also viewable on Substack:
https://open.substack.com/pub/palestinebookshelf/p/perfect-victims-and-the-politics
Copy of the summary:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KiBSLYqj5qd2TXU4cE9pLfRGg3Pdis7rd5fwQxwx-Tw/edit?pli=1&tab=t.rscryk4gru0z
MAIN THESIS Palestinians are required to pass endless tests imposed by society, journalism, and Israelis simply to narrate their own experiences. El-Kurd rejects this: as the oppressed, they need no permission. Their voices must be heard without qualification or interrogation. They are not mere victims but agents with rights and dignity. The "politics of appeal" (defanging Palestinians by demanding they humanize themselves, denounce resistance, or prove proximity to empire) distracts from the colonizer's actions and obscures power imbalances. Palestine is a microcosm of the human condition — wretched, raging, on fire, stubborn, and dignified — and how we see it reveals how we see everything else. HISTORICAL CONTEXT
Set against the ongoing Israeli occupation, the post-October 7, 2023 violence, and long-standing patterns of dehumanization. El-Kurd (from Sheikh Jarrah, East Jerusalem) draws on personal and collective experience of settler-colonialism, media double standards, and the "unchilding" of Palestinian children from birth. References include historical figures and policies (e.g., Ben-Gurion), contemporary Israeli leaders' statements, and the contrast with how other resistances (e.g., Ukrainian) are framed.
DETAILS OF KEY ARGUMENTS AND EXCERPTS
Horror stories establish context: reported organ theft from Palestinian corpses (missing corneas, livers, kidneys, hearts); the killing of 15-year-old Adam Isam Shakir Ayad (shot in the back in Deir Dibwan/Deisha camp, January 2023); six members of the Abu Salah family shot while waving white flags and bulldozed; branding of the Star of David into Orwa Shik Ali's cheek; a 5-year-old run over by a settler; Muhammad al-Dura; child prisoners such as Ahmad Manasra and Nefuz Hammad.
Palestinians die in fleeting headlines treated like weather events. Media prioritizes interrogating Palestinians over interviewing them (e.g., BBC demanding condemnation of October 7 before offering condolences). Resistance (stone-throwing) is framed as profane when Palestinian but heroic when Ukrainian. Citizenship humanizes selectively (Shireen Abu Akleh's U.S. passport made her newsworthy). The "not all Palestinians are Hamas" trope implies others are undeserving of rights. Children are treated as threats from birth. El-Kurd rejects romanticized return and slogans, calling instead for material resistance and a future homeland. The book ends with his mother's words: rain is coming, God is almighty.
Find other summaries like this at Palestine Bookshelf: www.palestinebookshelf.org
#EndTheOccupation