In this episode of The Never Seen It Podcast, we dive headfirst into Paul Thomas Anderson’s “One Battle After Another,” one of the most talked-about films of the 2025–2026 awards season. With a stacked cast including Leonardo DiCaprio, Sean Penn, Teyana Taylor, Chase Infinity, Regina Hall, Wood Harris, Tony Goldwyn, and Benicio Del Toro, this film has quickly become a lightning rod for controversy, praise, and heated debate.
We start with a spoiler-light overview of the premise:
After their extremist nemesis resurfaces 16 years later, a group of former revolutionaries reunite to rescue the daughter of one of their own—only to realize that the past is far from buried.
From there, we ask the big question:
Can “One Battle After Another” actually win Best Picture?
With ten films competing—including Sinners, Hamnet, Marty Supreme, Train Dreams, and Begonia—we debate whether the Academy is spreading the love too thin, or quietly signaling which film will be the “safe” winner.
The First Act: A Masterclass or Too Much, Too Fast?
We spend a lot of time on the explosive opening act set in an internment camp, where we meet Leo and Teyana Taylor as revolutionaries fighting against a militarized white supremacist faction led by Sean Penn’s chilling “Lockjaw.”
Some of us call it a screenwriting masterclass—a bold, in-media-res plunge into character, motivation, and chaos. Others feel it’s intentionally rushed, designed to shock us into the story rather than let us live in it.
Politics, Relevance, and Timing
We wrestle with the idea that this film arrived at the exact wrong—or right—moment. The movie’s themes of extremism, surveillance, rebellion, and generational trauma feel ripped straight from today’s headlines.
Is it art imitating life… or life imitating art?
Chase Infinity: The Next Breakout Star
We also spotlight Chase Infinity’s performance as the daughter caught between revolution and survival. The visual parallels between her and her mother—especially the machine gun imagery—become one of the film’s most powerful generational echoes.
Who Should Win the Oscar?
Opinions clash:
Some of us think Sinners will sweep the night.
Others believe Hamnet is the Academy’s “safe” choice.
A few of us argue that One Battle After Another is too bold to ignore—and might win because of the political climate, not in spite of it.
And yes… we also go on a few wild tangents about:
The Patriots conspiracy theory
Bad Bunny, Green Day, and the Super Bowl
Desert Hot Springs, colonics, and cults
And why Timothée Chalamet might need to calm down 😅
It’s chaotic, it’s hilarious, and it’s one of our most passionate film debates yet.