When Grief Comes With Betrayal: Mourning Someone Who Lied | Part 1
What happens when someone dies and, in the process of grieving them, you discover that parts of the person you knew may not have been true?
In Part 1 of this deeply personal conversation, Dr. Christina Zampitella is joined by psychologist and author Dr. Niki Serravalle to explore a complicated and rarely discussed kind of grief: grieving the death of someone who lied about significant parts of their life.
Dr. Serravalle shares the story of her relationship with her late ex-husband, from the intense connection they experienced early on to the small, seemingly inconsequential lies that eventually gave way to much larger deceptions.
Together, Christina and Niki explore the confusion of loving and trusting someone while also learning to overlook inconsistencies, and how patterns of codependency can become intertwined with relationships marked by instability and deception.
The conversation also examines the difference between compulsive lying and intentional manipulation, how codependency can show up even in people who appear strong and self-aware, and the grief that can happen long before a physical death when a relationship or the life you believed you had begins to disappear.
Then, after her late ex-husband’s unexpected death, Niki made a discovery that challenged one of the most fundamental stories he had told about himself. Despite years of describing himself as a Marine and appearing to live with the physical and psychological effects of military service, his family told her he had never served in the military.
That discovery opened an entirely new layer of grief and an unsettling question:
Who exactly are you grieving when you can no longer be certain who the person was?
Subscribe to Phoenix Rising with Dr. Z for conversations about grief, trauma, healing, and the complicated experiences that don't always fit neatly into traditional conversations about loss.
Chapters
00:00 Welcome to Phoenix Rising
00:45 Meet Dr. Niki Serravalle
01:30 Grieving the Death of a Liar
02:40 How Niki and Ed Met
04:15 Love Bombing vs. Intense Love
06:10 When the Small Lies Began
07:35 Discovering the First Major Lie
09:05 When He Suddenly Disappeared
10:05 Grieving Someone Who Is Still Alive
10:45 Being Pulled Back Into the Relationship
11:40 Codependency and the Need to Fix
13:25 Marriage, Money and More Questions
17:40 Understanding Niki's Codependency
19:25 Finding a Sense of Self
21:35 Why the Lies Became Easier to Ignore
23:35 When the Lies Became Part of His Identity
24:10 Ed's Story of Being a Marine
25:40 What Niki Discovered After His Death
27:00 “He Was Never in the Military”
Key Takeaways
Grief can become complicated when the person you lost is also someone you're still trying to understand.
Death can remove the possibility of asking questions, getting clarification, or ever knowing the complete truth. For someone grieving after deception, mourning may involve both the person who died and the unanswered questions they left behind.
You can grieve someone who is still alive.
Niki describes grieving the connection and relationship she believed she had when Ed abruptly disappeared from her life. Grief isn't limited to physical death. We can also grieve relationships, futures, identities, trust, and the version of life we believed we were building.
Codependency doesn't always look like neediness.
For Niki, codependency showed up as giving up her own truth to protect someone else's, trying to create enough safety for another person to change, and believing that if she could make things okay for him, the relationship would be okay.
A person can be accomplished, independent, and self-aware in many areas of life while still experiencing codependent patterns within intimate relationships.
Knowing that someone lies doesn't necessarily mean you recognize the biggest lies.
Once smaller lies became expected, Niki stopped looking as closely at certain details. Meanwhile, some of the largest deceptions were woven into enough truth and consistency that they seemed unquestionable.
Contradictory truths can exist in grief.
Someone can have lied, caused harm, or behaved in deeply confusing ways while still having been loved and experienced as meaningful.
Recognizing harmful behavior does not automatically erase the relationship, and loving someone does not require denying the harm they caused.
A death can change not only how you see the future, but how you understand the past.
Learning after Ed's death that he had apparently never served in the military meant Niki wasn't simply processing his death. She was also being asked to reconsider years of memories, conversations, and assumptions about who he had been.
That creates a unique form of grief in which the mourner may be trying to reconstruct both the relationship and the identity of the person they lost.
