
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Elizabeth Holmes was supposed to change the world. A Stanford dropout turned Silicon Valley superstar, she promised to revolutionize healthcare with technology that could run hundreds of medical tests using just a few drops of blood. Investors poured hundreds of millions of dollars into her company, Theranos, and Holmes became one of the most celebrated entrepreneurs in America. But behind the extraordinary promises, something wasn't adding up.
This week, Abby takes us inside the spectacular rise and collapse of Theranos, exploring the carefully crafted image of its charismatic founder, the whistleblowers who risked everything to expose the truth, and the very real consequences for patients who trusted the company with their health. We also dive into Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's new Elizabeth Holmes documentary, You Can See Everything, which we'd both recently watched and genuinely think deserves an Oscar.
Before we get into the case, Ally and Abby discuss the underrated perks of having just one kid (or so they assume) before Ally confesses her pretty creepy experiences with a toxic psychiatrist.
Story starts: 9:29
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In January 1995, 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was attending the Job Corps program in Knoxville, Tennessee, hoping to build a better future for herself. But a confrontation with fellow student Christa Pike would end in an unimaginably brutal murder, leaving Colleen's family devastated and eventually making Pike one of the most notorious women on Tennessee's death row.
What led an 18-year-old woman to commit such a horrific crime? And how did jealousy, manipulation, and group dynamics contribute to the violence? This week, Ally tells Colleen's story, examining the disturbing events surrounding her murder, the investigation that followed, and the circus around Christa Pike’s failed execution in 2026. At the center of it all is a young woman whose life deserves to be remembered for far more than the circumstances of her death.
Before diving into the case, Ally recounts her recent trip to Paris, including a particularly eccentric tour guide at Père Lachaise Cemetery. Somehow, this leads Ally and Abby into a surprisingly philosophical conversation about the evolution of death, burial traditions, and how our relationship with mortality has changed over time. Definitely a different kind of intro this week!
Story starts: 7:57
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources
In 1989, 18-year-old Kaitlyn Arquette was shot while driving through Albuquerque, New Mexico. Her murder devastated her family, especially her mother, Lois Duncan, the bestselling suspense author behind I Know What You Did Last Summer. Lois had spent her career writing fictional mysteries, but nothing could have prepared her for the real-life mystery surrounding her daughter's death. Convinced there was more to the story than investigators initially believed, Lois began her own relentless search for answers, documenting her investigation in the book Who Killed My Daughter?. What followed was a decades-long pursuit of the truth, filled with unsettling discoveries, competing theories, and questions that refused to go away. This week, Abby tells Kaitlyn's story and explores the extraordinary lengths a mother went to in pursuit of justice.
Before we get into the case, we're covering a little bit of everything! We start with comparing boomer and Gen Z slang, which somehow turns into a full-blown discussion about language and how it evolves. Ally also recaps her recent trip to Paris, and Abby makes sure she doesn't get away without addressing an Instagram story she posted while abroad.
Story starts: 12:24
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Ally covers the murders of Gladys Hosking, Ivy McLeod, and Pauline Thompson in Melbourne, Australia, in 1942. With World War II drawing closer, the city had dimmed its streets to make them harder to spot from the air. Then women began turning up dead.
When Gladys’s body was discovered in Royal Park, she was the third woman found murdered in just over two weeks. We follow the investigation through wartime Melbourne while getting to know the women whose lives were taken.
Before the case, we talk about the struggle to write an original melody, our inability to finish shows, celebrity blind items, and why bringing a beloved book to the screen means competing with everyone’s imagination. Our TV and movie catch-up includes Tony, The Love Hypothesis, Primetime, Verity, Wuthering Heights, and PEN15.
Story starts: 14:08
Shout-out to Ally’s cousin Jake for suggesting this story! Check out his YouTube channel.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Abby covers the murder of Sherri Rasmussen, a 29-year-old nursing director who was found dead inside her Los Angeles home in February 1986. Sherri was newly married, thriving in her career, and looking forward to her future when her life was tragically cut short. Investigators initially believed she'd been killed during a burglary gone wrong, but her family wasn't convinced. What followed was a decades-long search for answers, missed opportunities, and a case that would eventually expose deeply troubling investigative failures.
Before we get into the case, Ally and Abby are finally reunited after a month apart! We catch up on life and discuss the Cornell University sexual assault allegations, the public response, and why conversations about sexual violence and supporting survivors matter.
Story starts: 11:03
Sexual Assault Support Resources:
If you or someone you know has experienced sexual assault, free and confidential support is available.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this solo episode, Ally covers the story of Denise Huskins, a physical therapist who was taken from Aaron Quinn’s Vallejo home after a terrifying overnight intrusion. When Aaron finally reached police, he described blindfolds, sedatives, recorded instructions, and a ransom demand—but Denise was still missing, and investigators had to decide what, if anything, they believed.
As the story grew stranger and national attention descended on the couple, two questions remained: Was Denise alive, and had any of this really happened? Ally tells the story from Denise’s perspective—the woman behind the blindfold.
Story starts: 1:45
To support Denise and Aaron, you can read their book, Victim F: From Crime Victims to Suspects to Survivors, and watch the three-part Netflix documentary American Nightmare. Denise and Aaron are also members of the curatorial team behind The Wrong Questions Project, a survivor-led initiative working to expose and challenge victim-blaming.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Ally covers the disappearance and murder of Nicole van den Hurk, a 15-year-old who left her grandmother’s home before dawn on October 6, 1995, to bike to her supermarket job in Eindhoven, the Netherlands. She never arrived. Her bike, her bag, and eventually her body were found in separate locations, leaving investigators to piece together what happened on a ride that should have taken less than 30 minutes.
For nearly 16 years, Nicole’s family waited for answers. Then a confession appeared on Facebook, bringing her case back into the headlines. After so many years of uncertainty, what would it take to uncover the truth about that morning?
Before the case, we talk about cicadas and their lore, then ask what we could give a TED Talk about with absolutely zero preparation. The Marvel universe, classic TV shows, and ADHD coping mechanisms all make the list. Give us a microphone and apparently we’re ready. What would your topic be?
Story starts: 13:45
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Abby covers the murder of Betsy Faria. On December 27, 2011, Betsy returned to her Troy, Missouri, home after a chemotherapy appointment. That night, her husband, Russ, found her murdered in their living room.
Betsy had been facing cancer with people around her who were supposed to offer love and support. One of those people was her friend Pam Hupp, who had driven her home that evening. And if you think you know where this story is going, wait until you hear what Pam has to say.
What happened to Betsy—and how did the search for answers turn into a case so bizarre it became a television series?
Before the case, we’re choosing our death row meals, and we have a logistical question: whose job is it to actually procure these meals? Does someone get handed a shopping list? If you know, let us know in the comments. And shoutout to Uchi in Charlotte for making the cut in our final-meal selections: @uchirestaurants!
Story starts: 9:30
Want to watch the dramatization after listening? The Thing About Pam, starring Renée Zellweger, is currently available to purchase in the U.S. through Apple TV and Fandango at Home. Find current viewing options here.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Ally covers the murder of Anthony “Nino” Puglisi and the abduction of his wife, Debra Puglisi Sharp. On April 20, 1998, Debra was planting roses outside their Newark, Delaware, home when Nino arrived home from work and went inside. When Debra followed him a short time later, an ordinary spring afternoon became the beginning of a nightmare.
Over the next 101 hours, Debra’s family and investigators struggled to understand what had happened while she fought to stay alive. With no idea whether anyone would find her—or what the man holding her planned to do—every decision she made mattered.
What happened inside the Puglisi home, where was Debra taken, and how did she survive five terrifying days in captivity?
Before the case, we’re talking about the death of Hayden Panettiere, her history with addiction, and how an overdose can create ripple effects through families, relationships, workplaces, and entire communities. We also revisit Cory Monteith’s death, the lasting effect it had on Lea Michele and the people around him, and the tragedies associated with what fans have called the “Glee curse.”
Story starts: 7:59
Debra tells the complete story of her captivity, Nino’s murder, and her life after the crime in her memoir, Shattered: Reclaiming a Life Torn Apart by Violence. Learn more and purchase Debra’s book here.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
In this episode, Abby covers the disappearance and murder of Skylar Neese, a 16-year-old from Star City, West Virginia, who slipped out of her bedroom after midnight on July 6, 2012, and climbed into a waiting car. Skylar left behind the things she would have needed if she planned to stay away, making it clear to her parents that she intended to come home.
What followed was a months-long search shaped by surveillance footage, conflicting stories, social media posts, and the growing feeling that someone close to Skylar knew more than they were saying. What happened after she got into that car, and how long could the truth stay hidden?
Before the case, we’re talking about hickies, mosquito season, and how Ally somehow gave herself a quarter-sized bruise on her own face. Abby brings a major airport and airplane grievance to the table, while Ally has a complaint for anyone committing one particular crime against the English language. Bruises, bugs, baggage, and bad grammar—we’re covering it all.
Story starts: 14:53
At the end of the episode, we also mention Lexi Weinbaum, who has shared her experience surviving a similar violent incident. You can hear more of her story on Lexi’s TikTok.
We’re so happy you’re here. Follow along, share your thoughts, send us case suggestions, or submit a case request:
Instagram: @probationbehavior
Join our Patreon
Email: [email protected]
Case request form: Submit a case request
Sources:
And since you made it all the way down here: a quick shout-out to Ally’s cousin. You can check out his YouTube channel here.
From the publisher's feed