The investigation takes the P.I.'s of the Unexplainable to the Hamptons for a fanciful Valentine's Day Ball. Hank meets a kindred spirit, Charlie faces one of his greatest fears, and old nightmares come back to haunt our heroes.

George Primavera - DM / Kit Rockefeller

Nick Williams - Hank Blackstone

Jack Quaid - Big Charlie

Broden Kelley- Sykes P. Rogers

Natasha Mercado - Millie Tate

Dylan McCollum - Marble Mouth

Marty Abbe-Schneider - The Irish Bartender / Jake

Kira Rokith- Samantha

Lizzie McGroder- Elouise Thompson

Chuck McCollum- Dante LaPorta

Christopher House- Various