The Minefield

“Progressive patriotism” — is it an idea whose time has come?


Listen Later

Fresh from a commanding victory at the federal election, Anthony Albanese began to bundle his campaign policy offerings together in a new package — not just to give these political commitments a kind of internal coherence, but also to stake out what could be distinctive about his premiership as a whole.

The term he reached for to sum it all up is “progressive patriotism”. In a conversation with David Crowe for the Nine papers, the Prime Minister explained what he means:

“We spoke about doing things the Australian way, not looking towards any other method or ideology from overseas. At a time where there’s conflict in the world, where people are often divided on the basis of race or religion, here in Australia, we can be a microcosm for the world.

That says that we’re enriched by our diversity, that we have respect for people of different faith, that we try to bring people together, that we don’t bring turmoil overseas and play out that conflict here, either, and that’s really important.

This is a project, if you like, that’s not just about strengthening Australia, but also being a symbol for the globe in how humanity can move forward.”

Hearing a Labor leader talk in terms of “patriotism” should not be terribly strange to our ears. Bob Hawke did it in his own vernacular, and Paul Keating was able to combine a certain confidence over Australia’s place in the region with an irrepressible economic self-assurance that was his trademark style — a national confidence, moreover, that needn’t be undermined by a frank acknowledgement of what “we” Australians had done to the First Peoples of this land.

But left-leaning patriotism can lay claim to a longer, more noble lineage. It was, after all, the British Labour government of Prime Minister Clement Atlee (1945–1951) and his Minister for Health, Aneurin Bevan, that established the NHS and embarked on an unprecedented public housing program — a welfare state borne along by the winds of post-war patriotic sentiment.

For his part, Albanese seems to be invoking a notion of patriotism largely devoid of ideology and exceptionalism, and that is grounded in an enlarged idea of welfarism and social provision. It is a promising and undeniably noble sentiment. But in times like ours, can “patriotism” really shed its exclusivist undertones?

Can patriotism be reoriented as a horizontal attachment to our fellow citizens through the shared principles that govern our common life — or must it always involve a form of vertical loyalty, a civic religion that binds some of us together insofar as we swear fealty to a necessarily exclusionary ideal?

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

The MinefieldBy ABC listen

  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6
  • 4.6

4.6

32 ratings


More shows like The Minefield

View all
The Science Show by ABC listen

The Science Show

121 Listeners

All In The Mind by ABC listen

All In The Mind

751 Listeners

Late Night Live - Full program podcast by ABC listen

Late Night Live - Full program podcast

95 Listeners

Health Report - Full program podcast by ABC listen

Health Report - Full program podcast

133 Listeners

Conversations by ABC listen

Conversations

854 Listeners

Saturday Extra - Full program podcast by ABC listen

Saturday Extra - Full program podcast

13 Listeners

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today by ABC listen

Rear Vision — How History Shaped Today

78 Listeners

Philosopher's Zone by ABC listen

Philosopher's Zone

212 Listeners

Big Ideas by ABC listen

Big Ideas

94 Listeners

Future Tense by ABC listen

Future Tense

71 Listeners

Late Night Live - Separate stories podcast by ABC listen

Late Night Live - Separate stories podcast

47 Listeners

The Economy, Stupid by ABC listen

The Economy, Stupid

19 Listeners

Short & Curly by ABC listen

Short & Curly

1,683 Listeners

Politics Now by ABC listen

Politics Now

113 Listeners

Ladies, We Need To Talk by ABC listen

Ladies, We Need To Talk

344 Listeners

ABC News Daily by ABC

ABC News Daily

127 Listeners

If You're Listening by ABC listen

If You're Listening

305 Listeners

Unravel by ABC listen

Unravel

747 Listeners

ABC KIDS News Time by ABC KIDS listen

ABC KIDS News Time

190 Listeners

No Feeling Is Final by ABC listen

No Feeling Is Final

55 Listeners

Parental As Anything by ABC listen

Parental As Anything

55 Listeners

Stuff The British Stole by ABC listen and CBC

Stuff The British Stole

996 Listeners

Global Roaming with Geraldine Doogue and Hamish Macdonald by ABC listen

Global Roaming with Geraldine Doogue and Hamish Macdonald

43 Listeners