Is sharing your creative journey online an act of courage, or a cry for help?
This week, Steph and Jay dig into one of the most debated questions in the creator economy: should you build in public? Steph traces her own start back to 2008, posting as an interior designer, painter, and newly single mother in a small town, years before "personal brand" was even a phrase, and talks about the early community pushback that taught her to pull back before she knew how to lean in. Jay, a self-described private person, pushes on the harder question underneath all of it: are you inspiring your audience, or are you using them as a therapy session?
They get into why sharing your process isn't the same as oversharing your wounds, how the gatekeepers who used to decide which artists the world got to know are gone, and why Steph's rule for the comments section comes down to three phrases: block freely, engage genuinely, follow no one's rule book.
The difference between authentic sharing and using social media as unprocessed therapy
Steph's path from 2008 early adopter to visual artist building a brand before the term existed
Why early pushback from her small-town community taught her about resilience and knowing your audience
The artist's case for transparency: when someone buys the painting, they're buying a piece of the person who made it
Jay's Life Magazine and Jackson Pollock parallel, and why the gatekeepers of discovery no longer hold the keys
Building a personal content framework before you hit publish, so you know what's in and what's off limits
Steph's philosophy on trolls and the block button, and why she believes creepy interactions have become rarer
The Permission Effect: how one person's openness quietly gives everyone else around them permission to be brave
Whether radical online transparency deepens human connection, or eventually pushes everyone back toward privacyKey takeaway: Pushback is part of the game. If you're not prepared for criticism, you're not ready to build in public. You can't eat ice cream all day and expect not to gain weight. Pick your lane, know your boundaries, and let your openness do the rest.
Subscribe to never miss an episode of Pickles & Pasta, and share this episode with someone still deciding what they're willing to let the internet see.
Pickles & Pasta is hosted by Steph and Jay presented by ephelants & Have Some Fun Today
00:00 Introduction – Is Building in Public Brave or Broken?
00:55 Steph's Early Social Media Journey (2008, Divorce, Small Town)
05:05 Getting Pushback for Being Ahead of the Curve
06:30 Don't Pull Back Due to the Pushback
07:30 Being Brave vs. Using Social Media as Therapy
09:49 Think Before You Post
11:10 Sharing Your Work as an Artist – Building a Personal Brand
19:53 Social Media Changed Everything for Artists
22:10 Setting Boundaries on What You Share
26:13 If You Want to Grow, You Have to Think It Through
28:21 Advice for Getting Started as an Influencer/Content Creator
33:20 Engaging with Your Audience & Handling Creepy Comments
42:35 Forming Real Bonds Through Online Openness
45:35 Accepting People Who Think Differently
43:06 Wrap-Up – Think Before You Post, Be Authentic
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices