
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Welcome to the 574 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Thursday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 32,866 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Thursday! Today, we’re bringing back a format I love that we haven’t done for a while: the Not Boring guest post! The point of guest posts is to bring you insights and perspectives from people who know a lot more about a certain space, or have different or more nuanced takes, than I do.
Today’s guest writer, Dan Teran, fits the bill perfectly. Dan and I first met in 2014, during his time as CEO of office management platform Managed by Q, which he co-founded in 2014 and sold to WeWork in 2019. MBQ was at the forefront of applying the Good Jobs Strategy in a fast-growing marketplace startup. Harvard Business Review wrote about MBQ in 2017, saying:
Teran has focused on four things: pay, scheduling, benefits, and advancement. Employees start at $12.50 an hour. Full-time workers average 120 hours a month, and they are offered health insurance and a 401(k) plan. Employees are part owners of the company, and they get stock options.
So when Dan approached me about an essay he was writing on how food delivery platforms’ disregard for the little guy leaves them open to attack from new entrants and regulators alike, I got excited: he’s exactly the person who should be writing exactly this piece.
(Pair with: Jeremy Diamond’s excellent April piece on food delivery strategy, Feeding the Rebels.)
Dan delivered. This piece covers restaurant economics, disruption theory, the conservation of attractive profits, and the cycle of bundling and unbundling to argue that companies like DoorDash and Uber Eats are bad for restaurants, which will ultimately be bad for their own business.
Give it a read below, and check out the rest of Dan’s work on Medium.
But first, a word from our sponsor.
Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by… OpenPhone
OpenPhone is the easiest way to set up a business phone number. It’s so easy that Not Boring got a phone number before getting its own, non-Substack domain. I use OpenPhone when I have good-old-fashioned voice calls with experts and sponsors, and most importantly, to text with all of you.
Last time OpenPhone sponsored Not Boring, I asked you to text me, and kicked off dozens of great conversations. Let’s do it again. I’d love to hear what you think of the guest post format, what other guests you’d love to see, and what topics I should cover next.
So shoot me a text: 1-917-818-0620.
Plus, OpenPhone is even better for teams than for my 1-man operation. Companies big and small use it to replace Google Voice with modern software, give everyone on the team their very own business number, build custom, automated workflows, record conversations, and keep in touch with customers.
Get your team set up with a powerful and delightful business phone today:
Let’s get to it.
The Beginning of the End
By Dan Teran
The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on third party food delivery is a Rorschach test. What you see depends on what you believe.
Some view third party food delivery operators, such as DoorDash, UberEats, and Grubhub, as heroes of the pandemic, a lifeline to restaurants, creators of employment for masses of essential workers that are responsible for slowing the spread of the virus by keeping diners safely in their homes.
Others view these firms as unscrupulous predators, draining profits from independent restaurants while undercompensating and mistreating delivery workers, all to satisfy the appetites of venture capital investors who have gambled billions of dollars on a business model that may never generate more cash than it has consumed.
Public markets have made their view known. Uber has been catapulted to all time highs, trading at over $100B market capitalization, gobbling up competitor Postmates and adjacent Drizly in alcohol delivery, while the rides business lags. DoorDash is not far behind, with a market capitalization around $60B following a successful mid-pandemic IPO, earlier this week they bought a salad robot.
All of this comes just one year after Grubhub’s CEO penned a letter to shareholders that read like a death knell for the industry, citing rising costs and “promiscuous” diners. Have the markets lost their mind, or is something fundamentally different in a post-pandemic world?
While the pandemic has driven unprecedented demand and introduced new narratives, the facts remain largely unchanged – the third party delivery industry is bad for independent restaurants, bad for delivery workers, and serves customers who are indifferent so long as their food arrives. The pandemic has brought these harsh truths irreversibly into the light, and it is for this reason that we will look back on this year not as one of good fortune for third party delivery, but as the beginning of the end.
How did we get here?
The history of business is in many ways the story of the integration and disintegration of value chains. Netscape founder Jim Barksdale famously quipped “Gentlemen, there’s only two ways I know of to make money: bundling and unbundling.”
In an integrated value chain, one firm directs many or all of the activities required to deliver value to the customer, which results in tight control over the final product and, with differentiation, higher profits. In a modular value chain, many firms compete to provide the same services, which results in greater flexibility and customization but lower profits for participating firms. I highly recommend Ben Thompson’s work on the subject for further reading, which modernizes Clay Christensen’s original work in The Innovator’s Solution.
The past twenty years of the on-demand food delivery ecosystem is one long story of integration. In the interest of clarity, I’ve simplified the food delivery value chain to the steps of food and menu preparation, marketing, ordering & payment, and delivery.
In the beginning, there were a few menus in your kitchen drawer. You called to order, the restaurant took the order over the phone, prepared the food, delivered the food, and you paid in cash when they arrived. I can still remember the phone number of New World Pizza in Skillman, NJ.
The diagram below represents the value chain before third parties played a meaningful role in delivering value to the customer. All of these functions were likely coordinated by the proprietor.
The modern era of online ordering and delivery began around the year 2000, with Seamless (1999) and Grubhub (2003). In an effort to bring the menu in the drawer online, these firms created an online ordering and payment platform, and charged restaurants a commission of ~15% to receive orders through the platform. They focused on restaurants that already had in-house delivery capabilities, bringing the worlds of pizza and Chinese food online for the first time.
In 2013, Grubhub and Seamless merged and settled into life as a mature public company, seeing solid growth and consistent profits. It did not last. The very same year Doordash (2013) was founded, followed by UberEats (2014). This new breed of companies drew inspiration from the early wins of ridesharing, and adopted a similar playbook – they capitalized on broad adoption of personal mobile devices, a loose interpretation of labor laws, and mountains of venture capital to build distributed logistics networks.
These firms integrated delivery capabilities with a mobile-first online ordering and payments experience, introducing the fully integrated value chain we know today. To say nothing of the ethics or profitability of their execution, it is hard to argue with the strategic acumen of these firms in executing disruptive innovation on multiple fronts.
Clay Christensen describes two types of disruptive innovation, one in which a new entrant brings new customers into the market, and another in which a new entrant captures the low end of the market at a lower cost. These firms did both.
By integrating delivery capabilities into the food d…
Welcome to the 685 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 32,558 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
🎧 To get new Not Boring pods right when they come out, subscribe on Spotify or iTunes.
This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Mercury
Mercury is banking built for startups. I first heard about the company on Twitter early last year. At the time, Not Boring had about 1,000 readers and $0 revenue, so I stored a mental note away, for a time, one day, maybe, when this thing would start making money. Then, lo and behold, it did! So I went to Stripe Atlas to set up an LLC, and who did Stripe recommend first for banking? You guessed it… Mercury.
You know how I feel about Stripe. I took their word for it and signed up. I’m glad I did. Mercury offers FDIC-insured bank accounts, virtual and physical debit cards, and 3-click payment flows. It’s designed to be fast and simple. My favorite feature is being able to click to copy my account number, routing number, and bank address, right on the main page. Simple but wonderful.
Mercury doesn’t just help companies manage their money, though, it helps them raise it. Mercury Raise connects startups with 170+ top angel investors to pitch their business and, hopefully, but more money in the bank. Plus, it offers a Treasury product and an API that lets you automate your workflows.
See for yourself. Mercury is offering $500 to any new user who signs up with the Not Boring link when they deposit $250k. Join me in banking with Mercury:
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Monday!
This is the freshest I’ve ever felt the morning after the Super Bowl. No Super Bowl parties was a new twist, but some things never change: I half-watched the game and half-scrolled Twitter to join the conversation around it.
10% game commentary, 80% that Weeknd gif, 10% Tom Brady appreciation.
I’m an unabashed Twitter fan. It’s the main tool in the Not Boring toolkit, and my little corner of it has become my main online community. Twitter is an infinite game, and once you start figuring out, it becomes magical.
The stock price, however, doesn’t reflect the value it creates, because until now, Twitter hasn’t captured much of it. I think that’s changing.
One thing before we get to Twitter: you should listen to the conversation I had last week with my friend Brett Beller. Brett was the first employee at Drizly, which sold to Uber for $1.1 billion last week. He tells the most honest story you’ll hear about what it was actually like starting a $1 billion company, and how it felt hearing the acquisition news after selling most of his shares a couple of years ago.
Now let’s get to it.
How Twitter Got Its Groove Back
The Dumb But Plausible Bull Case for Twitter
If we’ve learned anything over the past couple of weeks, it’s that markets can be dumb.
So here’s a dumb bull case for Twitter: it has the lowest market cap of any public tech company that you use every day -- at $45 billion, Twitter’s market cap is just 2% of Apple’s and 5.9% of Facebook’s -- and that will change once the narrative around the company does.
I know, I know. This isn’t how this is supposed to work. I used a similar argument to highlight Snap’s potential upside in Oh Snap!, though, and it is kind of working. SNAP shares are trading up 215% since I wrote that piece in June.
Snap has performed well, but they didn’t triple revenue. They’re not even profitable yet. So what happened? The narrative around Snap changed. This isn’t a struggling dick pic company that can’t acquire older users and is getting its lunch eaten by Instagram Stories anymore. This is a company that has huge engagement numbers with Millennials and Gen Z, increased interest from advertisers, credible international expansion plans, increasing ARPU, and a call option on becoming the Augmented Reality platform of the future, Mirrorworld.
When you look at it that way, you stop focusing on things like EV/EBITDA, or EV/Revenue, and focus on growth. You don’t worry about whether the floor will drop out; you dream about just how high the ceiling might be.
Of course, it helps that Snap figured its shit out right when the market got downright ravenous for growth. Interest rates are so low that investors are acting like something that could possibly happen in the future has already happened. Investors want to believe; it’s the company’s job to make them believe.
That’s why I’ve come to love narrative investing. Narrative investing isn’t about finding the company with the best story; it takes advantage of the collective narrative bias of the market, the tendency of investors to view investments through the lens of a narrative, forming a simple story and ignoring data that doesn’t fit the story. In Slack: The Bulls are typing…, I illustrated the idea by saying that the market looks at anything Slack does through shit-colored glasses. It’s largely looked at Twitter the same way.
In this market, value is dead (jk sorry value folks!), obvious growth is crowded, but finding that inflection point when the narrative around a company switches from dead to very much alive is like finding a magical money printer in a market fueled by a magical money printer. brrrrrr^2
That’s what happened with Snap. It’s what happened with Spotify, when it changed the narrative from “structurally low margin music business” to “leading audio company” in the stroke of a few podcast deals. It’s what would have happened with Slack (I swear!) before Salesforce saw the potential and snatched it up.
And, I think, it’s what’s going to happen to Twitter.
Am I late to the party here? A little. $TWTR is up 70% over the past year, more than any of the FAAMG stocks save Apple. But zooming out, Twitter is practically flat for its entire history as a public company. Back in the day, in 2013, when Twitter IPO’d, it was right there with Facebook. Since then, as I wrote in If I Ruled The Tweets, Twitter has stayed pretty much flat, while “Facebook, lacking scruples in its pursuit of Rubles, has more than quadrupled.”
I wish I’d called it then; Twitter is up 68% of its 70% 1 year growth since I wrote that essay in July outlining what I thought Twitter should do to jumpstart itself. I think Twitter might have read the piece, because they’ve started to do some of the things I put on the crowdsourced Fantasy Jack Twitter Roadmap.
Twitter has started to do what it should have done all along -- focus on its power users. The launch of audio-chat rooms, Spaces, and acquisition of a newsletter platform, Revue, make me optimistic that they’re able to execute on the rest of the roadmap too.
The company is getting its groove back. If either of these moves, or other bets Twitter is making, begin to show promise, the narrative is going to shift and Twitter will rip. People want a reason to buy Twitter.
With Twitter earnings tomorrow, now’s the perfect time to get smart on what the company is up to and where it’s heading. To do that, we’ll cover:
* Prof G vs. Twitter. Scott Galloway ripped the company and its CEO, Jack Dorsey, last week. It’s a good summary of the critics’ view, and a bullish signal.
* If I Ruled the Tweets. Twitter needs to focus on its power users and make products that help them share their ideas and make money.
* How Twitter Got Its Groove Back. Twitter grew usage, improved its ad product, and survived the election. Now it’s focused on what’s next with the acquisition of Revue and launch of Spaces.
* Twitter’s Creator Bundle. Twitter is in the best position to build or buy a bundle of tools for Creators. Plus, why I think it can beat Substack and Clubhouse.
* Changing the Narrative. Adding up the sum of Twitter’s parts.
There are a lot of reasons to be bullish on Twitter, but maybe none more so than the fact that Prof G is yelling about the company’s issues.
Prof G vs. Twitter
Last week, Professor Scott Galloway wrote about Twitter, both in New York Magazine and his own site, saying of the company, “We know it’s terrible for society. But i…
Welcome to the 658 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Thursday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 32,292 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
🎧 I’m starting doing interviews on the Not Boring pod. To get all of the interviews when they come out, and to listen to me read this essay, go follow the Not Boring Podcast on Spotify.
Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by…Stacker Studio
Back in November, Tommy first told all of you about Stacker Studio, a turn-key content marketing and SEO service for startups. Since then, he’s met and advised over 30 companies in the Not Boring community, and today he’s back to help any brand frustrated with content SEO and looking to drive organic growth. (I would imagine that’s most of you!)
Stacker Studio develops newsworthy stories on your behalf and then promotes them to newsrooms at hundreds of top tier media outlets, including SFGate, Chicago Tribune, NY Daily News, and Newsweek. The result is your branded story getting hundreds of high quality/SEO-friendly pickups, valuable reach into new audiences, and that sweet, recurring organic traffic.
Stacker Studio is extending 20% off the first campaign and guaranteeing a minimum of 50 pickups for each produced story. Schedule time with Tommy to learn how their team can help supercharge your growth.
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Monday!
Ankur Nagpal, the founder of Teachable, is one of the founders / early stage investors I respect the most. We’re co-investors in Composer and Antara, and he’s nice enough to send me the updates for his fund, A$AP Capital. Each one is full of more impressive companies than the last.
So when Ankur told me he had the perfect deal to do together, my ears perked up. He sent me the deck for Supersapiens and introduced me to the company’s founder and CEO, Phil Southerland. Once we spoke, it was an easy yes. Supersapiens is a product I’ve been waiting for for a decade.
We’re excited to bring you this deal, and an experiment on a new way for accredited investors to participate in the deal (hint: it involves no carry).
Let’s get to it.
Supersapiens: Not Boring Memo
The Supersapiens Investment Thesis
I try to be healthy. I wear an Apple Watch, workout with Future, track my steps (around the house), and monitor my sleep. And then I eat chips. If what gets measured gets managed, carbs have gotten a free pass. Well, until Supersapiens showed up.
Supersapiens gives athletes continuous insight into their energy levels through a biosensor and app that provide the most accurate continuous glucose monitoring on the market. Top European endurance athletes including Ironman winners, champion cyclists, and record-holding runners trust the product, and the company is preparing to launch in the US, and to at-home athletes like me, with a large research trial rolling out this year with up to 10,000 participants.
It’s entering the market at the right time. Premium wearable health and fitness tech is gaining widespread adoption, with WHOOP’s recent $1.2 billion valuation as the most recent example. What WHOOP is to heart rate variability (HRV) monitoring, Supersapiens plans to be for continuous glucose monitoring (CGM). It faces competition in the space, most notably Levels, but brings a differentiated product and a cornered resource to bear.
Like WHOOP, Supersapiens has the best tech on the market, in this case through an non-exclusive partnership with Abbott. Abbott is the leader in the CGM space, having sold over $5 billion of its Freestyle Libre CGM for Type 1 Diabetes in the past three years. It launched the Libre Sense in partnership with Supersapiens in December 2020 to bring CGM to non-diabetic athletes.
Everyone knows that diet has a massive impact on health, fitness, and performance, but CGM is the first product that gives people real-time insights into how both exercise and food impact their body. CGM will be the next big trend in wearables, and Supersapiens is the patron of the CGM peloton.
Ankur and I are thrilled to invest in Supersapiens, and we’ll explain why by covering:
* Wearables and CGM
* Supersapiens Story and Product
* The Abbott Agreement
* Targeting Athletes (and Everyone is an Athlete)
* The Supersapiens Team
* Business Model and Early Traction
* Risks
* Opportunity
The world in which Supersapiens is successful at bringing its product to a broad swath of the population is a world in which people are aware of the specific impacts that food and exercise have on their body, more energized, and healthier.
Wearables and CGM
The fitness tech market is on fire. In the past year alone:
* Google / Fitbit. In late 2019, Google announced that it was acquiring Fitbit for $2.1 billion. The deal just closed in January.
* Apple. Apple generated more than 50% of global smart watch revenue in the first half of 2020 for the first time.
* Mirror. In July, Lululemon acquired connected-fitness startup Mirror for $500 million.
* WHOOP. In October, WHOOP raised a $100 million round at a $1.2 billion valuation.
* Future. That same month, Not Boring sponsor Future raised a $24 million Series B.
* Peloton. The connected fitness company has been one of the pandemic darlings. Since its March trough, PTON is up 6.6x to a $43 billion market cap.
Important measures like heart rate, activity levels, and sleep are tracked, dissected, and served up in real-time. We can get world-class training in the comfort of our own home. But monitoring the impact of our most important input — the food we put in our body — has been largely inaccessible.
I’ve worked in finance, then at a startup, and now write a newsletter and run a syndicate. I’m as cliché as it gets, so of course, I read Tim Ferriss’ The 4-Hour Body as soon as it came out in 2010. One of the things that still stands out from the book is that Tim measured his blood glucose levels. I remember wishing that I had that data on myself, but thinking that Tim Ferriss was much richer and more into biohacking than I was, so I’d have to make do without it. CGM was clearly important, but so far out of reach.
Each person’s body, optimal glucose levels, and responses to different foods are unique. By letting people track their glucose levels and adjust in real-time, CGM has immense benefits:
* Energy Management. Our metabolism produces energy from the food we eat. For our metabolisms to work optimally, we need to keep glucose in a healthy and stable range, which we can’t do accurately without CGM.
* Sustain Peak Performance. Glucose spikes and crashes can lead to fatigue, lethargy, lack of focus, and lack of energy. By monitoring how what you eat and when you eat it impacts your glucose levels, you can avoid spikes and crashes.
* Stave Off Diabetes. Almost 100 million Americans are pre-diabetic, and most don’t know it. Understanding and adjusting early can help hold off diabetes.
* Improve Recovery, Sleep, and Insulin Resistance. High glucose levels can hurt sleep, and I will do anything to improve my sleep.
* Potentially Increase Longevity. Glucose imbalances can lead to a number of conditions that shorten lives; maintaining stable glucose levels can fight off diseases and may help you live longer.
Take it from Supersapiens COO Todd Furneaux:
In the decade between The 4-Hour Body and today, though, technology did what technology does: got cheaper, smaller, and more reliable. In 2014, Abbott launched the Freestyle Libre 10 Day CGM for Type 1 Diabetes, and has done over $5 billion in sales since 2018. Now, CGM is finally becoming available to the non-diabetic population.
In November, CGM startup Levels raised a $12 million seed round led by a16z. You may have seen Levels on Twitter in the fall. Everyone who got the early version of the product posted the impact of different foods or drinks on their glucose levels. It was brilliant marketing and looked like a lot of fun.
Levels is exciting, but it’s early, and sports a $399 price point for a one-month program “designed for health seekers to measure how their diet affects the way they feel, and their long-term health.” It also…
Welcome to the 517 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 31,873 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
🎧 To get this essay straight in your ears: listen on Spotify (in about 45 minutes).
This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by… Future
Two weeks ago, I told you about Future, the 1-on-1 remote personal training app I’m using to fight off the dad bod. I shared my workout stats publicly to give myself some extra accountability, and it worked: I haven’t missed a workout since that email.
Lest I get too comfortable, last week, Future upped the intensity by introducing Challenges, a global competition to hit 21 workouts with your friends. I have a bet going with Future’s CEO Rishi and friend of Not Boring Mario - whoever gets there first gets a share of $RBLX from the losers.
Join in on the Challenge and get your first 45 days of Future coaching free bysigning up with my personal Challenge link:
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Monday!
Last week was not normal. Your mom is asking you to explain Reddit and Gamma Squeezes in the same sentence. The markets feel unstable in the most internet-y way possible. So this won’t be a normal newsletter.
If you write a newsletter that covers tech and finance, you kinda have to write about Gamestop / WSB / Robinhood. That means that plenty of really smart people have written great analyses. See: Jill Carlson, Matt Levine, and Alex Danco for some thorough and thoughtful takes.
But I haven’t yet seen the take that I want to read: that this was inevitable. Given how Robinhood built and incentivized itself, it would have taken a black swan event for the company not to end up in this situation at some point. And it’s only going to get crazier.
Let me get this out of the way upfront: I am clearly conflicted here, on both sides. Public has sponsored Not Boring, the Not Boring Syndicate invested in Composer, I know people who I like and respect who have invested in Robinhood, and I trade some of my money in Robinhood.
None of those facts change the way that I think about this situation. I have the paper trail to prove it. I’ve been expecting this for years!
The Robinhood story is a story about risk and chaos. If you introduce more chaos into the system than you’re ready to handle, the chaos is gonna getcha.
Let’s get to it.
Robinhood Robinhooded Robinhood
Do not be deceived: God is not mocked, for whatever one sows, that will he also reap.
Galatians 6:7.
Financial Chaos is a Ladder
Finance isn’t about good or evil. It’s about risk management. Hedge funds aren’t evil, Wall Street banks aren’t evil, regulators aren’t evil, retail investors aren’t evil. That’s one of the beautiful things about finance. It’s not about value judgments. It’s about numbers.
Robinhood isn’t evil, either, it just made a risky bet with tremendous upside potential, kind of like the bets that many Robinhood traders make every day. Robinhood bet that it could introduce tremendous amounts of risk into the financial system, push all of it onto its users and the market at large, and insulate itself from the consequences.
And it would have gotten away with it too, if it weren’t for those meddling kids!
In the good old days, circa a week ago, when Robinhood was still Robin Hood and st0nks only went up, there was a meme that circulated every so often about what would happen to the market when Robinhood went public and Robinhood traders could trade Robinhood shares on Robinhood. Woah.
It reminded me of that scene in Being John Malkovich, the one in which John Malkovich goes through his own portal and ends up surrounded by other John Malkoviches who can only say, “Malkovich.”
Robinhood Robinhood Robinhood.
There was also a meme, less cartoon and more condescension, among more serious markets types about what would happen to Robinhood traders when they got too long on margin and the market finally turned against them. They’d Robinhood themselves into financial ruin.
Robinhood, this idea went, made it too easy for unsophisticated investors to trade on margin (borrow money to buy stocks or options). That works really well when stocks go up, and really poorly when they go down.
If you own a bunch of stocks on margin, and the price of those stocks drops, you get hit with a margin call, and need to put up more cash, or sell the stock. Margin calls can be a killer, forcing traders to unwind at exactly the wrong time and lose a ton of money.
Robinhood knew that the people who traded on its platforms (I hesitate to call them customers, because “if you’re not paying, you’re the product”) might get hit with margin calls, or might wipe themselves out by trading options without fully understanding them, or do any number of things that could lead to huge losses. And they did. The most infamous and tragic example occurred in June, when 20-year-old Alex Kearns committed suicide after mistakenly thinking he owed over $730k due to margin trading.
But Robinhood, and I hope you’ll pardon my French here, did. not. give. a. fuck.
Until now, Robinhood has been able to push all of the risk it facilitates onto its users and to the market at large, and hide behind language about market democratization.
The markets, it turns out, do not give a fuck either. Numbers are numbers. Words are just words.
The delicious irony of last week is that by encouraging so many of its customers to make risky trades on margin, Robinhood Robinhooded Robinhood. It took on too much risk itself, got hit with a margin call of its own, and was forced to reveal whose side it was really on - its own. Them’s the breaks.
This was bound to happen, and it will happen again. Every move that Robinhood makes seems to increase entropy in the system by encouraging riskier and riskier behavior by retail traders. While it would have been impossible to predict exactly how this would go down, it was very easy to predict that something like it would. That’s the nature of chaos.
Today, we’ll cover:
* We’re All Idiots. Me included.And options trading is really hard.
* How Robinhood Makes Money. Looking at Robinhood’s incentives.
* Robinhood, WSB, and Entropy. A look at Robinhood’s history and chaos.
* Robinhood Robinhooded Robinhood. What happened last week?
* Where Do We Go From Here? Will Robinhood end up like Uber or Napster?
Please don’t get me wrong here: I firmly believe that people should be allowed to manage their own money. That genie is out of the bottle, thanks in large part to Robinhood, and that’s a good thing overall. It’s just that, if you’re going to facilitate and profit from chaos, don’t be surprised when that chaos turns back on you.
We’re All Idiots
Let me start out with a personal story that colors my views on all of this.
I started my career at Bank of America Merrill Lynch in 2009. When you work at a financial institution, they put all sorts of restrictions on your ability to trade: you need to get approval to buy stock or options on a specific company, you have to hold for thirty days, etc…
The intention of the rules is to protect the bank. Banks don’t want their employees trading on insider information, of which there is necessarily plentiful amounts floating around. But those rules also protected me.
When I quit in the summer of 2013, I owned a portfolio of stocks that I wanted to own for a long time. Facebook at $19, Tesla at $29, Apple at a split-adjusted $15. I even owned 38 Bitcoin at ~$100 because they weren’t subject to the bank’s restrictions. The list goes on, but I’m getting nauseous just writing it out.
Quitting meant no more restrictions. Time to make the real money. I logged into my Merrill Edge account and applied for access to options trading. I checked all the boxes -- good salary, professional experience with options, Series 7 and 63 licensed, recently employed by Merrill itself -- and there was still a bunch of friction, but I finally got approved to trade options.
Want to guess how the story ends?
I got my ass handed to me. I made all of the rookie mistakes, like bu…
Welcome to the 520 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 31,634 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
🎧 Listen to my interview with Podz CEO Doug Imbruce on Podz
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Thursday!
Every week, I record an audio edition of Not Boring. Typically the morning of the newsletter, I wake up at 5:30am, head to the basement, record, edit, pick music for, and publish a version of the essay that I read out loud. I have a face for radio and a voice for Twitter, but I like doing the audio version because it lets me give you another way to consume these essays that I spend so much time on.
Thing is, while anywhere between 30k - 100k people read each essay (thanks for sharing!), about 1,500 max listen to the audio version, despite the relative ease of consumption. A big part of the reason for the delta? Podcast discovery sucks.
Today, I’m writing about Podz, a company whose product I believe has the potential to change that. This is the first time I’ve written a deep dive about a consumer social product - all of the rest have been fintech or investing-adjacent - because I assume that if you’re the kind of person who takes the time to read Not Boring once or twice a week, you want to learn new things. I think Podz is going to make it a lot easier to find new audio content on the subjects you want to learn about, and make it easier for the people who, like me, spend hours behind a microphone recording.
Podz only ask out of this is that you try the Podz Beta:
And fill out this survey with your feedback:
To encourage you to give feedback, Doug has generously offered to donate $10 to the charity of my choice for every Not Boring reader who fills it out. I chose Alzheimer’s Foundation of America, because my grandmother suffered from Alzheimer’s, and to me, one of the best parts of audio is that it captures and preserves memory.
I’m excited about this one. Let’s get to it.
Podz & The Future of Audio
Getting on Audio’s Wavelength
I have heard the future of audio, and no, this isn’t another Clubhouse piece. I’m talking about Podz. Its solution, ten years in the making, has a legitimate shot at solving audio’s biggest challenge.
It’s bizarre that the social audio opportunity is still up for grabs. Talking is the oldest form of communication, but while text-, photo-, and video-based consumer social each have both casual and quality winners, audio just joined the party in 2020. Clubhouse has taken the lead in casual social audio, but Podz is going after what I think may be the bigger prize: building the quality social audio feed that surfaces the best content we humans create with our voices.
In April, I wrote one of my first Not Boring essays, Wackos and ZoomGlüts, in which I used an old episode of Hey Arnold to explain why, at the same time:
* It was so hard for podcasts and virtual events to stand out, and
* The buzziest startup around was one that combined podcasts and virtual events.
I was talking, of course, about Clubhouse, the drop-in audio chat app that launched in March.
It seemed crazy then. At the beginning of the quarantine, any brand, community, or family with a Zoom connection was hosting free events. Zoom fatigue set in fast and hard. Meanwhile, I wrote, “At a time when podcast listening is down by 25%, Amazon sold out of podcast mics. Production is increasing even while demand plummets.”
No commute meant less time to listen to podcasts, but more time stuck inside and more uncertainty about job prospects meant more people wanted to try their hand at making podcasts, hence a podcast supply glut. Our earholes weren’t wide enough to let everything in.
Clubhouse cut through the noise. By limiting invitations to a small group of tech Twitter illuminati, it manufactured exclusivity at a time when every other organization on earth was begging people to come to their free online event/happy hour/conversation/panel.
“While everyone else is begging ‘please!,’” I wrote, “Clubhouse is telling them ‘no.’ It’s the one velvet rope in a world of two-for-one happy hours hawked by overeager promoters.”
It worked. In May, Clubhouse announced a $12 million, a16z-led Series A that valued the company at $100 million. The company was still in beta, had a couple thousand users, and no revenue. Thinkpeople were flummoxed.
But here we are, nine months and eight decades’ worth of quarantine later, and Clubhouse just raised a fresh $100 million Series B, once again led by a16z, this time valuing the business at $1 billion. This time, out of beta, with 2 million users, and plans for creator-focused revenue generation, people get it.
Clubhouse’s success is remarkable, but it isn’t unique in the world of audio. In fact, after an early-pandemic dip, podcasts have come roaring back. Listening is up dramatically, all of the usual suspects are spending hundreds of millions on content, and more people are recording themselves talking than ever before.
Despite that, spoken-word audio is in the early innings of digitalization and monetization:
* Podcast ad revenue is projected to grow 10x faster than the next closest medium over the next five years, and even then, it will bring in less than 10% of what radio does.
* A tiny minority of podcasters take home the vast majority of the listens and dollars.
* Clubhouse and Twitter Spaces are pushing audio-only public conversations forward.
* Companies like Otter and Descript are making it easier than ever to capture and transcribe all sorts of conversations.
And still, spoken word audio discovery is an absolute disaster. It’s one of the things holding podcasts back.
That’s what Podz is working to fix, and the product is magical. Podz uses machine learning to pull the best clips from podcasts and deliver them to listeners in personalized feeds. Whenever you hear “machine learning” or “AI,” you should be skeptical, and I was too, until Podz sent me three clips of my own podcast. It picked highlights better than I could myself, pulling out the thesis from each (here, here, and here). It was so good that I thought the team had done it manually and e-mailed the founder and CEO, Doug Imbruce to confirm:
I think that Podz, which is launching its beta today, has the chance to be something special. Like the Clubhouse founders, the Podz team has been working on social products together for over a decade, and like Clubhouse, it’s building a product that stands out in a sea of audio. The first iteration of the product, like a TikTok feed for audio, solves a challenging podcast discovery problem. The underlying tech has the potential to transform audio consumption far beyond podcasts.
Most of the sponsored posts I write focus mainly on the sponsor company, but Doug asked me to write up my views on audio more generally, and to help think through how Podz fits into the audio landscape. That fits with Podz’ (is there an s after the ’ if the word ends in z?) ethos.
The team realizes it’s going after one of the few remaining large untapped opportunities in social, and that it needs to continually improve the product to capture the prize. In fact, Podz’ (going with it) big ask from all of you is to fill out a survey to help the team improve Podz. Download the Podz app here (iPhone only):
Then complete the survey:
Today’s deep dive won’t be like the others. We’re going to go deep down the earhole to cover:
* The State of Audio in 2021.
* Audio’s Challenges.
* Casual and Quality Winners.
* Podz and Human-Machine Pairs.
* The Opportunitiez for Podz.
Podz is the best solution I’ve seen to one of the hairiest, longest-standing challenges in tech: audio discovery.
The State of Audio in 2021
Note: to keep things simple, when we talk about audio, we’re talking about audio other than music unless otherwise stated.
After a rough start, 2020 turned out to be a fantastic year for podcasts. Remember that chart from a couple minutes ago? The one where podcasts fell off a cliff?
Turns …
Welcome to the 439 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 31,356 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
Today’s Not Boring is brought to you by…
I first heard of OpenPhone when I asked Twitter for their favorite work software. OpenPhone was in a small group that received multiple mentions. So I dug and learned that OpenPhone is the easiest way to have a business phone number. It’s a YC grad, just raised a $14 million Series A, and is used by companies from Deloitte to Not Boring Favorite, Ramp.
I decided to give it a try, and now I have my very own Not Boring number that I can use to text with all of you. Try it out. Text me at 1-917-818-0620.
OpenPhone is even better for teams, so I spoke to someone who runs one, Jonathon Barkl, the CEO at AirGarage. He told me that his team uses OpenPhone to replace Google Voice, give everyone a business phone number, and automate workflows. Actually, you know what, I recorded the call in one click with OpenPhone, so you can listen to Jonathon tell you in his own words:
Listen to Jonathon Barkl explain how AirGarage uses OpenPhone
To get your team set up with a powerful and delightful business phone in an app, sign up here:
(P.S. This is OpenPhone’s first paid marketing EVER. Show them some love!)
Happy Monday! Today is an essay that I’m both excited and nervous about.
Excited because some of the most fascinating work in tech is being done rebuilding the underlying structure of the internet and the economy, and I’ve wanted an excuse to dive in. We’re going deep on Web3, NFTs, and the Metaverse. It’s all more mind-blowing and more legit than I expected coming into this piece.
Nervous because, like APIs All the Way Down, I am airdropping into a couple of different worlds in which thousands of people smarter than me have spent years building, investing, and exploring. I’m trying to explain topics that are so much deeper than I could cover in even a year.
In doing so, I am definitely going to get some things wrong, or explain in the most surface-y way something that hides tons of complexity, but I hope that in getting those things wrong, it will help people building and evangelizing Web3 to understand where the holes in the communication are.
This is a risk - I’m fully ready and willing to get dunked on (read Building in DeFi Sucks). In fact, if you’re building in this space, I’d love for you to give feedback or poke holes publicly, like Lillian Li did when I wrote about Alibaba.
Here’s the tweet about this essay, do your thing:
[INSERT LINK TO TWEET]
I’ve been a Metaverse bull for a while, and I’m now finally understanding the huge potential of decentralization. My goal today is to translate to a broader audience, and flesh out some of the business models and value chains underlying the future.
Let’s get to it.
The Value Chain of the Open Metaverse
This Metaverse is going to be far more pervasive and powerful than anything else. If one central company gains control of this, they will become more powerful than any government and be a god on Earth.
Tim Sweeney, CEO, Epic Games
Beeple’s Millions
Between December 11th and December 13th, an artist named Mike Winkelmann, who goes by Beeple, sold his works directly to collectors via online auction house Nifty Gateway.
The welcome bidders received upon entering the site was the first sign that this wasn’t going to be like something Sotheby’s or Christie’s would put on:
hahahah, ok so we're going balls deep on this motherfucker.
Then, there was the structure:
* Three works were priced at $969 each and left open for five minutes. Anyone who wanted to purchase one or more, could.
* One work priced at $1 each, and only 100 were made available. They sold out within seconds.
* Twenty-one works were sold one at a time, normal auction rules, highest bidder wins.
* At the end, the artist auctioned off “THE COMPLETE MF COLLECTION,” including all twenty-five works sold prior.
Finally, and most notably, there was the art itself. Beeple’s Everydays collection was composed of digital art backed by non-fungible tokens (NFTs) used to prove the validity, ownership, and scarcity of digital items or experiences.
Oh, and over the course of those three days, Beeple earned $3.5 million.
Where Web3 Meets the Metaverse
Beeple’s auction is one of many wisps that have started to come together recently that have piqued my interest in Web3, NFTs, DeFi, and whether and how they’ll interact with the Metaverse.
I have been excited about the potential of the Metaverse for a while. I’ve written about it here, and here, and here. I think that Web3, a decentralized evolution of the internet. might hold the key, and that NFTs are a bridge between Web3 and the virtual economy of the Metaverse.
I know some of this sounds out there. I’m more bullish on the Metaverse and the blockchain conceptually than most non-crypto startup people. Relative to the more finance-y folks here, my views are downright techno-utopian. And yet, whenever I heard that the Metaverse would become a multi-trillion-dollar economy, or that Web3 is the new internet, Bitcoin will hit $100k, DeFi will obsolete fintech, and decentralization is our best bet in the battle against big scary corporations… I didn’t quite get it.
The vocabulary around Web3, like that of many early movements, is very idealistic. It’s all about using technology to create trustless systems, wrest power from corporations, and give it back to the people. I think that vocabulary is why I haven’t taken it seriously as a real alternative to the status quo.
But I have gone deep down the rabbit hole, and I think I get it now. I can see how the decentralized web might make the leap from passionate early adopters to the mainstream, that there are real economic advantages to a decentralized internet, and that Web3 architectures will play a crucial role in a robust Metaverse.
What has been missing for me is a clear use case, like NFTs, and an understanding of the business models and value chains underlying a lot of these concepts. Yes, there’s idealism, but there’s also a sense of building a new economy in which the value accrues to the people who create the value. That’s capitalism, baby.
Today, I’m going to do my best to unpack it. Web3 and the Metaverse are two separate ideas that may or may not intersect. I think the future is much more exciting if they do. To understand why, we’ll start by understanding Web3, dive into NFTs, then move onto the Metaverse, and then look at what could happen when these ideas converge.
* What is Web3 and Why is it Important?
* Non-Fungible Tokens and Digital Ownership.
* NFTs in the Wild.
* The Size of the Metaverse Prize.
* The Open Versus Closed Metaverse.
* Crucible and The Direct-to Avatar Economy.
* The Value Chain of the Open Metaverse.
You’re going to be hearing a lot more about Web3 (including DeFi), NFTs, and the Metaverse, and if you dismiss it, you could be left behind. So join me down the rabbit hole.
It’s going to get weird. Ready Reader One?
What is Web3 and Why is it Important?
I’m going to make a gross generalization about you based only on the knowledge that you read Not Boring: you’ve heard the terms Metaverse, Web3, and NFT, but you wouldn’t bet money on your ability to define them, and you don’t know how and where they intersect. That’s what we’re here for.
To start to unpack it, we need to define Web3. It’s the foundational concept here.
Web3 is a return to the vision of the early internet, with built-in superpowers. Decrypt, a media platform covering the decentralized web, kicks off its Web3 explainer with this description: “the next major iteration of the Internet, which promises to wrest control from the centralized corporations that today dominate the web.”
While that explanation might build fervor among early adopters and builders, it doesn’t do Web3 any favors with a wider audience. It says what Web3 is against, not what it’s for.
The best way to describe the positive attributes of …
Welcome to the 665 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 31,114 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Thursday! It’s been a good week. Let’s keep that momentum going!
Sponsored deep dives have become one of my favorite parts of writing Not Boring, and not just because they mean that this newsletter is a financially viable way to make a living (although that part is great!). What I enjoy most is that they give me access to the people building companies that are re-shaping the industries that you and I are interested in. I’m able to write in more depth on these topics with their guidance than I can alone. I know I seem very fancy and cultured, but I didn’t know nearly as much about the art market as you might expect.
Obviously, being paid to write something means that there’s a potential conflict of interest. Earning and keeping your trust is the only thing that keeps this newsletter going and growing, and I’m confident I haven’t written a single thing in a sponsored post that I wouldn’t have written anyway, but I want to give you a peek into my process. You can read how I think about it here:
I told you that I’d let you know how I’m being paid for each sponsored deep dive — CPM (paid a certain rate no matter what) or CPA (paid for each person who signs up for the product). Since I’m writing about an investment product, and this isn’t advice, I’m being paid on CPM.
Today, I’m writing about a company that I’ve written about before. It’s a leader in one of the spaces that fascinates me most: alternative investing. Software is eating the markets, and democratizing previously opaque and inaccessible markets. Maybe no asset class fits the bill better than blue-chip art.
Let’s get to it.
Masterworks: Demystifying & Democratizing Art
The Case of The Missing $450 Million Mundi
In November 2017, Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi became the most expensive piece of art ever when it sold at Christie’s for $450 million. The buyer, at first anonymous, turned out to be Saudi Prince Bader bin Abdullah bin Mohammed bin Farhan al-Saud, who was, in turn, allegedly serving as a proxy for Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (MBS). When the painting’s planned exhibit at the Louvre Abu Dhabi was delayed indefinitely, it set off wild conspiracy theories involving the Saudis, Russians, and the Trump campaign. According to Vox:
Narativ published a theory that placed Salvator Mundi at the center of an international money laundering scheme implicating the royal families of Saudi Arabia and Abu Dhabi, along with Donald Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign staff, the Israeli intelligence firm Psy-Group, and the Russian potash fertilizer magnate Dmitry Rybolovlev, the painting’s previous owner.
Rybolovlev, the Narativ post claimed, put the painting up for auction knowing that the Saudis and the Emiratis would bid for it, artificially inflating its value. Narativ posits the funds from the sale were then funneled to Psy-Group, which, according to a report by the Daily Beast, had ties to the Trump campaign.
That theory has been debunked -- if you’re going to launder money, why do it via the highest-profile art sale in history? -- but it highlights how blue-chip, or investment grade, art has historically been:
* Limited to the wealthiest of the wealthy
* Shrouded in opacity bordering on mystery
Three years later, half a world away from the United Arab Emirates, another art transaction proved just how much those two things have changed.
I hate to brag, and it feels a bit gauche to talk about this publicly, but we’re all friends here so I’ll tell you: I, like MBS, am kind of an art collector.
I own Agnes Martin’s Untitled #1, Lucio Fontana’s Concetto Spaziale, and, yes, a Basquiat, Loin, which the artist painted in his pivotal year, 1982.
Well, I own a small piece of each, at least, which I bought via the subject and sponsor of today’s essay: Masterworks.
Meet Masterworks
Masterworks, founded in 2017, is the first company to make it possible for everyone to invest in blue-chip art, from Monet to Warhol. It’s a part of the class of startups taking advantage of regulatory and technological advances to bring investing in alternative asset classes to the masses. There’s Fundrise for real estate, and Rally Rd. for collectibles, AngelList for venture capital, and Republic for equity crowdfunding. I wrote about this group in Software is Eating the Markets, saying of Masterworks:
Masterworks takes art collecting digital and makes it accessible to regular investors. Investors can buy shares in works by Andy Warhol, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Keith Haring, Picasso, Banksy, and Monet. Even a digital portfolio of blue-chip art is more tangible than a bond, is something buyers can brag about to friends, and provides an excuse to learn art history, and returns from blue-chip art have doubled the S&P 500’s over the past twenty years.
Art is the archetypal alternative asset class in a world in which rates remain low and software eats the markets. It provides social status, entertainment, education, and a digital asset that’s beautiful to look at and to display. Plus, unlike, say, Bitcoin, which uses math to create scarcity, each classic piece of artwork is truly one-of-a-kind.
It’s also compelling enough to own that it should attract some retail investment dollars away from stocks and help investors create more diversified and less correlated investment portfolios. In fact, using Masterworks’ data, Citi found that art has a minuscule 0.01 correlation factor with the S&P.
Blue-chip art should be an aesthetically pleasing part of most diversified, long-term investment portfolios, and indeed, art has long been a mainstay in the portfolios of the ultra-wealthy. But until very recently, art investing has been out of reach for the average investor. With art, maybe more than any other asset class, the best investments are often the most expensive, and investing in art, until now, meant buying the whole damn piece.
Masterworks is changing that, and making rare art attainable for regular people. I, for example, write a free newsletter and I own a Basquiat. So with Masterworks’ help, today, I’ll serve as your curator and guide through the wonderful world of blue-chip art.
* Masterworks’ Price Database. Masterworks built the most complete repeat-sale pair database, which underpins everything it does.
* Art as an Asset Class. Strong returns, low volatility, low correlation, and declining supply.
* Digitizing and Democratizing Art Investing. Masterworks gives anyone the opportunity to purchase shares in blue-chip art.
* Investing on Masterworks. It took me 15 seconds to invest in a piece of art. I’ll show you.
* Art Market Tailwinds. Blue-chip art is a classic investment, and one that should be particularly well-suited for the world today.
* Build Your Portfolio. Once you’ve read today’s essay, you’ll get your Art Connoisseur Diploma and can skip the waitlist to start investing on Masterworks.
If you’ve always wanted to invest in art and just want to get to it, you can sign up to start investing on Masterworks right now. Not Boring readers can jump the waitlist at this link:
If you want to sound smart and cultured at your next socially distanced dinner party, put on your top hat and monocle and come explore the wonderful world of art with me.
Masterworks’ Price Database
To understand the art market, we need to start with Masterworks’ Price Database. Much of the data we’re going to use throughout this essay, and Masterworks’ own buying process, is based on the Database. Normally, I would look for data from a diverse set of sources, and I did for this essay as well, but the fact is Masterworks’ data is the most complete picture there is. Even leading investment banks like Citi rely on Masterworks’ data.
So what is it and why’d they build it?
The art market has historically been opaque. If you’re one of the small handful of people in the know, that’s a feature. If you’re putt…
Welcome to the 611 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 30,449 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
🎧 To get the audio edition of Not Boring as soon as it hits your ear, subscribe on Spotify.
🎧 Listen to my interview with Teamflow founder, Florent Crivello, here.
This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by…
Four Sigmatic is a wellness company that is well-known for its incredibly delicious Mushroom Coffee. Try starting your day with their Ground Mushroom Coffee with Lion’s Mane instead of regular coffee. They make real, organic, Fair-Trade, single-origin coffee, with Lion’s Mane mushroom for productivity, and Chaga for immune support.
If you’ve been reading Not Boring for a couple of months, you know I’m a big believer in the magic of mushrooms. I first tried Four Sigmatic when I heard them on the Tim Ferriss Podcast a few years ago, and can confirm that the Mushroom Coffee doesn’t give me jitters or a mid-day crash. Try it with a 10% discount using code “Not Boring” or just by clicking this link:
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Wednesday! In November, I wrote that We’re Never Going Backto the office 9-5, Monday-Friday. After I wrote the article, Dan Doyon introduced me to Flo Crivello, long one of my favorite tech and strategy writers and now the CEO of Teamflow.
Flo responded to the email with two pages about why, while he liked the piece, I wasn’t nearly optimistic enough. I rarely get that feedback; if anything, I get too excited about the topics and companies I write about. But Flo has a vision for what the world will look like when remote work is even better than working in-person, and he built Teamflow to make that vision a reality.
When Flo and I spoke, I knew I wanted to invest — the company hits so many of the themes I write about — and he agreed to open up some room in his 3x oversubscribed seed round for the Not Boring Syndicate. We decided that, since Teamflow (then called Huddle) was in stealth, we’d raise the round quietly within the syndicate, and then send the memo explaining why we invested once the product was ready for showtime.
That day has come. Actually, it came last week, and we were ready to hit send on Thursday until the events at the Capitol captured everyone’s attention and delayed the Product Hunt Launch. Help make this launch day better than the first by supporting Teamflow on PH:
So today, I’m excited to share why I’m so bullish on the Virtual HQ product Flo and team are building. Plus, you can hear for yourself. In a Not Boring first, I interviewed Flo for the Not Boring Podcast to talk about why he built Teamflow, his hiring process, and how he combines strategy and execution.
I believe Teamflow has the potential to be a generational company, and one that in five years, is synonymous with productive, collaborative, and happy remote work. Or as we’ll call it then: work.
Let’s get to it.
Teamflow: Not Boring Memo
When Salesforce acquired Slack, I got really happy at first, and then a little sad. I was happy for the vindication but needed to find a new favorite that checked as many boxes as Slack did for me. Enter Teamflow, a Virtual Workplace startup for hybrid and remote teams that just came out of stealth last Wednesday.
I’m not the only one who’s excited about Teamflow: in December, the Not Boring Syndicate filled a $250,000 allocation in a matter of hours (new record) and the company raised a 3x oversubscribed $3.9 million seed round from a roster of top early stage investors including Menlo Ventures, Elad Gil, Ron Conway’s SV Angel, Balaji Srinivasan and others.
It’s no surprise that investors are so bullish. The founder, Florent Crivello is one of my favorite business writers, a former early engineer and PM for Uber, and a founder I’d bet on eight days a week. If you’ve been reading Not Boring for a while, you should recognize the name. Plus, he’s attacking a trillion dollar market with which I am all too familiar: the office workplace.
As I wrote about in We’re Never Going Back, remote work will unlock the enormous potential previously constrained by geography, give employees more choice and leverage, and bring about second-and-third-order effects that will reshape the world.
But it’s not inevitable. To unlock the full potential of remote work will take relentless effort from talented and passionate entrepreneurs like Flo and buy-in from early adopters like us. Today, Readwise founder and Teamflow co-investor Dan Doyon and I are going to make the case for remote work, and for Teamflow as both the product and the business that will make working online better than working in an office. We’ll cover:
* Meet Teamflow. The product offers a glimpse at what remote work should feel like, and a potential meta-layer for work and collaboration tools. And it’s still just in beta.
* We Might Be Going Back. A remote-first world is now more likely than ever, but it’s not as inevitable as we very online folk might think. It’s up to early adopters like us to help power through the valley of mismatch (one of my favorite Florent essays).
* Flo & Team Teamflow. Teamflow is a bet on Florent Crivello and the all-star cast he’s bringing together, from all over the world. That’s a bet I’m excited to make.
* Virality & Moats. Teamflow combines Zoom’s virality with Slack’s moats.
Pardon my French (Flo is Parisian, btw), but it is so fucking cool to see so many ideas I find important come together in one product. If Teamflow is successful, it won’t just ride the remote work wave, it will lead it, making work better, wherever your team is.
The best way to experience Teamflow is to try it yourself. You can signup today, and by joining with the Not Boring Link, Flo will move you up the waitlist:
While you wait, let me do the next best thing: tell you about it using pictures and words.
Meet Teamflow
Teamflow is what remote work should feel like. It’s a virtual HQ where teams can work, meet, and hang out together. It combines video, open spaces, meeting rooms, and tools like docs, whiteboards, video, and images to create a space that feels so much better than a Zoom.
See for yourself. From 9:30-10:30am est, I’ll be hanging out in the Not Boring Teamflow HQ.
Because Teamflow is spatial, it lets users do things that they can’t in Slack, Zoom, or a Google Doc. You can move your Bubbles around the space, pop into conversations with co-workers, or enter closed spaces to have private conversations or meetings. You only hear people who are nearby. You can even click on co-workers to teleport to them.
Just like a physical office, Teamflow lets you leave artifacts in a space -- the Marketing Room, for example, might have a doc with notes on your new campaign, images on the wall, and a whiteboard with the brainstorm from the last meeting. A Zoom room is like an office that the cleaning crew totally empties out at the end of each meeting. A Teamflow HQ persists.
Working in Teamflow brings back the casual face-to-face interactions we miss when we’re not in the office, without bringing back the commute.
Despite not having a “team,” I use Teamflow to create a focused work environment with the things I need for the task at hand. Here’s me watching an interview Flo gave to prepare to interview him.
I have my whiteboard, a scratchpad, my very own desk, and a YouTube video up in an iFrame. Today, there are just a few simple tools integrated, but over time, Teamflow plans to integrate all of the products that teams use to work. The team is currently working on a chat tool à la Slack. Soon, you’ll be able to design in Figma, work on presentations in Pitch, pair code, close the books, and do all of the things companies do today, together, in Teamflow.
Teamflow brings collaboration and communication into one place. In The Arc of Collaboration, Kevin Kwok wrote about the “meta-coordination layer” for work:
There is a need for a layer across all the applications. A layer for things that should be shared across the apps as well collaborative …
Welcome to the 551 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since last Monday! If you aren’t subscribed, join 29,828 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by…
ExitUp is a weekly newsletter that delivers a curated list of fresh job openings across PE, VC, strategy/biz ops, finance, marketing, and product management right to your inbox. You'll also get useful insights to help you navigate your job search so that when the time comes, you'll be ready to nail the interview.
Just this week, ExitUp featured dream jobs at WorkLife Ventures, Twitter, Niantic, Impossible Foods, and more. Go put what you read about in Not Boring to work.
Subscribe for free today, and find your exit opportunity with ExitUp.
BABA Black Sheep
We Don’t Know (Where) Jack (Is)
I can’t stop buying Chinese tech conglomerates.
After writing about Tencent in August (here and here), I’ve slowly built it into my second largest holding. Every time it drops on news that the US or Chinese government said or did something, I buy.
Now, its main rival, Alibaba, is embroiled in a situation so wild that if it happened in the US, to Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk, it’s all we’d be talking about. Its stock is down 25% from October highs. My mouth is starting to water.
In case you missed it, here’s what went down:
On October 24th, days away from the IPO of his fintech giant Ant Group, Alibaba founder and ex-CEO and Chairman, Jack Ma told an audience of China’s financitariat:
Banks today still hold a pawnshop mentality…. It is impossible for the pawnshop mentality to support the financial demand of global development over the next 30 years. We must leverage our technological capabilities today and build a credit system based on big data, to get rid of the pawnshop mentality.
We can’t use yesterday’s methods to regulate the future.
To western ears, those sound like the boastful and ultimately harmless words of a passionate entrepreneur. But in China, where the Chinese Communist Party (“CCP”) has long run the banking system and doesn’t take kindly to challenges, those were fighting words. And in China, the CCP doesn’t lose fights.
Jack’s remarks set off a chain of events that derailed Ant Group’s planned November 5th $37 billion IPO, which would have valued the Alibaba spin-off, of which the company still owns 33%, north of $300 billion.
* November 2nd: China’s central bank and securities regulators called Jack and two Ant Group executives to a meeting.
* On the same day, regulators announced that they were considering regulating Ant’s lending arm, its main growth engine, more like a bank and less like a tech company.
* November 3rd: the Shanghai and Hong Kong Stock Exchanges suspended the offerings at President Xi Jinping’s command.
* December 23rd: Chinese regulators opened an antitrust probe into whether Alibaba had engaged in monopolistic practices. Alibaba’s stock (BABA) tumbled 13%.
* December 27th: Regulators told Ant to return to its payments roots and come up with a plan to pare down its lending, insurance, and wealth management business.
And as of today, 79 days after that explosive speech, no one has seen China’s third-richest man in public. Jack Ma is missing.
Rumors have flown around the internet in recent days as to Jack’s whereabouts. For a minute, people feared he might be in jail or dead. Then sources close to Jack said he was just “laying low.” A video of a Jack doppelganger went viral, saying that he’d been found repairing an AC unit:
Pardon my Mandarin, but this is fucking crazy. The founder and CEO of the world’s largest eCommerce business by Gross Merchandise Volume (GMV) and one of China’s Big Three just… disappeared.
In China, Alibaba is like Amazon, Google, DoorDash, YouTube, Slack, Square, and Farfetch all rolled into one, plus some. Most people in the west still know Alibaba for its original and eponymous Alibaba.com, the B2B marketplace where wholesalers can find 1,000 ballpoint pens for $0.10 each. Chances are, when you buy something on Amazon, that product started on Alibaba, which has quietly powered the drop-shipping and third-party seller economy by letting anyone buy from foreign manufacturers and ship to the world.
But the legacy business makes up less than 5% of the company’s total revenue today. Its main sites, domestic B2C marketplaces Taobao and Tmall, are so massive that on 2020’s Singles’ Day, China’s version Black Friday/Cyber Monday, it did 7x the GMV that Amazon did on Prime Day. If a western brand wants to sell to China’s 1 billion+ consumers, it needs to go through Tmall.
Like Tencent, Alibaba has its hand in everything, often because if foreign businesses want to do business in China, they need to go through one of its two biggest companies. In recent years, Alibaba has expanded beyond eCommerce. It owns, among other things:
* Youku: the Chinese version of YouTube and Hulu rolled into one.
* Alibaba Pictures: a film production studio and investor that financed two Mission: Impossible movies, Fallout and Rogue Nation.
* Startup Investments: Alibaba still owns 2.3% of Lyft, and even invested in Quibi 🙈
* DingTalk: The Chinese equivalent of Slack.
* Cainiao: a logistics platform with ambitions to sit at the center of the world’s logistics.
* Ant Group: a 33% stake in China’s biggest fintech company.
Jack Ma and Alibaba have arguably done more than any single company to grow the Chinese middle class and improve the quality of life for the average Chinese person. But since Jack (characteristically) opened his mouth in October, Alibaba is a black sheep.
Look, I have no idea where Jack is or when he might come back. I have no idea what the government is going to do with Ant Group or whether it is going to break up Alibaba. But it doesn’t seem like anyone else does, either. As a result, this is what BABA’s stock chart looks like since October 24th.
After trading in line with other Chinese internet stocks throughout the year, BABA tanked in November after the government pulled the Ant IPO. It kept dropping as the government announced an antitrust probe, as the US signaled it might include Alibaba on a list of banned companies, and, of course, as people realized Ma went MiA.
BABA is down 25.5% from its October 27th high of $317. It’s lost $219 billion, or an entire Pinduoduo, in market cap. In a matter of months, it’s become the tech megacap equivalent of a deep value stock.
As it stands, the world’s tenth largest company by market cap is either mouthwateringly cheap or wildly risky. I don’t know which it is -- prognosticating on the actions of the CCP is above my pay grade -- and nor does anyone else. But it’s going to create an opportunity either way, and we need to be prepared. So today, we’re going to learn about Alibaba.
* The Story of Magic Jack and Alibaba
* The Strategic Tao of Jack
* What is Alibaba Today?
* Alibaba vs. Amazon
* Ant IPO Debacle.
* Investing in China
* What to Do About BABA
When I wrote about Tencent in August, I wrote that “Tencent is the most important company that many Americans know the least about.” Alibaba’s story is more well-known, partially for the same reason that the company is in trouble right now: unlike Tencent’s Pony Ma, Jack Ma speaks English, and he’s never been shy to wield his words.
The Story of Magic Jack and Alibaba
Note: I’ve used Porter Erisman’s documentary Crocodile in the Yangtze, Duncan Clark’s book Alibaba: The House That Jack Ma Built, and the Acquired podcast on Alibaba to piece together Alibaba’s history.
Jack Ma and Alibaba created eCommerce in China, the largest market in the world, from nothing, against all odds. He succeeded through surprisingly good luck, a tireless work ethic, and what author Duncan Clark called “a unique Chinese combination of blarney and chutzpah... ‘Jack Magic.’”
Jack Ma was born Ma Yun in Hangzhou, China in 1964, just two years before Mao Zedong’s Cultural Revolution. The Cultural Revolution was a movement to “preserve Chinese Communism by purgin…
Welcome to the 2,417 newly Not Boring people who have joined us since the last 2020 email! If you aren’t subscribed, join 29,252 smart, curious folks by subscribing here:
This week’s Not Boring is brought to you by…
Pipe is building an entirely new asset class based on recurring revenue contracts. It’s not equity and it’s not a loan. Pipe lets businesses raise money today by selling their monthly or quarterly subscription cash flows directly through its platform, without needing to raise more dilutive venture capital.
Since I wrote about Pipe in October, the company has been busy. Now, you can sign up and run through a self-serve walkthrough to see what it’s like trading your subscription revenue.
For any recurring revenue business, checking how much your recurring revenues are worth on Pipe is a no-brainer. Sign up and find out how much cash Pipe can send you today.
Hi friends 👋 ,
Happy Monday! I hope you all had a great holiday, and that it’s not too rough getting back into the flow of things this morning.
Every year, on New Year’s Day, I take some time to reflect back on the previous year and set some goals for the year ahead. This time last year, I was in the middle of starting an in-person community business and writing this newsletter’s predecessor as a fun side thing. I set a goal to hit 1,000 subscribers by the end of 2020.
Here we are on the first Monday of 2021, and there are more than 29,000 of us here, and all of my professional focus and goals are centered on this thing.
One of the goals I wrote down is to keep improving the content, pushing myself, and trying new things. In that spirit, why not kick off the year with something I didn’t do at all last year: a bear case.
Let’s get to it.
Bill-A-Bear
It was the fifth email in a long back-and-forth with a sponsor that changed me, made me bearish on a company not named “Quibi” for once.
Here’s how it went down: a company sponsored Not Boring. They wanted to pay me, asked me to invoice them on bill.com. Wham, bam, thank you sir. But they kept trying to pay me and they kept getting notifications that it didn’t work. I kept trying to fix it on my end, even upgraded to a paid plan, kept telling them that it was fixed.
“Should work now!”
“Nope. Maybe you should contact customer support.”
“OK got it, all squared away. Try again!”
“It didn’t work.”
Finally, on the fifth try, we got it, but not before a strange and unusual feeling set in: I was officially bearish on bill.com.
It’s not in my nature to be bearish. When I set out to write a takedown of SoftBank, I came away kind of loving Masa. As I wrote last time, I’m a natural born optimist. I have a really hard time seeing the downside. But every time I have to log into bill.com, a little bear growls loudly on my right shoulder, drowning out the typically ever-present angel on my left.
Finally, the growling got loud enough that I decided to look at the numbers. Surely, if I felt this way, others did too. That must be reflected in the stock price, right? Wrong.
Bill’s stock price nearly quadrupled last year, and the numbers don’t support the move. Bill is a bottom-quartile BVP Emerging Cloud Index company trading like a top quartile one. Its revenue growth is slowing, its revenue multiple: dizzying, its free cash flow: negative. It faces competition from powerful incumbents, fintech darlings like Stripe and Square, and new startups like Settle. And did I mention its product? It feels like something a Salesforce Product Manager would dream up if Salesforce enacted Google-like 20% projects.
(Ed. note: I learned, after writing this sentence, that indeed, bill.com’s first two engineers came from Salesforce and the company bought the domain from Marc Benioff. If it walks like a Salesforce and quacks like a Salesforce, or something.)
Now look, I don’t want to pick on bill.com. The company’s 618 employees are trying their best, and they’ve built a company worth over $11 billion. I, as a reminder, write a free newsletter. It brings me no joy to pop the Bill bubble.
But having a bad experience with bill.com was lucky. It forced me to sharpen my bear claws heading into a year during which sharp bear claws will come in handy.
While 2020 was a year for unbridled tech optimism, I think 2021 is going to be a year for discerning tech optimism. There’s going to be a flight to quality within tech. Market leaders with strong growth, big margins, profitability, and best-in-class products will continue to earn strong multiples, but laggards with outdated products and relatively unattractive numbers will underperform, regardless of sub-sector or market cap.
This whole bear thing is new to me, so we’ll take it one step at a time:
* What is bill.com? A just-the-facts look at Bill’s product, business model, and distribution.
* The Bill Bear Case. Bill.com touts the highest revenue multiple in the entire BVP Cloud Index, and it has neither the numbers nor the product to back it up.
* The Love-Hate Relationship with Work Software. People hate old, locked-in enterprise software, and love the new breed of product-first, consumerized B2B SaaS. Bill.com’s product fits with the old guard, but it hasn’t had as much time as them to dig moats.
* Killing a Baby Dictator. Bill.com is still small enough for competitors to defeat before it’s too late.
As always, this is not investment advice. I’m definitely not suggesting that you short a tech momentum stock in this market. The Keynes quote that, “The markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent” rings truer every day.
What is bill.com?
Bill.com is founder René Lacerte’s second bite at the apple.
In 1999, Lacerte, a fourth generation entrepreneur, left his job at Intuit to build PayCycle and replace manual payroll with software. It looked like this:
In 2004, five years into the journey and faced with slowing growth, PayCycle’s board removed Lacerte from the CEO role. (PayCycle later sold to Lacerte’s old employer, Intuit, for $170 million in 2009.) After being fired from the CEO role, Lacerte served as CFO for a year before leaving the company to work on his next thing.
Lacerte’s next thing, which he founded in 2006, was originally called “CashView.” When Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff heard about it, he called Lacerte and offered him, for the low low price of $200k, a domain that he happened to own: bill.com.
Bill.com’s mission was and is to “make it simple to connect and do business.” It attempts to do that through cloud-based Accounts Receivable (AR) and Accounts Payable (AP) software for SMBs.
If it sounds unsexy, that’s because it is, but it’s also important. In any business, particularly SMBs, cash is king. A company can improve its cash position without doing a dollar more in sales or cutting any costs by stretching out payables and pulling in receivables. There’s even a formula for it: the Cash Conversion Cycle formula.
Bill’s promise is that by giving customers better tools and data, companies will receive money more quickly and pay out more slowly, shortening the CCC and putting more money in the bank at any given time.
The prize for helping companies simplify AR and AP and improve the cash conversion cycle is large: there are 6 million small or medium businesses (SMBs), those with revenues under $100 million, in the United States, and 75-90% of those businesses still pay for things with checks. Over the next decade, most of that volume will move online.
The question is: how do you capture it?
In tech, there’s a never-ending battle between product (the actual software) and distribution (how a company sells to customers). Bill.com is a distribution play.
Lacerte ran essentially the same playbook at PayCycle and bill.com:
* Replace a paper-based finance workflow with software.
* Distribute through partnerships with accounting firms and others who own the relationships with SMB clients.
* Try to create network effects and switching costs and hold on for dear life.
Because PayCycle and bill.com competed with physically writing out payc…
From the publisher's feed