Coming back off of a two-week hiatus, the ghost-hosts did not disappoint! Mak covers the massive ghost story of the Crescent Hotel in Arkansas, complete with tangents on the mega dorm controversy and Emily’s Taco Bell shenanigans. Emily follows the cross-country exploits of the Happy Face killer, not to be confused with the smiley face gang or the smiley face killings conspiracy.

This episode... wow. What can even be said?

Mak somehow blurs the category line once again by talking about the famous "Devil made me do it" case of Arne Cheyenne Johnson in Connecticut. It has everything, from murder to demons, to the Warrens. Emily, meanwhile, decides to give everyone yet another heart attack by talking about the famous dinosaur deniers, AKA the Big Paleo conspiracy.

Alternately titled: Ghost Boat Gets Revenge 2K21

Alternately-alternately titled: Pirate Trauma

Ladies, gentlemen, and them-tlemen, this episode has a THEME! Mak and Emily, with no planning, somehow both brought pirate-themed stories this week! Join Mak in her retelling/ deep dive of the famous creepypasta Candle Cove, and Emily's coverage of the Flying Dutchman.

Not to mention this episode comes with a reading of the original creepypasta, and a terrible summary of the Pirates of the Caribbean movies.

Mak skips the whole ghost part of this episode and instead summarizes Pretty Little Liars for Emily. Juuuussttt kidding... kind of. The summary does happen, it just happens right after Mak talks about Bloody Mary, the demon in the mirror. Meanwhile, Emily comes in with the chessboard killer from Russia, and his many strange hobbies, along with The Office.

Somehow, Mak manages to talk about Maura Murray in one hour, following her last days as well as conspiracies around her disappearance. Emily, meanwhile, brings in the hollow earth conspiracy theory and wraps it up with Godzilla, and Ice Age.

(This episode was filmed in front of a live studio audience)

Mak really toed the line of the categories this episode, bringing ghosts who have solved their own murders. Emily stayed true though, with the famously haunted Hollywood Roosevelt Hotel. Between Marlyn Monroe, Superman, and a creep, this episode has more than its fair share of hauntings.

You know, one day there will be an episode that isn't full of rants about Sam and Colby. Today is not that day. Join Mak and Em on a discussion about the infamous Sallie House haunting in Kansas, and the unsolved case of America's missing boy.

Mentally prepare yourself for the doozy that is Episode 21. Mak brings the case of the missing Dylan Redwine, and a suspicious Dr. Phil episode. Meanwhile, Emily brings the mother of Reddit conspiracy, Eliza Lamb.

Tangents, Wendigos, and Pennhurst, oh my! This episode really has it all, complete with tangents about wedding dresses, stolen turtles, octopi, Minecraft, and more! Not to mention the podcast get's to welcome back Erin, who's entertained by Mak's Wendigo's and Emily's Pennhurst Asylum.

Join Mak and Emily in discussing the famous Island of Dolls in Mexico, and the Green Beret Murders. This episode is made extra bone-chilling with cameos from Harold the Doll, and a literal ice pick.