Not Boring by Packy McCormick

Not Boring by Packy McCormick

By Packy McCormickBusinessEntrepreneurship
Download on the App Store

Not Boring by Packy McCormick episodes

  • We Good Now? (Audio)

    Welcome to the 997 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 41,668 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts

    Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Masterworks

    Last week, you might have heard that the art market went—as they say in b-school—absolutely bonkers, setting a nice new record of $69 million for a nifty digital artwork. The takeaway? Art investing has hit the mainstream. But perhaps putting your money in physical art by the blue-chips makes more sense for you. Me, I own 5 paintings on Masterworks 👨‍🎨

    Contemporary art has outperformed the S&P by 172% from 2000–2020, according to data from Masterworks. They were the first platform to let you invest in paintings by the likes of Basquiat, Kaws, and Haring. But what about returns? They’ve got that too: They sold their first Banksy work for a cool 32% annualized return to investors.

    With results like that, it’s no wonder there are over 17,000 people on the waitlist. To skip the line, just use my special link, tell them the Packy sent you, and you’ll be good to go.

    P.S. Here's some important legal info from Masterworks

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday! 

    Today’s essay is one that I’ve been waiting a long time to write: WeWork is going public. 

    I’m bringing in the big guns for this one: Dror Poleg. Dror literally wrote the book on the future of real estate -- Rethinking Real Estate. Dror’s writing combines history and future, and is brilliant, nuanced, and balanced, words that don’t often describe WeWork coverage. 

    We’ve waited years for this. We can’t wait any longer.

    Let’s get to it.

    We Good Now?

    by Dror Poleg and Packy McCormick

    If I told you about a company doing $3 billion in revenue, leading a multi-hundred-billion-dollar market, that offers the easiest way for Fortune 500 companies to do flexible work, counts Amazon, Microsoft, Walmart, Goldman Sachs, Spotify, Netflix, IBM, and Airbnb as customers, and is going public at a $9 billion enterprise value (EV), would you buy it? 

    What if I told you it’s burning $3.2 billion per year, has historically failed to meet nearly every target it set, and has to do construction every time it wants to increase its inventory? And that it had to pull a planned 2019 IPO due to investor disgust at the founder and CEO’s antics. Would you buy it then? 

    This is the WeWork enigma. It has done some truly mind-blowingly impressive things while burning mountains of Masa’s money. If it weren’t for some huge unforced errors, it would have gone public at a valuation near $50 billion way back in 2019, before COVID supersized remote work valuations. It rode a positive narrative to the moon, and came crashing down when the narrative flipped. 

    We all know We. The company’s story was everywhere in the fall of 2019. WeWork’s failed IPO was a car crash of epic proportions, and we all rubber necked. As someone who worked for a WeWork competitor, Breather, I watched it all with particular schadenfreude (this is Packy, speaking for myself). 

    But since its public failure, it installed new management, flew under the radar, and refocused on its core business. It’s less exciting, but more solid. Its business model is neither inherently terrible nor is it as high-margin, high-growth as a pure software business. 

    When WeWork was private, figuring out WeWork was SoftBank’s problem. We could afford to laugh at the company’s story without thinking too much about the actual business. But now that BowX SPAC’d it at a seemingly reasonable $9 billion valuation on $3 billion in revenue (in this economy?!), it’s worth taking a closer look. Today, we’ll do that: 

    * The Royal We. Adam Neumann was narcissistic and brash… exactly what was needed to shake up office real estate. 

    * WeStory. From 3,000 sq ft in Soho to millions across the world, fueled by an epic hype flywheel.

    * From WeWork to We. Neumann pushed the company outside of office and into a little bit of everything. 

    * IPOh No! WeWork’s attempted 2019 IPO failed spectacularly thanks to unforced errors, and the company brought in new management, refocused, and trimmed down.

    * WeSPAC. On Friday,Vivek Ranadivé’s BowX SPAC announced that it’s taking WeWork public at a $9 billion valuation.

    * Side Note: Masa is a Genius Again. Masa is on a tear. WeWork breaking even would be the icing on his comeback cake. 

    * WeWork by the Numbers. The refocused WeWork is a straightforward business. 

    * The WeWork Bear Case. This time, maybe it’s the market’s fault. 

    * The WeWork Bull Case. WeWork survived, erased its mistakes, and is perfectly positioned to capture value in a more flexible world.

    * Back to the Future. You know who would have been a perfect CEO for this market?

    Look, no one expected us to be publicly defending Adam Neumann less than we, but here we are.

    The Royal We

    Maybe Adam Neumann really was the savior Adam Neumann thought Adam Neumann was. 

    For the first eight years of WeWork’s life, the We Story was the Adam Neumann story. The two were inextricably linked. He was the Royal We.  

    The WeWork co-founder and ex-CEO was a narcissistic cult leader who made off with billions and left employees and investors holding the bag. 

    * He regularly called his direct reports’ direct reports into late-night meetings to publicly embarrass their bosses. 

    * He pushed his co-founder, Miguel McKelvey, aside to give his wife Rebekah more power. 

    * He personally trademarked “We” and sold it back to his own company for $6 million. 

    * He established what is quite possibly the dumbest fucking financial metric in financial metric history: Community Adjusted EBITDA. 

    * He set delusional goals for himself: “becoming leader of the world, living forever, amassing more than $1 trillion in wealth.”

    But Adam Neumann was also the perfect person to launch WeWork, shake up the sleepy commercial real estate industry, and change the way that people rent office space.

    Commercial real estate isn’t like software, a fact that critics pointed out over and over again as WeWork’s valuation soared to $47 billion. In the world of bits, a polite, meek coder can spend months locked away in a dark room, emerge with a brilliant piece of software, put it up for sale on a website that anyone can access, and let the market decide whether what they built is worth paying for. It’s pretty close to a meritocracy. 

    Commercial real estate is an oligopoly. A handful of families, companies, and Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) own the vast majority of the desirable real estate in the world’s major metropolises. They own buildings and collect rent checks. Life is pretty good if you own the right piece of real estate, so landlords are not known for being particularly forward thinking or open to change. Polite and meek don’t work in real estate.

    Adam Neumann almost sunk his company, but he was also the right person, in the right place, at the right time to get it off the ground in the first place. 

    With the benefit of hindsight, it’s easy to say that WeWork should have done all of the good stuff and none of the bad stuff. They should have done revenue share deals with landlords instead of taking on lease obligations. They shouldn’t have thrown big parties. Adam should have been more straightforward and honest. 

    But you can’t have your cake and eat it too. A quieter, more conservative WeWork wouldn’t have had the scale, money, shine, or leverage to make a dent in commercial real estate. 

    WeWork was the disruptor. Like Napster, it broke some rules. Normally, the disruptor makes a lot of noise, spends a lot of money, and fails. Someone else swoops into a shaken industry, works with landlords, and builds a solid business. 

    But in this story, Adam met Masa. SoftBank’s billions both choked WeWork and kept it alive. Adam got the boot, and rightly so. His company, under new management, lives to fight another day. 

    What’s unique about this story is that WeWork is both Napster and Spotify. It’s disruptor and partner, destroyer and builder. Somehow, eleven …



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    42 min
  • What's On Deck for On Deck? (Audio)

    Welcome to the 404 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 41,075 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this memo straight in your ears: listen on Spotifyor Apple Podcasts

    Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Important, Not Important

    The world is changing, and the issues we face are not only connected, but enormously complex. Climate, infectious disease, pollution. To stay smart and do our part, we need to seek out the most reputable news sources and identify the most effective ways to take action.

    That’s where Important, Not Important comes in.

    Important, Not Important is a free weekly newsletter that curates the most vital science news of the week, providing a generalist analysis you can use to better understand what’s happening, and data-driven Action Steps to tell you what the hell to do about it, all in 10 minutes or less.

    In short, Important, Not Important exists to make you feel less fucking terrified and more in control. Selfishly, I read it because today’s biggest challenges are also some of the best investment opportunities. Want to go deeper? They have a podcast, too, featuring conversations with some of the smartest humans on the planet.

    Hi friends 👋 , 

    Today, On Deck is announcing that it’s raising a $20 million Series A led by Keith Rabois at Founders Fund with participation from Learn Capital, Chamath Palihapitiya, Slack Fund, Village Global, Eric Yuan, Fred Ehrsam, Allison Picken’s The New Normal Fund, Charles Hudson at Precursor Ventures, Adam D’Angelo, Jen Rubio, Elad Gill, Julia DeWahl, Henry Ward, Afton Vechery, Jules Walter, Eric Su, Julia Lipton, Scott Belsky, Anthony Pompliano, Bloomberg Beta, Dylan Field, Aarti Ramamurthy, and many, many more members of the On Deck community. 

    I’m thrilled that Not Boring is able to invest alongside that crew to help support the creation of a modern educational institution for the future of work.

    I’m particularly excited about this one as an On Deck alum and someone who once tried (and failed) to do a fraction of what On Deck is doing.

    Let’s get to it.

    What’s On Deck for On Deck?

    A Not Boring Investment Memo: A $20 million Series A to Rebuild Education

    When Not Boring Was Not Boring Club 

    "Find ways of staying curious and learning new things, because it's super sad to think your last day of college is the last day you are taught something new." 

    — Kevin Systrom, Founder, Instagram

    Before Not Boring was a newsletter, it was Not Boring Club, an idea I had for a mashup of social club and continuing education, Soho House meets college extracurriculars for busy and ambitious people. My thesis was that people wanted a combination of lifelong learning and community that was more interactive than online education and much, much less expensive than an MBA, within the flow of their daily lives. I hated that the end of college meant the end of learning with friends.

    To validate the opportunity, I did what I do to think through something: write. In July 2019, I wrote Why There Isn’t a Dominant Aggregator in Online Education. The numbers backed up the need for new (continuing) education models: 

    * Education is one of only two of the top 10 consumer spending categories (at 2% of total consumer spend) not owned by an Aggregator. 

    * In 2015, the US government spent $649 billion on K-12 education, US colleges spent $559 billion to educate and support their students. That spend accounted for ~7% of US GDP. 

    * In 2018, student loan debt passed $1.5 trillion, and is continuing to grow. 

    * $107 billion is spent on online education globally (and that was before COVID).

    Good enough for me. When it was time to leave Breather and really go for it, I decided to do what an increasing number of founders do: apply to On Deck. I got in, and joined ODF2 in New York. I remember getting into the Slack, joining the #intros channel, and thinking that I was so far out of my depth. On Deck put together one of the most talented groups of people I’ve ever been a part of.

    Turns out, On Deck was a lot of the things I was looking to build: education, community, network, friendships, and career opportunities. I made friends and connections in On Deck that I still talk to daily.

    Then the pandemic hit. After briefly trying to bring the Not Boring Club online, I threw in the towel. On Deck, which had previously been entirely in-person, went the other way and stepped on the gas. It quickly moved online, welcomed global applicants, and scaled up at breakneck speed. 

    Over the past year, On Deck has done something insanely hard: scaled community and education, online, profitably, while growing revenue 10x and building out a platform on top of which it can launch new products and integrate acquired ones such that each is a desirable standalone offering that connects to and strengthens at least one other part of the ecosystem. If that’s a lot in one sentence, that’s because On Deck has done a lot.

    While it’s so hard to avoid On Deck on Twitter that joining and/or working for On Deck has become a meme, I agree with #2 Not Boring referrer and VC Hunter Walk: 

    On Deck is undercovered and underappreciated relative to the strength of its business model, the frenetic pace of its progress, and the potential size of its impact (these excellent posts by Jake Singer, Paul Millerd, and Nick DeWilde aside). That’s what we’re here for. 

    EdTech and community have traditionally been hard categories to invest in. How did On Deck just raise $20 million from some of the world’s best venture investors? Let’s dig: 

    * On Deck Investment Thesis.

    * Natively Integrated Education.

    * Platform and Team Constellation. 

    * The On Deck Opportunity.

    On Deck is building more than a new kind of educational institution. It’s building a new way to build. 

    On Deck Investment Thesis

    On Deck is dramatically reimagining continuing education by breaking it into smaller atomic units, each of which feed off of each other to create a better customer experience, strong Lifetime Value, and deep moats that will protect its high price point and margins over time. 

    The On Deck investment thesis is a Russian Doll: there’s what they’re building, what that looks like today, and how they’re building what they’re building. 

    What they’re building: On Deck is building a modern, digitally native education platform at a fraction of the time and cost of traditional higher and continuing education. 

    What that looks like today: On Deck is comprised of 17 different programs, which themselves are comprised of smaller cohorts, which all roll up into a broader On Deck ecosystem. Each new program feeds into the others, providing “supply” for a “demand” the team has identified in existing programs. For example, On Deck Angels supplies capital to On Deck Founders, while Founders reciprocate with access to exclusive dealflow.

    How They’re Building What They’re Building: The meta, how On Deck is building what it’s building, is the most unique and fascinating part. The team is building a platform on top of which it can plug in new programs. As I was thinking about what makes On Deck special, I saw this tweet:  

    On Deck doesn’t make programs, it makes organizations that make programs. And it does so incredibly quickly. On Deck launches new products and programs more quickly than pure software companies do, while managing all of the complexity of dealing with real humans. 

    When I joined, On Deck only had its Founders Fellowship. Today, a little over a year later, it has fellowships for Founders, Angels, VCs, No-Code, Writers, Podcasters, leaders scaling companies, people looking to join startups as one of the first 50 employees, Community, Climate, FinTech, and more. In eight months, they went from one fellowship to this: 

    One of the challenges with both community and top-tier education is that it’s really hard to scale. There’s something called “evaporative cooling,” which is when the quality of the people and interactions in a community decreases as more people join. On Deck has one of the most credible…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    28 min
  • The Dao of DAOs

    Welcome to the 675 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 40,671 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts

    Today’s Not Boring sponsor asks: Looking for a new investing app?

    Unclear what J.R. Smith is looking for here. Perhaps a new investing app, in which case he may want to check out Public.com, the investing social network I’ve written about before.

    Much like J.R. Smith’s jumper, the stock market can be unpredictable. Sometimes you just don’t want to be alone with your charts and numbers and that’s where Public comes in.

    Public is an investing app AND a social network for talking about business trends, and the social features make it easy to share ideas in a fun way. Join me there by hitting the link below. Btw, if you’re looking to transfer your account from somewhere else, they’ll even cover the fees.

    *Valid for U.S. residents 18+ and subject to account approval. Transfer fees covered for portfolios valued at or over $150. See Public.com/disclosures/. J.R. Smith is in no way affiliated with Not Boring or Public.com.

    Hi friends 👋 , 

    The fun part about working for myself is that I don’t have a job description, but if I did, one bullet might go something like this: “Hang out on the internet and translate the most interesting things you find.” 

    A few months ago, I started seeing tweets about NFTs. I had no idea what they were then, but the people working on the edges did, so I read and talked and thunk and wrote. I wrote to learn as much as anything. Now, NFTs are everywhere. Beeple’s Everydays sold at Christie’s for $69 million. Your grandmother probably owns some NFTs. It’s moving fast out there.

    Now, all of those people who were tweeting and Clubhousing about NFTs are on to the next: DAOs. DAOs, or Decentralized Autonomous Organizations, are, apparently, what comes next.

    Each new depth I plumb in the world of Web3, the more out of my depth I feel. When I told Jess Sloss, who runs Seed Club, that I was exploring DAOs, he wrote: “🐇  meet 🕳”. I’m at the very top of the hole, and exploring out loud. I won’t have all the answers, but hopefully, we’ll learn something together. 

    Let’s get to it.

    The Dao of DAOs

    (You can click on ☝️ to go straight to the full post online)

    The Ether (ETH) that hackers stole from The DAO on June 17, 2016 would be worth $6.6 billion today if it weren’t for the fork. 

    Launched on April 30, 2016, The DAO was an early Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO) and venture capital fund. 11,000 people invested 11.5 million ETH, 14% of the total supply at the time, worth roughly $150 million, which they planned to collectively invest in crypto projects. 

    Unlike a traditional fund, in which institutions and high net worth individuals (Limited Partners or LPs) invest money into a fund that other people (General Partners or GPs) invest into companies, investors in The DAO would be able to vote on proposals based on pre-set rules, established in smart contracts. Each person’s vote was weighted by the number of tokens they held, which was based on how much they had invested. If a proposed project received enough votes, the smart contract automatically triggered the investment of The DAO’s funds into the project’s ETH wallet.  

    Two weeks into The DAO’s crowdfunding campaign, TechCrunch wrote, “The DAO is a paradigm shift in the very idea of economic organization. It offers complete transparency, total shareholder control, unprecedented flexibility and autonomous governance.”

    Then, less than two months in, on June 17th, hackers hit The DAO and took out 3.6 million ETH. At the time, that amounted to around $50 million. Today, with ETH trading at $1,851, the stolen ETH would be worth $6.6 billion, placing it among the most expensive hacks of all time. 

    The hackers aren’t billionaires today, though. The funds were put on a 28-day hold based on the terms of the smart contract, which gave The DAO and the broader Ethereum community nearly a month to figure out what to do. After a contentious debate, the Ethereum core team, led by Vitalik Buterin, released a hard fork of the Ethereum blockchain. It was essentially a new version in which everything was the same, except in the forked version, the heist never happened. 

    The Ethereum core team couldn’t force people to move over; people voted with their feet, answering this question: does the benefit of erasing the hack outweigh the cost of human interference on trust in Ethereum? To most, it did. While some people continued to use the Ethereum blockchain on which the heist had occurred, renamed Ethereum Classic, the Ethereum we all know and love is the forked version. If you look at the Ethereum blockchain today, you won’t find any trace of the heist. No harm, no foul. 

    From NFTs to DAOs

    Off-chain, there was some harm though: namely the death of DAOs’ early momentum. While you’re probably at least familiar with the terms Bitcoin, Ethereum, DeFi, and NFT, chances are, you don’t know what the hell a DAO is. In fact, the last 400 words probably read like gibberish. 

    But DAOs are re-emerging, five years later, with a diverse set of use cases, a growing software toolkit, and new governance and incentive models. A bunch of smart people I follow have been talking about DAOs recently, as the “what’s next” after NFTs.

    When Jill talks, I listen. So I decided to go down the rabbit hole, and it’s way deeper than I expected. 

    NFTs are relatively approachable. They’re easy to capture in catchy headlines. “Expensive JPEGs?! LOL.” Because at their most basic, they’re simple: they make digital media ownable and collectible, and people sometimes pay a lot of money for them. 

    DAOs sit a level above NFTs -- DAOs can own NFTs and create NFTs, plus do a whole lot of other non-NFT things -- and have more transformative potential than NFTs. An NFT is a piece of digital media; a DAO could be a whole media company.

    Because they’re more complex, they’re not nearly as easy to capture in a headline, soundbite, or price tag. But that’s what we’re here for. 

    This is the beginning of an exploration, a walk through my own process of figuring out what DAOs are, how they work, how they interact with the rest of Web3, what advantages they have, and where all of this might lead. We’ll start simple, and then we’ll build up: 

    * Enter the DAO

    * Ethereum and DAOs

    * Uniswap versus Coinbase

    * Forking SushiSwap

    * Progressive Decentralization

    * Why DAOs?

    * The 7 Powers of DAO

    * DAOs Today and Tomorrow

    All roads lead to DAOs. A lot of the more exploratory pieces I’ve written -- Secure the BaaG, Power to the Person, We’re Never Going Back, The Value Chain of the Open Metaverse, and Conjuring Scenius -- pointed towards DAOs without me knowing it. Those pieces all asked a version of the question: how are we going to work, invest, create, and play together in an increasingly digital and global world? 

    If Power to the Person was about how much a single individual can accomplish alone, DAOs are about how much we can do together.

    But wait. What’s a DAO?  

    Enter the DAO 

    Note: If you’re unfamiliar with Web3, or need a refresher, read The Value Chain of the Open Metaverse.

    Let’s start with a definition. In her post, A Beginner’s Guide to DAOs, Scalar Capital’s Linda Xie gives a good one:

    A decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) is a group organized around a mission that coordinates through a shared set of rules enforced on a blockchain.

    A DAO is “decentralized” in that it runs on a blockchain and gives decision-making power to stakeholders instead of executives or board members, and “autonomous” in that it uses smart contracts, which are essentially applications or programs that run on a publicly accessible blockchain and trigger an action if certain conditions are met, without the need for human intervention. 

    More simply, DAOs are a new way to finance projects, govern communities, and share value. Instead of a top-down hierarchical structure, they use Web3 technolo…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    37 min
  • Soundtrack the World (Audio)

    Welcome to the 2,104 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday!If you aren’t subscribed, join 39,996 (so close!) smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen here or on Spotify (in ~30 minutes)

    Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Secureframe

    Secureframe helps companies get enterprise ready by streamlining SOC 2 and ISO 27001 compliance. Secureframe allows companies to get compliant within weeks, rather than months and monitors 40+ services, including AWS, GCP, and Azure.

    Whether you’re an enterprise or a small startup, if you want to sell into enterprises, you’re going to need to be compliant. Secureframe makes the process faster and easier, saving their customers an average of 50% on audit costs and hundreds of hours of time.

    Secureframe’s team of compliance experts and auditors are happy to help answer any questions and give you an overview of SOC 2 or ISO 27001, even if you don't need it today. Schedule a demo and learn how:

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday! 

    Today’s post is one that I’ve been wanting to write for a while, made timely by some big funding news last week.

    It’s Fantasy M&A time.

    Let’s get to it.

    Soundtrack the World

    (You can click on ☝️ to go straight to the full post online)

    Back in April 2019, a recruiter reached out to me about a role I might be interested in: Managing Director, North America at Epidemic Sound. I’d never heard about Epidemic before. It was a fast-growing Swedish music company, but not that fast-growing Swedish music company. But I was itching to leave Breather and I decided to take the interview. After an hour in the office, I was sold. 

    Epidemic Sound’s mission is to “soundtrack the world.” It commissions artists to make music, which it licenses royalty-free to content creators who want to avoid dealing with all of the messiness of music labels and Performing Rights Organizations (PROs). The team was sharp, passionate, strategically savvy, well-read, and Swedish. The company had patiently grown for ten years and was beginning to bring its two ecosystems -- creators and musicians -- together in powerful ways. It was a dream job. 

    I didn’t get it. Epidemic went with Spotify’s former Australia Head, Kate Vale. Told you they were smart; that was very obviously the right call.

    In July 2019, Epidemic raised $20 million at a $370 million valuation. Last week, Epidemic announced a massive $450 million raise at a $1.4 billion valuation from Blackstone and EQT, a solid 12x increase from the reported €100 million valuation at the time of my interview.

    After I left the first day of interviews, my first thought was, “Spotify needs to buy this company.” The time wasn’t right then, though. Now, even at a 12x higher price tag, I think it is. 

    Spotify is coming off of a phenomenal year. It’s stock price has more than doubled year-over-year. It’s rolling out new features and products at a rapid clip. Its podcast Streaming Ad Insertion is showing early signs of working. And it’s charging labels to get their artists’ songs heard by more listeners. At 40% music streaming market share, the labels need to play ball with Spotify. 

    In late February, it hosted its “Stream On” event and Analyst Q&A. Without explicitly saying it, Spotify is slowly increasing its power over the record labels to whom it pays out the majority of its revenue. Things are going well for Spotify, but that arrangement is a thorn in Spotify’s side. It depresses margins.  

    Spotify backward integrated into supply via podcasts, and it should do it again in the core of its business, music streaming, by acquiring Epidemic Sound. That’s right, it’s Fantasy M&A time. I’ll tell you a little about Spotify, a little about Epidemic, and then walk through the rationale of a merger. 

    * Spotify’s Problem with Labels

    * Spotify Streams On

    * Enter Epidemic Sound

    * Spotify x Epidemic

    The logic for the deal starts with Spotify’s long-standing problem with labels. 

    Spotify’s Problem with Labels 

    Spotify changed the music industry by working with the music industry. 

    In 2001, Napster let people download songs for free, which predictably crushed sales. From a 1999 peak of $14.6 billion, the US music industry shrank to $11.8 billion by the time Daniel Ek founded Spotify in 2006, and another $3 billion to $8.8 billion by the time it launched in Sweden in 2008. 

    The music industry sued Napster into oblivion, but the genie was out of the bottle. Spotify wrangled the entropy Napster created, and more broadly that a new form of digital distribution made inevitable. Spotify worked with the labels, and listeners could pay one monthly subscription fee (or listen to some ads) to access most of the world’s music in one easy-to-use interface. That came with a cost for Spotify -- they had to pay the labels the majority of the revenue they brought in through subscriptions and ads. 

    Music labels, the biggest of which are Universal Music Group, Sony Music Entertainment, and Warner Music Group, do a few important things for artists: A&R Support and Funding, Marketing and Promotion, Distribution, and Admin. Until recently, making a high-quality recording of a song required expensive studio time, sound engineers, and producers. Getting that song out to people required expensive distribution and the right relationships with radio stations, record stores, or Digital Service Providers (DSP) like Spotify, Apple Music, or Tidal. All of that cost money, which most new musicians don’t have. 

    So they sign with labels. The label pays the artist upfront (an advance) and pays for all of the upfront costs of making, marketing, and distributing an album or song. In exchange, they get paid first when the artists start making money. After the labels recoup their costs, they pay the artist a percentage of revenue on an ongoing basis. Artists generally make 13-20% of ongoing revenue from major labels that paid them an advance, and can make up to 50% with smaller indie labels that don’t pay advances. 

    Labels have traditionally made the most money in the music value chain. To see why, let’s look at an example. Take an artist who signed with a major record label, and assume they’ve paid back the advance and upfront costs and receive 15% of streaming royalties. 

    For simplicity, let’s say Spotify makes $10 billion total, and this artist’s songs make up 0.1% of all streams (meaning its share of revenue is $10 million), and that Spotify pays out 70% of revenue to the labels (in range with reality). 

    Here’s how the payments flow from the $10 million attributable to the artist:

    * Spotify pays out $7 million and keeps $3 million (30% gross margin) 

    * The Label makes $5.95 million of the $7 million (85%)

    * The Artist makes $1.05 million of the $7 million (15%) 

    Plus, the labels own the valuable back catalogs (unless they sell them off to an investor; see Taylor Swift v. Scooter Braun). That gives them massive leverage over Spotify and the artists. If Spotify wants the songs that its listeners want to listen to, it needs to work with the labels.

    In Earshare: The Idiot’s Guide to Investing in Spotify, I wrote about the predicament that Spotify was in coming into 2020: 

    In its current state, it is essentially a marketplace business with little leverage over the supply side, the labels who own the valuable back-catalogs of music that the demand-side of the marketplace demands. Spotify pays about 70% of subscription revenues out to the labels for the right to stream their artists’ music...

    Adding to the complexity, as part of its early licensing deals, Spotify gave 18% of its equity to the record labels. Most of the labels have sold off their stakes, but Universal Music Group still owns roughly 3.5% of the company. If it sells, it will split the money with its artists. 

    For most of Spotify’s life, it’s been in a weird spot with the labels: it, along with other DSPs, have been largely responsible for saving the music industry, but the labels still hold…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    32 min
  • UserLeap & Differentiating Insights (Audio)

    Welcome to the 1,747 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since Sunday!If you aren’t subscribed, join 39,474 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by… UserLeap

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Thursday!

    Our little Not Boring family is growing — nearly 7,000 of you joined the party in the past month alone. That’s wild. I continue to be amazed that this is my job.

    One of my favorite parts of the job is writing Sponsored Deep Dives. (More on how I pick sponsors here). I love getting to tell you about the next big companies before they take off. The first two companies I did Sponsored Deep Dives on — MainStreet and Pipe — announced $60 million and $50 million fundraises this week, respectively.

    Today’s sponsor, UserLeap, is already taking off. Public companies like Square, Opendoor, Adobe, and Dropbox use it to collect and categorize real-time customer feedback, and the company has raised $20 million from First Round and Accel.

    You’ll be hearing about UserLeap a lot more, and interacting with it to share your insights on your favorite products across the internet. You heard it here first.

    As always, I’ll tell you how I’m getting paid: today is a mix of CPM and CPA.

    Let’s get to it.

    UserLeap & Differentiating Insights

    Acting On Continuous Research 

    If you’ve made it to the bottom of these essays over the past few weeks, you’ve probably noticed something new: 

    That’s a microsurvey I set up in five minutes working with today’s sponsor, UserLeap. UserLeap, which is backed by Accel and FirstRound, helps product teams continuously discover customer needs and evaluate the user experience via short, highly targeted surveys (microsurveys) displayed contextually within the product. 

    The magic of UserLeap is that it quantifies qualitative feedback by collecting rich, written responses, in real-time, and using machine learning to analyze and categorize the responses to pull out themes. 

    An example would help, and I’m an open book, so I’ll share what you’ve told me: 

    I’m proud that 92% of responses are good and above, and it’s awesome to see that people generally love these Sponsored Deep Dives, but the point of continuous research is to adjust and improve in real-time. To whit, the most common negative feedback is that sponsored posts, “Feel like ads with no analysis.” Ouch. 

    That’s only four people out of the 631 responses you’ve left, but UserLeap recommends that I take action, so let’s do it. This is going to be a meta-post: I’m using today’s sponsor’s product to make my Sponsored Deep Dives even better. I’m taking your input to heart and beefing up the analysis in this one. UserLeap’s working already. 

    To that end, today, we’re going to cover: 

    * The Need for Speed

    * The Modern PM Tech Stack vs. User Research Tools

    * Meet UserLeap

    * Building Moats in a Competitive Market

    * UserLeap’s Vision: The Two KPIs

    UserLeap is free for up to 10,000 monthly tracked users (more on why later), and if you or your company builds something online, you should go sign up for it now: 

    The Need for Speed

    UserLeap founder and CEO Ryan Glasgow joined his first startup as founding PM in college. The company, ExtraBux, was acquired by eBates in 2010, but that’s not the important part of the story. The important part is that to build a relatively straightforward company, Ryan and team had to set up their own servers, build out their own infrastructure, and run their own PHP. 

    That was a familiar experience for anyone starting a company a decade ago, or even five years ago. It will always be difficult to start, run, and grow a company, but just a few years ago, it was hard to just start one. Today, starting a company is much, much easier, because many of the startups launched over the past couple of decades were built specifically to make starting and scaling a company easier. Just last night, Lattice CEO and UserLeap investor Jack Altman tweeted:

    This is an ever-present theme in Not Boring, so excuse me while I do the Ben Thompson self-referential thing for a minute. 

    Just this Monday, Ben Rollert and I wrote about a wave of no-code and low-code startups Inspired by Excel that “aim to create powerful general purpose, highly flexible software targeted at a broad audience, including non-technical users.” With the rise of Inspired by Excel products, the universe of people who can create software products ballooned from the 25 million or so software developers in the world to everyone with a computer. 

    Two weeks ago, in Power to the Person, I wrote about the idea that, “Thanks to new tools and technologies, we are nearing the point at which the costs of carrying out a transaction through the market are getting so low that firms are less necessary.” More powerful tools mean that one person is able to build a bigger business than multi-thousand-person companies could a few decades ago. One of the reasons for that is the explosion of API-first companies, about which I wrote:

    When a company chooses to plug in a third-party API, it’s essentially deciding to hire that entire company to handle a whole function within its business. Imagine copying in some code and getting the Collison brothers to run your Finance team.

    These developments are incredibly exciting. AWS, Google Cloud, Netlify, Stripe, and hundreds of other products mean that people and companies are able to focus on doing the things that they do best without having to worry about all of the slow and painful work of setting up servers, building their own authentication and security from scratch, figuring out how to accept payments, or doing many of the things that each individual startup had to do just to get off the ground not so long ago. 

    As a result, the cost of starting a startup has come down dramatically over the past few decades, and particularly over this past one. More entrepreneurship is a great thing for the world, but it also presents a challenge, which I summarized in Shopify and the Hard Thing About Easy Things: 

    Here’s the hard thing about easy things: if everyone can do something, there’s no advantage to doing it, but you still have to do it anyway just to keep up. 

    The lower something’s cost, the more demand for it. As building products and starting companies got cheaper, more and more people started doing it. As fewer and fewer company hours and resources went towards setting up servers and infrastructure, more and more time has gone towards iterating on the product itself. 

    Taken together, building something good enough has gotten easier, everything has gotten a lot faster, but standing out from all the noise is harder than ever.

    The question, then, is no longer, “Can we get this product to market?” but “Can we create a product that customers love?” 

    That has huge implications for how startups are built and what they focus on. It’s why CEOs are spending less time coding in dark rooms and more time on Twitter, to lend some of their personal brand to their company. It’s why every company now seems to talk about their “community.” It’s why “10x designers” are suddenly harder to hire than 10x engineers.

    This trend isn’t new. It’s been obvious that things have been getting faster and more competitive for a while. That’s why most software that product teams use is fast, easy, and integrated. User research software has not kept up. 

    The Modern PM Tech Stack vs. User Research Tools 

    Almost daily on Twitter, one Product Manager or another tweets out their tech stack, the set of tools that they use to help build great products. Lenny Rachitsky, who literally writes the book (well, newsletter) on product management, polled his audience in December to see which tools the most PMs rely on (tweet here).

    Each one of these tools is easy to set up, fast, and collaborative. Each has a free plan through which users can get a good sense of whether the product will work for their needs. This is what PMs have come to expect. 

    For PMs and growth teams that want to better understand their users on a quantitative level, there’s a set of modern tool…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    23 min
  • Excel Never Dies (Audio)

    Welcome to the 1,359 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! 🤯 If you aren’t subscribed, join 37,881 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by … Michael Bolton

    (Okay, not actually Michael Bolton. But he does star in this sponsor’s latest ad campaign, so ... close enough.)

    I’ve talked (and written) about Public.com before, so you know the deal. One part investing app, one part community where you can discuss business trends and companies you believe in. 

    Some of you might be looking for a new brokerage these days, so you should know that Public is making the process of transferring your portfolio over ridiculously easy. They’re even covering the transfer fees from your old brokerage.

    For this week only, download the app with my link and you’ll start with $20 in free stock.

    You can even follow me and Michael Bolton there (@packym and @michaelbolton, respectively). Our music video drops soon 🔥

    *The fine print: This offer is valid for U.S. residents 18+ and is subject to account approval. Free stock offer valid for new accounts only. See Public.com/disclosures/

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday! 

    One of the places I learn the most is a group chat I have with my friends Dror Poleg and Ben Rollert. Dror, who writes about the history and future of work, cities, and finance, and Ben, who is the founder and CEO of Composer, are two of the smartest people I know. 

    Ben, the most technical of the trio (followed by Dror, then me), also happens to be an excellent writer. In late February, he released The Composer Manifesto, to make the case for investing as a creative endeavor. It’s tailor made for the two types of people who read Not Boring -- investors and tech people -- and you should read it: 

    So when Ben texted us about how underrated Excel’s power is, I asked him to write about it with me. He opened my eyes to so much depth I didn’t know existed in the product in which I spent every waking hour for the formative years of my career. We’ll try to do the same for you. 

    Let’s get to it.

    Excel Never Dies

    In the popular marketing book Alchemy, Rory Sutherland writes, “A spreadsheet leaves no room for miracles.” We could not disagree more strongly.

    Most software we use at work exists in one of two categories: 

    * It’s new and we love it for now. 

    * It’s old but we have to use it and we hate it. 

    But there’s one software product born in 1985, before many of us were even a twinkle in our parents’ eye, that inhabits its own category: it’s old, but we love it, we always will, and you’ll have to pry it from our cold, dead, fingers. That product, of course, is Microsoft Excel. 

    Anyone who has worked in finance or consulting grew up on it, learned to love it over thousands of hours of practice and improvement. Whether they realized it or not, they were becoming programmers, or at least no-code practitioners before the no-code movement took off. “Proficient in the Microsoft Office Suite” is so meaningless that it’s become a meme, but the ability to bend one specific Office program, Excel, to one’s will is a badge of honor. 

    But the enduring, passionate user fervor for the product isn’t even its most unique attribute. Excel’s most lasting impact extends beyond the spreadsheet itself.

    Excel may be the most influential software ever built. It is a canonical example of Steve Job’s bicycle of the mind, endowing its users with computational superpowers normally reserved for professional software engineers. Armed with those superpowers, users can create fully functional software programs in the form of a humble spreadsheet to solve problems in a seemingly limitless number of domains. These programs often serve as high-fidelity prototypes of domain specific applications just begging to be brought to market in a more polished form. 

    If you want to see the future of B2B software, look at what Excel users are hacking together in spreadsheets today. Excel’s success has inspired the creation of software whose combined enterprise value dwarfs that of Excel alone. There are two main ways Excel has set the broad roadmap for the B2B software industry for decades, and will continue to for years to come:

    * The Unbundling of Excel. Hundreds of B2B startups have been built by taking a job currently being done in Excel and trying to accomplish the job in more optimized, purpose-built B2B software. Every time you hear an entrepreneur say, “We’re replacing siloed spreadsheets and outdated processes with purpose-built software,” you’re hearing the Unbundling of Excel in real time. Many popular SaaS applications fall in this category. And yet, despite being “unbundled,” Excel keeps getting stronger. 

    * Inspired by Excel. That resiliency has inspired entrepreneurs to look more deeply at what makes Excel tick, and why. Adventurous builders are creating new software that doesn’t unbundle Excel, but is Inspired by Excel. Excel’s balance of usability and flexibility can be found in popular no-code and low-code products created over three decades since Excel first graced the screen. This source of inspiration is less direct and more meta; it is less about recreating anything concrete that happens in Excel, and more about capturing the essence of what makes Excel so successful.

    We love Excel, everyone reading this probably loves Excel, and still, its impact is deeply underappreciated. Today, we’re going to fully appreciate it by covering: 

    * The History of Excel

    * Excel as a Language  

    * The Lindy Effect

    * Excel’s Limitations 

    * No-Code and the Unbundling of Excel

    * Why Excel Will Never Die

    A little competition isn’t new to Excel. It was born fighting.

    The Spreadsheet Wars

    We have Steve Jobs to thank for Microsoft Excel, and Microsoft Excel to thank for Apple. Spreadsheet software was the first truly killer app for the Mac and home PC, and the Mac’s graphical interface helped bring spreadsheets to the masses. The two propelled each others’ growth.  

    Excel wasn’t the first digital spreadsheet. When HBS student Dan Bricklin had to decide between doing spreadsheets for a case study by hand or on the school’s mainframe, he, like so many entrepreneurs, realized there had to be a better way. He launched VisiCalc, a “visible calculator,” in 1978. Computer Associates followed two years later in 1980 with SuperCalc. That same year, Mitch Kapor sold VisiPlot/VisiTrend to VisiCalc’s parent company, Personal Software, for $1 million, and joined to work as a product manager on VisiCalc. 

    In 1982, Kapor left to build a yet-to-be-named product that combined the spreadsheet with graphing, and somehow convinced Personal Software to carve the product out of his non-compete. “I am not sure why they agreed to this,” he wrote in an email, “Perhaps they felt I lacked credibility to pull off something this ambitious. If so, they underestimated me.”

    Kapor founded Lotus in 1982 and launched 1-2-3 in 1983. In its first year of operations, Lotus did $53 million in revenue and IPO’d. The next year, it tripled revenue to $156 million. SaaS has replaced discrete sales as the go-to business model for software because it’s better for the customer, generates recurring revenue, and can lead to a higher Lifetime Value, but no SaaS company has ever put up such big numbers as quickly as Lotus did.

    The same year Kapor founded Lotus, Bill Gates and the Microsoft gang released its first spreadsheet software: Multiplan. It was notable for using R1C1 addressing (row then column) instead of A1 (the column then row we’re used to), for aiming to be the most portable spreadsheet application, runnable on over 50 different computers, and not for much else. 

    Lotus 1-2-3 crushed Multiplan, and Microsoft went back to the drawing board with “Project Odyssey.” They originally built Odyssey to be a better spreadsheet than Lotus 1-2-3 on the PC, but two critical things happened during development that would catapult the project into a lead that it still holds today, 36 years later. 

    First, was the team’s motto: “Recalc or die.” According to Jeff Raikes,…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    37 min
  • Jack of Two Trades (Audio)

    Welcome to the 2,105 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! 🤯 If you aren’t subscribed, join 36,522 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen here or on Spotify.

    This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Future

    Future is the 1-on-1 remote personal training app I use to stay in shape despite my sedentary profession. I’ve been working with my coach, Alex, for over three months now. I missed a workout in that first month, but thanks to the accountability he provides, plus the fact that I have to share my stats with all of you, I haven’t missed one in the last two months!

    That said… I did lose the 2021 Challenge to Mario and Rishi. I owe them each a share of Roblox, but I’m actually cool with it. Future has kept me consistent with a baby and an unstructured schedule. Four expertly-designed workouts a week, every week. 

    If you want to build a consistent, high-quality workout routine, or amp it up and get in the best shape of your life, get yourself a Future account and your very own professional Coach.

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday!

    One of my favorite parts about writing this newsletter is getting to meet incredibly smart people who are so much more knowledgable about their focus area than I could ever be. If I’m really lucky, those people happen to be writers, too, and I get to team up with them. Today, I’m lucky.

    Marc Rubinstein is a former financial sector-focused hedge fund manager who writes one of the best financial sector newsletters there is: Net Interest. Marc has written about everything from newer players like Ant Financial and Facebook’s Diem, to huge banks like Citi, to explainers on things that only industry insiders would know. You should subscribe now if you’re interested in … money.

    I’ve wanted to write about today’s topic for a long time, and Marc was the missing piece in my Jack Dorsey mental puzzle.

    Let’s get to it.

    Jack of Two Trades

    You Don’t Know Jack

    Why is Jack Dorsey so much worse at being the CEO of Twitter than he is at being the CEO of Square? 

    That was the question that kicked this whole thing off. After Marc Rubinstein wrote Hip to Be Square in December, I emailed him with that question. Marc is a former hedge fund manager who writes the brilliant newsletter Net Interest about all things finance and fintech. His fund participated in the Square IPO back in 2015. I understand Twitter, Marc understands Square. Together, we could crack this. 

    The companies’ relative product velocity and stock prices make the contrast stark. Since its initial public market struggles, Square has been an absolute rocketship. If you had bought $SQ at the November 19, 2015 IPO price of $9, you would have been up 25x by the time that Marc wrote about the company on December 18, 2020. $TWTR, meanwhile, was up only 24% between its November 7, 2013 IPO and December 18. Jack’s Square had performed 100x better than Jack’s Twitter, despite two years less time in the public markets. 

    The question was so obvious -- Jack was clearly a terrible CEO at Twitter and a great CEO at Square -- and we certainly weren’t the first people to ask it. Elliott Management launched an activist campaign in February 2020 that rested on “Jack is the CEO of two companies and he’s doing a bad job at this one” as one of its core tenets. 

    But despite the obviousness of the question, it didn’t have an obvious answer. So we decided to team up, Marc contributing his knowledge on Square, me adding my perspective on Twitter, to see if there was some way to … square … the apparent contradiction. We agreed to publish after Square announced Q4 earnings in February. 

    And then… Twitter got its groove back. It acquired Substack competitor Revue, launched Clubhouse competitor Spaces, reported strong earnings, and blew expectations out of the water with an ambitious and aggressive Analyst Day last week. Jack even acknowledged that the company has moved way too slowly, and set a goal to double the product cadence while doubling revenue by 2023. Since Marc and I first spoke on December 18th, Twitter is up 37%. 

    The obvious question -- why is Jack such a great Square CEO and such a bad Twitter CEO -- became a lot less obvious. Some new, more illuminating ones emerged in its place, such as: “Assuming Jack runs the companies in largely the same way, why might they perform so differently?” The answer to that explains why it’s so much harder to actually run companies than it is to write about them and come up with fun product ideas. 

    The differences in the way Jack runs his two companies have been (literally) litigated into the ground, but exploring the similarities, and what they say about both companies’ futures, is a more fascinating endeavor. Zooming out and looking ahead, Square and Twitter have a lot more in common than meets the eye. Today, we’ll unpack that, by covering:

    * Jackground

    * Back to Square One

    * Putting the Network Into Square

    * Old Twitter

    * Twitter’s New Groove

    * Back to the Original Question

    And look, we get why Jack’s dual roles make people uncomfortable. No one’s ever done it quite like him. 

    Jackground

    Some Twitter shareholders don’t love the fact that Jack Dorsey runs both Twitter and Square, for reasons ranging from time management to performance to conflict of interest. It’s not surprising that they’re concerned: very few people run two public companies. 

    Steve Jobs did it. After he was ousted from Apple, Jack’s idol acquired Lucasfilm’s animation studio and renamed it Pixar. Jobs took the company public in 1995, returned to Apple as CEO in 1996, and ran both companies until Disney acquired Pixar in 2006. That was Steve Jobs, and even he, the Zeus of tech CEOs, got kidney stones from the stress of running two companies. 

    Carlos Ghosn ran both Renault and Nissan after orchestrating the Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance which tied the three companies through a cross-sharing agreement. The multi-CEO role made sense because of the close relationships between the companies, and Ghosn apparently had few interests outside of work besides watching soccer. (Today, Ghosn is an internationally-wanted fugitive, hiding out in Lebanon with an Interpol red notice on his head, after allegations by the Japanese government that he underreported his salary and grossly misused company funds, so...) 

    Elon Musk leads both public Tesla and might-as-well-be-public $74 billion SpaceX. He’s a hard charging mega-genius who does more at each of those companies than most CEOs do at one, and it’s impossible to argue with his performance. 

    And then there’s Jack. 

    Jack is laid back, travels often, already worked from home one day a week pre-COVID, told Forbes that he “spend[s] 90% of my time with people who don’t report to me, which allows for serendipity, because I’m walking around the office all the time,” and was pushed out of Twitter, when he ran just that one company, in part because he would leave the office early to take fashion design classes. Ev Williams famously gave him an ultimatum in the early days: “You can either be a dressmaker or the CEO of Twitter.” In 2019, he made waves by saying that he wanted to move to Africa. His resume does not scream workaholic. 

    As Twitter’s public market performance dragged between 2013 and 2020, shareholders became increasingly vocal and litigious. In December 2019, Scott Galloway called for his ouster. In March 2020, Elliott Management and Silver Lake took seats on the board as part of an activist campaign that called for Jack’s head. Just last week, a shareholder sued Jack and Twitter’s board, claiming that Jack breached his fiduciary duty by giving advertisers access to users’ private data, often to the great benefit of Square, Jack’s ownership in which is worth nearly 8x as much as his Twitter holdings. (Square shareholders don’t seem to mind. Winning takes care of everything.)

    Jack would argue that hours worked != quality of work. On Rich Kleiman’s The Boardroom: Out of Office podcast, Dorsey said that he would, “Rather…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    35 min
  • Power to the Person (Audio)

    Welcome to the 1,125 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 34,427 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen here or on Spotify.

    Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Masterworks

    What’s the one thing in every hedge fund titan’s portfolio that you’re probably not investing in?

    A-R-T. In fact, 84% of ultra-high-net-worth individuals collect art according to a 2019 Deloitte survey. It makes sense—contemporary art returned 13.6% per year over the last 25 years vs. 8.9% for the S&P 500. And with the total art market expected to balloon from $1.7T to $2.6T by 2026, it’s no wonder that the price of paintings have skyrocketed. 

    One New York startup is at the center of it all: Masterworks. They’ve fractionalized multimillion-dollar masterpieces by KAWS, Basquiat, Banksy, and more—and you can be a part of it. If you're tired of meme stocks and are looking for an elite, non-correlated asset class, check out Masterworks today. 

    I went deep on Masterworks in January, have invested in four of their paintings, and am looking to add more. The best part? I've partnered with Masterworks to let Not Boring subscribers skip their 27,000 person waitlist. So do yourself a favor and sign up today.

    *See important information

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday! Hope everyone’s thawing out after last week’s winter weather.

    In late January, I wrote about NFTs in my essay on The Value Chain of the Open Metaverse. I told you about projects like NBA TopShot and $WHALE. Since then, both of those have exploded. $WHALE has more than doubled. But as I’ve mentioned before, I’m kind of an idiot, so of course, I didn’t buy either. I missed the run.

    I’ve followed with interest, though, and while certain asset prices are clearly inflated, we’re nowhere close to reaching NFTs’ true potential. Art is a start, but NFTs may be one of the most powerful primitives created in a long time.

    Today’s post is an exploration of the long-term potential of the short-term explosion of interest in NFTs, and in the Passion Economy. And there’s good news for all of us (assuming you’re a human): it’s a great time to be a person.

    Let’s get to it.

    Power to the Person

    If you’ve spent much time on the internet recently you might have noticed something: it’s gotten really fast-paced and really fun. It just keeps getting faster and funner. Bitcoin, Clubhouse, NFTs, unicorn startups galore, the Creator Economy. Each feels simultaneously like a potential fad and a nascent revolution.

    From the eye of the storm, it’s hard to tell exactly what it means. Will digital artists continue to mint millions from NFTs? Will Creator Economy startups continue to raise early stage rounds at dizzying valuations? Will consumer social apps need top-tier influencer founders to cut through the noise? 

    I have no idea, and instead of singling out any company or NFT, a thought exercise seems more appropriate, based on three ideas that keep coming to mind: 

    * A main Not Boring theme that Genies don’t go quietly back into bottles.

    * Chris Dixon’s famous line that “the next big thing will start out looking like a toy.”

    * Ben Thompson’s idea that media businesses are the first to adapt to new paradigms because of their relative simplicity, and others follow later.

    Taken together, what I see happening is this: 

    The Creator Economy and NFTs are massive human potential unlocks. Even if certain assets are in a short-term bubble, we are on an inexorable march towards individuals mattering more than institutions. 

    We’re on the precipice of a creative explosion, fueled by putting power, and the ability to generate wealth, in the hands of the people. Armed with powerful technical and financial tools, individuals will be able to launch and scale increasingly complex projects and businesses. Within two decades, we will have multiple trillion-plus dollar publicly traded entities with just one full-time employee, the founder.

    That sounds bold, but it’s kind of already happened: as of last week, Bitcoin, which has no employees, crossed the $1 trillion mark.

    I think that the Passion Economy broadly will continue to expand beyond media and entertainment and that we’ll see more and more companies -- some small, some big; some permanent, some temporary -- that do all of the things that companies do today, with one person. That doesn’t mean we’ll all be sitting in our basements, alone, growing rich and unhappy; to the contrary, I think we’ll see the continued rise of collectives and communities, some lifelong and some project-specific and fleeting. Some of us might even choose to work together. 

    Why does it matter that one person will be able to launch companies that rival corporations in scope, scale, and innovation? Because currently, Passion Economy businesses are tied to the creator. Creators, even well-paid ones, are still more labor than capital. If I get hit by a bus tomorrow, the content stops, and Not Boring stops making money. We’re after products can outlive their founders and continue to produce wealth after they’re gone. 

    People follow people, not companies, but companies have long had the advantage because of all of the coordination it takes to build scaled products. As a result, they capture a disproportionate share of the profits. Even Creator Economy platforms like Substack and TikTok treat creators themselves as commoditized supply. While people are making great livings through their work, which is a great step, I think the confluence of the Passion Economy, DeFi, and NFTs will mean that the creators themselves will capture the lions’ share of the profits. I’m excited to see more individuals commoditize platforms, instead of the other way around.

    We haven’t scratched the surface of the implications of giving the power to the person. Today, we’ll scratch. 

    * Creators’ Crazy Month

    * The Creator Toolkit

    * Coase and the Nature of the Firm

    * The New Nature of the Firm

    * The Age of Individual Influence

    It’s a great time to be a person. 

    Creators’ Crazy Month

    It’s been quite a year for the Passion Economy. Back in October 2019, pre-COVID, Li Jin wrote The Passion Economy and the Future of Work. In it, Li highlights that “Users can now build audiences at scale and turn their passions into livelihoods, whether that’s playing video games or producing video content.” 

    Note: We’ll use Passion Economy and Creator Economy interchangeably, but Creator Economy is technically a subset of the Passion Economy that’s more focused on media and entertainment.

    The piece was one of those magical self-fulfilling ones that both names a trend and supercharges it. By naming it, Li gave people license to go out and build, both as individual creators and as companies formed to build the tools to grow the movement. COVID helped, too, with more people stuck at home and facing uncertain job prospects. This newsletter is part of the Passion Economy, and it probably wouldn’t exist without COVID. 

    The Passion Economy just keeps picking up momentum, and it’s reaching a fever pitch. While TikTok, YouTube, and Instagram keep exploding, new entrants are joining the party with breathtaking speed. In the past month alone:

    * Clubhouse raised its Series B at a $1 billion valuation and announced plans to let creators monetize directly from the audience through tips, tickets, or subscriptions. 

    * Creator finance platform Stir raised its Series A at $100 million (a16z led both Clubhouse and Stir).

    * Substack announced that there are over 500,000 paid subscriptions on the platform, and that the top ten writers collectively make over $15 million. 

    * Twitter acquired newsletter platform Revue. 

    * YouTuber David Dobrik launched his photo app, Dispo, and it went so viral so quickly that it’s in talks to raise at its own $100 million valuation. (Read Divinations on Dispo).

    * LinkedIn (LinkedIn!!) is building a service called Marketplaces to compete with Fiverr and Upwork to connect freelancers and hirers. 

    * Li unveiled her own $13 million early stage venture f…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    32 min
  • AltoIRA: Interview with CEO Eric Satz

    Welcome to the 898 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Thursday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 33,771 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Thursday! Today, we’re doing a Sponsored Deep Dive on a company that I’ve been waiting for all my investing life without knowing it: AltoIRA.

    Instead of me reading the essay, we’re going to hear the Alto story straight from the mouth of its founder and CEO, Eric Satz. Listen by hitting play above, or on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.

    NBD but Sponsored Deep Dives are kinda famous now, after Ben Thompson said on his Dithering podcast yesterday:

    There’s another guy that has a newsletter, the name escapes me [ed note: it me], and he will write about the startups and he’s actually paid by the startups to do a big profile of them, and they give him access to what their business is doing and their plans and things like that. But he’s very upfront about it, he’s clear that he’s getting paid to do it. And I think that’s fine, as long as he’s super transparent about the fact that money’s changing hands here, but in exchange, he does get lots of interesting information in the way the company thinks about the business and their opportunity that I don’t get because I’m just someone sitting on the outside relying on earnings calls.

    That’s a highlight of my professional life, despite my name escaping him. Ben Thompson is, of course, one of my business analysis idols, and the quote shows why. He captured exactly what I’m going for with these Sponsored Deep Dives: the win-win-win.

    * I get to write about companies that fascinate me with more access than I’d get as a full outsider or even a journalist, and make money so I can keep doing this.

    * The sponsor gets an outside perspective on their business, and the chance to share their story with the smartest group of people on the internet.

    * You get a behind-the scenes look at startups that are shaking things up, and a new product that can be useful (and typically help you make money).

    If you want to learn more about the process behind the deep dives: read here. I will always tell you how I’m getting paid - CPM or CPA; today is a combination of the two.

    Today’s sponsor, Alto, is one of those “I can’t believe they’re actually paying me to write this” companies, because not only am I personally fascinated by the space they play in, I also got smarter about my retirement savings in this research process than in the entire rest of my life combined. Plus, Alto’s CRO Tara Fung is an actual, long-time Not Boring reader! IRAs aren’t as boring as I thought.

    Let’s get to it.

    AltoIRA: The World’s Least Boring IRA

    IRAs, But Not Boring

    Let me get a confession out of the way upfront: for most of my adult life, I thought that retirement accounts were so boring. 

    Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs), 401ks, pensions… I knew I had to max my contribution every year, and it hurt, because I assumed that the only option was to have the money sit in a mutual fund and earn average returns. I have friends (and a wife) who get real joy from figuring out whether a traditional IRA makes more sense for them than a Roth, but honestly, I zoned out whenever those conversations started. My apologies to 59-and-a-half year old Packy. 

    But in November, my friend Nikhil tweeted a screenshot memo about his investment in AltoIRA, and I took note. 

    AltoIRA is a self-directed IRA for alternative investments. Instead of blindly putting money into index funds and letting it sit there until you retire (or, uhhh, die), AltoIRA lets you invest your retirement savings in startups, art, crypto, real estate, and more, as easily as you’d expect from a modern technology company. It gives regular investors access to the type of diversification that the pros use to construct their portfolios, with the compounding benefits of deferred taxation. 

    It’s a product I didn’t even know was possible, but have been waiting for all my life. 

    Alternative asset investment startups like Masterworks, Fundrise, Pipe, Rally Rd., AngelList, and Republic are among my favorite subjects to write about. The fact that regulation and technology are working hand-in-hand to let anyone build the types of portfolios wealthier, more sophisticated investors long have is an incredible thing. 

    AltoIRA gives people access to a meta-trick the ultra-wealthy use: investing in alternatives from your retirement account, with the same tax advantages as the passive IRA you’re used to. Accredited investors can even invest in Not Boring Syndicate deals in their IRA, through a direct partnership between Alto and AngelList. 

    If you think I’m going to keep my entire IRA generating average returns in Wealthfront when AltoIRA exists, you haven’t been reading Not Boring very closely. I’m in the middle of transferring 20% of my IRA into Alto as we speak. Today, I’ll tell you why: 

    * Retirement Accounts, Taxes, and Alternative Assets. I’ll try to convince you that I was wrong, and retirement accounts actually aren’t boring, particularly with alternatives. 

    * Meet AltoIRA. What is AltoIRA and how does it work? 

    * Why Now? The intersection of regulatory, market, and technological trends make now the ideal moment in time to build what Alto is building. 

    * Alto Everywhere. Soon, investing with your IRA will be as easy as investing with your bank account.

    If you can’t wait to get started, you can sign up for AltoIRA using the special Not Boring link here:

    But we’re here to learn, too, about why the combination of IRAs and alternative investments is so powerful. So put on your party pants and come explore the world of retirement accounts with me. 

    Retirement Accounts, Taxes, and Alternative Assets

    Let’s start with why I was wrong not to care about optimizing my retirement accounts: there is so much money in retirement accounts, and the benefits of doing it right over time are massive.

    In the United States, there are 150 million retirement accounts that hold over $33 trillion in assets. Excluding home equity, retirement accounts comprise 70% of the average American household’s investable assets.

    This is by (very old) design. In the US, pensions started as early as the country, with lifetime incomes for military service, but the structure we have in place today largely comes from 1913. That year, the states ratified the 16th Amendment, giving the Federal government the right to impose a federal income tax. At first, pensions were taxable, but the Revenue Act of 1921 exempted retirement accounts from a person’s taxable income. 

    Since then, the system has evolved, but the purpose (shield retirement revenue from taxes) remains the same. Today, there are five main types of retirement accounts: 

    * IRAs: Account that individuals can use to save for retirement with tax advantages. There are two main types -- Traditional IRA and Roth IRA -- as well as others like SEP IRA and SIMPLE IRA. Traditional IRAs are funded with pre-tax dollars and grow tax-deferred, while Roth IRAs are funded with post-tax dollars and withdrawals are tax-free. 

    * 401(k)s: Also known as “defined contribution,” accounts that companies offer to employees. Employees can fund accounts pre-tax through automatic payroll withholding, and companies often match up to a certain % of employee contributions. Like IRAs, there are Traditional and Roth, with the same funding and tax implications. 

    * Public Pensions: Also known as “defined benefit” because they guarantee a set payment in the retirement for the rest of the beneficiary’s life. These are government-funded.

    * Private Pensions: Like public pensions, but company funded. 

    * Annuity Reserves: Mainly issued by insurance companies, annuities let someone pay in while they’re working in exchange for defined payouts after they retire. 

    For the rest of this piece, we’ll focus on IRAs: they’re the largest category, with $11.3 trillion in assets, and expected to be the fastest-growing as people switch jobs more frequently and pursue employment in the gig and passion economies, and as …



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    29 min
  • Dreams All the Way Up (Audio)

    Welcome to the 744 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 33,302 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:

    Hi friends 👋 ,

    Happy Monday! If you’re in the US, I hope you’re enjoying some time off for President’s Day. 

    I like mixing it up ever so slightly on holidays. On our last US holiday, MLK Day, I wrote a longer-than-usual Not Boring Investment Memo on Antara. Today, I’m going to go the opposite way, and try to write the shortest post I’ve written in a long time.

    Specifically, here’s the challenge I set for myself: explain what’s happening in the private and public tech markets in a novel way in only the space Substack gives me (no “Continue Reading” button).

    As you know if you’ve been reading this, it’s a lot easier for me to write long than write short, so this was a fun exercise. I’d love to hear your feedback on the format: text my OpenPhone number at 1-917-818-0620.

    But first, a word from our sponsor…

    Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Future

    Future is the 1-on-1 remote personal training app I’m relying on to get and stay in shape. I’ve been using Future since December, and I’m hooked. My coach, Alex, and I talk every day about the workouts, adjustments, how my creaky knee feels, and how I can improve my diet. 

    A couple of weeks ago, Future introduced Challenges, a competition to see who can complete the most workouts in 45 days. I’m battling Future CEO Rishi Mandal and fellow newsletterer Mario Gabriele, and I’m currently in last (see above, though I snuck one in this AM and am at 15). Losers owe the winner a share of Roblox, and I don’t like losing; time to pick up the pace.

    If you’ve been looking to get healthier, shed a couple pounds, or get in the best shape of your life, join us on Future and get your own expert coach to guide and push you. Use the link below to Challenge me and get your first $45 days free:

    Let’s get to it.

    Dreams All The Way Up

    It Feels Like a Bubble, But It’s Not

    Tech is not in a bubble, even if it feels like it is. Compared to the biggest tech companies, the best startups and smaller public companies may actually be undervalued despite record high valuations.

    In his classic A Random Walk Down Wall Street, Burton Malkiel wrote, “A blindfolded monkey throwing darts at a newspaper’s financial pages could select a portfolio that would do just as well as one carefully selected by experts.” Were the Princeton economist writing an updated version today, he might say, “A blindfolded monkey throwing darts at Robinhood could select a tech stock that would have doubled over the past year.”

    And it’s not just public tech stocks. Private market tech company valuations have soared too, with companies raising seed rounds at $20 million pre-revenue, Series A’s at valuations in the hundreds of millions, and Series B’s worth a billion. Robinhood faced an existential crisis two weeks ago, and then raised $3.4 billion in less time than it takes me to invoice a sponsor with bill.com. It’s as if every venture capitalist has become Masayoshi Son.

    It feels like frothiness that would make a barista jealous. But what if I told you that startups aren’t overvalued today? They’ve actually been undervalued for the past decade and are just catching up. 

    Let’s turn it over to Sir Roger Bannister to explain.

    The Four-Minute Mile and the Market 

    In the late 1860’s, when the mile record stood at 4:36, runners around the world started seriously attempting to break the four minute barrier. Three different Walters in a row traded the record, bringing it down below 4:20 by the mid 1880’s. 

    Between 1942 - 1945, two Swedes, Gundar Hägg and Arne Andersson, traded the record four times, driving it down from 4:06.2 to 4:01.4, a nearly 5-second improvement in just three years. And then, nothing. The record stood, unimproved, for the next nine years, until Roger Bannister stepped up to the starting line at Iffley Road sports ground in Oxford. 

    Bannister took two seconds off the record, completing his mile in 3:59.4 and becoming the first person in history to break the four-minute mile. 

    His record stood for 46 days. John Landy smashed it with a 3:58.0. A year later, three runners broke the 4-minute mile in the same race, and today, over 1,500 people have run a competitive mile in under four minutes. Hicham El Guerrouj holds the world record with a 3:43.13 that he ran in 1999.

    The moral of the story here is that there wasn’t necessarily anything physical keeping humans from breaking four minutes; it was mental. When people saw it could be done, they just kind of … did it. Bannister, through extraordinary performance, eliminated a mental barrier, and afterwards, other great but not all-time exceptional runners followed his lead. 

    In the public markets in the 2010s, the $1 trillion market cap was the four-minute mile. As someone who owned Apple stock and options earlier in the decade, I can tell you how frustrating it was that the stock seemed to trade at a discount (sub-10x P/E ratio) simply because it was so big, despite insane profitability and growth. $1 trillion felt like a restraining wall.

    Then, on August 2, 2018, an extraordinary company broke another mental barrier, when Apple became the first US company to crack the $1 trillion market cap mark. 

    What happened next wasn’t quite the immediate flood that Bannister unleashed, but within 16 months, by January 2020, three more companies -- Microsoft, then Amazon, then Google -- had broken $1 trillion. FAAMG had been undervalued across the board. Since Apple couldn’t break $1 trillion for psychological reasons, and it was clear that the other four weren’t as valuable as Apple, they had to be worth some discount to Apple’s artificially low market cap. 

    Note: FAAMG is a weird acronym for the biggest tech companies -- FB, AAPL, AMZN, MSFT, GOOG. They’re a good proxy for how big the market thinks tech companies can get.

    Apple took the governor off, and today, after a wild, tech-friendly pandemic and zero interest rate policy (ZIRP) drove stocks higher, the FAAMG market caps are:

    * Apple: $2.273 trillion

    * Microsoft: $1.848 trillion

    * Amazon: $1.651 trillion

    * Google: $1.415 trillion

    * Facebook: $770 billion

    If certain parts of the market feel bubbly, these companies don’t. They’re category-defining companies that continue to grow and innovate at a faster clip than megacaps ever have before, and they trade at very reasonable NTM EV/EBITDA multiples: 

    * Apple: 22.0x

    * Microsoft: 24.8x

    * Amazon: 22.4x

    * Google: 15.4x

    * Facebook: 13.1x

    That’s not bubbly. Poking fun at the bubble talk, Michael Batnick tweeted this chart: 

    That’s Amazon’s revenue, not its market cap. Insane. If Amazon keeps up that pace, $1.6 trillion will seem cheap within half a decade, which will make other numbers that seem big today seem smaller. The bar will keep getting higher. 

    The market caps of the FAAMG companies are the most important numbers in the market, because consciously or not, investors are pegging their private and public tech company investments against them. 

    Price / FAAMG Ratio

    Instead of Price/Sales or Price/Earnings, high-potential tech companies are subconsciously being valued on Price / FAAMG, or a probability that those companies will become as big as today’s biggest, and it’s not crazy.

    (If I’m wrong, and we actually are in a bubble that’s about to pop, this is the statement that’s going to get me roasted.)

    Let me explain. Traditionally, companies are valued based on a multiple of their earnings or profits per share (Price/Earnings or P/E), or if they’re earlier in their journey and growing fast but still unprofitable, on a multiple of their revenue (Price / Sales or P/S), or a free cash flow multiple, or some other financial metric.

    But today, in both private and public markets, with P/E and P/S ratios at uselessly high levels, it seems like companies are being valued on a rough probability that they can become as big as the biggest companies, which are themselves more valuable than ever before. With the $1 trillion barrie…



    Get full access to Not Boring by Packy McCormick at www.notboring.co/subscribe
    23 min

About Not Boring by Packy McCormick

From the publisher's feed

Business strategy, but not boring, delivered to your ears and your inbox every Monday and Thursday morning.