
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Dedicated readers that you are, Slushies, you may have noticed that each year there are fewer and fewer venues publishing book reviews. As writers and readers ourselves, we find this concerning. So much so that we have renewed our focus on soliciting and publishing reviews in PBQ. Today on the pod, we’re talking everything reviews from newspaper book review sections to magazines to Substack to shelf talkers to blurbs. We’re honored to welcome a member of the National Book Critics Circle to our discussion, Iris Jamahl Dunkle.
We have A LOT of opinions, Slushies, on spoilers (yes or no?), on what constitutes fair criticism, what duty writers themselves have to participate in the review process, and teaching the art of the review. We think about how the act of reviewing allows the reviewer the luxury and generosity of slowing down to spend time with a book. You’ll find an abundant list of links to many of the publications and reviews mentioned below. We think this is an important discussion and one we may revisit in an upcoming episode. Please let us know what your thoughts are on the state of the review. Thanks, as always for listening.
At the table: Iris Jamahl Dunkle (special guest), Karen Hildebrand, Tobi Kassim, Samantha Neugebauer, Kathleen Volk Miller, Marion Wrenn, Lisa Zerkle, Derek Grebis (Sound Engineer)
Guest Bio: Iris Jamahl Dunkle’s fourth collection of poems, West : Fire : Archive was published by The Center for Literary Publishing in 2021. Her new collection, Endnotes on the West, will be published by Texas Review Press in 2028. Her other books include USA Today bestselling Riding Like the Wind: The Life of Sanora Babb (University of California Press, 2024) and Charmian Kittredge London: Trailblazer, Author, Adventurer (University of Oklahoma Press, 2020), and forthcoming Strong (University of California Press). She writes Finding Lost Voices, a weekly blog that brings back the voices of women who have been forgotten or misremembered. Dunkle is Poet Laureate of Sonoma County Emerita and teaches at UC Davis and Sonoma State University.She currently serves on the National Book Critics Circle Board.
Now Available: Riding Like the Wind: The Life of Sanora Babb
Called, "heartbreaking and heroic." by Ken Burns and Dayton Duncan
Other books include: Charmian Kittredge London Trailblazer, Author, Adventurer and : West: Fire Archive
Finding Lost Voices on Substack: https://irisjamahldunkle.substack.com/
Website: www.irisjamahldunkle.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/iris.dunkle
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/irisdunkle/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/irjohnso
Review Resources and Links:
Marion Wrenn:
Eyes Wide Shut is a descendant of Bernardo Bertolucci‘s Last Tango in Paris. Both films examine the relationship of fucking to fraternity, of sex to society, and both reach the same conclusion: for the social order to survive, the instincts have to be recognized for what they are and then restored to their hiding place behind society’s curtains.
Other tidbits from Marion:
Kathleen Volk Miller:
Samantha Neugebauer:
Tobi Kassim:
Karen Hildebrand:
Lisa Zerkle:
We’re switching things up today, Slushies, with a discussion about a short story. Spoiler alert: we’ll be discussing the story in full. Before you listen to the pod, we suggest listening to the author read the story. That recording is available in the podcast feed. Today we’re talking about “The Lecture” by Brook J. Sadler, which takes on the notion of what’s required for the continued success of an older female writer. How is attention earned and sustained? Through writing and craft alone? The gambit chosen by the fictional writer sparks a spirited, Yesteryear-style discussion among the editors, Slushies. We get into the status of women’s rights and if the discourse around it is delayed. We wonder about progress or if there’s variation based on region. Amy Schumer’s iconic skit, The Last F*ckable Day is invoked. Listen along, read the story, and let us know what you think.
In other news, our esteemed colleague, Jason Schneiderman, couldn’t join us today because he was awarded the Pegasus Award for Poetry Criticism from the Poetry Foundation for his book Nothingism: Poetry at the End of Print Culture. Congratulations, Jason! We’re so proud of you.
At the table: Karen Hildebrand, Samantha Neugebauer, Kathleen Volk Miller, Lisa Zerkle, Derek Grebis (Sound Engineer)
Author Bio: Brook J. Sadler holds a Ph.D. in philosophy from Duke University and an MFA from the Warren Wilson Program for Writers. An award-winning teacher, she taught philosophy and interdisciplinary humanities and cultural studies at the University of South Florida for more than twenty years. Her poetry can be found in dozens of magazines, including Greensboro Review, The Dodge, and New American Writing. She also writes fiction, essays, criticism, and humor. Look for her work in McSweeney’s Internet Tendency, Ms. Magazine, and Aquifer: The Florida Review Online. Her philosophical articles, in academic journals address ethics, love and sex, feminism, and emotion. She lives in Florida, despite the heat and humidity, hurricanes and pythons, pernicious politicians and cane toads. When she is not at her desk, she is probably out walking the dog.
Social Media:
Instagram: @brookjsadler
Facebook: @brookjsadler
Read "The Lecture" by Brook J. Sadler
We’re changing things up today, Slushies, with a selection of prose from writer Charles Grosel. Spoiler alert: we only read the first page in the podcast itself. If you want the full experience of the piece before you hear us weigh in, scroll down to time stamp 38:15 where you can listen to the story in its entirety.
We’re all over the place in categorizing this piece as flash, fiction, and creative non-fiction. We discuss what literary elements are on display and which are not. Dagne notes the piece’s economy recalls Raymond Carver’s advice ‘to get in, get out, don’t linger.’ One character’s black-and-white outlook reminds KVM of the phrase “perfect certainty” that Sam used in a recent book review. Sam weighs in on the veracity, in general, of an author’s perspective. For example, she finds the famous fairy tale author, Hans Christian Andersen, an unreliable narrator based on his autobiography. Jason has thoughts about that habit of embellishment and about the iconic nature of the American Southwest. And listen in for the only thing that qualifies as pizza for KVM’s 90 year-old dad.
Sam also shares some of what she’s teaching to her writing students this semester, including a piece published in PBQ Issue 112 by Meghan Sterling called “Self-Portrait as Lee Krasner” that sent her students to the Smithsonian to see Krasner’s paintings in person. Thanks, as always, for listening!
At the table: Eric Baker, Dagne Forrest, Karen Hildebrand, Samantha Neugebauer, Jason Schneiderman, Kathleen Volk Miller, Lisa Zerkle, and Alina H. (Sound Tech)
Author Bio: Charles Grosel grew up in Ohio and now lives in Arizona. He has published stories in Western Humanities Review, Water-Stone, and The MacGuffin as well as poems in Epiphany, The Threepenny Review, and Cream City Review, among others. He has been a long-time student of The Writers Studio in NYC and would not get any work done without their support. His chapbook is The Sound of Rain Without Water.
Rain in the Valley of the Sun
Slushies! We’re delighted to have our own Marion Wrenn back at the table, throwing thumbs yea or nay. And Karen Hildebrand had so much fun discussing summer reads in our last episode, she decided to join us for another show (we welcome her back with only minor hazing). Today we’re discussing two poems by K. Hari. The first, “Rage Yoga After Roe”, gets us thinking about female spaces and friendships. We discuss what kind of poems can stand-alone and which ones are best in a manuscript when other poems can inform their narrative.
The second poem, “Proof of Relationship”, digs deep into multiple layers of memory in relation to what is and isn’t evident in a photograph. What does it mean when a couple must perform their relationship in order to prove it in an official capacity? The theme of governmental intrusion into one’s personal life in the form of immigration interviews resonates with the team. Our New Yorkers recognize certain landmarks mentioned in the poem, including the Vessel in Hudson Yards. And Jason gives it to us straight —New Yorkers ARE judging your fashion choices. We end with our terrible memories of the utter despair of Zoom dance parties. Thanks, as always, for listening.
At the table: Karen Hildebrand, Samantha Neugebauer, Jason Schneiderman, Kathleen Volk Miller, Marion Wrenn, Lisa Zerkle, Derek Grebis (sound engineer)
Author Bio: K. Hari (she/her) is a physician and poet of Tamil descent, whose work explores embodied heritage through poetic formalism. Her writing can be found in publications such as the New Orleans Review, the Journal, and the Margins, among others. She is winner of the 2024 Plentitudes Poetry Prize and the 2026 Third Coast Poetry Prize. She holds an MFA in Creative Writing from New York University and is a practicing obstetrician-gynecologist. She welcomes you to connect with her via Instagram: @scribeinscrubs.
Social media: @scribeinscrubs
Rage Yoga After Roe
Proof of Relationship
We’re back, Slushies! Did you miss us? We missed being with you. Much of our time this summer was spent reading an array of excellent books and today we share that abundance with you. Our wide-ranging conversation touches on blockbusters, novels, poetry, craft books, and (would you believe), an encyclical from Pope Leo XIV. Kathy gets a gold star, summer-reading-challenge style, for the stack of books she read on the beach. Dagne weighs in on the plus side for audio books. And several editors are fans of book-of-the month style subscriptions, whether from Book of the Month, or indie bookstores like The Lynx and Main Street Books. Joining in on the discussion is special guest, Karen Hildebrand, one of our dedicated PBQ editors.
All this talk of reading has us wondering how or if we ought to keep track of all of our reads. An online platform? A spiral notebook? How do you track your reads, Slushies? Let us know and, while you’re at it, share your summer reading faves with us. We’ll be back at the Slush Pile for our next episode but we hope you enjoy our reading enthusiasms. Thanks, as always, for listening.
At the table: Dagne Forrest, Karen Hildebrand, Jason Schneiderman, Kathleen Volk Miller, Lisa Zerkle, Derek Grebis (Sound Engineer)
PBQ Staff Reading Recs:
Marion Wrenn
Teaching Writing Through Journaling: Journaling as a Tool for Learning and Well-Being
by Kathleen Volk Miller
Magnifica Humanitas by Pope Leo XIV
Against Breaking: On the Power of Poetry by Ada Limón
Kathleen Volk Miller
Hamnet by Maggie O’Farrell
Gladiola Girls by Marion Wrenn
11/22/63 by Stephen King
Jason Schneiderman
Little Rot by Akwaeke Emezi
Final Slash Boy by Stephen S. Mills
Bright Lights, Big City by Jay McInerney
Dagne Forrest
Endling by Maria Reva
PBQ Issue 5
Chandelier by David O’Meara
Samantha Neugebauer
The Au Pair by Teddy Wayne
The Enlargement of Life by John Kekes
Tutelary Tales by Villy Sorensen
Lisa Zerkle
Orbital by Samantha Harvey
A Poetry Handbook: A Prose Guide to Understanding and Writing Poetry by Mary Oliver
A Stranger is an Animal Who Does Not Sing by Brian Teare from Albion Books: A Poetry Micropress
Karen Hildebrand
Her Read by Jennifer Sperry Steinorth
A Day Like Any Other: The Life of James Schuyler by Nathan Kernan
Wrong Norma by Anne Carson
(Bonus! See PBQ editor Samantha Neugebauer’s review of Wrong Norma here)
Emily Fedon
It Will Come Back to You: Collected Stories by Sigrid Nunez
Dear Monica Lewinsky by Julia Langbein
Sex and Rage by Eve Babitz
Alexa Josaphouitch
Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke
Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins
Most Eligible by Isabelle Engel
Greetings, Slushies! In this, our final encore episode for the summer, we revisit two poems from Glenn Shaheen. We hope you enjoy the conversation. We’ll be back in your feeds with a brand new episode on September 9. Thanks, as always for listening.
Our first order of business was debating lifestyle choices in NY vs. Philly, after which we dug into two wonderfully different poems by Glenn Shaheen. “Imago” plunged us into an elegaic interrogation of modern life, identity, and poetics framed by both the real world and open world gaming. With Glenn’s poem as our guide we roamed wide, touching on gaming terminology, Bey’s “Single Ladies” and 2008 as the last year of optimism, Kurt Vonnegut’s Breakfast of Champions, Shakespeare’s “filthy” Sonnet 135, and the ageless concern over the shelf life of language in poems and artistic works. The circular format of short, interlinked stanzas in the second poem, “Power and Punish”, introduced a real change in tone in the discussion. Frankly, we wondered if the poem’s format and approach would allow us to discuss it. We were delighted to discover it was possible, if different – but hey, you be the judge!
Some links we think you’ll like:
NPC (Non Player Character) on WikiHow
Beyoncé - Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)
Michel Foucault on the Panopticon Effect, Farnham Street blog
At the table: Marion Wrenn, Kathleen Volk Miller, Jason Schneiderman, Dagne Forrest, Isabel Petry
Website: https://glennshaheen.com/
IMAGO
DROSOPHILA MUTANTE
Hello, Slushies! We hope you’re keeping cool out there. In this encore episode, KVM rhapsodizes about the joy of a sandwich made with a perfect summer tomato. And Jason shares his astute thoughts on the nature of motherhood. Join in while the panel takes on three poems from poet Sarah Elkins. And thanks, as always for listening.
Are you ready to get primal, Slushies? We look at poems of birth and mothering that call on the senses as they shift between what’s animal and what’s human in us. Kathy celebrates the pure, messy pleasure of a classic tomato sandwich and Jason reminds us why an irregular opening line can be the hook a poem needs, while we all marvel at a poem’s ability to dazzle us with changing perspectives, locations, and personas. Oh, and strong titles get some much deserved love too.
This episode is brought to you by our sponsor Wilbur Records, who kindly introduced us to the artist is A.M.Mills whose song “Spaghetti with Loretta” now opens our show.
At the table: Kathleen Volk Miller, Jason Schneiderman, Samantha Neugebauer, and Dagne Forrest
Sarah Elkins is a poet, teacher, and reader. Sarah earned a BA with majors in English & Philosophy from the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and an MFA in Poetry from Pacific University. Sarah is the director of the West Virginia Interscholastic Cycling League where she works to get more kids on bikes. She and her husband, Max, own & operate Hammer Cycles bike shop in Lewisburg, WV.
Author website: https://www.sarahelkins.com/
The summer before my son was born, I ate tomato sandwiches
with mayonnaise, salt and pepper.
The rain was so heavy in June, the fruit
swelled on the vines and their skins ripped.
I took big bites holding thick bread with two hands,
pink rainwater running down both forearms
to my elbows—everything reduced, then,
to hunger. At night, curled on my side
in the un-airconditioned dark
I dreamt of big cats’ razor tongues
dragging the length of my back,
saber teeth at my throat, not tearing
the skin but feeling for pulse,
their muscled hips coaxing me
into the sweaty delirium of my final weeks.
The cats returned every night until
twenty-six hours before I howled him into being,
I opened. All the rain of June, and July
leaving me for the hardwood floor
where I crouched on all fours looking
for flecks of vernix, tasting my wet fingers,
sniffing the sweet water for signs it was time.
The cats slunk away until now, eating
this tomato sandwich, my first in twelve years—
I recall I was a panther once.
I floss at night after steak and butter.
My house: unguarded range, bison huffing,
ice-faced, hooves stamping an echo stutter.
I do nothing in this boundless nothing.
No thought, no synapse firing. Still hands still
stained—berry juice of an empty morning.
This room-less space, a translucent thin will
through which I, good sow, whiff my boy’s homing.
His trek complete, except for the recount—
bighorn sheep, bull moose, near miss, eagle plume.
I toss one sleek mink to the catamount.
The grass lies down; walls rise around my room.
Ursa fades. A house cat lurks in willow.
I sip gin, smooth the pelt of my pillows.
Greetings, Slushies! We’re here with an encore episode today, one we chose for its excellent exploration of craft, including a discussion about the golden shovel and the definition of ambiguity. Listen in for that and for two poems from poet Marko Capoferri. Enjoy. Thanks, as always, for listening.
How do you pronounce “San Gorgonio,” Slushies? How do you say “Schuylkill?” We talk regional accents, local knowledge, and artistic craft-- from the risks of the pathetic fallacy to the unknowability of metaphor, the art of ambiguity, and, of course, the golden shovel. Join us for an episode devoted to poems by Marko Capoferri where we discuss poetic craft, resonant symbols, and the peculiar power of telephone poles.
What can’t you pronounce where you live?
Links to things we discuss that you may dig:
Eula Biss’s “Time and Distance Overcome”
Jennifer L. Knox’s “Irwin Allen Vs. The Lion Tamer”
At the table: Katheleen Volk Miller, Marion Wrenn, Jason Schneiderman, Samantha Neugebauer, Larissa Morgano & Kate Wagner
This episode is brought to you by one of our sponsors, Wilbur Records, who kindly introduced us to the artist is A.M.Mills whose song “Spaghetti with Loretta” now opens our show.
Marko Capoferri is a poet, musician, and former conservation worker. He has lived and worked in eight US states, including Montana, where he has lived since 2015. He received an MFA in poetry from the University of Montana in Missoula. His work has appeared in The Shore, Painted Bride Quarterly, Porter House Review, and elsewhere.
Instagram: Instagram.com/markocapoferri
Two more recent publications:
https://www.stoneboatwi.com/issue-14-2/capoferri
https://sequestrum.org/contributor-spotlight-marko-capoferri
San Gorgonio
White paper coffee cups collect in drifts
by the freeway exit ramp—the hearts of ghosts
once held tight then tossed out the window
of a car speeding across the desert at four a.m.
trying to stay awake to see, when the light
came back, what the battered face of the land
could tell us about ourselves: how the mountains
were stark and risen; how we were sunk dumb
in between, a scathing plain of wind turbines
resonating unearthly as Amelia Earhart's flooded engines
chugging their final gasp on the ocean floor;
how the sea was here once and swallowed heights,
long since yawned and pulled away paving
this desert with a tired yellow dirt now blown
through our teeth, through our beating pistons,
and a few black rounded stones as souvenirs
from lost time; how thistle-studded towns
were hardly refuge; how the many stones
we had gathered were bright and jagged,
too young by design to tell any real story;
how lust and lost became an exchange in glances
through a motel’s cracked facade; how these roads
kept on dressing down like lightning on a postcard
running fingers in the hot mouth of experience.
Self-portrait with Elegy
Just like we were on the Great Plains
in 1949, my father and I would gather
summer nights with neighbors
lining our country road to watch
constellations disbanding. Whether tragedy
or a tragic lack of imagination, it’s hard
to say—he and I simply could not see
any threads or their severing. Then,
as now, telephone wires also lined the road
linking the night one lighted island
at a time, though the wires are now dead
gestures, props to a faded empire
of distant voices made close but never
close enough to turn that light
into warmth. What’s left—sinking
into my own humidity, my own
expanse of darkness, and he
to his own. As you read this
it is surely a summer night some place
the land extends forever
until it gives up where the visible
begins to visibly waver, either
from the heat or from the failure
of the possibilities of sight.
Greetings, Slushies! Today’s encore edition features special guest editor, the Pulitzer Prize winning poet Gregory Pardlo. His most recent collection is called “Spectral Evidence.” Listen along to the discussion of two poems from Daniel Biegelson which were ultimately included in his book “Of Being Neighbors” from Ricochet Editions. Thanks, as always, for listening!
On this week’s episode of the Slush Pile, we review two prose poems by the author Daniel Biegelson labeled “Neighbors III” and “Neighbors IV”. Kathleen and the gang welcome Pulitzer Prize winner Gregory Pardlo to the editorial table for this very exciting iteration of the podcast. Everyone was intrigued to delve into the works Daniel Biegelson provided for us and were quite pleased to find that they offered interesting conversation.
Daniel Biegelson is the author of the chapbook Only the Borrowed Light (VERSE) and Director of the Visiting Writers Series at Northwest Missouri State University. An Associate Editor for The Laurel Review, his poems have appeared in or are forthcoming from Cream City Review, Denver Quarterly, DIAGRAM, FIELD, Meridian, Salt Hill Journal, & Third Coast, among other places. He hails from New Jersey—a fact that means more to him than it probably should.
Did these poets survive the gauntlet? Listen on to find out!
Let us know what you think about these three poems and this episode on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook with #HelloNeighbor
Present at the Editorial Table:
Engineering Producer:
Daniel Biegelson
Neighbors (II)
Replace Glass Heart with Scalpel. Call for rain. Glisten. Close up. Magnify a leaf until the drop brims with color. Replace leaf with wind. Every June we lose limbs to straight line winds—elm, maple, oak, ash, etc., etc. They come knocking at night. Redact redundancy. Extinguish the list. Insert space. Remove the catalog. Remove, stack, and mulch the dead wood. Map my internal geography. I am a bowl of cold plums. I am a body of words in uproar and otherwise. Replace words with birds. Fill a tree. Take your pick. Redact free will. Replace map with mine. Relieve the workers. Every day we leave labor(s) behind. Exchange labor(s) with neighbor(s).The dark soil laced with slim roots swells and subsides beneath us. As the tide. Breathing. Who are you. Extinguish the implicit. We are the answer. Some of us are no longer breathing. I am used to defending the singularity of our experiences, but grow concerned about reducing the dead to their individuality. Redact redeem. We linger longer in blue light. We are not what we say or do.
Neighbors (III)
Replace dog with brother. Take walks on burnt grass and return under treeless sky. Exchange directives for best practices. Practice your run along the fence line. Monarchs carry on along the highways lined with causal wildflowers. Extinguish your sense of silence. You let your dog shit in my yard. The ocean levels rise. Mortgage rates rise. Don’t pretend to love one another. Turn your predatory beak. Redact the brackish ocean. Turn it black and red. Exchange ocean for consumption. Predatory lending of labor. Be still. We are the colony of bees in collapse and also the tractor trailer stocked with hives and the long driver on the CB radio and the farmers waiting for pollinators. See the red dust clouds rolling. See the black clouds closing. A tongue over a top lip. Bite hard and rain. Extinguish the dog barking. Redact the self. Exchange dog for children. Barking for howling. There is a wall beyond which our labor persists without us and we don’t dare to look. Replace words with words. Yours or mine. We don’t act upon what we see. Redact the sea. We are the murmurations leafing out over the highway. Pouring over the sky. We suffer decentered as we imagine stone. Human again. We don’t know each other at all.