In Part 2, Matthew Shepard’s case becomes much bigger than one criminal investigation. What starts with Aaron McKinney and Russell Henderson facing trial quickly turns into a national debate over motive, punishment, media attention, courtroom strategy, and whether Matthew was targeted because he was gay. As his family fights through grief, protests, and public scrutiny, the case pushes a movement that eventually helps change federal hate crime law in America forever.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices