In the 6th and 7th book of the Phantom Stallion series, Sam gets a stepmother, is attacked by a cougar, rides the Phantom, and gets into a fight with Jake. Stephanie visits the Phantom Stallion wiki and sprains a tooth. Melanie refuses to allow teeth to exist in her world, and lists her top 4 bad boys of the horse world.

We read books 4 and 5 of the Phantom Stallion series, The Renegade and Free again. Stephanie enlists Evan Smith for a dramatic reading of some of Jake's scenes. Melanie reads a horse story from Jeff, and we ask the audience to submit their own horse stories for future episodes.

We read the next two books in the Phantom Stallion series, which features one horse who is an escaped endurance champion and an abused mustang pony. Jake and Sam share two hugs and a lot of teenage awkwardness. Stephanie and Melanie talk about sexual expectations in relationships. For Mane Characters Melanie tells a story about a bad experience her family had with some barn sour horses on an island without cars.

We begin the first book in the 24 book Phantom Stallion series with The Wild One, and Stephanie rates it higher on the Pony Scales than any other book we have read. Melanie tells us a story about her childhood fantasy that the Backstreet Boys were always standing outside her window watching her, and for Mane Characters she talks about Tango, one of Jazzy's colts, kicking her father in the nuts.

We discuss Chris Platt's novel Race the Wind and our own plans for a horse story. Melanie tells a story about her friend Emily's horse who recently died of colic.

Stephanie and Melanie are disappointed by the movie adaptation of The Little White Horse. Stephanie talks about her bunny Lola and Melanie tells a story about her mother keeping a horse in the back yard. We brainstorm a better horse book and invite the public to help us.

We read and discuss The Little White Horse by Elizabeth Goudge. Melanie describes some of the more disgusting elements of horse ownership, and Kera fans are treated to a message from Kera.

In this very special episode, both Stephanie and Melanie read Whirlwind by Alison Hart, then research the author in an attempt to understand her misogyny and attitude towards men.

We discuss Alison Hart's Shadow Horse mystery. Melanie talks about how she was affected by beauty standards at age 8. Stephanie critiques the portrayal of the juvenile justice system in the book. Melanie tells a story about the first time she got to show Sugar, when she was a 3 year old.

We discuss the domestic violence and alcoholism present in The First Horse I See by Sally Keehn. Melanie talks about Jazzy, a horse who didn't like to be ridden but was a good mother. Stephanie talks about shop cats and lucid dreams.