, about each one of them. My team chimes in in our lookbook with their most anticipated fall releases, plus backlist favorites that feel just right for fall. You are going to want to tuck this lookbook in your journal, take it to the library and bookstore, or bring it to coffee with a friend so you can talk about great fall books.
[00:02:58] Now, this year, from the beginning, I also prioritized designing this little lookbook in a way that we could deliver a professionally printed, genuinely useful, readerly, delightful little zine kind of lookbook straight to your mailbox for right about 10 bucks, including shipping. And we did it. I hope the low cost makes it easy to say yes to our lookbook this year.
Mark your calendars, get your à la carte ticket, or if you're not yet a member of one of our communities, sign up now and enjoy our original Fall Book Preview experience as an included perk. Talked a lot about the lookbook in the past couple minutes because that's so different this year, but the full Fall Book Preview experience is worth taking part in, and I hope you will. Sign up now, place your order, or just get more information at modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp for Fall Book Preview. That's modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp.
[00:03:52] Readers, today's guest wrote into our submissions page with a plea we could not say no to. Amy Czuba is recently retired. Not too long ago, she wrapped up her career as a global HR leader, then said goodbye to Massachusetts after living there for nearly 40 years and moved south to Charleston, South Carolina, where she's now enjoying soaking up the history of her new hometown.
She enjoys pairing an active reading life with being active outside, getting out to walk, play golf, and tennis. As you'll hear, she is excited to have more time to read in retirement. She wants to find good books and, in particular, long books that she can really sink into, but her library holds keep wreaking havoc with her well-laid plans.
Amy is here today seeking ideas for those long books that she's craving. She would especially enjoy a book that teaches her about a topic she might not otherwise learn about. Amy also has a goal to read more books from her as-yet-unread pile of titles that she already owns.
[00:04:51] This is really important to her, and she has already identified a major obstacle in making this happen. She cannot resist a shiny new library book that's available for checkout at her local branch. Amy wants to know if I can save her from her library holds. Amy, I hope so. I have ideas. We will see what she thinks. Readers, let's get to it.
Amy, welcome to the show.
AMY: Thank you so much, Anne. I am super-duper excited about being here, and probably still having heart palpitations from that email I got.
ANNE: Well, I'm excited you're excited. Thanks for coming on.
AMY: My pleasure.
ANNE: Amy, we'd like to start by giving our readers a glimpse of who you are. Can you tell us a little about yourself?
AMY: Sure. So I'm calling from Charleston, South Carolina. My husband Steve and I just recently moved here a few weeks ago, after living in Massachusetts for 40 years, so that was a big move for us. But the other recent big thing for me is I just recently retired, couple of months ago. Retired. I worked at a large global technology firm. I used to say I'm the least technical person working at a technology firm.
[00:05:59] I was a director of HR. I had a global team of HR chat reps that I managed. Really super fun job. I miss the people a lot. But one fun fact about that is that I took your podcast format, and I used it for my quarterly check-ins and year-end annual performance reviews. So the format that I used was, tell me three things that went well, one thing then that didn't, and what you've been working on lately for your development. And it was just such a great format to kinda kick off those conversations and kinda hear from people.
ANNE: Ooh. Well, I love that. Thank you.
AMY: You're welcome. I just gave credit in my meetings. I'm like, "You guys know I got this from a podcast that I listen to." And so it was always fun.
When I'm not reading, I enjoy staying active. I like to go for walks, maybe jump on my Peloton bike. My husband and I both golf. He is a little bit better. I'm pretty terrible at it, but I do enjoy it. Play a little tennis. Anything to kinda just keep moving.
[00:06:56] We also recently learned how to play mahjong, which is, you know, sweeping the nation by storm, I think, and that's been a lotta fun. I personally love going on historical tours, so Charleston has been a great city to move to for that. Of course, New England was great, living in Massachusetts all that time. And then, you know, we also just enjoy going to the beach with a great book. That's very fun as well.
Then also, as a family, we love Disney, and we tend to go about once a year, and I always bring, or not always, but I have been known to bring a book in my backpack into the park so that I have something to read while we're standing in line, or while I'm waiting for the rest of the family to get off a ride that I don't like to go on anymore. So always have a book with me, for sure.
ANNE: I mean, I believe that's a rule many of our listeners live by.
AMY: Absolutely.
ANNE: Now, Amy, this is broad on purpose. Would you tell us about your reading life?
[00:07:52] AMY: Sure. I tend to read about 50 books a year. I don't watch a lot of TV, so that gives me time to read. I love to read every night before I go to bed, and I'll sneak it in throughout the day whenever I have a few extra minutes. Like I mentioned, I try not to go anywhere without a book, although the other day we went to the DMV to register our cars and get our new licenses, and I was so wrapped up, Anne, with all of the paperwork that we needed, that I left my book on the counter of our kitchen. Luckily the wait wasn't too long, but as I was driving over there, I'm like, "Oh, shoot, I forgot my book."
ANNE: I think I read half a book the last time I was at the DMV.
AMY: I believe that.
ANNE: I'm glad it wasn't too bad.
AMY: I believe that. And the thing is is I like a hardcover book, so I'm not going to pull up a book on my phone. I don't even use my Kindle anymore really for the most part. I like the actual book. I do like audiobooks too. I mean, love audiobooks. I've read some of my favorite books on audio, but I always listened while I was commuting to work, and so to be honest, I really haven't listened to an audiobook since I retired, so I'm a little sad about that.
[00:08:55] The types of books that I love to read, like my go-to genre has always been historical fiction. That's my favorite. But I really love narrative nonfiction. I like literary fiction. I love biographies and memoirs. And when I want to mix things up or get like a palate cleanser, I love a good mystery or a crime thriller. I feel like those are kinda my comfort reads. When I need to mix something up, I'll go back to a series with the same characters that I just love having them solve another mystery. And I'm the type of reader I don't try and figure out the mystery, so I'm always surprised at the end, which makes it great.
I'm in a couple of book clubs so I tend to end up reading maybe some books that I wouldn't normally choose, and that's always good. I really have to have my books grounded in reality. I don't like any kind of sci-fi or fantasy or magical realism and that type of thing. And I have tried. I mean, like, my husband loves sci-fi and fantasy, and he's tried to get me to read some of those books, and they're just not for me.
[00:09:53] Now, the only exception to that is I recently read Hail Mary on audio, and I absolutely loved it. But the reason why I loved it was because of the characters, not so much the science and all that kind of stuff.
Romance will fill the spot once in a blue moon. I generally don't like it because I find it's just too fluffy, and obviously it's predictable. But, you know, every once in a while it will hit the spot. Bookstores, love going into a bookstore. I can't go into one without buying at least something. But I'm really addicted to my library. I mean, I just walk into a library and think, "Oh my gosh, look at all these free books."
And when I hear about a book that I want to read, I end up just immediately going to my library app and requesting it. And then all of the library books come in at the same time, and I'm walking out of the library with a stack of books and coming into the house, and my husband's looking at me like, "What are you doing?" I'm like, "They all came in at the same time. I can't help it."
[00:10:51] My mom just said to me this morning, "I think the Franklin Library is going to go out of business since you moved." And I said, "That is not true." But I do really enjoy the library and getting the books. I have to tell you, like I said, I just went to the DMV in South Carolina to get my license, and it's been really, really hard not to drive myself immediately over to the local library and get a library card. I know I will do it, but I'm trying really hard not to do it right away.
ANNE: Because why?
AMY: Well, because then I'll be back in the problem of getting all the library books. And I have so many boxes of books here, Anne, that we are unpacking. I've gotten a few of them unpacked. But, like, all these books that I own that I would like to read, and I have not to get to them because I'm always reading the library books. It's a problem.
ANNE: Amy, I think we should tell our listeners that the headline on your submission was, "Please save me from my library holds."
AMY: Yes.
[00:11:51] ANNE: Your relationship with your library sounds amazing, except it seems... I'm imagining that it's not delivering the reading life you want, the reading experiences you want. Is what's the opportunity cost here the right question?
AMY: Yes.
ANNE: Tell me what I need to know.
AMY: Okay, so here's the way my brain thinks. When I go into a bookstore and I'm going to purchase a book, I want to get the very best book I think I'm going to love, that I'm going to pass off to my friends. And so I buy what I think are going to be the top five-star reads. I'm buying those in person, and now they're on my bookshelf. When I think of the library, I'm like, "Oh, well, there's no harm, no foul. If I don't like the book, I'll just request it, and if it's not great, that's fine, because I didn't pay for it."
So what ends up happening is, a lot of times I'm requesting books from the library that, ah, those sound pretty good, but maybe they don't sound amazing. And so I get a lot of pretty good books from the library, but meanwhile, some of the books that I think are going to be the best sit on my bookshelf unread. So it's kind of a mixed bag. I mean, sometimes I get amazing books from the library. And actually, some of the very best books I've gotten from the library, and now I'm sad that they're not on my actual bookshelf. So it's a mixed bag of problems.
[00:13:05] ANNE: Amy, I did notice that when you described what you love about the library, like you walk in, you see what you want, you take it home, I did notice that when you hear about a book you want to read, you request it immediately. When you walk in, you grab what looks good. This sounds so much fun. And also, it sounds like there's not a lot of filter in place. Like, you may more carefully filter... I mean, you just said what you get in the bookstore.
AMY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: All right. Amy, this is kind of weird for me, but I'm thinking of a clothing shopping analogy. I don't like to clothing-shop. I really like to shop for books. But I'm thinking how when I'm going through the items on the sales floor, there's a lot of stuff that looks like it could be promising, but the next step is I take it into the dressing room and I evaluate it and see if it fits and see if it works, and I take home a fraction, if anything, of what I walked into the dressing room with.
[00:13:57] And I wonder if this is kind of the difference between shopping at the bookstore, where perhaps you're, like, going into the dressing room and vetting them a little more carefully versus requesting things or picking things up at the library where you're like, "Oh, that looks good. That looks good." I guess your dressing room is at home when it comes to the library.
AMY: Yes. I mean-
ANNE: So at some point you have to filter.
AMY: Exactly. Yeah. And I'm filtering really carefully at the bookstore because I'm going to pay money for them, right? You want to make sure it's really, really good, something that I've wanted for a while, that I've heard about for a while. And yeah, with the library books... and you never know when they're going to come in, so it's always a surprise.
You might get something that's great, or you might get something that's marginal, or something's like, "Why did I even request this book? I don't even remember." But it's a low-risk thing because you can just return it if it's not for you.
[00:14:47] The other problem with my library books is, like, I can't tell you how many times I've checked out a book one, two, three times, and I've always had to return it because I never got to it. So that happens to me also.
ANNE: Okay. So it doesn't cost you anything in cash.
AMY: But it costs me my time, because I'm spending time reading those, whereas I've got some books that I own that I'm not making the time to get to, which is crazy.
ANNE: Now, you've said a couple things that we could explore more. I did notice that you said there, you don't know when your holds are going to come in. Would it change things if you could? Because in many library systems, it's possible to know, and even to choose or prioritize when your holds come in. So that is something to explore.
I also notice that you don't always remember why you requested something, and I wonder if implementing just, like, a little jotting. Like, if you're going to request a book, then your rule with yourself is you have to write down, "Oh, I heard about it on What Should I Read Next?", or, "I saw it on Instagram," or "My friend told me about it in my Tuesday book club." You could perhaps, if that would help you.
[00:15:52] AMY: That's a great idea.
AMY: Yeah. And you know what makes me crazy is I don't know how to track that on Goodreads. Like, how do I track where I found that from, or who told me about it? And I don't know if I just don't know how to use the app very well, or if it's really not a function of Goodreads.
ANNE: Okay. Readers, I bet you can tell us. Please go to whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com and go to the show notes on this episode and tell Amy and I in comments. We would love to hear if this is something that you use Goodreads or Storygraph or your online tracking site for. And then a lot of books get returned unread.
AMY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: I don't necessarily think that's a problem. A lot of books that you buy probably also go unread for a time. I believe that's part of the Save Me From My Library Holds request.
Amy, what would you like your reading life to look like? And I'm specifically thinking what you want to be reading, how you want to feel about what you are reading, and, I mean, even better, if you have this in mind, what role would you ideally like to see the library play in your reading life? How would you like it to support you instead of perhaps be in competition for your attention and priority reads? That's a lot of questions, but what rises to the top?
[00:17:08] AMY: The thing that kinda jumps out at me is an equal trade-off between the books that I own and the library. I mean, I don't want to ignore the library completely, or maybe I make it a reward. Like, "Amy, if you knock off two books from your personal bookshelves that you own, then you can go get a couple books from the library," and make it more of a fair trade-off.
ANNE: You're thinking like a balance?
AMY: Yes.
ANNE: Like a read one from one category and one from the other?
AMY: Yes. Yes, because what happens is I'll get a stack from the library, and then I'll feel like I need to power through six books before I ever go back to one of my books for more.
ANNE: I hear you. I mean, I heard you say you could use the library as a reward, but I think we can hear how much you enjoy going to the library and seeing what you'll find, what have already heard of that's there available for you right then. That's delightful.
AMY: It's fun.
ANNE: And also I imagine you discover new books at the library.
AMY: Yes. Also true.
[00:18:08] ANNE: So we want you to have that. But I do wonder if there is a way, or if this even sounds attractive, to put a beat between seeing the book and thinking, "Oh, I want to read that really soon." Because we're readers, lots of books look good, we probably want to read more than we realistically can. So that is going to be a constant tension. And it's a wonderful thing that you're seeing all these books that sound promising, and also, it doesn't change the fact that you can only read so much.
AMY: Right. All true.
ANNE: Okay, Amy, you know how this works. You're going to tell me three books you love, one you don't, and what you've been reading lately, and then we are going to talk about what you may enjoy reading next. We're going to think about this library dilemma. Is it fair to call it a dilemma?
AMY: Mm-hmm. Of course.
ANNE: And also, you came with another request about a certain kind of book, so we aren't going to forget about that either.
AMY: Okay, great.
ANNE: Okay. How did you choose these?
[00:19:05] AMY: All right. It was funny, when I went and looked at the list of books that I had submitted with my form, I was like, "Oh, gosh, I put that on there?" So it was kind of funny. And really it was only a couple of months ago, so you'd think I would've remembered.
Anyway, the first book that I chose is called Challenger: A True Story of Heroism and Disaster on the Edge of Space by Adam Higginbotham. This is an example of narrative nonfiction, which I really, really love. I first came across this book at my favorite bookstore back in Massachusetts, which is An Unlikely Story in Plainville, and it's... I noticed it because I had read another book by this author called... well, it was called something about Chernobyl. I forget the total title of-
ANNE: Oh, Midnight In?
[00:19:51] AMY: Yes, Midnight In Chernobyl. Exactly. And that was excellent. So I saw this one, and, you know, I'll just say that those of us of a certain age, we all remember exactly where we were when the Challenger shuttle exploded. And that was in 1986.
And if you're too young to really remember this, this shuttle exploded seconds after takeoff, and all seven crew members obviously were killed. The reason why this particular shuttle flight was so in the news was because it featured Christa McAuliffe, who was a high school science teacher, and she was the first-ever teacher to go into space. So the publicity around this was huge.
This book follows the seven crew members and their lives, so you really get to know all of them. Also, the history of the space program, and they go way back decades. And it's a really gripping account of NASA and how the space program worked. And all of the mismanagement and miscommunication and programmatic decisions and problems that were made all along the way, the funding issues, the political pressures, the go, no-go decision makers, the whistleblowers, everything that contributed to the disaster.
[00:21:04] And if you remember back to that time, we all knew, like, immediately came out, oh, it was the O-rings, the O-rings. So we all knew it was the O-rings. When you read this book and you kinda see the progression of all the problems, it is amazing, and it was fascinating and it was gripping, and it really read like a thriller-type of story. And so I just really love narrative nonfiction about a topic where the author just does such detailed research, but then they put the story together in such a consumable and accessible format and so easy to read. I just loved it.
ANNE: Okay. Thanks for telling us about that. I didn't realize that was the same author as Midnight in Chernobyl. This is the first book I've read by him. Amy, what's the second book you love?
AMY: The second book I chose is The Bee Sting by Paul Murray. This was one of the books I was honestly surprised that I had on here, but it really represents a book that I cannot stop thinking about. When I was done with the book, I didn't even know what to think about it. I was just kinda so blown away.
[00:22:08] But it is a story... takes place in Ireland. It's a story of a family of four: a mom, a dad, a son, and a daughter. The time period is recent, like after a very bad economic downturn in Ireland, and this family is falling apart for a whole bunch of reasons, which you will learn reading it. But it's really interesting in that it's told in like four sections. So the four different points of view, one for each member of the family.
It starts off with the daughter. She's a teenage daughter, and she is finishing up what's the equivalent of high school in Ireland and getting ready to go off to college, and of course, just thinking about herself and everything like that, but also thinking about her family. Her family used to be a more affluent family in the town. I think they owned a car dealership. But with this economic downturn, they're losing their money. And so all of a sudden, things are happening in their family, and it's hard for her to deal with, of course. So you get her perspective.
[00:23:03] Then the book shifts to the perspective of the son, and I think he was about 12 in this story. He's just really innocent, and he's lonely, and he's looking for friendship, both in person and online, and he's dealing with a local bully, and he's trying to understand everything that's going around him, too.
Then the third perspective is from the mom, and you get the backstory of her life and how it ended up with Dickie, her husband. Things start to get pieced together when you kind of see this whole background there, things that you really had no idea.
And then the fourth perspective, fourth part of the story is from Dickie, who is the father, and boy, does he have some dark secrets. And you get his backstory, and then you kinda see why he has ended up in such a mess. Then at the end of the book, all four of them come together in this one time, this one night. I'm just going to say that if you read this book, you have to buddy read this with someone or do it with a book club because you are absolutely going to need to discuss the ending with somebody.
[00:24:12] I had listened to this on Audible, and then it just ends. I'm like, "Wait, what?" And I'm like, "I need to discuss this with someone." Of course, I knew no one who had read it at the time, so I couldn't discuss it with anybody. I think that's why it took me such a long time to kind of really digest it, but I can't stop thinking about it. And these characters are so vividly fleshed out.
But this is a stressful book to read. Bad things kind of happen to this family, and they are making some poor decisions along the way. And I just remember, I think it was particularly the little boy's segment, and I just kept saying, "No, no, no, don't do that. Don't do that." It was a little bit stressful. But I mean, it's just brilliant writing. I love anything that takes place in Ireland, so that was also great. But that was my experience with The Bee Sting.
ANNE: I do not understand the word funny being attached to this book, which I've seen. I mean, I don't know. What did you-
AMY: I would never think of that word as the way I would describe it.
[00:25:12] ANNE: I've seen this slotted as humorous fiction, and I do not understand.
AMY: Oh, no.
ANNE: I found this riveting, but also just completely harrowing.
AMY: Riveting in that I had to find out what was going to happen to them at the end, like how this was all going to wrap up. I had to find out.
ANNE: It was tense?
AMY: Yeah, tense.
ANNE: It was such a tense reading experience. And a very long reading ex... okay, this is a very long book. Talk to me about that.
AMY: Oh, I love long books. I just love to sink into a really long book because I do, I think it gives time for the author to really give you the backstories, give you a lot of descriptions of what's going on, give you the character development that I love. I just love sinking into a really long story. Now, this one, like I said, I listened to it on Audible, and sometimes on Audible you don't realize how long it is. And then when I saw the book in the bookstore, I'm like, "Oh, wow, this was a longer one."
[00:25:59] I love long books. I mean, I generally think anything under 400 pages is like a rip-off, you know? It's like, give me a 500-pager plus. And when my friends will say, "Oh my gosh, we can't read that for book club, it's 500 pages," I'm like, "So?" To me, that's average. I just love long books, and I always have. I can remember, I think I was in college, sitting by the pool reading ...And Ladies of the Club, which is like a 1,200-page book, and thinking nothing of it.
ANNE: Okay, noted on the long books. Amy, what did you choose as your final favorite?
AMY: Okay, my final favorite is The Heart's Invisible Furies by John Boyne, and this really represents my favorite book from one of my very favorite authors. I have recommended this book to everybody, and I've bought it as gifts, and I just adored it.
It's another Ireland story. It's really the story of one man's life, and his name is Cyril, and it's got an interesting format in that it's told in increments of every seven years. It actually starts when his mother is pregnant with him, so that's the first section, and then it jumps to when he's seven, and then after a little while, it jumps to when he's 14. Then it jumps to when he's 21, and it goes throughout his entire life until he's of older age.
[00:27:20] Not only do you get to follow his life, you know, he's got a lot of struggles, he has a lot of joys, really great character development in this, but it also takes you on a journey through Ireland from the 1940s to the current day. I don't think it's a spoiler alert to say that Cyril is a homosexual man, and so you deal a lot with that in Ireland, the social norms.
It was illegal for so many decades, the Catholic Church and the power of the Catholic Church. You really just get so much texture and context about the different time and period. He's just a character you just love him, but sometimes you want to shake him. Like, "Cyril, why are you doing that? Don't." You know?
I just remember listening to this on audio, and I was driving to work, and I was almost to work, and the book was just wrapping up, and I just remember the tears coming down my face, and I'm like, "Okay, Amy, get it together. Now you have to go into work." You know what? My notes here, I'm like, "I am not a re-reader," but I really feel like this is definitely one I should re-read because I just loved it. It's wonderful.
[00:28:27] ANNE: All right. Amy, now would you tell us about a book that wasn't right for you? And it's important to hear why, if you're able to put your finger on it. Like, did it not align with your taste? Was the timing all wrong? Was it about a topic it turns out you don't want to read about in literature? What did you choose?
AMY: I feel like I need to duck because everybody is going to throw a rotten tomatoes at me, but-
ANNE: I hear you stalling.
AMY: The one I chose was Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry. The reason why I chose it, it was my most recent not-for-me. It certainly wasn't the worst. And as I was kinda reviewing some books for this podcast, I was looking back through my Goodreads, and boy, there are some duds in there that I have read. But this was just my most recent not for me.
Honestly, I think it was an issue of timing and my expectations and what I was hoping for in a book. I had recently read Theo of Golden, which I loved. It was just like a warm hug, and, you know, there's a lot of tough things happening in the world these days, and I just thought Theo of Golden was wonderful. And I think I was looking to replicate that feeling, to be honest.
[00:29:35] So I had heard about Jayber Crow on your podcast, and specifically, the anniversary episode, I think had a number of different guests come on and give a quick blurb about why they loved it so much. So when I was at a bookstore and I saw it, I thought, "Oh, this sounds perfect for me," so I grabbed it. And here I am reading one of my actual books, which was great but just not enough was happening for me.
This book takes place in an early 1930s small-town life, I think, in Kentucky. Starts with the main character as a boy, and then he grows up, and he becomes the town barber. It's definitely one of those kinda just character-driven stories, which I do tend to love. I don't have to have action-packed plots and things like that, but it just not enough was happening for me.
[00:30:20] I think maybe it was too close following on the heels of Theo of Golden, which was, you know, one of those nice soft books, and I think I just needed something different. Also I had a stack of library books staring at me in the face on the counter too. I got about halfway through the book, and every night I would get into bed, and I'd be like, "Ugh, I guess I should read this." And I'm like, "Amy, you're clearly not loving this book. Just set it aside. It's not for you right now." And so I did. I set it aside. It wasn't for me right now.
ANNE: Okay. Amy, I heard you reference ideas like it was slow, leisurely paced. You said you were seeking a read-alike, so something charming, whimsical.
AMY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Okay. Wendell Berry might be gentle, but... oh gosh, I remember laughing once when I saw Jayber Crow in a grouping of books about sad, small towns. And I thought, "Wow." I mean, that's not wrong, but also, what company to keep. It's very character-driven, very leisurely paced and that was not what you were seeking at that time.
[00:31:31] AMY: You know what? I just kept thinking to myself, I need something to happen. I need some more action. And I believe I set it down, and I went right to, like, a mystery thriller. So the timing just wasn't right.
ANNE: Okay. Also, it doesn't crack 400 pages.
AMY: No. But that's okay. I mean, I read plenty of books that don't, but you know.
ANNE: So not a rip-off, but not for you.
AMY: Yeah, exactly. Not a rip-off, but it wasn't for me.
ANNE: You are allowed to declare Wendell Berry not to be to your taste on this podcast.
AMY: Okay, thank you.
ANNE: All right. All right. Amy, what have you been reading lately?
AMY: I feel like I've been on a really great streak. I just read The Whistler, finished that a couple of weeks ago. It's a wonderful story. Again, short story. I mean, it's not a short story, but I mean, it's... I don't even know if it's 300 pages. But it's by Ann Patchett. I just adore everything that she writes. Really, really great contemporary story.
[00:32:25] Then I read The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett, and that was an easy five-star read for me. I mean, just really hit all the things that I love in a book: historical fiction, great characters. This book is really... it's about 1930s Mississippi and women's rights or lack thereof and things that used to happen all the time, but truly it's a story about sisterhood. I just loved it. And that's a big book. That was over 600 pages, and I flew through it because it was so good, and then I was really sad when it was over. So that was a great experience.
And then just the other night, I finished John of John by Douglas Stuart, and that one was really good too. It is a story about a young man who comes from a small Scottish island, and most of the people there are weavers or sheep herders, and they don't have a lot of money. But he was one of the few people that got to go off to a college, and now he's finished college, he's broke, he doesn't have a job, and he has to return home to the island. And he doesn't want to.
[00:33:28] He's kinda coming back with his tail between his legs. He doesn't want to go, but now he's gotta acclimate himself again to life with his family and his friends and life on the island. Really great story. Again, great character development, such a sense of place. Like you could just imagine these Scottish islands. That one was really good too, so I definitely recommend that. So had a good run.
ANNE: All right. I'm glad to hear it. Amy, what are you looking for in your reading life right now? I have to say, this is the place where we want to talk about your library holds and your long books. Is there something else you want to throw into the mix? Now's the moment.
AMY: No. I mean, I really, really want some long books. Now that I'm retired, in theory I should have a lot more time to read, and so should give me plenty of time to sink into a really great long book. Although, you know, with this recent move I haven't had quite as much reading time as I thought I would have, but that's going to settle down very, very soon.
[00:34:27] I find that heading into the fall and the winter tends to be a great time to also read long books. You just feel cozier and can really settle in with them. So long books. I'd love maybe a historical fiction selection, like some big long sweeping saga. I would love a narrative nonfiction.
What I have kind of discovered about myself is that I kind of love a book about a random topic that I know absolutely nothing about, if the author can really turn it into a compulsive, readable story. A few examples of that were The Boys in the Boat, which is about a crew team from the University of Washington in the 1930s, and I thought it was absolutely riveting. Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe, which is all about Ireland and the IRA, which I knew nothing about as well. And then I also read a book called Everything Is Tuberculosis. I forget who the author is on that one.
ANNE: It's John Green.
[00:35:23] AMY: But it was all about tuberculosis. And it's like, who knew I'd be so interested in this? That's a really short book, but it really packed a punch. I loved it. So really looking for things like that, that I can really sink into. I love to learn when I read, so something that I can learn about, and maybe a mix between new-to-me books and maybe things that are currently sitting on my shelves. Who knows?
ANNE: Okay. And we want long bo... not all long books, but long books.
AMY: Yeah, long books.
ANNE: Okay. Amy, since you said in your submission that you're not getting to the books you own and you want to prioritize some of those, we asked you to send some of those books that you really wanted to get to sooner rather than later. And I'm looking at those lists. So we're going to draw some from there also.
AMY: Okay, great.
ANNE: Okay, let's recap real quick. The books you loved were Challenger by Adam Higginbotham, The Bee Sting by Paul Murray, and The Heart's Invisible Furies by John Boyne. Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry was not for you, and lately you've enjoyed Ann Patchett's The Whistler, Kathryn Stockett's The Calamity Club, and John of John by Douglas Stuart.
[00:36:29] You have referenced Irish fiction over and over. We've heard about your love for narrative nonfiction, and I'm looking at this... It's not a long list of books. I think there's maybe 16 to 18 on this list. But you did send some books that you thought you may enjoy reading next.
Also, I want to say, we are facing a new literary season, and there is so much Irish fiction coming out. Now, some of it is short, some of it is short, but I don't know, I wouldn't call Louise Kennedy a rip-off at any length.
AMY: No, she's good. I've read some of hers.
ANNE: As just one example of many. So I think there is going to be more on the way, more we'll talk about this on the show, more that I can't wait to talk about in Fall Book Preview, that I think will really pique your interest. But let's look at these titles.
The first one that jumped out to me, I think especially with your book clubs ringing in my ears, was Caste by Isabel Wilkerson that could've been on your list for... I mean, not forever. Some of these books are quite old, and this one just came out not much longer than five years ago. Okay, I heard you gasp. What's that about?
[00:37:38] AMY: That has been sitting on my bookshelf probably since it came out. I was going to guess five years ago, but four or five years ago. I think I bought it right away, because I loved her other book, The Warmth of Other Suns. So when this came out, I'm like, "Oh, for sure I'm going to buy it," and it has sadly sat on my bookshelf for so long, and I look at it all the time, I'm like, "What is wrong with you, Amy? Just grab it and read it." So, yes, tell me more about why I should put that to the pop- top of my list.
ANNE: Well, I think it's also ringing in my ears because I was in conversation earlier this week with a group of readers sharing the books that prompted the best book club conversations they ever had. And Caste by Isabel Wilkerson came up several times.
AMY: Okay.
ANNE: If you enjoyed The Warmth of Other Suns, I felt like this one was even more story-driven. I know that readers will often use or hear the phrase, like, "Oh, this is nonfiction that reads like a novel." And Isabel Wilkerson does not write like that, nor is she trying to, but she does this incredible job of writing these narratives that feel like she's telling you an important story that makes you want to lean in and say, like, "Just keep it coming. Just keep talking. Tell me more. Tell me more."
[00:38:56] But for those who've already read The Warmth of Other Suns, or those who haven't, this feels either like the obvious next thing to read next. But no prior experience with her work is required. But she tells this story about how... well, one formative experience in her own life, and also one important conversation helped her understand that maybe we shouldn't be evaluating the history of the United States through the lens of racism, but perhaps America has been shaped by a hidden caste system.
Here she's arguing for this idea that if you want to understand US social hierarchy, which might sound a little textbooky, but Isabel Wilkerson is not dry when it comes to explaining these concepts that, like, we are immersed in and living in, and describing how people live their lives and think about being human and think about being in society and relationships. I mean, Amy, I know from what you enjoy reading that this is something that you find inherently fascinating.
[00:39:52] But because of this nudge she was given in a conversation long ago, she realized that understanding the United States as operating under a caste system unlocks things in her own mind and in what she's found many people's understandings. So what she describes a caste system as being a deeply entrenched, but totally invented method of categorizing people by birth.
Here she links the caste systems of India, Nazi Germany, places that we may think, like, "Oh, of course," while excluding the US from there. But she says, like, "No, it's how the United States fits into this picture," and just does this deep dive into caste and also history, class, race, social norms. What I think really makes the book for many readers is she explains the concepts, but the stories she tells that really helps them make sense, sink in, come to life, not only are vivid and fascinating and sometimes horrible, but also I think really cement the ideas in readers' minds, where it's the kind of book that sticks with you for the long haul.
[00:41:07] So you know how you ended up putting this on your shelf, and what you had in mind when you thought about maybe reading it. Like, how is it sounding right now in that light?
AMY: Oh, it sounds amazing. I'm like, "What have I been doing letting that linger on my shelf for so long?" It sounds amazing.
ANNE: Well, we want to save you from your library holds and you know, the newer, shinier arrivals. But I hope you find this to be one that has earned its spot, and that there's a good reason it's been hanging out for a while.
AMY: Great.
ANNE: So you recently loved The Calamity Club.
AMY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Kin by Tayari Jones isn't by any means a readalike, but this has so much in common with The Calamity Club. It's sadder for sure. But I think what you'll find here is you've got historical fiction, great characters that you are deeply invested in from early on. You've got a historical setting, not the same, but I think pleasantly different while being pleasantly similar. But as far as sisterhood stories goes, oh, my. How did this end up on your list?
[00:42:11] AMY: Interestingly enough, I belong to a... it's not really a book club, but Ann Patchett, who owns a bookstore in Nashville called Parnassus, she has a monthly club that you can join. It's called The First Editions Club.
ANNE: The First Editions Club.
AMY: Yes. And so every month she sends a book, and it's been signed by the author, and Ann writes this really wonderful letter in there about why she picked the selection and what she thought about it and why she thought it'd be good for this book club. So every month I get one of these, one of these books. I haven't had it that long, but I haven't gotten to it either.
ANNE: Okay. Well, it's only 384 pages. But I mean, Tayari Jones, never a rip-off. My reading experience, which might not be the same as yours, it took me a little bit to figure out which character was which, but then I was off and running and just drank it right down.
AMY: Oh, good.
[00:43:05] ANNE: This is a platonic love story. The two women, who are so c... when I say sister story, I'm thinking about Vernice and Annie. They're two girls from small town Louisiana who feel psychically bonded in that they both lost their mothers when they were babies. One was murdered, one ran off to Memphis, but they are both gone. And on the brink of adulthood, Vernice goes to Spelman and marries rich; Annie runs away from home to try and find her mother, and she just encounters one devastating obstacle after another on her journey.
But they stay in touch through it all, and they remain the most important in each other's lives. But then when one of them really needs the other, like, whoo, the story enters a whole other... I think you may really enjoy it.
AMY: Ooh.
ANNE: It would be an excellent companion to The Calamity Club. I also think it would be an excellent companion to readers, if you remember me talking about These Heathens by Maya Mackenzie from last year's Summer Reading Guide. Not readalikes, but just books that really feel companionable. How's that sounding?
[00:44:11] AMY: Oh, it sounds amazing. Right up my alley.
ANNE: I'm glad to hear it. I am wondering about doing a... I mean, Middlemarch was jumping out at me. I didn't want to recommend any of your series installments because... you know best there. But I will say, many What Should I Read Next? listeners would definitely say, like, "Don't sleep on that, Amy." Like, "What are you doing? Why is that, why is that book hanging out?"
Middlemarch jumped out at me. It's a book that's referenced so often in literature, and I think I... That sounded a little nerdy. What I mean is there are so many references in mainstream books and also very literary works about... You know, are those even different? Not really, but Middlemarch references abound. I just finished reading Jane Smiley's 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel, which I know I mentioned here. She talks at length about Middlemarch.
[00:45:01] You know what Middlemarch does? Okay, I think this is why it's jumping out for you. As you've been discussing the books you enjoy and why, I've been wondering how much you might enjoy seeing authors analyze real events, history, people and their actions, the whys behind what we do. I wonder if there's something there about Project Hail Mary, and why that was the exception in the sci-fi fantasy you don't usually enjoy, and why perhaps Wendell Berry wasn't it for you. But I am wondering. Is there anything there?
AMY: The only thing that worries me about Middlemarch, and you can tell me one way or the other, sometimes these classical books are hard to read because the language is from the 1800s, and it takes a while to get into. Is this a book that I will find difficult to read, or will I be able to kinda, like, after a little bit just kinda sink right into the language and totally get it?
ANNE: Ooh, okay. I'm sorry to say I don't know, because I listened to Juliet Stevenson read it to me. And I find that when the language in classic books is not so smooth to the modern ear, a skilled narrator who, like, it just rolls off their tongue, it eliminates that gap between how we talk in the... I mean, George Eliot wrote this in the 1870s. She was writing about the 1830s. It feels more current.
[00:46:23] But I will say many readers say that part of the pleasure of reading Middlemarch is just the consistently striking sentences and turns of phrases, and how it just feels good on every line. And that doesn't sound like a description people give to archaic language.
AMY: Right. Right. That's interesting what you said about audio versus, on the written page, because I found that true with Pride and Prejudice. I could listen to it on Audible. It was great. It was one of those times when I think I had it from the library, or... At any case, after a couple of weeks, the audiobook just got scooped off my device, like my time ran out on it, and I wasn't quite done. And I thought, "Well, I'm just going to pick up the book from the library, and I'll just finish reading the book."
I picked up the book, I opened it up, I'm like, "I can't read this." It was just too difficult to read on the page, but the audio was amazing. So that's something to think about.
[00:47:19] ANNE: That's a common experience. And the only thing that really makes me hesitate on Middlemarch, I mean, if you hadn't said you hadn't listened to an audiobook since you retired, I'd say, "Amy, just pick up the audio." But that being what it is right now, yeah, I leave that in your hands.
AMY: Okay. Well, I can just pick it up off my bookshelf as well. So maybe that's- Oh, that's-
ANNE: Oh, yeah, so true. Yeah, give it a try and see what you think. I wonder if you may find that worth your while. And at 900 pages, it is definitely not a rip-off.
AMY: Right.
ANNE: Okay. So you also mentioned in your submission that something that you really noticed about pulling that list of books together that are on your shelves, that it's made you realize how much you love nonfiction books about random topics you know nothing about. And I was wondering if we might want to end with a few titles in that direction.
AMY: Yes, please. I would love that.
[00:48:12] ANNE: Okay. I kinda want to ask you what random topics you don't know anything about. But let's do three that are pretty different. Does that sound okay?
AMY: Okay. Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Have you read anything by David Grann? Killers of the Flower Moon is his best-known. But-
AMY: Yes, I read Killers.
ANNE: Okay. How about The Lost City of Z, his earlier work?
AMY: No.
ANNE: Okay. The subtitle of this is A Tale of Deadly Obsession in the Amazon. This is about an expedition in search of an ancient civilization into the Amazon wilderness in the 1920s. The whole crew vanished, and they were unfound for many years because the forest was thick and it wasn't clear exactly where they'd gone. But the lead on this crusade left a few clues behind about the undiscovered city he was seeking that he called Z.
[00:49:08] So for many years, scientists and explorers have been looking for what happened to this expedition and what he might have discovered before his disappearance. So, David Grann found this collection of diaries of the lead on this expedition, and he embarked on his own quest to solve the mystery, and he found out he's not the only one. Like, other people are in the jungle looking to find out the truth of what happened 100 years ago. Bum, bum, bum. Okay, how does that sound to you?
AMY: I've never heard of this. I've never heard of The Lost City of Z. I didn't know that there was a crew that disappeared. This sounds exactly like something I would love because... Except for... you know, one thing about reading books about the Amazon is I do worry about the snakes.
ANNE: Oh.
AMY: I don't know if they got attacked by snakes or not. Or there are probably references to snakes, but that's... I'll just kinda pass over that when I get to the snake part if there are snakes in there. It's a jungle, right? Yeah, there's going to be snakes.
ANNE: It is. It is a jungle.
AMY: But yeah, no, this sounds great.
ANNE: The snakes might not be the worst part.
AMY: Okay, okay.
[00:50:11] ANNE: I mean, you said topics you don't know anything about, okay?
AMY: Yes.
ANNE: I might recommend a shorter book like Trash by Simon Paré-Poupart from the Summer Reading Guide, but I wasn't going to, because that's so short. That might be unwelcome. But it's there. It's out there. Now, I'm just really apologizing for recommending a book about parking, but I do wonder if you might enjoy- something super nerdy like The High Cost of Free Parking by Donald Shoup. It's 800 pages about the economic structures that are invisible to most of us that support the use of the car in many communities, including the one I live in, likely including the one you live in.
This is the kind of book that you read... I mean, you read a chapter, and then you think about it every time you walk down a city street. But he evaluates parking, mostly in the United States, how we got where we are, how decisions are made, how making different decisions impacts how people respond and what the communities look like. Is this sounding terrible or perhaps intriguing?
[00:51:21] AMY: No, this sounds really, really good. I don't know if this is the same book that I, or if I read a phrase about something that says people don't realize that when you go to like a Walmart or a big box store and you have to park in that giant parking lot, the distance you walk from your car into that store is no different than the distance you might walk on a city street or a small town downtown area that you have to park and walk to. But people don't like to go to the small downtown areas because they think they're parking so far away from the store. Is this along the same lines, or is this the same concept from this book?
ANNE: It's not dissimilar. But what Donald Shoup is going to do is he's going to say, "Why is the parking lot so big in the first place?" How does the zoning work? Yeah. What does it mean? Why is it in the front and not the back? What could be different? How does consumer behavior change when we alter the variables? What happens when we change the zoning laws to restrict fewer parking? Why are the zoning laws what they are? How'd they get that way in the first place? What changes when you charge for it? Oh my goodness. Right now, as we record, they've just announced that they are going to start charging for some suburban mall parking in my community, and-
[00:52:33] AMY: What? People must be losing their minds.
ANNE: People feel a way about it. But I think Donald Shoup says, "Read this book, you'll never look at a parking spot the same way again." 100% true.
AMY: Oh, that sounds so good to me. It's funny because I just moved to a new community, and we are... This community, it's within the city of Charleston, but we're far away from the downtown city of Charleston. We're a little bit further up. And it's all being developed. We're kinda one of the earlier communities in here, and it's all going to be developed over the next 10 to 20 years, and it's going to change so much.
But we're very close to Mount Pleasant, which compared to the Northeast... So if you live in a city in the Northeast, the big joke is all the towns are designed around the original cow paths when people had their cows grazing in the town common, and the cows would walk home, and that's how all the roads came to be.
[00:53:28] I mean, it's so hard to find your way around in Massachusetts if you don't know where you're going because the roads make no sense. But when you come down here to Mount Pleasant, for example, it is a community that has been developed over the last 20 years or so, and it just makes so much more sense the way they've designed like the shopping and the roads that get you through. I'm just so curious about this topic. Who knew I was going to be so curious about this? But we're living in an area that's going to be going through this development, and it will give me a lot to think about, for sure.
ANNE: I'm really interested to hear how what you find in these pages will connect with the two most recent places you've lived. Like what a fascinating contrast, too. So you could see some of the differences he's talking about, and sometimes advocating for, sometimes just observing, play out before your eyes and in your experience.
AMY: Awesome.
[00:54:22] ANNE: Finally, knowing your love of History, I'm wondering about something by Andrea Wulf. We did talk about... We. I talked about The Traveller in the summer reading guide, but I think The Invention of Nature: Alexander von Humboldt's New World would be a really interesting pick for you. It's pleasantly long at... It's almost 600 pages. Is this a book you're familiar with?
AMY: I have never heard of this.
ANNE: Okay. So The Invention of Nature, this concept, of course, is what... you know what nature is, I know what nature is. But Von Humboldt really changed the way that we think about the natural world. So now he's known as the Father of Modern Environmentalism. He was certainly the most famous scientist of his age. He was born in the late 18th century, and just had this innate love for outdoor exploration, and he traveled the globe just searching for unusual environments.
[00:55:23] Amy, I'm noticing a kinship with you, who likes to read about random topics you don't know anything about, just for the pleasure of learning new things. I mean, he got around. He was friends with Thomas Jefferson. He was an inspiration to Darwin and Thoreau, and he really wanted to help people understand our relationship to the natural world and helped us think about it.
So this is a biography that also takes you by, through following his life through scientific discoveries, through a variety of sometimes familiar, but sometimes really fascinating far-flung places, and also into the Royal Court of his patrons, for example. How's that sounding?
AMY: It sounds really good. I've never heard of him. I've never heard of the book. It definitely sounds like something I would learn a lot from in a really great way.
[00:56:15] ANNE: Andrea Wulf has this gift for combining these really deeply researched topics with their emotional meaning, and it makes for really satisfying non-textbooky kind of reads.
AMY: Ooh. It's going to make me want to look her up right after this call and see what else she has written too.
ANNE: I recommend it. I recommend it.
AMY: That's great.
ANNE: Okay. Can we look at where we are?
AMY: Yes.
ANNE: All right. So we're looking to save you from your library holds by focusing on some books already on your shelves, and also books that you would be glad to know about that maybe aren't going to be face out at your local library or not going to hunt you down on Instagram, but might be right up your alley, especially focusing on those nonfiction reads that you really love to read about... How would you finish that sentence? Unknown topics to you?
AMY: Yes, yes.
[00:57:13] ANNE: Okay. So from your own shelves, we talked about Caste by Isabel Wilkerson, Kin by Tayari Jones, the shortest book we talked about, almost, but not quite 400 pages, and Middlemarch by George Eliot. So we have two novels in the midst of this nonfiction
AMY: I think from that group, I'm going to grab Caste first because-
ANNE: I love that choice for you.
AMY: I am. It's been on there for so long. It's always looking at me. I've always wanted to grab it, and this is the perfect time to grab it and read it. So I think from that group, Caste.
ANNE: Okay. And then to satisfy your realization that you love nonfiction books about random topics you know nothing about, we talked about The Lost City of Z by David Grann, The High Cost of Free Parking by Donald Shoup, and The Invention of Nature by Andrea Wulf. What do you think about those?
[00:58:14] AMY: I think I'm going to go for The High Cost of Free Parking.
ANNE: Not sad about it. Very curious to know what you think.
AMY: I mean, obviously all of them will end up on the list, and I'll definitely get to all of them, but for some reason, The High Cost of Free Parking just really sounds fascinating to me right now.
ANNE: I love it. All right. Amy, this has been a pleasure.
AMY: Oh.
ANNE: How are you feeling about your library situation?
AMY: You know what? I am super excited. Now I can go to the library and get a library card without feeling guilty about it, and enjoy the new libraries that we have down here in Charleston. And I can't wait.
ANNE: All right. I'm so excited to hear it. Thank you for talking books with me today.
AMY: Oh, thank you for having me. It was absolutely so much fun.
[00:59:02] ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed my discussion with Amy, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next. Find the full list of titles we talked about today at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
Keep up with what's new around What Should I Read Next? HQ on Instagram, where you will find us @WhatShouldIReadNext. We also send out updates right to your email inbox. Join our list at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
And if you could, would you please make sure you are following us in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, or whatever your favorite podcast player happens to be. This is a free and easy one-click way to help support our show.
[00:59:44] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir (Audio edition)
Challenger: A True Story of Heroism and Disaster on the Edge of Space by Adam Higginbotham
• Midnight in Chernobyl by Adam Higginbotham
The Bee Sting by Paul Murray
The Heart’s Invisible Furies by John Boyne
▵ Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry
• Theo of Golden by Allen Levi
• Whistler by Ann Patchett
• The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett
• John of John by Douglas Stuart
• The Boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown
• Say Nothing by Patrick Radden Keefe
• Everything Is Tuberculosis by John Green
• Caste by Isabel Wilkerson
• The Warmth of Other Suns by Isabel Wilkerson
• Kin by Tayari Jones
• These Heathens by Mia McKenzie
• Middlemarch by George Eliot
• 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel by Jane Smiley
• Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen (Audio edition)
• Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann
• The Lost City of Z by David Grann
• Trash! by Simon Pare-Poupart
• The High Cost of Free Parking by Donald Shoup
• The Invention of Nature by Andrea Wulf
: Guest favorite book
▵: A book they didn’t love
• An Unlikely Story (Plainville MA)
• Parnassus First Editions Club
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Please save me from my library holds appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
Readers, last week you heard part one of our team’s selections for their best books of summer. And as promised, today we’re back with another round of book talk.
In today’s episode, you’ll hear from Executive Producer Will Bogel, Community Coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, Community Manager Shannan Malone, and Media Production Specialist Holly Wielkoszewski.
As with last week, today’s team members represent a cross-section of the bookstore. Today’s conversation features sci-fi and fantasy picks that range from cozy to dystopian, thrillers and stories with non-stop action, memoir, and nonfiction.
If today’s conversation adds a new title to your reading list or you have a suggestion to share, we’d love to hear about it. Please tell us more by leaving a comment below.
Today we’re talking about summer books we’ve loved, but fall is just around the corner and that means it’s almost (or already!) sweatshirt season. Our shop is freshly stocked with all colors and sizes of our MMD Sorority Sweatshirt. We spent literal years finding just the right source for this sweatshirt: after a long, painstaking process, I’m thrilled with how it came together. Based on our original sales from our limited spring release, so were you. Order yours now and shop all our merch, including our newly available Fall Book Preview print lookbook, at modernmrsdarcy.com/shop.
[00:00:00] SHANNAN MALONE: Well, I guess I am the regular, normal reader who, for the summer, wants fun, fun, fun books.
HOLLY WIELKOSZEWSKI: My next book is very fun, Shannan.
WILL BOGEL: That sounds super fun!
BRIGID MISSELHORN: Don't worry-
SHANNAN: Well, I know you have more, but, you know, that just seemed kind of bleak.
WILL: Well, yeah. Yeah, sorry.
SHANNAN: I tend to like those kind of books, though, Will. You know that they make me think differently about something or encourage me to pursue a goal. The book I'm bringing was not that, and I enjoyed it so much.
[00:00:43] ANNE BOGEL: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. This week, we are back with part two of our team's summer reading superlatives.
Readers, today we're talking about summer books we have loved, but fall is just around the corner, and to me, that means it's almost sweatshirt season. Forget "almost". In my house, sweatshirt season is here because Will Bogel just picked up an enormous shipment of brand-new sweatshirts from our local printer. That means our shop is freshly stocked with all colors and sizes so you can get your new sweatshirt now.
I love a great sweatshirt, even better if it's got a logo or saying that I enjoy putting on my body. That's why we've taken great care to create stylish and comfortable sweatshirts for our Modern Mrs. Darcy shop each year. And we've recently restocked this year's new style, our MMD sorority sweatshirt.
[00:01:55] We spent literal years finding just the right source and design for this sweatshirt, the right colors from the Comfort Colors brand, and crucially, well-made appliques in just the right navy with white stitching around the edges.
You know how I'm always quoting Wallace Stegner, who says, "Hard writing makes for easy reading"? Well, my experience has been quite similar with our sweatshirt design. And after a long, painstaking process, I'm thrilled with how it came together and how beautifully simple it looks. Based on our original sales from our limited spring release, you are, too. We promised that we would restock sizes and colors for fall and let you know as soon as they are in. So they're here. Get yours now.
If you're on the hunt for the perfect sweatshirt for back-to-school season or any time of year, if you're lucky to live in a place where it's not blazing hot in the summer, whether you're the student going back to school or you are just ready for fall and its comfy layers and long sleeves, check out our MMD sorority sweatshirt and all our merch, including our newly available Fall Book Preview print lookbook at modernmrsdarcy.com/shop.
[00:02:58] Readers, last week you heard part one of our team's selections for best books of summer. As promised, today we're back with another round. In today's episode, you will hear from executive producer Will Bogel, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski.
As with last week, today's team members represent a cross-section of the bookstore. Today's conversation features sci-fi and fantasy picks that range from cozy to dystopian, thrillers and stories with nonstop action, memoir, and nonfiction. Readers, it's always a good one when our team is on. Let's get to it.
[00:03:36] WILL: Well, welcome everybody. Glad to be talking summer reading with you again. We were just laughing off mic that we are calling in from a little bit different locations and time zones and all that stuff. I've got Shannan, Brigid, and Holly here. And Holly, it is what time of the day there?
HOLLY: It is 6:06 in the morning-
WILL: 6:06.
HOLLY: ...here in beautiful Australia.
WILL: Okay, in Australia, yeah. And my kid just walked in from school. So little bit different, little bit different right now, but we're all eager to talk about our summer reading. A week ago I did not think it was the end of summer. I'm like, "Well, we can't record. Summer's not over." And then, yeah, we took a kid back to college, and one of them started... You know, it feels like summer's over, even though it's...
SHANNAN: A point of order. I refuse to allow the machinations of society and school boards to determine that summer's over.
HOLLY: Hear, hear.
SHANNAN: It is still happening in my house.
WILL: Okay.
SHANNAN: It is still 99 degrees outside.
WILL: Oh yeah, it's still plenty summer here, too.
[00:04:35] SHANNAN: It is still summer.
WILL: But you know, when the kids go back to school, all the lifeguards are gone. And like, so, you know, you...
SHANNAN: Ah.
WILL: Fair. They shut down the water park at the big amusement park, and so...
SHANNAN: Mm-hmm. Fair.
WILL: All kinds of falls apart, so.
SHANNAN: I just refuse to yield.
WILL: Well, continue doing your summer reading, Shannan. You've got at least three weeks until Labor Day.
SHANNAN: Thank you. I do.
WILL: How's your summer reading going?
SHANNAN: It has not gone as I expected it to go, which I believe I say at every summer reading event that we have. I always think that I haven't read anything, and then I do the preparation for the event, and I realize, "Oh, I have read like six things." Like, okay, that's not too bad. Okay, two per month. I always think that I want to read sci-fi/fantasy during the summer. I always plan to go into the summer reading sci-fi/fantasy. And it turns out, the past couple years, I have not enjoyed that. I have not read any... I have read mystery and thrillers...
[00:05:40] WILL: Summer mysteries.
SHANNAN: ...for the summer, which I did not realize that, which is why reflection is good for the soul. Now, my midyear check-in I did with Anne on Episode 533. Yeah. So I won't go into all of those details because I've already done that. So you guys can go. But that was interesting that I noticed in preparation for this event.
BRIGID: Interesting.
WILL: I always love looking at my journal and going, "That's not what I remember... that's why I write it down, right? Because that's not what I remember." So yeah. Brigit, how about you? How's your summer reading been?
BRIGID: Well, I'm really laughing over here because we've had a really busy summer, Shay Misselhorn, as we like to call it. We've had road trips, beach time, art museum, summer camps, food poisoning, colds. You know, all-
SHANNAN: The gamut.
BRIGID: A full summer. But when I went to check my Goodreads and StoryGraph in preparation for this, I panicked also because I thought, "Wait, I haven't read anything this summer." But I had tricked myself, you guys. I was like, "What am I even going to talk about?" But then I remembered I'd been keeping a totally separate note of all the summer books. Thank goodness.
So just like you said, good thing we write it down well. But yeah, I'm really glad. I'm going to enter all those books into my Storygraph and Goodreads after this. But overall, I've felt like I've had a really top-notch summer reading experience, thanks to some really interesting finds that I'm going to talk about in a little bit. And independent bookstores, they have really helped me. We visited quite a few over the summer, and that's where I found some of these.
[00:07:23] WILL: Nice, nice, nice.
SHANNAN: That's nice.
WILL: I forget that... That's one of my favorite parts is, like, whatever you're reading, but like, why? Why now? Like, how'd you find it? That kind of thing, you know?
BRIGID: Yeah, yeah. "Why did I pick it up?"
WILL: You know, can relate to that. I have a line in my reading journal that is blank because I'm sure there's a book that goes there, but I don't know what it is. Because I'm looking at this, I'm like, "Okay, read that. I finished that at the beach. I can't imagine that I started this other book at the beach, but, like, what was I reading in between?"
So I went flipping through my Kindle to see, like, can I find a title? And I didn't notice anything there. I'm afraid it's a library book, so it went back to the library, and I don't know what... I don't know. Because I'm looking at the stack of books, and I was like, "Oh, yeah, yeah, I pulled those out for the beach," and I don't know what it was. I might be missing the best book I read this summer. I don't know.
SHANNAN: That's a problem.
WILL: That would be terrible, wouldn't it? I think I'd remember the best book. Holly, what have you been reading as you travel?
SHANNAN: And it's not summer there, is it, Holly?
[00:08:18] HOLLY: It's not. It is winter here, which I'm actually really enjoying. Every time we've traveled to this part of the world before, it's been summer or summer adjacent, so it's a very different vibe. I feel like I historically have had much better reading seasons in the winter than I do in the summer. And I think that that is what's contributing to my excellent reading recently, which has been great.
So when we had our kind of midyear freakout, I had a similar commentary of, like, my reading life's been weird, my Storygraph's been a mess... it's not been bad, it's just been weird and kind of unexpected.
Well, I've gotten my Storygraph sorted. I'm no longer in process of reading like 22 books or however many I had marked over there. It's now down to a reasonable maybe seven or something. And yeah, the cool weather. We've had a couple of rainy days. I mean, to be fair, where we are, the weather has been much more what I would consider fall weather, and that's been really nice. But it's been a little bit more of that cozy vibe of curl up with a good book. We've had a chance to do a few things that work really well for reading. Like we took a train, a five-hour train across part of the country...
WILL: Oh, fun.
[00:09:29] HOLLY: ...which was not particularly exciting for any other reason other than being on a train and getting to listen to an audiobook while you look out the window, which is one of my favorite modes of travel, no matter where I am. So that was fun. The other thing I really just enjoy is having access to books that I don't easily have access to in the US. You know, some of the Australian fiction and things that are not as readily available. So it's been a good summer/winter. I still have it summer in my brain, so I'm good with that language today.
WILL: When you're thinking about doing your midyear freakout, were you still stateside then?
HOLLY: I was, yeah.
WILL: Okay. So summer was still not great.
HOLLY: Summer was still not great.
WILL: And then you went over there.
HOLLY: Exactly. Yeah, yeah. That was still there. And I think at the time of recording that, we still weren't sure if we were traveling or where we were traveling or anything. That was all very much up in the air, so it's come together quite well.
[00:10:19] I'm pleased with how everything's going. I've gotten some interesting books that I wouldn't have necessarily picked up otherwise. And I have a follow-up question, Will, which is I think that you can get your library hold or your library checkout history if you really need to go and track down that book. So that is my reminder of something you probably already know.
WILL: You're right. I'm sure I could. If I wanted to do that much research, I'm sure I could.
HOLLY: If you do. If you have time and energy for an extra little research project.
WILL: Buried somewhere in the settings there, yeah. Well, it sounds like your reading life needs a snowbird-sorta situation where we just kinda keep...
HOLLY: Apparently.
WILL: ...keep it always cool and ready to cozy up.
HOLLY: Yeah, maybe I will win the lottery, so that can always be true.
WILL: There you go. Keep playing. Somebody's going to win.
HOLLY: Somebody somewhere.
[00:11:12] WILL: It might be you. I have felt like I've had a really weird, hard reading summer. I don't know if that's necessarily true. Looking what I wrote down or whatever, I read a lot of nonfiction in the summer, and it turns out I've read a lot of nonfiction this summer, but I don't know, it's been bad. I didn't know what to read. Talk about bad, I just don't know what to read.
So when we went to the beach, I do a fair amount of reading while we're on vacation, and I packed more physical books than anybody else in the house because I just didn't know. I was loading books on the Kindle that I'd be like, "Oh, Anne read that before, so I want to make sure it's downloaded on mine, and here's an ARC that she has in advance. I could get that." And then also I got two library books.
So I get all this stuff, and then I put it in airplane mode because I'm like, well, I don't want the thing to connect and my library holds to disappear, you know? But I didn't know what to read, and so I came back, and the books are still there because I just haven't ever connected back to my home Wi-Fi, and finally read the last one that I'm like, "I'm never going to get this back if I return it to the library or whatever."
[00:12:14] So I've been a little fickle, I guess, on what kinds of things I want to read, you know? I'm settling back in. I was 10% of the way into a book the other day, and I texted my daughter to be like, "I'm really hung up on this stupid thing. Does it end? Does it get better, you know?" She's like, "Oh, yeah, that's real short." And within 2%, 3%, they had moved on, and it was over. But I was like 10%, I'm like, "I don't care," and she's like, "No, no, no, that's real quick." So it ended. I'm moving. We're doing okay.
SHANNAN: I've done that with Brigid. I asked Brigid, "Is this going to resolve?" She was like, "Nope." I said, "DNF, thank you very much."
WILL: It is great to know people that you can ask. Like, "I got into this, but I'm not sure what I've signed up for." Brigid, I'm real curious, you said you've got some good books that you really had a great experience kind of finding them at different places, and we're excited to get ahold of them once you finally found your note that told you what they were. So would you tell us?
[00:13:17] BRIGID: Yes, yeah, I'm more than happy to. I'm going to start with the most quirky, weird one. This book is for anyone who likes a weird, weird little book. I saw it on a table at Schuler Books, which is in Grand Rapids, and it was next to Open Throat by Henry Hoke and Audition by Katie Kitamura, and I was like, "Okay, I'm going to get something like a fever dream novella." And it is. And it's called Mostly Hero by Anna Burns.
Now, some people might be familiar with this author because she wrote a Booker Prize-winning novel called Milkman. I have not read that. This was actually written prior to that, but it's now being re-released in a hardback format, and it's bright neon green. So the cover just drew my eyes right to it. And so I picked it up, and I thought, "Oh, this is cool cover." And then the inside flap said follow Hero, the Superhero, as he saves the world from villains and falls in love with a femme fatale named Femme Fatale. And I was like, "I'm in. I'm in. I don't need to know anything else. This is coming home with me."
[00:14:30] And I soon found out that that is a similar naming convention she used for Milkman as well. Milkman is the character Milkman. So this is something she does in her writing. But when I tell you I just adored this really bizarre, silly book.
So you've got Femme Fatale, she's in love with Superhero, but unbeknownst to her, Femme's very sweet great aunt is actually Great Aunt the Supervillain, and Great Aunt the Supervillain is Hero's arch nemesis. And oh, also, Femme Fatale is... So the Downtown Eastside villains have put Femme under a magic spell created by evil wizards that make her randomly try to kill the Hero as well.
I mean, I'm not even making this up. It's hilarious, it's witty, it's silly, but it also makes super astute observations about society, family, relationships, love. I just could not put it down. It's short. You can read it so quickly.
[00:15:39] I would say the best thing to equate this to is think of the big fight scenes in an Avengers movie, but instead add in some Lemony Snicket kind of vocabulary and humor, and a battlefield of intimacy, if you can think of it that way. It is a love story, but it also... it's just wild. I'm so glad I found it.
WILL: I'm imagining Adult Swim. That's kind of what's in my head.
BRIGID: Yeah, yeah, it kind of has that vibe. I can see that. I can see that, yeah. At one point Superhero says something like, "Women being angry equates with the end of the world." And I was like, "Yep, okay." I just thought it was so funny. Very wild. And I'm thankful to an independent bookstore just having it on display next to two other books that I loved.
WILL: Very nice. Holly, you said you picked up some good ones from the various different sort of stores that you've been able to get to there in Australia.
HOLLY: Yeah.
WILL: What have you found?
[00:16:46] HOLLY: The first one I'll share is a memoir. It's called Always Home, Always Homesick by Hannah Kent. It came out in April 2025. You might recognize Hannah Kent's name. She wrote Burial Rites, which is a novel that I believe has been talked about on the podcast before, and I have known about her from that book. I went back and looked in my Storygraph. Apparently, I read it in January of 2014, if my dates can be trusted that far back, which is a question I'm not very clear on, and I gave it four stars at that time. I read it at the time that I was very much, and still am, to be fair, obsessed with Iceland. So Hannah Kent's kind of been an author in my circle of awareness, but I haven't read anything else by her.
I saw this memoir on the shelf. I actually saw it, I believe, last time I was in Australia, but it was large format, and I had carry-on and I didn't have a lot of time, and I was like, "Oh, I want to read this book, but I cannot read this book right now, physically." And it's not something I've been able to find distributed in the US.
[00:17:50] But this is a memoir of Hannah Kent's year abroad in Iceland when she was 17 years old. She went on a Rotary Exchange program. She was sent out to this tiny little village, didn't know the language, didn't know anything. She came out of Australia to literally the other side of the world, and how that experience just completely changed the trajectory of her life and her career and set her on this path that she would follow.
I just loved this memoir so much. It was written during the time of COVID. It was looking back at her experiences and her, like, now after multiple times of returning back to Iceland in the course of researching for and then writing this novel, Burial Rites, how she ingrained herself with the local community and leveraged deep genealogical resources and everything in writing this book. And also kind of what it means to have two feet in different countries and your heart split across different parts of the globe, and to be in places that you love, but also places that you can't be in all the time.
[00:18:55] This spoke to me on so, so many levels, and it was just a wonderful, beautiful memoir. I found it at my friend Renee's indie, where she works here outside of Sydney, which was great. I saw it on the shelf. It was a smaller format this time because it's been about a year, year and a half since it was initially released. I picked it back up, and I think it will actually be making the trip back across the ocean with me as one of my one to two books I'm able to fit into my carry-on luggage without overdoing the weight limits.
WILL: High praise. High praise.
HOLLY: So if you haven't read Burial Rites, it's not required to read that in order to enjoy this memoir, but I do think that they would be really enhanced by reading these books in close proximity. I'm actually thinking about going back and rereading the novel now, having had this context of how the story came together and how she was almost kind of haunted by this woman and this story over the years as she was writing this first debut novel.
[00:19:53] The story of how she wrote it is really a driving element of the memoir, and she takes us around all these places and the people that helped shape that story. So if you haven't read it, I would recommend maybe considering reading that first. But again, the memoir does stand alone as a wonderful book on its own.
I did recommend this book to Dana Prescott after our recent follow-up over on Patreon, and she said she was able to find it in her library system in Canada. So that might indicate it's becoming more available in North America in general, but I'm not 100% sure of its availability, especially digitally in the US right now. So that's a wonderful Australian find for me this summer and a really great book.
[00:20:37] WILL: One to keep our eyes out for. I also read a great memoir this summer. My son, who is probably the... He reads the least in the family. We'll just put it that way, kinda gave up on doing a book flood because we're like, "What do we give the one kid that doesn't read the book we give him?" You know? Not to disparage anyone's children or their reading habits. He just isn't into it, you know?
But he gave me a book for Father's Day, which was a memoir. It's really weird. The cover of this book is written as if the subtitle is the... It's kind of backwards. So the book is called Everything You Want Is on the Other Side of Hard, but then they sort of refer to The Other Side of Hard. Like his website name is The Other Side of Hard. He has a podcast that's called The Other Side of Hard. So it's all sort of flip-flopped that like the least important words are the first ones, you know?
[00:21:23] This is Ken Rideout. Came out this year. And I'm looking at this book, I'm like, "Okay, my kid bought it for me. What does he know about how to find these things?" I'm pretty sure he's just like Amazon top-running dad books. Like whatever, you know. Like I'm just not sure how he kind of comes across these things or whatever. But I was like, "You know what? I'll take it to the beach, thank you very much."
Ken Rideout is currently the Masters marathon champion. So it means he's run the fastest marathon in whatever year that was a little while back. I don't think it means it has like a world record, but in whatever season he won the championship race sort of thing, whatever. And then he ran the crazy why-would-you-do-this Gobi Desert race thing, which is like 10 days of like... You carry your own stuff and run across the desert. They give you water, and that's it. They'll set up a tent, but you gotta carry your food and all that stuff, whatever, as a whatever he is, 52, 54-year-old, something like that.
[00:22:18] So I'm pretty sure that's how I ended up with it, but it was a crazy story. As far as memoirs go, super readable. I'm pretty sure he didn't write it. You kind of get the idea that he got... I didn't check to see if there was a ghostwriter, but clearly got help because it was very well done and very much carried his voice. But sometimes people who are not writers trying to write their own memoirs, like they're trying to tell their own stories, and it's just not all that good. So this was super readable.
He starts out just in a really rough family situation and kind of chronicles, that, and then sort of the mindset of like, "I've got to get myself out of all this," into college and figuring out his first job. He ends up doing finance, and though kind of having a little bit of imposter syndrome, ends up landing several big finance jobs, and he's making tons of money and whatever.
[00:23:11] He gets addicted to opioids, so throughout this time period, he's on and off of opioids, like just back and forth and back and forth. He's got stories about the 2008 financial crash and all these things that are clearly a lot of pressure. Somebody's spending a lot of money on whatever. He's making a ton of money, like all this stuff. He's got all these things you could imagine, but he's also stuck with this thing that he can barely just function without it kind of deal.
And at some point... he's always been sort of working out. He had been a college hockey player and really thought he was going to go to the NHL, and that didn't work out. He's always kind of been into fitness stuff or whatever, but at some point he starts running, and the combination of like getting clean and running and whatever, he sort of turns into this marathoner, whatever guy.
[00:23:54] But it was a... You know, it's not heartbreaking. I was about to say heartbreaking. I don't think it's heartbreaking, but it's bleak at times, kind of deal. But where he is now telling the story, he really has a pretty good perspective on all of it.
I did finish the book and think, "Oh, I think he's addicted to running." Like, I'm pretty sure. He quit the pills, but like you now listen to what he's doing now, and then the commitments and all that stuff, I'm like, "Ooh, yeah, he still definitely has some addictive stuff." And I've listened to a couple of his podcasts, and he just straight up says that. He's like, "Oh, no, I don't think I'm not an addict. I'm still an addict, but before it was grim and I was thinking I was going to kill myself chasing whatever. And now I'm doing something that is productive and good for me and whatever." So I was like, okay, well. Because I kinda got the sense at the end of the book, I was like, I'm not sure how much of a redemption story this is. But he does admit to that kind of stuff. That's Ken Rideout telling his story about addiction and overcoming all that stuff. So The Other Side of Hard.
[00:24:56] SHANNAN: Cool. Wow. Well, I guess I am the regular, normal reader who, for the summer, wants fun, fun, fun books.
HOLLY: My next book is very fun, Shannan.
WILL: That sounds super fun.
SHANNAN: I know you have more, but, you know, that just seemed kind of bleak, so.
WILL: Well, yeah. Yeah, sorry.
SHANNAN: I tend to like those kind of books, though, Will. You know that they make me think differently about something or encourage me to pursue a goal. The book I'm bringing was not that, and I enjoyed it so much. It was a satisfying summer read. I kept turning the pages because I wanted to know what happened.
[00:25:45] The one I'm bringing was in the summer reading guide, so thanks, Anne. And it is The One Day You Were My Husband by Rosie Walsh. I have not read anything by her. Anne says she inhaled it in two days, and so I was like, "Okay." But when I went through the Summer Reading Guide, that category, which was mystery and suspense, I picked The Fine Art of Lying. And I read it, and it was fine. So I was like, "Oh, no. Oh, no. I'm not sure I should read The One Day You Were My Husband." I'm like, "I don't think this is for me."
I was so apprehensive. I haven't read any five-star reads this year, which is bothering me, and I was very afraid I wouldn't enjoy it. I mean, the premise: a girl marries a guy who gets arrested the day of the wedding, after the wedding. Like, I'm like, "This just doesn't sound appealing." But then I did my trick, which is where I download a sample on Kindle. And I started reading it, and I was like, "Oh, this is interesting. This is kind of interesting." The sample ran out, and I was like, "Hmm, kind of want to know what happens." But I was still apprehensive.
[00:27:15] WILL: Still interesting.
SHANNAN: I was still apprehensive. The writing was great, I have to say. I don't even know how to describe the style, but it felt not... A little literary. Like, very emotive, but still, you know, not too over the top for me. So I finally brought it to the Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club in a Sunday dispatch. I was like, "Should I read this? Let me know if I should read this." And everyone said, "Yes, you should." So I picked it up. I'm very happy that I did. I really, really liked it.
I wouldn't call it a five-star read, but it is very, very close. I kept turning the pages to see what happened. That was so fun for me. My mouth kept dropping open over and over again. I did not see the last mouth-agaping moment coming. Like, I was just like, Oooh. I think I picked up the phone at that point and texted Anne, and was like, "Oh, my goodness. What is this? I'm dying to talk about it with somebody."
[00:28:25] It was not what I expected also, because even though it was one of those turn-the-page, turn-the-page, turn-the-page, there was a lot of emotional resonance and emotional heft with it, I thought, and I was not expecting that. Again, it was mysterious. The end, didn't see it coming. I need a sequel. At this point, I want to know what happened to these characters.
I mean, she did end it very nicely. She did, and tied it up. I don't mind things being tied up nicely, and it was ended very well for me. But man, I need part two. Like, let's keep going. It doesn't need a mystery or a thriller. It can just be about their lives after that. I would love to read that. So, fun, interesting, mouth-dropping experiences. Very good. Very good.
WILL: Wow.
BRIGID: So excited to hear this, because I tried it on audio and it wasn't... I don't know, it just didn't grab me. So now I'm thinking maybe I need the pages so I can turn and turn and turn.
[00:29:31] SHANNAN: Well, you know how I feel about audio, Brigid. You know, generally I...
BRIGID: I do. I do.
SHANNAN: I only do memoirs by the authors in their own voice on audio, because I struggle with the whole people trying to emote. I'm like, "No, no. That's not right. The acting with the... No." So I read it. I would say read it just for the ending. I thought the whodun... It's not really a whodunit, but you do wonder what happened, and so I was blaming everybody. Like, "Oh, it's this person. It's gotta be..." Oh, it's definitely... Oh, yep, shady. And then, yeah, I did not see that coming.
WILL: That's awesome.
SHANNAN: That's my one book that I'm bringing.
WILL: It sounds like a great one.
SHANNAN: It was pretty decent. Now, that is to say there could be other books, but I have not finished them at the time of this recording, so they cannot be included.
[00:30:26] WILL: And you are on record that your summer's not over, so you've still got time.
HOLLY: You got time.
WILL: There you go.
SHANNAN: I do have time.
BRIGID: Okay, Shannan, so you mentioned you thought you were going to read sci-fi over the summer.
SHANNAN: I did.
BRIGID: Or fantasy. And I normally read thrillers or mysteries or suspense.
SHANNAN: You do?
BRIGID: But I read the sci-fi.
WILL: Okay.
SHANNAN: Okay.
BRIGID: This one, oh my gosh, I really think you and Holly would both love it. If you are not aware of it, it is Moss'd in Space by Rebecca Thorne. Came out this summer. My husband Chad has read the Tomes & Tea series by Rebecca Thorne. It starts with that book. You Can't Spell Tea Without-
SHANNAN: Treason Without Tea.
BRIGID: Treason Without Tea. So many puns. I love this. I love this about the author. But this is the first book I read by her. I had seen something pitched as Murderbot meets The Spell Shop. And I would agree, that is a pretty good pitch.
[00:31:28] I do think it'd be really good for fans of Becky Chambers' books. I would call this a cozy sci-fi. There is, though, a little bit of stakes going on here. So it follows... Well, I guess I should tell you the tagline first. The tagline's really funny. It's, "Human romance is ridiculous." And I was like, "This is just too cute." What a great little tagline.
And it opens with the ship log from the mechanical operation and support system, and that sub identity is Moss. So this is a life support system who calls itself Moss, and it truly is moss. So this moss is growing on a ship that has been left abandoned for a century. You read a few of Moss' logs and think of the voice like... it's like sarcastic space entity.
[00:32:24] To me, it reminded me of K-2SO, who is from Rogue One. That's Tudyk's role. That kind of humor or sarcasm. Soon thereafter, main character, Torian Razner, shows up with money to buy a ship to try to find a place to move with her sister, who is suffering from a breathing disorder on the planet they currently live in. I just loved her discovering Moss, because truly Moss is all she can afford with her credits, as you would say. It's just a lovely found family, true family, space adventure. I read it and listened to it at the same time, while I was reading it often, and it's really well performed by Dylan Fitzpatrick, who I'd never listened to read an audiobook, but all the other parts are done by Natalie Naudus, who is a favorite of mine. So I knew I was going to like that no matter what.
[00:33:33] It's wonderful sci-fi. I think it's perfect for any time of year, but could be good for fall. I happened upon this one at Sourcebooks in Detroit when we were traveling, and I'm so glad because the print copy is really beautiful, and it's a paperback original. The author, Rebecca, mentions in her acknowledgments how thankful she is that her publishers helped her to make something that was beautiful yet affordable for readers. And I really appreciated that. It was so sweet.
It does have an epilogue that's like an end credit scene from Guardians of the Galaxy. So I will mention that because it is book one in a series. And so the epilogue I would not say is a cliffhanger, but just keep that in mind. There is more adventure to be had. So that was my sci-fi for the summer.
SHANNAN: Sounds interesting. Holly, are you familiar with this one?
HOLLY: I am not familiar with this one, so I am definitely going to check it out. I particularly think the audio sounds interesting, so thank you, Brigid.
BRIGID: You're welcome.
[00:34:37] HOLLY: And I also have sci-fi for the summer, if we want to continue on a theme for one more book.
WILL: Yeah.
HOLLY: So my second pick today, I have two, is Seek the Traitor's Son by Veronica Roth. This just came out on May 12th. I have been really enjoying Veronica Roth's work recently. I think a lot of people know her from the Divergent trilogy series. I don't remember how many books ended up being in that, but that was, you know, back when The Hunger Games and everything were first launching and that was all the rage. But she's been doing a lot of writing more recently, and I found it to be really compelling and mature and interesting. This is a tome of a book, and I thought it was fantastic. So let me tell you all about it.
[00:35:25] First of all, I will say I got this through Bookshop as an e-book, and it is DRM-free, so thank you to Tor and Veronica Roth for embracing that technology. I appreciate that. This is a dystopian speculative fantasy with a little bit of sci-fi and romance. So it's basically a genre bundle of delights altogether.
It's set on a future post-apocalyptic earth, and at its core, it's about two women. One of them is Rava Bedar. She is the reincarnation of great warriors. She's a ruthless general, and she is part of the Talassar, which is the powerful nation that's in control of most of what's left of earth. This culture is savage and fierce, and they have been infected by this disease, this tremendous disease that kills everyone who gets this disease, but 50% of them then come back to life with new capabilities.
[00:36:28] The Talassar worship this disease. They intentionally infect everyone. They inoculate everyone. I don't know if that's the proper use of that word since it is a fatal disease, but people come back to life. I don't know about my terminology. But it's a really interesting structure and has led to this very kind of martial, powerful culture.
On the other side, we have Elegy Ahn. She is the second daughter, or the spare, of the leader of Cedra, which is the other nation that is here in a residual Earth. This is a small but very high-tech nation. They have fled the Talassar and their disease. They try to stay away to keep their people uninfected and mostly are split between a few small footholds left on the planet of Earth and their space station that orbits above.
[00:37:17] One of these two women is going to be the savior of their people that delivers them to power and prominence. But even the augurs, who are these fortune-telling clan of future seers, they don't know which one it will be. So that sets us up at the beginning of the story of these two kind of enemies who are pitted in this battle that neither of them really knew about, wanted to be chosen for, or knows how it will unfold.
And if that sounds a little bit complicated to you, it did to me too when I read the flap. I was like, "I don't even know what's happening here." But on the page, Roth makes it feel really fluid, really organic. It's laid out very nicely. So don't let world-building hold you back if this sounds like an interesting read to you.
WILL: Yeah, appreciate the caveat.
BRIGID: That was going to be my question.
HOLLY: Yep, yep. You know, Anne always says that hard writing makes for easy reading, and I know that's a quote that she has from somewhere that I can't attribute at this exact moment in time. But I think that this is a twist on that idea, that this is... I think Roth has put a lot of work into this world building, so it is complicated, but she's done it in a way that is really easy to read.
[00:38:27] So as we come into the story, we do see it from multiple perspectives of a few other characters, but overall, it's Elegy's voice that guides us. I was just really drawn into her journey, the unexpected twists and turns it took. We have, fairly early in the book, a major event happens, and then we have a time jump of several years, so we're able to see how these characters have matured and have responded to this significant event and what that has meant for their journeys.
We meet a lot of Elegy's network of friends and supporters and people. It's not something that I would describe as quite the, you know, cozy found family, but there is a really great character bank here of people that we get to know and care about and see how they are navigating this prophecy and this battle that is going on between their two countries and cultures.
The best news about this book is that it is part one of a duology, but Roth has come on record and said the second book is already written and is releasing in spring 2027. So we're not going to be waiting for however long it takes for fantasy and sci-fi authors to get to their next installment. I'm very happy about that.
[00:39:37] WILL: To write another tome.
BRIGID: What are you talking about? They always write them right away.
HOLLY: I know. Right away. It's no problem. So yeah, if you enjoy any of these themes, topics that I've mentioned here, I think this one would be a really great pick for you. It was a perfect summer read for me. It was immersive. I found it really page-turner. I really cared about what was happening to the characters and what might happen next, and it was just different enough from a lot that I've read in this space that it felt really fresh and really unique to me. So that was Seek the Traitor's Son by Veronica Roth, and you should probably find it on your new release shelf.
SHANNAN: Question, how old are the main characters?
HOLLY: Great question. They are older. I am struggling to come to an actual age, but if I was going to tell you, I think when they first start, they're probably in the like 20 to 22 range, and then we have a time jump of about four to five years, so by the time that the action is really happening, they're older 20s. They've had some careers, some work, some skills. There's some cred there. They're not middle-aged protagonists like one of my other recent books in the sci-fi/fantasy light pick, but they're old enough to not be annoying little 17-year-olds running around with all the magical powers.
[00:40:56] SHANNAN: You just answered the question that I was not asking.
HOLLY: So thank you. I'm here for you, Shannan. No problem.
WILL: It's like we know each other. Well, I also read a tome. It doesn't sound nearly as fun as your book, Holly. But yeah, I read a pretty long book this summer that I actually recommended. We were all sitting around talking about it, I was like, "Oh yeah, you won't believe it. This is good," whatever. But I don't think you care this much because like I'm only halfway through and it turns out more than 50% of the book was end notes. Right after I had that conversation, the book ended, I was like, "Oh, here? Now? Over?" It was enormous. So lots of detail, lots of... Okay, before I get to that, this spring I read London Falling by Patrick Radden Keefe. Oh, I see some nods. You guys know this. Okay. I thought that might've been a Summer Reading Guide book, but it was not in the Summer Reading Guide.
BRIGID: I haven't read it yet.
WILL: So...
BRIGID: I think it was in the Spring Book Preview.
[00:41:55] WILL: Okay. Okay. So Leigh is a big Patrick Radden Keefe fan and has been telling me for a while, like, "You've got to read Patrick Radden Keefe." Instead, I listened to his podcast. Have you listened to that? Really loves this podcast?
BRIGID: You recommended it to me.
WILL: Did I? Okay, good.
BRIGID: Loves this podcast, yep. And I loved it, devoured it.
WILL: So good. It's eight episodes on whether or not the CIA wrote the song Wind of Change by Scorpions. He does this investigative thing because he heard a rumor that maybe it wasn't actually written by them, and the CIA intentionally created this sort of anthem to help bring down the Soviet Union.
Anyway, great research, fun topic, you know, whatever. But I was always a little scared of his books because they're big. And I'm not sure why I jumped on London Falling, but started there because it's the new one. It's the one that just came out. I think I heard a podcast with him talking about the book, so I think that helped me kind of have a way in a little more than I have felt like I have when I go to grab one of these big, meaty nonfiction books on the shelf.
[00:42:56] This book just came out, but I think the story is maybe four or five years old. London teen from a pretty well-off family jumps out of a, whatever, I don't know, fifth story apartment or something like that, and his parents, when they find this out, are like, "Where was he? And with who? And why?" And like nothing makes sense.
And it turns out he was living an entirely different life, had made up this entire background, and was hanging out with some really rich and powerful people that apparently just didn't ask a lot of questions about where he came from. Both the author and some of the cops are like, "I don't know how this works." Like, "How did you all not know?" And they're like, "Yeah, we just didn't ask questions, I guess." A lot of handshake stuff, a lot of, "Well, I trusted this person who introduced me, so I figured he was cool, and I didn't have to do my own due diligence."
[00:43:44] He gets mixed up in this world, and what I believe now is pretty normal Patrick Radden Keefe ways. He goes into all these different things. What's going on in London? How did it become this town? Why are these people all moving to town? These people, lots of them being Russian. Where does the financial business in London, how does it convert from a port city to this big money machine? Why do people kind of turn a blind eye to some maybe not legitimate activities? There's all this sort of background as to what's happening in the city as we lead up to like why is this kid Zach fascinated by this? How does he insert himself into this world? What happens to him?
The only thing I really didn't like about the book, he handled it really well because he's talking to the parents, he's doing all this deep dive and all this stuff and it's not that old. They're baring their soul to him or whatever. It just didn't have a satisfying ending.
[00:44:36] SHANNAN: And it's one of your best books this summer without a satisfying ending?
WILL: Well, it's just a sad story. There isn't an ending that makes you feel better about it. It's a true story. And so you got to the end and you're like, "Oh no, that's what happened?" Like it just didn't kinda give you that hero's journey, you know, you kinda maybe think of the journalist as the hero. It doesn't give you that "And then I solved it." And apparently in one of his other books he solved an old mystery.
And so he's trying to tell, when he meets the parents, he's trying to tell them like, "I can't tell you I'm going to get the answers." That happened, but it's not like how it works, you know? And so he's kinda trying to frame expectations and all that stuff.
I thought it was great, very readable. He's super, super readable, so as far as detailed nonfiction, investigative sort of stuff, like yeah, he was super good. So that was the beginning of the summer. I was like, well, at this point I'm hooked. Leigh, I'm finally going to do it. I'm going to get Empire of Pain, which was the book I put on my Kindle and then put into airplane mode because I was like, "Well, I'm not going to get it... Like I don't know when I'm going to get it back. This is checked out quite a lot." And it was so long.
[00:45:40] Empire of Pain, if you don't know, is the story of the Sackler family who invented OxyContin. But the book... have any of you read it? Any of you?
BRIGID: No. I haven't read that one, no.
HOLLY: Just aware of it.
WILL: Well, I'll tell you, it's not as long as you think it is. When you pick it up there's a lot of notes. So don't be too intimidated. It's a pretty long book, but it's not as bad as you think. It starts with the previous generation of Sacklers. So right now the people that are like in court are the grandkids who've sort of taken over the business. It was the parents who pushed all the OxyContin stuff, but the story starts with the previous generation, the grandparents.
Holly, you were talking about world building. I do have a hard time keeping track of people, and every one of these people's name is Sackler. So there are three brothers. They get married, they have kids. All the kids' last name is Sackler. They all get divorced and get these trophy wives that are younger who are like, "Oh, I'm married to a Sackler. I'm changing my name," so they're Sacklers too. You know, it's just like all these... And then they all have families. And they all work at the company. So like there's just like all these Sacklers.
[00:46:45] And also one of the kind of things that they did as a business move is like it's all very, very tightly held to the family, but then also like very, very confusing. What businesses do they own? What business runs this other piece? So like it's not technically that business. They're kind of always shell games, moving things around and stuff like that. There is a point at which the older generation, he launches a pharmaceutical marketing company, and there's only two guys in town. There's him and the dude down the street, and they have all the big accounts. Everybody goes to one of these two. Well, somebody realizes he's the money behind the other guy. So he's playing both sides.
Anyway, it's shady all the way through and through. I mean, 60, 70 years of shady. All the things you may have heard about how OxyContin came to be and how hard they pushed it and some of the shady things they did and whatever, the grandpa did with Valium back in the '50s. Same playbook, same stuff.
BRIGID: It's hereditary.
[00:47:44] WILL: OxyContin is this miracle drug that we probably don't need is kind of basically what it comes down to. And they start just telling stories and like most of it is not true. Talk about a not satisfying ending. They do finally get a judgment against them, but there's so many lawsuits and all that stuff, the judge rolls them all up into one. And so it's like this is the last lawsuit, final, whatever. They gotta give up, I don't know, something like 9 billion of their $12 billion or whatever. But of course, he's doing all this research and realizes, but they could pay it over time, and it turns out $12 billion makes a lot of money, so over time they never lose their principal. They're making payments, but... Anyway, it's awful.
There's a whole story of the arts community, the artists and stuff like that, because they start pouring a lot of money into both medical research and colleges and all that stuff, and then also into the arts. There's the one particular artist who starts a group. She got hooked on opioids but had some art in... I think it was the Met. One of the museums. She had art in the museum that had his name on it, and she's like, "Oh, no." And they start staging all these die-ins and these big gatherings to sort of bring attention to like, you can't be taking these guys' money.
[00:48:59] But they did so much to avoid putting their name with the company. So everybody knew who the Sacklers were, and they donated a lot of money, and that they were rich, but nobody really knew why. Because when you talk about Purdue Pharma, no one ever mentioned their name. And they were very specific about that. All the press, all the whatever, they sent the like yes men out front to do things, and so like they just kinda stayed clean for a while.
So there is an end to that one, Shannan, but I don't know. If you sorta look around at what's going on or, I don't know, read Demon Copperhead or whatever, or read... So talk about a book fight. I read Ken Rideout about opioid addiction, and then I read about how that all happened, and I was like, "Oh, yeah. This is still happening." So, there's not really any coming back from that kinda deal. But Patrick Radden Keefe — my apologies, Leigh, for taking so long — he's great. Great research, great storyteller.
[00:49:54] BRIGID: Well, if you do want to switch to some fiction, my last book has kind of your...
WILL: Do you have another book?
BRIGID: Yeah, but it has your name written on it.
WILL: Because I'm like, downer, downer, d-
BRIGID: Yes. It is. I'm going to end it a little lighter there.
WILL: Thank you. Thank you. What do you got, Brigid?
BRIGID: It's something that I wanted to talk about. I was really trying to keep it to two books for this, because I know, you know, time, but I also knew this might be right up your alley.
WILL: Me? Okay.
BRIGID: So I had to talk about it. And it is a mystery. I did read a mystery, did some mysteries this summer. And this one I found on Instagram, and I cannot remember how, so if it was somebody, please tell us in the comments that you posted about this book. It came out this summer. It's called Get Lost by Justin Halpern. If the name sounds familiar, it's because he is the author of Ish My Dad Says. Ish is not the word I'm actually trying to say here.
[00:50:52] But he also is one of the showrunners for Quinta Brunson's Abbott Elementary, which I know you guys like watching, and I like as well. I was like, "A mystery by this guy?" You know? I was familiar with Ish My Dad Says. I didn't know he wrote Abbott Elementary. I did this one on audio. It was read by Catherine Luttrell. I don't think I've read or listened to anything narrated by her before, but it was very entertaining.
So this is a darkly humorous noir. I would say, people are saying like for fans of Carl Hiaasen, and I thought it also kinda had the feel of some of those Anthony Bourdain crime fictions we've talked about in the past. It does have more emotional of a feel than a Carl Hiaasen. So the premise is that we meet Lila. She's a reluctant baseball talent scout, and she gets a call that her mother has gone missing, but this has happened before. Her mother has a tendency to go missing and just kinda show back up.
[00:51:53] So she's not really worried about it until they tell Lila that her dad, who is a former baseball player and has served time before, is under arrest for her mom's disappearance. So she's gotta go back to her small hometown in California with all these almond farms and try to figure out what happened to her mom and why her dad is possibly the fault of it. There's lots of baseball in it, obviously. The writing is really easy to visualize as a movie or show, which now makes sense knowing that he is a co-showrunner for this. But Lila's dad, John Dickerson, everyone calls him Dix, he's charming, mess up of a guy. And so it's a lot about this troubled relationship between him and his daughter, and how absentee he was, and trying to find her lost mom. I kept thinking of Corbin Bernsen in Major League or Tom Selleck, just kind of like a washed-up baseball player.
[00:52:55] It was great. I think you would really enjoy it if you have a chance to pick it up. And that's Get Lost by Justin Halpern. The ending is a noir. So keep that in mind when you pick it up. But it is humorous, and dark, and very touching in a lot of ways, too.
WILL: Fun.
BRIGID: So that's that. I had to make sure to squeeze that one in.
WILL: Thank you.
BRIGID: Thank you, guys, for humoring me.
WILL: I appreciate it. And you know what? I don't think people mind if we spend a little more time talking about books.
HOLLY: I don't think so.
BRIGID: Yeah, right? Especially ones that... I feel like these ones that I brought were... I hadn't seen them at very many places.
WILL: Yeah, I have not heard of most of these. And Holly, you said Divergent, I'm like, "Oh, okay, good. I am familiar." Like I do know something. Because I'm listening to you guys, I'm like, "I don't know any of these books. What's going on?" Well, thank you all for talking books with us, Holly, for getting up early and for sharing your summer reads.
BRIGID: Absolutely.
HOLLY: This was fun.
BRIGID: It was absolutely delightful.
HOLLY: Bump a few things up my list. This is great.
SHANNAN: Thanks for having us.
WILL: All right, Shannan, enjoy the rest of your summer, and hopefully you knock out a few more of those in-process books.
SHANNAN: Hopefully.
WILL: All right. Happy reading, everybody.
HOLLY: Happy reading.
SHANNAN: Happy reading.
BRIGID: Happy reading.
[00:54:11] ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed hearing more summer reading superlatives from the MMD and What Should I Read Next? team. Find the full list of titles we talked about today at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
Join us on Patreon to hear episodes like today's without the ads. Sign up to receive ad-free episodes directly to your podcast feed for just $5 a month. Or for even more “make your reading life better” book talk, bundle ad-free episodes with our weekly bonus episodes and live events, including our upcoming Fall Book Preview in our Patreon all-inclusive tier. Find out more and see all the options at patreon.com/whatshouldireadnext.
Follow us on Instagram. We're there at whatshouldireadnext. I promised my team I would get on Instagram and do video to talk about Fall Book Preview in my own words, and that's happening soon. We're on Instagram @whatshouldireadnext.
Join our email list at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter for weekly updates on our show, merch restocks, upcoming events, and more.
[00:55:15] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• Open Throat by Henry Hoke
• Audition by Katie Kitamura
• Mostly Hero by Anna Burns
• Milkman by Anna Burns
• Always Home, Always Homesick by Hannah Kent
• Burial Rites by Hannah Kent
• Everything You Want Is on the Other Side of Hard by Ken Rideout
• The One Day You Were My Husband by Rosie Walsh
• The Fine Art of Lying by Alexandra Andrews
• Moss’d in Space by Rebecca Thorne
• Can’t Spell Treason without Tea by Rebecca Thorne
• The Murderbot Diaries by Martha Wells (#1: All Systems Red)
• The Spellshop by Sarah Beth Durst
• Becky Chambers (try The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet)
• Seek the Traitor’s Son by Veronica Roth
• Divergent by Veronica Roth
• London Falling by Patrick Radden Keefe
• Empire of Pain by Patrick Radden Keefe
• Demon Copperhead by Barbara Kingsolver
• Get Lost by Justin Halpern
• Sh*t My Dad Says by Justin Halpren (Brigid used the word “ish” while recording.)
• Carl Hiaasen (try Squeeze Me)
• Anthony Bourdain (try Bone in the Throat)
• WSIRN Ep 538: Our team’s best books of summer (Part 1)
• WSIRN Ep 533: Midyear reading checkin
• WSIRN Guest Follow-Up: Dana Prescott
• The Other Side of Hard podcast
• Schuler Books
• Source Booksellers
• Wind of Change podcast
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Our team’s best books of summer (Part 2) appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
For years now, our team members have joined me on the podcast in late summer to talk about the books we’ve all been loving most this season. Last year, we split this conversation into two episodes: we heard really positive feedback, so that’s what we’re doing again this year.
In today’s episode, the first in our two part series, I’m in conversation with three of our team members: our Resident Spreadsheet Queen Donna Hetchler, our Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club Community Manager Ginger Horton, and Modern Mrs Darcy Editor and Social Media Manager Leigh Kramer. Next week, you’ll hear from the rest of our team.
Our reading lives vary widely and we read across a range of genres that reflect the reading world at large. Today you’ll hear about true crime and books in translation, a backlist novel that inspired an award-winning musical, a literary mystery from a fan favorite author, romantasy and thriller titles that captured our team’s imagination this season, and more.
We’d love to hear about your best books of summer, too: please share those titles by leaving a comment below.
Fall reading is just around the corner and if you’re curious about the titles that you may be hearing about in the weeks ahead, or what new releases might be suited to your TBR list, our Fall Book Preview was designed to help with those answers. We’ll be gathering for our 8th annual Fall Book Preview on Thursday, September 17. A la carte ticketholders and eligible community members will receive a downloadable digital preview, as well as an invitation to the live Unboxing event happening that night at 8pm EDT. We’re also offering a printed booklet edition of the digital preview: it’s smaller and in a different format than our printed magazine-style Summer Reading Guide, and priced accordingly. Find out more and join us at modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp.
[00:00:00] LEIGH KRAMER: I just want to note that I'm always accused of talking about more books than we're technically allowed, but I have not done that at all. Anne and Ginger have both been sneaking in extra titles.
GINGER HORTON: It's true.
ANNE BOGEL: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Today's episode is part one of two for a popular summer tradition featuring the Modern Mrs. Darcy and What Should I Read Next? team.
[00:00:49] Readers, we're talking summer reading today, but fall reading is just around the corner. And if you're curious about the titles that you may be hearing about in the weeks ahead or what new releases might be suited to your to-be-read list, our Fall Book Preview is designed to help with those answers.
We are gathering for our eighth annual Fall Book Preview on Thursday, September 17th. A la carte ticket holders and eligible community members will receive a downloadable digital preview plus an invitation to our live unboxing event happening that night at 8:00 p.m. Eastern. That's when I get to talk about it all and answer your questions.
If you are a member of our Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club or our Patreon all-inclusive or bonuses and events tier, you are good to go. You'll have full access to the event and our digital Fall Book Preview look book. If you're not yet a member, our Patreon community invites you to join us at two different levels, and now is such a good time to do so.
[00:01:48] Our bonuses and events tier includes events like our Fall Book Preview, as well as our weekly bonus episodes. Our all-inclusive tier also gives you weekly access to ad-free episodes of this podcast. If you'd prefer a one-time charge, you're welcome to purchase an a la carte ticket for just this event. That's Fall Book Preview unboxing and the Fall Book Preview download.
We are offering a printed booklet edition of our preview this year, our little look book. And I had so much time getting in and designing it because this year we're doing something a little bit different. I can't wait to show it to you. This is smaller and in a different format than our printed magazine-style Summer Reading Guide. It's priced accordingly. We are working out the details and we'll have them ready for you soon. But right now we wanted you to know Fall Book Preview, Thursday, September 17th. All the details are coming. Now is a great time to join Patreon if you're interested. Find out more, get all the details and your Patreon info at modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp for Fall Book Preview. That's modernmrsdarcy.com/fbp.
[00:02:56] Readers, for years now, our team members have joined me on the podcast at right about this point in the year to share the books they've been loving most this season. Last year, we had so many titles to discuss that we split this conversation into two separate episodes. We heard really positive feedback from all of you about that format. So that's what we're doing again this year.
In today's episode, the first in our two-part series, I'm in conversation with three of our team members. They are our resident spreadsheet queen, Donna Hetchler, our Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club community manager, Ginger Horton, and our Modern Mrs. Darcy editor and social media manager, Leigh Kramer. Next week, you will hear from the rest of our team.
As a team, our reading likes vary widely. We read across a range of genres that reflect the reading world at large, so I'm pretty confident that between today's conversation and next week's part two, every listener will hear a title that appeals.
[00:03:52] Today, you'll hear about true crime and books in translation, a backlist novel that inspired an award-winning musical, a literary mystery from a fan-favorite author, romantasy and thriller titles that captured our team's imagination this season, and more. Readers, let's get to it.
Hello, team. Welcome to the show. Thank you so much for joining me in this format. I'm so excited you're here today.
LEIGH: Excited to be here.
GINGER: We are excited, too. I love summer.
DONNA HETCHLER: I always love sharing my favorite books, so it's an honor to be here.
ANNE: Oh, my gosh, the pleasure is all mine. We have been doing this for several years now and just always have the best time. Readers, we really enjoy this episode because we don't need an excuse to talk about books as a team, but we will still take anyone we can get. I think Shannan divided us into two groups of two, so as you heard today, I'm joined by Donna. Donna, tell us hello so everybody can hear your voice.
DONNA: Hello, everyone.
ANNE: Leigh.
LEIGH: Hi, everyone.
ANNE: And Ginger.
GINGER: Hi, this is Ginger.
[00:05:00] ANNE: And we're kicking off a two-part Best Books of Summer. And we're going to talk about what that means, best, favorite, how we individually thought of our superlatives, because I didn't make the rules. We make our own reading rules around here. We're the bosses of our own reading lives.
But first, I'd love to hear, here we are, late August, I feel like my summer is kind of over because the kids went back to school, but also it's still a bazillion degrees. So Fall Book Preview's coming. I'm thinking about fall. All of which to say, tell us how your summer reading is going, not how it went. Donna, you start us off.
DONNA: It's actually going great, I am happy to report. I really went into this year trying to simplify my reading, so I am more focused. I'm reading one book at a time, I'm reading fewer books, and I've been using Goodreads to help me narrow down my selections. So I analyzed the data, of course I did, from my spreadsheets, and I have picked a threshold of 4.2 on Goodreads ratings. Most of my books are above 4.2 on Goodreads, and it's been great.
GINGER: I love the specificity.
ANNE: You wouldn't have read any of my favorites then.
[00:06:17] DONNA: Sorry. It's just working for me. It doesn't work for other people.
ANNE: I just think it's funny. And I'm glad to hear what's working for you. That's why we're here.
LEIGH: How did you land on 4.2?
DONNA: Should I walk through the math?
LEIGH: Yes.
ANNE: Please. Yes.
GINGER: Absolutely.
DONNA: No, we don't have enough time for it, but we can have a one-on-one session with charts and graphs.
ANNE: That's like the three-hour graduate literary lab.
DONNA: Correct.
LEIGH: What Should I Read Next? 401 here.
ANNE: I'd sign up for that.
LEIGH: Me too.
ANNE: Donna, is there a short version? I remember reading a John Green post once upon a time where he indicated 4.3 was a magical Goodreads number.
DONNA: Oh, I'm going to look that up.
LEIGH: Oh, interesting.
GINGER: I want to find that.
LEIGH: It feels so high.
ANNE: You can fact-check me later
GINGER: One of my favorite things to happen in the reading life is when you loved a book and then you go onto Goodreads or your favorite platform and it's like a 2.5, and I think, "Excellent, like I'm not normal and I love that for me."
DONNA: This is a whole other episode.
[00:07:22] LEIGH: I don't know if I've ever loved a book that was rated that low. I don't even know if I always look at Goodreads first.
GINGER: Oh, okay.
LEIGH: And the rating doesn't really bear in mind if I'll read something or not. I always look at reviews. But this is fascinating to me.
ANNE: All right. Leigh, tell us about your summer reading.
LEIGH: Well, this has been a strange year of reading and I feel like that's been true for the past few years, where it's just harder to find the books that I love. I'm reading a ton. There's lots of four-star books, so it's not bad, but the five stars have been harder to come by. And then I don't know what it is, but in the last month or two I've had more five-star books than the first like five months of the year combined. So something seems to be working. I don't know if I'm just picking differently or if the stars have aligned, but I'm glad. Glad to see it.
[00:08:25] And just for some context, I looked yesterday to see how many books I've DNF'd so far this year and I've DNF'd 53 books.
ANNE: Wow.
LEIGH: So that should give some other context about like... it's just been hard to find the right ones. I've still read around like 100. I don't know. Donna, you're the mathematician of the two of us, so I don't know what that means, but-
GINGER: I did not expect to talk about this much math on a book podcast, you guys.
LEIGH: I'm taking over, Ginger.
DONNA: We love the good nerdy fun.
LEIGH: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Ginger, how about you? How's your summer reading? And maybe remind everyone of your history with summer reading, perhaps, not being the... you take it away.
GINGER: Yeah, we're going to remind everybody of that because I'm usually a bad news first kind of girl. So let me tell you the bad news first. The summer slump has found me. It is early August and this is not to be surprised. I'm not surprised by this. August is usually my hardest reading month, and sure enough, that found me. But I had a great reading summer up to now. And I have high hopes for the next few weeks.
[00:09:31] Some of you know that I'm in graduate school and I had a great reading, you know, winter and spring, of course, but it looks very different. I'm reading Descartes and Augustine and Kant and Euclid. Donna told me I absolutely am not allowed to talk about Augustine on this podcast. I loved it.
DONNA: Spoiler alert.
GINGER: But I wanted to just have a grand old Summer Reading Guide kind of time. I wanted to like frolic and read the buzzy books and maybe like some middle grade. I wanted a respite, and I absolutely did have that. I think I bought every single Annabel Monaghan book after we read Dolly All the Time with book club. I wanted to reread some like Ann Patchett and Alexandra Andrews that I knew were having new books come out, Marisa de los Santos, like new books that were coming out this year. So I had a grand old start to the summer. Travel and company sometimes slows me down, it feels like, in August, and that has happened, but that's okay. I'm okay with it.
[00:10:25] ANNE: I'm sorry the slump has found you.
GINGER: Yeah, it's always a bummer. It's never surprising.
ANNE: You're still you
GINGER: But it is a bummer. And slump kind of means to me that I'm not finishing books.
ANNE: Oh.
GINGER: I'm still reading, but like nothing's sticking.
ANNE: Okay. Interesting. I've had a great summer. So my two twin goals in our time together today is not to talk about Summer Reading Guide books and not to talk about Fall Book preview books. I've been trying to live in the in between this summer, and it's been really fun.
I've had a pretty nerdy summer. I have definitely read some frothy... I've gotten to frolic a little bit, like you said. Not gotten to. I mean, I've chosen that a little bit. But I've also really enjoyed spending some time with some old books I've been putting off, or some more scholarly, literary, how-to-read kind of books. Like right now I'm reading a book about, I don't know, how to craft the perfect sentence. That's not what it's called. I'm going to finish it first, and then I'll tell you about it if I like it to the end, or I'll tell you about it with my complete opinion.
[00:11:29] But I spent forever with Jane Smiley's 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel. Right now I'm loving reading through my annotated like 700-page edition of Pride and Prejudice with Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club. I've read old Anne Tyler and Toni Morrison, and a couple of older books I'm going to talk about today as my favorites.
And I've just really enjoyed taking the time to, I don't know, like read the stuff that doesn't have a reason for me to read it right now, except that I want to, which is different from reading for a Summer Reading Guide or a Fall Book Preview. I got to go to the beach, and for the first time in a couple years, read almost a book every single day, in part because some were 200 pages. And there was an exception. I read a 500-plus page novel that I'm really excited about for fall that took me two days. And I read some backlist. I've just really enjoyed going, I don't know, just spending a lot of time with good books.
[00:12:23] I have had two, not really slumpy exactly, but there were two different times this summer where I stalled out. And once, I was reading a book that's coming this fall that I've already seen so highly praised, and I could tell, stylistically, this is gorgeous, but I don't care. And I just didn't want to read. You know, I'd pick it up, I'd read 10 pages, I'd be like, "That's enough for tonight." So I kinda stalled out for a week.
And then I was reading something else that was older earlier in the summer, where again, didn't care. I mean, I powered through, and then I moved on. Powered through might be the wrong phrase. I decided I do actually want to complete this book, and I did it slowly, and then I moved on.
DONNA: You stayed the course.
ANNE: Yeah. I had something good happening in my ears in, you know, the meantime, so I was still enjoying good books. But on the whole, it's been fun, and a mix of like frothy, and nerdy, and forthcoming, and old, and... I mean, this is the same kind of thing I always say, I think, actually.
GINGER: That's a good mix, though.
ANNE: It's a nice mix. It's a nice mix.
GINGER: Yeah, we like that.
ANNE: And this is what the mix often looks like in June, July, and August.
[00:13:34] LEIGH: I mean, there could be a year where it'll be completely different. So I want to know, are things the same?
GINGER: That's right.
LEIGH: Or are you doing things differently?
ANNE: When we do the Summer Reading Guide that's the pre-2000 edition, it'll look so different. We'll see. Okay, so we enjoyed talking a little bit before we hit the record button about how we chose our favorites and then, you know, made a joke that we should have been recording. But we all want different things from our summer reading. I'm talking to our listeners, but also just looking at the four of us, we all want different things from our summer reading and measure success by different outcomes. So what I'd really love to hear is, as you sat down to choose your best favorite superlative for today, how were you thinking about what you might choose? Donna, how'd you choose?
DONNA: Well, Anne, I went to my spreadsheet, I did, and I filtered on five-star ratings. And then I kind of like to look for a theme, see if anything pops out, which it did, and it is nonstop action are what my two picks are. And then I also try to do ones that maybe are a little bit different. Maybe people haven't heard of them, maybe different from your picks. And that's how I came up with my two.
[00:15:00] ANNE: Donna, what makes a five-star read for you?
DONNA: It's like instinctual to me. It's hard for me to describe. It just is a feeling where I was so immersed in that book, I wasn't even aware of what was going around me. I can tell when I'm just living in a book, and that is what happened with these two books.
ANNE: So I hear you say spreadsheet a lot, which sounds like math, math, data-driven, but you got some poetry in there too. Wait, that sounds like a genre. You've got-
DONNA: I do.
ANNE: It's emotional math.
GINGER: Anne has some insider knowledge of this spreadsheet.
ANNE: Vibes plus math. I was trying not to say vibes. That word is... I'm over that word.
DONNA: It is, though. It is. It's just a feeling that I have.
ANNE: Mm-hmm.
GINGER: An art and a science.
LEIGH: Yeah.
ANNE: Oh, that's a good way to put it.
DONNA: Thanks, Ginger.
ANNE: Leigh, what were you considering?
[00:15:55] LEIGH: I keep a note with all of my five-star reads for the year, so I just pulled that up. And honestly, I only have probably 15 five-star reads so far this year. So I thought about, of the five-star reads, which are the ones that I have thought about the most and that I have recommended the most to friends, and that's what I came up with.
GINGER: I like that framework of recommending. That's a great one. I'm going to keep that in mind.
ANNE: Love it. Ginger, how'd you do it?
GINGER: Well, I really was thinking in two different directions. One, I wanted to share something that I hadn't talked much about but that I did love because book club members know that we just had our Best Book of the Summer event in book club, where members share theirs, and I gushed about Finding Grace. I think that's such a buzzy book that is on a lot of people's radar.
[00:16:51] I also had so many good experiences. I took down Paradise Pawn from the Summer Reading Guide in one sitting, like one day, which is really rare for me. I'm a slow reader. So what I was sort of thinking about is... I mean, I could talk about one of those buzzy books that everybody is probably already aware of, but I wanted to talk about my favorite reading experience. So those were such fun books, but I wanted to talk about the book that sort of obsessed me, that I sunk into. It was unexpected, it was surprising, and it sent me off in other directions, trips and research. So I wanted to talk about my favorite reading experience today.
ANNE: Trips.
GINGER: Mm-hmm. Well, I don't know which one came first. Did the book inspire the trip or did the trip inspire the book? We'll see. We'll talk about it.
ANNE: Intriguing. Not thinking of everywhere I know you've been. We did not share our books in advance.
GINGER: Nope.
ANNE: So this is our reveal to each other as well as to y'all. Okay, are we ready?
LEIGH: Yeah.
ANNE: Any final words before we launch into favorites?
LEIGH: I just want to note that I'm always accused of talking about more books than we're technically allowed, but I have not done that at all. Anne and Ginger have both been sneaking in extra titles.
GINGER: It's true.
LEIGH: And I clocked it.
[00:18:10] ANNE: Ginger did sneak in Augustine twice.
GINGER: Definitely. Always.
ANNE: We all saw that. All right. Leigh, your gold star will be in the mail shortly.
LEIGH: Thank you. Thank you.
ANNE: Donna, would you do us the honor of starting us off?
DONNA: I will. Remember, the theme is nonstop action. Book number one is Lightlark by Alex Aster. This is a romantasy book. It is the beginning of a series. I actually don't know how many are going to be in the series, but the second one does come out in April of next year.
I think one of the things I loved about it is it really reminded me of The Hunger Games, which are some of my favorite books and favorite movies. And I've been looking for another book that has that same kind of similar elements to it. So there's kind of this hierarchy of the haves and have-nots, but in this case, the haves, what they have is magic, and then other people do not. But there's something that happens every 50 years where the have-nots can get some magic.
[00:19:24] And there is a set of brutal, and I mean brutal, trials that happen as part of this quest to get some magic. I also really love this book because there is an enemies-to-lovers trope, but what I really want to point out is that they are really enemies. I feel like a lot of times when I see that trope, there's just not much to it, and so it doesn't feel like much of a change to go from, quote-unquote, enemies to lovers. But here, there is really something very serious keeping them apart, and I find that very intriguing. And I think you need that when it's a long series. You need something serious. But yeah, just a total page-turner and highly recommend.
GINGER: I think a lot of readers' ears perked up when you said The Hunger Games, so.
DONNA: Yes. But it does have that brutality, right? I mean, The Hunger Games is no joke, and so I wanted to make sure people understand that there is a violent side to this book.
[00:20:31] LEIGH: I mean, you had me at enemies to lovers that are real enemies. I like those high stakes of not knowing how is the author going to pull this off? How are they going to make me believe in this?
DONNA: Exactly, yes. All right. We'll see if you're interested in book two. It is called Cold Zero. This is by Brad Thor and Ward Larsen. I wanted to highlight this book because I feel like a lot of people, maybe in particular women, would pass this book by on a shelf because it kind of looks like a dude book, is what I've been calling it. There's a big picture of a dude on the back.
Actually, one of the authors, Ward Larsen, he writes for the Tom Clancy estate, so they do write military books and thrillers, things like that. But I think that if you enjoy T.J. Newman's books, like Drowning, you're going to love this. Or it also reminded me of the movies like Crimson Tide or The Hunt for Red October. I love those movies. So if that is your vibe, if you like a kind of a spy international thriller, this is a good book. And it does have a female lead protagonist, which kind of surprised me and I think really helped draw me in.
[00:22:01] So it starts with a bang. A plane goes down in the middle of nowhere, and I mean nowhere, in the Antarctic. There's something on this plane that multiple countries want. So now there is a race to the plane to get this thing, which I'm purposely not describing. And when I say nonstop action, I mean it. It is just one thing after another. And it's kind of like watching, you know, one of those movies that I just described. And in fact, Netflix has said they have bought the rights to this, and they said that they're going to make a big movie out of it, which I hope they do, because the book is very cinematic. Again, I just couldn't put it down. So that's Cold Zero. Those are my two.
ANNE: Wow. Ooh, I'm really intrigued by Cold Zero. That sounds like the kind of book I love occasionally. And I think it's so... I don't know what's happening here that I've read three books in the past... I don't remember when I read the Charlotte McConaghy set at one of the poles, but I've read three books that have been Arctic or Antarctic just in the past couple months that I've really enjoyed. So why not make it four?
LEIGH: Why not?
[00:23:15] GINGER: I would like to say, too, that my best book of summer last year was a military book, so I'm kind of like putting this in that category of sometimes that's really surprising, because non-stop action is often there.
LEIGH: Sounds good.
ANNE: Okay. Thank you, Donna.
DONNA: You're welcome.
ANNE: All right, Leigh, here you are with your not more than two, not dropping extra titles. You know I'm totally kidding. Here, what do you have for us?
LEIGH: I'm behaving today, but that's also because I know that we have a Patreon vote.
ANNE: Oh, don't disappoint people.
GINGER: Don't change now.
LEIGH: Okay. I'm actually going to surprise everyone, and this is a good segue from the book that Donna just shared, and I am going to recommend a crime novel.
ANNE: What?
GINGER: Come on, now.
LEIGH: Surprise.
GINGER: Leigh, we said yesterday in team meeting, we don't know you, so this is a surprise.
LEIGH: Always keep people guessing. So this is Murder Mindfully by Karsten Dusse. It was originally published in Germany, and it's now being translated into English and published here. And it's also apparently a Netflix series, so people may have heard about it that way. But this was so up my alley, even though I don't read very many crime novels at all. But once you hear the premise, you'll be like, "I understand why Leigh wanted to read this."
So criminal defense lawyer Björn's wife has given him an ultimatum, so he starts seeing a mindfulness coach, and this changes him in very surprising ways. I love mindfulness. It was my favorite class that I took in grad school when I got my master's in social work, so this was my entry point.
So when Björn's mobster client makes demands that will interfere with his time with his daughter Emily, it's the perfect opportunity to apply the mindfulness techniques he's been learning. And if that means he accidentally or not so accidentally kills his client and anyone else who stands in his way, well, sometimes that happens.
[00:25:17] And it includes excerpts from this fictional Slowing Down in the Fast Lane: Mindfulness for Managers book, and Björn is always consulting the book of like how should he approach this situation. Some great dark humor, so delightful.
The second book, My Inner Child Wants to Kill, came out August 4th, and I'm excited to read that next. And I really hope that the rest of the series is translated, because I want to read more. This was so much fun.
ANNE: I'm loving the zaniness of organized crime plus mindfulness.
LEIGH: Yes. Right?
DONNA: Amazing.
ANNE: You know, I want to read thrillers in German. I'm thinking, "Can I read this?" No, I don't think I can. I don't think I'm-
LEIGH: I was thinking that it might have specific appeal to you, Anne, because of your project. But you could get the side-by-side comparison going, so feel like you might want to give it a go.
GINGER: Hopefully they do translate those for you, Leigh, but if they don't, you can have Anne read the rest of them and just tell you what happens.
LEIGH: Yes.
[00:26:18] ANNE: I don't know. I believe I might be missing some of the specific vocabulary necessary to truly understand these. I don't know how to describe the inner workings of any organization, let alone one that it sounds like is involved in this book. But, you know, you gotta learn and grow in your language skills, so maybe this is my opportunity. I just maybe need to not use those words in conversation.
LEIGH: I mean, haven't you always wanted to learn about crime in German?
GINGER: That'll come in handy.
LEIGH: I feel like Anne's going to start-
ANNE: This is the book for me.
LEIGH: ...bringing these mindfulness techniques into our team meetings. Better watch out.
GINGER: Hopefully the mindfulness and not the crime. Let's-
LEIGH: Not the murder. All right. For my second book we're going to do choose your own adventure style, and I'm going to make you pick, so nonfiction or romance.
[00:27:15] GINGER: Okay, I'm only basing this on what I'm bringing, which is not nonfiction, and so I'd love a little nonfiction in this mix. We haven't had any so far.
DONNA: Sounds good to me.
ANNE: I agree.
LEIGH: Okay. Well, this is actually not too far from a crime novel, but it is nonfiction. So it's called Unreasonable Women: Three Stories of Violence, Imprisonment, and Extraordinary Survival by Justine van der Leun. This might be the most important nonfiction book that I'll read this year. It's difficult, but it was very compelling, very well-written. So van der Leun is a journalist, and she follows three women incarcerated for murder, even though they were actually protecting themselves after years of abuse. So this really is examining criminalized survival and just how many people are complicit, from family members to the so-called justice system.
[00:28:13] While the stories are hard to read at times, I definitely want to emphasize that you should look at the content warnings. But it's very important to not look away from what is happening. I really hope that this book leads to real change. It was just so, so well done.
ANNE: I hadn't heard of this until our Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club member best books, which put this on my radar. Several readers just raved about it. It's interesting that the universe is now bringing it to me again.
LEIGH: It's truly so, so well done. I really want more people to read it. I mean, it just came out in the last couple of months, but I was just very impressed with how she structured everything and how she grapples with the ethics. And also I just hope that certain prosecutors are haunted for the rest of their lives by their misdeeds. I don't think that they are, but I hope that this book leads to some suffering, as I say with a smile.
[00:29:15] GINGER: Well, I'm glad you actually brought that one, Leigh, because it does feel like one that deserves to be put in front of more people. But I do have to ask, are you going to share your other path of the choose your own adventure on the Patreon bonus episode?
LEIGH: Yes, yes. So the romance picks will go on the Patreon bonus.
GINGER: We'll hear about that one, too.
ANNE: I appreciate the quick yes. I get to go next. First, I'm going to repeat one that I shared in our Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club Best Books of Summer. And that is Last Night in Montreal by Emily St. John Mandel, which I chose as the... actually, I chose both of these as the reading experience. I thought they were both very well done, finely crafted, or whatever snooty lit critic superlative you want to use. But it was the reading experience that made this for me. And part of that reading experience was this was the third Emily St. John Mandel book I read in quick succession. I'm now a completist. There will be a blog post on Modern Mrs. Darcy coming your way before too long.
[00:30:20] But I read Exit Party for Fall Book Preview. I'll be talking about that then. And then for reasons involving overlapping characters, I read The Singer's Gun when Holly, What Should I Read Next? alum, organized a community read over there. And then I thought, "Well, I'm so close. I'm just going to finish," and I picked up Last Night in Montreal, which I found out after I finished was her debut that was plucked from the slush pile by the person who became her agent, and then it was finally sold to a small press, and everything changed with Station Eleven. But I didn't know that backstory for her early novels that I didn't hear of until after Station Eleven had already sold a bajillion copies.
But I really enjoyed the reading experience of sinking into a story with three Emily St. John Mandel books ringing in my ears. I feel like that kind of immersive experience really let me notice style and approach in the way she talks to the reader and kind of makes an argument in her books in a way that I wouldn't have had I just picked this up out of the blue. You know, 2020 Anne would've had a very different experience with this book.
[00:31:31] But I so enjoyed the lit class I was running in my head on this book. And I highlighted a bunch, and my annotations are ample in the front of my book, and I dog-eared and bookmarked and made notes and Googled.
Last Night in Montreal is about a woman who has been constantly moving since she was seven years old and was escaping something scary. Her father, who she hadn't seen in years at that point, comes to take her away in the middle of the night. And the mother is distraught in the morning, goes to authorities. But throughout the book, you are not entirely sure that it wasn't a good thing that she was spirited away. But you're not entirely sure because taking a child out of her bed when she's seven years old in the middle of a brutally cold Montreal winter, which that's not the last night of the title, well, there's a lot to explore there.
[00:32:28] So throughout the book, she's constantly on the run. The story begins when she skips out of her boyfriend's house in New York City in more the present day. She's 20-something years old, and he always knew that she was going to leave at some point because she doesn't stay in one place very long, but he yet still didn't believe that she would leave him, and he goes to search for her. And interspersed, we have the story of him looking for her in the present day and her entire history of never spending more than six weeks in any place since she was seven years old.
The first line of this book is, "No one stays forever." And how many times can I use the word nerdy? I really enjoyed... It felt like it was done with a light touch, but I'd read three Emily St. John Mandel books in a row at this point, which her new one is much more in the realm of science fiction fantasy, and yet so many of the themes were the same. Like, how does one choice we make in a moment impact the trajectory of our entire lives? Like, how might things have been different if only?
[00:33:31] And several characters in the book are living arguments for the beauty and fulfillment of staying in one place, and others really argue with their lives and actions for the necessity of being on the run. We have a PI trying to hunt her down. We have characters at odds. I mean, there's just a lot of good stuff here. I enjoyed it. It wasn't long. It was only 200-something pages. Just over 200. I read it quickly, but I just really enjoyed reading this with my pen in hand and my notebook early in the morning at the time I do my more like scholarly reading. But had this been queued up for me at the beach, I would've happily read it there. It would've suited me in either place. So that's Emily St. John Mandel.
GINGER: I love a backlist.
[00:34:16] ANNE: Which does not have a 4.3. Not even close. And then my other one, again, definitely an experience for me in this season of my life, and that is Prague Spring by Simon Mawer. I chose Prague Spring because this was a book for me in this season. It's not super old. It was just published 10-ish years... Let's see. The copyright is 2018, but it's about events that happened in the summer of 1968.
I haven't really talked about this, but Will and I took our boys to visit Mel and Dave of Strong Sense of Place — I know many of you are listeners and fans of their work — in April. And we were browsing at this little bookstore in Prague, and Mel said, "Oh, Simon Mawer. Prague Spring. I love that book." And I said, "Sold." And I took it home with me, and I didn't read it until we went to the beach in July.
[00:35:12] But I wasn't familiar with Simon Mawer's work, although maybe some of you will be. He was shortlisted for the Booker for The Glass Room, which I now want to go on and read, because I enjoyed this one so much. But I am wondering if this was the unique combination of the book I wanted. But I don't know. I thought this was going to be very, very serious, and when I picked it up, it read almost like a spy novel.
But something that's so interesting about this book is it's called Prague Spring, which is a real historical event. And what happens is we're looking at two couples. One is university students at Oxford who are spending the summer hitchhiking through Europe, and the other is a British diplomat stationed in Prague, and a younger Czech political activist.
[00:36:05] So as they are living their lives in the summer of 1968, the reader knows that Russian tanks are going to roll in to Wenceslas Square on August 20th. This is historical fiction. That was a historical event. But when you meet these characters in June, the Oxford couple, oh, they are young and snippy, and one is in love with the other, but it's not reciprocated, and they're kind of whining, and they want to have an adventure, and they're not quite sure what they want. And they're making their decisions about what cities to go to based on, like, literally rolling dice. Which is how they end up in Prague.
But the other couple, the diplomat and the political activist, have very different interests in what's happening in Prague that spring. And, like, here's a little history lesson, because you didn't go on the amazing post-World War II and communism tour that I went on in Prague, which was an amazing backdrop to this book.
So in January 1968, the Czechoslovakian Communist Party appointed this man named Dubček to be its new chairman, and he believed in socialism with a face. And very quickly, beginning in 1968, restrictions were loosened. Western books and radio were allowed into the country. There wasn't press censorship to the extent there had been. Like, artistic and cultural freedom greatly increased, and you can see characters in the book saying, "Things are changing. Like, we are opening to the West. We're freer. We're going to keep moving in this direction."
[00:37:39] And Khrushchev did not agree, made threats to Dubček, who was like, "Yeah, yeah, this is fine. I'll, we're going to work it out. We can all stay friends," because he was loyal to the Russians. And the Russians keep saying, "You gotta tighten this back up," and he's like, "You don't really mean that, do you?" And then in late August, the tanks rolled in.
DONNA: Oh, no.
ANNE: So there's this impending sense of doom because you know what is going to happen, and you know the characters have no idea. And yet, even though I knew this history, there are things in the book that I didn't know really happened. Like the Moody Blues were playing on the Charles Bridge the night before the tanks rolled into the city, and they were trapped. Shirley Temple was in Prague when the tanks rolled in. And in the story, they're figuring out how to spirit out the Americans or the Brits while, you know, the Czech people are stuck.
[00:38:34] But reading about this book with history that I had just been, I mean, for an eight-day trip, immersed in, and places that I had just been and sights I'd just seen with my own eyes, it was just great timing. And also not the book I expected. I thought it was going to be a chore that would make me a better reader, you know, that I should read. But from about page two, I was like, "Well, I didn't know it was going to be like this. Why didn't anyone tell me?" Mel told me. Mel told me. I should have known.
GINGER: That does sound like a good summer reading experience, for sure.
LEIGH: No, that sounds very, very good. I don't read a lot of historical, but yeah, that appeals.
ANNE: That's fun. I mean, it was a very intellectually and emotionally satisfying kind of fun. All right, Ginger, we saved you for last because you took a different take than Donna, Leigh, or I did.
GINGER: Yes.
ANNE: Tell us everything.
[00:39:33] GINGER: I love the torturous experience of deciding about one book. And I kind of already told you my qualification there is that I was trying to decide on what has been my best reading experience for the summer. So you're not going to get off that easy. I did bring a classic, depending on how you define classic, but it's not as old as Augustine.
So it is written in 1975, and that book is Ragtime by E.L. Doctorow. So this, you might have guessed, I am second only to books is my obsession with Broadway. I don't talk about it a lot, but I read a lot of show biz memoirs, and I read a lot of the source material. I have read the entirety of Hamilton by Ron Chernow because I wanted to annotate that with the lyrics of the play, the musical.
[00:40:20] So when I heard that Joshua Henry, whose career I followed for years and years since Tick, Tick... Boom! was on Netflix, when I heard that he won the Tony, if you have not seen that NPR Tiny Desk concert with him singing Let Them Hear You, please go do that as soon as you're done with this episode. I just got obsessed. I thought, "I knew he was in Ragtime. I've gotta see it."
So my husband and I booked a quick trip to New York on the train. I grabbed the book to read on the train, and I have been listening to the soundtrack forever. But I really didn't know much else about the origin story or anything, but I just got obsessed. So reading this on the train on the way up to see Joshua Henry as he ends his run really shortly, actually, was just such a delight, kind of having the soundtrack in my ears and the book in my hands and, you know, going to this place where the story takes place, New York. It was so immersive.
[00:41:17] I didn't quite finish it on the trip itself, and so after I got home, I was still continuing just to research the references, the Broadway lyrics. I was annotating that book, again, with all the lyrics that I knew in my head. It was just such a delightful immersive. Since then, I've been buying old books on ragtime music itself. I mean, I love when a book influences a trip, and the trip influences music, and the music influences learning about the music. That is my favorite kind.
A little bit about this book itself. It is pretty standard size, like just over 300 pages, but I do not know how E.L. Doctorow fits in this many characters. So lest it sounds like a dull, dusty classic, it feels very timely and very modern. He shoves so many... The three main characters, yes, but their family members, their friends and neighbors. There are historical figures in here, like we... You mentioned Shirley Temple. That was so funny because Evelyn Nesbit, Houdini, J.P. Morgan, like there are these historical figures that come into the book and the play that are just really fun to see how they intersect, how their lives intersect.
[00:42:28] I had the best time reading this. It is really present writing. Like I said, it's not too long, but it almost feels like Hemingway-esque in that it's short and terse and propulsive. And because you're following so many characters, there is a lot of action, again, in this book. Yeah, Donna. I just loved it. I mean, I loved the experience certainly, but I was so surprised that this book has some things to say about the immigrant experience, about women's experience in the home and outside of the home. It had a lot going on, and yet it was pulled off so successfully.
LEIGH: I'm going to sound ignorant, but I didn't realize that the show was based on a book.
DONNA: I didn't either.
GINGER: Truly. Me neither. That's it. Yeah, exactly. That's-
LEIGH: I was like, "Does everyone know this?"
[00:43:15] GINGER: No. And what I really love is when you do sometimes read Broadway source material, how seriously the people that write the book for a Broadway show are drawing on. I mean, there are some exact quotes I cannot give away. It is a huge plot point. If I tell you, my favorite line of the entire soundtrack is a really shocking line from the younger brother, and it is word for word in the book. And I mean, when I tell you I laughed out loud, I laughed. I honked a laugh out loud, because I was not expecting to see that humor folded in there. And it's always a surprise to me, no matter how many times I've heard.
LEIGH: That's so fun.
GINGER: It was a really good time.
ANNE: I love that for you, and I love a field trip. Is this the reason you went to New York?
GINGER: I think the impetus was Joshua Henry was finishing his run on Broadway, and I just wanted to be in the room with that man's voice. So I think it's in 10 days from the time we're recording, so I knew that that was my moment. I hope he goes on to do even bigger and better things in the world, because he's a delightful human. But if this is the pinnacle of his career, he has done something extraordinary with his life. Again, I mean, just go listen to that man's voice is extraordinary.
[00:44:27] ANNE: I mean, if we must, we must.
GINGER: Well, you must.
ANNE: Yeah, we must.
LEIGH: This is my kind of homework.
GINGER: Yes, exactly.
ANNE: Any parting thoughts or peeks into what you might be talking about in the Patreon bonus?
GINGER: I did hard work. Now, I could talk about books all day, but I decided on one. And, really truly so many of my great reading experiences this year have been summer reading guidebooks. I mean, if I can break all the rules and just say Country People and Trash and Main Characters, like, Anne picked out some great-
DONNA: Cheater.
GINGER: ...SNG books. I'm not talking about them, I'm just saying I loved those titles. Is that allowed?
ANNE: We're never going to tsk-tsk in our buddy for sharing more books they loved.
LEIGH: I'm truly impressed by the way you're just able to weave that in. I feel like your sneakiness inspires me to be more sneaky the next time.
[00:45:27] GINGER: A maximalist will come with one title, if you can hear the air quotes there, and somehow also mention six others.
LEIGH: Yeah.
ANNE: I said very clearly up top, you make your own rules. Thank you all so much for coming on to talk favorites. It's always a pleasure.
GINGER: This was great.
LEIGH: It was so fun.
DONNA: Had a great time.
ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed this first part of our team's conversation about their best books of summer. Find the full list of titles we talked about today at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com. Keep up with our show and other happenings, like our upcoming Fall Book Preview, by signing up for our email updates at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
Make sure you're following in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, and more. We hope it helps you to find out when our new episodes are released. It really helps us when you sign up to get notified and download these new episodes. It makes us look good to the people who help make our podcast happen, and we really appreciate that.
[00:46:31] Find us on Instagram at whatshouldireadnext. We love it when you help us spread the book love by sharing our posts or commenting and responding.
And thank you to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• Dolly All the Time by Annabel Monaghan
• 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel by Jane Smiley
• Finding Grace by Loretta Rothschild
• Paradise Pawn by Meg Richardson
• Starside by Alex Aster
• The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
• Cold Zero by Brad Thor & Ward Larsen
• Drowning by T. J. Newman
• Murder Mindfully by Karsten Dusse, translated by Florian Duijsens
• My Inner Child Wants to Kill by Karsten Dusse, translated by Florian Duijsens
• Unreasonable Women: Three Stories of Violence, Imprisonment, and Extraordinary Survival by Justine van der Leun
• Exit Party by Emily St. John Mandel
• The Singer’s Gun by Emily St. John Mandel
• Last Night in Montreal by Emily St. John Mandel
• Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel
• Prague Spring by Simon Mawer
• The Glass Room by Simon Mawer
• Ragtime by E.L. Doctorow
• Strong Sense of Place Podcast
• Joshua Henry on NPR’s Tiny Desk Concert
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Our team’s best books of summer (Part 1) appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
We hear from many readers who set reading goals informed by their to-be-read stacks, whether physical or digital. Today’s guest has a specific and relatable goal of making progress through her library of already purchased ebooks.
Danielle Petrie lives and works in the Canadian prairies, where she enjoys swing dancing, outdoor activities, and reading. Historically, it’s been important to Danielle to keep her ebook library at about 50% read, with the other half ready to enjoy. But lately, Danielle’s balance has tipped heavily towards the purchased but not yet read end of the spectrum.
When she reached out as a potential guest, Danielle’s ebook library was sitting at 36% read. She shared her desire to create a reading challenge to bring that ratio back into balance and focus on reading from her unread library of titles.
Today, we take a look at Danielle’s reading life, see what’s on her Kindle and how it got there, and make a plan for her to experience reading satisfaction on several different levels.
If you have ideas for Danielle or an ebook reading strategy, we’d love to hear more: please share by leaving a comment below.
For many years now in the Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club, we mark the month of August by reading an Austen novel. This year, we’re reading Pride and Prejudice. We’ll enjoy reading through the annotated edition together, gathering for a watch party of the 1995 BBC edition, and enjoying all things Austen all month long. We’d love to have you join us and stick around into the fall for more bookish connection and conversation. Get all the details or join us now at modernmrsdarcy.com/club.
[00:00:00] DANIELLE PETRIE: I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and then told the whole world about it.
ANNE BOGEL: So you're the reason it sold so many copies?
DANIELLE: Absolutely, I thought it was me.
ANNE: Okay.
DANIELLE: I'm such an influencer.
ANNE: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading, and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:46] Readers, this episode is coming to you in early August, which means we are underway with our fifth annual celebration of Austen in August over in the Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club. For many years now, taking a cue from the author who lends Modern Mrs. Darcy its name and our love for alliteration, we mark the month of August by reading an Austen novel.
This year, it's Pride and Prejudice for the second time. We'll enjoy reading through the annotated edition together, gathering for a watch party of the 1995 BBC edition, and enjoying all things Austen all month long. We'd love to have you join us and stick around into the fall for more bookish connection and conversation. Get all the details or join us now at modernmrsdarcy.com/club.
[00:01:36] Readers, we hear from many of you that you set reading goals informed by your to-be-read stack at home, whether that stack is a literal tower of books or something that exists on a paper list or in the digital space. Today's guest has a specific and relatable goal of making progress through her library of already purchased e-books and keeping her unread list balanced against those she's already enjoyed.
Danielle Petrie lives and works in the Canadian prairies, where she also enjoys a unique hobby in her downtime as an avid swing dancer. When Danielle's not working, dancing, or enjoying the outdoors, you'll often find her enjoying her latest read. She has a particular enthusiasm for Canadian authors, as you'll soon hear.
Historically, it's been important to Danielle to keep her collection of Kindle e-books sitting at about 50% already read status. That is, she's read half of her purchased books already and has the other half still to look forward to.
[00:02:32] Lately, Danielle's balance has tipped heavily towards the purchased but not yet read end of the spectrum. When she reached out via our What Should I Read Next? submission form, she was currently sitting at 36% read, the balance unread, and told us of her desire to create a reading challenge for the purpose of reading what she already owns on her Kindle and bringing that ratio back into balance.
Today, we're going to take a look at Danielle's reading life, see what's on her Kindle and how it got there, and make a plan for her to experience reading satisfaction on several different levels. Readers, this is going to be fun. Let's get to it.
Danielle, welcome to the show.
DANIELLE: It is so great to be here.
ANNE: Oh my gosh. Well, I'm so glad you sent in a submission. I'm really looking forward to talking today.
DANIELLE: Thanks for having me.
ANNE: I feel like the first question is the hardest, but we love to give our readers a glimpse of who they're hearing from each week. Can you tell us a little about yourself?
[00:03:27] DANIELLE: I grew up in a small town a few hours outside of Edmonton, and I work right now as a pharmacy technician. I currently specialize in research pharmacy. So I took a nerdy career and made it even more nerdy by reading protocols and being very detail-oriented. It can be stressful sometimes, but I really love working with the coordinators and the nurses and the doctors and just that professional life that I get to have.
When I'm not working, I'm an avid swing dancer. So we have a dance studio here that does lessons during the week, but then they also hold social dances on the weekend. So I have this opportunity to learn how to dance and then also express that dance. I really love being able to, like, the combination of moving my body and being creative and connecting with people. Yeah, it's just the perfect hobby for me, I feel like. I obviously think everybody should do it, but that's just my bias.
[00:04:27] ANNE: I did ballroom dance club in college for maybe one semester. Swing was the best. Oh, it was so fun. I wonder if I can do that here. I can't resist clicking on every link that says, "Dancers are happier. Read about why," and how it is about the mind-body connection, and movement makes you happy, and it's collaborative, it's artistic.
DANIELLE: There are days where I'm like, "Oh, I have to go dance tonight." And then I'm like, "This is a hobby that you like," and then I leave and I'm like, "Oh, I'm so glad I went. That was amazing."
ANNE: Does this exist in its own pocket, or does that influence your reading life in ways that I just never would have considered?
DANIELLE: I've read books like-
ANNE: It's okay for it to be in its pocket.
DANIELLE: Yeah. I mean, I've read like Swing Time by Zadie Smith, and then a biography about Frankie Manning, who's kind of considered the ambassador of swing dancing. So things like that, but not... Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. So in standard nerdy fashion?
DANIELLE: Yeah, yeah.
ANNE: Okay. I love it. Danielle, tell us about your reading life.
[00:05:26] DANIELLE: I grew up... both of my parents were avid readers. I don't know if these are actual pictures or just memories, but my dad laying on a sun lounger with a book on his chest taking a nap kind of thing. My mom has seven sisters, so they all read these Christian romance books, them and my grandparents. So these books would just rotate between all eight of them. Usually they would end up on my grandparents' bookshelves with little initials in the front cover so people could remember which ones they had read and which ones they hadn't. As I grew up and was a teenager, I started reading those books as well.
And then the first series that I really remember having that was my own, and I loved these books, was this series by Robin Jones Gunn. It was the Christy Miller series. I read all 12 of those books. And then she had the Sierra Jensen series, and I read all 12 of those books. Then she had these books where Sierra and Christy were in college together, and I read all of those books. I just loved that whole universe. And that was really when I became like my own reader, I think.
[00:06:27] I did have a little stint in my 20s where I took reading so seriously, and I would only read like nonfiction and biographies. That didn't last very long though, because I just needed reading to be fun.
ANNE: Ooh. What was happening there?
DANIELLE: I think I just was trying to be a serious adult, and wanted to learn and wanted to grow, which weren't bad things, but it didn't need to be so serious, you know? Like, it could've been both.
ANNE: I think I get it. And I imagine that wasn't just about your reading life.
DANIELLE: Yeah, no, it for sure was my whole life for a point there. But yeah, now I would say I read a lot, but I really just love connecting with people through books. Like, I have organized brunches and books, or I do a reading weekend with my cousins. We did an independent bookstore crawl this year for Indie Bookstore Day. It feels like reading is this thing that you can do in a solitary space but still feel connected. You're reading alone, but you're thinking about the person you bought the book with or the person you're going to tell the book about. And I really love that aspect of the hobby as well.
[00:07:41] ANNE: What do you find yourself drawn to?
DANIELLE: I read a lot of romance plus books as my easy reading books, where they have like a little bit more story, a little bit more emotional resonance, but they don't require too much of my brain. I read literary books, like general fiction, literary fiction. I like when books take me just a little outside my comfort zone. Like, I'm not really into full-on fantasy, but there have been books like The Blackbird Cafe, I think it's called, or A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping, like those kind of books that... they're set in mostly a world that I know, but they have a little magic to them. Those kind push me out of my comfort zone, but I really like them. Mystery books that aren't too graphic on the page, I enjoy as well, that kind of stuff.
ANNE: Okay. Now, Danielle, I'm curious about... I know you've been listening for a little while to What Should I Read Next? What brings you to the show right now?
DANIELLE: So I have a problem with my e-reader.
ANNE: A problem.
[00:08:46] DANIELLE: A problem. So I think what happened... So, okay, let me back up. I like to keep my e-reader at like about 50% read. It feels nice to finish a book and be able to buy two more. That feels like a good ratio to me.
ANNE: I apologize for what I'm about to ask. Why?
DANIELLE: I don't know. It just feels like the books aren't getting away from me. Like, the list isn't daunting.
ANNE: Okay, abundant but not overwhelming?
DANIELLE: Yeah, and then I still get the joy of buying new things because I really like buying books.
ANNE: Ah, okay. So this is like ticking several of your readerly satisfaction boxes to maintain this ratio.
DANIELLE: Yes.
ANNE: Okay, and everything that happens when you do.
[00:09:31] DANIELLE: Yes. But I think I read a couple of books that like... or picked up a couple books on my e-reader that I was like, "Ah, not right now," or, "Oh, I'm not really that interested in it." And so I set it aside, distracted by whatever library books or physical books, and I haven't really picked it up again. However, I have continued to buy Kindle deals. So my ratios are off and I'm at like 36% read or something like that, so I have some catching up to do. So I would like to do kind of a little reading project where I catch up a bit on my Kindle.
ANNE: Ooh, we love a reading project. Thank you for bringing it to me and to What Should I Read Next? So today our goal is to help you envision a plan to take that ratio from 36 to... we're getting closer to 50 is what we're aiming for?
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. You know what? I was going to ask you a bunch of questions, but what if we talk about your books first?
DANIELLE: Sure.
[00:10:30] ANNE: You know how this works. You have at the ready three books you love, one book you don't, and what you've been reading lately. Are you ready? Can we do that now?
DANIELLE: Yes.
ANNE: Okay. How did you choose these for today?
DANIELLE: I tried not to think about it too much. I just went through, I think it was Goodreads, looked at five-star reads, and was like, "I liked that one. I liked that one. I liked that one. This looks like a good mix."
ANNE: Okay.
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: And it feels like you.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I think so.
ANNE: Okay. What's the first book you love, Danielle?
DANIELLE: The first one is The Wedding People by Alison B. Espach. I adored this book. I was hesitant going in because the premise is about somebody un-aliving themselves, and-
ANNE: I almost quit at like page 13 myself.
[00:11:19] DANIELLE: Yeah, like just considering it, and I was like, "I don't know if I want to read about this." But the way that this book... the way that people will spill to a stranger, I was all in. I was like, "Give me all the tea." And also it felt so relatable. Like, we'll do that, right? As humans, we'll be like, "Oh, like I'm not going to see you ever again. There's no purchase here, so I am going to just tell you my whole life story, and my whole unfiltered story, I guess," right? And so I just loved that aspect, and then obviously the relationships that develop throughout that. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and then told the whole world about it.
ANNE: So you're the reason it sold so many copies?
DANIELLE: Absolutely. I thought it was me.
ANNE: Okay.
DANIELLE: I'm such an influencer.
ANNE: But I think many readers had the experience we did. Maybe not the experience like, "Oh, gulp, do I want to read this?" Does this count as a romance plus for you, or do you think of this as being something different?
[00:12:24] DANIELLE: No, I do think of it as being something different.
ANNE: The publisher described it as a literary beach read, which I thought was a fun phrase.
DANIELLE: Oh, okay. Oops.
ANNE: I mean, I'm not saying that like, yes, that's official, we could enter it in the dictionary, but I did think that was an interesting phrase. Okay, I'm going to file that away. But I do want to note the dark humor in there really worked for a lot of readers.
DANIELLE: Yeah, they somehow took a heavy topic and made it accessible in a way that it didn't feel oppressive.
ANNE: I'm ready for her to write another one. I don't imagine... no, I've seen your spreadsheet. You don't have any Alison Espach on your Kindle, so we're not going to talk about the other options. I really am going to try today to not talk about books that aren't on your e-reader, because I don't feel like that's going to help you with your goal.
DANIELLE: Fair.
ANNE: Okay. Danielle, what's the second book you love?
[00:13:23] DANIELLE: The second one I love is You Are Here by David Nicholls.
ANNE: Mm-hmm. Tell me more.
DANIELLE: I was looking at my own review of this book, and it basically said, "I don't think this is necessarily a five-star read for everyone, but it's a five-star read for me." And I think that that was me just identifying that it's like, this book isn't going to be like this well-written, well-conceived book for the whole world, that the whole world's going to like or whatever, but I really loved it.
I loved that the protagonists were a little bit older and had lived a bit. I loved that it was set outdoors and that they were like walking through the English countryside. I loved the romance of it, but it felt like a romance book. I've read a lot of romance books, and I felt like one that just had a different feel to it. I don't even know if it was just more realistic and less fluffy or what. I don't know exactly what the term would be for it, but it felt a little bit different than maybe the other books that I've read, and I really liked it.
[00:14:30] ANNE: Is it fair to say it's a little moody, little broody? Maybe that niche market is those who would appreciate grammar and copy editing jokes about improving erotica?
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Because that's her job, and I loved it so much. I think a high school, although they don't call it high school in the UK, history teacher, so he's got material, too.
DANIELLE: Their banter was so good.
ANNE: Okay. I really enjoyed... Not the point, but I really enjoyed this as well.
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Danielle, what's your third love?
DANIELLE: My third book I love is Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb. This book, for me, one, I just think we should normalize therapy for people, and I think it is becoming more normalized, but I think it's books like this that help maybe somebody who feels nervous to go to maybe get an insight on what it could look like. But again, there's the serious side of it of like... it's really nice to hear people's stories and to get to know people and to know that maybe you're not alone on your own inside thoughts. But also, it was a bit of a tell-all, and I just... Tell me more. Tell me more about people's problems and what they're going through.
[00:15:55] That sounds kind of gossipy. Maybe I do like a little bit of gossip, but I do also like the opportunities for empathy and stuff as well, the opportunities to know other people's stories and have a little bit more space and grace for the way that people behave, because we don't know what people have been through, right?
ANNE: Okay, I'm not sure that this is about things being gossipy that appeal to you, but I have other ideas as well. So we'll talk about those. But first, tell me about the book that wasn't right for you. How did you choose this one?
DANIELLE: I just kind of went to the most recent book that was like a one or two-star read for me, and was like, "Sure, that one will do." I really tried to not overthink the books because otherwise I probably never would have submitted, basically.
ANNE: Well, I appreciate that. I'm glad you didn't.
DANIELLE: So I picked Jackpot Summer by Elyssa Friedland.
[00:16:52] ANNE: Did it not align with your taste? Was the timing wrong? Was it about topics you don't want to read about? Where was the mismatch?
DANIELLE: I really loved the premise of this book. I love family relationships, and this one felt like it was going to be a little bit messy family drama, and it was, but I felt like the timing was wrong for me. I wanted more time spent on character development and a growth narrative.
ANNE: Tell us a little bit about what this story's about.
DANIELLE: Jackpot Summer is about a family that wins the lottery, and I believe it's three siblings win the lottery, and the fourth sibling didn't go in on it. And so then it's kind of their adjusted family dynamics to these winnings and how the winnings affect each person individually, but also how it affects the family relationships. I would say I liked it for about the first third of the book, and then the middle section was just about how awful everybody was. And it just kept doubling down on how awful everybody was. And then all of a sudden everybody had like one intervention moment where somebody called them out, and then all of a sudden they were all better again.
And I just wanted more of a growth character development kind of thing instead of just a magical, "And now they're all better." And I'm like, "I don't think that's how being a human works."
[00:18:17] ANNE: You were talking about how you really enjoy books where there is character development and emotional resonance.
DANIELLE: Yes.
ANNE: And that's the version of the story that you were hoping for.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I think so.
ANNE: Okay, that's helpful. Danielle, what have you been reading lately?
DANIELLE: Yeah. So I have been on a bit of a kick of reading Canadian authors. Ooh,
ANNE: I love it. Do tell.
DANIELLE: I don't think I did this intentionally, but I will always seek out Canadian authors, but just this last month I've read a bunch of them.
ANNE: Danielle, this American would really love to hear you, an Edmonton dweller, like, when you think, "I want to read Canadian authors," what do you hope to find? What do you expect to find? Would you talk to me about reading Canadian authors?
[00:19:07] DANIELLE: I think reading Canadian authors, part of it comes from just the idea of being seen in a book or being able to read about spaces that I am aware of, but maybe from a different angle. So like an immigrant's experience in Canada would really be something that captures my attention, or something set on the Canadian prairies. I'm like, "Okay, I want to read about that." There's a bit of familiarity to that.
I listen to a lot of the CBC, so the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, they have a few book podcasts that I listen to that I get books from. And then I shop at independent bookstores that always have Canadian content on their shelves. And so it's easy for me to find these things that are closer to home, and I'm going to naturally gravitate towards them.
ANNE: Well, I'm glad to hear that. So with that in mind, what have you been reading lately?
[00:20:07] DANIELLE: I listened to this book on audio. It's not a very long one, and I listened to it in a day. I just didn't put it down. It's called Searching for Terry Punchout by Tyler Hellard. It was one of the Canada Reads finalists. It's about a journalist who's... he's a sports writer, and he moved away from his hometown like 10 years ago, went to college, started his career, and never went back home. But now his sports journalism career is failing, and so he goes back to his hometown in Nova Scotia to reunite with his dad, who used to be an NHL player. And his idea is he's going to write an article about his dad for Sports Illustrated, and that's going to revive his career.
This story is about him reuniting with his dad, but it's also about him reuniting with this town. He interacts with friends who some of them treat him like he's never left, and some of them are maybe a little bit more hurt that he's never been back. And he runs into an old flame, just like a lot of different relationships that almost he didn't even remember having or wasn't maintaining.
[00:21:18] So he returns to his hometown, and he has all these relationships that he is interacting with. I think for me I'm from a small town, and I go back regularly, but there is those aspects that you're like, "Oh, what is that relationship going to be like if it hasn't been maintained? What's it going to look like now?" And it was interesting to see the different dynamics between the different relationships for him and his peers.
ANNE: That sounds really interesting.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I really liked that book.
ANNE: I'm glad to hear it. I mean, did you just say out loud you read this really fast, or was I just imagining one could?
DANIELLE: No, I listened to it on audio in one day.
ANNE: High praise.
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: What else have you been reading lately?
[00:22:03] DANIELLE: So the next one that I finished recently is called Finding Flora by Elinor Florence. This one is set in Alberta in the Canadian prairies in the early 1900s as Alberta is becoming a province. So the Homesteading Act of Canada only let men be homesteaders, and there was a couple of caveats that this author found where if a woman was a widow with underage children, she could get homesteading land, or if you were a veteran from a war.
So there were some nurses who were part of the Boer War who were veterans, so then they got given land as well. So that was like the only way women could own land. And so then this story talks about the women who were homesteaders. Obviously, it's fiction, so there became this area called Ladyville, they called it, where four different women had each their own parcel of land and were developing it, and a lot of the sexism that they went through as well as just the environmental factors of homesteading in the Canadian prairies.
I found it really interesting. I will say the history kept me in the book. The story could have used a little bit more depth, but yeah, overall it was an enjoyable read.
[00:23:23] ANNE: So not the made for you in a lab kind of book, but there was enough there to keep you interested.
DANIELLE: Yeah, for sure.
ANNE: Danielle, we've already talked about this a little bit, but what are you looking for in your reading life right now?
DANIELLE: Obviously, aside from the Kindle project, I have time to read. I am single and childless, and I have a day job Monday to Friday, so I actually have a lot of time to read, but sometimes I have troubles sitting, like getting my butt in a chair and staying there. So that is something that I would like to improve on. Sometimes that's a matter of leaving my phone inside and going outside and sitting on the patio or something like that.
I also noticed that different times of the day I can take on different books. So evening reading is for sure the least mental energy book. So the romance books and such. And then maybe if there's something more literary that I want to read, I'm going to try and read it in the afternoon or maybe on like a Saturday morning kind of thing where I have a little bit more mental energy to put in it, and just kind of... I want to be more cognizant of that. I can't start a new book while I'm laying in bed at 9:00 PM. I'll never understand what that book was about. That kind of thing.
[00:24:44] ANNE: I tried to do that last night. I just started it again this morning. It wasn't about the book. So you sent me your spreadsheet of what is on your Kindle, the read and the unread, and we... the royal we, but I think my team too, I love it when readers send me spreadsheets for a project when they want to read unread books they own in their home library or on their Libby wish list or, in this case, on their Kindle.
We've seen some spreadsheets that are dozens of pages long. And yours is just maybe four, so it's not overwhelming. I'm wondering if you've done the math to see how many books it would take without purchases in the meantime, which might not be reality at all, to bring you back up into your comfort zone as far as the percentage read is concerned.
DANIELLE: It was somewhere between 10 and 15 books. I don't remember exactly.
ANNE: How does that feel to you?
[00:25:47] DANIELLE: Like a lot. Like a lot to balance with because I also have physical books, and I also have library books. But I think if I have something that's going on my Kindle and something that's going in physical, I'm okay with that, with reading multiple books at a time. I just need to get back into reading my e-reader.
ANNE: Are there any of these that you look at and think, "Hmm, that was another life when I purchased that book, and I wish I could zap it from my Kindle"?
DANIELLE: Mostly the books that... So when you're a Prime member, you get a free book a month. And usually it's like new releases and stuff, and I accumulated a bunch, and I don't know if I read any of them. And I'm just like, "Those could go. I don't know what they're about. I don't remember." It was like I picked one out of five, but I'm not that interested in them.
[00:26:45] ANNE: Is that something you would consider doing?
DANIELLE: I didn't know you could delete things from your Kindle.
ANNE: I mean, mine's ancient, so I don't want to... I mean, on mine you just hover on the bottom of the screen, and delete permanently is an option. But I think Google is your friend. Look, if Google is still going to turn up a decent search result... We used to say Google is your friend for years. I don't know if that's actually true. But the internet knows.
Readers, you know. If you have tips for Danielle. Not saying you want to do this, Danielle, but if you might feel like you had more options if you knew how to do that, readers, would you tell us in comments, whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com? We would be grateful.
Danielle, what's your order of priorities here? I can see you saying, "No, I'm not going to breathe easy in my reading life until I get my ratio back where I want it," or, "Eh, you know, the most important thing is something else entirely," for example.
[00:27:41] DANIELLE: Well, I just think my Kindle is also full of good books, and I think my priority is always to just read good books.
ANNE: I mean, I'm glad to hear that, but I'd respect whatever you said.
DANIELLE: Yeah. I would like to get it to a space where I don't feel guilty buying new things, or just generally have it in the rotation, because it is full of books that I really want to read. But yeah, I think I'm happy to make my e-reader a priority for a season.
ANNE: I mean, that's up to you. I'm not asking you to. I was wondering how important it was to you to bring it up. I keep coming back to this. Have you noticed this? Maybe I'm the one who needs bibliotherapy here. We're going to talk about this. Is there anything else you want me to know about what you like, what you don't, about your reading life, what the season looks like, anything at all?
[00:28:36] DANIELLE: I don't know if this has come through in my likes and dislikes, but I really love books around friendship and community, and especially when it's like groups of unlikely companions or being immersed in a life experience that's unlike my own, like different socioeconomic backgrounds, cultural backgrounds, sexuality, like those kinds of things. I really like connecting with humanity through reading.
ANNE: That sounds lovely. Let's take a look. Now, readers, I am pulling up Danielle's spreadsheet and... is it okay if I just rattle off some of the you haven't read yet books?
DANIELLE: Yeah, go for it.
ANNE: Okay. So you said that Romance Plus is your favorite in the romance genre. I see Susannah McFarlane, Mia Sosa, Sally Thorne, Farrah Rochon. I know there's more further down the list. I see a little bit of fantasy. There's The Fourth Daughter from Lyn Liao Butler that I've heard good things about, and that it's very much an eat, drink, and be merry kind of book, with that kind of community gathering over food and such. Haven't read it myself, though. And I see quite a few Louise Penny novels, beginning with book six. Your fellow Canadian.
[00:29:55] DANIELLE: Yeah, I bought the first book on Kindle, and then that just became how I buy Louise Penny books now.
ANNE: I gotcha. I gotcha.
DANIELLE: So I think I have one to... I don't know. Whenever they're on a deal, I buy another one, so.
ANNE: I hear you. I see some new releases like The Missed Connection by Tia Williams. I see some from last summer, like So Far Gone from Jess Walter, The Other Side of Now by Paige Harbison. I see some old Kate Clayborn and Liane Moriarty. I wandered away from romance. I see some mystery thriller, like Julie Clark, The Ghostwriter. Let's see. There's a Katrina Jackson romance. I saw several of her titles. Can I share what's jumping out at me?
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Low-hanging fruit. You have two short stories. I think one is just about 40 pages, and the other's closer to 100, by Elin Hilderbrand. Have you read Elin Hilderbrand?
DANIELLE: I read the one she wrote with her daughter, The Academy.
ANNE: Mm-hmm.
[00:30:55] DANIELLE: Yeah, I liked that. I tried to read the one where it's like a ghost in the hotel, and I didn't get very far in that one.
ANNE: Okay. So maybe the short story is not the most obvious entry point. I don't know. But the one that really jumps out at me is the one from Mike Gayle. Have you read him before?
DANIELLE: No.
ANNE: Okay. Mike Gayle is a British author. Readers, he's been in the Summer Reading guide before. It was The Museum of Ordinary People. But he writes novels about lonely people finding each other. And The One That Got Away is a short story. It's not a short story I've read.
But I wonder if that would be a gentle and short, you know, like low-commitment entry point to an author whose ethos I think you may really enjoy. And if you do like stories of friendship and community, and you get dropped into a world, I wonder if you may enjoy him. I think he's in London now, but he often sets his story in smaller towns in the UK, which, I mean, setting isn't going to be like a surefire if you liked, let's say, David Nicholls, you'll enjoy this one. But I am noting that connection. The stories they write are very different. Mike Gayle isn't sharp. He's more earnest, but he's not without humor, and I wonder if you would enjoy that.
[00:32:16] Oh, my gosh. You know what we didn't talk about? We didn't look at your loves before we started looking at your Kindle list, but this is definitely in my head. Can we roll back and talk about the books you love and do a little recap?
DANIELLE: Oh, okay.
ANNE: So as I'm looking at your books, I'm filtering through what I think you'll enjoy, but I didn't say that out loud. So you really loved The Wedding People, You Are Here, Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb, and I noticed that all these books have a strong element... I mean, they're funny. Is that something you really like in your books?
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: They're also very frank in their tone, and I think all of them. We only talked about three loves, so maybe this is coincidence, but they are very much about confronting the reality you find yourself in, even the nonfiction. Like, you had this idea of what the world was going to be, this is where you are, you, either the protagonist or the narrator, is able to look at both and see the difference and talk about it in a forthright way. I'm just interested in your thoughts on those elements. Is there something there? Am I making this up? Is there something that you really enjoy? Is that a coincidence?
[00:33:29] DANIELLE: I don't know that I've ever thought about it that way, but it's not surprising, I guess. I'm interested in people's lives. I'm interested in their experiences. I'm interested in the journey more than the destination, like those kind of things. Definitely love having serious chats with people about what's really going on in their lives and stuff like that, so for books to reflect that isn't surprising.
ANNE: Like, what's the truth under it all, and what do we do about it?
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Now I really want to interrogate Jackpot Summer and see how that does or doesn't jive with what is the actual truth, and how do we live in light of that? I'm wondering if that answer was not satisfying or if that was not the question being asked in the book.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I think that the problem was just so topical in Jackpot Summer, and then they didn't get into, like, "Why are the people really the way that they are?" It was more just like, "Oh, money made them terrible, and then they got better."
[00:34:26] ANNE: So when the siblings get their money or don't, as I recall, the question was, "Now we have this money, and we're supposed to spend it," not, "Oh, gulp, what happens next, and why, and what does it all mean?"
DANIELLE: Yeah, and like what really matters to me and what do I want to, yeah, use this for.
ANNE: I mean, I enjoyed that book. I thought that part was really juicy. And also, I totally see what you're talking about when you pick up different books for different reasons. So this is not the only gateway onto Danielle's actual AM reading pile, metaphorical or otherwise, but books that are funny, books that are frank and forthright, and books that are about looking at reality straight on and saying, "Now what?" is definitely something I'm going to be looking for in your books.
[00:35:19] So Mike Gayle, a little earnest, but I like him for you, especially as that confronting reality, frank and forthright, merges very nicely with unlikely companions coming together because of a shared felt need, whether, whether or not the reader perceives that felt need before they do. I could not help but notice that there are two unread L. M. Montgomery books on this Kindle list. Tell me more.
DANIELLE: I never read her until I was an adult. We had the Anne of Green Gables VHS series that I watched multiple times, but I never read any of her books until I was an adult, and then once I read one, I was like, "I must read more."
ANNE: What did you first read as an adult?
DANIELLE: Oh, just Anne of Green Gables. And then there's-
[00:36:18] ANNE: Emily of New Moon is on your Kindle.
DANIELLE: Yeah. There's another one I read of hers, but I can't remember what it is. Is it Blue Castle? Is that her?
ANNE: It is The Blue Castle.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I've read that one.
ANNE: It makes perfect sense as a standalone entry point.
DANIELLE: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Now, you are the boss of your reading life, but the assignment I would like to give you is read the unread L. M. Montgomery on your Kindle. Emily is not as funny as Anne of Green Gables, because Anne Shirley is funny. Emily is very earnest, but also she... I mean, just give it a few pages. I don't think you'll want to put it down.
DANIELLE: Okay.
ANNE: I'm not going to say more.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I feel like I twist my rubber arm on that, like... on my Kindle for a reason.
ANNE: But readers, these editions of these very old L. M. Montgomery books, you know, like classic Canadian literature — is that too fancy a word? — yeah, continue to be read by readers 100-plus years later for a reason, youths and adults.
[00:37:19] The Blue Castle, again, another wonderful standalone entry point, but, yeah, this is a series you can really fall in love with. And yeah, I hope you will, and then you might want to buy more Kindle books. But... readers, also free and 99-cent Kindle editions are widely available. Also, your library, no matter where you are, is likely to have Emily of New Moon, Anne of Green Gables, the first books in each series. Emily's only a trilogy, so it's a smaller commitment, but emotional resonance, character development, I mean, you got it, Danielle.
DANIELLE: Awesome.
ANNE: For romance plus, now I don't know if this is how either of the authors would describe their books, but you have some Elinor Lipman and you have some Liane Moriarty. And the Liane Moriarty on here is What Alice Forgot. It's one of my favorites. And I don't know what you know about this book. Do you remember how you happened to buy it?
DANIELLE: I think I just recognized the title, and it was probably on sale. I've read one of her books before.
[00:38:23] ANNE: Yeah. What Alice Forgot is one of her definitely more lighthearted and whimsical books. And it's quite old. I mean, I remember inhaling it on the couch in a day back in like 2012 or 2013 maybe. But in it, a woman, a hard-driving... She might be an attorney, type A, laser-focused, in a failing marriage because she doesn't have time for anything else except her professional dreams, as I recall... If I'm botching this, I'm so sorry, readers, falls off the bike at her spin class, bumps her head, wakes up, and doesn't remember anything that happened in the last 10 years. And she wakes up, and she expects to be young and optimistic and buoyant and happily married, and that's not the life she's living.
The plot is a little ridiculous, and definitely it's frothy and page-turnery. I just like blitzed through this book and then found myself thinking about the very serious questions this book raises forever. Like I read this almost 15 years ago, I think at this point, and still can remember... I mean, the essential questions at the heart of this book come immediately to mind. Hard writing makes for easy reading. That's a real skill to write something that goes down like candy but then that really gets to important questions in life. It's funny. It's frank. She's forced to confront her reality in a very inventive way. How's this sounding?
[00:39:54] DANIELLE: Very good. I think I'm picturing just like, yes, sitting on the patio on a summer day and being like, "Yep, we're just going to immerse ourselves in this world for a little bit."
ANNE: That sounds good to me. And I love that you have Elinor Lipman on your list. I think you had some that you've also read from her as well as some you haven't. Does that sound right?
DANIELLE: I have read some of her books, and if you ask me what they are specifically, I won't remember the titles. But yeah, I have enjoyed the ones that I've read before.
ANNE: Well, I'm glad to hear that. And she's prolific. I don't even want to guess at what you might have read, but On Turpentine Lane is one that's unread on your Kindle. And Elinor Lipman is... I mean, she has likable characters who are often quirky, offbeat. They're funny. They're not always... I mean, she pushes the bounds of reality. Like, really? Like, did she really purchase a house where the owner's second and third husbands fell down the basement stairs and died? Like, did that, did that really happen, Elinor Lipman? Like, no. But it still feels like it's set in the recognizable world that we live in.
[00:41:08] This happened to be my first Elinor Lipman book. It came out about 10 years ago. And it's about a woman in a job she doesn't love. She's doing grunt work for the private school she went to as a kid. She's, like, writing thank-you notes to donors or something. Her boyfriend is pretty terrible. She's basically paid for him to go on this hike to find himself, and keeps sending selfies of him with ex-girlfriends. Her dad is going through an identity crisis. Her parents' marriage isn't doing great, and she gets a handsome new coworker who's newly single, very funny, and the combination of the new house, family of origin in quirky upheaval, and hot new office mate turns her life upside down in a way that many readers find pretty fun to read about.
DANIELLE: That does sound very interesting.
ANNE: The dialogue in this is really great. Elinor Lipman does that really well. It's funny, it's upbeat, it's character-driven. I hope you're happy with their arcs. Is this sounding like it ended up on your Kindle for a reason?
[00:42:21] DANIELLE: Yeah, I think so. All of those words you're using feel like... I'm like, "Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I want to... Yeah, I want to read that."
ANNE: Okay. Good, good, good. I'm glad to hear it. Now, for more books that are funny, frank, and looking at reality head-on, I love These Heathens For You by Mia McKenzie, So Far Gone by Jess Walter. The Other Side of Now puts a magical realism spin on the confronting reality.
An unhappy actress in Los Angeles takes a flight to go visit Ireland, and flies through a portal to her alternate life had she gone to acting school in this charming small Irish town right out of high school she dreamed of. So she lands, and she's like, "I am in the upside down. Who are all these people? Why is my best friend who died in a car wreck after graduation still alive and living here?" So she gets to live out an alternate version of her life.
[00:43:18] You know, I never thought to compare this with What Alice Forgot, but the books have a lot in common with how they have an unrealistic setup. That would never happen, but ask, like, big questions about what does it mean to live a satisfying life? What do we do when we realize we've gone off course? Like, how do we course correct? And I think that could be interesting.
But I don't want you to miss good books on your Kindle just because they are not funny, and you do have so much good stuff here. Like Brooklyn by Colm Tóibín is earnest. It's not funny. But the prose is so lovely. And he writes so poignantly about immigrant experiences and the homesickness that comes with your family being an ocean away. You mentioned that you love Canadian immigrant stories, and this is not that. It's called Brooklyn because that's where the action takes place, and it's about Irish immigrants making a new life in America. But I imagine it ended up on your Kindle for a reason as well, and I doubt it's because it was your free book.
[00:44:17] You had Crying in H Mart by Michelle Zauner on here. I mean, entering an unfamiliar world, character development, emotional resonance. I mean, this is a sad book about grief, but she is such an engaging companion. I found it to be so well-told. I imagine this ended up on your Kindle for a reason.
DANIELLE: Yeah, I think it was in one of the Summer Reading Guides, yeah?
ANNE: Yes. I'm fascinated by the overlap between music and written art. I don't think it's any surprise that she's a wonderful lyrical writer. I read some interview or something where she talked about her editing process and said that her editor had made such an amazing difference in her book. And it was just little notes like, "Michelle, I want to hear more about the weather." And Michelle Zauner said that she went through and wrote in such a way that the characters could really experience the world that she was moving through, not just the emotional journey alone, and how it really added depth and heft to the story. I thought that was fascinating.
[00:45:26] DANIELLE: I do just love a person's story. I mean, this one's obviously a more emotional experience, which is just going to draw me in more, so I'm, yeah, sure I'll love this.
ANNE: Yeah. You have good stuff here. You do have some stuff that makes me think "that definitely was one of the free books," right? Because I'm, I'm struggling to see the match between the reading life... I mean, we didn't, of course, get an entire picture in our short time together, but it's not obvious to me what the connection is.
Maybe it won't be obvious to you either. Maybe you'll pick it up and you'll realize, like, "Oh, I remember exactly what appealed to me here."
DANIELLE: I do try, I mean, maybe less with my Kindle because of those free books and stuff, but I often will forget why I picked a book, but I just try to trust my past self that wanted that book or recognized that book and be like, "Okay, let's just see what it ends up being."
ANNE: I love that for you. What I want to know, Danielle, is how are you feeling about your Kindle challenge? Is a plan emerging? What jumps out to you as likely priority reads?
[00:46:30] DANIELLE: I think I'm going to start with this short story because I think you're right, it'll be a good entry point, and then try to pick something that might be a little bit more fast-paced to just really sit and immerse myself for a day kind of thing. Get the ball rolling again.
ANNE: I love that. Danielle, thank you for coming on the show. I really enjoyed our conversation today.
DANIELLE: Awesome. Thank you. Me too. This was really lovely.
ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Danielle, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next. Find the full list of titles we talked about today at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
Follow our show on Instagram @WhatShouldIReadNext and subscribe to our emails. When you join our list, we'll send you updates about the show and other happenings and upcoming events. Sign up at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
[00:47:30] And please make sure you're following in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, and more. It's convenient for you, and it helps us in real, tangible ways with our audience and our network, so thank you. If you already subscribe, thank you in advance for doing so if that would be new for you.
And thank you to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• The Christy Miller Series by Robin Jones Gunn (The Christy Miller Collection Vol One)
• The Sierra Jensen Series by Robin Jones Gunn (The Sierra Jensen Collection Vol One)
• Midnight at the Blackbird Cafe by Heather Webber
• A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
The Wedding People by Alison Espach
You Are Here by David Nicholls
Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb
▵ Jackpot Summer by Elyssa Friedland
• Searching for Terry Punchout by Tyler Hellard
• Finding Flora by Elinor Florence
• The Fourth Daughter by Lyn Liao Butler
• The Missed Connection by Tia Williams
• So Far Gone by Jess Walter
• The Other Side of Now by Paige Harbison
• The Ghostwriter by Julie Clark
• The Academy by Elin Hilderbrand and Shelby Cunningham
• The Museum of Ordinary People by Mike Gayle
• The One That Got Away by Mike Gayle
• Anne of Green Gables by L.M. Montgomery
• Emily of New Moon by L.M. Montgomery
• The Blue Castle by L.M. Montgomery
• What Alice Forgot by Liane Moriarty
• On Turpentine Lane by Elinor Lipman
• These Heathens by Mia McKenzie
• Brooklyn by Colm Toibin
• Crying in H Mart by Michelle Zauner
: Guest favorite book
▵: A book they didn’t love
• Canada Reads
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Tackling a tower of unread ebooks appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
If you’ve ever felt intimated by old books, or haven’t been sure you’re reading them “correctly”, it is not just you. We regularly hear from readers seeking tips and advice on how to read the classics.
Earlier this season New Yorker Lizzey McFarlin sent us her guest submission asking for help to approach the classics in a different way. She’d been trying to read them the way she’d approach any other book—late at night, hoping to sink in and quickly turn the pages—but found herself growing bored and abandoning them. She knew that her strategy wasn’t working, but she wasn’t sure what to do instead. Lizzey would appreciate some fresh ideas, and I have those to share today.
We’ll also talk about Lizzey’s local book club and the themed excursions they pair with the classics they read each quarter.
We hope you’ll find this conversation inspiring and empowering, and we’d love your ideas for excursions to pair with your favorite classic novels. Please share by leaving a comment below.
Find Lizzey on Substack.
We’re excited to share that we have a new option to enjoy our weekly What Should I Read Next? episodes without ads. When you sign up for our new WSIRN Ad-Free tier on Patreon, you’ll get an ad-free version of our weekly episode each week. Or, join our new Patreon All-Inclusive tier to enjoy ad-free episodes along with our weekly bonus episodes, live events, and more. Learn more about the options and join us at patreon.com/whatshouldireadnext.
[00:00:00] LIZZEY MCFARLIN: My parents hate this, but I would always take my books to sporting games, and Dad was like, "Look at the baseball game happening," and I'm like reading Harry Potter Six and couldn't be bothered with the baseball game.
ANNE BOGEL: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading, and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:40] Readers, we have news. We are excited to share that beginning today, August 4th, we're adding a new option to enjoy our weekly What Should I Read Next? episodes without ads. We have long heard from listeners that you'd appreciate an ad-free version of our weekly show. We have hammered out the details, and starting right now, you'll find that new option over on our Patreon platform.
When you sign up for our new ad-free tier in Patreon and add your personal subscriber link to your favorite podcast player, you'll get an ad-free version of our weekly episode automatically each week. It's exactly the same show, just no ads.
This means that you'll now find three options to join us as a Patreon supporter. Our existing Patreon subscribers will not see any changes. You will continue to enjoy weekly bonus episodes and special events and resources like our Summer Reading Guide and Fall Book Preview. For those readers who are not interested in bonus episodes or peeks behind the scenes, events and extras, none of that stuff, but who would like the ad-free weekly podcast, that is now available thanks to our new ad-free tier.
[00:01:42] And if you'd like to have the best of both, that's our weekly bonuses, our conversation posts, our upcoming Fall Book Preview and unboxing, and ad-free episodes, you can join or upgrade to our new all-inclusive tier. It includes bonuses, events, and ad-free episodes, all inclusive. Find out more and sign up for the option that suits you best at patreon.com/whatshouldireadnext.
Readers, we regularly hear from listeners seeking tips and advice on how to read the classics. If you've ever felt intimidated by old books or haven't been sure you've been reading them correctly, it's not just you. Earlier this season, New Yorker Lizzey McFarlin sent us her guest submission, and in it, asked for help to approach the classics in a different way.
She'd been trying to read them the same way she'd approach any other book: late at night, hoping to sink in and quickly turn the pages. But that wasn't working. She was too often growing so bored she would abandon them. She knew what she was doing wasn't working, but she wasn't sure what to do instead, and she came to us seeking some fresh ideas.
[00:02:50] Lizzey isn't reading the classics alone. She's in a local book club with five women who pick a new-to-them classic quarterly, and they plan a themed excursion related to the book. Today, Lizzey shares about some of the classic book and excursion pairings they've enjoyed so far and is hoping I can share possibilities for what they might read and where they might visit to go along with it in the future.
Whether you're interested in picking up a challenging book or you're contemplating making a lifelong dream come true, I hope you'll find this conversation inspiring and empowering, and just a lot of fun. Let's get to it.
Lizzey, welcome to the show.
LIZZEY: Thank you so much for having me. I cannot be more excited.
ANNE: Oh my gosh. Well, the pleasure is ours. Thank you so much for sending in your submission. Readers, that's at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/guest. I was really excited to see it because, readers, as you will hear, we receive multiple queries a week from readers saying, "Help me," in a very similar way that showed up in your submission, Lizzey. So thanks for that.
[00:03:53] LIZZEY: So happy to help. Okay. So excited to chat classics today.
ANNE: Well, I'd love to begin by giving the readers a glimpse of who you are. Would you tell us a little about yourself?
LIZZEY: I am 29 years old. I live in New York City with my husband and baby, Grant and Lucy. Lucy is seven months old, and is just a ball of perfection. She was born in December, so she's just like... She couldn't be cuter. I rave about her daily, as one should with their child.
I am originally from Texas, so I do have that Southern sensibility, I guess you would say. But I dreamed of living in New York my whole life, and two years ago me and my husband moved here just because we wanted to try it out, and it has been beyond our wildest hopes and dreams. We love it so, so much.
By day, I work in corporate recruiting. I work at a consulting company. But I spend a lot of time writing. I have a Substack I use. I do a lot of film photography, and I just love eating, drinking, cooking, and I spend a lot of time exploring my wonderful city with my friends. People are always in town visiting, and so spend a lot of time hosting as well, and it's just so fun.
[00:05:07] ANNE: Okay, that sounds incredible. I want to hear more about the texture of your life. I believe that is going to come up in today's episode.
LIZZEY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Tell us about your reading life. I'm leaving that broad on purpose.
LIZZEY: I have always said, like, if someone's like, "Tell me about yourself," probably the second thing to come up would be that I'm a reader, which just feels very defining of me as a person. I am an only child, so I grew up and reading was my companion. You know, I was just always reading. Such a gift is that my parents are huge readers as well.
On vacations we would always just sit and read, and that was... That's just a huge part of our life and always has been. My parents hate this, but I would always take my books to sporting games and Dad was like, "Look at the baseball game happening," and I'm reading Harry Potter Six and couldn't be bothered with the baseball game.
[00:06:05] But I really became an extrovert, like I became very extroverted late high school and early college, and so I stopped reading as much. And then mid-college I rediscovered my former love, and now I've been able to continue to be super social but reading is just such an important part of my life. And I feel like I combine the social-ness of myself and my reading life by always having book clubs.
I just love, love, love my book clubs. I had a really great one in Texas, and now my one in New York is just weird. It's like a weird format, but it's such a delight. I talk about it all the time. And it's a group of five girls, and we read classics. So we have a classics book club. So while I still do a lot of reading outside of the classics on my own, the classics and my book club are kind of anchors for my reading life throughout the year.
ANNE: We hear from a lot of readers who want to join or start a book club in their real life. You haven't been in New York City very long. Is your book club local? I'm so curious about how you connected so quickly.
[00:07:03] LIZZEY: I'm just deeply lucky to have made really good friends from the start of life here. So my book club is Lucy, Hannah, Courtney, and Catherine. It was actually Hannah's idea. I knew them all separately, and Hannah and I were talking one day, and she was also new to the city, and she was like, "I really want to have a book club, but I really want it to be classics adjacent." Because her and I both read voraciously on our own. We don't need a book club to help us do that.
She was like, "I really want to work on my classics reading, and I think it'd be fun to do it in a group." So it started as me and Hannah, and then Courtney joined, who was one of my friends, and then Catherine joined, and then Lucy joined. So we just found each other along the way, people who had genuine interest in reading the classics or were already doing it. And we just invited them to come along. But we purposely try to keep it pretty small. It's not like an open book club. Because of the way we format it, it would just be hard if we had 20 people, you know?
ANNE: Yeah. Yeah, I hear that.
[00:08:03] LIZZEY: One of my favorite elements... I just love to brand my book club. I just love to make it a big part of my personality. I think we all do, but to me it's very, very special. So we recently decided that we're going to have a name, and we're going to be called the Blue Stockings, which from my understanding, there could be, you know, elements that are off about this. But it's like an 18th-century feminist movement that started as literary discussion groups and salons, and it was just basically a lot of women being like, "We like to talk about things, like scholarly, educational things, not just hosting and fashion and things."
To my understanding, that is the origin of the Blue Stockings movement. And me and a couple other people in my book club were reading the Emma M. Lion series, The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion, and several times in that series they reference Blue Stockings. And so we were like, "Wait, this is the perfect name for our group. We should go by the Blue Stockings." So we decided to call ourselves the Blue Stockings.
[00:09:09] We bought matching socks that we all wear, and so they're blue, and they have these little frills on the side. And then this is a secret from my book club, but I'm already dreaming about the Christmas gift I'll buy everybody that involves a blue stocking in a way. So I won't say any more because I assume they will listen to this episode, but it's fun having a kind of themed... an icon for your group that you can reference.
ANNE: Okay, I'm so intrigued by these Christmas gifts. All right. But no gifting spoilers here. So in your submission, you told us something else interesting about your book club, because you take it off the page as well. Tell us more.
LIZZEY: Uh, yes. Because we're reading the classics, we don't meet monthly. That would be way too much, at least in our individual seasons of life. We're all late 20s, early 30s, and so we meet quarterly or seasonally. So we have a summer, fall, winter, and spring classic. And our very first book was Mansfield Park, in spring of last year.
[00:10:15] ANNE: That's an unconventional choice for where to start with Jane Austen. I love it.
LIZZEY: It's because I read a Jane Austen a year, and I'd only... This was my fifth Jane Austen. So this was one of the ones I hadn't read. None of the others had read it as well. So we started with Mansfield Park, and we went to a British tearoom. And we were like, "Oh, wait, this is a perfect setting. We're drinking tea. We're eating scones. We're talking about the book." Like, it just felt so perfect. So we picked our summer book as East of Eden. It felt very grand but also dry California desert. I don't know, it just said summer to us.
And then Hannah was assigned to pick our destination for that trip or for that excursion, and she was like, "Oh, John Steinbeck, when he used to come to the city, would always stay in this hotel. He signed the wall in the lobby. So we should do our next book club at this hotel so we can live the John Steinbeck life."
[00:11:11] And then I think we just had so much fun picking the book but also picking the excursion, and it's kind of flipped a little bit. Sometimes, like this summer, we knew we wanted to go on an upstate trip and do an overnight as our book club. And so we were like, "Okay, how could we find a book that pairs with what we already want to do?" And so that's kind of the formatting we've fallen into. I also really like that it's seasonal because New York is such a... Like, every season is wildly different, and all have their individual magic. And so I think when we pick pairings, we're also being like, "What do we want to do in the fall of this year, and what book really aligns with that experience?"
ANNE: So what did you pick for upstate?
LIZZEY: Okay, it's a bit of a stretch. Stay with me.
ANNE: Well, I love how you made Jane Austen work in New York City, so...
LIZZEY: Absolutely. It started with... I think it was also Hannah. She was like, "Guys, we should go to Italy, and we should read A Room with a View." And I was like, "That feels a little bold, but what about if we go to the Catskills?" And so we were like, "Okay-
ANNE: You just need a view.
[00:12:18] LIZZEY: We just need a view. Any view.
ANNE: Field of flowers.
LIZZEY: Exactly. And so we were like, "Okay, okay. We're not going to go overseas, but we'll stay in New York. We'll go upstate. That sounds fun. What book would pair well with it?" I think we just were like, "Who is a New York author?" And so that's how we landed on Fitzgerald. We picked Tender Is the Night. We were like, "We're going to go upstate."
And the reason we did that is because I think it ends on Long Island, or... I'm not positive if it ends there, but he's from Long Island or is from New York in general. And so we knew we wanted to read a book by him because he felt like he captured the New York summer essence.
ANNE: Lizzey, I'm so curious. What was the motivation for the Classics Book Club? Was this a recent love of yours and the book club instigator's idea? Was this a gap you saw? How did that focus come to be?
[00:13:18] LIZZEY: I really love doing hard things on a micro scale because I think it prepares me to be the kind of person who can do hard things on a macro level and in the actually important areas of life, like the larger scale things. And so I want to be a runner so that I can have endurance to overcome hard things, you know?
And I think it's the same with reading. A lot of reading, I love it, it's so effortless for me, but I will, in stressful seasons of my life or when I'm feeling overwhelmed, I can just go to easy books that I don't remember at the end of the day, I don't remember anything that happened. You know, they're pleasant, but they don't stick with me. And I really wanted to be proud of my reading life. I always am. I love to read. I love all the different types of books I read. But I wanted to feel the sense of accomplishment in my reading life as well.
[00:14:17] And so I think that was the reason for the classics, because you have to approach them just so... At least for me, I have to approach them so differently than I do a normal book or a non-classic novel. I have to read them slower. I have to be a lot more focused. I can't just go in and out of them and be chatting with someone or texting on the side. I really have to devote my whole attention to it. And I find that when I do that, I get so much out of it. Like, they really stick out to me in my mind, and they're these pillars of my reading life. Whereas last year I think I read 75 books, and I remember 10 of them or 15 of them super well, and the classics are in that group, because of how I have to approach them.
So I think that's why we wanted to challenge ourselves a little bit in our reading life and do it in a social setting, so... because I think the discussion amongst friends really helps us remember them as well and have them stand out to us.
[00:15:18] ANNE: Okay. I'm curious to hear how your reading practices have changed or evolved since this book club began.
LIZZEY: I would also throw in "since having a baby", because my book club has existed... It started once I was already pregnant, and then has extended through the first seven months of my daughter's life. So I think my reading has slowed down a lot, but I've also realized there's just a lot more going on in my life in the last year, year and a half, and I don't have as much time or attention to devote to reading. And so the time I am spending, I've just noticed how much more liable I am to be distracted than I was before.
And so I'm trying to figure out how to acknowledge that I may need to read less in this season, but how can I read more thoughtfully and less distracted? Maybe I don't get to read for an hour at night, maybe I only get to read for 30 minutes, but how can those 30 minutes be really concentrated and focused rather than me trying to do five things at once?
[00:16:31] I also used to listen to a lot of audiobooks, and I don't really do that anymore. If I'm doing something, I'm doing one thing at a time, and I'm trying to be really focused on it. Otherwise, it just doesn't stick with me. I've noticed that in our summer book, which is Tender Is the Night, the language is so beautiful, but it's very dense and a little convoluted at times. And if I'm not fully focused, I can breeze through five pages and have no idea what I just read. So I think the classics have forced me to focus more intently on the words I'm reading and read slower, but in a way that actually sticks with me.
ANNE: Okay, so if you're reading less but want to be thoughtful about it, it seems like reining in the options of books you might be choosing from. Like this is really helping you.
[00:17:26] LIZZEY: Yes. I would totally agree. Right now I have seven library books on my shelf that I'm just not going to get to. I'm living a lie. I need to return six of them and just focus on one book at a time. I'm a person who thinks she can do everything and loves to do five different things at once, and I feel like in this season I'm learning, do one thing at a time, do it really well, and you'll be better for it.
ANNE: Okay. Well, I'm interested in hearing more. I'm definitely interested in hearing more about your classic book and excursion pairings, because your upstate trip sounds amazing. And also in your submission you talked about how you wanted to read the classics differently. But we're also going to talk about the ones that have worked for you and the ones that haven't. What should we do first, Lizzey? Should we talk about your books?
LIZZEY: I think we should talk about my books, yes.
ANNE: You know how this works. You brought me three books you love, one you didn't, and what you've been reading lately. And, you know, I'm not sure exactly what you're looking for, but we are going to figure it out and try to find it for you. How did you choose these books that you brought today?
[00:18:35] LIZZEY: They honestly felt pretty easy to pick because I was keeping it to just the classics I've been reading, not every book I've been reading. And so in my lifetime, I've probably read 15 classic books, you know, so it didn't feel that hard to narrow it down.
I've really noticed a theme between all of them, so I'll say that before I get into my books. I notice I love language. I love just exquisitely crafted sentences. At the end of the sentence, I'll pause and just be like, "Oh, that is so beautiful. I love the way they said that." One of these books specifically made me cry when I was reading it just because I thought it was so gorgeous. But also, I love when the characters feel personal to me, and there's still a little bit of a plot. I don't like beautiful language, no plot.
[00:19:27] So the three books I picked were East of Eden by John Steinbeck, The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde, and A Room with a View by E.M. Forster. E.M. Forster is the one that I just kept reading it and clutching it to my chest after paragraphs and be like, "I can't believe I get to read this. I can't believe this book exists." But I had that experience with all of these different books.
ANNE: I love that for you. Okay, let's take it one by one. Tell me about East of Eden.
LIZZEY: Okay, East of Eden, uh, such a special book. Every member of my book club rated this in their top five books of all time after we read it, which was really special to us. So I think also part of it. I am a Christian, and so the Genesis story is very familiar to me. And so hearing it or reading it rewritten in this really creative way was so compelling to me.
[00:20:22] I think the reason this book ranks so highly for me is the language is beautiful, the structure of it is beautiful, but it's simple. I feel like a lot of classics are, you're glad you're reading them, but sometimes they're a slog to get through. I did not feel that way with East of Eden at all. I was racing through it. And I think it's because it has such a robust plot, and the characters are really compelling, and they're definitely not one-dimensional. They're just very robust, complicated characters. So in some ways it felt like a modern-day murder mystery at times or a massive family saga. So I thought the plot of that book really kept me engaged, and his writing, while stunning, was also very simple. It wasn't too complicated.
[00:21:14] ANNE: Okay. That's really impressive that it made such an impact on all your readers. I got to say, for those who think the classics are dry and dusty and boring, East of Eden, oh my, was not what I expected it to be when I finally picked it up, maybe like 10 years ago. I mean, thanks to comments from readers, this may have predated the podcast age, but I'm really glad I tried it. I mean, do you want to say anything about what is often surprising to modern readers who think like, "Oh, here's an old book about old things," and then they find this?
LIZZEY: I really just think if you read for the love of language and the beautiful way words are assembled on a page and just you hear a description of something and you want to cry or laugh or it just feels so accurate to what the thing is, the classics do that better than anything. There's a reason they're a classic. I think it's stretched my understanding of what books can be, and it's given me a higher bar for my everyday reading life, and I really appreciated that challenge. It's been hard to force myself to do hard things, but I feel like I'm becoming a better reader because of it.
[00:22:29] ANNE: All right. Tell me more about The Picture of Dorian Gray. So bossy.
LIZZEY: No.
ANNE: Tell me more, Lizzey.
LIZZEY: Get into it. The Picture of Dorian Gray was a delight. This was my fall book club last year. And we did a double feature for our book club last year, so we read The Picture of Dorian Gray, and then we read The Legend of Sleepy Hollow by Washington Irving because we wanted to go upstate to Sleepy Hollow, the town, for a day. Which is like, Washington Irving is buried there, and The Legend of Sleepy Hollow is based there. That one was an example where the excursion comes before the book.
We paired it with The Picture of Dorian Gray because it felt a little creepy, and we were going around Halloween, and we just felt like it emulated the fall spooky nature of it. The Picture of Dorian Gray was a delight to all of us. All of us loved it. I feel like my book club is often in alignment on how we feel about books, which is a nice feeling. But it just is so creepy. It's the same sort of beautiful language, really compelling characters. You're just fascinated by... You're so sucked into the story. It didn't feel hard to read. I felt like I was being pulled through it by a really plot-heavy novel, very complicated character. So I wasn't bored for a second with this book.
[00:23:49] I think I like classics that I can see how modern books evolved out of them. Like, there's a lot of echoes of the modern books I'm reading in it. Because in The Picture of Dorian Gray, there's a murder mystery, and he's on the run, and it's just a very complicated man. And I think that was a compelling read for me.
ANNE: Sounds good. I love the sound of that trip. That sounds amazing.
LIZZEY: It was so dreamy. And we got stuck into a Halloween festival while we were up there. It was amazing.
ANNE: I love that for you. All right, Lizzey, tell me more about A Room With a View.
LIZZEY: Okay. A Room With a View is the one that is a little uncommon because this was not a book club pick. My friend Hannah was like, "We should read A Room With a View and go to Italy." And she was joking, but she pitched it to our book club, we were all like, "Okay, ha ha. We can't go to Italy this summer." And we chose a different book.
[00:24:48] But I ended up reading A Room With a View because I was on maternity leave, and I had time, and Hannah was like, "This book will be very, very important to you." And she was right. The main character's name is Lucy, which is my daughter's name, so that was just like a fun little aside that I loved. It almost felt Jane Austen-esque, which I don't know, maybe they're not similar at all, but they felt similar to me. Like, you just love this young woman who is finding her way in the world, and she's learning to explore and see new parts of the world, and then she comes back to stuffy old England and is changed by her travel experiences. I felt like I was Lucy in this novel, and I just love that.
Again, the writing is exquisite. The characters are really personable. Feel like those are always themes for me. But I think I liked that it was witty as well. I love the way E.M. Forster poked fun at this persona of English citizens going abroad to find themselves and discover themselves in Italy. And while he was talking about a very common experience that people had at that time, he also was making fun of the way that they travel, and when they're in Italy, the different idioms they do or the idiosyncrasies they embody while they're traveling. So I just thought it was a really easy book to read. I loved the characters, and also I just liked the sarcasm that was built into the novel as well.
[00:26:15] ANNE: Okay, not a question we ask a lot on What Should I Read Next?, but have you seen The Merchant Ivory adaptation?
LIZZEY: No, tell me more.
ANNE: Well, it's widely argued that this is one of the few adaptations that's better than the book it's based on.
LIZZEY: Whoa.
ANNE: It features a very young Helena Bonham Carter and Daniel Day-Lewis. There's an iconic nude bathing scene. Not sexual at all. Very, very funny. Oh, Maggie Smith is Aunt Charlotte.
LIZZEY: Oh, wow. Okay, I need to watch this. I have heard about this. My friend, once I read A Room with a View, was like, "The movie is amazing. We need to watch it together." So that's up on my list. I'll add it to my end of summer bucket list.
ANNE: I mean, if you're not going to Italy with book club, maybe it would be a fun movie night.
LIZZEY: Which I think is a mistake that we're not, but maybe next year.
ANNE: Yeah, if you're not going yet.
LIZZEY: Yes, exactly.
ANNE: Okay, Lizzey, tell me about a book that was not a good fit for you, and I'd love to hear why.
[00:27:18] LIZZEY: I feel bad saying this, so I'm going to start there. The book that was not for me was The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky. I was so excited about this book. Every book club, we pick the book for the next book club. And so in the fall, I was one month away from having my baby, and the girls in the book club were like, "Lizzey, what do you want to do? You get to pick our winter book because you're the one about to have a child, and you kind of get to set the scene." And so I was like, "The Brothers Karamazov is a book I've always wanted to read." I have several friends who are like, "This is my favorite book of all time," so I had very, very high expectations for this book. But for anyone who doesn't know, it's like a 900-page Russian tome, with all these great themes about spirituality and family and good and bad and all this stuff.
[00:28:13] So we decided to read it, and we decided to do as our pairing. This is my favorite pairing yet. We went to the New York City Ballet, and we went to this place called Dante, which is this fabulous bar in New York City, and got vodka martinis and just felt very Russian in our... We all dressed up in formal gowns for this excursion as well. And so it's my favorite excursion we have done yet.
However, the book, all of us were like, "This was really, really hard to get through." I think the reason this wasn't for me was so much my phase of life and not specifically about the book itself, which is why I have some regrets. Like, I had just had a baby. I was trying to read a little bit every day while she's crying in the background and figuring out how to be a person. I think I was missing a lot of the things that make this book great, which are the great meditations on good and evil and spirituality and family and our place in the world.
[00:29:13] I think a lot of those massive chapters or these moments where Dostoevsky is trying to tell us a story and impart meaning to us, I was just missing because I was flying through. And so it's a book I would really like to come back to one day and read differently than I was able to do at this time in my life.
ANNE: Mm-hmm. It'll be there for you when you're ready to pay it a return visit.
LIZZEY: I agree. I think the problem is me, not Dostoevsky, and I apologize to him.
ANNE: You know, okay, so I see many ways in which what I'm about to say is patently false, okay? However, it does seem like the older books are more patient when it comes to the reader not having time for them right now. I feel like I phrased this really weirdly. Here's what I mean. There's books coming out right now that, like... It almost feels like I might miss the cultural moment if I don't read it now. You know?
LIZZEY: Oh, yes.
ANNE: I'm not going to be able to participate in the conversation. But there's never going to be a wrong time to read a book that's been around for a couple hundred years.
[00:30:20] LIZZEY: I agree with that. I think that's a very good way to put that.
ANNE: The theory needs a great deal of refining. But there's a seed there I'm going to tug at later, to mix my metaphors completely.
LIZZEY: No, no, I love that. I agree completely, and I know that it is waiting for me when I am ready for it.
ANNE: Okay. All right. Well, I'm glad you sound philosophical about that. I mean, one of the reasons to read at all is discover what it is we like and why. So maybe in 10 years, you'll be like, "Ugh, I see why this has stuck around, and also this is not to my taste, and here's why." But it feels like your reading experience was not in-depth enough to feel like you're able to say that at this moment in time, and also you don't know what kind of reader you'll be in 10 or 20 or 30 years.
LIZZEY: 100%. Can I add one more detail about-
ANNE: Absolutely.
[00:31:12] LIZZEY: So another element that I'm thinking about as you're talking is, I think the cultural context is so, so important for a book like that, and I didn't have it. Like, very soon after I read this book, I reread A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles, which is a book I adore. And that's set like 30 years after this book ends. I could be getting the dates wrong a little bit.
But so much had changed in Russian society between those two books, and I was like, "Oh, I think I would've enjoyed The Brothers Karamazov a lot more if I had understood what was going on in Russia at that time in their society." It was the end of serfdom, and a new class was rising up. I think for these classic books, I need to do a little bit of prior study to help understand the scene that they're set in. And I think that will really help my enjoyment of them. So that's like a note for myself for the future is to do some study in advance.
[00:32:20] ANNE: You know what's so interesting is I think that much contemporary historical fiction we're reading does some of that work for you. Like, it helps you understand the context.
LIZZEY: Yes.
ANNE: Amor Towles isn't assuming you know nothing, but he also really helps you out in understanding the world the count was living in, and not just the world of the hotel. That's not all I'm talking about. But Brothers Karamazov assumes a lot of you.
LIZZEY: 100%. He just is like, "So yeah, the serfs, there's no more serfs, and they used to be serf owners, so they're bad." I could be getting some of these details wrong. He keeps referencing Pushkin. I'm like, "I don't know how important Pushkin is to this society. I think I would appreciate this a lot more if I understood what you're trying to tell me in these small details that I just... I don't know."
[00:33:10] ANNE: And I think the subtext I'm hearing is at the stage of life in which you were reading this book, you wanted to read the book. You didn't want a lit seminar on how to approach the book, the background information you needed to know, etc, etc. In order to read the book, you wanted to be able to read a book.
LIZZEY: Correct. I wanted simplicity.
ANNE: Okay. Because sometimes, I mean, readers might be thinking, "Well, there's a solution here I'm seeing," but that's not the package you were looking for.
LIZZEY: Correct.
ANNE: Okay. Maybe it'll be the package you're looking for at age 45, but not today.
LIZZEY: Fingers crossed.
ANNE: Yeah, not when Lucy's less than seven months old.
LIZZEY: Seven months old, yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Lizzey, what have you been reading lately?
[00:33:54] LIZZEY: The book I'm reading for my classic book club, which I referenced a few times, is Tender is the Night by F. Scott Fitzgerald. It's, on paper, my perfect book because it starts in the French Riviera. I'm obsessed with France. I took French all through college. It's set in the French Riviera. It's basically about a love triangle, I would say, if that's not too simplistic of a way to say that. So it's a great start.
And then to my knowledge, it ends in Long Island. Maybe it doesn't actually come back to New York. But F. Scott Fitzgerald is a New Yorker, so I'll give him that. And so far it's been really, really lovely. I do think I'm having the same problem where I went back to work recently, and so I'm kind of trapped in this like I just don't have a ton of time to read this in the way I would like to. And then I didn't start early enough.
[00:34:48] So I think some of the problems I'm having with this book are entirely self-created. But the book itself, whenever I settle down with it and really focus, I love it. And I think it's exquisitely told, and I can see why he's the master. So I'm really enjoying that.
And then I always have like four or five books going at the same time, which is my own problem. So I'm reading Crossing to Safety by Wallace Stegner, Dolly All The Time by Annabel Monaghan, and then Fates and Furies by Lauren Groff. So lots of different books kind of going in the background, but really trying to focus on Tender Is The Night right now.
ANNE: Okay, I'm glad to hear that. So what are you hoping to take away from our conversation when it comes to recommendations on what you might read next or in the future?
LIZZEY: I would really like to hear some classics you think I should read based on what I've shared, and think of some fun pairings that could go with them, things we could do, and I'm happy to workshop those together because I plan events for a living, and I just find that I love to curate experiences. And I think that makes my reading life more enjoyable, and I have more motivation to finish my books when I have something I get to do to look forward to.
[00:36:04] So I'd love to think of some classic excursion pairings. And then if you have any tips for how to read the classics better at this period of my life, I would love to hear them because I'm trying to improve my method.
ANNE: This sounds good to me. Lizzey, let's start by talking tips, and I'm thinking specifically about what you said in your submission about how you often try to read these like you do regular books, which is late at night, wanting to read quickly, and they just don't grab you. So it's easy to, I think as you said, read five pages and be like, "Wait a second, my mind is wandering. What is even happening?" And we don't want that to happen for you.
So let's talk about maybe approaching that differently. And, you know, we've just been saying the classics without really saying what we're talking about. Like, how does your book club define a classic? In Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club, and we've done classes on this, the very loose way we've defined is about 50 years old, still being commonly read today. And then often we'll talk about modern classics as well, which loosely defined, works of such literary merit I feel like that needs air quotes, highly subjective, but the language endures, the story endures, still has something to say decades later. Often being taught in classrooms is a signal, but not a defining quality that it's the kind of book we're talking about. But how do you all think about this for your book club?
[00:37:36] LIZZEY: It's a great question. I think we have a very loose definition of it. Like for example, our spring book club was Anne of Green Gables and paired with a book called Hotel Ludwig, which is like set in New York and written by...
ANNE: Oh, I don't know that one.
LIZZEY: His last name's Bemelmans. He wrote the Madeline books. He illustrated the Madeline books.
ANNE: Oh, okay.
LIZZEY: And so he has a bar called Bemelmans Bar that he illustrated the designs in the bar. And so we wanted to go to Bemelmans Bar, so we read like a double pairing of Anne of Green Gables and Hotel Ludwig. Those are both atypical classics. They're not in the same category as East of Eden, but they felt old enough. They felt like they had enduring significance, or like in the case of Hotel Ludwig, he has enduring significance because of the Madeline series and all of that. So I think we have a pretty loose method of defining that, but it has to be old. That's a good bar for us.
ANNE: How old?
[00:38:36] LIZZEY: Definitely 1900s. Lonesome Dove is the earliest classic I would count, and I feel like that's... Is that like 1980s or something?
ANNE: That sounds right.
LIZZEY: Yeah. I would say about 50 years, like what you said. That feels like a good mark for us.
ANNE: Okay. It's possible that there's something I think you would really like where I'm like, "Okay, is this old enough? Is this old enough?" We're going to talk about it.
LIZZEY: I trust you.
ANNE: Okay. So tips. First of all, people come to the classics for different reasons, and I really want readers to hear and understand that. Like some readers just really are seeking to... I mean, people have explicitly told me, "I am seeking to recapture my lit seminar experience from college or grad school where we can just really get into all the things, the symbolism, the literary heritage, the meta-analysis." Like they want to dig in and talk, and talk, and talk. And that's not everybody, and that's fine.
[00:39:35] Some readers are looking for an experience. They want the mood, they want to be immersed in the time period of history, nature, strong emotions, the power of imagination, timeless tales, old-fashioned feeling now customs. Like, that's the appeal for them.
Some people are enchanted by history. Some readers just don't want to miss out on all the good stuff available to them in the literary canon, whether that's traditional or reconsidered.
Some readers are really drawn to the power and distinctiveness of language in the classics. And I've heard you say, Lizzey, "The language, the language, the language" over and over. Classic novels often use language that definitely sounds more notable to the modern ear, in part because it's old, and it's not how we talk or write anymore. And we're really captured by older words and phrases or recognizable quotes that have become well-known over time. But these classics with striking language and also writing that just seems so well-crafted, that may have unique structures or groundbreaking at the time narratives, really appeal to a writer drawn to these linguistic elements.
[00:40:56] We did a great Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club class on this years ago, I think it was 2020 or 2021, on what kind of classics reader are you. And that may be interesting to book club members or those who are interested in signing up to check that out. But, for readers I believe... not like we can't be drawn to the classics for different readers, but for those who really love the language, James Baldwin, Toni Morrison, Gabriel Garcia Marquez are reliably wonderful authors with numerous works to choose from to get started with. And you could keep quotes in a journal or a spreadsheet.
You said you didn't do audiobooks much because you're more of a mono-tasker these days, but if you really enjoy the language, listening to the audiobook while reading on the page might sound like overkill. It also might be a perfect way to just let the language wash over you. Experience it in your ears, but also not miss visualizing it on the page.
[00:42:02] LIZZEY: I think it also might help me focus, because it creates kind of a holistic experience, and you're surrounded by it. So in some ways, I actually think that would be a great idea. I've thought about doing that with Tender Is the Night, because I'm having trouble focusing on what it's telling me. And I think surround-sounding it would be a great experience.
ANNE: Yeah. And I think something I see a lot of readers do is they think, "Okay, I'm a grown-up, I'm a reader, I should be able to enjoy this classic work on my own, left to my own devices, no context." But, if you were in a grad school seminar, you wouldn't just go home and start reading the book. You would talk about it first, often in a group. So if you do really enjoy the language, or for any reader, just knowing what you're getting into before reading the book, look, you can go into any book cold if you want to, but many readers find that old, dense, substantial books are ones that really lend themselves to knowing what the story's about before going in.
[00:43:06] So if you read an essay, a summary, if you talk to another reader before sitting down to let the language wash over you, you can pay closer attention then to the writer's craft, to deciphering what the older language is saying, or just paying attention to the beautiful turns of phrase.
LIZZEY: Mm-hmm. I love that you said that, because the language and then the lit class experience are the two types of classic reader profile that you shared that stuck out to me. I love a footnote. I love knowing what the chapter, the Grand Inquisitor in The Brothers Karamazov is trying to tell me about, like what is the overarching theme that I'm supposed to get when I'm reading through that chapter. That is one of my very favorite parts of reading the classic is getting to get the full context of what is happening. So I think I would do well with some prior study.
[00:44:02] ANNE: Yeah. And just even simple things. Okay, I recently read Jane Smiley's 13 Ways of Looking at a Novel, and now I'm going to talk about it in every episode for a year. I think I'm kidding, but time will tell. But she talks a lot about various classics and what they're doing. And I just remember her... Like, I've read Anna Karenina twice, it's been a long time, which is very succinctly she says, "What you need to understand is this is what's happening with Kitty, this is what's happening with Levin. These are their roles in the story." I think she said like three sentences, and my brain went, "Oh. I wish somebody had told me that going in. It would've helped me experience the story more as opposed to trying to discern what Tolstoy was up to." Being told what the author's up to so you know what to look out for is just so helpful. Even if somebody tells you, "Pay attention to the water imagery," something real simple like that changes the way you read.
LIZZEY: 100%. I agree.
[00:45:00] ANNE: So, okay, just a couple quick tips. And we wrote a blog post... We. We as I. That's the royal we. Wrote about helping you tackle kind of intimidating classic novels years ago. We'll link it in the show notes. But immersing yourself in context, using a tool like SparkNotes. Like, you're not plagiarizing an essay. It's a great resource for comprehending classic lit, or it can be, used well, review the character list, read the plot summary, see what themes and symbols are to be paying attention to. And then you're not reading it as a substitute for the story. You're reading it to appreciate and get more out of the story.
Having a copy that you can mark up is really helpful. Your brain processes the words differently when you're interacting with them on the page. And like, don't make this feel like homework, unless you really like homework. Just mark down what interests you or sparks your curiosity, what you want to look up later.
[00:46:00] One of the most helpful things that I didn't start doing until my 30s was taking the blank pages in the beginning of a book that often exist, or just writing right on top of the title page, and writing down something like, "Page 18, quote. Page 374, theme restated." Just things that I can refer back to that are really important in helping me understand the core of the book, like to think deeply about it later.
Some readers like to make character lists or sketch out family trees. Some like to sketch maps. My art skills aren't that good. But the act of putting pencil or highlighter to paper helps readers retain what they're reading. Maybe you have a different system that works for you that doesn't involve a pencil. That's great, but think about how an interactive kind of experience might help you.
[00:46:56] Audiobooks are great. Honestly, movies can be great. I remember reading an interview with Jennifer Ehle, who was Elizabeth Darcy in the 1995 Pride and Prejudice with Colin Firth, and she said, "Reading the Jane Austen novel, it's so tricky to get your modern ear around the language, and I had to hear it out loud to get the hang of it." And that felt so affirming to hear her say that. Because when you're watching the movie it doesn't sound stilted. Like it sounds like people talking. And when you're listening to an audiobook or watching the movie, they've interpreted it for you. Like, you can hear it as spoken speech and not like you stuttering over, "I'm not used to this sentence structure."
LIZZEY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: And talking about it with other readers, and look, that's why you're here today, because this is something you're already doing.
[00:47:45] LIZZEY: Yes. Ah, I love that. I agree wholly. That's why I love Shakespeare in the Park, the free play New York City does every summer, because Shakespeare's so confusing to me when read on a page, but then seeing how they act it out and put a modern interpretation on it but still using the old language, I have such an appreciation for Shakespeare that in the past when I was reading it in my English classes, I was like, "What? What are you saying? I am not following anything." And as soon as I saw it performed, I said, "Oh, I get why this has endured for as long as it has." It is miraculous. But I never got that until I saw it in person.
ANNE: Yeah. I hear that. Oh, and also, so many classics have an introductory essay in the front. And some readers are going to want to be careful with those, because they often do discuss the entire book start to finish. And maybe you feel like just by living in this world, "I know how Pride and Prejudice ends," that's totally fine. I tend to feel that way about Jane Austen. There's no such thing as a spoiler in Jane Austen, but you may have another opinion.
[00:48:50] But those essays can be really helpful in that they often will tell you, "This is when the book was published. This was the context. Here's a little bit about the author's biography. Here's the reason they wrote this book when they did. Here's the difficult path to publication, or here was the easy path to publication. This is what the initial critical reception was. This is how it hits differently today." You know, just curated nuggets that somebody believes will inform your reading experience or how you understand the book and its meaning.
LIZZEY: Yeah, I love that.
ANNE: Any of that helpful?
LIZZEY: Oh, so helpful.
ANNE: Anything missing, I mean, of course, lots of things are missing, but anything you would add that's helped you?
LIZZEY: No, I think I need to be a little bit more disciplined to do the pre-work, because I think I know myself, and the pre-work helps me appreciate the novel I'm reading so much. Yeah, exactly like you said earlier, I can get out of having to try to parse through the sentences to see what it's trying to tell me, and because I already know what it's trying to tell me, I can enjoy it so much more on the second read.
[00:50:04] I had that experience with East of Eden. I read it in high school and enjoyed it, but it didn't stick out to me that much. And then when I reread it recently, because I already had a basis for understanding it and I'd studied it in that class, I could just sit back and appreciate the novel in its entirety. So I think the more I can do that and do a little hard work upfront, it's going to pay off a lot.
ANNE: That sounds good to me. Okay, I am, in the back of my mind, thinking of books and literary excursions, but would you please first tell us about some of your memorable literary excursions and book pairings that you've done with book club?
LIZZEY: I've already referenced some of these, so I will be repeating them, but I'll highlight my three favorites, because I just think I love it. I love the different seasonal settings we explore. So last fall, we did Picture of Dorian Gray and The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, and we went upstate to Sleepy Hollow, the town, for the day, and we went to Washington Irving Cemetery. And they were doing a half-marathon for Halloween, so everyone was dressed in costumes as they were running the half-marathon.
[00:51:21] So we were just watching the half-marathon go past, and the leaves were changing, and we were talking about these creepy old books that, at least for The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, it had been set in that town. I think that was really fun for our book club to also get out of the city and have a whole day together, because it helped with bonding. Because not all of us knew each other initially, so it kind of helped us coalesce as a group even more. And we just loved that excursion, so I'm really excited for our fall trip this year.
Another memorable one was The Brothers Karamazov, and then the New York City Ballet, and the vodka martinis. I just loved that. We ended that book club at 2:00 in the morning in formal dresses in the West Village in New York, and I was like, "This is so weird, but I'm loving every second of it." Like, I just feel so charmed by the setting we found ourselves in.
[00:52:18] And then our spring book... I think all of us after The Brothers K needed a break. And so we were like, "Let's do something a little unconventional." So we picked Anne of Green Gables and we picked Hotel Ludwig, and we went to the Brooklyn Botanic Gardens when the cherry blossoms were in bloom. And we had just named ourselves the Blue Stockings and bought our matching socks, and so we were all in our little blue stockings, it was so cute, and wandering around the gardens. And then got to go to Bimbleman's Bar and just have a drink and enjoy the person that wrote Hotel Ludwig. So really, really special.
I think one reason I love the excursions is because even when we don't like a book, meeting for book club is like a non-negotiable for me. It's always one of my favorite things. I love being with my friends and talking about it, even if the book wasn't enjoyable. Like, I really did not enjoy Hotel Ludwig, but that day with my friends, having this curated fun experience in New York City, made it so worth it. You know? It didn't feel like a bummer that I hadn't enjoyed that book. I still got to go to the botanic gardens and hang out with my friends and talk about it. So that felt really special.
ANNE: That sounds amazing.
LIZZEY: So good.
[00:53:38] ANNE: Okay, thanks for sharing those with us. Gosh, I am overdue for a trip to New York. It's been a few years. All right. Lizzey, I have some ideas for you. Tell me what you think. I've really confined myself to New York City here as a way to rein in from the classics. There's so many. But we're thinking about destinations you could actually go to, and I'm aiming for a range of years and content, and also just how the books land emotionally, what the literary tone is, variety of language, that kind of thing.
LIZZEY: That's perfect.
ANNE: Okay. I'm also keeping in mind I want to get you at least a couple of books that would definitely offer an extremely rewarding reading experience if you read all the essays and researched in advance and knew everything about the whatever era or the literary society that the author was a part of. But also, you could just get in bed and read a chapter at night, and you would know what was going on in this story. So that's what I'm aiming for.
LIZZEY: I love it so much.
[00:54:43] ANNE: Okay. Have you read Passing by Nella Larsen?
LIZZEY: No.
ANNE: I love this for you. I'm not the boss of your book club, but I love this for your book club, too, because it's so discussable, it's short, and it lends itself to a field trip. It's just 141 pages. And for those who tend to think that the classics are dry and dusty and boring, check out this book. And then you could watch the adaptation, which I haven't seen, but it has Tessa... Tompkins? I've loved her since the Veronica Mars days, and I've heard it's good, so that's hearsay, but there's lots you could do with this book.
But Nella Larsen wrote this in 1929. It's set during the Jazz Age in Harlem. It's the story of two childhood friends who reconnect after they've chosen very different paths, very different ways to lead their lives. Both women are Black and light-skinned. One has chosen to pass for White, and is even married to a White man who doesn't know anything of her heritage or history. The other friend is married to a successful African American physician.
[00:55:50] As the women start to spend more and more time together... you know what? I didn't identify these women by name, but one of their lives, the one who has chosen to be active in the African American community in this day and age, starts looking better and better to the woman who's chosen to pass for White. And what unfolds as envy starts to creep into the relationship and take over this woman's mind. It feels like a psychological thriller.
The ending is perfect and shocking. This story feels so fresh and modern and unexpected. I couldn't believe it was written nearly 100 years ago. Obviously, I'm reading this as a White woman in the 21st century in Kentucky. Like, these are not my people and not my place. So I really need those introductions to really understand the context and the history and how common were these characters' actions at the time. The answer surprised me, what I read in the literary commentary. But, what a portal into a different time and place.
[00:56:55] This could be a great entry point to Nella Larsen and the Jazz Age and the Harlem Renaissance, which is right up the road from you. I mean, I'm definitely not going to pretend to be your Harlem Renaissance tour guide. Like, I walk the streets of the area, but I don't know any. I want to read this and go visit Harlem. But I know that there's a lot there you could do, from formal walking tours to just like, "Hey, friends, let's go check out some of the sites and intersections that were name-checked in this book." How's that sounding?
LIZZEY: I love this idea. I also love it feels very fall-themed because of the psychological thriller aspects of it. So this book sounds fabulous. It sounds a little bit like The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett in some ways.
ANNE: Oh, my gosh. That is a wonderful flight pairing for this book. Just excellent.
LIZZEY: Yes, I loved that book a couple of years ago. So that would be amazing. We could do a walking tour and end at a jazz bar. I'm loving it.
[00:57:56] ANNE: Yes. Okay. I love that for you. Okay, vibe shift. How about some Edith Wharton?
LIZZEY: Okay. Never read Edith.
ANNE: Well, she was a New York City author, and she did not like New York. She describes it constantly as ugly and bland and boring, but her books are set in New York City, and there are so many different places and locations. I haven't read everything, but my recommended starting points would be either The House of Mirth or The Age of Innocence. And I really like the locations that are on the pages of The Age of Innocence, and it's probably her best-known. So let's start there.
This is a story about fashionable, rules-driven, turn-of-the-century New York society. And she was born and raised in elite New York society. She married into New York elite society, as she was expecting to do. Her novels were both very much in this world while being critical of this world, and yet we see the characters struggle with wanting to break free of the norms and conventions, but when they do, they are punished on the page.
[00:59:21] So in The Age of Innocence, we meet a gentleman lawyer named Newland Archer. He's of elite New York society, and he's getting ready to wed his fiancée, who is also of elite New York society, and they are going to cement their legacy and their wealth by uniting these families in marriage, as you did back then in these social structures. So his fiancée is like the platonic Victorian female. She's beautiful. She's rich. She's... Oh, gosh, my mind is thinking Jane Austen. She is an accomplished woman. She's a society lady.
And the gentleman lawyer, he's like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I know this is what I want. Of course this is what I want. I'm that kinda man, you know. Like, I want the best. This is what my culture says the best is." But also, he then kinda falls in love with his fiancée's cousin, who has just returned to New York after leaving behind a marriage to a European count that went badly, and she is flashy, and fun, and sexy. He's intrigued, and he kinda wants to throw over his parents, and society, and everything that society has said he owes them, and do whatever he wants. So does he want to make the good match, or does he want to follow love, or what he thinks love is? That is the question.
[01:00:48] But, in this book, they go to Grace Church. They go to the little art museum up in the park, which is The Met. They wander the streets of the Village. They stop their horse and carriage in Union Square. They visit the intersection at University and Lower Fifth. They visit a brownstone on East 39th. They really get around Manhattan. And that could be really fun to be reading with the city you live in in your mind, knowing these locations. Like Grace Church, that's going to look exactly the same. Like, you could stand on the little paved path going up to the doors and be like, "Yep, Edith Wharton was here. Her character was envisioned being right here." And then, you know, things like The Met have changed a lot but also not as... It's still The Met. It's still the art museum in the park. And what I really want to know is how is this sounding?
[01:01:43] LIZZEY: I love this book. This was actually a book we considered for our summer read because of all the reasons you said, Edith being a New York City author. But it sounds so lovely. I would love to just go to The Met for a day and have lunch or dinner there, and then wander through the museum and talk about this book. It sounds amazing.
ANNE: That sounds good to me. I was asking you how you define a classic because I really wanted to put some Laurie Colwin on your radar if you hadn't read her yet.
LIZZEY: I have not.
ANNE: Okay. So she is an American writer who died at age 48 in 1992. She was still writing at the time of her death, but that was not that long ago. She started writing in the late '60s, and the books that I think you might really enjoy were published in the '80s. But modern classic I don't believe is a stretch at all. I hear those words associated with Laurie Colwin all the time.
[01:02:41] And Lizzey, I wish I could quote the words that came out of your mouth when I thought, "Ugh, Laurie Colwin," but you said something about how you love food and friends and family and gatherings and...
LIZZEY: Mm-hmm...
ANNE: Yeah. Do you want to fill in the blanks for me, or is that enough?
LIZZEY: Yes. I just am a social butterfly. I love hosting people. I love eating and drinking with my friends and family. I feel like people are always at our house. It's my favorite thing in the world to eat and drink with my friends.
ANNE: Well, Laurie Colwin shared a similar love, similar sensibility. She indulged hers in the Village, from her childhood in the '40s through the early '90s. And she wrote both fiction and nonfiction. Her best-known nonfiction book is probably Home Cooking. The subtitle is A Writer in the Kitchen. And she writes about... I mean, she writes about food preparation, but also what it means to gather people, what it means to cook, where the pleasure is in cooking.
[01:03:45] She tells these wonderful stories about meals that were lovely and perfect and satisfying, and also ones that just went horribly, terribly, disastrously wrong. If I had to pick one word for Laurie Colwin, she is charming. She's consistently funny. It feels like she's talking to you as a friend. She feels like a relatable kind of expert who's wise and who's seen things, but always gracious and understanding. Like, she's going to understand where you're coming from, and she understands when it's been a hard day, and she understands when you want to make the meal really special, and she understands when things aren't quite working out the way that you hope they would, and can she tell you a story to make you feel better about it?
So I was about to say, that's Home Cooking, even though I didn't tell you very much. But she's also well known for, and listen to this very strong sales pitch, she's well known for writing fiction in which not that much happens and yet, readers find themselves hanging on every word to find out what happens in these novels where not much happens.
[01:04:49] A typical kind of review of Laurie Colwin is, "How did I just read this book in which not much happens and still came away feeling completely charmed." Or like my friend read one of her novels and said, "Okay, I think I just read this book about a woman quietly trying to destroy her own life. Why was it so winning?" Like, it was so winsome. And I'm smiling to myself as I'm reading about this woman sabotaging herself. How? And the answer to the how is Laurie Colwin. She has a whole collection of books to choose from. You know, not like in the tens, but 10-ish books. But I recommend starting with Home Cooking for nonfiction.
And then for a novel, she has one quartet, and I believe the others are all standalones. I haven't read everything, but I aspire to. She did write a book that maybe is not for you. So I want you to know. It's called A Big Storm Knocked It Over. It's about a woman whose entire life is disrupted, made chaotic, and then needs to be rebuilt. The big storm that knocked it over, I am sorry to tell you, is the arrival of her firstborn child. So maybe don't read that one yet unless you really want to.
[01:06:07] LIZZEY: I mean, Lucy is a storm, but a beautiful storm. So we'll see.
ANNE: Well, Laurie Colwin wouldn't deny that, but she would understand that it does change some things in a person's life. Okay, decide how you feel about the new baby thing, but that would not be... It wouldn't be a bad place to start. I can tell you that my first novel that I read by her was Happy All the Time, where... yeah, I was just going to tell you again, not much happens. It's about two couples who are more or less happily married, and yet even though plots thrive on conflict, there's a story there despite there not being a whole lot of conflict.
LIZZEY: Yeah. This sounds so, so up my alley. I don't think I've heard of this person, but her novels sound like they fit exactly into themes I like. I read a lot of books about food and hosting, like Supper of the Lamb or Save Me the Plums, and this feels similar, adjacent in some way.
[01:07:07] ANNE: Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Those books would nestle up very comfortably on a bookshelf. They have a lot to say to each other. And I think those authors would very much enjoy each other's company. I know Ruth Reichl wrote an intro to one of Laurie Colwin's reissues.
LIZZEY: Oh, well, maybe then I need to start there. I love Ruth Reichl and is one of my very favorite authors, so that pairs well.
ANNE: Oh, yeah. And for a book club... I mean, y'all have been really creative with this, but if I were making it up off the cuff, not an event planner, you go for a walk, you eat a good meal, you have a good conversation. You honor Laurie Colwin.
LIZZEY: Oh, that's lovely.
ANNE: All right, I'm going to stop there. We've covered a lot of ground. Thanks so much for bringing your classics questions and also your book club adventures to What Should I Read Next?.
LIZZEY: Thank you for letting me talk about it. It's been the delight of my life.
[01:07:56] ANNE: Oh my gosh. Well, the pleasure is all mine. But Lizzey, before you go, please tell me what you think you may read next. So we talked about Passing by Nella Larsen and the Harlem Renaissance adventures you could go on. We talked about Edith Wharton, and specifically The Age of Innocence, and how you could cover Washington Square, Grace Church, up to The Met. And then we talked about the works of Laurie Colwin and the associated potential food and dinner possibilities. So of those books, what do you think?
LIZZEY: They're all amazing. Truly. I feel like... So my book club trip, our summer trip, is this weekend, so I will be bringing them all to the group, and we will decide as a group what we explore next. But if I had to guess, I would pick Passing by Nella Larsen. It just fits the fall theme so well. I love the psychological thriller aspect you talked about, and I think it would be really perfect for our fall book. But I'll report back on what we choose, because I truly could see us doing all of them at some point in time.
[01:08:59] ANNE: Well, that sounds amazing, especially for fall in New York. I'll be curious to hear what they think, and I hope you all have a great time with whatever you end up reading and doing next.
LIZZEY: Thanks, Anne.
ANNE: Thanks, Lizzey.
Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Lizzey, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next. Find Lizzey on her Substack. We have that link, as well as the full list of titles we talked about at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
Make sure you're following in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, wherever you get your podcasts. Find us on Instagram @WhatShouldIReadNext. And make sure you're on our email list by signing up at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion by Beth Brower
• Mansfield Park by Jane Austen
• Tender Is the Night by F. Scott Fitzgerald
East of Eden by John Steinbeck
The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde
• The Legend of Sleepy Hollow by Washington Irving
A Room with a View by E.M. Forster
▵ The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky
• Crossing to Safety by Wallace Stegner
• Dolly All the Time by Annabel Monaghan
• Fates and Furies by Lauren Groff
• Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery
• Hotel Splendide by Ludwig Bemelmans
• Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry
• James Baldwin (try The Fire Next Time)
• Toni Morrison (try Beloved)
• Gabriel García Márquez (try Love in the Time of Cholera)
• 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel by Jane Smiley
• Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy
• Passing by Nella Larsen
• The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett
• The House of Mirth by Edith Wharton
• The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton
• Home Cooking by Laurie Colwin
• A Big Storm Knocked It Over by Laurie Colwin
: Guest favorite book
▵: A book they didn’t love
• A Room with a View (1986 Film)
• MMD Book Club Class: What Kind of Classics Reader Are You
• 6 tips to help you tackle a classic novel
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Classic novels ripe for discussion (and excursions to pair with them) appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
Today’s guest is a Kentucky neighbor who came to me with both a specific reading project and a dilemma I know is shared by many readers. Emily Holladay is a pastor in Frankfort, Kentucky, where she lives with her family. As a newish mom, Emily is still finding her outside-of-parenthood hobbies, but reading has been a constant throughout her life.
Emily’s a member of a book club at Carmichael’s Bookstore, which happens to be my local bookstore. When Emily completed her guest submission form and told us about her struggles with completing her Carmichael’s bingo card, I knew exactly what she was talking about and couldn’t wait to talk about this reading challenge with Emily.
Emily often finds herself browsing Libby for her next read. She often feels like every book that’s top of mind for her is also on everyone else’s mind, and suspects she would be happier if she had an assortment of backlist books on her radar that might be available on Libby right when she wants them.
I have ideas for Emily and I’d love to hear your suggestions too: please share the titles and tips you’d like to share with Emily by leaving a comment below.
Connect with Emily on Instagram.
Every week here on the podcast, we share an hour of enthusiastic book talk, and our podcast stays free for all to enjoy. A lot goes into crafting this hour of free bookish entertainment every week: we love what we do, and we value your support so much.
If you want to help us keep producing high-quality, human-made work like we do every week, we hope you can find one or even several ways to support us (and we know that many of you already are—thank you!) If you’d like to support us financially, that’s easy to do by joining our Patreon community, becoming a member of the Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club, visiting our shop, or buying Anne’s books. And if financial support isn’t an option for you right now or if you’re already a financial supporter, there are great free ways that really support us as well. Simple actions make a big difference, like subscribing to our email list, subscribing to or following our podcast on your favorite app or player, sharing a post, a story, or an episode on social media, or by telling a friend to listen in, which is our very favorite way to share the book love. Those things help so much.
No matter which of these actions you take, know that our team is grateful. We truly couldn’t do this without you. Thank you for listening, and thank you for supporting our show.
[00:00:00] EMILY HOLLADAY: That would be a good... what do we call it? Side... What do you call it when we have two books together?
ANNE BOGEL: A flight.
EMILY: Flight, yes. Why could I not think of that?
ANNE: A side quest? Is that what we're doing? We could call it that too.
Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading, and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:43] Readers, every week here on the podcast, we share an hour of enthusiastic book talk, and our podcast stays free for all to enjoy. We've been doing that for 10 years now, but a lot goes into crafting this hour of free bookish entertainment every week. We have our team of talented readers, writers, and editors who we pay competitively for their expertise. We select platforms that are reliable and allow thousands of you to enjoy our show every week, no matter where you are.
Each week's episode requires hours and hours of time from our team, from selecting guests, preparing for recording, packaging that conversation, making it sound real good, and then getting it out to all of you on your devices and in your inboxes. We love what we do. We are so grateful to be able to do it, and I think those requirements make clear why we value your support so much. Not only does it help the finances work, it's a huge morale booster to hear that you value what we do here every week.
[00:01:36] If you want to help us keep producing high-quality, human-made work like we do every week, there are ways to support us, and we hope you can find one or even several that are right for you.
If you'd like to support us financially, that's easy to do by joining our Patreon community, becoming a member of the Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club, visiting our shop, or buying my books. To everyone who has already supported us in one of these ways, or several, or who provides sustained support as a member of one of our communities, thank you so much from me and my team.
And if financial support isn't an option for you right now or not what you want to do, or even if you're already a financial supporter, there are great free ways that really support us as well. Simple actions make a big difference, like subscribing to our email list at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter, subscribing to or following our podcast on your favorite app or player, even sharing a post, a story, or an episode on social media, or by telling a friend to listen in, which is our very favorite way to share the book love. Those things help so much.
No matter which of these actions you take, know that our team is grateful. We truly couldn't do this without you. Thank you for listening, and thank you for supporting our show.
[00:02:45] Readers, today's guest is a Kentucky neighbor who came to me with both a specific reading project and a dilemma I know is shared by many readers. Emily Holladay is a pastor in Frankfort, Kentucky, where she lives with her family. As a newish mom, Emily is still finding her outside-of-parenthood hobbies, but reading has been a constant throughout her life.
Emily's a member of a book club at Carmichael's Bookstore, which you may recognize the name of because it happens to be my local bookstore. When Emily completed her guest submission form and told us there about her struggles with covering some specific spaces on her Carmichael's bingo card, well, I knew exactly what she was talking about.
And because our listeners have responded enthusiastically to episodes featuring readers' various reading challenges, we thought it might be fun to dig into the details of this particular bingo challenge. What compelled Emily to sign up? What has she read so far? Which categories are tripping her up? And what might she read to get the cover all that she is aiming for?
[00:03:43] Emily also has a near universally relatable reading dilemma that we'll dig into today. Like many readers, Emily often finds herself browsing Libby for her next read without a good sense of which of the available options, that is the ones that she can click and download right then, which of those options might fit her reading tastes best.
As Emily put it in her submission, she often feels like every book that's top of mind for her is also on everyone else's mind, since they tend to be the same new releases and buzzy books that everyone is seeing everywhere, or so it seems.
Emily suspects she would be happier if she had an assortment of backlist books on her radar, top of mind, that would make for satisfying reading for her, and that hopefully will be available on Libby right then when she wants to download when she's ready for her next book versus those long wait times she's encountering for the new releases. You know I have ideas for Emily for bingo and for Libby strategy. This is going to be fun. Let's get to it.
Emily, welcome to the show.
EMILY: Thanks, Anne. I'm so glad to be here.
[00:04:43] ANNE: Oh, the pleasure's mine. I was really excited to read your submission when it came through. So we are airing this episode the end of July. We've still got some summer left for summer reading and other summer enjoyment. And I had a personal connection to this challenge that was really fun. It sounds like we have a lot of overlap in our personal life. It's nice to talk to somebody from the great state of Kentucky.
EMILY: Yes, I'm so excited. It's so fun to listen to you and know that we have some history in common, and now to be able to talk to you is so cool.
ANNE: Well, thank you. I'm delighted to dive in today to your reading life and summer book bingo. And readers, the thing that caught my eye specifically was Emily's pursuit to get a cover all in her Carmichael's Bookstore bingo card, but I knew many systems throughout the country do book bingo and summer book bingo. And also, y'all love to hear about a challenge, and I love to talk about a challenge, no matter what kind of challenge it is. So there's lots here to enjoy today.
Emily, could we start by just giving the readers a glimpse of who you are? Please tell us a little about yourself.
[00:05:48] EMILY: As we alluded to, I'm originally from Louisville, Kentucky, but I now live in Frankfort. I'm the pastor of Immanuel Baptist Church in Frankfort. I have lived in Kentucky for a total of 27 years, but I've also lived in Birmingham, Alabama, Atlanta, Georgia, and a little sojourn to a town outside of DC called Bowie, Maryland.
I'm married to Scott, who's a middle school English teacher. We have a seven-year-old boy and a two-and-a-half-year-old girl, and we love them so much. But a lot of our time is obviously spent at the pool, carting them around to summer camps, and all these different kids' events.
One of the questions that always comes up is, you know, what do you do outside of that? And I'm still kind of learning what my outside of parenthood and also outside of pastorhood hobbies are. But reading has always remained a constant for me, so I am just very excited to talk about books today.
[00:06:54] ANNE: Oh, well, I imagine that reading as a constant is very relatable to so many of our listeners. But if you're new to reading as an adult, like reading for the thrill of it, the enjoyment of it, you are welcome too.
EMILY: One thing that I will add is I would love to share about the pilgrimage that I went on this past October. I went on a pilgrimage to Switzerland. And this kind of combines my book life with just my real life. Not that those are actually different things. But Common Ground Pilgrimages does these pilgrimages. And we went to Switzerland and talked about Frankenstein. The hosts of the podcast Pantsuit Politics were our guides for that experience.
Something about traveling to another continent by myself and having this experience has just really had a major impact on my life, and I think will kind of come up in some of the themes that we talk about today because I've started to slow down more and soak in just the beauty of the world around me.
[00:08:01] I mean, I know you can appreciate this. Kentucky is such a beautiful place, but being home, you can kind of forget how much you have just staring you in the face every day.
I've been joking that going across the ocean has taught me more about being rooted and growing where I am than anything else. Some of the things that have really stuck out to me recently have been people and stories of people who are learning to be where they are, and either make a difference there or just be okay there. And that's been really inspiring to me, and been just very impactful in my life right now.
ANNE: Oh, I'm glad to hear it. Okay, so you need some distance to really see and appreciate what's easy to take for granted otherwise. I don't like the phrase "take for granted". It doesn't feel quite right. But you need some distance to see clearly the things that are familiar to you, maybe.
EMILY: Right.
ANNE: Right. Okay. And that interest applies to your reading life as well?
EMILY: Mm-hmm.
[00:09:05] ANNE: Okay, I will keep that in mind. Emily, please tell me about your reading life.
EMILY: I have been a reader all my life. My mom would often tell us that we couldn't afford things, but books were the one thing that she would spare no expense on. I remember as a kid coming home from school when they would pass out the books from the Scholastic catalog, and I had a box of books, whereas other kids were coming home with one or two books. We would often spend, you know, hours browsing bookstore shelves after dinner on a Friday night. So it just has always been a part of my life.
When I came back to Louisville after seminary, I decided I wanted to join a book club because I wanted to meet some people outside of the, you know, family and friends that I had known all my life. And so I discovered that Carmichael's, the independent bookstore we've been talking about, that was just up the street from where I grew up.
[00:10:08] I discovered that they had a book club and they were about to read The Annotated Pride and Prejudice, which just made my nerdy heart sing because I love Pride and Prejudice. And these annotated versions are one side of the page is the actual book, and the other side is all these notes about the book. And so I said, "This is the perfect time to join," and started going to that book club.
And then long story short, because of my love for books and for Carmichael's in particular, my husband proposed to me at Carmichael's with the book club leader and my best friends among his accomplices. I mean, I was so surprised by that. I still can't turn the corner at Carmichael's without picturing him sitting there.
[00:11:00] So that's kind of overview of my life of reading, but I will read just about any book I can get my hands on. My favorite novels are generally contemporary romance and historical fiction. I love characters that you want to root for and storylines that pull at your heartstrings.
I really hate being confused by a book and feeling like I wasn't smart enough to get it. I feel like a very smart person, and so when I'm reading a book, and I just think they went way over my head or I don't get what everybody else got, that's really difficult for me.
But I prefer plot-driven books versus purely character-driven books. But I really want to have both that propelling plot and good character development to keep me invested in the story. My guilty pleasure is celebrity memoir, especially if it's read by the author on audio.
ANNE: Favorites?
[00:12:08] EMILY: I just recently read Chelsea Devantez's memoir, and that was really great. One of the first ones that really got me into celebrity memoirs was Jessica Simpson's, Kelly Bishop, hers was really fun, and Lauren Graham. I love Gilmore Girls, so those are fun. Matthew Perry, of course I read his. There's so many. I will blow through them.
Of course, I really gravitate to ones where they'll spill the beans on whatever happened on set. Oh, Barbra Streisand's memoir that I read earlier this year. Oh my God, I went down such a rabbit hole of watching all her movies and listening to her music. I did not know I adored Barbra Streisand until I read that memoir. She's so fun, and she's… what a woman! I mean, oh, wow. So yeah.
ANNE: Wait a second. Okay, this is pinging something in my brain from your submission, like the idea of you going down a rabbit hole, just like doing a really nerdy deep dive does not sound unfamiliar based on what I've read.
[00:13:12] EMILY: Yes. That is very common for me. I love to read a book that then makes me want to read about other things or go deeper on that topic. One example I think I gave on my submission was the book We Burn Daylight, that one of your guests, I think, recommended. Because I remember there was a... She made a joke about how it was billed as being historical fiction, and it was about the Branch Davidian and David Koresh saga in the 1990s. And she's like, "That could not be historical fiction. That's not cool."
But the way she described the book, I was like, "Oh, I need to read this." And so I read it, and then I just kept reading more about the Waco David Koresh saga. It was a weird thing to have that popping up on my Netflix and everything else over and over again every time there was a documentary that came out. But, you know, it was a part of my recent, I feel like, history.
You know, Toy Story 5 is coming out, but Toy Story 1 came out somewhere around then, and I feel like that was just yesterday. I didn't know much about it, but learning about that was fun for me.
ANNE: Okay. So you
EMILY: Feels weird to say fun.
[00:14:35] ANNE: You don't like to be impressed, you like to be moved, and you really like the details.
EMILY: Yes.
ANNE: Okay. So, Emily, I think you've been listening for a long time. What brings you to the show right now?
EMILY: Yes, I have been listening for a long time, probably since about the beginning or close to it. Since about the time that you interviewed Rider Strong.
ANNE: Oh, gosh. Well, thank you. That is a long time.
EMILY: So one of my friends from Louisville recommended the podcast to me, and then I saw that you had interviewed Rider Strong, and I was like, "Oh, my gosh. Boy Meets World," you know? So I thought that was so cool.
What brings me to the show today. I know I have filled out the submission form a couple times, but this time I thought, "I finally have something to talk about." Because normally there's that question, "What would you like to talk with Anne about?" And I'm like, "I don't know. Books?" And this time I said, "Oh, I've got this bingo challenge that our local bookstore does, and I would love to talk about how to fill some of the categories that I don't immediately have books that come to mind for those categories."
[00:15:44] So I've done this bingo card. I think Carmichael's has done it for three years, and I've done it all three. Maybe it's been more than that. I can't remember. But last year I did not cover all. I came within one or two books of covering all, and I was so upset because you get one entry for a gift card for one bingo, and you get two if you cover all. But you don't get extras for bingo-ing multiple times if you don't cover all. So I really wanted to do that.
And some of the categories are really fun, but they're meant to stretch you outside of your comfort zone and things like that. And so I just didn't immediately have picks for that. So that's what I was hoping we could talk about.
ANNE: Okay. Well, I'm looking at the Carmichael's bingo card, and readers, you can too. We will link it in our show notes. But can I ask you some of the books you have chosen already?
EMILY: Yes.
[00:16:42] ANNE: What were the first ones you picked? What did you look at and be like, "Oh, I know a book in a genre I don't usually read," or, "I know a book with a number in the title that I want to do this summer"? I'm wondering what book you picked just for the cover if you've done that yet, or the long book, 400-plus pages.
EMILY: The book just for the cover was The Wedding People. I have had that book on my mind for a long time because that cover, it's just kind of the ocean with a wine glass or something coming out of it. And at first I said, "That book looks like it's just too marketed to everybody. It's meant to be too cool," or something like that. But then I heard good reviews about it, and so I kept coming back to it. So I picked out The Wedding People, and I really enjoyed that book. My book with 400-plus pages was My Name Is Barbra, that we talked about, Barbra Streisand. That I did listen to on audio, but I don't feel like that's a cheat because it was still a big time commitment.
ANNE: Not a cheat.
[00:17:48] EMILY: And then the book with the number in the title is probably either 107 Days by Kamala Harris or Dog Man: Fetch-22, which I've been reading all the Dog Man books with my son. I got so frustrated with him because there were no books with numbers in the title for the longest time, and I'm like, "Come on, these are kids books. You've gotta... We've read, you know, 15 books so far. None of them have numbers in the title." And we finally got to Fetch-22, and I was like, "Yes, I can use that."
ANNE: Or is a book recommended by someone under age 12.
EMILY: Yeah. I wondered if that counted since I don't know if he technically recommended it to me. But I think it does, right? Because we're reading it together.
ANNE: I mean, you are the boss of your own book bingo. But if it were up to me to decide, absolutely. A book that takes place somewhere you want to travel?
[00:18:49] EMILY: I had two books that I'm trying to choose between. One was Agent Josephine, which is about Josephine Baker, and it takes place mostly in Paris. I have been to Paris, but I loved Paris, and I want to go back. I was on a tour with somebody who took me to this crepe stand and said, "If you want to be a real Parisian, you get lemon sugar crepe." And that thing was so good and not overdone like the crepes we make here. I dream about it. I want to go back.
She also told me about Josephine Baker, and she said, "I can't believe how many of you Americans don't know about her." So I read Agent Josephine. I also read her memoir, which I put under the category of a book by a Black author. But she has a memoir called Fearless and Free.
[00:19:51] And this woman was a Black American who moved to Paris to be a dancer and singer and just live in a place where she could be more appreciated because America was not open to people of color. She ended up becoming a spy during World War II, and just having this amazing life that's so cool to hear about and read about. Then also, you know, to just hear more about Paris, and it made me want to visit more places in France. Again, this whole book bingo is about broadening your horizons. And it broadened my horizons even about a place I'd already been, so it was pretty cool.
ANNE: That does sound really cool. I want to read that. Emily, some of these categories have really stymied you.
EMILY: Yes.
ANNE: How are you deciding what to read for each category? Like, what kind of mindset are you bringing to the challenge? So you've talked about broadening horizons. Are you finding yourself, for example, using this as an opportunity to read books that have been on your radar for a long time that you just haven't gotten to yet? Is it discovery? Is it other things? Is it all of the above?
[00:21:07] EMILY: I think it's all of the above. One of the categories is a book by a Native author, and I chose to read There There by Tommy Orange, which has been on my shelf for a long time. It actually was a Carmichael's Book Club pick a long time ago, and I just didn't make it to that book club. And so, you know, I said, "Okay, rather than trying to find something new, let's read this book that you have been intending to read for a while."
Others have been, you know, I've been in book clubs and things like that, and so it's just made a lot of sense to just go ahead and use one of the books that I'm already reading for the book club. A book with two or more authors. I chose Shakespeare: The Man Who Pays the Rent because I heard somebody talk about it on here. I think they said the only way to read this book is on audio, and it just happened to be that it was available on Libby, and I said, "Okay, got to read that," so it counted. So it's a little bit of everything.
[00:22:10] ANNE: Okay. I'm glad to hear that. What are the categories that you are still in need of titles for? Maybe that's the wrong way to put it, but what categories are you feeling stymied by?
EMILY: One of the categories is a book written by an author from the state of your birth. So they changed this category. Previous years it's been a book written by a Kentucky author, and then they made it more inclusive. Well, I was born in Kentucky, so I'm still needing a Kentucky author.
I keep going with Barbara Kingsolver and Emily Bingham. I want to read Jayber Crow so bad, but I don't think I'm going to commit to that this year, so then I'm lost. I don't know where to go and what to pick for a book from a Kentucky author. And I feel like I get stuck because there are so many authors I'm sure from Kentucky, but I always just think of Wendell Berry, Silas House, Barbara Kingsolver. That's kind of where my mind goes, and I would love to be introduced to some other great authors from the state of Kentucky.
[00:23:18] ANNE: Oh, I would love to claim her, but I'm pretty sure Barbara Kingsolver was born in Virginia.
EMILY: Yeah, but we-
ANNE: Can we pretend that's not true, though? It's too Kentucky.
EMILY: I know she was born in Virginia, but they claim her... On her bio they say she's from Kentucky.
ANNE: Oh, do they?
EMILY: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Well, I'm going to put my trust in Barbara Kingsolver official here.
EMILY: I think it's kind of where does she claim. So I claim her even though, yeah, technically not born here, but it was the state of my birth. You know, it's kinda like where is Abraham Lincoln actually from? Everybody in the Midwest claims him, but where is he really from?
ANNE: I'm curious about the "you know you want to read Jayber Crow, but not yet" thing. Do you find it intimidating? Is it not the vibe you're going for?
[00:24:07] EMILY: It's just a slower read than what I feel like I want to commit to right now. Because it's not necessarily too long, but every time that I pick it up, I want to sit with it, and I don't have a lot of sitting still time right now. Although I know I'm saying that, and all this conversation about being rooted and finding the beauty of the place where you're in is such a Jayber Crow thing, so I know I'm contradicting myself there. So maybe you can convince me that Jayber Crow is the one for that category.
ANNE: I mean, I don't know. I don't want to send you to it begrudgingly, but I was curious. Are you feeling the same way about Silas House?
EMILY: I just don't know where to start with Silas House, honestly. I have a bunch of friends who talk about how wonderful he is, and I've come to him a little bit late, and so I'm not sure where's the best place to start.
[00:25:08] ANNE: I mean, I think the one about the pastor who has the meltdown. Or is that absolutely not for you?
EMILY: Yeah. No. Pastors... I'm known to melt down from time to time.
ANNE: Okay. Well, that would be Southernmost, and we will come back to that.
EMILY: Okay. Another category is a banned book. I am always so confused about what counts as a banned book, so it's hard for me to kind of narrow that down. Another one being a book of poetry, because poetry is not always my go-to, but I do enjoy when I've read it. One of my favorite books of poetry that I've read recently is Amanda Gorman's book that came out after she read the poem at President Biden's inauguration. Her poetry was so good and so relatable, and I loved it. And then I still don't ever turn to poetry, even though I know I've had good experiences with it.
[00:26:10] A retelling of a story is just one I don't have on my to-be-read list, or something that just comes out to me, a retelling of a story. And a book with a non-human narrator. I guess you said earlier that, you know, I'm the boss of my own list, but I'm like, Cat Kid Comic Club does not count as a book with a non-human narrator.
ANNE: You don't feel like that appropriately runs your horizons in the way you're hoping this book bingo would do?
EMILY: Exactly.
ANNE: Okay. All right. This sounds fun. Okay, let me see if I jotted this down fast enough. You are looking to find titles for the categories that are a book from, for you, Kentucky, the state of your birth, poetry, a banned book, with what counts being a big question, a retelling; and a non-human narrator.
EMILY: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Ooh. Okay. Can we talk about your options?
EMILY: Yes.
[00:27:11] ANNE: There's so much good stuff here. And really I'm imagining, maybe this is my cluttered brain, but I'm imagining that your answers for how you want to fill in these boxes are going to emerge in composite. So we're probably going to talk about Kentucky books that have a lot of different sorts of tones, and you're not going to hit that same tone for all five categories. You're probably going to want some variety, is what I'm hearing from the way you describe your reading life. So we're going to give you some options.
But Emily, you also mentioned something else in your submission about this recurring moment of readerly pain you have in your reading life where you open up Libby, and you're just like, "Aah, choices." Would you tell me about that in your own words? Because I'm definitely going to keep that in mind as we're talking about these various options for the book bingo categories.
[00:27:57] EMILY: Yes. I like to always have an audiobook going, and I mostly use Libby for that. It tends to be that I end up having a lot of holds because I'm looking at the Summer Reading Guide where books are just now coming out or I hear about books that are pretty popular and I put that on my holds list. And then I'll finish a book, and I have nothing actually available.
I search through Libby and try to find something that's on my bookshelf or TBR, and they're all still, you know, a two-week wait or a five-week wait or God forbid, a year-long wait. I go to the "Available Now" section on Libby, and I have to scroll through... And no offense to anybody, but I have to scroll through dozens of Freida McFadden and ACOTAR books. And those just... they just don't stand out to me. I want to read something that somebody in my life has said, "I think you'd enjoy that." So I'm not just listening for the sake of listening, but listening because there's something that connects me to that book or makes me want to listen to that book.
[00:29:12] It's like when you scroll Netflix at night trying to find something to watch. I'm scrolling Libby, just endlessly trying to find an available audiobook, and it's so frustrating how many flicks of the thumb I have to make in order to find one that fits.
ANNE: Do you keep some sort of running priority list of audiobooks that you may want to listen to on Libby next?
EMILY: I have a nightstand beside my bed that has probably 10 books that are my books I want to read next. And they're all physical copies, but I don't really care how I read them. So if I read them with my ears instead of my eyes, I'm good with that. So that's kind of the first thing I do is I look to see if any of those books are available on audio. And if they aren't, I will just try to think of what are the most recent books that I heard about. Either my book club, we take a time at the end to say, "Hey, what's everybody reading?" And we'll write down what we're reading, things like that.
[00:30:23] Sometimes I'll go through my Libby searches to see if anything that I have recently searched for or anything, any holds I recently had to drop have become available. And if none of that works, then I'm going to the "what's available right now" list.
ANNE: So those are great ideas, but it sounds like it's not working as consistently as you would like if you keep finding yourself in this situation.
EMILY: Yeah, because the books that are constantly on the top of my mind are often books that are on the top of everybody's minds. I think 10 years ago, I was really good at remembering both the backlist and the frontlist books, and now I do need to rethink how I'm keeping that list or keeping those things in my head because I have two kids and a full-time job, and life and memories just don't work the way that they used to.
ANNE: There's not a lot of RAM available?
EMILY: Yeah.
[00:31:30] ANNE: I hear that. Well, we are going to talk about a lot of titles today for your various book bingo categories that many of these could fulfill multiple categories, and because the prompt that your brain gets working on are things like a retelling, your mental search isn't limited to... or our conversations today won't be limited to what's on the new release table at the bookstore.
So I hope that you can use... and like listeners, you can always use our show notes as a reference. We talk about titles from new and old. Some of our episodes are ones in which readers are specifically asking for backlist gems. I know that our old Summer Reading Guides and fall and spring book previews are very popular for readers who are like, "I want something available at the library now." But I hope your notes will be a nice resource. And you know, it could be fun to go through your old book club notes and just make a list of, "Oh, I remember that sounding really interesting. Maybe that's available right now since it didn't come out in April."
EMILY: Yeah, that's a good idea.
[00:32:27] ANNE: Emily, we have talked so much about your reading life, and I feel like I have a good image of what you've enjoyed and what you're willing to try, but we haven't talked about the books that you love yet. You know how this works. You brought three books you love, one you don't, and what you've been reading lately. Let's round out the picture before we move forward. Does that work for you?
EMILY: Yes, absolutely.
ANNE: Okay. How'd you choose these?
EMILY: I took very seriously the three books you love because I'm very bad at picking favorites. So these three books are books that are some of my favorite reading experiences, and are indicative of the kind of books that I'm loving right now and what works for me in a story, in a reading experience. These are not in any particular order, but just three books that I really love. And here it goes.
[00:33:23] The first book that I chose was The Guncle by Steven Rowley. I first heard about this book actually on an episode of What Should I Read Next? back when it came out in 2021. It was one of the best books of summer episodes. One of the team members said they loved The Guncle, and she described the book as sweet, funny, and also a tearjerker, and that really intrigued me, along with the title. So I ordered it right away. And it was one of the best reading experiences that I can remember.
The book is about a washed-up actor named Patrick. He lives in Palm Springs, and his niece and nephew call him Gay Uncle Patrick or GUP for short. His niece and nephew, their mom, so his sister-in-law, dies of cancer, and his brother is like, "Hey, dude, I need you to take care of these kids for the summer so I can kind of figure my life out."
[00:34:22] He agrees to do it, but he's really in over his head, and the life he leads is not really a kid-friendly life. So we just walk with him throughout the book and learn that he is doing his best to be there for the kids, but dealing with these layers of his own grief. He creates these Guncle rules for the kids, which is one of my favorite things. Things like, "Guncle rule number one: brunch is splendid," or, "Guncle rule number five: we wear what we want." They seem really silly, but they turn out to be pretty profound. The progression of the rules goes along with his progression as a caregiver for the kids. I just love that development of relationship, the journey they walk together. It's so sweet.
Rowley is such a clever writer, and everyone just has such a unique voice. When I say that this was such a great experience reading, it's because I normally would binge a book like this. But when I read The Guncle, I ended up waking up every morning early and reading a chapter to start my day because I felt I just wanted to savor it. I did not want to leave... From Patrick and Maisie and Grant, I didn't want to leave their presence too quickly.
[00:35:42] I can't even tell you how many people that I gave this book to as a birthday present or Christmas present, or just shoved in their hands and told them they had to read it after I read it. It was so fun. It was tender. It was emotional. I laughed out loud. I cried. I just loved it.
And then I reread it and I read The Guncle Abroad through audiobook. The author narrates those books, and his voice just brings the characters off the page. It's pretty amazing. I loved that book.
I can't remember if it comes up in just one or in both of the books, but Patrick mentions that he was accepted into the residency program at Actors Theatre of Louisville, and unfortunately he turned it down, but I thought how fun it was that-
ANNE: I do not remember this.
EMILY: Yes. I just got so excited. I was like, "That's my town." Actors Theatre, that residency program is actually a pretty big deal. So it's a fun shout-out, but I wish that maybe he would go back and write a book about that, because it would be fun to see a book in Louisville.
[00:36:53] ANNE: For sure. Thank you. That's The Guncle. What's the second book you love?
EMILY: Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell. Rainbow Rowell is one of my favorite authors of all time. I would seriously just read a Post-it Note if she wrote on it. But I first found out about her the year I graduated from seminary, because one of my best friends was a master of library sciences. She was getting ready to start as a high school librarian, and she said, "I think you will love this author." I am almost a completist, but she's written some comic books that I haven't kept up with. And I haven't read her newest books. I'm not a completist yet.
But Fangirl, it's written from the perspective of Cath Avery, who's entering her first year of college. She's a huge fan of what's called the Simon Snow series, which I think at the time Rowell was relating to the Harry Potter series. So it's about a young magician who goes to school and faces a bunch of challenges against dark magic.
[00:37:54] Cath and her twin sister have spent a lot of time in high school writing Simon Snow fanfic, and they've become very popular on fanfic blog sites, which I didn't even know existed until I read this book. So when they go to college, Ren, her twin sister, wants to explore new passions, wants to learn more about herself, and Cath is this awkward introvert who's just so used to just sticking to her sister, and she's left to figure out how to finish their fanfic story on her own and try to grow into her own person without the comfort of being constantly with her twin.
It's such a sweet coming-of-age story. It has everything from the magical realism of the Simon Snow universe interspersed between chapters, where we get to see bits and pieces of both the fictional Simon Snow novels and Cath's fanfic. And it has family drama, young adult angst. Rowell really gives you someone to root for.
[00:38:59] I really buried the lede here, but there's a love scene involving a side-by-side reading of The Outsiders, which is probably the book more than any other that drew me into being a reader, like a real reader. I swoon every time I read that scene, and I've read this book multiple times. It's just so charming. It also spawned a series of Simon Snow books that Rainbow Rowell wrote based on the characters she imagined. And so for anybody who's looking for a book that then turns them on to more books, this is the one.
ANNE: Love a book like that. And also one that you love so much you've read multiple times.
EMILY: Yeah.
ANNE: Emily, what's the third book you love?
EMILY: The Almost Sisters by Joshilyn Jackson. To be honest and possibly name-droppy, not meaning to be that way, but Joshilyn Jackson is a friend of mine. We met at church when I was in seminary, post her Gods in Alabama writing. I didn't realize who she was at first, but when she told me she was an author and I asked her what she wrote, she said, "I like to think of my writing as Southern Christian fiction with cuss words, but bookstores don't always classify me that way."
[00:40:19] Her books are kind of everything: Southern fiction, domestic fiction, mystery. Now she writes thrillers. This book, The Almost Sisters, it's so much fun. It's told from the perspective of Leah Birch-Briggs, who is a comic book writer who's become most notable for her graphic novel, Violence in Violet, which has this really amazing female protagonist.
She attends a convention to promote her book, finds herself in the throes of a romantic encounter with a man dressed as Batman, and then following the convention, has to kind of drop everything and go to this small town in Alabama where her grandmother lives with her best friend. And she's gone down there to sort out family drama involving her stepsister's marriage, but stays when she discovers that her grandmother has been hiding her dementia along with some other family secrets.
[00:41:25] Batman does come to play a role again, as in the midst of all of this, Leah discovers that one night at the convention was more than one night. She's pregnant, and she has to find a way to share this news with her family in that conservative environment in Alabama. I'll tell you, I don't ever really think my Storygraph reviews are very good or very helpful, but what I said about The Almost Sisters kind of sums it up for me. "It's a must-read book for anyone feeling the tension of what the South could be and what it still is, or really anyone feeling that tension in culture in general. She makes you feel like you're reading the story of your own hometown, neighborhood, or church. The book is so entertaining that you'll find yourself laughing hysterically on one page and challenged to create a more loving society on the next."
[00:42:18] I love this book. I think I would love it even if I didn't know the author. And I feel like I'm not doing complete justice to describing the story because there's so many parts, but that's what she does so well, is just pulling together the chaos and ever-evolving pieces of our lives and weaving them together into this unputdownably relatable book. And I love it.
ANNE: Ooh, I love that description. Emily, tell me about a book that was not right for you, and I'd love to hear why.
EMILY: Okay, the book that was not right for me was My Year of Rest and Relaxation by Ottessa Moshfegh. This is a book about a young woman who recently graduated from Columbia University in New York. She lives in this fancy apartment paid for by her inheritance from her family, and she decides to do what she calls a year of narcotic hibernation.
[00:43:18] So there's this crazy psychiatrist in town who prescribes her meds for this, quote-unquote, experiment. And so it's this story of a young woman spending a year under the influence of drugs and trying to hide from the world and all that's going on. It's also set beginning in the year 2000, so there's a bit of a 9/11 through line in the story. And I felt like that ended up being, for me, more gratuitous rather than helpful to the story.
I found the narrator really unlikable and unrelatable, and that, for me, is not a good sell. I want to relate. I want to root for somebody. I'll mention my Storygraph review one more time because I laughed at it. I said, "I had a lot of trouble suspending my disbelief long enough to believe that someone on so many drugs could have the reflections she has as a narrator." I could be wrong about that.
[00:44:15] I just read John and Paul, the book about the Beatles, and they wrote a lot of great songs while they were on LSD, but they were taking drugs to heighten their awareness, and she was taking drugs to escape from it. I also read this book as a part of a book club that I went to, which had previously been led by a friend of mine. It was in a bit of transition, and the focus was on getting more people there. But when I was describing why I didn't really jive with the book, there was a new guy there who decided to mansplain to me why my opinion was wrong and to tell me how I actually enjoyed the book. That experience, along with really not enjoying the book, made it an even worse reading experience for me and left a really bad taste in my mouth.
ANNE: Didn't win you over.
EMILY: No.
ANNE: That one is also quite a bit darker than the books you've enjoyed.
EMILY: Yes.
[00:45:15] ANNE: Coincidence, or just part of the package?
EMILY: I think I don't prefer dark books. If they're done in a way that makes you want to still root for the person, I guess, or feel there's some sort of redemption, then I can go with it. But I didn't feel that from this book.
ANNE: Okay. I know you want to broaden your horizons, and also I was having a hard time syncing that up with characters you want to root for and books that pull at your heartstrings.
EMILY: Yeah, that's true.
ANNE: Okay. But all in all, not a great reading experience.
EMILY: Yeah.
ANNE: Okay. Emily, what have you been reading lately?
EMILY: I recently finished Ordinary Time by Annie B. Jones. It was part of the Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club. I didn't actually make it in time for the book club, but I just loved the way that... It just felt like you were having a conversation with a friend.
[00:46:10] Her emphasis on, again, like rooting yourself where you are and really coming to love the place that you're in, even if it's the home that you were formed in. I loved that reading experience, and I thought it was so much fun. And I didn't know anything about her before going into it.
I also recently read The Shippers by Katherine Center. I love Katherine Center. I thought that was the perfect book for vacation. Felt like it was the perfect beach read, and I was very committed to having a good beach read, because my book club books were not beach reads. So...
ANNE: Okay. A vacation book for your vac...
EMILY: Yes.
ANNE: I mean, a book that's set... Oh, it's a destination wedding, is it?
EMILY: Yes, yes. It's set on a cruise ship. It's her characteristic quirkiness, fun. You're going to laugh, you're going to cry, but you know you're going to be taken care of in the end. I love how she's able to maintain all that, and you know she loves and respects her characters and you as a reader. I know that if I'm ever in a reading rut, picking up Katherine Center will help give me that palate cleanser that I need. So she did not disappoint with this new book.
[00:47:28] ANNE: Oh, I'm delighted to hear it. Okay. I think we know what you're looking for. I mean, we could talk about your options for the rest of the day. But let's start with Kentucky. Does that work for you?
EMILY: Yes.
ANNE: You are so correct that Silas House, Wendell Berry, Barbara Kingsolver are excellent picks, but you have more, and in different broader genres as well. Like, you could look back in time and go for like a Jesse Stuart or a bell hooks, or you could do more contemporary. You could do a Meg Shaffer cozy fantasy, or Kim Michele Richardson historical fiction, or Leesa Cross-Smith contemporary. Or you know who I really like for you perhaps is Kayla Rae Whitaker. Have you read anything by her?
EMILY: No, I haven't.
ANNE: Okay. Am I remembering correctly that a sophomore novel is also a category that you were curious about how you're going to fill?
EMILY: Yes.
[00:48:30] ANNE: Well, her sophomore novel, Returns and Exchanges, just came out in May 2026. It's in this year's Summer Reading Guide. It's historical fiction that has an epilogue set in more contemporary times, but it's mostly set in the 1980s, and it's mostly set in Lexington, Kentucky.
I live in Louisville. I've not spent a ton of time in Lexington, but it's close enough, and Kentucky gets so little love at all, or appearances in fiction, that to read a book that was set granularly, like with locations and street names and historical landmarks in Lexington was... It's not something I get to do a lot.
She is a writer of, or at least her first two books have been queer fiction. Returns and Exchanges is a fascinating multi-generational epic about this married couple who married at the age of 16. They fled intense rural poverty and an abusive household, and came to the big city of Lexington, Kentucky, and are this unexpected success story as the founders of this Walmart-like Lexington-only discount chain store that expands and grows over the years.
[00:49:40] It feels a little Gatsby-esque in that they have, by so many standards, made it, but the husband especially still chafes against the fact that they have new money and have no standing or credibility in the eyes of Lexington blue bloods. And that's the backdrop to the wife developing what she doesn't even recognize as a crush on her female assistant manager, because that's not a category she can think in. But over time, that relationship grows, and it just creates upheaval in the family, the business, the community.
I mean, this is definitely a story of being rooted, but also how stretching against those constraints that at one time felt pleasing and now feel suffocating is a constant theme of the book as it unfolds over decades.
ANNE: Her first book, The Animators, is about two female animators who meet in college and make big projects. They have a tumultuous working relationship, it's complicated, but they make amazing indie adult animated films.
EMILY: Wow.
[00:50:45] ANNE: But there's this passage where they go to Louisville, and the way they describe Louisville, Kentucky, as this weird little quirky, lovable, adorable place that isn't quite any one thing, because it's kind of in the middle of everything, and it's not too big and not too small, and it's not the North and it's not South, but it's not Midwest. The way she describes Louisville is a way that could only be done as a Kentuckian, but I think, like, "Aw, somebody likes us. Somebody makes us sound good." And that aspect is, I'm going to boldly say, delightful. No equivocating, delightful. But she could be really fun for you. But you do have lots of options.
Based on what you've enjoyed, I do really wonder about The Lost Story by Meg Shaffer, bell hooks would get you a banned book for sure. I love Crystal Wilkinson. She has a poetry/prose collection called Perfect Black that could be a really interesting pick for one of several categories for you. It came out, ooh, I'm going to say five-ish years ago. I really also did love her interesting food and writing and history and ancestry collection, Praise Song for the Kitchen Ghosts.
[00:51:55] But Perfect Black is... She covers so much ground, like joy and heartbreak, love and trauma, lots about heritage and family. There's this wonderful piece about her love for Prince songs, and there's so much food throughout the book. So it's not solely a poetry collection, but I don't think the people at Carmichael's would raise their eyebrows if you wrote that in to your little poetry slot.
For Kentucky, and also poetry, I do wonder if those books that you're not sure where to start or you don't want to start now for like Wendell Berry and Silas House, I wonder if you could do poetry for one of those. Wendell Berry has several new... not new collections, old collections that are available on e-book. I don't know if they're read on audio or if you'd want to do that format. But he has tons of collections, but I personally really like his New Collected Poems and the pretty little hardcover, A Small Porch, that's also available on Libby on e-book. That could be a good place to start.
[00:52:59] And Silas House has a new poetry collection. Well, you know what? I guess at this point it came out last summer, but he has a new collection called All These Ghosts. I wonder if the poetry could be a good alternative to a novel for either of those authors right now.
EMILY: I think that would be great. That's one thing with Wendell Berry that I often find that there's just so much that it's nice to hear just a couple options to start with because he's such a prolific writer and such an amazing writer and representative of Kentucky, but the options can be overwhelming sometimes.
ANNE: You just said fewer options were good, and now I'm going to give you one more.
EMILY: That's okay.
ANNE: His newest novel in what is known as the Port William series — it has something like a dozen books right now — came out last fall, and it's really short, small format. It's less than 200 pages, and also the pages themselves are small.
[00:54:00] But what I like about this one for you... Well, what I don't like about this one for you is you won't know any of the characters, but I think that's okay. But in this book, he's very explicitly repeating a lot of his philosophy about agriculture and community and politics that he's repeated throughout his entire career and in much of his nonfiction work. And he's telling you a formative story in... it's the Catlett family, who live in this... it might be Henry County, but his Port William community is based on a real town near Carrollton, Kentucky.
But it almost feels like an origin story, like it's a myth in this family that actually happened, but is so formative in how they think about themselves. And I wonder if it's a nice little easily digestible package that's representative of his novels and his nonfiction.
EMILY: I think that sounds great.
ANNE: Well, that is called Marse Catlett, and that's the protagonist's name, the Force of a Story. Can we consider the Kentucky options done?
[00:55:06] EMILY: Yes, I think I could make a Kentucky bingo card in itself now.
ANNE: I think maybe you could. Now, that wasn't a lot of poetry, but it was some poetry. What do you think?
EMILY: Yes, I think I've got a place to go with poetry now.
ANNE: Okay. Banned books. I mean, some of those will get you the... You know what? Let's skip banned books for now, because I think we're going to touch on some. But Carmichael's has had great displays through the years. If you're not sure what... Okay, look, I'm a first-born daughter, good girl, rule follower by nature, but they've had wonderful displays through the years. And you could browse their Instagram and see what they put on their display. But you could go old. You could go new. You have so many options. Actually, you might have too many options. Maybe I should ask, is there anything you're inclined to read as a potential banned book?
EMILY: I would love to read a banned book that's newer. I know a lot of the older banned books. I've read, you know, Toni Morrison, and Octavia Butler, and things like that. But I'm interested in what books are coming out now that have been very quickly banned, or that people have just wrestled with that are newer.
[00:56:20] I feel like it's interesting to me to read books that to you and me would just seem like, "Oh, that's a story about such and such," and then somebody else really did not jive with that book and wanted it off the shelves. Not the books that you look at and you're like, "Oh, yeah, that's going to offend somebody."
ANNE: Okay. Something readers can always do is go to the American Library Association website that keeps records of top banned books for every year. So I doubt they have 2026 yet, but they'll have 2025 and prior, and so it would be really easy to see at a glance. Can I recommend one of my favorite banned books from recent years?
EMILY: Sure.
ANNE: Okay, this is now aging a little bit. It might be as many as five years old, but it's not older than that. That is Everything Sad Is Untrue by Daniel Nayeri. And it was kicking around in my brain because you were talking about Libby, and I remember the experience of hearing amazing things about this book and being so gratified that it was available right away on Libby. That just really stuck with me. I should ask first, is this one you've read?
EMILY: No, I haven't.
[00:57:25] ANNE: Okay. I don't believe this is an adult novel, but I've heard many adults with wildly disparate tastes gush about it. And they specifically recommended the audiobook. And I just looked. There's only one hold on it right now on our library network. Actually, you know what? Maybe you have it at Frankfort Library, but on the Louisville Free Public Library, Libby, there's just one hold on it right now.
But it's this beautiful, heartbreaking, hilarious book that really pulls on your heartstrings. You want to root for this kid so hard. And that kid, our narrator, is a 12-year-old Iranian kid who lives in Oklahoma and is known as Daniel because his Iranian name, Khosrou, that's not going to fly in Oklahoma Middle School. And he is a storyteller. He has this great quote that's something like, Every story is the sound of a storyteller begging to stay alive, so you can hear what they're going to tell you that'll be worth listening to. Like, that's the only way they're going to make it.
[00:58:25] But he tells story after story drawn from his family, from his heritage, from ancient Persian folklore, and sometimes from the by turns heartbreaking, horrendous, hilarious, ordinary moments of Oklahoma Middle School. How does that sound?
EMILY: I got goosebumps when you said, "Every story is the story of a storyteller begging to stay alive." Literally, the hair on my arm stood up, so that sounds beautiful.
ANNE: Amazing. I'm glad to hear it. Okay, we have lots of retelling possibilities and also lots of non-human narrator possibilities, and it just depends on what you're into. Have you read any Kevin Kwan?
EMILY: I have not. I've watched the movie, of course, but I haven't read Crazy Rich Asians or any of his other books.
[00:59:17] ANNE: Well, I feel like just here on the podcast we were recently talking about Lies and Weddings, which is a retelling of Doctor Thorne. You could read This Motherless Land by Nikki May, which is a Jane Austen retelling. That's Mansfield Park. And we've had her as a guest on the podcast, so it's possible that sounds familiar.
You could read Xochitl Gonzalez's new one, Last Night in Brooklyn. It's a gender-swapped Gatsby contemporary retelling. Home Fire by Kamila Shamsie is an amazing, punchy... Ooh, maybe not characters to root for, actually. It's a retelling of Antigone. It's pretty bleak, but wow, is it striking.
Ann Napolitano's Hello Beautiful. It's not a retelling exactly, but she calls it an homage to Little Women. Where the Rhythm Takes You by Sarah Dass is a YA Caribbean retelling of, again, Jane... not again, of Jane Austen again, but of Persuasion this time.
[01:00:08] Fault Lines by Emily Itami is dark, but has some hope to it. It's got Madame Bovary vibes. Of course, there's James by Percival Everett, which is Huckleberry Finn. Demon Copperhead, of course, by Barbara Kingsolver. That could be your 400-plus page book, but you already checked that box. How are any of these sounding? I mean, I didn't tell you very much, but is anything pinging your brain?
EMILY: No, that sounds great. This Motherless Land, I just finished Mansfield Park as a part of that Jane Austen class I'm reading, so that would be a good... what do we call it? Side... What do you call it when we have two books together?
ANNE: A flight.
EMILY: Flight, yes. Why could I not think of that?
ANNE: A side quest? Is that what we're doing? We could call it that, too.
[01:00:50] EMILY: So that would be fun. A couple of those I had already read. Of course, Demon Copperhead was one that I've read before. But yeah, This Motherless Land stood out to me. And I think Lies and Weddings. I think I remember you talking about that on a recent episode, and that was one that I flagged in my head as well. And Last Night in Brooklyn, I think could have been a book you pick for the cover, because I remember that one standing out.
ANNE: Yeah.
EMILY: I mean, I don't think it has a lot of graphics or anything. It's bold.
ANNE: It is. It's like a bright yellow.
EMILY: Yes.
ANNE: And I think both of those books, Lies and Weddings and Last Night in Brooklyn, seem like good fictional picks for fans of celebrity memoir.
EMILY: Okay.
ANNE: Now, I remember for your non-human narrator you didn't want to use Remarkably Bright Creatures because you already read it. But readers, if you find yourself in need of a non-human narrator for book bingo, that is, I imagine, a very popular pick right now.
[01:01:52] Let's see. I mean, there's so many books that have been around forever, like Redwall, The Art of Racing in the Rain, Watership Down, The Book Thief, The Murderbot series, The Call of the Wild, Grendel. The Screwtape Letters. You could go old if you wanted to or you could go more contemporary.
Lessons in Chemistry is a book that feels like it fits in with your favorites. I don't know if you've read it, by Bonnie Garmus.
EMILY: Yes, it's one of my favorite books as well.
ANNE: Okay. Well, good. I'm glad to hear it. Well, that's not going to work, but readers, if you're like, "What are you talking about with a non-human narrator?" much of it is narrated by a dog named, I think, Ninety-Nine. Does that sound right, Emily?
EMILY: It is a number. That's almost one of the book bingo categories.
ANNE: Okay. Well, I wasn't sure if you would like this based on what I knew about your favorites, but hearing what you have read and appreciated and what you're looking for, it's possible this could pull on your heartstrings a little bit. But there's this book that came out in 2023 called Open Throat that was actually recommended to me by What Should I Read Next? alum, Michelle Wilson, so thanks for that, Michelle.
[01:03:06] But this is a slim little book, but it really packs a serious punch. And it's less than 200 pages, and I think it's also small format, but I read it on Kindle.
This story is told by a mountain lion who lives in the wilds near L.A, which to give you a sense of what it's like to read this in the mountain lion's voice, Los Angeles appears as E-L-L-A-Y in the book because they're just repeating what they've heard. And this mountain lion watches hikers from the shadows and keeps close tabs on one human family in particular in this nearby encampment of unhoused people. And the mountain lion is just telling it to you as they see it, how the humans are acting and how the mountain lion is trying to make sense of it. And this is definitely strange, but it's got this sly feel to the tone, and really... it's really different. How does that sound to you?
[01:04:03] EMILY: I love that idea. I feel like that was what I was hoping for with a non-human narrator. So I've read The Art of Racing in the Rain, and I really... Talk about pulling your heartstrings. And I want to have that experience again. But it feels like so often the books that have non-human narrators, it's like Remarkably Bright Creatures where it's just interspersed with other things and you're seeing their perspective. But I could have read a whole book just narrated by that octopus in Remarkably Bright Creatures. And so I think this sounds amazing.
ANNE: I'm glad to hear it, but I'm going to give you more options in case. I just saw the trailer for Kazuo Ishiguro's adaptation of Klara and the Sun, and I imagine that's going to send many more readers back to that book. But that's narrated by a non-human.
[01:04:56] And also Elif Shafak, who was a guest on What Should I Read Next?, she's brilliant and so fascinating to listen to. She's written several books that have non-human narrators, or non-human narrators in part. The Island of Missing Trees has a final section narrated by a fig tree, and then There Are Rivers in the Sky, which is the book we mostly talked about when she was on the podcast, I think two late summers ago, is narrated by a raindrop.
EMILY: Wow.
ANNE: Yeah, it's real cool. It's real cool. Those are both a bigger investment, especially, There Are Rivers in the Sky, a bigger investment time-wise than something like Open Throat would be, but I mean, you know, maybe they're what you're looking for.
EMILY: Well, and it sounds like because those are a little bit older, that they probably would be more readily available on Libby, if not right away. So that sounds like a good option to add to my list, for sure.
ANNE: Emily, we just talked about a lot, a lot of books. How are you feeling about your book bingo?
[01:05:55] EMILY: Well, I think I'm going to get it done this year, so that's really exciting.
ANNE: You have the options. The reading of them is up to you.
EMILY: Yes, that's right. And maybe I won't be turning it in on December 31st this year like I did last year.
ANNE: I'm glad to hear it. I'm not going to rattle all these titles off, but readers, I want to remind you, if you go to whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com, we always list all the titles we talk about in the episode so that you don't have to frantically jot them down while you're driving or doing dishes or working out or, I don't know, laying on your couch. Whatever it is you like to do when you listen to podcasts, we got you covered.
But Emily, I'm really wondering what stands out to you and what you're thinking you may read next or soon.
EMILY: I think I'm going to go for Kayla Rae Whitaker and those two books that you recommended because they just sounded so good. They sounded so good. I also have not spent a ton of time in Lexington, but I live a lot closer to Lexington now than I used to, and so I feel like it would be fun to go to Costco one day and then just drive by some of the places that she talks about.
[01:07:10] ANNE: It could be. It could be. I mean, some of the street names you'll see on the highway signs. It'll look familiar. All right. Well, I'm excited that you're feeling good about your book bingo, and I can't wait to think about what you read. Thanks so much for talking books with me today.
EMILY: Thank you.
ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Emily, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next. Find Emily on Instagram at RevOnTheEdge, and find the full list of titles we talked about at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com. We also have links to other things that came up in conversation, like that bingo card.
Keep up with our show by following along on Instagram. We're there @whatshouldireadnext.
And like we mentioned at the top of today's show, two fast and free ways to support our show are by joining our email list at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter, and please open those emails. It's a small thing. It might sound silly. It helps us so much. As does following or subscribing to our show wherever you get your podcasts: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, wherever it is, follow or subscribe and download new episodes. It helps us so much. Thank you so much for taking a moment to check your settings and subscribe.
[01:08:22] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• I Shouldn’t Be Telling You This: (But I’m Going to Anyway) by Chelsea Devantez
• Open Book by Jessica Simpson
• The Third Gilmore Girl by Kelly Bishop
• Talking as Fast as I Can by Lauren Graham
• Friends, Lovers, and the Big Terrible Thing by Matthew Perry
• My Name is Barbra by Barbra Streisand (Audio edition)
• We Burn Daylight by Bret Anthony Johnston
• The Wedding People by Alison Espach
• 107 Days by Kamala Harris
• Dog Man: Fetch-22 by Dav Pilkey
• Agent Josephine by Damien Lewis
• Fearless and Free by Josephine Baker
• There There by Tommy Orange
• Shakespeare: The Man Who Pays the Rent by Judi Dench and Brendan O’Hea (Audio edition)
• Emily Bingham (try My Old Kentucky Home: The Astonishing Life and Reckoning of an Iconic American Song)
• Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry
• Southernmost by Silas House
• Call Us What We Carry by Amanda Gorman
• Cat Kid Comic Club by Dav Pilkey
The Guncle by Steven Rowley
• The Guncle Abroad by Steven Rowley
Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell
• The Outsiders by S. E. Hinton
• The Simon Snow series by Rainbow Rowell (#1: Carry On)
The Almost Sisters by Joshilyn Jackson
▵ My Year of Rest and Relaxation by Ottessa Moshfegh
• Ordinary Time by Annie B. Jones
• The Shippers by Katherine Center
• Jesse Stuart (try The Thread that Runs so True)
• bell hooks (try Appalachian Elegy)
• Kim Michele Richardson (try The Mountains We Call Home)
• Leesa Cross-Smith (try This Close to Okay)
• Returns and Exchanges by Kayla Rae Whitaker
• The Lost Story by Meg Shaffer
• Perfect Black by Crystal Wilkinson
• A Small Porch by Wendell Berry
• All These Ghosts by Silas House
• Marce Catlett: The Force of a Story by Wendell Berry
• Toni Morrison (try The Bluest Eye)
• Octavia Butler (try Kindred)
• Everything Sad Is Untrue by Daniel Nayeri (Audio edition)
• Lies and Weddings by Kevin Kwan
• This Motherless Land by Nikki May
• Last Night in Brooklyn by Xochitl Gonzalez
• Home Fire by Kamila Shamsie
• Hello Beautiful by Ann Napolitano
• Where the Rhythm Takes You by Sarah Dass
• Fault Lines by Emily Itami
• James by Percival Everett
• Demon Copperhead by Barbara Kingsolver
• Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt
• Redwall by Brian Jacques
• The Art of Racing in the Rain by Garth Stein
• Watership Down by Richard Adams
• The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
• The Murderbot Series by Martha Wells (#1: All Systems Red)
• The Call of the Wild by Jack London
• Grendel by John Gardner
• The Screwtape Letters by C. S. Lewis
• Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus
• Open Throat by Henry Hoke
• Klara and the Sun Kazuo Ishiguro
• The Island of Missing Trees by Elif Shafak
• There are Rivers in the Sky by Elif Shafak
: Guest favorite book
▵: A book they didn’t love
• Carmichael’s bookstore
• WSIRN Ep. 105: Reading makes the whole day better
• Book Bingo Card
• WSIRN Ep 455: Elif Shafak on the resilience of literature
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Branching out thanks to a book bingo challenge appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
I’m excited to share today’s conversation with an author I’ve recommended three times here on the podcast, and one whose work has been mentioned many more times as well: William Kent Krueger.
This is an author conversation that we originally held over in Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club, and which we’re sharing with you today as we explore Krueger’s book This Tender Land.
This conversation feels especially timely and has been on our minds and on our tongues, as This Tender Land was inspired by Homer’s The Odyssey, a timeless story that many of you tell us you’re looking forward to seeing on screen this summer in the new blockbuster adaptation film.
Today’s conversation and your enjoyment of it does not hang on whether you know anything at all about The Odyssey, or whether you’ve read anything by Kent Krueger yet. Join us as we explore the power of a good story well told, how authors make creative decisions, and the backstories behind Krueger’s beloved series and his decidedly different standalone novels. You’ll also hear the story behind his favorite pair of boots.
Let us know if you’re looking forward to seeing or reading The Odyssey this summer in the comments section.
We’re excited about our upcoming annual observance of Austen in August, followed by our Fall Book Preview in mid-September. We’d love to have you join us for our live events, including our seasonal previews and author chats like this one. Members also enjoy our robust community featuring dedicated book forums, buddy reads, classes, and more happenings. We hope you’ll find your book people in Book Club. Find out more and join us at modernmrsdarcy.com/club.
[00:00:00] KENT KRUEGER: I find it interesting, Anne, that this book is being called a historical novel. It takes place in the Great Depression, and I was born really not that long after the Great Depression ended.
ANNE BOGEL: They call the 1970s novel historical fiction, so.
KENT: Yeah, okay.
ANNE: We're all getting older, I guess.
Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read.
[00:00:43] In today's episode, we are sharing a meaty and satisfying author talk we enjoyed with author William Kent Krueger in Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club.
First, I want to give you a timely update about what's happening in Book Club. We just wrapped our latest Annual Readers Weekend that we've hosted online each summer since 2020. Members, whether you're a current member or you sign up today, can go to our member site to snag our Digital Readers Weekend kit with all the resources you might need to create your own reader retreat.
Right now in Book Club we're looking ahead to our annual observance of Austen in August, followed by our fall book preview in mid-September. You might also notice us reference our Book Club community picks in this author chat today. Our Book Club community manager, Ginger, tells me that that 2020 community read of The Odyssey, on which Kent Krueger's book, This Tender Land, is based, is still one she thinks about all the time.
[00:01:41] Reading our official monthly selections together means there's always bound to be someone to talk to about books. Recently, members of our community have hosted community reads for The Once and Future King, summer reading guide selection, The Fine Art of Lying, Game Changers, Middlemarch, A Swim in the Pond in the Rain, and the one I'm participating in myself, Emily St. John Mandel's The Singer's Gun, and that is just to name a few.
We would love to have you join us for our live events in Book Club, like our author chats and seasonal book previews, as well as being part of our member community with its dedicated book forums, buddy reads, classes, and more happenings. We hope you will find your book people in our Book Club. Find out more and join us at modernmrsdarcy.com/club. That's modernmrsdarcy.com/club.
[00:02:27] Readers, today I'm excited to share a conversation with an author I've recommended three times here on the podcast, and one whose work has been mentioned many more times as well. He's beloved by many; that is William Kent Krueger, who you may know from his Cork O'Connor series or his standalones.
He's written five standalone novels, and today we're diving into one of them, This Tender Land. This happens in an author conversation that we originally held over in Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club, and which we're sharing with you in full with one edit that you will hear for spoilery reasons today.
This conversation feels especially timely and has been on our minds and on our tongues, as This Tender Land was inspired by Homer's The Odyssey, a timeless story that many of you tell us you're looking forward to seeing on screen this summer in the new blockbuster adaptation film.
[00:03:17] A frequent thing I've heard repeated from you is you're a little scared, but also you're excited. But today's conversation and your enjoyment of it does not hang on whether you know anything at all about The Odyssey, or whether you've read anything by Kent Krueger yet.
Today we're exploring the power of a good story well told. We're exploring how authors make creative decisions, the backstories behind Krueger's beloved series and his decidedly different standalone novels, and we're even going to hear the story behind his favorite pair of boots.
Kent won us over in like the first 20 seconds when he joined us in Book Club. You are going to hear why. I am so excited to share this conversation with all of you today. Let's get to it.
Kent, thank you so much for joining us today.
KENT: A pleasure to be with you, Anne. Thanks for the invitation.
[00:04:07] ANNE: Well, it's a pleasure to welcome you to Book Club, everyone. We're so glad you could be here. We've known for a long time that we would love to discuss really pretty much anything with you. I know we have lots of fans of the Cork O'Connor series here. I think it was actually Janine, are you here today, who said, "Anne, based on what you love, you've got to read this series by my fellow Minnesotans." From there, I read Ordinary Grace and then This Tender Land. We really enjoyed reading your fiction, but also there's so much to talk about for Book Clubs. So thank you for coming to talk to us today about This Tender Land.
KENT: Again, my pleasure.
ANNE: Well, let's start by, if you could, give us a brief overview of the book. And y'all, we have a treat. Kent said that he is an experienced reader. I know you've heard some authors say that there's nothing they'd rather do less than read in a bookstore, but that is not Kent's background. And I'm really excited to hear you talk a little about the book and read us the prologue. I'm going to open mine and follow along.
[00:05:06] KENT: Thanks very much, Anne. This Tender Land, for those of you who haven't read it yet, takes place in the summer of 1932, deep in the Great Depression. It's the story of four orphans running from the law because they've committed a terrible crime, but for the right reason.
They know if they take to the roads to get away, they'll be caught rather quickly because a huge manhunt has been launched to capture them. They're afraid to ride the rails, as everybody was doing back in the Depression, because the railroads back then were patrolled by private cops called bulls. And the bulls had a reputation for being incredibly cruel, so the kids are afraid to ride the rails.
Instead, they decide to take to the rivers. They canoe a river called the Gilead to the Minnesota River. They canoe the Minnesota River to the Mississippi. And their plan is to canoe all the way down the Mississippi River to St. Louis, where they believe they have family and they'll be safe. I have always wanted to write an updated version of Huckleberry Finn. This is my Huckleberry Finn.
[00:06:09] I'm going to read the prologue to you for a couple of reasons. First of all, it's really short. It's just over a page. But the other reason I like to read this prologue to audiences is that it's simply maybe my favorite piece of my own writing ever. So this is how I bring readers into This Tender Land.
"In the beginning, after He labored over the heavens and the earth, the light and the dark, the land and sea and all living things that dwell therein, after He created man and woman, and before He rested, I believe God gave us one final gift. Lest we forget the divine source of all that beauty, He gave us stories. I am a storyteller. I live in a house in the shade of a sycamore tree on the banks of the Gilead River. My great-grandchildren, when they visit me here, call me old. "Old is a cliché," I tell them with mock disappointment, "a terrible trivializing and insult. I was born along with the sun and earth and moon and planets and all the stars. Every atom of my being was there at the very beginning." "You're a liar," they scowl, but playfully. "Not a liar. A storyteller," I remind them. "Then tell us a story," they plead. I need no goading. Stories are the sweet fruit of my existence and I share them gladly.
[00:07:39] The events I'm about to share with you began on the banks of the Gilead. Even if you grew up in the heartland, you may not remember these things. What happened in the summer of 1932 is most important to those who experienced it, and there are not many of us left. The Gilead is a lovely river lined with cottonwoods already ancient when I was a boy. Things were different then, not simpler or better, just different.
We didn't travel the way we do now and for most folks in Fremont County, Minnesota, the world was limited to the piece of it they could see before the horizon cut off the land. They wouldn't have understood any more than I did, that if you kill a man, you are changed forever. If that man comes back to life, you are transformed.
[00:08:32] I have witnessed this and other miracles with my own eyes. So among the many pieces of wisdom life has offered me over all these years is this: open yourself to every possibility, for there is nothing your heart can imagine that is not so.
The tale I'm going to tell is of a summer long ago, of killing and kidnapping and children pursued by demons of a thousand names. There will be courage in this story and cowardice, there will be love and betrayal, and of course, there will be hope. In the end, isn't that what every good story is about?"
ANNE: Thank you for that.
KENT: You're welcome.
ANNE: What copy are you reading from?
KENT: I'm reading from the advanced reader's copy, the ARC.
ANNE: Okay, is it marked up? Do you keep it handy? Is it dog-eared?
KENT: It is dog-eared. It's the one I always read from.
[00:09:31] ANNE: Okay. Do you keep it at your desk? Do you travel with it when we can do such things?
KENT: Yes, both of those.
ANNE: Okay, we will get the slew of audiobook questions we now have. Now, correct me if I'm wrong, but I have read in some interviews that the origin story for this book actually goes back to Ordinary Grace, a book that was different from your previous works and was quite successful. And I'd love to hear you elaborate a little on... you know, in your own words, what led to the publication and the writing, first of all, of this novel?
KENT: I think it's an interesting journey, and thank you for asking about it. So, I cut my teeth on the Cork O'Connor mystery series, which, you know, is in a genre. But about 10, 12 years ago, a story idea came to me that wasn't a part of the Cork O'Connor series. It wasn't suited to the Cork O'Connor series. And when I proposed that project to my publisher, they didn't want it. In fact, they called me out to New York City in kind of a panic and sat me down and said, "Kent, we only want Cork O'Connor stories from you."
[00:10:39] So I knew if I wrote this story, it was going to be a very risky proposition. Clearly, my publisher wasn't interested. I had no idea if any other publisher might want it. But it was a story that spoke to me in such a compelling way that I knew I had to write it.
So across the course of the next three years, every moment that wasn't devoted to a contractual obligation in my Cork O'Connor series, I spent composing the manuscript for Ordinary Grace. Now, even though my publisher had told me they didn't want it, when it was finished, I went ahead and sent it to my editor at Simon & Schuster. She fell in love with it. She said, "Of course, we're going to publish it." And they did.
And Ordinary Grace has just had this remarkable, really gratifying reception among critics and readers alike. It won tons of awards when it came out. It's been translated into a couple of dozen languages. So far it's sold nearly a million copies. And when my publisher saw how well that book was doing, boy, did they want another book just like it.
[00:11:31] So I signed a contract and spent the next two years writing what I believed would be the companion novel to Ordinary Grace. Now, that manuscript was contractually due to my publisher five years ago. Two months before that contractual deadline, I set up a meeting in Chicago to talk with my agent about revisions to the work because there were problems with it. I knew it. She knew it.
Two days before we met, I sent her a note saying, "When we get together, I don't want to talk about how we revise this piece. I want to talk about how we keep it from being published." Because it wasn't the story I'd imagined it would be. I didn't know how to make it that story. And frankly, my heart was no longer in it. It turns out I have a very understanding publisher. They said, "Fine, you don't have to give us this manuscript, but you still owe us a companion novel."
So here's the deal, Anne. The expectations for that follow-up novel were enormous. And the whole time I was trying to write the story, I just felt crushed by the weight of all those expectations. And the truth is, when I was writing that manuscript, what I was trying to do was, you know, meet everybody else's expectations instead of writing the story that spoke to me from my heart.
[00:12:45] But when that weight got lifted off my shoulders, and I felt free again, I saw so very clearly the story I should have been writing. And honestly, it was a story I've been wanting to write since I was 11 years old. When I was 11 years old, in the fifth grade, toward the end of that year, our teacher read to the class out loud, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. He did it by reading half an hour every day after lunch. And I loved that book.
I mean, here was this kid who was just like me, and he's having these great adventures on the Mississippi River. And after that, of course, I had to read Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, which I also loved. And so across my whole career as a writer, I have wanted to write a story in which I could pay homage to Mark Twain. And that is a major part of the inspiration for This Tender Land.
[00:13:36] ANNE: We're so glad that you returned to Huck Finn. Now, with both Ordinary Grace and This Tender Land, you have a character looking back over time, telling us a story that we know is complete. But as readers, we don't know how we're going to get from here to there. And when you have a character looking back over the decades, like your narrators have in Ordinary Grace and This Tender Land, you have this wistful, reflective feel to it that really suits these books... Well, we'll focus on This Tender Land, although we have a pitch for Ordinary Grace, making a note. It really suits the story well. How did you know that that was the way the story needed to be told? How did you decide on that?
KENT: I didn't at first. I tried to write the story a couple of times during my career, and I was never able to sink my teeth into it. And the reason was that I could never see the structure for the story. I knew it was going to be some kids on the river, what it was going to be set, what they were doing on the river, where they were coming from, where they were going. I knew the Mississippi would be involved. But beyond that, I really didn't know anything.
[00:14:53] And then when I came out from that dark period of that manuscript that I was disappointed in, I saw the structure for the Huck Finn story. And it was a structure that was inspired by another book I loved as a kid. I have to tell you this. My father was a high school English teacher, and so he always had me reading Great Literature instead of the stuff that most kids were reading, I'm sure.
But I read so many of the epic, mythic journeys when I was a kid. One of those journeys that was a favorite of mine was the Odyssey. I loved Homer's Odyssey as a kid. Not so much the Iliad, but I love the Odyssey, the story of a guy making his way back from Troy to Ithaca, and having all of these incredible adventures along the way.
So when I came out of that dark period, I thought, "I'm going to write the Huck Finn story and I'm going to use the structure of the Odyssey to create it." These kids are going to experience many of the same kinds of things that Odysseus experienced on his long journey from Troy back to Ithaca. I didn't know which of the many experiences I would use, but these kids' journey would mirror that of Odysseus, which gave me the structure.
[00:16:08] But this story really revealed itself to me pretty much as I was going down the river with the kids. Which adventures would happen, I sort of decided on after I had completed one section of the book. So where are they going next? Why are they going there? What are they supposed to learn there? I discovered, basically as the reader discovers it, going through the story as it is.
And I have to tell you that it's a very different process than I follow from my Cork O'Connor series stories, which I think through significantly before I ever set pen to paper or fingers to the keyboard today. I wanted this story to be different, to come to me differently. I wanted it to feel organic, which it did. And it was an extraordinary creative experience for me as a result.
[00:16:55] ANNE: Many readers really enjoyed noticing the similarities. And there's a reason that I'm not asking Kent this, though you're sitting right here, but sharing an insightful comment from a fellow book clubber, I want you to know that even to someone who's not behind the scenes of this process, the way you're drawing on the Odyssey was apparent. You can decide if you want to jump in and say, "Yes, yes, that's right, that's right," or, "Not exactly."
But let me read Nicole's comment. She wrote in our forum, so you can go see this: "I was surprised at how many characters from the books, that's This Tender Land and the Odyssey, overlapped. It's kind of brilliant. One-Eye Jack is obviously the Cyclops; Aunt Julia is Penelope with her problematic suitors. I think that maybe Sister Eve represents the sirens with her beautiful voice that causes the vagabonds to abandon their ship for a while. Also, this place where they discovered the skeleton and learn how many Native Americans were murdered here, much like the sailors upon the rocks. And the people in the flats could be the lotus eaters, as only Odie wants to leave this group of people who nourish the vagabonds with the very little they have. Maybeth seems like Calypso in that Odie fell for her and almost stayed with her family. Finally, it feels like none of the Odyssey monsters are terrible enough to be the Black Witch, but I think she may be Circe, beautiful and powerful with the ability to turn men or students into animals. Odysseus only escapes her by remaining immune to her tricks and enchantments and with help from Athena. Athena guides Odysseus and changes his outcomes when she can. This can only be Emmy, right?"
[00:18:21] KENT: Well, this is a brilliant dissection, and I love it. And it's almost dead on except for one thing. For me, Sister Eve is Circe. Sister Eve right at the very beginning tames the beast in men. She has what appear to be the powers of a sorceress. And we're never quite sure, at least in the beginning, of her intentions toward Odie and his companions. So aside from that, everything else is absolutely dead on. Bravo!
ANNE: A-plus, Nicole. Now, Kent, I'm wondering, so many readers read your book, and then we have a group reading through Emily Wilson's translation of the Odyssey right now together. And we may have read Homer once in high school but haven't touched it since. And we don't have the story internalized in the way that I suspect you might.
[00:19:20] KENT: You know, that doesn't matter. When I was writing it, and I was using the Odyssey to give me a structure for the story, I thought, "This is going to go over the head of most readers probably." And that didn't matter to me. What mattered to me was that I created, in the Great Depression era, a story that would ring true for readers. And even if they didn't understand the parallels I was drawing, that wouldn't matter. They don't need to know the parallels with the Odyssey in order to enjoy the story. And I hope they pick up on the themes that I was trying to weave throughout the narrative.
ANNE: Something that we've talked about here in Book Club before that I firmly believe is that when a novel has deep structure and symbolism, even if the reader doesn't consciously notice, it lends a heft and weight to the story that they cannot help but feel. Really what I meant, because I absolutely agree with what you're saying, is, is this a story that has lived in your bones for a long time?
[00:20:25] KENT: Oh, yeah, absolutely. It has. In one form or another, bits and pieces of it. This was the coalescing of lots of ideas I've had from the past. Lots of scenes that I've tried to write earlier on. Very early on in my career, I wrote a short story, a failed short story, about a couple of kids who stumble onto an evangelical revival group who work with snakes. The short story didn't work out, but I resurrected it for the visit with the Sword of Beauty and Healing Crusade. Other bits and pieces of it have been with me for a very long time. And just the whole idea of a Huck Finn-like character has haunted my imagination forever.
ANNE: Wherein lies the appeal of young Huck Finn on a journey down the river? What stirs the imagination for you in that?
[00:21:16] KENT: Well, for me personally, Huck Finn and my Odie represent the kind of kid I wish I'd been. They're both rebellious. They're both adventurous. They're both resourceful. They're both, in their way, fiercely loyal. And I was none of those things when I was a kid. You know, I was the goody two-shoes.
And so when I thought about writing a revisionist Huck Finn, I thought, "The character I create is the character I'm going to have a lot of fun with. And he's going to do the kinds of things I always wished I had done as a kid." That said, I spent a lot of time on rivers when I was a kid, probably doing things that my parents, had they known about it, would have thrown up their hands in terror, you know?
ANNE: This reminds me of some things you referenced in the author's note, which readers, we say this every time we read a historical novel, do not miss the author's note. I'm trying to remember, is it in the audio version, Kent? Do you know?
[00:22:15] KENT: I believe it is. I believe everything that's in the original work is also in the audio version. And then there's additional content in the audio version.
ANNE: Okay. Because they're not always in the audio version and you'll be rewarded if you track down a copy of the author's note whenever you read a historical novel. But in addition to referencing some of your inspirations for characters, which I'd love to get to in a minute, you talked about your research process, including spending time on the river.
KENT: Oh yeah.
ANNE: Did you always know that would be important to the story?
KENT: I did. I did. I've never written a story about a place I haven't visited myself. And although I write a lot of murder mysteries and have never committed a murder myself, I try to experience as much of the rest of what happens in the book as I can. So when I knew these kids were going to be on a river journey and I had a sense of the rivers I wanted them to be on, I kayaked or canoed those stretches of the river that the kids canoe.
[00:23:14] So I kayaked the stretch of the Minnesota the kids are on and my wife and I canoed the stretch of the Mississippi River that the kids actually canoe. So, yeah, I wanted to get a feel for what it's like to be on these rivers. What would the kids see? What kind of, you know, fears might they have?
As we were talking earlier before we came live, yeah, I was kind of scared when I was out there on the river. So I bought myself a kayak, an inflatable kayak, to do the river work with, and I had only been in the kayak once before I set it on the Minnesota River.
And so I'm in this kayak that's a little unknown to me and it's tipping a little more than the manufacturer guaranteed. And I've got my life vest on... and I have never been on the Minnesota. I've done a number of other rivers, never been on the Minnesota, which is kind of a silty river. So you can't really, generally speaking, see the bottom. I know there are deep holes there. The current's pretty swift because this was during a kind of a flooded period in Southern Minnesota. And I'm thinking, "Oh God, if I go over, what's going to happen? Well, I've got my vest on, but you know there are whirlpools in this river that can suck you down? And maybe there's quicksand here. God only knows what's... you know, snags under there. So as I'm thinking this, I'm thinking, "Okay, what happened?" I looked over the side of the kayak and the bottom was about two feet below me. Okay. I just get out and walk.
[00:24:47] But on the Mississippi River, the day that my wife and I canoed the Mississippi, the barge traffic was enormous. And the wakes from those enormous vessels and the barges that they're pushing were just huge. And a couple of times we really were afraid we were going to get swamped.
ANNE: At what point in the writing process did you go on the river?
KENT: Pretty much after I had completed the first draft of the manuscript, then I went back and was doing a lot of research to get the central details correct. Make sure that what I had... I had already traveled this territory in my car and stopped and got out, took photographs of all the places where things occurred, but I needed to get onto the river as that final piece of it. So it was after the first draft was finished.
ANNE: That's fascinating. Now I could spot Aimee Semple McPherson's influence in the manuscript, but you also referenced in the author's note a fictional character that I was unfamiliar with that really influenced the way you shaped her character. Would you tell us a little bit about both women?
[00:25:54] KENT: In the early part of the 20th century, there was a great revival, tent revival movement, with a lot of miracle healing that went along with it. And these shows were popular across the entire country. So Billy Sunday, maybe as a name, some readers are familiar with, Aimee Semple McPherson, another slightly later revivalist. And these were people who drew hundreds of thousands of followers to their faith healings, to their preaching of the gospel, of their very evangelical preaching of the gospel.
But by the time of the Great Depression, that movement had died out across most of the country, with the exception of the South and the Midwest, where these shows were still quite popular. So I did a lot of reading of Aimee Semple McPherson and her belief in having been tapped by God. And she was an interesting woman, but I found a more complex and really compelling character in Sinclair Lewis, in his novel, Elmer Gantry.
[00:26:57] For those who haven't read Elmer Gantry, you've forgotten it, during a portion of Elmer Gantry's career, he hooks up with a revivalist named Sharon Falconer, who is definitely a woman of the world, that's very clear, but she is also a woman who firmly, devoutly believes that God has called her to preach a gospel of love to the masses. And so I thought, "What an interesting character she would be." And so more than Aimee Semple McPherson, even, I used Sharon Falconer as kind of a template for Sister Eve. But Sister Eve grew into her own character, with her own set of remarkable talents.
ANNE: I love how, when we start digging into this book, we can't do it without talking about the power of story. There are stories woven through the books, there are stories to you that served as inspiration. In your prologue, Odie is telling us that story is... well, I was going to say story is everything. You probably know how he says it in his own words in like sentence two. Did you say something?
[00:28:04] KENT: Lest we forget the divine source of all that beauty, He gave us stories.
ANNE: Very good. I was wondering at first. I really thought you might have been reciting and not reading your prologue.
KENT: Well, I have read it so many times, I could probably do it.
ANNE: Do it with your eyes closed. He gave us stories. In this book, you're addressing issues that go to the heart of what it means to be human and many of the core struggles of human nature through the lens of story, and in your own words, instead of Odie's, though I wonder how much they might overlap, Kent. I'd love to hear you discuss a little bit why it matters to discuss these things, to tell stories instead of talking about topics.
[00:28:49] KENT: For me, stories can do so much more than entertain. Stories can enlighten us. They can encourage us. They can inspire us. And maybe the most important thing that stories can do for us is they give us hope. So when I write a story, one of the things that I really try to do is set out to write a story that ultimately is going to be a story of hope. Because honestly, when I read a piece of fiction, when I get to the end, I want to feel as if I've been on a journey. And in my own understanding of the world, and my own understanding of myself, I'm in a different place than I was when I began that story.
So I try to do everything with my stories that I think a story has the potential of doing. They are so important to who we are. You know, across countless millennia, stories have told us who we are as a people. They have given us instructions on how we're supposed to behave, or even how we're supposed to do our daily things in life. Stories are, I think, every bit as important to us as breathing. There you go.
[00:30:05] ANNE: There is so much we could discuss: poverty, the Great Depression, faith, hope, and children in peril in those reform schools. But I just want to focus on one because Michelle, in advance of today's talk, asked a really nice question, nice meaning thoughtful, and I'd love to hear what you said.
Her question was rooted in... Well, here, I'll just read this in her own words. She says, "Why does an author who obviously cares deeply for Native communities and culture choose to silence them here? Is it perhaps to reflect the way Native communities were and are silenced to show the loss when assimilation of tribal cultures into the American culture is completed?"
Now, it's interesting. She's talking about themes that I believe are visible not only in This Tender Land, but in your murder mysteries as well, which, perhaps surprisingly to some readers, also have that undercurrent of hope and do address these topics that matter so much through the lens of story. I know this is just one facet of a substantial novel, but I'd love to hear you reflect on that.
[00:31:10] KENT: Sure, Mose is mute. Mose, one of the vagabonds, the Native kid on the journey, is mute. And he's mute because he represents something much larger than himself. He represents an entire culture that had no voice. And that has always been the situa... continues to be really the situation for so many minority cultures in our country, and particularly the indigenous people.
For more than 100 years, from the late 1800s until 1978, when the National Indian Child Welfare Act was passed, if the government came to your home and you were Native American and said, "We want to take your child away to a government boarding school," you had no recourse. You could not prevent them from doing this. You had no voice in the matter.
[00:32:12] So one of the things that I wanted to talk about in This Tender Land was that lack of voice, at least in the beginning of Mose's journey. But for those of you who have read the story, you know across the course of the journey, all of the children discover things about themselves. They're all seeking something different, and they all end up... Well, I don't want to give it away.
ANNE: Oh, but there's that great scene. There's that great scene with... yeah.
KENT: Mose, as he travels across this epic summer for him, begins to discover who he is, discover the importance of where he has come from, the importance of his people, of his culture. And though he has no voice, he begins to understand how to speak for his people, and by the end of the story, he has a powerful voice for his people.
[00:33:06] ANNE: This reminds me of a much more lighthearted question from Shannan. Do you know sign language? Do you play the harmonica? What was your inspiration for using both in this story?
KENT: I do not know sign nor do I play the harmonica. But I did a good deal of research in terms of sign language so that I could make it as realistic as possible. Odie, in my early thinking, I knew Odie was going to play two important roles on this journey. He was going to be the guy who had to hold everybody together and keep them focused on moving forward, as Odysseus did with his crew while he had a crew, and he was going to be the guy who had to keep their spirits lifted up when dark things happened and threatened to drag them all down.
And he was going to do it in two ways. I knew he was going to be a storyteller, 'because boy, I was looking forward to using Odie to talk about so many of the things that I think are important as a storyteller. But I knew he was going to use music then as the way to lift up the spirits of his crew, his group, the other vagabonds.
[00:34:14] And when I thought, "Okay, how is he going to do this with music? He's on a river. They're traveling. You know, you can't bring a tuba along on their river journey. So what's he going to play?" And I thought, "Well, of course, a harmonica," because it's so easy to carry and it's so iconically American. And the tunes that fit a harmonica are just... they go way back in our awareness as a culture here in the States. So I thought, "Okay, he's going to play the harmonica." I had no idea about the harmonica. I had to talk to some of my friends who do, in fact, play harmonicas to get an idea of what that would be like and to help me choose some tunes that would be appropriate for the harmonica. So I had a lot of fun in that.
I actually believed I was going to learn at least how to play Shenandoah on the harmonica so that I could do that when I did book events. Didn't happen. I'm pretty lazy.
ANNE: Oh, that would've been amazing at book events.
KENT: I thought so too.
[00:35:15] ANNE: Well, it's a good thing you're such a good reader. If I had to choose, I'd rather hear you read the prologue.
KENT: Well, thank you.
ANNE: Now, I have resisted asking you about your in-depth research process because you talk about it in the author's note, but I mean, we're together, and I can't resist. You read a ton of information to give the story that authentic feel and texture that makes us feel like these are real people, this happened, we're right there with them.
And I would love to hear... Here's the thing about the reading experience. You don't appreciate all the ways the author got it right. You just feel that it is so, until they get something wrong, and then it jumps right out at you. But this story feels so right. And I know that's not just luck or good writing, but also painstaking research. Would you tell us a little bit about your journey into memoir, microfiche, and whatever else you touched in the process?
[00:36:11] KENT: Sure. You know, I find it interesting, Anne, that this book is being called an historical novel. Takes place in the Great Depression, and I was born really not that long after the Great Depression ended.
ANNE: Well, they call the 1970s novel historical fiction, so.
KENT: Yeah, okay.
ANNE: We're all getting older, I guess. What do you call it?
KENT: I grew up on stories that my folks told of surviving the Depression. My father was from Oklahoma, and I grew up on his stories during the Dust Bowl years of watching it rain mud from the sky and having to go out and scavenge greens from vacant lots and along railroad tracks to supplement their meals. My mother was born in North Dakota and was farmed out at four years of age to a distant relative because her family simply couldn't feed all of the mouths that they had to feed at that point.
[00:37:00] So the Depression wasn't like history to me. It was all of these great stories that my parents told. But I hadn't lived during that period of time, and I knew to get the factual underpinnings correct. We are blessed here in St. Paul to have a great historical resource in our midst. We have the Minnesota History Center here. Inside the Minnesota History Center is a section called the Gale Family Library, which is simply an archive of all of the newspapers ever published in Minnesota.
So I spent hours and hours poring over microfilmed newspapers from back in the... particularly the summer of 1932, to know what the kids would've been aware of in that time. What were people conscious of? What were the important events of the day? What were the fashions like? What did things cost? What kinds of foods were people eating? All of that. So that when I wrote the story, I didn't want to hit the reader over the head with all of the research I'd done. I needed to make sure it integrated in just a very matter-of-fact way in terms of all of the activities that were going on in the story. So I hope I accomplished that.
[00:38:09] Here's one of the interesting things I learned. I learned a lot of interesting things, but here's one of the really interesting things. Back in the Great Depression, people didn't have a lot of money to buy clothes, so women took to using flour sacks and feed sacks to create clothing, their dresses, they would make shirts out of them. And when all of these companies became aware of that, they began putting out flour and feed and other things in patterns so that people, when they created this clothing from it, would... It would look not like sacks. It was just such really a kind of a gracious offering to the people out there who were in need, I thought.
ANNE: Now we're shifting to reader questions, lest I get in lots of trouble. Here's an interesting one that hadn't occurred to me from Mary Ellen. "Do you know," or I'm going to add, do you wonder, "if Mark Twain was thinking about the Odyssey when he wrote?"
[00:39:02] KENT: God only knows what Mark Twain was ever thinking. That guy was brilliant and so off the wall, you could just never predict where His profound wit and wisdom is going to take you as a reader. I have no idea if that was on His mind. I have more a Shakespearean feel when I read Huck Finn rather than a Homer feel, in all honesty.
ANNE: Janine says, "As a fellow Minnesotan, I'm curious, what drew you to focus on this aspect of Minnesota history, the Native American boarding schools?"
KENT: I knew when I discovered the structure of the book, really saw the structure, that these kids had to be running away from essentially a war zone as Odysseus was leaving the war zone behind him in Troy, and I wanted them to be running from a horrific environment. And because I'd been working with the Native community now for more than two decades, I've been aware for a very long time of the horrific situation of the Native American boarding schools, and I couldn't imagine a more horrific environment for the kids to have to flee from than that.
[00:40:17] So I decided, okay, I'm going to do this, but I'm also going to do this because it's a situation most White folks are clueless about, never even heard about. And I thought, well, maybe this might be a way that I can raise a little bit of consciousness at the same time.
ANNE: Moke asks, "Did the names of characters and places have particular significance? Gilead and Moses are more obvious biblical references, but were there others, and why did you choose them?"
KENT: God only knows. I am always asked about the names of my characters, and honest to God, sometimes I flounder around a long time before I settle on a great name. I knew Odie's name, Odysseus. I had no idea what his last name was going to be or really what his history was going to be until I began to create him and I saw this rebellious Irish streak in him, and I thought, "Okay, I'm going to make him Irish, of Irish ancestry," and then worked on a number of names until O'Banion felt right.
[00:41:27] Albert, I needed a very stiff name for an older brother who's kind of stiff in a lot of his behavior. Moses, I loved the Biblical reference because he's a kid who's found sort of in the same way that Moses is found, among the reeds. And Washington just because... Well, God, I can't even remember why I chose Washington as the superintendent's, you know, iconic figure from American history. Emmy was always Emmy, for whatever reason. Her name came to me right away with the character.
Sister Eve, she came to me very early on as Eve, another Biblical reference. The Gilead I chose because obviously there's a balm in Gilead. These kids start off on the Gilead on their journey, and it's a river that treats them kindly in the beginning, as they need to be treated after the horrific experiences they've had. And it treats them kindly until they join the Minnesota River and a lot of things start to happen there. Beyond that, I don't know what to say.
[00:42:33] ANNE: Well, I asked how do you choose them. You said, "God only knows." My first question was the God of the tornado or the other God? Which leads us to talk to us about the title.
KENT: This Tender Land, I love that title. It came to me as I was driving across southern Minnesota one day, and I happened to be listening to our classical music station here. An absolutely gorgeous piece of music that I was completely unfamiliar with came on, and as I listened to it, I was just swept up and swept away. And when it finished, the announcer said, "You've just been listening to an excerpt of the only opera Aaron Copland ever composed called," and I thought he said This Tender Land. The actual title of the opera is The Tender Land, but I heard, "This Tender Land," and I thought, "Oh, God, there it is. That's the title." And I have always just loved what that title suggests.
[00:43:31] ANNE: Here's a question that never occurred to me from Danny: "Were the Red Wing boots inspired by Hermes the messenger?"
KENT: No. But now that you mention it, I wish they had been. No, they were inspired by my love of Red Wing boots. I was married in a pair of Red Wing boots that I picked up in a used clothing store actually, along with a suit that I picked up at a used clothing store. I was married back in the days of Love Child, of the flower child days, and so we didn't have the kinds of big festive weddings that they have now. Ours was full of daisies that we gave to everybody, and my wife made her dress and I bought mine at a secondhand store. So Red Wing boots have been deep in my heart.
I worked construction for many, many years as a young man. I always wore Red Wing boots because honest to God, they were the best boots I thought you could buy. When I moved to Minnesota, Red Wing boots are manufactured here, so I had to give Odie and the other boys on the journey their own pair of Red Wing boots.
[00:44:37] ANNE: Now I'm about to ask Kent a question from about the halfway mark in the novel. Kent, you can answer this however you'd like. Readers, I'm about to ask Kent a question about setup and payoff, and my question itself hints at a spoiler, so we wanted to cut it here. But we did want you to be able to hear Kent's spoiler-free answer. It's coming up.
I found that thread to be so satisfying and well-placed without feeling overly clever, which makes me wonder...
KENT: Or manipulative.
ANNE: Yes. Oh, because there's... Well, okay. No, with disregard for whether this is an accurate superlative, there is nothing worse than feeling like the author is just messing with you, so...
KENT: Yeah.
ANNE: Or thinks they're cleverer than you. But I just really love the way that you laid that thread. Which makes me wonder, what part or parts of this story did you find just satisfying to write?
[00:45:40] KENT: That was one of them. That was certainly one of them. You know, as a mystery writer, one of the things that I've learned is the joy of suspense for a reader. I don't care if you're trying to write a thriller or straightforward literature, suspense is really what it's all about, creating a sense in the reader that they want to turn the next page to find out what happens.
And so as I was writing that section of the novel, I was creating characters, Sister Eve, Sid, that raised a lot of suspicion in a reader's mind, a suspenseful wonderment about who these people are and where are they going with this story, and how much should I trust them? So as a writer of suspense, I just reveled in that section.
ANNE: I'm glad you did, because I found it extremely satisfying to read. And that's interesting that the things you learned writing mysteries work so well in this book as well. Okay, we're not going to chase that thread because we just have a few more for you. First, tell us about Ordinary Grace, Kent.
[00:46:47] KENT: Ordinary Grace is set in the summer of 1961 in a small town deep in the very beautiful Minnesota River Valley, the same territory that the kids travel in This Tender Land. It's the story of a Methodist minister whose beloved child is murdered. That's the compelling mystery component. But at heart, it's really the story of what that terrible tragedy does to this man's faith, his family, and ultimately the entire fabric of this small town in which he lives.
For anybody who's read my Cork O'Connor novels, they're going to see an undercurrent in many of those stories that deals with the spiritual journey. It's a situation that comes quite naturally for the protagonist in those stories, Cork O'Connor, because he's a man of mixed heritage. He's part Irish American, and he's part Ojibwe Anishinaabe. So he's a man with a foot in two different spiritual traditions: his White Catholicism, he's Irish Catholic, and his Ojibwe spirituality.
[00:47:47] So very often in those stories, he's trying to figure out where his unique spiritual path lies. And that's been an issue for me my whole life. I wrote This Tender Land in large measure because I wanted to explore more deeply the question of the importance of the spiritual journey that I believe we're all on, whether we embrace that or not. Until I wrote This Tender Land, it was far and away my favorite piece of my own writing. I thought I would never write another book as meaningful to me as that one was, and then I wrote This Tender Land.
ANNE: Now, you can choose how to answer this, knowing that some readers have said, "Oop, I just bought Iron Lake. It's going to be here on Saturday." And some readers are waiting with bated breath for the next Cork O'Connor novel. But the question is, what's next for Cork?
KENT: I finished the first draft and have sent it off to my agent for her review of number 18 in the Cork O'Connor series. It's a novel called Lightning Strike, and it's actually a prequel to the series.
ANNE: Oh.
[00:48:50] KENT: It takes place when Cork is 12 or 13 years old. For anybody who knows my series, they know that Cork O'Connor was sheriff of the fictional Tamarack County when he was an adult. As a child, as a young man, his father was sheriff of Tamarack County before him, and his father was killed in the line of duty when Cork was an adolescent. Lightning Strike takes Cork in that summer before his father is killed. And what it's allowing me to do is explore the relationship that Cork had with his father, the relationship that Cork had with his mother, the relationship his parents had with each other, all these important relationships that helped shape Cork into the man who occupies center place in the series. I have just enjoyed tremendously going back in Cork's life and creating him as a young man.
ANNE: Now, you might have just answered my final question as well, but at the beginning, before we welcomed everybody into the room, Kent, you and I were discussing your writing and what you're doing right now, but we didn't discuss what you are writing right now. What are you working on?
[00:49:54] KENT: Two novelettes. Lightning Strike won't be... Typically, I would have a novel released this fall. I have a novel pretty much released every single fall, but the pandemic has changed the thinking of many publishers, mine included, and they are delaying the release of a lot of their books. My novel now has been postponed for release until the fall of 2021. But I'd like to try to bring something out in the interim period, so I'm putting together two novelettes, and I'm just enjoying the hell out of that experience. So that's what I'm at work on right now.
ANNE: Have you done the short form before?
KENT: I never have. I'm finding it an interesting exercise, really. Very creative, interesting exercise.
ANNE: So for readers who don't know, how would you describe what a novelette is?
KENT: It's much longer than a short story, much shorter than a novel. So these are running about 125 pages apiece.
ANNE: Are they independent or characters that we may know?
[00:50:54] KENT: No, they're completely independent, very different timeframes. One takes place during the massive flooding of the Mississippi River that took place in 1928 and 1929. It's the story of some convicts who are impressed into labor helping save some people who are trapped by the flood. And the second novel takes place in 1980. It's the story of a man and his wife traveling across the country, retracing their honeymoon at the very end of their lives together. A very poignant story.
ANNE: Oh, Kent, I never asked you about your audiobook. The first time I read This Tender Land, I read it on audio. Scott Brick was wonderful, and I heard-
KENT: Oh, good.
ANNE: ...that you had a good amount of input into... That you felt strongly about how the book would sound to listeners, which we are grateful for.
[00:51:45] KENT: Yeah. And for the very first time, I had a hand in helping select the reader for this. We had three essentially auditions, and both my agent and I liked Scott Brick the best. And I think he's just done an outstanding job with the reading of This Tender Land.
ANNE: Did your publisher ask you this time, or did you stand up and say, "Let me into that process"? I'm just interested in what it was about this story that made that change.
KENT: Well, I know what I asked of my audio publisher was I want a different voice for this than we used for Cork O'Connor, and I think I'd like even a different voice than we used for Ordinary Grace, because I don't want any of them to sound like the others. They all need to stand alone. And my audio publisher said, "Fine, so let's take a look at what our options might be." And I just really appreciated being brought in on that process. You know, really the writer is kind of the lowest guy on the totem pole in most of the publishing process.
[00:52:50] ANNE: Well, I'm glad that you're pleased with the results, because many of us certainly were as well. Kent, this has been a pleasure. Thank you so much for taking the time to discuss your work with us.
KENT: Well, I have had a delightful morning with you. Thank you so much, Anne, for the invitation.
ANNE: We hope that we can hear from you again, and we really hope that we can catch you in person sometime. A favorite bookstore in your area?
KENT: Every mystery writer in my area who launches a novel launches it at a marvelous independent mystery bookstore called Once Upon a Crime in Minneapolis. So a shout-out to Once Upon a Crime.
ANNE: That many of us know from afar, if not in person. Well, I hope I get to see it myself and you one day. Thank you again.
KENT: I hope so too.
[00:53:39] ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed listening in on our conversation with William Kent Krueger. Find the full list of titles we talked about at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com. And if you'd like more conversations like you heard today, even to join us live and ask the authors questions yourself, come and join us at modernmrsdarcy.com/club.
Make sure you're following along in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, or your favorite podcast player. We are there ready for you to sign up and download new episodes. And that helps us so much, so thank you in advance for doing that. It's free, it's easy, it is genuinely so helpful.
Sign up for our email list for regular updates on what's new around What Should I Read Next HQ. That's at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
Follow our show on Instagram @whatshouldireadnext. I have promised my team I will get on there this fall and talk about Fall Book Preview, so follow us there at @whatshouldireadnext.
And keep up with the Modern Mrs. Darcy Book Club at @mmdbookclub. Ginger runs that account. It's a lot of fun. You're going to enjoy it.
[00:54:42] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Thank you to our book club community manager, Ginger Horton, for bringing this particular episode together this week and for hosting the initial conversation with me.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• The Cork O’Connor series by William Kent Krueger (#1: Iron Lake)
• Ordinary Grace by William Kent Krueger (Audio edition)
• This Tender Land by William Kent Krueger (Audio edition)
• Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain
• The Odyssey by Homer, translated by Emily Wilson
• Elmer Gantry by Sinclair Lewis
• Lightning Strike by William Kent Krueger
• Aimee Semple McPherson
• Minnesota History Center
• The Tender Land by Aaron Copland
• Red Wing Boots
• Once Upon a Crime
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Writing stories of hope, and a timely Odyssey discussion appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
Readers, today Shannan Malone, our Patreon Community Manager, is joining me for a third year as we dive into our reading lives for a midyear check-in.
This is a conversation that I and many of you have come to look forward to every year, and now I can barely believe this is only year three, because it feels like I’ve been reflecting for this episode and planning for this episode for a long time. I’m so excited about what Shannan is bringing to share today. You’ll also hear about what’s been happening so far in my reading life and where recalibration or adjustment may be called for as we head into the second half of 2026.
We’d love to hear your midyear reflections: please leave a comment to share an answer to any of the questions Shannan and I discuss today.
Our Patreon community features more conversations with our team as well as bonus episodes from me. We rely on our Patreon community members to keep everything running: their financial support is a critical part of how we create our episodes and pay our team. A huge thank you to everyone who is already a paid supporter: if you’re interested in more conversations like today’s or want to be part of making What Should I Read Next? happen each week, we would love it if you’d consider joining us as a monthly or annual member on Patreon. Find out more at patreon.com/whatshouldireadnext.
[00:00:00] SHANNAN MALONE: Okay. You've thrown a spanner into the works, so listeners, I take all that back. Maybe I'll keep it.
ANNE BOGEL: No, no, no, no, no. Don't take it back. Don't take it back. I'm not the boss of you, but don't take it back, Shannan.
Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading and today, we are having a wide-ranging conversation with our team member, Shannan Malone, for a fun and informal mid-year reading check-in.
[00:00:51] Readers, Shannan serves as our Patreon community manager. Something I love about that space is that's where we get to feature more conversations with our team and dig further into topics that we talk about here on the podcast. In Patreon, every Friday we share a bonus episode. Many of these come from me directly, like our Industry Insights episodes or our Mini Matchmaking ongoing series. That's where I do speed recommendations in response to regular requests from our Patreon community members asking what they should read next.
Many of our Friday bonuses also come from our team, either individually or as a large or small group. We rely on our Patreon community members to keep everything running here at What Should I Read Next HQ. Their financial support is a critical part of how we create our episodes and pay our team.
A huge thank you from me and our team for everyone who is already a paid supporter. And if you're interested in more conversations like today's or want to be part of making What Should I Read Next? happen each week, we would love it if you consider joining us as a monthly or annual member over on Patreon. Find out more at patreon.com/whatshouldireadnext.
[00:01:59] Now for today's episode, readers, this is the third year that Shannan is joining me here to dive into our reading lives for a mid-year check-in. Something we do around here often is embark on a little experiment that feels like so much fun to me and our team, and also to you, that it comes to be a little tradition.
And this is one of those. This is a conversation that I and many of you have come to look forward to every year, and now I can barely believe this is only year three, because it feels like I've been reflecting for this episode and planning for this episode and getting to talk to you here, Shannan, for a long time. So I'm so excited about what Shannan is bringing to share today.
And you'll also hear about what's been happening so far in my reading life and where recalibration or adjustment may be called for as we head into the second half of 2026. This is going to be fun. Let's get to it
Shannan, thanks so much for joining me on Tuesday edition, What Should I Read Next?
[00:03:00] SHANNAN: Thank you for having me again.
ANNE: Oh, I really enjoy doing this every year. And something that I find really beneficial, and listeners, I hope you have some version of this in your own life, even if it's just reflecting in a journal or on a walk, is that you reflect back to me what I've said I wanted in my reading life. Somehow it sounds different to me when I'm listening to you tell me what you heard versus me just trying to remember what I said or listening to an old episode or seeing what I put in my reading journal. So this is great for me. Thank you so much.
SHANNAN: It's great for me. It keeps me accountable, external accountability. I'm an obliger from Gretchen Rubin's personality thing, so if I'm reporting to somebody else, I'm probably going to do it.
ANNE: Mm-hmm. And we joke around here. I wrote a book by this title, We'd Rather Be Reading. But also, I love talking about what I'm reading. I love thinking about my reading life. I love talking with other readers about those same things.
[00:04:03] First, it's just enjoyable and interesting to me. But also, I have seen how I get more out of my reading life, and I make wiser and more informed choices. And if that sounds really boring, reflection on fun and satisfaction begets more fun and satisfaction. So, really, the goal of this episode is to reflect upon and then take away what we need to know about how 2026 has gone so far so that we can thoroughly enjoy the rest of our reading year.
SHANNAN: I must admit that I probably enjoy the reflecting and the planning more than the actual doing.
ANNE: Luckily, that is part of being a reader. So you can have both experiences. And if one works better than the other, well, I'm glad that both are available to you.
Okay, so here's what we are going to do today. We are going to look back on our reading intentions that we shared in a Patreon bonus back in January.
SHANNAN: Yes, January, and we'll link it in the show notes for-
ANNE: Great.
SHANNAN: ...our Patreon members obviously. And if you're not a member of Patreon, as Anne has said, feel free to join us over there. We have a lot of fun.
[00:05:14] ANNE: And then you joked to me that you're going to turn this into your own personal bibliotherapy session.
SHANNAN: I am.
ANNE: So we're going to explore some of your... I mean, you tell me, what are we going to explore there? Give us a little preview.
SHANNAN: I am going to talk about an intention I made, and then what happened when I made that intention. Well, what happened after I made that intention, and where that went, and now I'm in a... I have a conundrum, so I'm going to bring it to you.
ANNE: Okay. We're going to address a readerly conundrum.
SHANNAN: Yes
ANNE: We're going to discuss what we want for the rest of the year. We're going to talk about what's working and what's not. Maybe we could take a little snapshot of where we are midsummer 2026. And then we're going to talk about what we want more of of the rest of the year, and we're going to close with a... I think other podcasts might call this a lightning round.
SHANNAN: Yes.
[00:06:10] ANNE: I don't know that we've ever been especially speedy at answering these questions. But we're going to rattle through some what's working, what's not, most anticipated, biggest disappointment, favorites, that kind of thing.
Well, I'm excited to do this. Let's begin. Do you want to go first?
SHANNAN: Sure.
ANNE: Okay. Tell us about your January 2026 intentions for the year.
SHANNAN: So I had this grandiose idea. I always have grandiose plans.
ANNE: Uh-oh.
SHANNAN: You should always know this. I said earlier, I love planning. I love reflecting and coming up with things, and then life has a way of hitting me straight in the face. I don't know if anyone's watching the soccer on television, but I heard a quote, I believe it was Mike Tyson, sorry to be quoting Mike Tyson. But he said, "Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face." And I'm like, yes. So that's where I am.
[00:07:12] I had this really good intention of aligning my reading with my real life, so I wanted to read books and consume media about being courageous and strong, physically, emotionally, and mentally. And I call this my Personal Curriculum Project. But life has hit me in the face, and I think I have moved more to what you said during that bonus episode that we talked about earlier. And I wrote it down. You said, "Act from the gut with a little Post-It Note plan."
ANNE: I think readers might appreciate some context on that. I mean, I know what you're talking about.
SHANNAN: Well, I took it to mean, and that's what I'll say. I took it to mean, like, okay, Shannan, you have plans, great. I am going to go a little bit more intuitively with a general idea of what I want to do. And so that's where I've wound up. My pseudo personal curriculum about strong and courageous physically, mentally, and emotionally, that fell off, but I did end up doing a pseudo personal curriculum around poetry, and I have read a lot more poems this year and listened to podcasts about poetry.
[00:08:36] And that has really, really worked for me. I've enjoyed it. I've read more poetry than I ever have. I still feel like I've done a pseudo-personal curriculum, just not the one I was intending on doing.
I did not have a reading goal this year. That was great. It's the first year I've never had a reading goal in terms of numbers, I mean. I have read 13 books, which is kind of in line with what I normally do, which is kind of surprising that without a goal intention, I'm still kind of following my usual trend.
I would say that I would love to have a five-star fiction read, but I don't have one yet, and that's a little disturbing to me. I think I'll hold the next observation for after you discuss your intentions.
[00:09:32] ANNE: Okay. Well, as you captured, I shared that my intentions apparently were not reading-related, I think because I had so few reading-related intentions. Like I told you, that I was going to change Daisy's bandana every single day. Y'all, our 10-year-old lab is such a sweetie, and she gets so excited about mealtime, obviously, going outside, because she's a dog. I mean, I know not every single dog does this, but I know many dog owners know exactly what I'm talking about. And also, when she gets a new bandana, she is so, so happy.
So this was my resolu… I never make resolutions, but I made one: every day, I'm going to change the bandana, and I have. This has been a winner. Like, small success, happy dog, happy family. We all go, "Oh, Daisy. You're wearing my school color. You're wearing my favorite color. You're dressed for, I don't know, Fourth of July." It's great. Also, apparently, I told you I wanted to vacuum less, because I was going to brush my dog more.
SHANNAN: Yes. I believe you did say that.
ANNE: Yeah, yeah.
SHANNAN: How's that coming?
[00:10:32] ANNE: I mean, okay, so my 16-year-old realized there was a setting on the vacuum that I didn't know existed, so I'm vacuuming less because apparently I've been vacuuming on low this whole time, and vacuuming on low is not good for the dog hair. It's a Dyson stick vacuum, y'all. Make sure you know how to turn it to high, and all of a sudden, it zips up the dog hair. It's amazing.
SHANNAN: Good.
ANNE: So maybe more satisfaction from less vacuuming.
SHANNAN: Oh, nice.
ANNE: I'm killing it, you know? Thank you, teenager. But with books, which is probably why you all are tuned in, I wanted to make space to welcome the unexpected, and weird, and strange into my reading life. And the making space has to do with the obligations I have created for myself, and we've created for me as a team in a little readerly business with things we do for Summer Reading Guide, and fall and Spring Book Previews, and various projects.
[00:11:31] At Austin in August every year, I know I'll be reading the Pride and Prejudice Annotated Edition. I do have a fair amount of reading that I'm committed to. And I wanted to be really thoughtful about how I approach all my reading. I was interested in exploring what I'm finding especially satisfying and fruitful in my reading life, and to make sure that as best as I was able, I'm making decisions that align with that. Like even when I'm choosing... Not even, I mean, always when I'm choosing Summer Reading Guide and Fall Book Preview books, like what I even want to vet, I'm thinking about what would you all find surprising and unexpected and unusual, but be really glad you found. But I have to read a lot of books to find the ones that I think are worth talking about.
Also, this isn't captured in that unexpected and weird intention, but I am very aware of the space that I carve out in my reading life for not just the unexpected and weird, but maybe like classic and just unexplored or off the beaten path that came out in 1982. I just wanted space to explore... This is a long-winded way of saying backlist. I'm always looking for a way to carve out lots of time for backlist.
[00:12:54] SHANNAN: Hey, how is it going?
ANNE: You know, it's going okay. It's going okay. I read fewer books this year. Part of that is just how I'm spending my reading time. Actually, part of that is I'm looking directly at Jane Smiley's Thirteen Ways of Looking at the Novel, which maybe isn't unexpected and weird. But I bought this book after speaking with Julie Berry on the podcast. She mentioned it, and I thought, "That sounds amazing."
And I do not even remember at this point, Shannan, what I expected from this book. But lots of people are surprised to find out I was not an English major. I didn't take English courses after my freshman year of college. I haven't critically analyzed anything in a classroom since the '90s. And this book and the way she talks about the evolution of a novel, and what is it even, and what does it mean, and what's the French novel versus the English novel, and how did the Russians contribute and, you know? You know, you may not know. On and on and on in that vein. I felt like this is the literature class I never had. But this book was 600 pages, half theory, half book by book, going through 100 novels.
SHANNAN: Wow.
[00:14:10] ANNE: I felt like this was the literature seminar that I didn't take as a college student, but I am ready for now. It was a slow read, and I did a lot... I mean, I'm a fast reader, but I don't read a book like this at the same speed I read like Lucy Foley. Probably takes me four times as long per page.
But I made this my morning reading, and I spent like four months with this book and I thoroughly enjoyed it. But that was very much in line with my intentions. Like, I wanted to be deliberate and not feel rushed and make time for the things that are important to me.
And I hope the things I'm learning filter through me and end up coming out in my work and make everything feel richer and better anchored and stronger. And I got all kinds of ideas for further exploration of a whole bunch of backlist for what to read next but, of course, I'm thinking about what I learned as I'm reading this fall's crop of forthcoming novels.
[00:15:12] SHANNAN: Sounds like you did a little personal curriculum of your own there.
ANNE: Yes. English nerd. And then I've picked up some books on my travels and accumulated some backlist titles of interest. And I've tried to be really thoughtful about how and when I make sure I'm taking the time to go back and look at those old ones.
I'm also trying to be thoughtful about how I approach the rhythms of my reading. Right now it's for our Fall Book Preview. Like, how can I make the most of my precious reading time for my own sake, and also, I hope, for your sakes. So we just got back from the beach, where I read... It's been a while since I read a book a day, and I didn't quite do it. But I spent two days on the new 512-page Chloe Benjamin. But other than that, I read a book a day.
SHANNAN: What?
[00:16:08] ANNE: I enjoyed it so much. Only one of those was backlist, and I thought it was going to be a dry read, and I loved it. I just zipped through it. I know you want to know. That was Prague Spring by Simon Mawer, which I picked up on my travels at the recommendation of Melissa Joulwan from Strong Sense of Place. She told me it was great, and I said, "Okay, enough said." Oh, but I loved it. And it made me wish I'd brought more backlist on that trip, but it worked out okay.
And unexpected and weird, like just picking stuff up on my travels. Y'all, I don't travel all the time, but I think I've said "on my travels" several times. Like when I'm visiting my college kid and we go to the bookstore, I really enjoy just browsing the shelves of a store that I'm not familiar with and just seeing what strikes me, what looks good. And I came home with a couple books that way that I've been looking forward to. I've only read one of like the three I bought on that college visit in the fall, but I'm making my way through there.
[00:17:05] And just recently, Will and I were in Grand Rapids, and I picked up this book on the table at Books & Mortar. I picked it up, I said, "That looks really interesting. I've heard good things about this author. I bought their previous book several years ago and haven't read it yet." And then I put it back down. And Will's like, "Aren't you going to buy it?" I said, "Didn't you hear me? No, I'm not reading these things."
But it was The Fifth Year by Marlen Haushofer, a German author. The publisher's New Directions. I keep an eye on what they're doing. They have interesting stuff from around the world, often in translation. But it sounded interesting. It's 100 pages, a little novella. And Will's like, "Isn't that like the off-the-beaten-path kind of unique, weird reading experience you said you wanted?" And I said, "Okay, fine." So I brought it home with me. I'll be reading that soon. So I'm making room for that book, and books like that, in my home right now. And you know, they're hanging out on my, like, "Oh, think of all the things I could read right now if I wanted to," after I finish the forthcoming RF Kuang.
SHANNAN: Ooh.
ANNE: Ooh. I thought you might be interested in that.
[00:18:10] SHANNAN: You talked about making space, and my therapist has been working with me on the subject of capacity. Apparently, I don't have as much as I think I should have. And she has been working with me very steadily for the past two or three months about it. And one of the things I read was that if something isn't adding up in your life, you should start subtracting.
And the way I like to do that is removing physical things. So one of the things that I did was curate my bookshelf, and I kept five-star reads, and I have a few sentimental books that maybe weren't five-star reading experiences, but I still loved anyway. I love looking at my bookshelf now. It's so joy-inspiring. It sparks joy. Yes. What am I trying to do? Just quote Marie Kondo. It sparks joy, and I love it. And over 65 books have been released back into the world, and I couldn't be happier about it.
[00:19:20] Now, Anne, can we now go to where I turn this session into being all about me and get your opinion on some books that I have that you have discussed in the podcast, in book club, and in various spaces, and I'm not sure if I should read it or not. So kind of like a Dear Book Therapist session.
ANNE: Yes. Let's do it. Okay. Okay. We can say that it's going to help my purposes for this question of "should they stay or should they go?" But also just out of nerdy curiosity, what are some of those five-star reads that are now smiling back at you from your bookshelf?
SHANNAN: Oh. Well, I mean, so many. Of course, you guys can't see me, but I'm literally turning myself so that I can see my bookshelf. Pretty much anything by Alix E. Harrow is here. I think I own a copy, physical hardcover copy of everything she's written in book form. And I cannot wait to read The Slantwise Histories, her short story collection that is coming out shortly.
[00:20:35] Then of course, we have Becky Chambers' A Song for the Wild-Built. I have a bunch of memoir that I absolutely love, Elizabeth Gilbert's All the Way to the River, Mary Laura Philpott's two, Bomb Shelter and... oh, man, I can't see the title of the other one. It is slipping my mind.
ANNE: I Miss You When I Blink.
SHANNAN: Thank you. I have my paperback backlist novels that I love: My Oxford Year, Charlie Lovett's The Bookman's Tale. I have books about writing, which prompts me to one of the books that I need to ask you about. And I have my TBR shelf, which I have curated. And so that brings me back to some that are on my TBR shelf, and I'm like, "Do these still need to be here?"
ANNE: All right. Do you want to tell me about what they are?
[00:21:30] SHANNAN: Yes. My first one that I wanted to talk about, since I already mentioned my writing books, is On Writing Well by William Zinsser. I've read a lot of writing books, and I struggle to keep all the information in my head from the ones that I do read. Bird by Bird is my absolute favorite. Anne Lamott released another one with her husband that I am currently enjoying. And I'm wondering, "Do I need to read On Writing Well? Is this one that you think I should keep? Is it on the pantheon of writing books? What's your opinion on that?"
ANNE: I mean, gosh, I read this a long time ago.
SHANNAN: Okay.
ANNE: What I'm interested in knowing for this and all your books is what are you hoping to get out of the book?
SHANNAN: Okay.
[00:22:27] ANNE: Like, why read it, and why read it now? And I think only then can we talk about if you need to. I mean, need? The answer to "need" is, absolutely not. This is a modern classic on writing nonfiction. So, practical, helpful, fun to read if you're interested in such things or a grammar geek. Are you looking for insight into reading, into writing? Are these tips you want to put into practice? How did it end up on your list? You don't have to answer all those questions, but these are the things I'm wondering.
SHANNAN: I think it was on the list of books to read if you want to be a writer. Again, I'm going back to my newish intention given to me by my therapist in terms of capacity. If it's one that you're like, "Yes, Shannan, I learned a lot from that book. I still remember it. You definitely need to read it," then I would say, okay, I should. But if it's not, then I think that what I'm wanting to do is have room to implement the ones that I have read and the things that I did learn from those books and not, you know, put more on my plate. So that's kinda like what I'm asking.
[00:23:49] So I kind of got that answer from what you said, so I think I might release this one back into the world.
ANNE: Okay. Okay, counterpoint. As I recall, it's very actionable. And I wonder if it would be interesting for you to experiment with reading a chunk as you're sitting down to write something because I believe much of what you write is, like personal essay, narrative, a little bit of technical writing where you're explaining things. And I wonder if connecting the... I don't really like digestive words. Ingest is a little like, ugh. Okay.
But I wonder if taking that into your brain and then seeing if there's anything that you could find helpful right away could, I mean, at least give you the information you need to tell you like, "Am I going to find this useful?" Not that there's not things that you couldn't reflect upon further, but some of what he says is like, you know, when you're writing a sentence, think about how you're loading the verbs in the sentence and in the reader's mind. Like, do you find that kind of stuff helpful? Are you like, "You know what? I've read a lot of writing books, and I don't need to hear more from Zinsser"?
[00:25:03] SHANNAN: Okay. Well, you've thrown a spanner into the works, so listeners, I take all that back. Maybe I'll keep it.
ANNE: No, no, no, no, no. Don't take it back. Don't take it back. I'm not the boss of you, but don't take it back, Shannan. Okay.
SHANNAN: All right. My next three books are fiction. The first is Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin. Now, I have heard that people love this book, and I've heard other people who have been like, "Ugh." Now, I have to say, it's here because I adored A.J. Fikry. I've read it three times. It's on my favorites shelf. I love it so much.
But I have to say, I have started Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow many times — Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow — and I have always been distracted and I haven't been able to get into it. I can't tell you why. Maybe the subject matter is not appealing to me. I've probably gotten 20% in, and something has always come up. And you know I like a good ending in a book, a satisfying ending. Should I keep this one?
[00:26:22] ANNE: Okay. What I wonder is how this book fits into what you've said about capacity.
SHANNAN: Okay.
ANNE: Is there an option here where we can take a hefty, emotional, 500-page, epic might not be going too far and put it on a little shelf that says, "For an era with a different kind of capacity"? It has a lot of elements that I think you would really enjoy.
SHANNAN: Okay. But maybe not in this space of right now. Because you just said the words there that made me say, "Hmm. Yeah, no, not right now." Epic, 500 pages. Hmm. Okay, thank you. I think I might release this one back into the world, and then get it when I am in a space for that.
[00:27:21] All right, my next one is a shorter, not 500-page epic. Heart the Lover by Lily King. Now, I loved Writers & Lovers, and I think I loved it because of the ending. The ending was worth everything I went through in the first part of the book. It was so satisfying. I appreciated it so much.
Now, I have good friends who loved Heart the Lover. Like, it's on their best book of the year consideration. I have started it once, and it feels very slow-paced for me right now. And I'm wondering, in your opinion, is the ending worth it?
ANNE: I hear your question, and I'm not going to answer it.
SHANNAN: Oh.
ANNE: I mean, to me, I thought so. These books have so much in common.
SHANNAN: Really?
ANNE: Yes.
SHANNAN: Oh.
ANNE: They feel like mirrors.
SHANNAN: Interesting.
[00:28:23] ANNE: Which is funny. So Heart the Lover takes place both before and after Writers & Lovers. So you get the backstory to what happens in Writers & Lovers, and also the what came after. But Writers & Lovers is about the protagonist, Casey, assembling a life. And it ends with like, no spoilers I don't believe, but like fireworks, and triumph, and fanfare. Lily King said, if the book hadn't come out on March 3rd, 2020, she thought she was going to get brutalized in critical reviews for it being happy, because literary fiction doesn't end happy. But she thinks that the book was perfectly timed because who didn't want something that wasn't bleak for a book that released on March 3rd, 2020?
SHANNAN: That is so interesting.
[00:29:22] ANNE: Heart the Lover is set into motion by an untimely imminent death. And the protagonist is going through... as this long-lost loved one is desperately ill, is going through this swim in all the complicated and untold and unspoken experiences and emotions of what happened between them back then. It's a very different emotional energy than a young writer struggling to make her way. I mean, there's no a cappella boys singing in the restaurant in Heart the Lover, you know, and other moments of levity. It's sad.
So is the ending worth it? I think so. But is that the right question? I don't know that that's the question for you. I don't know that that's the pond you want to swim in.
SHANNAN: I think that in this time, no. And I think I'm probably one of those people that Lily King was not talking about. I love my literary fiction to end happily. I know that's not traditionally what happens, but I love it when it does. And so I'm glad it happened, and I'm glad everyone got the response, or, you know, that it came out in March when it did, 2020, because it was perfect for me. But now this is on a different vein. I'm thinking this probably not for me right now because I do kinda struggle with the genre sometimes.
[00:31:03] ANNE: And I'm not saying it's unhappy, and I found it really satisfying, but the whole book takes place in a different emotional register. I mean, there's grief in Writers & Lovers. She's grieving the death of her mom, but also it's a different kind of loss, and she's grieving that loss in a different way than what's happening in Heart the Lover.
SHANNAN: I think my decision will be to hang on to this one because it is a little bit shorter, not the epic 500-plus pages, and see if I can get back to that space where I can read that one. Okay. And my final book, and I'm a little disappointed, but I think you hinted to this one, it was from last year's Summer Reading Guide. It was my pick, The Phoenix Pencil Company by Allison King.
[00:31:51] I remember I said, "I think I want to read The Phoenix Pencil Company by Allison King," and you hesitated, and I got a sense that you were like, "Hmm, I don't know if you'll like that, Shannan." And I have tried to read this twice, and I always put it aside for something else. Again, I think all of my questions are... You know, I said on my inaugural episode, I don't mind endings. I don't mind spoiler endings, I actually almost prefer them, but I kind of need to know that right now, a satisfying ending is more on a joyous, happier side of things. And so I can persevere if I know I'm going to kind of get that from The Phoenix Pencil Company. One, I'm curious why you were like, "Hmm, I'm not sure if you'd like that," and I'm beginning to think you were right, and I want to know why.
[00:32:51] ANNE: Well, that was a different conversation and a different time and place.
SHANNAN: Okay.
ANNE: I mean, I think it was about tone and where the history and meaning of The Pencil Magic lay. But I will say, it is so much like two books I think you really enjoyed. I mean, you enjoyed Babel by R.F. Kuang, right?
SHANNAN: Yes, I did.
ANNE: Okay. This one feels a little less deeply rooted in the meaning of where the... These pencils are magical in this book. They are used to capture and then extract people's memories and histories. Is that fair? I'm asking you this. I know you haven't finished it.
SHANNAN: Yes, yes.
ANNE: But you've read that much.
SHANNAN: Yes, I did read that much.
ANNE: And also it's got some major Ten Thousand Doors of January crossover with Alix E. Harrow.
SHANNAN: Which I loved.
ANNE: And also it's a book about painful family histories, and war, and betrayal. And I think it was those factors that caused my hesitation.
[00:33:54] SHANNAN: Yeah. As you said, painful family histories and war. I'm like, "Ugh." Everything you told me.
ANNE: Maybe that one can go on the capacity shelf, because it has a lot to recommend itself to you based on what you've enjoyed in the past.
SHANNAN: Yeah, I think so.
ANNE: And also what you just said.
SHANNAN: Okay. All right. Well, thank you for your assistance, Anne.
ANNE: Okay. Well, we're just throwing everything out the window. You got anything else you want to get rid of? Table for now?
SHANNAN: Readers, thanks for indulging.
ANNE: Not out the window. We're rearranging. Reshelving.
SHANNAN: Yes. Yes. Thanks for indulging me, readers. I hope you got something from that, because that is very, very helpful. I always appreciate your insight, Anne. You're so good at what you do.
ANNE: Oh. I love to hear what people are up to in their reading lives, what conundrums they're facing. So thanks for inviting me in.
SHANNAN: Shall we get to our mid-year questions?
ANNE: Yes, let's do it.
SHANNAN: Okay.
[00:34:51] ANNE: I was about to say I'm ready, but you know I'm not. I want to give you like 47 titles for the answer to every question.
SHANNAN: Right. Remember, we're going to try to do this as a lightning round. And readers, on last week's bonus episode, Holly and Brigid answered these questions, and I answer some of them as the host of that episode. It will be interesting to note that we recorded that two weeks ago, and some of my answers have changed since that recording. So there you go.
ANNE: That's so exciting. Oh, I can't wait to hear.
SHANNAN: All right. Best book you've read so far this year, Anne?
ANNE: Oh, okay. Please note that many of the Summer Reading Guide books I read in 2025, going on recency bias, one of the many Irish ones coming out this fall that I just read at the beach for Fall Book Preview was good. But also, I reviewed my reading journal, of course, in preparation for this episode, and I would like to tell you about my first week of the reading year. January 3rd through January 7th, I read The Great Wherever, The Camino, two old books by Anne Tyler, The Beginner's Goodbye and A Spool of Blue Thread, and Maggie O'Farrell's Land.
SHANNAN: Wow.
[00:36:05] ANNE: In one week, that's definitely my best reading week of the year.
SHANNAN: Yeah, you were killing it with that one.
ANNE: I really was. How about you?
SHANNAN: This has changed from the answer that I gave on the bonus episode. The Tapestry of Fate by Shannon Chakraborty. It is the second book in the Amina Al Sirafi series, but I can't stop thinking about it. It was four and a half when I finished, and it's probably going to work its way up to a five-star. I know I said I hadn't read a five-star. It's not quite there yet. If I keep thinking about it through the month of July, it'll firmly be a five-star. But that's my best one in fiction land.
And then in nonfiction, I finally finished I Will Teach You to Be Rich by Ramit Sethi. I was working my way slowly through that because I was incorporating all the steps. It's six weeks to a better financial future. Took me a year, but it's okay. I finished it. I got it done. It is my best nonfiction.
ANNE: All right.
[00:37:10] SHANNAN: Next, best sequel you've read so far, Anne?
ANNE: Ooh, I don't think I've read much in the way of sequels, but I reread, on audio, The Happy Ever After Playlist by Abby Jimenez because I wanted to do a One Great Audiobook episode on it.
SHANNAN: Ooh.
ANNE: So maybe that old book is my best sequel I've read so far, but I'm wondering if The Tapestry of Fate is going to make my list very soon because I was waiting till after the Summer Reading Guide to listen to the audio. I loved the first one on audio, and so I have it downloaded already, and I will be starting it before too long.
SHANNAN: Someone pointed out that it is kind of slow through the middle. And it is. It really is. But you keep going, it all comes together, and it is obviously my best sequel of the year so far.
[00:38:00] New release you haven't read but want to. And I'm going to cheat by saying Ransom by Daniel Silva. I think it releases the week we release this episode, so it would have released this week. It's the 24th book in the Gabriel Allon series. And I love that series and enjoy it very much. What about you?
ANNE: I'm going to say, actually, another series installment, Cool Machine, which will end Colson Whitehead's Harlem trilogy.
SHANNAN: Okay. Why am I just now discovering that was a trilogy?
ANNE: Well, they just come out one at a time.
SHANNAN: Oh, wow. Okay. Learn something new every day. Most anticipated release for the second half of the year. And I already mentioned mine, which was The Slantwise Histories: Collected Stories by Alix E. Harrow. And on the bonus, I mentioned The Paradox Club by Charlie Lovett.
[00:39:04] ANNE: I'm looking forward to both those as well and haven't read them yet. Okay, I'm going to say a book I haven't read yet, the new book from the author of A Ghost in the Throat, who is Irish and whose last name I am not even going to try. But I loved and adored A Ghost in the Throat.
SHANNAN: Me too.
ANNE: That was such an amazing surprise. And I was so excited to find out that she had a new one on the way, and it's supposed to be really interesting, genre-bending. I'm looking forward to it.
SHANNAN: Biggest disappointment. And Anne, I just saw your notes on that one, and I'm like, "Oh, no." So go ahead and tell us.
ANNE: Okay. Well, I don't think you're "oh, no-ing" would be by Kira Madden.
SHANNAN: I am not.
[00:39:56] ANNE: And the disappointment isn't just about the book, but I didn't think it was for me. I think I'm disappointed in myself. The book isn't what I wanted it to be, and I think I recognized that pretty quickly, that like, I don't think this is a good idea. But readers keep telling me, "But no, it's so good." And I get in trouble when I... I mean, I don't do it very often, but I kept picking it up, and I kept trying, and I should not have done that.
SHANNAN: Okay.
ANNE: Okay. I think the thing you're grimacing about is I said also maybe Priya Parker.
SHANNAN: Oh, no. Yes, I am grimacing about that.
ANNE: I adore The Art of Gathering. I've read it multiple times. I was really looking forward to... I mean, I'm still looking forward to. I'm looking forward to talking about it with people. The Art of Fighting, her book coming out in September, and I'll be talking about this more in the Fall Book Preview. So much of The Art of Fighting was so good, and some of it was really funny and refreshing. I read some passages that were examples out loud to my kids as I was reading, because I was like, "Guys, listen to this," because it was just cracking me up.
[00:41:03] But I was disappointed in the inclusion of some examples that I thought substantially weakened the argument. But not just that, but the book... And it was so close to great, but like thinking of some of the examples now, like I'm just... Could've been better. Subtract, as you were talking about with your theme for this year. Subtraction can make things stronger.
SHANNAN: It can.
ANNE: Okay. Moving on. Biggest surprise.
SHANNAN: I'm going to say Against Breaking on the Power of Poetry to represent all the poems that I have been reading and enjoying. I never considered myself a lover of poetry or even a reader of poetry other than, you know, a few things. And there's so many poems that I read that I can't even name, but I did pick up Against Breaking, and I absolutely adored the concept and what she's saying in the book. And so I'm throwing that out as the representative of all of the poetry that I've read this year, which has been a big surprise to me.
[00:42:14] ANNE: I'm surprised, and I love that for you. My biggest surprises are books that I either didn't enjoy in the past and came back to and was like, "What was I thinking? This is amazing." Or looked at the cover and went, "I'm not reading that," and then got talked into it. Okay, so what these books actually are, I started Kayla Ray Whitaker's debut, The Animators, when it came out back in 2018. I made it through maybe 30%, and I didn't like it, and I quit.
But a book in the Summer Reading Guide is her new May release, Returns and Exchanges, which I loved. And so I went back to The Animators, wondering what 2026 Anne would think about this book. I mean, I don't know. This time, I couldn't identify where I stalled out. I listened to the audio. I read the print last time. Maybe that was the difference. But this time it caught, and I enjoyed it so much. Actually, you'll be hearing me talk about this more soon because I recommend it to a Kentucky guest later this month.
[00:43:18] And then the book, Finding Grace, came to me in the mail. I do not remember how it arrived. First I got the advance review copy, and then I got the hardcover, and both times I went, "I dislike that cover, and I don't want to read that book, and I don't even care what it's about. I don't want to look at it." Mm. But then Ginger read it, and she was like, "Have you read Finding Grace? It's amazing. Oh my gosh, this is all I want to be reading right now." And I listened to the audio. I don't think I even found my hardcover, but I started listening to the audio and just was so hooked. I enjoyed it so much. So yeah, I saw neither coming, but I really, thoroughly enjoyed them.
SHANNAN: That's making me rethink some of the books that I'm like, "I think I'll let them go," and then you're like, "Oh, 2018 Anne and 2026 Anne are different. Like, should I hang on to everything?" Listeners, let me know in the comments section."
[00:44:17] Next, favorite new author, debut or new-to-you. And I do not have one. In that vein of sticking with what I know and what I know I'm getting into, I pretty much read the back list or front list of authors that I know and love this year, and it's worked, so I'm happy about that. But what about you?
ANNE: Ooh, okay. I met a few authors this year that I want to read all their work or that I will wait patiently or impatiently for them to write more. Shannan Sanders, who wrote The Great Wherever, I loved her debut. I can't wait for more. First, we're talking about her... no, we're talking with her about her book in book club in August.
Nayantara Roy, who wrote actually, again, our July book club selection, Sisters of a Halved Heart. Loved that sophomore novel. Just went back and listened to her debut, The Magnificent Ruins. Can't wait for her to write more. I just read Prague Spring at the beach, that book that my friend Mel recommended to me. It's by Simon Mawer. He was shortlisted for the Booker for The Glass Room. He wrote serious literary fiction for a while. The Glass Room is his most famous, but I had seen his name around, but I didn't have any idea what he wrote about. But I love Prague Spring and would be very interested in reading more by him.
[00:45:33] SHANNAN: And finally, going to end with books that made you, or book, I should say, book that made you happy.
ANNE: Ooh, okay. So, at the beach, I had a little Christmas in July situation and I read the forthcoming Ally Carter called It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Murder, which I will absolutely be talking about at Fall Book Preview. I started reading it a couple times earlier in the week and ended up going for more serious literary fiction. But when I picked it up, it was the right book at the right time. Not years later, just like four days. And I enjoyed it so much. And also didn't mind the contrast between the Florida heat and the Colorado snowed-in mountains.
SHANNAN: Interesting.
ANNE: It was a delight.
SHANNAN: I think I'm going to go with a mystery thriller, The Fine Art of Lying by Alexandra Andrews. I have read quite a few mystery thrillers this year. I think I love the knowing that it's going to end kind of cleanly, about those. And that one, it was fun. Propulsive and fun. Made me happy.
[00:46:44] ANNE: Sometimes that's exactly what I want.
SHANNAN: I know.
ANNE: Propulsive, fun.
SHANNAN: Yeah.
ANNE: Meaty, but not I have to read this at four times slower than my normal speed.
SHANNAN: Mm. Yeah.
ANNE: Okay, final question. Shannan, how do you want December 31st Shannan to feel about her reading life?
SHANNAN: Oh, Anne, that is a good question. Relaxed. Can I feel relaxed? Ooh. Can I feel happy and contented? I am really enjoying being forced, by my therapist, to remove expectations and this drive. And so putting that into my reading life and just saying at the end, "I did what I could. I enjoyed what I did. It was a good year," I think that would be amazing. No pressure. None.
[00:47:50] And that totally feels weird to me to say. It's feeling weird to do. Sometimes I feel like I'm failing at something, but that's not the case. I have to constantly remind myself that's not the case, and if I can get to the end of the year saying, "Okay, that was a good reading experience in that I enjoyed it and there was no pressure," I will be very happy about that. What about you?
ANNE: Well, I love that for you, first of all.
SHANNAN: I feel like it's totally against brand, but-
ANNE: No. I mean, for years one of Book Riot's mottos, phrases that I'd see around was "read harder." And like I get it, like that sounds fun in a lot of ways, but also I think I'd like to read easier. It can be enjoyable, and we can be passionate about it and still have it... You know, it's not like I want to be lazy about... I don't think you're saying you want to be lazy. But you can read deeply, and intelligently, and thoughtfully, and also still have a sense of ease.
SHANNAN: Yeah.
[00:49:11] ANNE: Yeah. Oh, so perhaps an unhelpful abstract word, I want to feel satisfied.
SHANNAN: Oh, nice.
ANNE: And for me, I think that means I want to feel like I have done something substantial with my reading time. Like I was really unsure if I wanted to spend all those reading hours on one book for the Jane Smiley English literature seminar, but I felt like I did a thing that I will remember and will stay with me. And I don't feel that way about everything I read. So I imagine that having something to show for what I've done, not because I need something to point to necessarily. Like, I don't need to show you, "Look what I've done, Shannan." But I think I need to see for myself how what I'm reading is perhaps making a difference.
SHANNAN: I like that.
[00:50:14] ANNE: You know, this is my question, and yet I think one of the reasons these midyear reflections are so helpful is because I know I want to feel satisfied, but thinking about how that needs to be worked out practically, like how am I going to get there?
Now, sometimes feeling satisfied means ripping through a really great thriller mystery. Like I want those moments of just enjoyment, and levity, and lightness, you know, as you're reading about murder. But sometimes it means like discovering new things about the world and about yourself, or learning more about how novels work.
SHANNAN: Yeah, or in my case, learning about poetry.
ANNE: Yes. Yes, and learning new things about yourself, and finding out that there are things that you can enjoy now that you didn't, and you know, that we're learning and growing. I don't want to sound too cheesy, but books are great. I love the places they can take us and the ways they bring us together. And I'll try not to be a sap about it. But every once in a while, it's just going to happen.
[00:51:22] Okay. Relaxed and satisfied. Readers, we would love to hear how you're feeling at your midyear and how you want to feel at the end of the year. Shannan, final thoughts?
SHANNAN: Happy reading.
ANNE: Oh, you know, maybe not the biggest surprise, but up there is the number of times I encountered Rainer Maria Rilke in the pages of fiction and nonfiction this year, epigraphs or woven through the text.
SHANNAN: That is true. I have noticed that myself.
ANNE: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I strongly connect him in my mind with What Should I Read Next? Since episode one. We've been telling everyone how wonderful it is to be with those who are reading, and well, among those who are reading, and I am always happy to see him out. And I just give like a little tip of my hat when I see him out in the world.
[00:52:21] Shannan, thank you for joining me in this conversation today. Readers, I hope you enjoyed listening in. If you're reflecting on your own reading life, we would love to hear what's working and where you may be making your own adjustments or facing your own conundrums. Please share your thoughts by leaving a comment on our show notes page. That's also where you'll find all the titles we talked about. We do that every week for you. That's at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
If you could take a moment to make sure you're following or subscribed on your favorite podcast app, that helps us so much in practical, tangible ways. We are on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, basically wherever you get your podcasts.
When you subscribe, that's free and easy for you. It also provides valuable data to our platforms, and this is a quick, easy, and free way to show your support for our show.
We also send out weekly emails with news and updates. Sign up at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter. We are on Instagram @WhatShouldIReadNext. Our team member Leigh runs that account, and she sees your every post and message and shares those with our team. If you share an update about your mid-year reading check-in, we would love to see. Please tag us in those posts or stories @WhatShouldIReadNext.
[00:53:35] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
SHANNAN: Happy reading.
• I’d Rather Be Reading by Anne Bogel
• The Annotated Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen, annotated and edited by David M. Shapard — please note: based on team member experience, it seems that if you want the Shapard annotated edition, it’s the print edition you want. Despite appearances to the contrary on the item listing, kindle (and potentially other ebook) links are not tied to the Shapard annotated edition.
• 13 Ways of Looking at the Novel by Jane Smiley
• Under Story by Chloe Benjamin
• Prague Spring by Simon Mawer
• The Fifth Year by Marlen Haushofer
• Taipei Story by R. F. Kuang
• The Slantwise Histories by Alix E. Harrow
• A Psalm for the Wild-Built by Becky Chambers
• All the Way to the River by Elizabeth Gilbert
• Bomb Shelter by Mary Laura Philpott
• I Miss You When I Blink by Mary Laura Philpott
• My Oxford Year by Julia Whelan
• The Bookman’s Tale by Charlie Lovett
• On Writing Well by William Zinsser
• Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott
• Good Writing by Neal Allen and Anne Lamott
• Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin
• The Storied Life of A. J. Fikry by Gabrielle Zevin
• Heart the Lover by Lily King
• Writers & Lovers by Lily King
• The Phoenix Pencil Company by Allison King
• Babel by R.F. Kuang
• The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E Harrow
• The Great Wherever by Shannon Sanders
• The Camino by Anya Niewierra
• The Beginner’s Goodbye by Anne Tyler
• A Spool of Blue Thread by Anne Tyler
• Land by Maggie O’Farrell
• The Tapestry of Fate by Shannon Chakraborty
• I Will Teach You to Be Rich by Ramit Sethi
• The Happy Ever After Playlist by Abby Jimenez (Audio edition)
• Ransom by Daniel Silva
• Cool Machine by Colson Whitehead
• The Paradox Club by Charlie Lovett
• Said the Dead by Doireann Ní Ghríofa
• Whidbey by T Kira Madden
• The Art of Gathering by Priya Parker
• The Art of Fighting by Priya Parker
• Against Breaking: On the Power of Poetry by Ada Limón
• The Animators by Kayla Rae Whitaker
• Returns and Exchanges by Kayla Rae Whitaker
• Finding Grace by Loretta Rothschild (Audio edition)
• Sisters of a Halved Heart by Nayantara Roy
• The Magnificent Ruins by Nayantara Roy
• The Glass Room by Simon Mawer
• It’s Beginning to Look a Lot Like Murder by Ally Carter
• The Fine Art of Lying by Alexandra Andrews
• WSIRN Patreon
• Patreon Bonus: Looking back to look forward: Reading intentions with Anne and Shannan
• WSIRN Ep. 489: The satisfaction of sinking into a good book
• Strong Sense of Place
• Books & Mortar
• Patreon Bonus: Midyear freak-out with Shannan, Holly and Brigid
• Patreon Bonus: One Great Book: The Happy Ever After Playlist
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Midyear reading check-in appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
We often talk about backlist books around here because there is a wealth of delight to be found in titles that aren’t getting the buzz and attention of recent releases. In fact, one of our most frequent requests from listeners and prospective guests is “help me find backlist gems.”
We are riffing on that theme by sharing a backlist episode with you: today I’m resurfacing a conversation that we still talk about and hear about from you all the time, in part because of the guest’s absolutely unique way of choosing her next read. Today I’m chatting with reader Elizabeth Cooper, in an episode we originally aired in July 2020 as Episode 244: You Love to Read, Don’t Ruin It.
Elizabeth came to me to find books she described as brain candy: books with a killer premise, pages that practically turn themselves, and totally satisfying endings. This is a great conversation, and I’m excited for you to hear it again or for the first time.
Tell us about your creative book selection method by leaving a comment below.
Connect with Elizabeth on Goodreads.
Reflecting on our reading lives is an endless source of joy and discovery, and over the past few years, What Should I Read Next? Patreon community manager Shannon Malone has joined me here in this space for a mid-year reading check-in. We’re doing that again this year, and that brand-new episode will be landing in your podcast apps next week. If you’re new to this idea, check out our conversations from 2024, and 2025: those are both linked below for your convenience.
[00:00:00] ANNE BOGEL: You know that little gumball machine thing that pops up the lotto ball numbers? That's how I'm picturing your books being chosen.
ELIZABETH COOPER: If my husband knows how to build one of those, I would love it.
ANNE: Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:44] Readers, reflecting on our reading lives is an endless source of joy and discovery, and over the past few years, team member and What Should I Read Next? Patreon community manager Shannon Malone has joined me here in this space for a mid-year reading check-in. We're doing that again this year, and that brand-new episode will be landing in your podcast apps next week.
If you're new to this style of reading reflection, check out our conversations from 2025 and 2024. We put links to those episodes in our show notes.
Readers, we often talk about backlist books around here because there is a wealth of delight to be found in titles that aren't getting the buzz and attention of recent releases. In fact, one of our most frequent requests from What Should I Read Next? guests and applicants to be guests is, "Help me find backlist gems."
[00:01:32] Today we are riffing on that theme by sharing a backlist episode with you. We've aired more than 500 conversations over the past decade, decade-plus here at What Should I Read Next? And while I know many of you are completist listeners to our show, you've heard every one of those 500-plus episodes, many more of you are new here or have missed some along the way.
Today I'm resurfacing a conversation that we still talk about and hear about from you all the time. That is with reader Elizabeth Cooper, and we originally aired this episode in July 2020 as Episode 244, You Love to Read, Don't Ruin It.
Elizabeth came to me to find books she described as brain candy, books with a killer premise, pages that practically turn themselves, and totally satisfying endings. This is a great conversation, and I'm excited for you to hear it again or for the first time.
But that is not the reason readers are still talking about this episode. Nope. That's because the way Elizabeth chooses her next read continues to blow my mind and many of yours as well. This is a good one. Let's get to it
[00:02:39] Elizabeth, welcome to the show.
ELIZABETH: Thank you so much for having me. I'm excited to be here.
ANNE: I'm so excited to talk books with you, and not just books but your experience writing books over the years. I have to tell you here at What Should I Read Next? headquarters, when your submission came in, it got our attention. Can I read it to you? Because you might not remember.
ELIZABETH: Oh, yes, please.
ANNE: Okay, so this is just a selective portion. You said that you spent a decade writing erotic romance novels before your daughter was born, and then once she came along, "my idea of a hot night became sleeping through it without having anyone touch me, and there went my romance novelist career."
ELIZABETH: Yup. That's accurate.
ANNE: So knowing that you're someone who has a lot of experience with lots of different aspects of books, I'd love to hear a little about your reading life.
ELIZABETH: My reading life is super eclectic. So I have a degree in English literature, and when I was in school, of course I had to read all the books. I had to read all the classics. I'm Canadian, so I had to read a great deal of Canadian literature. And so when I got out of university, I swore that I would never read a classic again. I just made myself promise that was not going to be a part of my reading life going forward.
[00:03:50] I rebelled by going to the exact opposite direction and I bought every Harlequin I could get my hands on. And that's where I basically started after I got out of university. I read all the romance novels and then I read all the fantasy novels and all the science fiction novels. And it was just the more brain candy, the better. It was, like, I was making up for long lost time.
ANNE: Well, that's so interesting. First of all, I am not an English major. People just assume that I am, but a couple of older friends warned me. They said, "Hey, you love to read. Maybe don't ruin it." So sometimes I think, like, "Oh, how many more books would I have read and studied if I did major in the subject in college?" But I didn't and that's why. And I feel validated in my choice. But also I'm so sad … I mean, do you ever feel a loss when feeling so burned out on the classics after college? Or do you really feel like no, it's just balancing out and it's all good.
[00:04:42] ELIZABETH: Yeah, I never feel a loss. I just feel super confident in my decision to move forward and just read whatever I want to read, whatever feels good to me. So these days my reading life is so eclectic. I read a lot of fantasy, science fiction. I don't read romance anymore, which is interesting and we can get into that if you'd like, but I read a lot of nonfiction. I read self-help. I read widely. I read literary fiction. Just I don't go into classics.
ANNE: When you were reading the classics in college, did you ever see yourself writing those books one day? Writing any books one day?
ELIZABETH: It's so interesting that you ask that because the beginning of my novelist career was actually in university and I was taking a children's literature class. Part of our assignment was to write a children's story. And I had never really written fiction before. I wrote a lot of essays being in school, but I didn't write fiction.
[00:05:35] And I fell in love with the act of writing fiction. I can actually remember the story that I wrote. It was about a little girl that got lost in a fairy garden and ate a pear and had to stay there, which of course wasn't unique by any stretch of the imagination. But I just loved the process of doing it so much that I thought, wow, I could do more of this.
ANNE: What was it about it?
ELIZABETH: I think it was just giving myself permission to get as creative and as wild as I wanted to, which is why even when I started writing erotic romance, I wrote paranormal subgenres most of the time. So I just wanted to get out of the world that I lived in, and I still want that from my reading life as well, but my writing life was very much about escapism.
ANNE: Now you said that you have a slew of hobbies, but reading has always been one of your greatest passions. Practically, what does that look like in your reading life over the years?
[00:06:27] ELIZABETH: It was always the thing I went back to in times of stress. I would grab a book whenever the world just got to be too much. And as far as other hobbies went, I paint, I draw, I craft. But there's just something about reading, and again I think I just go back to that need to escape that is fabulous for me.
Now, having said that, when I had my daughter, I had really bad postpartum depression and I couldn't read for about a year. And when I say I couldn't read, I would open a book and I would reread the same paragraph for 15 minutes without being able to remember a thing I had just read. And it was so frustrating. And I remember thinking, "Will I ever be able to go back to reading?" And it was such a loss for me that I couldn't do it, but I think I just needed to give both my brain and my body some time to heal. And then when I stopped forcing it, eventually it came back.
ANNE: Oh, I'm glad to hear that. And also I'm so sorry. And how frustrating it must have been.
[00:07:25] ELIZABETH: Yes. And the more frustrated I got, the more I tried to force it, and of course that never works.
ANNE: Elizabeth, how did you discover the genres that you enjoy? The ones that you keep coming back to again and again?
ELIZABETH: Fantasy is a big one for me, and I discovered that thanks to my husband. My husband and I have been married for 21 years and I was 18 when we got married. So I was in university. And I remember reading all these classics and all these heavy tomes and just being exhausted, and my husband handed me a Dragonlance novel. And I thought, "What is this?" And he tried to explain Dungeons & Dragons to me because he was really into it, and I just thought, "That's crazy, but okay."
I remember sitting on the couch and I devoured this little Dragonlance novel in a couple of hours. I came out of it as though I had just gone to a different world, and I thought, "Oh my God, I had no idea this kind of thing existed." It was like a whole wide world of fantasy had opened up for me. So that's how I got into fantasy.
[00:08:24] And then I stretched from there into science fiction. I had always liked both fantasy and science fiction movies and TV shows, but I hadn't read it.
Another genre I keep going back to is nonfiction, particularly self-help, but I also just really interesting bits of pieces about the world. I recently read The Body by Bill Bryson, and I loved it. It's just so fascinating. I couldn't put it down.
So those are the genres I keep going back to again and again and again. That's not to say I don't read other things because I certainly do. But if I want a comfort read, that's where I go. And also psychological thrillers. Love those too. I think there's just something about brain candy.
ANNE: Well, that's not everyone's idea of candy, though.
ELIZABETH: That is a very good point.
ANNE: So with thriller has that puzzle element to it, but is that what makes it so enjoyable for you? Do you even know? These are often not things we articulate. We just know as readers like, ugh, we find those books really satisfying and really fun. But oftentimes we're not asked why.
[00:09:22] ELIZABETH: No, and I love so much that you're asking this because it is making me think about it. And it's not the puzzle aspect. I don't even like puzzles, so it's definitely not the puzzle aspect. I want to say again it's about being in an entirely different world. When I read, I put myself in the main character's shoes, and I just love feeling that thrill of fear but in a controlled environment. I imagine it's the same reason why people like to watch horror movies, which I don't, but I would imagine that if I was somebody who liked horror movies that's why I liked it because it gives me that illusion of control while still getting to experience something that is entirely out of my realm of knowledge and possibility.
ANNE: Okay. So we're going to be looking for books that take you places today.
ELIZABETH: Yeah.
ANNE: Elizabeth, I'm ready to hear about your books. Are you ready to jump in?
ELIZABETH: I am so ready. Let's do it.
ANNE: You know how this works. You're going to tell me three books you love, one book you don't, and what you've been reading lately, and we'll talk about what you may enjoy reading next.
ELIZABETH: Fantastic.
[00:10:23] ANNE: All right, Elizabeth. What's book number one?
ELIZABETH: Book number one is Kings of the Wyld by Nicholas Eames. This is a fantasy novel. It's the first in a series, and it revolves around a group of over-the-hill mercenaries. They were once part of the most renowned band of warriors in their realm, and now they're old, drunk, or all of the above. But when one of the band members' daughters is in trouble, she gets kidnapped, the rest of them have to rally to rescue her. And then chaos and adventure ensue from there.
This book reminded me of all the reasons why I love fantasy. It's campaign Dungeons & Dragons at its very best. It brought back every memory I have of falling in love with Dragonlance and World of Warcraft and Lord of the Rings. I adore the characters. Every single one of the guys in the band is so well-crafted and so perfectly drawn. Throw in a few secondary characters who are just as magical, and I just couldn't put this book down.
[00:11:24] One of my favorite aspects of this was that the groups of warriors were actually treated like famous rock stars are in our society. So imagine if, say, The Rolling Stones had been monster hunters instead of rock 'n' roll stars, but their fans were still diehard fans and knew everything about them. I just loved that. That was so much fun.
ANNE: I haven't read this one, so I talked to a few readers I know who love sci-fi. I read a few reviews, and I just want to read you this little snippet from a Kirkus review. "Eames has cranked the thrills of epic fantasy up to eleven with gleeful disregard for restraint or good sense. The world is rich and exciting; the plot is emotionally rewarding, original, and hilarious, and boasts a satisfying conclusion while leaving room for future books. He clearly set out to write something fun to read and he has succeeded spectacularly."
ELIZABETH: That's perfect.
ANNE: I mean, I want to read that right now based on everything you said.
ELIZABETH: I honestly think you would love it.
ANNE: Did he go on to write follow-ups to this one?
ELIZABETH: Yes. I have book number two on my shelf, and I'm afraid to read it because I don't want to ruin the experience for myself.
[00:12:27] ANNE: Well, that does sound like so much fun. Well, and I noticed this is a book that is constantly described by readers who love it as being fun to read, and I don't feel like it's a coincidence that you chose it as one of your favorites of the past two years. Am I wrong that that's something that you really value as a reader right now?
ELIZABETH: You're absolutely right. It was really fun to read. I just love that element of reading. Just having fun with it.
ANNE: Elizabeth, what did you choose for book two?
ELIZABETH: Book number two is Mistress of Rome by Kate Quinn. Now, I'm not typically a huge fan of historical fiction, but I adore ancient history, so give me books that's set in Ancient Egypt or Rome and I'm all in. This particular book centers around Thea, who starts out as a slave for a spoiled, cruel mistress named Lepida.
Lepida is very jealous of Thea and she makes her life miserable, especially once Thea catches the eye of the most famous gladiator around, which is a man that Lepida wants for herself. Lepida casts Thea out of Rome, but Thea is very resourceful and she ends up making herself as a singer and as a courtesan for Rome's elite. She catches the eye of the emperor and she ends up having much more power in Rome than her former mistress does, which sets these two women on a conclusion course right up until the end of the story.
[00:13:48] And I feel madly in love with this book. It's so clear to me that Kate Quinn did an incredible amount of research. There's something about the scenarios, the characters, the environment, they all rang so authentic and true. I was so deeply enthralled while reading. I mean, I flew through this book in a couple of days and I'm typically not a binge reader.
What's really interesting for me about this book in particular is that when I read I felt like I was living within the pages. Like it was me falling in love and me in the arena smelling blood and terror. And even as I turned the last page, I still felt like I was there. Like I could hear the screams of the audience in my ears and I could taste figs and I could feel silk on my skin. It was just this whole total body experience, like isn't that reading at its best? I don't know. It is for me.
ANNE: That sounds like an incredible reading experience. And I think it's interesting that you said that you're not usually a binge reader. What kind of reader are you usually?
[00:14:46] ELIZABETH: I would say I'm slow and steady. I read between 30-50 pages every night before I go to bed, so it takes me a little while to get through a book, depending on how long the book is. I also never, ever read two books in a series back-to-back. Like I need something else in between.
ANNE: My husband and I were just discussing series rhythms yesterday for a bonus episode that's going up on our Patreon. So if you don't read them back-to-back, do you have a preferred rhythm? How do you tackle a series? I say tackle like there's this mountain you need to climb and not this pool that you get to dive into, but how do you approach a series? How's that?
ELIZABETH: Okay. Here's the other really interesting thing about me. I choose all my books randomly. I never, ever walk into my library or bookstore or wherever and pick out a book and bring it home and read it. I pick up a book, I add it to my Goodreads list, and then when it's time to read something new, I go to my trusty randomizer, and I plug in a number and whatever that number pops up with is what I end up reading. And so this means that I might end up taking years in between reading the next book in a series.
[00:15:57] ANNE: Elizabeth, this is a new strategy to me. I like it. How did you first ... how did this even occur to you to do? I mean, I understand that a randomizer is not a novel idea, but it is an unusual approach to your reading life. How did it come to you?
ELIZABETH: I think I just started building out my TBR list, and my TBR list is pretty massive. So I started having trouble picking books. And I thought, "You know what? I'm just going to take the decision-making off the table altogether." Now, I will say that the only way this works is if the only books on your TBR are books that you are excited to read. Because every time a number comes up, I feel that thrill of "ooh, I get to read this! That's fantastic." If I didn't have that, then I would feel like I was being forced to read something and it would feel like I was back in school.
ANNE: Have you ever had a number come up and realize, Oh, I didn't actually want to read that book?
ELIZABETH: On occasion this happens and I will just … I won't even put it back on the shelf. I will just take the book out of my house and take it off my TBR altogether because I will know that this isn't something I'm ever going to be excited reading.
[00:17:02] ANNE: How many books are on your TBR?
ELIZABETH: 3,000 physical books, and a lot more digital books.
ANNE: So when you enter your fields into the randomizer, it's 0 through how many?
ELIZABETH: Three thou … Well, no, it's zero through 4,500 right now. My husband is a computer programmer and he actually built me an app to keep track of all of my books.
ANNE: Oh, I love it.
ELIZABETH: I know. And it has a randomizer feature built in, so all I actually have to do is push a magic button and a book pops up on my screen and I just go and grab it.
ANNE: Oh, I can't wait to hear what you've been reading lately. Okay, tell me about book three.
ELIZABETH: Okay. Book three is The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow and this was a Modern Mrs Darcy book club pick which was the only reason why I picked it up. And I did so with some trepidation because I don't really read young adult. And while this book isn't actually categorized as young adult, I think it's historical fantasy. The teenage protagonist gave me pause.
[00:18:04] So this book is about January Scaller. She's a ward to a wealthy man and has a tumultuous relationship with her own father who's often gone on long expeditions. She's quite different from those around her, both physically and in terms of her personality. She's adventurous and wild and curious and she loves to read. So one day she finds a strange book and it's a book that tells a tale that seems at once familiar and impossible, and it leads her on a journey of self-discovery unlike really anything I've ever read before.
And honestly I can't remember another time I sobbed so much while reading a book or became so interested in the characters and their circumstances. Actually, now that I think of it, it may have been while I was reading Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay. I remember being just as swept away and desperate to read more while reading that.
[00:18:54] But while I was reading The Ten Thousand Doors of January, I was on a cruise, and I remember just being out on the balcony completely ignoring my husband and my daughter because I just couldn't stop reading this book. I loved everything about it. I loved January, her mom, and her dad, the secondary characters. I loved the writing. It's so lyrical and heart-wrenchingly beautiful, but not in a showy way which I really appreciate.
January's voice is so distinct and captivating. It's really the voice of a true scholar, I thought. And I just really enjoyed rooting for her and for her parents and just following her on the journey that she takes. It was, again, so much fun, but with that emotional punch that I wasn't expecting.
ANNE: I'm so glad you enjoyed it. That sounds like an incredible reading experience, and I'm so glad that you picked it up despite your hesitance to read about a teenage protagonist.
ELIZABETH: And this is why I'm part of the Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club because I get to read things I wouldn't otherwise, and it's just so much fun.
ANNE: I'm so glad to hear that. And she was so fun to talk to, too.
ELIZABETH: Yeah.
[00:19:55] ANNE: Okay. I'm really excited. Now that we're indulging our Alix Harrow fan club moment, she has a new one coming out this fall called The Once and Future Witches, and I can't wait to get my hands on it.
ELIZABETH: I am so excited to hear that. You just made my day.
ANNE: Now, Elizabeth, I'd love to hear what you're reading now and also I'm desperate to know, were these randomizer-produced titles?
ELIZABETH: Of course they were. Absolutely they were. What I just recently finished is Sphere by Michael Crichton. This book has been sitting on my shelf for 20 years and the randomizer finally served it up for me, so I was super excited. It was published in 1989. It was also made into a movie with Dustin Hoffman and Samuel L. Jackson and Sharon Stone, which I haven't seen yet but I'm looking forward to.
It's about a group of scientists who discover a spaceship at the bottom of the ocean, and the weird part is that all the labels are in English, but the ship is at least 300 years old. Of course it's Michael Crichton, so it holds this alien intelligence that could kill us all. I enjoyed it.
[00:20:55] ANNE: You know, I read a lot of writing books and Michael Crichton gets referenced a lot in writing books. It's interesting to me how so many people who do writing or do story or plotting or critique for a living say often about Michael Crichton, nobody can do a premise like Michael Crichton, just over and over and over again. His premises are amazing.
ELIZABETH: There is something really incredible about his premises. And sometimes the books fall apart at about the halfway mark. You know, in this particular one, like the scientific explanation didn't quite hold together and the technology, you know, didn't quite make sense, but his premise was so good that I just had to keep reading because I just had to know what happens.
ANNE: The first Michael Crichton book I read was The Andromeda Strain, and I read it when I was about 15 or 16. It blew my mind. I loved it so much. I still think about it sometimes, specifically because... I mean, I don't remember the details of the plot or how it ended, but I remember that the people involved in some kind of close corridors situation drank this smoothie basically every day that had everything they needed, all their calories and nutrients. Sometimes when I'm traveling I think, "Man, I wish I had one of those Andromeda Strain smoothies. That would be so easy right now."
[00:22:06] But I'm curious to go back and read it to see what, you know, my current self thinks about my 15-year-old taste. What else has the randomizer served up lately? I'm curious to hear what a monthly mix of books might look like for you.
ELIZABETH: Oh, absolutely. Actually, let me just pull it up here. So after Sphere I went straight to Untamed by Glennon Doyle, which again, I'm just loving. The one before that was Girl, Stop Apologizing by Rachel Hollis. Before that I read Dexter in the Dark by Jeff Lindsay, which I think is book three is the Dexter series, so you know, I'm getting quite far into this series given how many books I have on my TBR. I'm always surprised when a Dexter book pops up. I've also read Force of Nature by Jane Harper, Maybe You Should Talk to Someone, Since We Fell by Dennis Lehane. Yeah, those were my recent ones for the last couple months.
ANNE: And are hitting those genres that you said you enjoyed, which I imagine is no coincidence because that's everything there, right?
[00:23:07] ELIZABETH: Yes, exactly. So pretty much everything on my TBR is in my happy place.
ANNE: Elizabeth, is there anything you want to be different in your reading life?
ELIZABETH: You know, we talked so much about my randomizer method, but I would really love to be more intentional with the way that I choose my books. I'm finding that even though I have a lot of books on my TBR that are in the genres that I enjoy, I also get a lot of books and I start a lot of books that don't really do it for me. I would love to maybe change those percentages a little bit. I now find that about 50% of the books that I grab just … they're okay, but they're not amazing. They don't give me that reading experience I'm looking for. And I'm thinking that if I could be a little bit more intentional with what I choose, then chances are good that I will have that experience more often.
ANNE: Have you considered how you might be more intentional about what that might look like for you?
[00:24:01] ELIZABETH: So I started by joining the book club, and that's one way that I've been able to filter books and choose books that aren't randomizer picked. So just looking at suggestions from people I trust seems to be a really good way for me to find a good read, or something I will enjoy. And I'm also thinking about just going back to those authors I love and just reading more in their backlist, which is something I don't do very often because again I have so many books on my TBR. And I'm thinking that I would really like to dive deep into some of these authors' backlists, and see what comes of that.
ANNE: When you think about scrapping your TBR or maybe just culling it, does that feel exciting? Or anything but?
ELIZABETH: It actually feels super exciting. I'm finding that the older I get, and I turn 40 this year, the older I get the more I want to embrace a minimalist lifestyle. But I have these 3,000 books and that doesn't quite go with a minimalist lifestyle, so I would really like to be able to go through and just really prune and tame that beast in my library.
[00:25:08] ANNE: How did you end up with 3,000 books? That's a lot of books and it's not something that happens by accident.
ELIZABETH: It's not, is it? No. When I was writing a lot of them I considered research, so I bought a ton of romance novels. I bought a ton of Harlequins, in particular, I would go to eBay and I would find lots of Harlequins and I would just buy them, boxes at a time. And then I would just go into used bookstores and library sales, and my library has this amazing sale that happens once a month. You can buy, I think it's a paperback, for 25 cents. So I would walk out of there with, I don't know, 40, 50 books at a time because come on, who can pass up a bargain, right?
ANNE: I mean, those library sales are magical but also serious trouble.
ELIZABETH: Yes.
ANNE: Okay, so you've contemplated maybe clearing the shelves a little bit?
[00:25:54] ELIZABETH: Absolutely. I would really like to get down. I mean, in my ideal world, I would like to have a physical TBR that's under a hundred books. I think that might be stretching it a bit, but that's my goal. I would love to get there.
ANNE: That sounds like plenty of books. Abstractly …
ELIZABETH: Yes.
ANNE: I was just thinking how do you get to a hundred and thought, "Well, that sounds like a reasonable amount." But I'm looking at a post it note of the books that … Well, it started as the five books I want to read in the next couple of weeks, but then I kept adding to it as I kept realizing, "Oh, wait, actually I have more priority titles" or "I'll learn about a new book and I want to read it immediately." And just on this one little Post-it note, which began as books I want to read in the next two weeks, I think I have like 22 books on it, which is 22% of the way to your 100 titles … And oh, how did you arrive at the 100 number?
[00:26:43] ELIZABETH: It was just this number that feels... it feels extreme. It feels extremely small. I have a room full of books, so thinking about culling that down to one bookshelf, I'd loved to make that happen. Especially because I know that a lot of the books that are on there are not really part of these genres that I really love.
ANNE: Now, this is going to sound like a motivational speaker kind of question, and I don't mean it like that, but you haven't done it yet. What are the big things holding you back, aside from the sheer amount of labor it actually would take to move that many books? I mean, I'm a reader. I have a lot of books. It doesn't sound completely overwhelming to me and yet when I start to visualize, I know about how many books are on each shelf in my own library and in my office, and I need a room several times that large to hold 3,000. You know that's a lot of books.
ELIZABETH: Yes.
ANNE: So there's many reasons not to move forward. What are the big ones for you?
ELIZABETH: I think I have this fear of running out of reading material.
ANNE: Yeah.
[00:27:42] ELIZABETH: I think, Oh, no, what if I somehow get through all hundred books and then I won't have anything to read? And so having that many books makes me feel like I will always have something to read. I have my own library and my own house, which by the way, has come in very handy while the libraries have been closed.
ANNE: You're not going to run out of reading material.
ELIZABETH: No.
ANNE: Maybe not for several lifetimes.
ELIZABETH: No, not for several lifetimes for sure. And I think that's part of it. The other part of course is just the amount of time commitment, and then I think, What am I going to do with all these books? Like I will physically have to take them somewhere. I will have physically have to donate them or my daughter's school has a book sale every fall, so I mean I could just pile them up and save them for the book sale. They'd be thrilled to have them, I'm sure.
ANNE: They could just host it at your house.
ELIZABETH: They could!
ANNE: Have you thought about taking any intermediate steps?
[00:28:35] ELIZABETH: Yes. And I've actually started doing this. So I've culled my bookshelves and I've taken all the romances novels, all the Harlequins that I don't read anymore, and I've just separated those. And I know that's a very easy step for me. Those are the first ones that can go, and that will be easy enough to do. And from there, I will probably be left with somewhere close to 1,500 maybe. Which still sounds like a lot, but it will be-
ANNE: No, but that's huge. That's 50%.
ELIZABETH: Yeah, it's half of my collection. I can start there.
ANNE: Okay. High fives.
ELIZABETH: High fives all around.
ANNE: I mean, obviously. There's nothing intrinsically good or bad about adding or removing books, but if this is what you want, like, well done.
ELIZABETH: Yes. And you bring up a good point about adding books because I do take out a few books and I add twice as many.
ANNE: Oh, that's relatable. Well, now I feel really bad because you know what we're going to do next. We're going to recommend books for your reading list, Elizabeth. Should we not do this?
ELIZABETH: Please, please, let's do this.
[00:29:36] ANNE: Okay. I'm curious to hear what you say about this because the first book that occurred to me as you're talking about how you want reading to be fun and just an enjoyable experience and to take you into somebody else's problems, in a controlled kind of way. I thought about a fairly new romance novel and the reason is that so many readers have said, "Oh, I just read this whole thing with a giant smile on my face. It just made me so happy." I mean, like really hard stuff happens in this book, but there's so much funny, witty banter where you think, "Ugh, I want to be best friends with these people. That would be so great." But you don't read romance anymore, and I would love to hear a little more about that.
ELIZABETH: So remember how I said that when I was in university and I came out and I said, I'm never doing that again because I overdosed on it? I had the exact same experience when I was writing romance. When I was writing romance, I only read romance. I considered it research for my writing. I wanted to know what was going on in the industry, who was getting published, what kinds of themes kept coming up. I read a lot of romance.
[00:30:40] So once I decided that I was no longer going to be writing romance, I also made the decision to read other things. I felt like I had gotten enough of that and I wanted to move on to something else.
ANNE: That makes sense. So most readers parcel out a genre over the course of many years or even a lifetime, but you got yours in a concentrated decade.
ELIZABETH: Yes, exactly.
ANNE: Elizabeth, how long has it been since you closed the metaphorical book on your romance career?
ELIZABETH: It's been six and a half years, which is exactly how old my daughter is.
ANNE: Readers, I think it's worth mentioning here that Elizabeth wrote under a pen name as many authors do for privacy reasons. So if you go Googling Elizabeth Cooper novels, that's not going to get you anywhere. That is why, and we ask that you respect that.
So we are going to skip the romance novel in that place because that's a good reason. Also, I like the pattern we're seeing unfold here. You do the thing, you do it well, it's done, and you move on.
ELIZABETH: Oh, it's so interesting that you say that because I can probably see that in my life even outside of reading quite a few times.
[00:31:43] ANNE: True to character. But you're not done with fantasy, right?
ELIZABETH: No, definitely not.
ANNE: Okay, because I got an interesting urban fantasy that I think... I'm not sure whether I should be hopeful that you've heard of it and it's in that randomizer somewhere or maybe you'll give it a special spot and pull it out or maybe you'll just be really excited in 2027 when it pops up as its turn to read. But the book I'm thinking of is Trail of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse. Do you know this one? This series?
ELIZABETH: No.
ANNE: I don't know if it's good for you or not, but I'm happy that this is a new one to you since you do love all the fantasy and sci-fi. Sometimes this book gets categorized as cli-fi, climate dystopian, end of the world, fantastical fiction, but we'll get to that in a second. This is the first book in a trilogy. It's incomplete. Book two is out. Book three is … I think she's been posting on Twitter that she's on deadline right now, so leave her alone, she's not going to respond because she's gotta finish and turn this thing in.
[00:32:36] But the trilogy is called The Sixth World trilogy. The origin of that Sixth World idea is traditional Navajo stories. Roanhorse is herself Ohkay Owingeh, she lived for several years in the Navajo Nation, she is married to a Navajo man and their child is Navajo. This is an Indigenous OwnVoices story. And she says that similar to other Indigenous worldviews, they believe that there've been multiple iterations of the world we're living in now. So truly in contemporary time, we're living in the Fifth World, or she says Fourth, it's regional which one you believe, but it's not the Sixth.
So what she says she was inspired to think, what if this world ended in this cataclysmic, climate event? It'd be over and it'd be time for the Sixth world. So that's where the series name comes from. And that apocalyptic climate change here is an event that in the book they call The Big Water. It's the epic flood that basically wipes out everything. And as the story unfolds, you learn more about what happened and how it changed life as this community knew it. That's the backdrop.
[00:33:45] What I like about this story for you is, it's really interesting. It takes you into a totally different world, and it was really important to Roanhorse that you feel completely immersed in and experience the world, so the writing is really evocative. You were talking about the Kate Quinn book, how you could taste the fig and feel the silk on your skin. Roanhorse is so good at writing those descriptions that make you feel like you're right there in the story.
And also from the get go, when you start reading the first paragraph, I just felt like, boom, here we are. I'm in it. Like I'm right there with the character. And you find out right at the beginning, the protagonist, her name is Maggie, she's … she's a monster hunter. She has special powers because she's been trained by a legend, although a legend with whom she has a complicated relationship. So when this young girl goes missing, everybody knows Maggie's the one you have to ask.
It starts in this scene where they, you know, need her because something terrible has happened and she's, you know, like dropped into the middle of the action. It's exciting and interesting and you want to know what happens next. And you may be able to read this 30 to 50 pages a night, that's fine, but I know that many readers, including myself, just blew through it because they wanted to see what happens next.
[00:34:58] And about that monster hunting, I didn't realize that so many Navajo stories have this tradition of monster hunting, so she's drawing from the legends of her people to tell this story. You know, fantasy authors have incredible imaginations and they can come up with these completely new ideas that they pulled out of their back pockets or more like their powerful imaginations. But I thought it was so interesting that her cosmology here does feel so thoroughly fleshed out, I just wondered, is that because she's drawing on these rich traditions that have been around for forever?
So there's monster hunting. But also she's working through a whole bunch of personal junk with her mentor and with other people. She's lost a lot of people in really painful ways. She meets someone that becomes her partner as they go monster hunting, but he's got his own issues. I think you might enjoy it. How does this sound to you?
ELIZABETH: It sounds fantastic.
[00:35:56] ANNE: Now, I don't see you reading the books just because they have like awards smacked onto them, but she's got them. She won the Nebula. Actually, she was the first Indigenous American to do so. She was a finalist for a Hugo. Readers are on edge to find out when her next book will be published, that one she's about to turn in. But if you enjoy this, there is already one more and another one on the way so that you can put them into your series. I'm picturing... you know that little like gumball machine that pops up the lotto ball numbers? That's how I'm picturing your books being chosen.
ELIZABETH: I need one of those. If my husband knows how to build one of those instead of an app, I would love it. It's like one of those claw machines, you know, that the kids love, you can just pull out a book and drop it in.
ANNE: Yes, exactly. Except ... You know, the claw though, you have your eye on what you really want.
ELIZABETH: That's a good point.
ANNE: But maybe subconsciously you do too. Okay. So that book is Trail of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse. Okay, next up, Kevin Kwan who is beyond famous for his Crazy Rich Asians series has a new book coming out this summer. It's called Sex and Vanity. I wouldn't even have to tell you this. You can enjoy the story perfectly well without knowing it or caring or anything, but it's a retelling of A Room with a View. Right off the bat, how does that strike you?
ELIZABETH: Amazing.
[00:37:12] ANNE: Okay. First of all, I was excited to read the new Kevin Kwan novel, which might be a little bit silly because I read Crazy Rich Asians but I haven't finished the series. But reading his interview, seeing how he believes he's gotten so much better with every book, and I thought Crazy Rich Asians was fun, it makes me want to go back and read them. And they are on my physical bookshelves, Elizabeth, so I can do that. Glad they're still there waiting for me.
But he loves A Room with A View. And he said in many ways this book is an homage. It's been a big influence in his life. He's always loved Forster, but also the first time he saw the film, the Merchant Ivory version with Maggie Smith as Charlotte and a very, very young Helena Bonham Carter as Lucy, it made a big impression on him. It also reminded him of people he knew in Singapore, particularly an aunt that he was really close to.
[00:38:05] So he said that he's been thinking about writing this book for ten years, or actually maybe very, very much longer in his subconscious and he … It was time to write another book, and this is what he chose to do. And he wanted to be very clear, like this is not Crazy Rich Asians part four, this is something entirely different.
So in this book, Lucie Tang Churchill is 19 years old. She is a woman of privilege, of course because it's a Kevin Kwan novel. She's half-Chinese, she's half-WASP, and she goes to Capri to attend her also very rich friend Isabel's wedding. And when she's there she meets a guy named George, and he's rich and he's handsome. He's a Chinese-Australian surfer and she's into him and thinks he's interesting. They hook up.
The 2020 update for George kissing Lucie in a field, like he does in that Merchant Ivory movie, or in the novel, is not what I expected. Drones are involved. But they don't see each other again after that the rest of the time in the over-the-top wedding in Capri, until four years later when their paths cross again in New York City, only now she's engaged to the horrible Cecil, which you know if you've read A Room with A View. But again, it is not essential that you do so or know anything about it.
[00:39:24] I didn't know going in that this was A Room with A View retelling. I was reading and going, "Oh, there's a Lucy here, and her aunt's name is Charlotte. Wait a second." And I slowly realized, oh, that is totally what is happening, and I was here for it. He satirizes culture so well, but he's not mean about it. He wants you to have a really fun reading experience that is the emotion he is after which is why I think this could be a really excellent pick for you.
ELIZABETH: That sounds perfect. I'm going to love this, I'm sure.
ANNE: That is Sex and Vanity by Kevin Kwan. And again that will be out summer 2020. Okay, so we did sci-fi, cli-fi fantasy novel. We did the popular contemporary novel. How about we round out your list with a thriller?
ELIZABETH: Oh, let's do it.
ANNE: Okay. I want to do something new, is that okay?
ELIZABETH: Absolutely.
[00:40:16] ANNE: Okay. This season there's a new book by American writer Mindy Mejia. It's called Strike Me Down. This is not nonfiction. This is a thriller. But you mentioned that you really enjoy nonfiction that illuminates a piece of the world. And this thriller kinda does the same thing because it's about a forensic account and I imagine that a lot of readers like myself didn't know that they really wanted to read about the fascinating world of forensic accounting, but accounting never seemed so interesting as it does in this book. I mean, I am here for more accountant thrillers if anybody wants to recommend any. If any writers want to write me some, I will read them.
So, this is about a forensic accountant named Nora. She's based in Minneapolis, and she has devoted her life and her career to finding and prosecuting fraud. Sometimes this comes at a great personal cost. She exposed some fraudulent activity in her career that had absolutely devastating consequences, which may be a surprise to a reader, but Nora knows that when you're stealing money from your company, that's embezzlement. That's a lot of what she investigates.
[00:41:20] She knows that when people commit fraud, they have to have a motive and they have to have the opportunity to do so. These are the three things she's looking for as she investigates. She's approached by the co-owner of a business that she patronizes, that she loves, founded by a husband-wife team; she really admires the woman. It's called Strike. It's a kickboxing gym. It's really expensive. It's really prestigious. Nora just loves it. She's come a long way. And the wife in the partnership that founded it, Logan Russo, is basically Nora's idol.
So when Logan's husband, co-founder of the business, approaches her and says, "We need help and you're the only one who can do it," she can't help but say yes, even though she has several, like, big, blazing warning signs going, "You should not take that job." But she can't resist because she loves them, and she wants to do them a favor, and they, like, really stroke her ego by saying, "It can't be anybody but you, Nora." And this job needs to be done in a big hurry, so there's a rush to bring her on board.
[00:42:22] What's happened is Strike is putting on this huge kickboxing event, this huge tournament. It's a big deal and there's some exciting things happening for their business and the purse of 20 million dollars has disappeared with one week before the event. And the husband thinks his wife stole it, but he doesn't know why and he doesn't know how.
Nora knows she should say no. This is a classic thriller line, right, you know you shouldn't do it but you do, and then bad things happen. Like this is how the plot goes. She can't resist. And so she signs up for the job but as she starts digging in, she can see that something is amiss with this case. It's not just business. It goes beyond that. This is very personal to Nora and to this couple and she has entered into the middle of something she has no business being in. It's pretty fun to read, Elizabeth. How does that sound?
ELIZABETH: That sounds wonderful.
ANNE: Okay. That's called Strike Me Down. It's by Mindy Mejia. This definitely has some gruesome scenes. It's got some poor choices in many aspects of life. If you are a sensitive reader, this may not be right for you, but if you love the thriller genre and you know what you're getting into, have at it. I think you'll find it interesting. Also, I think you'll be amazed at how riveting it is to read about accounting in this book.
ELIZABETH: I love it.
[00:43:36] ANNE: Okay. Elizabeth, today we talked about Trial of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse, Sex and Vanity by Kevin Kwan, and Strike Me Down by Mindy Mejia. Am I allowed to ask which one of these you might read next? Or do we just see which number pops up in the lotto machine?
ELIZABETH: Well, while you were talking, I entered all three of them into my randomizer app and it's already chosen one for me, so I think I will be starting with Strike Me Down which sounds fantastic. I can't wait to get into the wild, wild world of forensic accounting.
ANNE: Words you never thought you'd say.
ELIZABETH: Never.
ANNE: That's what good books do. They take you places you've never been and never imagined you'd go.
ELIZABETH: I love it.
ANNE: Elisabeth, this has been a joy. Thank you so much for talking books with me today.
ELIZABETH: This has been so much fun. Thank you, Anne.
[00:44:23] ANNE: Hey readers, I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Elizabeth, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next now in 2026. Visit whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com for everything we referenced in today's episode, including the full list of titles we talked about today.
Sign up for our email list at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter. We will send you weekly updates about our latest episodes, plus news to know from What Should I Read Next? HQ.
Keep up with everything Summer Reading by following our show on Instagram at @WhatShouldIReadNext. And make sure you're following along in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, wherever you get your podcasts. When you hit "subscribe" so you get new episodes downloaded automatically, it helps us so much. Thanks in advance.
[00:45:14] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• The Body by Bill Bryson
Kings of the Wyld by Nicholas Eames
Mistress of Rome by Kate Quinn
The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow
• Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay
• The Once and Future Witches by Alix E. Harrow
• Sphere by Michael Crichton
• The Andromeda Strain by Michael Crichton
• Untamed by Glennon Doyle
• Girl, Stop Apologizing: A Shame-Free Plan for Embracing and Achieving Your Goals by Rachel Hollis
• Dexter in the Dark by Jeff Lindsay
• Force of Nature by Jane Harper
• Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed by Lori Gottlieb
• Since We Fell by Dennis Lehane
• Trail of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse
• Sex and Vanity by Kevin Kwan
• A Room with a View by E. M. Forster
• Crazy Rich Asians by Kevin Kwan
• Strike Me Down by Mindy Mejia
: Guest favorite book
• Modern Mrs Darcy Book Club
• WSIRN Ep. 485: A midyear reading check-in
• WSIRN Ep 440: Anne’s midyear reading check-in
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Backlist gems: still the wildest way we’ve heard to choose what to read next appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
Today’s guest is navigating a tough season, and as a result she is looking forward to a summer of books with heart that won’t be too emotionally draining. Kayla Crum is searching for what she calls light but not fluffy reads, and she’s not exactly sure where to find the types of titles she’s looking for.
Kayla’s an RN and freelance writer living in Grand Haven, Michigan, where she enjoys making the most of her Lake Michigan proximity by spending time outside with her family and reading on the beach when she can fit it into her schedule. When it comes to her summer reading quest, Kayla’s identified a specific type of story that is really working well for her. Today, Kayla is hoping I can help her understand why this specific setting is working so well, because she’d love to discover more books that satisfy in the same way.
I have ideas for Kayla, and I’m sure you do, too: please share your suggestions by leaving a comment below.
Connect with Kayla on Substack and at her podcast website.
[00:00:01] ANNE BOGEL: Are we just looking hotel books or is that one example of what's working for you?
KAYLA CRUM: That's one example. It's sort of a stand-in and a favorite, but I'm happy to have a summering book, people who summer in a different location, a boat book.
ANNE: No, I'm sorry. Why am I laughing? I think I'm laughing because it sounds so delightful.
Hey readers, I'm Anne Bogel, and this is What Should I Read Next?. Welcome to the show that's dedicated to answering the question that plagues every reader, what should I read next? We don't get bossy on this show. What we will do here is give you the information you need to choose your next read. Every week we'll talk all things books and reading and do a little literary matchmaking with one guest.
[00:00:50] Readers, early summer is our busy season around here, and we know that's the case for many of you as well. We like to build in intentional breaks to keep up with our TBR piles and everything else in our lives. So we are taking next week off to give our team an early summer breather. We will be back in your podcast players the following week, and in the meantime, we hope you enjoy exploring our archives of over 500 episodes. Visit us at modernmrsdarcy.com/podcast to explore both recent and backlist episodes.
Readers, today's guest is looking forward to a summer of books with heart that won't be too emotionally draining during a season of grief. I'm sure she's not the only one navigating a tough season, and I love this focus on what she calls light but not fluffy reads.
Today, I'm excited to welcome Kayla Crum to the show. Kayla's an RN and freelance writer living in Grand Haven, Michigan, where she enjoys making the most of her Lake Michigan proximity by spending time outside with her family and reading on the beach when she can fit it into her schedule. That sounds like the dream.
[00:01:54] Lately, Kayla's been navigating the grief of losing a loved one, and she's turned to favorite authors and stories to help her through. Kayla would like to add more books like these to her summer reading list, but she's not exactly sure what will scratch that itch.
She knows she's identified a specific type of story that is really working well for her, as you will hear today. Okay, I'll tell you now. Those are hotel books. And Kayla is hoping I can help her understand why this specific setting is working so well because she'd really like to discover more books that satisfy in the same way.
Let's get to it.
Kayla, welcome to the show.
KAYLA: Thank you, Anne. I'm delighted to be here.
ANNE: Oh, the pleasure's mine. Thanks so much for coming on today. Thanks for sending in your submission with an enticing topic.
KAYLA: Yes, I've sent several over the years. I think I've listened for almost 10 years, so it was so exciting to get the email that I got to come on.
ANNE: I often know this in advance, but I didn't realize that you'd sent in several times. Do you know when your first one was? Because I just searched my inbox and I can tell you.
[00:02:57] KAYLA: I don't know. Would it be like five years ago?
ANNE: Longer. Ooh. It was Sunday, November 17th, 2019.
KAYLA: Oh, wow.
ANNE: At 9:31 PM.
KAYLA: They tend to happen late at night, I think.
ANNE: Any idea what you may have loved and hated?
KAYLA: Oh, gosh. I mean, I think I used to always throw Anne of Green Gables out there as my lifetime favorite.
ANNE: You did.
KAYLA: Yeah.
ANNE: You did.
KAYLA: Yeah, but I don't know the others.
ANNE: They were Chris Cleave's Little Bee.
KAYLA: Oh, yes.
ANNE: And Lori Frankel's This Is How It Always Is.
KAYLA: Mm, good reminders of good books.
ANNE: And the book you wanted to love but just couldn't was...
KAYLA: I have no idea.
ANNE: It was Madeline Miller's The Song of Achilles. You did not like Patroclus.
KAYLA: I just didn't even finish it, which is... I wanted to. I've never tried again since then.
ANNE: Well, Kayla, I'm glad we're finally having this conversation on the show and not in the submissions inbox.
KAYLA: Me too.
[00:03:53] ANNE: Thanks for persisting. Readers, if you want to be on What Should I Read Next? in Kayla's seat, timing is everything. So if you've filled out that submission form before, there is no harm in doing it again. We're always looking for the right themes at the right time and books that we haven't talked about lately or haven't talked about at all, and would love to feature. I mean, would love to by virtue of the fact you're bringing them up mostly, but we're always looking for a wide array.
But Kayla, thanks for coming today. Would you tell us more about yourself than you've listened for a long time and submitted before? We always like to give our listeners a glimpse of who our guests are.
KAYLA: Yes. I'm a lifelong voracious reader. I make my home, born and raised, in Grand Haven, Michigan, which is a little beach town on Lake Michigan. I was a nurse by trade, and I'm still licensed, but left that several years ago to be a freelance writer, communicator, podcaster. I sort of help others communicate their stories, which has been very fulfilling for me. I love reading on the beach or anywhere, eating ice cream. I'm a summer girly, summer birthday. Love to play with my husband, my two-year-old, and our dog. So that's sort of me in a nutshell.
ANNE: Favorite ice cream flavor?
[00:05:10] KAYLA: I mean, I can't argue with a good just plain chocolate, especially if it's homemade by the ice cream shop. But grocery store ice cream, Ben & Jerry's The Tonight Dough is my go-to.
ANNE: That's a Bogel family favorite as well.
KAYLA: So reading-wise, I loved The Chronicles of Narnia as a child, were my home base for reading. I think I read all seven books seven times, and I was very proud of that. I feel like The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe was my entrance into reading. It was a read-aloud at school, and then that kind of kickstarted everything for me. I've always been a bit of an opportunistic reader, so anything that's readily available, you know, if it's lying around, my parents had it, my grandparents had it, whatever, Reader's Digest is there, I'm going to read it, even though I was like eight years old.
[00:06:04] ANNE: That sounds so much more inviting and complimentary than compulsive reader, which is what I've always used to describe myself, and others who will read like the back of the cereal box if that's the only reading material nearby.
KAYLA: Yes, like reading the shampoo bottles in the shower. Yes, if words are around, I will probably be reading them.
ANNE: Okay. Opportunistic.
KAYLA: Yes, opportunistic. Definitely, in high school, got into some of the popular fantasy series. Hunger Games was coming out at the time, Harry Potter, the movies were finishing up while I was in high school. So fantasy was big for me as a teenager. And then in college, I was pretty busy with college reading and nursing school things, but my roommates would make fun of me because I'd always have a fiction read going just while I brushed my teeth. So I had to have something going, and I had no time to read it, but I would read about one book per semester just by brushing my teeth and reading. So that was my little escape every day into fiction world, and probably got my teeth cleaner too.
[00:07:07] ANNE: I think so. Kayla, what's your reading like these days?
KAYLA: I became a mom two years ago, and I've shifted more towards audio. I had a big reading renaissance a couple years ago, probably in part due to the pandemic, and then had my daughter in 2024, shifted half and half pretty much to audio and physical or Kindle. I always have something going on audio, something going with my eyes.
I have recently been in a season of grief. My sister lost her husband to cancer in February, and have been reading as an escape. So leaning hard on Elin Hilderbrand, other beach-type reads, but also just really moving character-driven novels with heart that kind of meet me where I'm at emotionally, but don't devastate me. I feel like that's sometimes a tricky line to walk. But yeah, reading is definitely an escape for me from various things.
[00:08:12] I specifically saw your post recently about hotel books, and I love a hotel book. Many of my favorites are set in a hotel. I think way back to Eloise at the Plaza as a child, and this has been a favorite setting for me over the years. And so I wanted to talk to you about that today.
ANNE: Ooh, we can definitely do that. And we will explore more... or maybe we can do this now. First, I'm so sorry for your loss.
KAYLA: Aw, thank you.
ANNE: I know many readers, including myself, resonate with the idea of turning to books to escape into another world. But also I hear... so character driven novels with heart. I don't know, I think what's standing out to me is escape, but not avoidance.
KAYLA: I like that characterization, yes. And maybe something about a hotel book is even that hotels by nature are temporary, right? With few exceptions. It's like a temporary break from real life, and that's what I'm looking for in a book, too. I'm not looking to move to Alaska or you know, wherever.
[00:09:26] ANNE: Oh, so maybe hotel books are a nice place to escape to.
KAYLA: Yes, and in a temporary way, and then you know that they're going back to their real lives and I'm going back to my real life.
ANNE: But what if they're not, because the book is set in a hotel, but it's more about the staff than the guests? How do we feel about that?
KAYLA: I do like those, too. I recently read The Hotel Nantucket by Elin Hildebrand, and I felt like that focused mostly on the staff. I do love when the staff and the guests are characters, and you kind of get a peek into both.
ANNE: I'm trying to articulate, like envisioning my mental cobbled-together vision of The Hotel Nantucket lobby. But I'm imagining how even though the staff is somewhat, you know, it's semi-permanent, the hotel is still built around the idea of people coming and going, like of impermanence.
KAYLA: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Okay. So it's a holding place?
[00:10:28] KAYLA: Yeah. I'm trying to scratch out what it is I like about hotel books because a setting, I guess, is what it would be, because hotel books can spread genres, mysteries, and otherwise. But I do like when the hotel... I want to picture it in my head. I've read a few where you think you're getting a hotel book, but it's really more of just background. And I really do like when I feel like I could walk in in my head and picture everything, and it's almost a character in itself. I like the idea of nooks and crannies, and all the secrets of all the people that have stayed there. You know, it's just kind of whimsical and magical to me.
ANNE: You mentioned something about the idea of a book being set in Alaska.
KAYLA: Mm, yeah.
ANNE: How do you feel about a book being set in Alaska versus a book being set in a hotel? I'm just thinking there's the vastness of the one place and the minuteness, relatively speaking, of the other.
[00:11:26] KAYLA: I think Alaska appeals because of its remoteness and uniqueness. I've found that I also am drawn to island books, English manor houses, or on a boat. Like these closed sets, so to speak, to use a movie term. Like a locked-room mystery. I like something about there's like a container holding all of these various people in some way. And a hotel is just my favorite form of that. But I also like, you know, you're not getting to Alaska by accident. Does that make sense?
ANNE: It does, I think. Well, sometimes the truth emerges in contrast, thus bringing Alaska into it, but we'll set Alaska aside for now. That's a different conversation for a different episode. I wonder if there's something about the way a hotel setting is like the world made small.
[00:12:23] KAYLA: That sounds right to me. I like how people rub shoulders with people they might not meet on the street back home, right? Like it brings in various versions of people. I think I like the idea of play-acting a little bit. It's fun even if, like, I were to go on vacation, you're like, "I could be anyone. I could have made 1,000 different life choices." And just to kind of imagine a different life, or what if I lived here? And yeah, just seeing the possibilities, like you said, writ small within a hotel. It does feel like a world within the world.
ANNE: I'm playing with an idea of like you already have the solution, you have everything you need. Everything and everyone that is needed for the story is there or will come to you. I wonder if that's pinging anything for you.
[00:13:16] KAYLA: Yeah, like almost the opposite of a vast wilderness. Like the opposite of Frodo's journey in The Lord of the Rings where you have to trek forever and find everything. It's like everything's here and contained, and we almost just have to look among us or within us. I did like living in an apartment back in the day. I felt cozy, like nestled among the other families and lives. I think that's part of it, too, the communal living aspect.
ANNE: Or in another genre we might call that forced proximity and the interesting things that may happen as a result.
KAYLA: Right, like how the hotel brings together characters that you might not find side by side in another scenario.
ANNE: Yeah. Okay. And then in the blog post you're referring to that was written by our team member Ginger, she said that, sure, she's intrigued by what is sometimes a glamorous setting or sometimes the cozy one if we're talking about a little inn. But also there's the question of, like, what are the characters doing? Are they with a group? Are they alone? Are they a couple? Are they running to something? Are they running away from something?
[00:14:27] Hotels are where people go on purpose to make memories or to disappear or to get a needed escape or at times of transition. There's a lot of potential for drama there. But drama is actually not what I'm hearing draws you.
KAYLA: I do like the appeal of the glamour a little bit, and sometimes drama, but it doesn't have to have drama. I think I like to sprinkle more drama, glamour, rich people behaving badly. I do enjoy a book like that, but I need to mix it up with more inner heart-driven stories as well. And you can find both with hotel settings, it's just trickier sometimes.
ANNE: You can. All right, so it sounds of these, the idea that you've got a whole world that you can hold between your hands is a big part of the appeal.
KAYLA: I think so.
ANNE: And it gives your brain like someplace very concrete to visit.
[00:15:29] KAYLA: Yes. I mentioned reading Narnia as a child, and obviously that's a vast land, but I think that's similar. Or Anne of Green Gables is another childhood favorite. She lived on Prince Edward Island. Like, you go to these places, or with Ellen Hilderbrand, it's Nantucket, it's like, now I'm transporting to this specific place that's going to hold the whole story. I like that.
ANNE: Well, there's some great hotel scenes in the Anne of Green Gables books. I'm thinking of her and Diane wanting to eat chicken salad at the White Sands Hotel.
KAYLA: Oh, so true.
ANNE: Or they go eat dinner with Aunt... Is it Josephine?
KAYLA: Josephine.
ANNE: It might be tea in Charlottetown.
KAYLA: Yes. Yes. And it's such luxury to the little girls who are used to country life.
ANNE: It's a whole different life. All right. Well, we'll see where we can take you away to in the pages. Are we just looking hotel books, or is that one example of what's working for you?
KAYLA: That's one example. It's sort of a stand-in and a favorite, but I'm happy to have a summering book, people who summer in a different location, a boat book.
[00:16:28] ANNE: No, I'm sorry. Why am I laughing? I think I'm laughing because it sounds so delightful. Summer as a verb always makes me giggle a little bit.
KAYLA: That also feels like something wealthier folks do, like, "I'm going to go summer on the coast." I like a book like that, or really any sort of, yeah, I'm traveling to X location type of book.
ANNE: Okay. Now, some of these books are very warm, and some are snarky, and some are murdery, but I guess you already told us, character-driven novels with heart.
KAYLA: Yeah. Any of those things are welcome, but I do need character development as a primary tenet of the book.
ANNE: Okay, Kayla, what kind of genres do you find do and don't work for you? Or maybe it's more helpful to say they feel hospitable to you right now.
KAYLA: It's funny I grew up loving fantasy, but have not found any five-star fantasies for myself as an adult. So I'm not completely opposed, but that's just not typically what I read anymore. I love family dramas, historical fiction, classics, book club picks. That's kind of my usual.
[00:17:41] I do like murder mystery, think like Louise Penny or The Thursday Murder Club, so not gruesome, but not... I hesitate to use the word "cozy". I think cozy mystery has a bit of a nebulous definition.
ANNE: You said in your submission you were fantasy-curious. Does that apply today when we're talking?
KAYLA: Yes, although with the hotel theme, I'm not sure that that is an overlap we could find, but if anyone could do it, you could, so we'll see.
ANNE: Oh, were that only true, but I may have an idea or two. Kayla, this is important information about your reading life. Can we pile on more by talking about the books you love and don't?
KAYLA: Yes.
ANNE: You know how this works. You've brought three books you love, one you don't, and what you've been reading lately to the show, and I'd love to hear how they connect to what's working for you and what you're looking for right now. How did you choose these?
[00:18:40] KAYLA: I'd been thinking about books that, like I mentioned, were character-driven, had heart, and were sort of cathartic or moving, but didn't bring me low during this season of grief. And that's a tricky path to walk, maybe even bringing me to tears, but not in a devastating way. So these three books, and after I chose them, I realized they all have a female protagonist who could be considered somewhat unlikable, but you really peel back who she is at her core and why she ended up the way she is. That's sort of a theme I didn't even realize until I put them all down here. But they all-
ANNE: Wow. Okay, I love that.
KAYLA: They all scratch that itch of the character developing over time and feeling the emotions without being left in a desolate place, if that makes sense.
[00:19:41] ANNE: Yes. Okay, if I asked you to put me together a list like that, I think that would be impossible to do. But look, you did it accidentally.
KAYLA: I did.
ANNE: All right. Well, what do you have? What's book one that you love, if not already strongly implied?
KAYLA: The first book I loved was The Ice Cream Queen of Orchard Street by Susan Jane Gilman. First of all, any long title like that is going to draw me in, especially if you reference a street, like The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street as a middle-grade novel, or even just a name like The Penderwicks, just thinking back to my childhood. So the name alone caught my eye in the used bookstore, The Ice Cream Queen of Orchard Street.
And this is a book about a young immigrant girl who moves to America with her family in the early 1900s, ends up taken in by another family when hers passes away, and rises to be this super powerful ice cream magnate. And it sort of has a Forrest Gump feel in that you get to walk through the essential points of American history through the 1900s, but with the lens of this woman's life.
[00:20:48] We flash back and forth from modern day when she's elderly and undergoing a difficult lawsuit for her ice cream company, and then kind of going back to like, "Well, here's how I got here and here's why, you know, I shouldn't be sued for this." It's an interesting setup, and it's long. These days with my toddler, I don't know that I would've picked up a 500-page book, but I really enjoyed it a couple years ago. And it's primarily set in New York City, which is also a fun place I like to read.
ANNE: And in 1913, I think, which is a good ways back, how big a role does historical fiction play in your reading life these days? I'm just curious about, as far as places to escape go, how do you feel about the past?
KAYLA: I do love history. I was a big American Girl doll reader and enjoyer. I'm not opposed to it. I don't think I've been leaning on it much lately because, like beach reads, at least the ones I've been exposed to, and with the splashy beach covers that I've been reaching for, don't seem to have as much historical fiction among them as, you know, modern. But I'm not opposed to it.
[00:22:02] ANNE: Good to know. Kayla, what's the second book you love?
KAYLA: Same As It Ever Was by Claire Lombardo. This is really cheating because I could have put either of Claire Lombardo's books here. They're just so stunning. The way she writes about human relationships and emotions is just unparalleled. She really makes you feel for each character's position, particularly in this case the protagonist, Julia, who we kind of flash back and forth between her difficult season as a young mother when she's questioning her marriage, questioning every choice she's made to get her where she is now, and then we flash forward.
And so it's not a spoiler to say, like, you know she's still with her husband, she's still with her family, she's got this job. So you're like, "Okay, she was so unsure here, and yet she's settled here." So the book kind of draws you in that gap, helps you move from that difficult season of young motherhood to when she's sending her young adults off into the world.
[00:23:10] I just think Claire Lombardo is a master of peeling back the layers of why we do certain things, and why sometimes the people we're closest to are also strangers to us, and we might feel more comfortable divulging things to others. The knots we tie ourselves in as families and friends, she untangles all that so masterfully.
ANNE: I see what you mean. And what I'm really thinking about is where the space is for you between tears that feel cathartic and ones that feel devastating.
KAYLA: So, Claire's other novel, I think it's called The Most Fun We Ever Had, is actually about a group of sisters, one of whom lost a husband to cancer. So that's very relevant to me. I really liked actually how she wrote into that tension of, like, there's a sister with a normal life and happy children, and then a sister with this loss who's a widow. I thought she did a very real raw, but gentle at the same time, examination of the tensions in that relationship.
[00:24:23] So weirdly, even if it's right on the nose for me with that, I think I'd be okay with that. When I say "not devastating", I've noticed since I had my daughter, I don't want to hear about children being kidnapped or abused. Child abuse, not for me. I did love Florence Knapp's The Names, but I read that a while ago. I don't think right now I could handle those descriptions of domestic abuse. Does that help delineate it a little bit?
ANNE: Yes. Hard things happen in this world is okay.
KAYLA: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: The world is a terrible, hard place, and then it gets harder, and then we die, not okay.
KAYLA: Right. And specifically if there's, I think, a perpetrator, I don't know why this is coming to me right now, but I'm thinking of Florence's book, and yeah, like someone in your life who's just ruining everything and it just goes on and on. Yeah, not really here for that right now.
ANNE: When the person is the object of fear in like that very clear, purposeful way?
[00:25:28] KAYLA: I think I like to believe the best of everyone. And talking about these character-driven books, I like to see, you know, we all have our flaws, and yet we have this deep-rooted goodness. So when there's a character who's just not that at all, I struggle with that.
ANNE: Okay, so a book in which the author's worldview incorporates the idea that there is good in people and not we're all destined to devastate each other willfully because we hurt each other despite our best intentions, not because of our worst.
KAYLA: Yes, that's a good way to put it.
ANNE: Okay. We're gathering so much info. Kayla, what is your third favorite book?
KAYLA: The third book I brought is The Correspondent by Virginia Evans, so me and half the world. I saw this book everywhere. My mom read it in her book club and passed it along to me. I just think the biggest praise I can give it is that I was supposed to leave on a trip to Florida, and I had a little bit left in the book, and I was like, "I'll just sit at the kitchen counter and have a quick snack." It's like 10:00 at night and I haven't packed, and I just sat there and finished the whole book and was weeping, but in the best way.
[00:26:44] I just found Sybil, the protagonist, so... Endearing feels like too sweet of a word, but again, it's like a slightly unlikable or complex main character. But we get to peel back the layers of her relationships with various people in her life and the choices she's made along the way, and kind of see the why behind it. I thought that book scratched at how bad things can happen to any of us, and sometimes we are partly or mostly at fault, and that that is just life and how... It really examined the idea of holding yourself tenderly and trying for forgiveness and holding others the same way.
And it was, for anyone who doesn't know, written in an epistolary format with letters back and forth, which I do enjoy. And I think that too was just a fresh take and helped us take a look at Sybil in a new way. Like, we could kind of gather different clues from who she was talking to about different aspects of her character in a way that just like a first-person narrative or even a third-person narrative couldn't jump around and do.
[00:27:59] ANNE: Okay, so those are the books you loved. What didn't work for you? And please do tell us why.
KAYLA: I read Havoc by Christopher Bollen. That was a hotel book, which was why I picked it up. I will say I loved the hotel setting, the staff, our characters, the main character, who I am forgetting her name, but she... Another elderly woman, just like The Correspondent and The Ice Cream Queen of Orchard Street. So this is becoming a theme.
She's a guest at the hotel. You sense early on that she's perhaps an unreliable narrator, and I'm not opposed to that, but I won't say it's my favorite. So that was maybe the first red flag that it wasn't for me. The ending is what really ruined this book for me, and I don't want to ruin it for the listeners. But when you get to the end, and I had the feeling of like, it was all for nothing. I don't know. I don't need a happy ending, but I need an ending with some heart and hope, and this one did not have that. So it did not work for me.
[00:29:06] But it was a hotel in Egypt, and there was a fun little boy character, and this main elderly woman, and I wanted to like it so much, but the ending just... I couldn't.
ANNE: Kayla, what have you been reading lately?
KAYLA: I recently read The Hotel Nantucket by Elin Hilderbrand. I've been leaning on Hilderbrand books right now as an escape. So loved the setting of Nantucket and the hotel itself. This one is unique in the Hilderbrand canon because it has a ghost. I don't mind some light, friendly ghost. I'm not here for the scary things, but a little magical realism or like, oh, there's something a little supernatural in addition to the main plot is good with me. And loved how we were rooting for this new hotel to make it another year, and that the staff and the guests were sort of working together on that.
Also like half the world have been listening to The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion. So that's been a fun escape as well this summer. The narration is just so great.
[00:30:09] I'm almost done with Heartwood by Amity Gaige, which is thrilling for sure. It's a woman lost in the Maine woods, and you rotate between three different women's perspectives. I actually was loaned it by a friend back in the immediacy of my family member dying, and I was like, "Oh, I can't read this right now." Like, somebody lost in the woods and possibly dying is not for me.
But again, we're the opportunistic reader. Here it was laying around when I finished my last book, and so I picked it up, and it has been fun to have a book that has me like, "I have to keep reading," and I'm like staying up past my bedtime reading. So I'm almost done with that one. And that's been an escape of a different kind, you know, kind of keeping me turning the pages.
ANNE: Okay. So let's recap, if that's okay.
KAYLA: Yeah.
[00:31:04] ANNE: All right. Kayla, you loved The Ice Cream Queen of Orchard Street by Susan Jane Gilman, Same As It Ever Was by Claire Lombardo, and The Correspondent by Virginia Evans. The book that wasn't for you was Havoc by Christopher Bollen because you need an ending with heart and hope, and that wasn't it. Lately, you've been reading Elin Hilderbrand's The Hotel Nantucket, Amity Gaige's Heartwood, and Beth Brower's The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion. And there are a whole bunch of volumes of those that could keep you busy. How do you feel about having a series on deck like that?
KAYLA: That's been fun because it takes the work out of what you're going to read next, right? So just been queuing them up on my Hoopla app, and that's been a nice accompaniment to my chores.
ANNE: Okay. Glad to hear it. Kayla, is there anything else you want to put on the table as we think about what you may enjoy reading next?
KAYLA: I don't think so. We covered a lot of ground.
[00:32:01] ANNE: Kayla, I have ideas, and I definitely have emotional tone in mind, but my goal here is to give you the information you need to decide: is that a reading experience I want and that I'm ready for right now?
KAYLA: Mm-hmm.
ANNE: Okay, let's start with a fantasy book set at a little inn that I feel like I've talked about all the time on What Should I Read Next?. So maybe you've read it or maybe you've already decided it's not for you. But I'm thinking of Sangu Mandanna's A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping that came out last summer. Is this a book you know?
KAYLA: Now that you say the title, I think I've heard you mention it, but I don't remember anything about it.
ANNE: This is a fantasy novel that has a strong romance element. It's very grounded fantasy that features a found family. It does have that romance. It has strong platonic relationships, and it just has lots of cozy vibes.
[00:32:57] This book is about a witch named Sarah, who many years ago lost her magic because she cast a forbidden spell. And she has no regrets because she cast the spell to save the life of a cherished family member. She would do it again in a heartbeat, but it still stinks. And something I thought was so fun and charming about this story is it stinks for very practical reasons. Her great aunt that she saved runs this adorable welcoming inn that has serious Three Pines vibes.
KAYLA: Love that.
ANNE: There's a spell cast on the inn, and people who find the inn need the inn. And if you don't need the inn, you will not be able to find your way to it. And that sounds a lot like Louise Penny, which I enjoyed. But they're running this old inn together, and this inn has seen better days.
[00:33:55] And if Sarah could just use her magic to fix the boiler, it would relieve all the money stress they've been feeling. Because you could wallpaper that room, or you could just wave your wand. And it's much easier to wave your wand, but that option is not available to her right now.
So the inn is just super charming because I think in my head like it's just beautifully, charmingly, imperfectly, perfectly decorated. And you just want to cozy up in the corner of every room you're seeing in your mind's eye with a book. But there's also an enchantment that's been placed on it long ago.
Sarah cast a spell before she lost her magic. And the spell is whimsical and mischievous. Like, if there are empty teacups sitting around, then wildflowers are going to be blooming in them. Doors open and close, not in a menacing way, but just like, "Oh, hi, hello," kinda way.
[00:34:46] In one of the guest bedrooms, it rains apple blossom tea for an hour every Sunday, and then it stops, and nothing is a mess. But then several things happen at once. Sarah, for reasons, decides she has to get her magic back. And then also at the same time, the inn's spell draws in this gruff and also extremely good-looking magical historian to the inn, along with his little sister, who happens to be autistic, and she takes to the place immediately and never wants to leave. And the gruff, magical historian who's very, very good-looking is going to feature prominently in the plot.
This little group of strangers becomes extremely tight and they decide, "You know what? Together we can take on the big, bad, mean, magical dudes and cast this impossible spell and get your magic back." I don't know. How's that sounding?
[00:35:44] KAYLA: That sounds delightful, very cozy. I don't have time to learn an entire world, but I can learn an inn. You know what I mean? Like the world-building. So that sounds lovely.
ANNE: That sounds good. Okay, it's not a ghost story, but I'm just thinking about the way that characters' past pains and traumas surface in the plot. And it does have a little bit of a ghostly element, but people have been through hard stuff in this book, and that does definitely surface on the page. Based on what you've said, I think the pervasive tone is "this is hard, but your friends have you. Like, your loved ones have you, and this house has your back." I think that could be really important for you to know as you think about if this is a right book at the right time for you.
KAYLA: Yeah, that's a good note to know.
ANNE: Okay, I'm glad to hear it. Can we talk about a book that I don't know at all is perfect for you, but I still really want you to know about?
KAYLA: Yes.
[00:36:45] ANNE: This is a hotel book that's set on a thinly veiled version of Mackinac Island.
KAYLA: Ooh.
ANNE: And listeners, Kayla was kind enough to give me some Michigan recommendations before we got started, so at least maybe I can give you a Michigan book in exchange.
KAYLA: Yes, I would love that.
ANNE: Okay. This is new. It comes out in July 2026, so not quite yet, but very, very soon, and it's a debut family drama by Ryan Effgen called Make Nice. The tone is light, whimsical, but I'm wondering if this is right for you, because it's a little edgier than I think some readers are going to expect based on what this book sounds like.
[00:37:32] So at its heart, this is a story of three siblings who have been called back to... It's not actually Mackinac Island, but it's so thinly veiled that it was only in going back after I read it and reading the author's description again as I thought about Summer Reading Guide potential coverage. It's not in there, by the way, but I thought really hard about it, that I realized, wait, it's not actually Mackinac Island. It just sounds exactly like everything I've ever heard and read about Mackinac Island. And I'm definitely picturing the Grand Hotel that is one of the iconic images. There's no cars on the island. There's buggies. There's ice cream stands galore, gorgeous seaside, nostalgic parades, that kind of thing.
So in this book, Make Nice, it's about three adult siblings who reconvene at their father's request at the Grand Hotel on Mackinac Island for one last time. They have come to this place together their entire lives, usually with their mom, but their mom recently died. And Kayla, I do not remember how. That is backstory, not present tense in the plot.
[00:38:40] But each sibling wants to impress the others and show them how they are doing so great, everything is working, they're living their best life, but they do have these old rivalries and sore spots as siblings often do, and they end up upsetting each other and really getting into it, their history and their present together on the island.
The siblings are really fun to read about. There's three of them, two men and one woman. Corey is the family ne'er-do-well who has stolen a five pound block of cocaine that he has brought with him by Greyhound bus to Michigan, and he's thinking, "I'm going to sell this and make a bunch of money and solve my problems."
Then we have daughter Viv, who is dealing with a marital breakdown, but doesn't really want her siblings to know it because she's afraid they'll be like, "Hello, we told you so. We've been telling you for years."
And then we have Pete, who is a super nerdy snail scientist who has never quite fit in in his life. He works at a university. He's obsessed with these snails. But Pete's story made the novel for me, and I still have open tabs on my phone about Carthusian snails and Carrera marble in the Michigan shoreline thanks to his story, which I just loved. He really is living his best life on this Michigan island.
[00:40:10] There's a teenager who belongs to Viv, who's also in the mix and also the patriarch of the family. But this family has a lot of history, and it all comes to the surface in these intervening plots at the Grand Hotel. And I wonder if this is a book that is a little fun for the hijinks, but I wonder if the setting could make this especially interesting to you. I don't know. Are you interested in this at all?
KAYLA: This sounds right up my alley. I love the Michigan piece, but I also love a sibling story. I remember reading The Nest by Cynthia D'Aprix Sweeney kind of about siblings going at it a little bit. Also, as to the snarkiness or dark humor, I really enjoyed The Wedding People at that hotel on the East Coast. So I feel like what you're describing sounds just right.
[00:41:05] ANNE: I think lovable mess applies to so many of these characters. And if you enjoyed The Nest, this one is a little bit gentler. I was worried this might be a little too bristly for you. But if you enjoyed The Nest, I think you're okay. I mean, this really is a book... A sibling story is a plus, but this is location, location, location.
KAYLA: Love that.
ANNE: All right. Well, that is Make Nice by Ryan Effgen. And then if you haven't read any Kevin Kwan, you get a whole bunch of hotels in your 320 pages or whatever it is. Have you read Lies and Weddings?
KAYLA: No. He wrote Crazy Rich Asians, right?
ANNE: He did. Another good hotel story.
KAYLA: Yeah, I read that one, but not Lies and Weddings.
ANNE: Okay. This came out a couple summers ago. It was in the Summer Reading Guide then. And Lies and Weddings is a comedy of manners that is actually, I was surprised to discover, a retelling of Anthony Trollope's Dr. Thorne. But you can forget I told you that. And you don't have to know a thing about Dr. Thorne. I mean, I think some readers will be like, "I miss my English literature seminar days. I'm going to read them both side by side." But you don't need to know a thing about Trollope.
[00:42:14] This is a plot-driven book. It's not so much about character development in that everyone is larger than life in their lifestyle and a little bit in their personality, but the two main characters are not without their struggles and subsequent growth. But this is about a not exactly a single man in want of a wife, but a single man whose mother very much wants him to find a wife.
He is the Viscount St. Ives, who is known internationally as Viscount St. Abs after a photo of him ironing shirtless went viral. And he is not at all concerned with his believed to be obscenely wealthy family's money problems, because he would prefer to happily live out his days surfing in Hawaii. But his mother doesn't want the well to dry up, so she needs him to marry. She needs him to marry up and quickly. And of course, that's not what he wants to do. He doesn't want to marry at all, and well, there are the seeds of an old-fashioned marriage plot in that little setup.
[00:43:22] But what's so fun about this book is you get to follow him and his cronies around the world. And I so enjoy googling all the... I mean, all the locations of these luxury hotels that you can look up on maps and browse through the pictures of the lobby. And Kevin Kwan describes them with all the details, and sets things like wedding receptions and cocktail parties, and just waiting for your pals in the lobby, and it's so much fun. And they do ridiculous and expensive things like go on group hot air balloon rides, and visit these jaw-droppingly beautiful botanical gardens in Morocco. That browser might still be open on my phone from two years ago. I probably shouldn't tell anybody that.
But the food, the clothes, the wines, that you could google and be like, "Oh, that's $600 a bottle, huh?" The specific glitzy intersections where things take place, the cars they collect, the watches, the handbags, the other luxury goods. In that sense, I think Kevin Kwan and Elin Hilderbrand are very similar in that they both add a lot of texture to their stories by letting a lot of the physical settings and material goods do a lot of the lift on characterization for their people.
[00:44:33] This has a vibe not unlike The Guncle Abroad, if we have any Steven Rowley fans listening, Kayla, if you're one of them. But this is just frothy and fizzy and escapist, but not without its substance. And it does have that classical anchor here. How does that sound?
KAYLA: That sounds fun. Yeah, I read The Guncle, but not The Guncle Abroad, so that's kind of a two-for-one. I should read both that and this one. This sounds like a fun escape.
ANNE: All right, I'm glad to hear it. Kayla, for our next book, I wonder how a Vermont inn sounds to you as a setting.
KAYLA: Yes, that sounds nice.
ANNE: Okay. Have you read any Elinor Lipman? I'm thinking about The Inn at Lake Devine.
KAYLA: The name Elinor Lipman is ringing a bell, but I can't think of what I might have read by her.
ANNE: Okay. She's been writing since the '90s, and is prolific, with a book coming out every couple of years.
KAYLA: Wow.
[00:45:23] ANNE: So this one is, oh gosh, late '90s, early 2000s. And this is a love story and a family story that's grounded very much in the real world. This is a first-person tale narrated by a woman named Natalie Marks. And this story talks about hard things, as it's a story about two couples who are of different religious faith backgrounds, whose parents are really unhappy when they get together. But the tone throughout is one of, "We're going to work it out. It is going to be okay." I feel like the reader feels really supported through the whole story.
But Natalie's family was in Massachusetts, and every year they summered, the verb, either by the lake or by the beach. And one summer they sought out this place called The Inn at Lake Devine in Vermont, and got a letter back from the proprietor that said, "We don't take people like you because our guests are all Gentiles." And this happened to Natalie's mom, not our narrator, Natalie. But when Natalie was young and she watched this happen, she was angry, but she was also very curious, and she had a contrarian streak in her, and she grew up thinking, "Well, wouldn't it be fun to infiltrate this place?"
[00:46:53] So in her teens, she figured out a way to spend a summer at the inn. And then when she grew up and trained to be a chef, she gets invited along to a wedding at the inn, to a society kind of wedding. So Natalie goes, and she cooks, and when she falls in love with someone there at the inn, neither of the parents are happy.
But this is a comic novel, and they are going to work it out. And I wonder if you may not enjoy just the story of people working through differences in a way that hopefully feels authentic but also safe. But also just the details that we see from all sides of life at the inn. But we get to see the perspective of her being a teenager, and then an adult, and then a special guest, as she's in a wedding party, and then she's a chef at the inn as well. And I wonder if all those perspectives will be a nice, well-rounded hotel story, and some for you.
[00:48:00] KAYLA: Yeah, I love the through-the-lifetime approach. That reminds me of The Ice Cream Queen that we talked about, and Same As It Ever Was. So, yeah, that sounds really fun.
ANNE: I'm glad to hear it. And I kind of want to give you a sad one that might be too sad, but it might also be really good. So are you comfortable with wielding the power of making the call, but hearing about a sad book?
KAYLA: Yeah, I can always tuck it away for later, too.
ANNE: Okay. Have you read any Mary Lawson?
KAYLA: No.
ANNE: Okay. She is a Canadian author who was shortlisted for the Booker for, let's see, maybe in the past five years. It's called A Town Called Solace. Her debut was Crow Lake, that Will Bogel has talked about a lot in these parts. And I know we've talked about Solace and Crow Lake on the podcast.
[00:48:52] Road Ends is coming to mind because it's a recent one I read, and I did not expect it to be a hotel book, but I loved that storyline so much. For readers who know Lawson or Crow Lake, this book is set in that same story world, and there's a slight overlap of characters, but you do not need to read one with the other.
So, like all of Lawson's novels, this is set in northern Ontario, and there's a little town called Struan that is far north and remote. And this story starts in that small community in the 1960s. This is a novel about a large family in a hard place. And we mostly hear from the two eldest children, who are like 21 and 23 when the novel begins. But to zoom out a little, their parents are married unhappily. They never meant to get married. At least the father never meant to marry the mother, but because of World War II, that's what happened.
[00:49:54] The mother keeps having babies because she loves and dotes on her infants. But once they exit infanthood... Is that a word, Kayla, infanthood?
KAYLA: Infancy.
ANNE: Once they exit infancy and move on, once they can walk and talk, she is uninterested. It's like they don't exist. She is mentally unwell, but none of the family members can quite put a name to it. And the firstborn daughter, secondborn child, Megan, has been keeping the wheels on the wagon for a long time. She has been parentified since about the age of six. She has been running the household.
And when the story opens, she is about done. And exacerbating her sense of doneness is that her elder brother, Tom, who could ostensibly help her, is dealing with his own crisis because his best friend died under circumstances that are still haunting him not that long before. And Tom had this promising career in naval aviation. He was going to go to Seattle and work for Boeing, but he is stuck, and he's okay with that for right now.
[00:50:59] And the family is at this crisis point. Like, somebody has to step in and do something, because the mother's having another baby, and they cannot keep this going the way things are. Oh, and the father's just absent. He's just denial and avoidance. But that's not the tone of the whole book. But that is the situation.
At the beginning of the story, Megan gets an opportunity to leave for London to visit a friend, and she's like I don't have to tell my parents how half-baked this plan really is. I just gotta get out of here. And she leaves, and what we see in the rest of the story is split narratives of Megan trying to make her way in London, and gosh, it is terrifying at first, because she does not have a plan when she leaves. And it's the '60s. It's not like she can call up her friend on the cell and be like, "Hey, where are you? Help me. Let me in out of the rain so I can start my British life." And then we're back in this small town, Ontario, where this family is struggling.
[00:51:57] And I think the things that are hardest in this story is they aren't just struggling emotionally, they are struggling physically, and there's a four-year-old child whose mother has forgotten about him because he's not a baby anymore. He can walk and talk, but he's being neglected, Like basic things. Like he's wetting the bed and nobody's cleaning it up. He doesn't have any clothes. He hasn't had a bath in weeks, like that kind of stuff. And it's hard.
But what I didn't expect about this story, because people having a hard time and Mary Lawson was not surprising to me. She often puts her characters through it, and I've read enough of her books now to trust she will bring me back to a place that feels redemptive, where maybe it's not great, but it is okay, and I can see it's getting better.
But Megan ends up through... Well, through a little bit of stick-to-it-iveness, but a lot of sheer luck. She ends up falling in with a couple who are passionate about renovating old homes into hotels, and they have taste and style and vision, and she throws herself into the work with them.
[00:53:05] And I wonder if that perspective of building a boutique British hotel from... Not building it, I mean, the building is there, but creating it out of shambles into a classy place with a swanky bar and lots of cachet and travelers from all over the world. I wonder if that would be an interesting and appealing angle to you.
More happens in this book, but the combo of family drama, serious character development over time and across vast spaces, and also that really interesting and unexpected hotel angle will add up to something special for you. How does that sound?
KAYLA: I'm liking the hotel angle, and I normally love a messy family story. The neglect piece is sort of hitting me a little wrong right now, but I'll definitely tuck this title away for maybe when I'm in a better place.
ANNE: That sounds like a good place to put it. All right, Kayla, we're going to stop there. How is all this sounding to you? How are you feeling about looking forward in your reading life?
[00:54:19] KAYLA: This is exciting. I knew you could do it, but I was afraid you would throw out hotel titles I'd already heard of, so I'm excited that there's so many out there, and I also feel you've helped me scratch at or broaden my net for finding these hotel-adjacent stories.
ANNE: Oh. Okay, I'm thrilled to hear it. Now, of the ones we talked about today, I'm so curious to hear what you may read next. We've got A Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna, Make Nice by Ryan Effgen, not out yet, but very, very soon, Lies and Weddings by Kevin Kwan, The Inn at Lake Divine by Elinor Lipman, and that last one, Road Ends by Mary Lawson. Kayla, what do you think?
KAYLA: I feel most drawn to Make Nice, but since that won't come out till July, I think I'll start with, is it The Witch's Guide to Magical Innkeeping? Did I get the title right?
ANNE: Yes, you did.
KAYLA: That sounds cozy. I'm excited.
[00:55:21] ANNE: All right. I'm glad to hear it. Kayla, this has been a pleasure. Thanks so much for talking books with me.
KAYLA: Thank you.
ANNE: Hey, readers. I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Kayla, and I'd love to hear what you think she should read next. Find Kayla on Substack. We have all her links, as well as the full list of titles we talked about today at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com.
Make sure you're following along in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Overcast, Pocket Casts, wherever you get your podcasts. When you follow or subscribe to our show, that means you'll never miss a new episode. It also helps us out a lot.
Please join our email list for weekly updates on our latest episodes and other news from What Should I Read Next HQ. Sign up at whatshouldireadnextpodcast.com/newsletter.
Follow our show on Instagram @WhatShouldIReadNext. We love it when you tag us in your summer reading stories.
[00:56:16] Thanks to the people who make this show happen. What Should I Read Next? is created each week by executive producer Will Bogel, Media production specialist Holly Wielkoszewski, social media manager and editor Leigh Kramer, community coordinator Brigid Misselhorn, community manager Shannan Malone, and our whole team at What Should I Read Next? and Modern Mrs. Darcy HQ. Plus the audio whizzes at Studio D Podcast Production.
Readers, that's it for this episode. Thanks so much for listening. And as Rainer Maria Rilke said, "Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading." Happy reading, everyone.
• Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery
• Little Bee by Chris Cleave
• This is How it Always Is by Laurie Frankel
• The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller
• The Chronicles of Narnia by C. S. Lewis
• The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
• Eloise at the Plaza by Kay Thompson
• The Hotel Nantucket by Elin Hilderbrand
The Ice Cream Queen of Orchard Street by Susan Jane Gilman
• The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street by Karina Yan Glaser
• The Penderwicks by Jeanne Birdsall
Same As It Ever Was by Claire Lombardo
• The Most Fun We Ever Had by Claire Lombardo
• The Names by Florence Knapp
The Correspondent by Virginia Evans
▵ Havoc by Christopher Bollen
• The Unselected Journals of Emma M. Lion by Beth Brower (Audio edition)
• Heartwood by Amity Gaige
• A Witch’s Guide to Magical Innkeeping by Sangu Mandanna
• Make Nice by Ryan Effgen
• The Nest by Cynthia D’Aprix Sweeney
• The Wedding People by Alison Espach
• Lies and Weddings by Kevin Kwan
• Crazy Rich Asians by Kevin Kwan
• The Guncle by Steven Rowley
• The Guncle Abroad by Steven Rowley
• The Inn at Lake Devine by Elinor Lipman
• Road Ends by Mary Lawson
• Crow Lake by Mary Lawson
• A Town Called Solace by Mary Lawson
: Guest favorite book
▵: A book they didn’t love
• 10 books set in hotels
• Please support our sponsors.
The post Seeking light but not fluffy summer reads for a good escape appeared first on Modern Mrs Darcy.
From the publisher's feed