Hi everyone!
Happy new year! Welcome back not just for another week, but a whole other year of reviews! Thank you so much for all your support over 2018 and 2019. We're looking forward to 2020 more than ever before! This abbreviated week, we'll have today's review of STAR WARS: EPISODE IX, which will be as forgiving as it can be. We'll follow that tomorrow with the return of One Movie Spouse with her review of LITTLE WOMEN (Episode #673). And then Andrew Campbell, the man, the myth, the legend, returns with not one, but two reviews: IN FABRIC (Episode #674) for his Fantastic Fest beat, and 1917 (Episode #675), because I let him after he introduced me this year to ONE CUT OF THE DEAD (Episode #625).
Also, be sure to tune in this Sunday for our Patreon episode covering Year Three at One Movie Punch, along with two delayed episodes from the break seeing the light of day. While you're there, please consider becoming a sponsor for the podcast in Year Three! You'll be eligible for Sponsor Sundays, which you'll hear a little more about before today's review. Find out more at patreon.com/onemoviepunch.
Subscribe to stay current with the latest releases.
Contribute at Patreon for exclusive content.
Connect with us over social media to continue the conversation.
Here we go!
/////
>
/////
Today's movie is STAR WARS: EPISODE IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER, the final installment in the recently coined Skywalker Saga, directed by J.J. Abrams, and written for the screen in collaboration with Chris Terrio, based on a story by Derek Connolly, Colin Trevorrow, and Kathleen Kennedy, based on the characters and universe created by George Lucas. Following the events of THE LAST JEDI, Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) discovers the path to the hidden Sith world of Exegol, where he also learns that Emporer Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) is still alive and wants Rey (Daisy Ridley) dead. Now the Resistance must face this new threat, before Palpatine conquers the entire galaxy.
No spoilers.
Before we start talking about today's movie, I want to walk through the sordid history of the Star Wars film franchise, particular with the naming of this nine movie film series the Skywalker Saga. My first taste of Star Wars films was watching RETURN OF THE JEDI on television, having been far too young to have seen the films in theaters. I was absolutely entranced by the Ewoks and thought the lightsabers were pretty cool. I also knew that my peers had quite a few of the toys, which became a sort of status symbol amongst us. I think I was more into G.I. Joe and Transformers at the time, but I definitely dug Star Wars, and when it became available, I bought the trilogy on VHS for a lot more than I should have paid. I also read quite a few of the extended universe novels and comic books, which my friend had, including the incredible Timothy Zahn trilogy currently being reworked into the new canon. I started out knowing way less than my friends, and through a lot of reading, came to know more about that galaxy far, far away.
I might have been too young for the original trilogy, but I was definitely old enough to know the hype was so real in 1999 when THE PHANTOM MENACE was finally coming to theaters, sixteen years after the last film. My friend group was mostly nerd, or at least nerd-friendly, so we got our tickets for the midnight showing, got all sorts of liquored up, then headed to see the film. And, as we all know by now, it didn't live up to expectations. I don't think it could have. The special effects were incredible, but the story lacked something important, and also included the overly-maligned Jar Jar Binks, who became the target for this hype backlash. By the time 2005's REVENGE OF THE SITH had graced theaters, the fanbase had reached new levels of toxicity, and the films quietly disappeared as Lucasfilm went into production for THE CLONE WARS animated series.
It wasn't until my daughter started getting into Star Wars that our family went back to view the first two trilogies, which was well after Lucasfilm was sold to Disney for $4 billion. Subsequent viewings made the original trilogy seem a lot less good and the prequel trilogy to seem a lot better than it had been received. One Movie Spawn and I began working our way through THE CLONE WARS, along with a whole new generation of Star Wars enthusiasts finding more affinities with Ahsoka and Anakin. It also filled in a lot of the gaps between Episode II and Episode III, both in terms of plot and character development. So, when Disney announced they were bringing J.J. Abrams on board to reboot the franchise, I was stoked.
THE RISE OF SKYWALKER feels like what happens when a franchise tries too hard to safely cater to its fans. Whatever criticisms there might be of the first two trilogies, George Lucas did provide a singular vision for the characters and the story, building a universe out of the surprise success of A NEW HOPE, with the constant support and co-leadership of Kathleen Kennedy. However, in the wake of Lucas' retirement, and the backlash from a subset of franchise fans, that vision has slowly gotten muddled in the past few years between the continuing saga films and the one-offs set before the original trilogy, and in the case of ROGUE ONE, right before the original trilogy.
We should expect a few bumps in the road trying to rewrite canon, rather than just starting over. Even the pre-reboot canon had more than one instance of contradictions requiring clever retcon, a sign that the universe was growing much too fast for its creators. All the toxic fans came out of the woodwork again, picking apart the plot of THE FORCE AWAKENS, then the absolutely bizarre fascination with tearing down Kelly Marie Tran's portrayal of Rose Tico in THE LAST JEDI. With each bit of criticism, the franchise seems to be constantly overcorrecting. Critically speaking, the new films have been well-received when they take chances (THE FORCE AWAKENS, ROGUE ONE, THE LAST JEDI), and not as well received when corporate has come in to provide feedback and comments. SOLO had a major shake-up along the way, when Phil Lord and Christopher Miller were fired in favor of Ron Howard, with the result being muddled. And now, with THE RISE OF SKYWALKER, we see overcorrections all over the place, real or perceived.
We have toxic fans to thank here again. It seemed like every bit of information about THE RISE OF SKYWALKER came with an avalanche of hot takes. I don't mind speculation, especially with teaser information, but toxic fans have a way of turning speculation into fact, then forcing everyone to pick a side, and lambasting anyone who doesn't choose their side. I still can't believe folks thought there was a beef between Johnson and Abrams, and that they would use $200M movies to wage it, but it happened. The coverage in the wake of THE RISE OF SKYWALKER has already started with the "IS STAR WARS OVER?!" messaging, and frankly, I'm getting tired of it.
So, to be safe, it looks like Lucasfilm brought in a team of writers, to try and make everyone happy, and not really succeeding anywhere in the process. The story appears to be a collaboration between Abrams, Terrio, Connolly, and Trevorrow, and it really shows in THE RISE OF SKYWALKER. Connolly and Trevorrow are no strangers to franchises, having successfully, in a matter of speaking, rebooted the Jurassic Park franchise with the current Jurassic World trilogy. THE RISE OF SKYWALKER contains a lot of iconic shots, similar to the Jurassic Park franchise. And those iconic moments look really great in the screen, but the connective tissue between those shots is, at best, a mixed bag. Everything is played pretty safe, and as such, doesn't really surprise.
The question is why? How can an iconic franchise fizzle out in such spectacular fashion? Well, first, it was an impossible task, told over too many years to be effective. Lucas' career appears to have been one of fascination, moving between his two major franchises, Star Wars and Indiana Jones. Franchises, as we saw more than once last year, require consistency to stay viable, and having ten to sixteen year gaps between trilogies is ineffective to maintain momentum. I wonder how much better these stories may have been without the massive gaps. And I'll just say here that "The Mandalorian" gives me a great deal of hope for the future of the franchise.
The other major factor is the storytelling approach. The trilogies have acted as the backbone for the franchise, with the rest of the canon being built off that backbone. By contrast, the success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe is not just in consistency, kicking up to four films a year soon, but also in their crossover approach for building their backbone. All the character development we need for Marvel characters happens inside their individual films, so we can focus on the story almost exclusively in the crossover films. THE RISE OF SKYWALKER, having no other real development for its characters outside of the canon novels, ends up having to do character development, find the iconic shots, and close out a massive nine-film space opera story in one film. Much more story was needed before this film to make it effective on the screen for franchise fans.
STAR WARS: EPISODE IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER is a lackluster ending to a nine-movie saga, which may either lead to some deep introspection for the franchise, or perhaps releases the franchise from the three trilogy burden initially envisioned by George Lucas. Struggling to do too much with the final film, Abrams & Terrio (along with Connolly, Trevorrow, and Kennedy) attempt to please everyone, and end up with mixed results. Where it lacks in story, however, it makes up for somewhat in Lucasfilm's commitment to special effects and gripping action scenes, along with more than a few iconic shots set in the beauty of space. Hardcore Star Wars fans have already seen the film, possibly more than once, and will likely have mixed feelings. Everyone else, especially those without franchise expectations, will find a visually appealing film that is still ultimately entertaining at its core. And much like the prequel trilogies, I suspect this reboot trilogy may age better over time.
Rotten Tomatoes: 55%
Metacritic: 54
One Movie Punch: 6.5/10
STAR WARS: EPISODE IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER (2019) is rated PG-13 and is currently playing intheaters.