"Take everything you know about teenage dramas and throw it in this script!" Is what one intern overheard an NBC executive scream into their phone when 'One of Us Is Lying' began production. Peacock might be late to the party when it comes to High School murder mysteries, but that doesn't mean they didn't try with this story. Distancing themselves from the source material, and casting a plethora of actors already famous for shows like Cobra Kai, Wayne, and Cruel Summer... This Gossip Girl/PLL/Elite rip off has some good moments, but overall doesn't seem worth the effort. Tune in to hear our full breakdown!