Paranormal In Pennsylvania

On Chambersburg Pike in Gettysburg sits the small stone Mary Thompson House, better known as General Robert E. Lee’s Headquarters during the Battle of Gettysburg. This humble home bore witness to strategy, suffering, and sacrifice as wounded soldiers were tended inside and burials took place just steps away. Today, the restored property looks much as it did during the Civil War—but many say its ghosts remain. From phantom footsteps and disembodied voices inside the house, to doorknobs turning on their own and objects mysteriously shifting, the energy here is undeniable. Outside, visitors report cannon fire, gunshots, and even the beat of a distant phantom drum. Shadowy figures have been spotted roaming the fields. Join us as we visit Gettysburg through one of its iconic and haunted landmarks: General Lee’s Headquarters.

We’re throwing it back three years to one of our earliest episodes, The University of Pittsburgh! This time, it’s just Sara diving into brand-new ghost stories and hauntings from Pitt’s campus. From the shadowy figures roaming the Cathedral of Learning, to the infamous “Ruskghost” in Ruskin Hall, to restless spirits in Centre Plaza shaking students awake, the Steel City’s most haunted university never fails to give us chills. Pitt might be known for its history and academics, but for us—it will always have our haunted hearts.

Built in 1794, Selma Mansion in Norristown, PA, has stood witness to centuries of history—from Revolutionary War hero General Andrew Porter to the prominent Fornance family. Today, it’s preserved by the Norristown Preservation Society, but many believe its past residents never truly left. Visitors report a mischievous kitchen poltergeist, the restless spirit of General Porter pacing outside his study, and Mrs. Fornance, who still lingers with the scent of roses. Beyond these familiar spirits, the mansion echoes with disembodied voices, phantom piano music, and children’s laughter. Is Selma Mansion a place where history refuses to fade?

This week, we’re heading to Happy Valley—where the spirits are anything but cheerful. Penn State University in University Park, PA, may be a hub of science, history, and higher learning, but it’s also home to some truly chilling hauntings. We start with Coaly the ghostly mule, Penn State’s oldest (and most unexpected) ghost. From there, we head into Schwab Auditorium, where phantom figures flip seats and vanish into walls. Some of the ghosts are lucky in love. George Atherton, the university’s seventh president, is said to stroll the auditorium where he’s buried just outside. Meanwhile, his wife Frances Atherton reportedly watches over his grave from the windows of the Old Botany building… and doesn’t take kindly to after-hours visitors. And finally, we discuss one of Penn State’s most tragic legends: the unsolved murder of Betsy Aardsma in 1969. Her screams still echo through the stacks of the library, and some say her ghostly form appears without warning. Would you dare to roam these halls?

Buckle up for a paranormal road trip through the backroads and haunted byways of Wisconsin! In this episode, we sit down with Brandon Rugzie and Mitch Goth, two members of the Haunted US team and co-authors of a brand-new book chronicling their eerie adventures across the Badger State. Brandon, a seasoned photographer, and Mitch, a writer with a passion for ghostly lore, take us behind the scenes of their haunted travels. From narrowing down which chilling sites to visit to navigating the unique challenges of ghost hunting on the go, they share their favorite stories and tips. We talk about what makes haunted trips so compelling, tips for visiting paranormal hotspots, and what readers can expect from their new book. If you love haunted houses, eerie towns, and the thrill of the unknown, this is one trip you won’t want to miss.

Purchase the book here: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FLG2VGRM

This week, we’re digging into the ghostly remains of Livermore, PA's cemetery. Despite popular belief, Livermore Cemetery was not featured in Night of the Living Dead, but its eerie reputation is enough to rival any horror set. Founded in 1827 and incorporated in 1865, Livermore was wiped off the map, either by flood or demolition to make way for a dam—depending on which legend you believe. All that remains is the cemetery, perched on a hill above what used to be the town. And according to visitors, it’s far from quiet. We explore strange tales of phantom touches, paranormal resistance, and a cemetery said to exist in its own weather pattern—calm when the world around it rages. Some even say a witch’s curse doomed the town, predicting a flood that eerily aligned with a real disaster in 1889. Is Livermore a forgotten piece of Pennsylvania history… or a place where time, space, and the spirits of the past still linger?

Join us as we uncover the chilling true crime story of six men who insured Joseph Raber’s life—then drowned him for the money. All six shared one strange trait: piercing blue eyes. Five would hang, one would walk free—but not for long. We explore the eerie aftermath of the crime, from George Zechman’s unexplained seizures to haunted flowerbeds and spectral blue lights seen near Moonshine Church. Was justice served? Or did Raber’s restless spirit—and those of his killers—refuse to go quietly?

This week, we're finally diving into one of the most requested haunted spots in Pennsylvania—Hans Graf Cemetery in Lancaster County, also known as Shock Graveyard. This small, stone-walled cemetery in Marietta may look quiet, but it's packed with centuries-old legends, ghostly sightings, and werewolf lore that will make your hair stand on end. Some believe Hans himself was bitten and doomed to roam the graveyard in lupine form, while others say he cast a powerful curse to protect his bloodline from beyond the grave. From mysterious orbs to eerie audio recordings and that infamous full moon curse, we unpack the many variations of the legend and what might really be lurking in “God’s Acre.”

She took an axe—or did she? In this chillingly captivating episode, we sit down with the writer and creator of Borden: A New Musical, a bold new take on the life, legend, and legacy of Lizzie Borden. Known for the infamous 1892 axe murders and the haunted house that still bears her name, Lizzie’s story has fascinated and horrified for generations. But what makes her tale ripe for the stage? We dive into what inspired the musical, how it separates itself from previous adaptations like Lizzie, and how the creative team has approached such a dark, complex figure through music and storytelling. Plus, we get the inside scoop on an exclusive song preview happening August 2nd—inside the actual Borden House.

Nestled in the woods of York County, Pennsylvania, lies a place where true crime and the paranormal collide, Hex Hollow, also known as Rehmeyer’s Hollow. In this chilling episode, we dive into the 1928 murder of Nelson Rehmeyer, a local folk healer accused of witchcraft. Killed in his own home by a man who believed he was cursed, Nelson’s story is one of superstition, fear, and brutal vengeance. We explore the hauntings that have followed, from Nelson’s angry spirit and a red-eyed ghost dog to phantom smoke and stones that hurl themselves back at visitors. Some say it’s not just the house that’s haunted, but the land itself, with reports of UFOs and inexplicable energy shifts. What is the truth behind this homestead?