In this episode, we slice into the premiere of "Mystic Pizza" at Paper Mill Playhouse, the musical adaptation of the beloved 1988 film. We knead through the dough of this jukebox musical, exploring how it serves up 80s nostalgia with a side of cheesy romance. Does this pizza deliver a satisfying theatrical meal, or is it a half-baked attempt at bringing the cult classic to the stage? We dish out our thoughts on the direction, design, and performances, with a particular focus on the standout female leads. Join us as we debate whether this retro recipe has the right ingredients for Broadway success or if it's better suited for smaller venues. Is "Mystic Pizza" a delicious new addition to the musical theater menu, or does it leave you craving something more original? Tune in for our piping hot take on this nostalgic musical adaptation.

Follow and connect with all things @HalfHourPodcast on Instagram, and YouTube. Share your thoughts with us on "Mystic Pizza" on our podcast cover post on Instagram.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices