Paranormal In Pennsylvania

We’re back at one of the most paranormally active spots in Missouri — Pythian Castle in Springfield. This time, we teamed up with our friends from HauntedUs for a full investigation and even recorded a live episode of The Haunted Atlas inside the castle’s walls (you can find that wherever you get your podcasts). Built in 1913 by the Knights of Pythias and later taken over by the U.S. military, Pythian Castle has seen everything from fraternal rituals to World War II POWs — and the energy left behind still lingers in every corridor. In this episode, we revisit the castle’s chilling history and share our newest findings — floor by floor

Behind the elegance of Pittsburgh’s Frick Mansion—also known as Clayton House—lingers the quiet presence of those who never truly left. Once home to industrial titan Henry Clay Frick and his family, this 23-room Gilded Age estate has seen both immense wealth and heartbreaking loss. Though the family moved to New York in 1905, many believe their spirits remain among the ornate halls and velvet drapes. Staff report phantom footsteps echoing from the third floor where daughter Helen Frick once slept, and the indentation of a figure mysteriously appearing on Adelaide Frick’s bed. Guests have claimed to see a lost young boy wandering the parlor, accompanied by the scent of flowers, and even the lingering voice of a Civil War soldier declaring “haunted home.” Join us as we uncover the history, heartbreak, and hauntings that make the Frick Mansion one of Pittsburgh’s most refined—and most restless—residences.

Built in 1836 by banker George Swope and also home to his son, Dr. John Swope, the manor served as a Civil War hospital before being transformed into a stately inn. Over the years, it’s welcomed everyone from President Eisenhower to ghostly figures that refuse to rest. In this episode, we uncover the paranormal side of this Gettysburg landmark—from the shadowy figure said to wander the third floor, to phantom voices caught on recorders, and even the spirit of a loyal dog still padding through the halls. Some believe a poltergeist stirs within the manor’s walls—others say it’s just history refusing to fade. Join us as we explore the refined yet eerie energy of The Swope Manor and the restless spirits that still call it home.

Deep in the woods of Hellam Township, Pennsylvania, lies one of the state’s most infamous legends: The Seven Gates of Hell. Some say the gates once surrounded a burned-down insane asylum, trapping its patients inside as the flames consumed them—while others insist they belonged to a mad doctor’s estate, where strange experiments took place and few who entered ever returned. Despite the lack of historical evidence, the stories persist… and so do the hauntings. Visitors report phantom voices, unexplained injuries, and phones that die without warning after stepping through the first gate. The deeper you go, the stronger the dread—and some say spirits appear to push you back, desperate to keep you from reaching the end.

In this episode, we take you deep into the woods and along the misty shores of Lake Arthur—a place we’ve hiked many times, but this time we’re exploring its darker side. From the tragic spirit of Nancy McCandless, who still roams after her shocking murder in 1871, to the terrifying black mass known as Old Red Eyes, this park’s serene landscape hides some serious paranormal energy. We’ll talk about the park’s glacial beginnings, its industrial scars, and the spirits said to linger in its forests and along its trails. Some visitors even claim to see glowing green orbs dancing above the lake—others feel the watchful presence of those who walked this land long before it became a state park.

We’re back with another dive into haunted haute couture! In our first spooky fashion episode, we covered arsenic green gowns, mad hatters, and more—but we couldn’t resist returning to explore even more deadly designs from history. From corsets stiffened with whale baleen to the ghostly glow of lead-based beauty creams, this episode peels back the silk and lace to reveal the horrors beneath the hemline. We’ll talk about The Spirits of Saturn, the poisonous “foundation” that claimed lives in the name of pale perfection, and the belladonna eye drops that gave Renaissance women their hauntingly beautiful, and sometimes literally blinding, gaze. Because when it comes to fashion, history proves one thing: beauty has always been a killer.

Built in the 1800s, this estate has lived many lives — once home to the Hankey Baking Company Farms, and later a printing press and horse farm under James A. Stewart. Today, it’s the site of a thriving winery that embraces its history — and the spirits that never left. During our investigation, we explored every floor of the mansion from the subterrean rathskeller to the upstairs bedrooms. Guests and investigators alike report phantom footsteps, knocking, voices, and even moving wine bottles. Whether it’s the former owners checking in or just residual energy from the mansion’s long history, one thing’s certain — the spirits here are still swirling. Raise a glass and join us as we uncork the mysteries of the Black Dog Wine Company where history and hauntings blend perfectly.

You told us your stories — we listened. In this listener-powered episode, we read and react to the paranormal encounters sent in by you, our listeners. From chilling apparitions to fog that vanishes at the edge of the road, these are the firsthand moments that stuck with everyday people. From Gettysburg to Lake Erie, we debate whether these stories point to lingering spirits, residual energy, mass suggestion, or something else entirely. Got a spine-tingling story? Send it in!

Built in 1810, the Farnsworth House Inn has stood through centuries of history, including the bloody Battle of Gettysburg. Confederate sharpshooters once fired from inside, its walls still bear over 100 bullet holes, and its rooms once served as a Civil War field hospital. Today, this historic inn isn’t just a place to stay—it’s home to restless spirits. From the playful ghost of little Jeremy, to the stern soldier in grey who sometimes salutes guests, to the phantom cook who still prowls the kitchen, the Farnsworth is alive with spectral energy. Guests report phantom harp music, beds kicked in the night, shadow figures descending from ceilings, and even a ghostly cat. Hear about the hauntings that keep the nearby Holiday Inn reserving rooms for visitors too terrified to stay the night at the Farnsworth. 

Hidden deep in Pennsylvania, the remains of Alvira tell a chilling story. Once a thriving town, it was seized by the government in 1942 under eminent domain to build the Pennsylvania Ordnance Works—an enormous TNT plant and a network of bunkers meant to store munitions. The plant shut down after just 11 months, leaving behind toxic land, abandoned bunkers, and a ghost town swallowed by time. Today, the Alvira Bunkers stand as eerie relics of war and betrayal. Visitors report disembodied voices echoing through the cement chambers, and unsettling feelings of being watched. Burn marks in some of the bunkers spark rumors of dark rituals, while the nearby cemeteries—untouched by the demolition—add an extra layer of ghostly energy to the site.