
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


John Solomon and Jerry Dunleavy at Just the News published what looks like an explosive piece, featuring notes from an FBI interview of a former Democratic House Intelligence Committee staffer turned whistleblower. The staffer was interviewed repeatedly over the years, most recently at the St. Louis Grand Hotel in May 2023, where he or she said this about onetime Intelligence Committee chair and current California Senator Adam Schiff:
When working in this capacity, [redacted] was called to an all-staff meeting by SCHIFF. In this meeting, SCHIFF stated the group would leak classified information which was derogatory to President of the United States DONALD J. TRUMP. SCHIFF stated the information would be used to indict President TRUMP.
“Schiff stated the group would leak classified information…”The DOJ had these interviews for years, but they never surfaced, and FBI Director Kash Patel’s office only discovered them recently (“just last week” was a version I heard). It’s important to note that the existence of an official FBI “302” form summarizing an interview of a witness doesn’t mean the interviewee is correct, or that the information has been reviewed or investigated.
In this case, however, there’s good reason to look. The existence of a Schiff staffer who talked to federal investigators was referenced in a Justice Department Inspector General report released nine months ago, in December 2024. That was another investigation by Barack Obama appointee Michael Horowitz, into possible abuses by the Justice Department in Trump’s first term in searching for the origin of classified leaks to the Washington Post, CNN, and The New York Times in the “spring and summer of 2017.” The subject of those media reports? Russiagate.
There’s a complex story underlying that Horowitz report, as some sources believe that the DOJ 2017 leak investigation Horowitz examined was aimed not at news reporters but the Congressional investigators into Russiagate’s origins, who were also placed under surveillance at that time. (See “A True Bipartisan Scandal” in Racket last year.) Mainstream reporters contended the opposite, that the DOJ probe in 2017 was aimed at outlets like the Times, Post, and CNN that were publishing Trump-Russia bombshells.
For the moment, the key passage in last December’s report by Horowitz was about a “Committee Witness,” described as a “staffer from the Democratic staff” of a key committee, who claimed to have important information about “two Democratic members of Congress” leaking classified information:
Subscribe now
Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live.
Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
See you soon!
Listen to the Full Episode
Book Club ScheduleThis Episode: Voltaire’s Candide Part 2
Monday Night: Voltaire’s Candide Part 3/3
Listen to Episode 145
Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.
Matt Taibbi: Walter, I want to start the show. I want to get deep with you about something-
Walter Kirn: Okay, good.
Matt Taibbi: ... quick. I want to ask you a rhetorical question.
Walter Kirn: Okay.
Matt Taibbi: Actually, it’s not even a rhetorical question, it’s a philosophical question. Do you view fiction writing, what you do for a living, on some level as a quest for truth? In other words, are you trying to write something that’s true the way Hemingway described it, like one true sentence. Hunter Thompson once said, “The best fiction is truer than any journalism.” Do you view what you do as a quest to find something that’s eternal and true?
Walter Kirn: Well, after you are forcing me to contradict both Hunter Thompson and Hemingway, if I say, no-
Matt Taibbi: No, it’s okay. No, I’m interested.
Walter Kirn: But the answer is yes. I’m not kissing Hunter’s ass or coming after Hemingway, but the answer is, of course, yes. I am after that kind of truth that people feel when they close a book or they finish a chapter and they go, “Oh my God, that cut deep. Oh, I just heard the bell ring in my soul.” That kind of truth.
Matt Taibbi: Right. And I think this is something that’s consistent across all genres of art. Comedy. Seinfeld talks about how the audience’s reaction is true. You can’t fake it. It’s either funny or not. Certainly, for most of my career, I view journalism, yeah, it’s kind of a junior league version of what art is, right? It’s a quest for truth. It’s not as highfalutin and exalted as fiction writing or comedy or any of those things, but it comes close, right? You’re trying to be accurate. You’re trying to get to something that’s lasting.
Walter Kirn: I think especially journalism, which synthesizes smaller stories into a bigger story, getting down the record of what happened that day and what spokesman said what, and the numbers that come out of an accident or something, that’s factuality. But journalism, I think, does seek truth when it put together stories and create a sense of what’s really happening and gets into human motivations and things like that.
Matt Taibbi: So just, again, to go to Hunter because he’s the American icon of our business. Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail ‘72, that’s a very true book about what campaigning is like.
Walter Kirn: Right.
Matt Taibbi: You know what I mean? The sights, sounds, smells, emotions, all those things, I think they were very lasting for a long while.
Walter Kirn: Well, and I’ll say one more thing. Fiction often misses the truth because fiction gets caught up in tropes and conventions very easily, and it loses touch with reality. And one of the things that I think great journalism like Hunter’s does is it refreshes our ability to see reality. We really had political campaigns in fiction that didn’t resemble real ones for a long time. We had the conventions, we had the whistle stops, or a ton rhetorical exaggerations of the candidates and the pom-pom girls and so on, but he really got the tedium of it and the weirdness of it and so on.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, the weird adrenaline rushes in between all the dead spots, right?
Walter Kirn: Yes.
Matt Taibbi: The weird fascinations you have with candidates, the disillusionment, all that stuff, right? And conversely, that’s why I don’t love books by people like Henry James. Things are too polished. They’re too perfect. It doesn’t feel like reality to me. It’s not weird enough. There’s something missing.
Anyway, I say all this as a preface to, what if suddenly the game changed? We all, for all of our lives, imagine, for instance, journalism to be about trying to find answers to underlying questions and get things right. What if suddenly it wasn’t about that anymore? What if the standard was to have enough quantitative convincing power to force a version of reality onto people that isn’t real?
Walter Kirn: Well, Matt, I think our audience has waited for this moment because whether you know it or not, I think you’re reaching a conclusion that underlines and underlies a lot of my assumptions for a long time here on these big mega stories. Because you are so dogged and single-minded in your pursuit of the truth, I think you’ve lost touch sometimes with how badly the rest of the field does it, and how completely changed their priorities have been. You continue to see the best in them. I, of course, look for the worst, first of all, never wanting to be disappointed.
It’s because I’m a lightweight. I always want the bad news first so I can get used to it. And you’re absolutely right, impact, leverage, the projection of pure brute power, getting people to do things. When we remember that Catherine Maher speech that she gave about there not being truth because she said, “We want to get you to do things.” And that’s, I’m afraid, what so much journalism has become, and I think I know where you’re going, it’s where it might go in a turbocharged fashion soon.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. And I think we’re in that moment of acceleration.
Walter Kirn: Yes.
Matt Taibbi: And what are we talking about? We’re talking about AI, but it’s AI in addition to all the things that Walter and I have been talking about for years is about anti-disinformation and other things. Essentially, AI is about to become the dominant factor in information and how it’s related not just in journalism, but in academia and all kinds of other things. And we’re going to see some of the stories that have come out just in the last few weeks.
Journalists are now realizing that you don’t have to apologize to audiences for getting things wrong anymore because it’s not the human audience that really matters, it’s the AI audience, it’s the algorithms, it’s the platforms, and it’s how they weigh how authoritative you are, and they will continue to present a wrong version of reality, if so programmed, right? Am I getting that wrong, or is there a better way to put this?
Walter Kirn: No, I think it’s a great way to put it. I would just footnote what you said. Their authority is something that they carry from the pre-AI age into this one. In other words, the paradox of this is that the authority is not based on how often you told the truth recently, but how much of a reputation you developed in the old world.
In a strange way, you can be a liar now if you developed a reputation for truth in the past because your statements are favored algorithmically by the AI. A lot of these places are harvesting the fruits of their past integrity, which gave them the reputation or the market share or whatever it might be. The pure number of hits that caused the AI to favor their input.
Matt Taibbi: Awards. Yeah.
Walter Kirn: Awards and so on. But now they can abuse it because they won’t be questioned. You see, when we talk about truth, it’s who determines it that I think is at the root, and you just brought this up. In the old days, truth meant does it register in the reader’s mind as logical in accord with their own experience or in accord with other places that have informed them? Now, we’re not making the truth judgment, in fact, it’s not being made at all.
What’s being made is a kind of search engine style, prioritizing, and it’s a mathematical judgment, not a judgment of correspondence between elements that says, “Does this correspond to what I know, what I’ve read, and what I’ve learned?” And does it come from a journalist who has the authority? You see, Matt, if something comes from you, I’m more likely to believe it’s the truth because you’ve made that a priority in your writing, and you’ve corrected yourself and you’ve beaten yourself up when you’ve gotten things wrong, but when it comes from Grok, or whatever, ChatGPT, it has no presumption of integrity. It’s simply the result of a mathematical equation.
Matt Taibbi: Right. And this is the part that has stumped me and a lot of old-timers in the business. So beginning, I would say, with the WMD thing, but really taking off with the Russiagate story, the phenomenon of being caught in a lie publicly, having it written about at length, having it out there, and yet not making a correction. That was something that’s kind of new. If you got caught previously, the rest of the business piled on to you, and you would have to issue a correction. And sometimes it was career-ending and it was painful, and sometimes they did it selectively, like to Judith Miller and not to others in the WMD story. What happened with this Russia story, and we’re not going to spend all our time in Russiagate today.
We’re going to talk about AI more, I would say. But a lot of the people in the business who grew up with this other standard are looking at this and saying, “Well, how can they keep saying this one thing? If these other facts have surfaced, then how can you keep saying that?” And it seems maddening, but the reason is because that’s how the algorithms work. Even before we got to AI, Google, in 2017, right as this story was taking off, they reinstituted something called Project Owl or they instituted something called Project Owl. And this was in part incidentally in reaction to complaints that conspiracy theories had surfaced too much in the 2016 campaign, allowing disinformation to reach, say, Trump voters.
From “Gabbard overrode CIA officials’ concerns in push to release classified Russia report,” in the Washington Post this week:
The Trump administration pushed to unveil a highly classified document on Russia’s interference in the 2016 election after an intense behind-the-scenes struggle over secrecy, which ended in late July when Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard released a minimally redacted version of the report, according to multiple people familiar with the matter.
Gabbard, with the blessing of President Donald Trump, overrode arguments from the CIA and other intelligence agencies that more of the document should remain classified to obscure U.S. spy agencies’ sources and methods, the people said…
For sheer chutzpah, it’s hard to match Warren Stroebel’s crude hit piece. First, it isn’t news: many of us who wrote on Gabbard’s releases already reported that these documents came out over objections from other agencies. The crucial 46-page House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) report showing how officials like former CIA Director John Brennan cooked the books to argue Russia “aspired” to help Trump was declassified only after current HPSCI chairman Rick Crawford complained about it being “held hostage” at the CIA and “Trump interceded in early July,” as I put it weeks ago. Gabbard herself hinted at struggles with a still-formidable “deep state” in a speech on July 12th:
More to the point, the fact that she’s had to fight elements in the intelligence community (and others in government) just to get true material to the public is to Gabbard’s credit, not any kind of demerit. The Post, in a breathtaking spin job, simply took news Gabbard’s office is proud of, and spat it out as a negative.
“I love the Washington Post headline,” said Alexa Henning, Deputy Chief of Staff in Gabbard’s office. “Of course, the deep state is going to try to push back against us. When the CIA and others are leaking to the Post and the New York Times, that means we’re onto something.”
A source close to the original HPSCI investigation added: “Gabbard had to climb Everest to get this stuff out, and they’re giving her a hard time… Ridiculous.”
Amid this week’s media attacks, not one reporter noted the fight over Russiagate releases is ongoing, and involves material some intelligence officials are still determined to keep hidden. According to multiple people with knowledge of the probes, the “sources and methods” the CIA and other agencies are most concerned about don’t involve sensitive human assets or intelligence gathering, but bureaucratic tricks to burnish weak evidence or cover up bad practices. Burying the unclassified Steele dossier in the highest level of classification in the 2017 Assessment, pushing analysts to endorse conclusions based on unseen information, and using a “circle jerk” method of leaking to friendly media and then citing their articles in intelligence reports are among the practices at issue.
The recent press hysterics have to be understood in this context. Features decrying releases to taxpayers of documents written by public servants omit another fact: when you hear “sources and methods,” it’s a good bet the next word out of a reporter’s mouth is a lie. It’s nearly a 100% tendency:
Subscribe now
Once, journalists denounced excessive secrecy. Until the Trump years, it was common to see editorials at papers like the New York Times railing against overclassification. In the last ten years, legacy outlets flipped the script, and reporters reveled in new roles as gatekeepers who helped national security officials hide the ball.
In the Russiagate scandal, whose long-suppressed issues are now exploding into view thanks to officials like Gabbard and FBI Director Kash Patel, the “sources and methods” line has been invoked countless times to stall public demands for disclosure. If you read these stories closely, you’ll notice that the same bylines from the same newspapers figure over and over in these whitewash jobs.
In May of 2018, when the House Intelligence Committee was on the trail of an informant who’d been deployed to spy on figures in the Trump campaign, the Washington Post cried that releasing information about the informant would “cross a red line of compromising sources and methods.” The paper even quoted Assistant Attorney General Stephen Boyd in saying it could lead to “severe consequences including potential loss of human lives.” Virginia Senator Mark Warner warned House colleagues it was “potentially illegal” to even try to learn the informant’s name. The man in question turned out to be Stefan Halper, a U.K.-based academic who’d been outed as a CIA operative in the pages of the New York Times in 1983.
It was all a bluff, just like the cries about “sources and methods” when investigators attempted to get hold of text messages between FBI lovers Peter Strzok and Lisa Page, and when Patel’s team of investigators tried to get documents pertaining to the faked FISA application used to spy on onetime Trump aide Carter Page. In the latter case, Patel’s assertions about FISA abuse were proven correct by an Inspector General investigation, but then-Congressman Adam Schiff and other House Democrats bemoaned what was described as an intrusion on “sources and methods” for “no legitimate purpose.”
“No legitimate purpose.” House Democrats reached for “sources and methods” to condemn accurate reports of FISA abuseThe same thing happened in late 2017, when Patel — then heading a group of investigators at the House Intelligence Committee under Devin Nunes — attempted to get hold of information about who funded the infamous dossier by British ex-spy Christopher Steele. New FBI Director Christopher Wray bellowed, “We are dealing with very, very dicey questions of sources and methods, which is the lifeblood of foreign intelligence and our liaison relationships with our foreign partners.” It turned out there were no “liaison relationships” in play in that case, unless you count the one between Steele’s funders in the Hillary Clinton campaign and the FBI.
An important thing to note is that all of these “sources and methods” cries in the Russiagate affair helped cover up press negligence in addition to official malfeasance. The Steele case involved the unbelievable prospect that none of the many media outlets known to have possessed the dossier before release were aware it was paid Clinton campaign research. The FISA misuse story exposed a string of news agencies — including especially the Washington Post — which helped convey the inaccurate claim that Carter Page was an “agent of a foreign power.”
The Halper story made idiots of reporters (again, including from the Post) who claimed the “informant” was there to protect Trump, not spy on him. The Post went so far as to speculate that the “informant” who turned out to be Halper was “possibly someone who was already in Russian business or organized crime circles,” and a likely provider of other valuable intelligence that “will need to cease if made public.”
In hindsight, it’s incredible how far off-base some of these stories were, underscoring the enormous motive news organizations had in preventing the contradictory raw information from escaping.
Neither intelligence agencies nor media outlets worried about “sources and methods” when reporting on Robert Mueller’s indictments of GRU officers, or news about alleged “blackmail” material Russians kept on Donald Trump (which came from that highly classified annex briefed to the then President-elect), or conversations between Jeff Sessions and Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak (announced cheerfully as gleaned from “signals intelligence”), or any of a dozen other episodes in which details about intelligence procedures were leaked to drive Trump-Russia mania.
Now it’s being reported as breaking news by the Post that “people familiar with the matter” say Gabbard “overrode” officials in the CIA and other agencies in her recent declassifications.
So far, though, the big “sources and methods” reveal in these releases is that the CIA pulled the key conclusions out of its backside. Prize “sources” proved to be an email with “no date, no identified sender, no clear recipient, and no classification,” a US ambassador reading a Russian “media item” saying Trump and Putin should “work together like businessmen,” and a “scant, unclear, and unverifiable fragment of a sentence” of unknown origin relayed secondhand to Director John Brennan, who tried to include it orally, from memory, nearly half a year after the encounter. The dangerous secret is that the CIA had fewer sources than a junior high newspaper, not awesome penetration of the Kremlin.
You wouldn’t know that reading the Post, which included hysterical quotes from Virginia Senator Mark Warner, who in a repeat of the Halper episode said Gabbard’s release “puts at risk some of the most sensitive sources and methods our Intelligence Community uses to spy on Russia and keep Americans safe,” and sends a message “the United States can no longer be trusted to protect the intelligence you share with us.” Author Stroebel added that “human sources reporting on Putin’s plans” are “among the agency’s most closely guarded secrets.”
He didn’t mention that the Post years ago wrote multiple features about Brennan’s alleged prize source “deep within the confines of the Kremlin,” even directing readers to a Komersant story that included his name. That was different.
Back then, the Post and most everyone else in the press were claiming the existence of detailed, specific intelligence about Putin’s evil plan to put Trump in the White House. From a June 23, 2017 report about the “bombshell” intelligence:
Early last August, an envelope with extraordinary handling restrictions arrived at the White House. Sent by courier from the CIA, it carried “eyes only” instructions that its contents be shown to just four people: President Barack Obama and three senior aides.
Inside was an intelligence bombshell, a report drawn from sourcing deep inside the Russian government that detailed Russian President Vladimir Putin’s direct involvement in a cyber campaign to disrupt and discredit the U.S. presidential race.
But it went further. The intelligence captured Putin’s specific instructions on the operation’s audacious objectives — defeat or at least damage the Democratic nominee, Hillary Clinton, and help elect her opponent, Donald Trump.
The Post offered a helpful infographic detailing how Brennan handled this amazing intelligence:
When it was convenient, the Washington Post made infographics for “sources and methods”We now know this was false. The intelligence Brennan actually received at that time came from retrieved Russian material describing, in Brennan’s own words, “alleged approval by Hillary Clinton on July 26, 2016 of a proposal from one of her foreign policy advisors to vilify Donald Trump by stirring up a scandal claiming interference by Russian security services.”
That’s what Brennan briefed Obama about on August 3, 2016, and that’s what prompted Brennan to call counterpart Alexander Bortnikov of the FSB on August 4th, allegedly to warn him “not to meddle in the election,” as the New York Times put it. Speaking of sources and methods, information from intercepted Russian communiques mysteriously dried up after Brennan’s call.
“Sources and methods” was the cri de coeur after Edward Snowden told the world about illegal surveillance. It was George Tenet’s excuse in a 2002 letter to the Senate for not giving better WMD intelligence. Judith Miller dragged it out in her defense after her WMD stories blew up. It is the oldest and most pathetic trick in the media book. Now, it’s being thrust back in service, at a desperate time.
Expect new information soon not only on Russiagate, but on the underlying bad practices that made it possible. The intensity of the infighting taking place between releases gives some indication of how damaging this information is. The intelligence bureaucracy isn’t going down without a fight.
The high priests of journalism should be able to detect the difference between good coverage and epic failure
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 08/4/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
I see in the comments to the just-released piece on the FIRE suit against Marco Rubio and the Trump administration, that I may not have clearly explained a key element leaning toward FIRE’s view that Trump’s deportation policies are unconstitutional.
There’s significant precedent arguing that aliens enjoy the same First Amendment rights as citizens. There are multiple cases. Bridges v. Wixon is a closely analogous 1945 case about an Australian labor organizer accused of communist affiliation. Not unlike someone like Mahmoud Khalil, Harry Bridges was a foreigner thought to be here on a specious premise, advancing unpopular beliefs and causing trouble. However, the Supreme Court was clear:
Freedom of speech and of the press is accorded aliens residing in this country.
The court in that same case ruled that foreigners enjoy First and Fifth Amendment rights once they enter the country, noting the Constitution speaks of “persons,” not citizens:
Once an alien lawfully enters and resides in this country, he becomes invested with the rights guaranteed by the Constitution to all people within our borders. Such rights include those protected by the First and the Fifth Amendments and by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. None of these provisions acknowledges any distinction between citizens and resident aliens. They extend their inalienable privileges to all “persons…”
In the 1953 case Kwong Hai Chew v. Colding, a Chinese-born man who married an American, served in the merchant marines and “proved his good moral character” was detained en route home from a sea voyage, when an immigration inspector deemed him an “alien whose entry was deemed prejudicial to the public interest.” The court cited Wixon in noting that neither the First nor Fifth Amendment, nor the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, “acknowledges any distinction” between citizens and aliens. It added:
It is well established that, if an alien is a lawful permanent resident of the United States and remains physically present there, he is a person within the protection of the Fifth Amendment.
There are a handful of others that generally reference the same concept. What makes the U.S. different from Europe or Canada is that there’s no notion of balancing individual rights and the rights of society. If government can selectively infringe on the “free exercise” of speech for foreigners, it would mean conceding that government has some jurisdiction over speech.
Just wanted to highlight the above cases, which suggest the principle has to apply generally or not at all. It may sound counterintuitive, but if you think about it…
First rule of speech controversies: no one appeals to the Constitution to protect popular opinion. Words that need defending are always repugnant, obnoxious, and offensive to someone’s sensibilities. Cops have to put up with “Fuck the Police,” bankers have to abide communists (and vice versa), black Americans coexist with the Klan, and everyone has to live with NAMBLA. Entering a speech debate, expect to wince.
Between a duel of loud headlines about Jeffrey Epstein and Russiagate, the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) this morning filed Stanford Daily Publishing Corporation, Jane Doe, and John Doe v. Marco Rubio and Kristi Noem, challenging the Trump administration’s immigration policies on speech grounds. The suit will test the patience of anyone frustrated by excesses in recent campus protests, some of which themselves crossed First Amendment lines. But FIRE, which has been such an important actor in fighting digital censorship, is doing the right thing. In the name of trying to protect the country, the Trump administration is advertising to the world its misunderstanding of a core American idea. It’s a mess:
Subscribe now
At issue is the Trump administration’s much-criticized deportations policy, specifically efforts by Marco Rubio and the State Department to revoke visas of students and other foreigners deemed threats. Trump officials in February announced an intention to “root out” those guilty of “anti-Semitic harassment in schools and on college campuses,” and Rubio followed up in March with an announcement that he’d personally revoked over 300 visas. “We do it every day,” Rubio said. “Every time I find one of these lunatics, I take away their visas.” Using a seemingly Charlie Murphy-inspired metaphor many Trump supporters found convincing, Rubio added:
We gave you a visa to come and study and get a degree, not to be a social activist that comes in and tears up our university campuses…
If you invite me into your home because I say, “Oh, I want to go to your house for dinner,” and I come into your house and I start putting mud on your couch and spray-painting your kitchen, I bet you you’re going to kick me out.
The signature cases involved activist Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil, whose presence Rubio said would create a “hostile environment for Jewish students in the United States,” and Tufts student Rümeysa Öztürk, who aroused displeasure via an editorial she wrote for the Tufts Daily demanding that the school “acknowledge the Palestinian genocide.” Both cases aroused massive media furor, with video of agents grabbing Öztürk off the streets going viral, triggering instant comparisons to a smorgasbord of secret police regimes. Massachusetts congressman Seth Moulton told the Boston Globe, “It’s like the Gestapo. That’s what the Gestapo was established to do.” Joe Rogan, bashed as a Nazi-booster by MSNBC in March, came back into the station’s good graces when he ripped the deportations as “fucking crazy.” Amid the frenzy, few commentators noted the controversial policy’s unusual legal genesis.
Rubio and the Trump administration were attempting to deport “these lunatics” by drawing upon two provisions of the Immigration and Nationality Act. The first allows the federal government to deport an alien if the Secretary of State “personally determines” his or her admission “would compromise a compelling United States foreign policy interest.” The second allows the Secretary of State to, “at any time, in his discretion,” revoke a “visa or other documentation.”* Herein lies the rub: the “Gestapo” tactics appear enshrined as permissible under current immigration law.
At the same time, there exists a 1945 Supreme Court ruling, Bridges v. Wixon, which grants legal aliens First Amendment rights. Long before Trump, in other words, there was a gray area in the law, one not challenged until FIRE decided to take on the case on behalf of a group of plaintiffs. Two are unnamed foreign students who’ve participated in pro-Palestinian protests or published pro-Palestinian opinions, and the third is the Stanford Daily, some of whose noncitizen writers “have self-censored by declining to cover pro-Palestinian student protests.” Immigration law says they can be thrown out at any time, for any reason, but can speech rights exist at all if they vary according to visa status?
“The way we see it,” says Conor Fitzpatrick, FIRE’s lead counsel in the case, “is that if non-citizens have First Amendment rights in this country — which we know under Bridges v. Wixon, they do — a right has to mean something.”
Foreigners and citizens are clearly treated differently when it comes to laws and regulations. The former can’t vote, the latter mostly can’t hide from the IRS. FIRE’s argument is that rights generally and speech rights in particular can’t be variable.
“Everyone agrees, for example, that a non-citizen can’t be thrown in jail for voicing an opinion,” says Fitzpatrick. “I think there’s pretty universal agreement that the First Amendment at least provides the same level of protection against criminal prosecution for protected speech. What this suit is seeking is some long-awaited clarity that a federal immigration statute does not trump the First Amendment.”
Politically, the story is complicated. The U.S. government for decades has mass-deported immigrants who bust their asses for pennies in farms and slaughterhouses and would do anything to be Americans, and no one makes celebrities of them. Meanwhile, Khalil especially has become a green-room star, fawned over by Congressional delegations and media panels as he denounces everyone from the school that accepted him to the agents who detained him: “I want to make sure that everyone who contributed to my arrest will be held accountable,” he said, adding that Trump and company chose “the wrong person” to challenge. No matter how you view his cause, he comes across as exactly the exhausting guest Rubio described.
That’s where the wince test comes in. The First Amendment doesn’t delineate who does and doesn’t qualify for protection. It just lays out that what people say or think isn’t this or any government’s business.
“Madison and Jefferson wrote that opinions are not within the purview of the government,” says Fitzpatrick. “The whole idea behind the First Amendment is it deprives the government of authority to wield its power based on the opinions of the speaker.”
That’s what makes Rubio’s attitude toward this issue ironic. He questions why “any country in the world” would “welcome people into their country that are going to go to your universities as visitors, and say ‘I’m going to your universities to start a riot.’”
America isn’t “any country in the world,” though. We’re the one place on earth where you get to say the craziest conceivable shit and government doesn’t get to say boo. If someone like Khalil drifts into truly prohibited activity, like incitment or rioting, charge them. But a precedent that government can punish for criticism of its policies or even just for being mouthy guests would open doors to nightmare eventualities, one being a slide from a unique society to “any other country in the world.” Shrugging off crazy things people say is the essence of the American experience. The alternative is putting the state in the computerized opinion-measuring business.
In that vein, the reported State Department plan to use AI to scour social media for “any indications of hostility toward the citizens, culture, government, institutions or founding principles of the United States” is just an inverse of Biden-era plans to have the FBI and DHS work with Internet platforms to “to share and receive domestic violent extremism threat-related information.” These same types of calculations led to deamplification or removal of vaccine critics, alleged conspirators with Russia, and other blue-party bugbears, few of whom were genuine threats. Democrats spent the last eight years fetishizing these forms of digital guilt-by-association, and looked like demented nanny-staters doing it. Why would the Trump administration go there Tighten borders and immigration policies all you like, but speech has to stay off the table.
*In a bizarre twist, the first provision was once ruled unconstitional by Judge Maryanne Trump Barry, Donald Trump’s sister, in a non-speech-related case, Massieu v. Reno, only to be overturned by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals.
When I was told Friday that President Trump fired the BLS commissioner due to a poor July payroll report (a less-than-expected monthly job add of 73,000 and very large negative two-month revision of 258,000), I waited for a laugh track that never came.
He did what? Really?
I spent most of the weekend shaking my head and laughing that the president would fire BLS Commissioner Erika McEntarfer for a lousy Non-Farm Payroll report.
Then I thought about it a bit more.
Most of us who have been in the markets have probably spent at least six of the 12 first Fridays of the month every year scratching our heads when the monthly report is released. Our staff economist leads us through the various seasonal adjustments, model adjustments, survey participation rates, data revisions to the last two reports and other assorted “kinks” in the reporting, and by the end it usually sounds like nonsense. I believe these monthly reports warrant a good dose of skepticism.
Year-over-year however, I always thought the numbers were relatively accurate, which is why I was pretty surprised when in February the BLS revised the total 2024 non-farm payroll employment level down 598,000, a revision of −0.4%. That’s the largest revision in 10 years. Annual benchmark revisions have averaged 0.1% in the last decade, ranging from less than .05% to 0.3%.
Trump already had his suspicions back in August 2024 when the BLS estimated that the 2024 revision would be a whopping 818,000 fewer jobs than previously reported.
A big negative revision for 2024 annual job creation meant that his Democratic opponent had been campaigning on inflated employment numbers. While it was probably just poor data, as Racket’s Matt Taibbi has been tirelessly reporting, the president has a very justified “trust issue” with other supposedly non-partisan organs of government, so why not the BLS as well?
It has not been a good decade for the BLS in the “trust” department. In 2022, BLS investigated a suspicious event and found it did nothing wrong. Then, in 2024, senior BLS officials blatantly lied about a release of material nonpublic information to a select group of people.
“Super Users”The New York Times reported that in January 2024 a BLS staff economist engaged in highly inappropriate communication revealing material nonpublic information to a select group of banks and hedge funds. From the Times:
In an email addressed to “Super Users,” the economist explained a technical change in the calculation of the housing figures. Then, departing from the bureaucratic language typically used by statistical agencies, he added, “All of you searching for the source of the divergence have found it.”
To the inflation obsessives who received the email — and other forecasters who quickly heard about it — the implication was clear: The pop in housing prices in January might have been not a fluke but rather a result of a shift in methodology that could keep inflation elevated longer than economists and Federal Reserve officials had expected. That could, in turn, make the Fed more cautious about cutting interest rates.
That kind of information had tremendous value in the wrong hands.
There was an uproar when news of the Super User group leaked. When confronted in early March 2024 by news outlets, the BLS called what happened a mistake and denied there was an actual “Super Users” group, but rather a one time reply to multiple inquiries. From Bloomberg News:
“To expedite a response, the employee blind-copied a number of requesters and referred to them as super users — this was a mistake,” said Jeffrey Hill, a BLS associate commissioner.
The New York Times filed a FOIA with BLS, and found there was indeed a “Super User” list, kept by at least one “low ranking” staff economist who was communicating with a number of banks, money managers and hedge funds.
The emails show that the employee did engage in extended, one-on-one email exchanges with data users about how the inflation figures are put together. Such details, though highly technical, can be of significant interest to forecasters, who compete to predict inflation figures to hundredths of a percentage point. Those estimates, in turn, are used by investors making bets on the huge batches of securities that are tied to inflation or interest rates.
In at least one case, emails to super users appear to have shared methodological details that were not yet public. On Jan. 31, the employee sent an email to his super users describing coming changes to the way the agency calculates used car prices, at the time a crucial issue for inflation watchers. The email included a three-page document providing detailed answers to questions about the change, and a spreadsheet showing how they would affect calculations.
“Thank you all for your very difficult, challenging and thoughtful questions,” the email said. “It is your questions that help us flesh out all the potential problems.”
The questions also seemed to have fleshed out for the Super Users important changes to how the BLS was changing their calculations of the CPI two weeks before their official release in mid-February!
The Times identified several “Super Users.” Among them: Barclays, Nomura, BNP Paribas, Millennium Capital Partners, Breven Howard and Citadel.
Bloomberg News, after reviewing the documents, found JP Morgan, BlackRock and Moore Capital were also part of the group.
In response, an external team of experts was formed to investigate the incidents and suggest improvements.
While the team’s report stated that “none of the incidents were related to the quality or accuracy of the agency's core data work,” the issue of the Super User group had nothing to do with the quality of the agency’s work. Rather, it had to do with disseminating that work to a select group before it was made public.
Here is what McEntarfer had to say about the Super User incident:
It was an idiosyncratically collected group of emails of people who had been asking him questions that he put together against policies and procedures that BLS outlined, so, yeah, it was limited to one person and ceased at the moment its attention was brought to the agency.
Idiosyncratically collected group of emails? I have to give McEntarfer credit for some fantastic, institutionalized bullshit there!
How many times did this “idiosyncratic” behavior take place, who did it take place with, and what was discussed in each of these idiosyncratic exchanges? What did the members of the Super User group do with the information that they knew was material and non-public? Why did the employee provide this service?
Regarding the expert report, the McEntarger concluded:
I want to emphasize that throughout their conversations with me, the team emphasized that overall, their investigation revealed a really excellent organization with a highly capable staff, deeply committed to their mission and their agency,"
Nothing to see here, please move alongYou might remember that back in 2022, inflation was raging. On the morning of December 13, 2022, the markets were on pins and needles waiting for the 8:30 a.m. November Consumer Price Index report. About one minute before the release, 10-year U.S. Treasury Futures began to skyrocket, along with equity futures. At 8:30 the BLS reported that inflation for November came in much lower than expected, something that would have caused bond and equity futures to surge higher, like they did 60 seconds prior to the release! The March 2023 Ten-Year Treasury futures saw the buying of 13,000 contracts seconds before the release, a notional value of nearly $1.5 billion.
Interestingly, while there was much hand-wringing, the incident passed without any investigation. This was a bit “disconcerting” since the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) could have discovered who traded right before 8:30 a.m.
The CFTC could have rounded up all the Futures Clearing Merchants and had them divulge which clients placed the trades. It might have taken subpoenas and some investigative work, but the government has folks who do that sort of thing. As far as we know, this was never done, or at least disclosed.
Hilariously, White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre contorted herself into a pretzel later in the afternoon, essentially telling the press it was no big deal and if it was, the White House wasn’t the leaker!
The Labor Department conducted an initial investigation as to whether the data was hacked and dismissed the possibility of a data leak. The BLS denied any awareness of an early release of the data. Not exactly The Inquisition!
What is true is the report got into the wrong hands at the wrong time. Either somebody at BLS leaked the report, or it was a very senior official from either the Federal Reserve, the Treasury Department, or the president and/or his senior economic advisors. The odds point to the former. Either way the BLS seemed to want no part in finding out the answer to this mystery.
Personally, I don’t think that the July Non-Farm Payroll report was rigged. However, I do think the BLS has a credibility problem, which unfortunately extends beyond its statistical acumen. Once the lying and potential covering up begins, credibility is shot. There has been much talk this week about how casting doubt on our economic data is another blow to democracy. Interestingly, I have not seen any mention of either the “Super User” or the December 13, 2022, scandals in the reporting.
The timing and optics of Commissioner McEntarfer’s firing could have been much better, but it’s past time to clean house at the BLS.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.