
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In this one-minute teaser, get a glimpse of Murder on Horsetooth—a true crime podcast unraveling the mysterious death of Paul Gallenstein at the beloved Horsetooth Reservoir near Fort Collins. Discover how a serene recreational haven turned into the backdrop for unanswered questions, and join us as we set the stage for a deep dive into the case that shocked a community. Subscribe now to follow every twist and turn.
From the publisher's feed
Murder on Horsetooth is a narrative true-crime podcast that investigates Paul’s death and the questions that still haunt the trail where he was found. Was it an accident? A robbery gone…
Through public records, interviews, and firsthand reporting, this series explores the mystery surrounding Paul’s final moments and why so many questions remain unanswered.
Because sometimes… even the most peaceful places hide the darkest stories.