
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Study Guide Nazir 10
Today’s daf is sponsored by Tina Lamm in memory of her grandfather, Gershon Katz, Gershon ben Yochanan HaCohen v’Chaya Toba, whose yahrzeit is today. If someone said, "My cow/door said I am a nazir if I stand up/open," Beit Shamai and Beit Hillel disagree about whether the person becomes a nazir by this declaration. Rabbi Yehuda says, as in the previous Mishna, Beit Shamai meant this only if they explained it as referring to being a sacrifice and it then will be forbidden like a vow and not as a nazir. The Gemara questions how we can be discussing a talking cow/door? Rami bar Hama and Rava each bring explanations for the Mishna. Rava rejects Rami bar Hama's explanation as it doesn't match the wording of the Mishna. Rava's explanation is also rejected, but he tries another two attempts to explain it until he finds an explanation that is not rejected.4.7
4040 ratings
Study Guide Nazir 10
Today’s daf is sponsored by Tina Lamm in memory of her grandfather, Gershon Katz, Gershon ben Yochanan HaCohen v’Chaya Toba, whose yahrzeit is today. If someone said, "My cow/door said I am a nazir if I stand up/open," Beit Shamai and Beit Hillel disagree about whether the person becomes a nazir by this declaration. Rabbi Yehuda says, as in the previous Mishna, Beit Shamai meant this only if they explained it as referring to being a sacrifice and it then will be forbidden like a vow and not as a nazir. The Gemara questions how we can be discussing a talking cow/door? Rami bar Hama and Rava each bring explanations for the Mishna. Rava rejects Rami bar Hama's explanation as it doesn't match the wording of the Mishna. Rava's explanation is also rejected, but he tries another two attempts to explain it until he finds an explanation that is not rejected.90,523 Listeners
316 Listeners
280 Listeners
5,526 Listeners
179 Listeners
190 Listeners
370 Listeners
1,080 Listeners
2,894 Listeners
991 Listeners
550 Listeners
15,295 Listeners
1 Listeners
303 Listeners
520 Listeners