This is DM. I speak for myself here and not Eric or Dave.Honestly, I don't remember exactly when it started. But, at some point, having graduated Bible College, the thought occurred to me that the fiery, eternal torment of sinners I had been taught since I became a Protestant at age 8 just didn't line up with the Heavenly Father I was also being told to trust in and find comfort in.Looking back, I don't know what took me so long. Except, the words of teachers and parents are extremely powerful. So is the echo chamber. So when EVERYONE around you believes something and is telling you that you need to believe it as well, it's extremely difficult to break out of that thinking, even if it has obvious logical problems. Even as some of you read this, your heart and mind are rebelling -- you're getting annoyed and wishing the heretic, me, would stop insinuating the God DOESN'T burn people in a place call HELL for eternity the second they die having not "said the sinner's prayer."I know. You believe it. Your parents believe it. Your pastor believes it. So how can this NOT be true? Even though there's a conflict within you about it and always has been. Even though it means loved ones who have gone on before you are now burning in an inescapable fire for all of eternity. Even though the SAME God who must have created this place of torment is also the one you worship and praise on Sunday morning...Deep within, you want to question it. You want it to not be true. But you don't feel like you're allowed to question it. You feel like it HAS to be true or everything falls apart.How about this. Give yourself some space. Surely you're not going to be thrown into hell yourself for just QUESTIONING the teaching, right? Surely God wants you to be certain about the truth of our eternal condition. So, if you question and STILL believe this is what God does, then fine. But at least you've questioned and have come to the conclusion on your own.Let me tell you my already obvious perspective: God doesn't punitively punish people for eternity. That's sadistic. And, no it doesn't fail to be sadistic just because God does it. (The illogical argument that whatever God does is GOOD and therefore if He does something sadistic, that makes it good also.)
God ALWAYS acts in LOVE. That means PUNISHMENTS, too, are for LOVE and LOVE alone. They cannot be punitive, because that would oppose LOVE. They have to be redemptive. Just like your punishments toward your children are for redemption.Unless you're actually the kind of person who would burn your children for eternity because they sinned...I didn't think so.