
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Listen to Episode 135
Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.
Matt Taibbi: And we have an amusing show. We’re probably going to have some fiery responses about this material. Walter, you’re in Vegas, right? You relocated last night?
Walter Kirn: Yeah, late last night I left the East Coast. Which is leaving a pressure cooker at this point. I mean, I can’t tell you how many conversations of ultimate fear about the coming fascist regime that I had in New York. I talked to three people who were seriously concerned that they might go to camps at some point. What’s so funny is that I had those same conversations back in 2016. However, when you fly to Vegas where there’s a huge Bitcoin conference going on, and you look at Twitter and you look at your friends’ feeds from the Bitcoin conference and read your emails, it’s a completely different country. It’s a country that’s really excited about a reset of our currency using Bitcoin and so on. The freedom that’s going to come from the blockchain, the Trump administration’s embrace of tech and Silicon Valley, and it really is split screen America.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, it’s two completely different realities. And my feeling on this is that the truth is somewhere in between and maybe leaning a little bit more in one direction, but certainly the paranoia level. And we saw this, and we’ll get to this later because this was the theme right after Trump got elected the first time in 2016, this idea that there was going to be a mass exodus out of the United States.
Walter Kirn: Remember all the journalists who thought they were going to end up in prison or somehow silenced and so on. And yet they have been the most vocal anti-establishment, anti-Trump journalists in our history. No one has criticized the presidency and the President more than this crop of journalists. And yet there they are publishing bestselling books, not in camps yet.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, I mean, the big... Well, the real blow to the press in the first Trump administration was Julian Assange, but-
Walter Kirn: They all bailed on too.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, they all bailed on too. But the other thing that everybody actually remembers is Jim Acosta losing his gesticulating privileges at the White House, which again, I have a hard time working up the sympathy for that. But the reason we’re giddy in advance is because we watch... Every now and then, the New York Times gives us a gift in the form of something so nuts that-
Walter Kirn: The last time was their road show of deep staters when they interviewed-
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, the deep state’s awesome.
Walter Kirn: Went down to Huntsville, Alabama and interviewed a guy from the deep state who had basically saved us and was going to save us from asteroid strikes. Unless he gets fired. Maybe that guy got fired by Doge and we’re about to have a big one, a lake of fire in the middle of the East Coast. But now, they-
Matt Taibbi: And wouldn’t that be a big joke on us? We laughed and now look at that asteroid about to hit us right in the middle of this broadcast.
Walter Kirn: Could have been stopped. If not for Elon and what’s the guy?
Matt Taibbi: Doge.
Walter Kirn: Doge. We might’ve lived another 10,000 years on this planet, but in any case, they have topped themselves. That was funny. But this is through the sound and speed of light barrier. Funny. It’s Christopher Guest funny. It’s spinal tap for academics.
Matt Taibbi: It is, yeah. So essentially it’s three Yale professors, and there’s a punchline buried in this who are declaring that they’ve fled the country because of imminent fascism and they’re making the case. So can we see the grandiose opening first? So this is what it looks like online, and here’s your headline, “We study fascism and we’re leaving the US.” And you can see it’s a multi-person byline and everything, and it’s a lengthy-ish for the New York Times digital video that starts out as follows.
Marci Shore: I’m a historian of totalitarianism.
Timothy Snyder: I look at fascist rhetoric.
Jason Stanley: I’ve been thinking about the sources of the worst kinds of history for a quarter of a century.
Speaker 2: Experts say the constitutional crisis is here now.
Speaker 3: The Trump administration deporting 100s of men without a trial.
Speaker 4: A massive purge at the FBI.
Speaker 5: To make people afraid of speaking out against him.
Matt Taibbi: Look at, they’re all dressed in black. Look at the plane. All right, so that’s the setup. It’s three Yale professors, Walter, Jason Stanley, Marcy Shore, and Timothy Snyder dressed in identical somber, almost like Viet Minh black talking about-
Walter Kirn: To me, he looked like he is about to start his meditation practice for today.
Matt Taibbi: That’s right. I can hear the little water feature and see the massage room with the bamboo.
Walter Kirn: And the trickle of steam coming out of the aromatherapy vaporizer.
Matt Taibbi: Yes, exactly. Exactly. And we’re going to hear from all of them that they’re all leaving the country. So let’s look at number one, that this is Stanley giving his credentials and then talking about his intentions.
Jason Stanley: I’m leaving to the University of Toronto because I want to do my work without the fear that I will be punished for my words.
Marci Shore: The lesson of 1933 is you get out sooner rather than later.
Timothy Snyder: I’ve spent a lot of time in the last decade trying to prepare people. If Trump were elected once, let alone twice,
Donald Trump: Look wh
at happened. Is this crazy?
Timothy Snyder: I have to not flee Trump. But if people are going to leave the United States or leave American universities, there are reasons for that. One thing you can definitely learn from Russians-
Speaker 1: Is that it’s essential to set up centers of resistance in places of relative safety.
Timothy Snyder: We want to make sure that if there is a political crisis in the US, that American-
Matt Taibbi: Okay. All right.
Walter Kirn:Wait a second, Matt.
Matt Taibbi: Yep.
Walter Kirn: Editing, the editing. They actually had them finishing each other’s sentences.
Matt Taibbi: Oh, I know.
Walter Kirn: Did you see that?
Matt Taibbi: Can we go back and see that again?
Timothy Snyder: But if people are going to leave the United States or leave American universities, there are reasons for that. One thing you can definitely learn from Russians-
Speaker 1: Is that it’s essential to set up centers of resistance in places of relative safety.
Timothy Snyder: We want to make sure that if there is a political crisis in the US, that America-
Walter Kirn: Talk about a hive mind. If you look at the backdrops, they weren’t in the same room. So either they agreed to have themselves edited into a multi-headed single being, or there was a script or it just got cute. But what I’m telling you here is that what we saw so far is a milestone in deceptive editing. Well, creative editing. I mean, we talked about CBS maybe fudging a Kamala Harris answer in a 60 minutes interview. But what we just saw here were we saw shots of an El Salvador prison, which wasn’t introduced as such. Could have been anywhere. Could have been in the United States.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, could have been Alabama for all we knew.
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
I have worked in capital markets for three decades, and Wall Street has some unflattering names for the retail investor.
Dumb Money.
Racket News is supported by readers. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Slow Moving Deer.
Ray Charles Buyers (Because Ray was blind).
In other words, such investors have been the Rodney Dangerfield of investment money. No respect.
Still, the private equity industry has long dreamed of getting access to the trillions of dollars of retail money, and now it might just get it.
The industry is pushing President Trump to issue an executive order that would, according to the Financial Times, direct the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Departments of Labor and Treasury to “study the feasibility of opening 401k plans” to private equity investment.
This happens to coincide with a period when private equity management firms are particularly desperate. Investors are clamoring for their money while funding for future investments is drying up. The PE industry may not respect the retail investor, but now it needs their cash as opposed to just wanting it.
While some private equity investment was permissible in 401k funds, managers have been reticent to invest due mainly to litigation risk. In 2015, Intel employees sued the company, alleging that its pension fund manager invested in hedge funds and private equity stakes, which in turn according to the complaint were, “unreasonably costly and risky” and underperformed the post-2008 market rally.
The case actually wound its way to the Supreme Court in 2020 before going back to the lower courts, where it was ultimately dismissed in 2022. Nevertheless, the Intel case has been a bright red warning sign for fund managers due to the time and high cost of the litigation. It is thought that a new “feasibility study” by the SEC could give legal cover from potential litigation and would remove the main stumbling block that currently keeps private equity’s hucksters from breaching the walls of retirement funds.
Wall Street is trying to dress up this idea as expanding investment access to everyday Americans. In a March 31 letter to investors, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink preached:
Today, many countries have twin, inverted economies: one where wealth builds on wealth; another where hardship builds on hardship. The divide has reshaped our politics, our policies, even our sense of what’s possible.
Yes, to save ourselves and make gobs of money, we need everyone to invest in private equity! Altruism at its finest.
It’s kind of amusing when you consider that people on the wrong side of the divide that Fink describes have a hard time putting $400 together in an emergency, let alone 401ks to invest in private equity. Fink continues:
Protectionism has returned with force. The unspoken assumption is that capitalism didn’t work and it’s time to try something new.
But there's another way to look at it: Capitalism did work—just for too few people.
Markets, like everything humans build, aren’t perfect. They reflect us—unfinished, sometimes flawed, but always improvable. The solution isn't to abandon markets; it's to expand them, to finish the market democratization that began 400 years ago and let more people own a meaningful stake in the growth happening around them.
It all reminds me of what my dad used to say: Nothing good happens after 3 a.m. Consider the Blackstones, Apollos, Ares and KKRs of the world to be like thugs in the night at 3 a.m., zeroing in on the retail investor stumbling in the dark.
George Carlin’s warning more than 30 years ago is becoming a full-fledged reality.
“They want your fucking retirement money, they want it back so they can give it to their criminal friends on Wall Street, and you know something, they’ll get it, they’ll get it all from you sooner or later. It’s a big club, and you ain’t in it!”
Fink’s CrusadesFink had another great crusade just a few years ago when BlackRock launched billions of dollars of Environmental Social Governance (“ESG”) Exchange Traded Funds (“ETFs”) and mutual funds to save the planet.
Most of these vehicles were just cruel jokes based on bogus “ESG Ratings” made by the likes of MSCI that did little for the planet except make BlackRock and eventually other investment product companies billions of dollars. Now that many ESG funds have been unmasked as frauds, I suppose it is time to move on to democratizing finance for the common man.
Private equity used to be open mainly to institutional money (pensions, endowments, sovereign wealth funds) and ultra-high net worth investors. Recently however invitations to invest in private equity have been sent to high net worth accredited investors (the working-rich) in what are known as secondary funds. These funds purchase existing private equity stakes from the original limited partners.
With Donald Trump in the White House, PE is making a push for the big win, the $12 trillion 401k sector. In fact, the push started before Trump took office, as this Bloomberg News story notes:
Less than a week before President Donald Trump’s second inauguration, more than 30 money managers gathered on Zoom to strategize about how to pull America’s
retirement savers into investments far beyond stocks and bonds. During the meeting attended by Blackstone Inc., UBS Group AG, Neuberger Berman and others, participants assembled a manifesto articulating private equity’s rightful position in 401(k) plans, including in the default portfolios for workers who don’t select their own investments.
“Rightful position”
Besides private equity investments being illiquid and difficult to value, the risk to the retail investor is that, as private equity honcho Orlando Bravo warned last week, they may be saddled with the worst assets. But the good news?
“Retail investors could end up saving these companies that people cannot sell,” Bravo told the Financial Times.
Meanwhile, Blackstone, KKR and Apollo have already struck deals with large asset managers such as Vanguard, Capitol Group and State Street, according to the FT. They’re already primed in the event that Trump issues an executive order.
As Carlin said, “It’s a big club, and you ain’t in it.” If they are suddenly offering us an invitation to the “Big Club,” I’d be very wary of such an invite.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
I wasn’t going to do it, really. After stepping to the edge of nervous collapse of late, I promised, no more Conventional Wisdom Bestsellers. I saw Abundance in an airport and turned away before registering cover art. I had the same plan for Original Sin, the “controversial” book in which CNN’s Jake Tapper teams with Alex Thompson of Axios to get real about the media and Joe Biden’s health. One moment of late-night weakness later, I was reading from Chapter One, “He Totally Fucked Us”:
No one thought that the Harris campaign had been without error. But for the most knowledgeable Democratic officials and donors, and for top members of the Harris campaign, there was no question about the father of this election calamity: It was Joe Biden. Harris, loyal to Biden to a fault, might never say such a thing. But plenty of people around her would… “We got so screwed by Biden as a party,” David Plouffe, who helped run the Harris campaign, told us.. Harris, he said, was a “great soldier,” but the compressed 107-day race was “a fucking nightmare.”
“And it’s all Biden,” Plouffe said. Referring to Biden’s decision to run for reelection, then wait more than three weeks to bow out, Plouffe added: “He totally fucked us.”
Holy catfish! I thought from online buzz that Original Sin was a mea culpa. It would own press failures to cover Joe Biden’s infirmity in a super-belated version of Canadian comic Bruce McCullough’s “I’m sorry I caused all that cancer” routine. But Original Sin isn’t that. It’s much crazier! Instead of a dreary and predictable book-length excuse for thousands of media professionals simultaneously whiffing on the most obvious story in history, it’s an ambitious book-length effort to absolve all concerned, pin an industry’s coverage mistake on its President Droolcup subject (a gambit many times ballsier than blaming one reporter, à la Judith Miller), all while additionally swirling a new storm system of bullshit storylines to delay more serious questions about things like who was just president for four years.
It’s the opposite of a mea culpa and the literary degree of difficulty is awesome, equivalent to a blind unicyclist trying to juggle six chainsaws. Do Jake and Alex pull it off? They don’t! But they sure leave a hell of a lot of blood on stage:
Subscribe now
The book’s opening lines tell us we’re supposed to be shocked by Joe Biden’s delusional state:
President Joe Biden got out of bed the day after the 2024 election convinced that he had been wronged… The elites, the Democratic officials, the media, Nancy Pelosi, Barack Obama—they shouldn’t have pushed him out of the race. If he had stayed in, he would have beaten Donald Trump. That’s what the polls suggested, he would say again and again… His pollsters told us that no such polls existed…
The disconnect between Biden’s optimism and the unhappy reality of poll results was a constant throughout his administration. Many insiders sensed that his inner circle shielded him from bad news.
Reading this, you may experience a memory double-take. Wasn’t the public told repeatedly that after last year’s infamous debate between Biden and Donald Trump very little had changed, there was “less polling damage than expected,” and “few of the results reflect a radically altered race,” as NBC put it? Didn’t we see high-profile polls during the post-debate period Tapper/Thompson tell us were known in the White House as “The Bad Times,” showing Biden in the lead? Was I high and now misremembering, or did NPR senior politics editor Domenico Montanaro insist on July 12th that a PBS/Marist poll that put Biden ahead 50-48 meant “the race really hasn’t changed all that dramatically since the debate”?
There were less optimistic takes, and in fairness Tapper’s CNN ran perhaps the bleakest coverage of Biden’s prospects after the “disastrous” debate, but if Biden read the same news as the rest of us, he’d have every reason to think he was doing fine, even after the debate. There may not have been post-election polls showing he’d have done better than Kamala Harris, but among all these clowns Joe Biden is the only one to actually beat Donald Trump in an election, and unless the public was lied to on a grand scale, there was reason to think he was viable. None of that however compares to the charge that Biden was somehow to blame for the Harris loss:
Harris made plenty of mistakes, both before Biden became a candidate and afterward, but no decision that she and her campaign made was anywhere near as consequential as his decision to run for re-election and pretend he wasn’t mentally melting before our eyes… “It was an abomination,” one prominent Democratic strategist—who publicly defended Biden—told us. “He stole an election from the Democratic Party; he stole it from the American people.”
In the introduction, Tapper and Thompson explain theirs is a literary porridge not too hot, not too cold, but just right. Those who are “convinced that Joe Biden was little more than a husk from the very beginning of his presidency, barely capable of stringing two sentences together, will not find support for that view here,” they write, while those who insist he was “unaddled” to the end and “his rumored deterioration was all right-wing propaganda” are just as wrong.
I belong in the first camp, writing in Rolling Stone before his election that Biden “on multiple occasions looked close to grabbing prospective voters by the ears and speed-eating their faces off” and “often he looks around like he expects a thumbs-up for giving in to his rage-response.” He verbally and physically badgered voters in every state, and there was no shortage of quotable Democrats upset the issue was being blown off. “They’re so used to events where everyone is rooting for them,” said Tracye Redd, one of multiple people Biden sternum-poked in Iowa. He routinely held voters’ hands or forearms for too long (“We’re talking minutes,” a woman in Cedar Rapids said), got Way Too Close to peoples’ faces, became confrontational, and slurred words, all at once. His campaign heading into the first caucus was “like a passenger jet trying to land with one burning engine, hitting trees, cows, cars, sides of mountains, everything.” It was a mess, impossible to not see:
Anyone who recalls this will find it very hard to take the Tapper/Thompson line that Biden was fine at the start but not at the end, and at some point in between his incapacity became obvious enough to be “melting before our eyes,” only not so obvious that anyone but Biden could be blamed for lying about it. It hurts my brain to think about the math of that one. The book is also filled with passages like:
Millions were shocked by Biden’s unintelligible, slack-jawed performance at the debate, but some Democrats weren’t surprised at all. Though they had seen him like this behind closed doors, they didn’t say anything. For a variety of reasons, they rationalized their silence.
These passages make no sense juxtaposed as they frequently are next to someone f-bombing Biden and blaming the entire loss on him. How do the people who said nothing not get mixed in the blame pie? And what interesting people there are on that list! Take this passage, in which top Democrats consider how to come up with a replacement candidate on July 3rd of last year, before Biden stepped down:
There was one thing everyone at the White House seemed to agree upon: An open primary process would be a disaster… That’s not how two éminences grises in the party saw it. Privately, Barack Obama and Nancy Pelosi favored some sort of process. Pelosi in particular heard from voting-rights activists who insisted on such a thing. The Obama/Pelosi position would be viewed by the Harris camp as skepticism of Harris’s political abilities.
This is one of many times I would have liked to hear from a lawyer, historian, or anyone who could speak to the propriety of Barack Obama and Nancy Pelosi blithely discussing how to replace a sitting president outside the scope of the constitutional process designed for this situation, the 25th Amendment. The detail about Pelosi having “heard” from “voting-rights activists” about potential unhappiness with a closed process hits my ear as pure nuttery (only one of these toffs even considers the opinion of voters in all this, and Pelosi only really worries about what “voting-rights activists” might say), but to Tapper/Thompson, it all sounds fine. Yet we also get passages like this:
Ponder the question… if Biden had not run for reelection, or if he had acknowledged his decay and changed his mind about it in 2023, what would have happened?
If history is any guide, a competitive primary and caucus process would have produced a stronger Democratic nominee, one who had more experience with debates and taking questions from reporters, one with a more cogent and precise answer as to why they were running, one with time to introduce themselves to the American people. Would that candidate have been able to do 1.5 percentage points better in Michigan, 1.8 points better in Pennsylvania, and 0.9 points better in Wisconsin? To the Plouffes of the world, it’s hard to argue no.
“If Biden had decided in 2023 to drop out, we would have had a robust primary,” Plouffe said.
Thompson and Tapper know well that the entire party vetoed the idea of an “open primary.” There’s a long chapter titled “Dean Phillips” that chronicles, weirdly and incompletely, the abject process by which challengers were excluded from any kind of primary process. Though a lot of the worst shenanigans are left out, the two authors nonetheless note “it was machine-style politics to ensure that Biden would be the nominee… Phillips could not get Biden on a stage to prove his point. And the entire Democratic Party apparatus went along with it.”
If “the entire Democratic Party apparatus” went along with spiking a “robust primary,” how can it be “all Biden” who “fucked us” by refusing to “acknowledge his decay” and quit? I don’t know Thompson and don’t have anything against Tapper, but it’s all a classic Washington hive-braineurysm. The story is all told from the vantage point of characters like “one prominent Democrat,” “one senior White House aide,” and Barack Obama, who like the God of the Old Testament communicates not through words but omniscient narration (“Obama’s phone was blowing up with texts”; “Obama had arrived at the conclusion that Biden didn’t have a path”; “Obama… never directly told Biden not to run”). Collectively they offer every conceivable self-serving excuse, even ones that contradict one another before the end of the sentence.
I was partial to the unnamed Democrat above who denounced the “abomination” of Biden’s decision but “publicly defended Biden,” or the “top Democrat who called the White House and said, “Every day I’m defending this guy… Someone tell me he’s okay. Like, it doesn’t look great.” If it doesn’t look great, why are you defending him? The same person snitches out Biden aides Anita Dunn, Jeff Zients, and Mike Donilon for not being straight about Biden’s condition, but that person was doing the same thing to the public (and in a sense still is by staying anonymous). It’s all good because they’re talking to each other, not Actual People, or Republicans, or other inconsequential humans. As Megyn Kelly and others noted, the book blows off the conservative media figures who were on Biden’s problems from the jump and absolutely should take that omission as an insult. Still, it’s more indicative of how this book’s sources think, or more where they think; on a different plane, somewhere above.
Meanwhile the authors never address the monstrous ethical/legal issues that should be at issue in a book whose apparent revelations are about Biden’s incapacity being more extensive than known. Who was making decisions in that case, not just about who should be Run Against Trump (all these people seem to care about), but everything?
Obama is so ubiquitous and so ferociously tongue-bathed in Original Sin that I found myself wondering at that as an alternate narrative. What if the submarining of the primary to guarantee Zombie Joe’s re-nomination was Obama’s idea (it’s put more on “leaders of the Democratic Party” in the book), or the scheme to oust Biden was Obama’s idea and Biden unexpectedly stuck them with Harris, or it’s a combination of that and more and this is a P.R. offensive to get in front of some brave Democrat thinking about spilling? Tapper right now is getting toasted by everyone from Jon Stewart to Hunter Biden for saying things like, “I do not accept that I was part of a cover-up,” but I almost feel like that’s too serious a criticism for a book like this. People should more find it funny, for its sheer irrelevance and circle-jerkness. Is it wrong to be entertained, or is that the least this kind of media can do for us?
Racket just published an essay called “Can ‘Abundance’ Top the ‘Culture-Warrior-in-Chief?’” by friend David Sirota, whom I’ve known for two decades. I met Bernie Sanders through David, watched as he was set upon by press jackals for absurd reasons, and have been amazed at how much hard reporting his site, The Lever, puts out on a regular basis. (David also wrote an underappreciated and entertaining book about the politics of 80’s movies called Back to Our Future). Without talking out of school, I believe the Democratic Party establishment that’s given him such a hard time over the years would probably still be occupying the White House if it followed his general thinking, which was to tack away from neoliberalism and toward a New Deal model focused on working-class issues.
His essay today, which we publish in the spirit of stepping out of our bubble, echoes some of those themes, but I feel a need to offer a gentle reply. For instance I don’t agree, about Donald Trump, that “sure, he embodies the rise of oligarchy.” The bulk of institutional America opposes him, he’s been outraised in all his presidential runs, and even the New York Times now concedes his base is concentrated in “working-class counties.” Oligarchy to me is a better description of the duopoly that squeezed out candidates like Sanders for so long.
I also think that to see Trump as a creator of culture-war controversies is to miss something key about his politics. The candidate I saw in 2016 was doing the same thing Sanders did, drawing huge crowds by speaking to existing frustrations about trade, war, bailout economics, the “rigged” insider politics symbolized by Hillary Clinton’s Wall Street fees, and more. But Trump the reality star did something Sanders couldn’t and apparently wouldn’t do, hunting the broader audience, people who lived in those busted ex-factory towns and in addition to the other slights felt powerless to impact loony academic trends, corrupt media, hectoring Hollywood. I know Sanders was aware of these issues because he talked about them. After Trump’s first election, Sanders noted that when Trump voters saw themselves depicted, it was always “a caricature, some idiot. Or maybe some criminal, some white working class guy who has just stabbed three people…” The rage was there already, Trump didn’t invent it. He just had an ear for it, while Democrats refused to listen even to legitimate complaints without condescension, a tendency which has now cost them two elections.
I agree Democrats need to stop getting their political ideas from Davos and Ezra Klein, but I’m not sure the urgency is in “swinging disillusioned voters away from the authoritarian right.” I believe ending the culture war starts with respecting the choices of those voters and dealing with them as legitimate. I remember after 2016 when Sanders, whose rhetoric was often eerily similar to Trump’s (“Look at products like the iPhone, the X Box. These are American inventions, but they’re not even made in America anymore”), talked about giving Trump a chance, offering to work with him on legislation, etc. He framed it as “we will see to what degree there was any honesty in what he was saying” about, for instance, “draining the swamp.”
What happened there? If the populist wing of Democrats who Sanders and AOC ostensibly represent could stop calling Trump names and offer to work on areas of agreement, like for instance tearing down trade deals they dislike, it would have the twin benefit of terrifying Chuck Schumer/Davos Democrats and creating leverage to urge Trump back from various constitutional ledges. I know David’s essay is meant to imagine a new long-term political approach, but reading it I couldn’t help but feel that just offering to build that factional bridge would incentivize everyone to behave better, open eyes all around, and turn the gain down on worsening culture war madness.
Or maybe not. Either way, thanks to David for his piece, which offers food for thought.
David Sirota is the founder and editor in chief of the investigative news outlet The Lever. Subscribe to The Lever’s free newsletter here.
President Donald Trump is often perceived as an ideological paradox — at once populist and plutocratic, pro-working-class and anti-labor, pro-growth and anti-trade, maverick conservative and Old Guard Republican. But for all of what looks like impulsive zig-zagging, there is a consistent throughline: He’s always focused on finding, spotlighting, and exacerbating the country’s most divisive cultural flashpoints.
So far, the strategy is working. Polls show Trump is historically unpopular, but still more popular than his Democratic opponents. Democrats have spent Trump’s first 100 days following the advice of the Clinton clan’s political strategist James Carville, who instructed them to “embark on the most daring political maneuver in the history of our party: roll over and play dead.”
When Democrats have woken up, they’ve toggled between berating their enraged rank-and-file voters, purging critics from their party, eschewing blame for the 2024 campaign — and now invoking TED Talk buzzwords like “abundance” to repackage their tepid agenda that keeps losing elections.
As the economy burns, the opposition party still seems unable to formulate a response to the central question of this moment: How do they combat a GOP leader with a different political formula than past Republicans — a president who sees the culture war not as secondary skirmish to entertain a rabid conservative base but as the central unifying cause animating his government?
Can an opposition to MAGA fight and win a different kind of culture war?
A Different Kind Of Republican
The first step toward an answer is understanding what Trump represents. Sure, he embodies the rise of oligarchy, the end of civility, the spread of misinformation, the normalization of corruption, the electoral irrelevance of job experience, and the embrace of pathological dishonesty.
But at his core, he’s more than the sum of those parts. Above all else, this Roy Cohn mentee who cut his political teeth enflaming the Central Park Five brouhaha personifies the new supremacy of cultural conflict.
Consider Trump’s executive orders, which are the most unvarnished declarations of presidential priorities. Trump’s edicts are a smorgasbord of culture-war virtue signaling positioning him as the brave warrior defending America against the bogeymen haunting conservatives’ nightmares — what the White House depicts as biased media snobs, non-English speakers, anti-Christian apostates, trans athletes, radical environmentalists, academic elites, crime-ridden cities, uppity minorities, woke language police, and scary criminal aliens stealing America’s wealth.
Whatever archetype you see in Trump — a Bonfire of the Vanities villain? The Joker? Bulworth? — he clearly views cultural inflammation as a feature of his political program, not a bug.
The incendiary language in his orders betray their real mission: They tout “beautiful clean coal” (trolling the climate movement); deride the alleged “forced use of paper straws” (trolling enviros); lament “anti-Christian bias” (trolling secular liberals); and pledge to “prevent illegal aliens” from obtaining benefits and to “repel invasions” from the southern border (trolling immigrants). There’s even one for a “Loyalty and Law Day, USA” to insinuate that MAGA critics are this generation’s flag-burning, America-hating hippies.
Trump’s devotion to the culture war explains why he’s always weighing in on the zeitgeist conflict of the moment, even if it has nothing to do with his job (most recently, he stomped into Major League Baseball’s oldest controversy and reframed it as a fable of the Persecuted White Guy). It also explains why his cabinet is teeming with Fox News personalities rather than subject-matter experts. These carnival barkers weren’t hired to run government bureaucracies, but to use federal agencies as media platforms for the news cycle’s cultural skirmish (Trump’s Fox News host-turned-Defense Secretary literally installed a makeup studio in the Pentagon).
Those conflicts are mostly manufactured by Trump, who designs them to not only crush dissent, but to also caricature his opponents as defenders of right-wing bugaboos and to focus the discourse on conservative grievances.
His threat to strip Harvard’s tax status aims to bait Democrats into defending Ivy League universities.
His crusade against diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives aims to lure Democrats into caricaturing themselves as annoying HR consultants.
His arrest of protesters and his deportations seem designed to help conservative media cast the left as overly focused on protecting allegedly undesirable (often non-white) dissenters rather than Middle America.
His blocking of most asylum seekers while boosting an influx of allegedly persecuted white South Africans who don’t like their home country’s post-apartheid government – it is yet another effort to stoke the mythology of white grievance and persecution.
Trump has so successfully stoked social conflict that he and his party are now creatively weaponizing the culture war for his donors’ class war. Indeed, Trump is right now defunding white-collar criminal prosecutions (from their already historically low levels) in the name of better funding his immigration crackdown, and congressional Republicans are using Medicaid cuts to fund a special new tax break for purchases of gun silencers.
In all of his machinations, Trump presumes that if 21st century politics is just a battle for attention, then an ever-more spectacular culture war can overwhelm Americans’ senses and distract us from the smell of our money burning up as GOP donors quietly feast on policy favors and the president enriches himself.
Democrats Never Miss An Opportunity To Miss An Opportunity
In prosperous economic times, Trump’s formula makes sense as a political gambit — when the vibes are good, betting on bread, circuses and Internet clicks is a decent wager in a social-media-addled society that forgets its entire world every 15 minutes under a flood of text messages, emails, spam calls, and TikTok videos.
But as the macroeconomy now contracts and fears of a recession intensify, it’s a dicier gamble — a bet that a White House-led, cable-news fueled filibuster of nonstop conversation about cultural conflagration will prevent anyone from noticing the potential economic calamities on the horizon.
It’s such a risky bet at this point that even some Republicans seem freaked out.
In recent weeks, GOP senators have tried to rescind Trump’s reckless tariffs, which threaten economy-wrecking shortages in the coming weeks — and which are projected to hit various red states particularly hard.
Now, some Republican lawmakers are also sounding the alarm about Trump’s “big beautiful” budget bill, which Congress’s own budget office projects to be one of history’s largest upward transfers of wealth in American history. At a moment when survey data show GOP voters want higher taxes on the wealthy, the legislation proposes to finance six-figure tax breaks for billionaires with Medicaid cuts that could eliminate health insurance for more than 7 million Americans — many of whom are in MAGA country.
“I don’t understand the argument that says, ‘Yes, congratulations working folks, you voted for Donald Trump, and now we’re going to take away your access to health insurance.’ It seems insane to me,” said Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.), who has called for his party to back off Medicaid cuts and to prioritize the child tax credit rather than high-income tax cuts. “We increasingly have an economy in this country that does not work for working-class people. And as Republicans, we need to do something about that… We need to preserve social insurance programs that they rely on — and pay into.”
MAGA icons like former Trump strategist Steve Bannon are making a similar case, creating GOP fissures for Democrats to exploit. But Democrats still haven’t capitalized because their dominant faction still wants nothing to fundamentally change. So far, their political strategy appears to be:
• Shrieking the word “democracy,” while crushing it inside their own party; reelecting their congressional leadership; and trying to conjure a “liberal Joe Rogan” by throwing cash at TikTokers and YouTubers.
• Voting for Trump’s nominees, courting Trump’s Silicon Valley cabal, and feigning ignorance about Biden’s cognitive impairment.
• Presenting Gotham supervillain (and Trump pal) Andrew Cuomo as a presidential contender; repackaging Chicago’s human personification of revolving-door corruption Rahm Emanuel as their party’s anti-corruption crusader; and trotting out former CIA analyst-turned-Bush White House official Elissa Slotkin to flip off Bernie Sanders and offer up some forced profanity and odes to patriotism — as if this is still the 2004 election with John Kerry reporting for duty.
Beyond circulating slide decks about the party’s message and holding lanyard conferences reviewing the party’s brand, this coterie of Democratic elites is now onto an allegedly new “Ezra Klein-pilled” policy agenda — one championing the billionaire-financed “abundance” movement amplified by the New York Times’ liberal whisperer in his book of the same name.
That movement essentially argues that environmental, city planning, clean air, and tech regulations pushed by an allegedly all-powerful American Left are the primary obstacle to prosperity. Recently, this faction demonized the idea of requiring real estate moguls to guarantee breathable air in their rental properties and pushed Republican congressional legislation preempting state limits on artificial intelligence, even when it is being used to fleece renters and deny medical claims.
In absolving robber barons from blame for this new Gilded Age, the supply-side messaging is exquisitely crafted for Democratic politicians, operatives, think tankers, and influencers whose careers have relied on finding an ever-narrower path between the demands of their big donors and the rage of their party’s voters.
Through “Abundance,” they are attempting to sell their party’s increasingly affluent (and shrinking) voter base on the plutocrat-approved idea that — rather than being a generational catastrophe — conservatives’ deregulatory assault on the New Deal hasn’t gone far enough.
Of course, that’s Trump’s own economic ideology and message — a reminder that corporate Democrats still believes they can compete with Trump by merely offering a more polite, stable, and culturally refined version of the boorish president.
This repackaged version of deregulation is the same election-losing algorithm Democrats used in the 2024 campaign and that they’ve been amplifying for a generation: On economics, it’s incrementalism, technocratic neoliberalism, and corporatism that placates donors; on culture, it’s identitarianism, social libertarianism, and lawn-sign liberalism that generates plenty of Internet memes for YouTubers and Instagram influencers — but so often alienates voters.
To be sure, refusing to adapt and playing dead could work for Democrats in the short term if things get bad enough. Maybe Trump will so decimate the economy that impoverished voters will briefly return Democrats to power out of total desperation.
But at that point, what’s left to govern?
Without a more direct and compelling challenge to Trumpism and its culture war, what will the next Democratic presidency be beyond another brief interregnum between MAGA governments?
There Is An Alternative
This dark future isn’t preordained. Time doesn’t have to be a flat circle. There is another nascent faction inside the Democrats’ coalition — one that offers a different path in this political multiverse.
You can see it in the huge crowds flocking to rallies headlined by Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, in the growing antitrust movement infiltrating the party, and in periodic labor uprisings across the country. You can also see it in the crop of new-generation populist challengers running for office, in longtime incumbents suddenly feeling the need to echo anti-establishment themes, and in the more honest discussions about the downsides of Democrats constantly avoiding economic populism.
“You get to what we call identity politics (which is) you’re Black you’re wonderful, you’re tremendous, you’re gay, you’re the greatest human being on Earth, rather than saying, ‘What do you stand for?’” Sanders said recently. “You’re gay, that’s fine, who cares … The issue is, what you stand for, which gets you back [to] class politics in the sense of which side are you on? Are you going to stand with working families?”
Though still inchoate and disorganized, this rag-tag alliance is built around a critique of concentrated corporate power and oligarchy. There, we find something that the donor-coddling Democratic political and media elite don’t want to admit: In an era that saw $79 trillion purloined from the bottom 90 percent of income earners over the last half century, the epochal problem isn’t a lack of abundance — it is that oligarchs are hoarding all of the abundance for themselves.
“You can’t make your rent because the guy that employs you is not paying you enough money,” said comedian Bill Burr recently in blunt language that most Democratic politicians still somehow can’t seem to muster. “There’s enough money, there’s enough food, there’s enough shelter for everybody — but these super rich [expletive] want too much for themselves and they are heartless.”
This is a truism that most Americans face in their daily lives. They see it in their credit card bills funding higher bank earnings, their rents fueling bigger landlord windfalls, and their health care premiums financing insurers’ profit margins.
That frustration makes the anti-oligarchy message a far stronger counter-argument to MAGA than Abundance Bros’ technocratic complaints about zoning regulations or #Resistance liberals’ paeans to democracy and identity. Moreover, unlike what Democratic leaders are offering, anti-oligarchy politics offers a direct contrast with Trump not just on economic matters — but on cultural terms.
Unlike the Big Tech-courting Abundance acolytes, anti-oligarchy is a challenge to the titans sitting in the front row of Trump’s inauguration. It’s a challenge that doesn’t just mock Trump-aligned moguls’ obscene wealth, but also makes a pro-family, anti-predator case against their business models that target kids, their surveillance pricing schemes that target your purchases, and their censorship crusades that target their critics.
Unlike Democrats’ Wall Street wing, this faction can indict Trump donors’ junk fees and price-gouging not just in inequality language for lefties, but also in culture-coded vernacular for normies. Anti-oligarchy Democrats can go to war with Trump’s private equity pals harming our elders, our hometown economies, and even our pets. They can attack the monopolies pricing us out of the hospitals we need, the communities we live in, the concerts we want to see, and the sporting events we want to attend (particularly critical for a party whose “bro” rhetoric tried to turn masculinity into a smear and now has a serious dude problem).
As important, anti-oligarchy offers a far clearer contrast for the electorate that sees Trump as merely a more honest — and more entertaining — version of both parties’ worst behavior.
To many disaffected independents, Trump doing favors for his Wall Street donors looks like Clinton, Bush and Obama doing the same; his foreign crypto scheme looks like the Clintons gorging on foreign cash and paid speeches; and his library accepting a $400 million Qatari plane looks like the 21st century version of the Clinton, Bush, and Obama library boondoggles. These voters no doubt see the Trump family grifting off the Washington swamp as merely a new reality TV episode whose previous seasons featured the Bidens and Pelosis.
Liberals are offended by Trump’s lack of manners in pulling off extreme versions of what their own party icons have done, but many Americans seem to cherish the Joker-like quality of Trump’s antics. They seem to appreciate that — unlike establishment Democrats — Trump at least doesn’t use a dog whistle to trick anyone. He uses a bullhorn to proudly broadcast and brag about his malfeasance — all while offering a captivating and distracting culture war along the way.
Swinging these disillusioned voters away from the authoritarian right is an imperative — not for saving the Democrats, but for saving the country. And yet right now, these voters are being offered only conservatives’ MAGA circus or liberals’ Davos cocktail party.
Something better is possible — particularly now as the economy teeters. But the working class will not be swayed by a Democratic Party more interested in creating a 21st-century version of Rockefeller Republicanism than in fighting the culture war.
It’s a war that Trump has spent his life fighting, but that can still be won — if a MAGA alternative channels the populist uprising in a different direction.
After a two-week hiatus, the Monday livestream of America This Week returned at 4:00 PM ET, Monday, instead of the previous campaign-inspired evening schedule. With Harvard University at the center of the news cycle, it’s a lucky accident Walter and I chose Graham Greene’s The Quiet American as our first novel to discuss.
Get more from Matt Taibbi in the Substack appAvailable for iOS and AndroidGet the appIn Chapter Two of The Quiet American narrator Thomas Fowler, like author Graham Greene a war-weary British journalist, watches in horror as young CIA agent Thomas Pyle orchestrates a disaster. Pyle has just arrived in Vietnam from Harvard and follows an anticommunist playbook in backing the dubious General Thé, who blows up a street full of women and children instead of soldiers:
“He said, ‘Thé wouldn’t have done this. I’m sure he wouldn’t. Somebody deceived him. The Communists…’
He was impregnably armoured by his good intentions and his ignorance. I left him standing in the square and went on up the rue Catinat to where the hideous pink Cathedral blocked the way.
The Quiet American, Graham Greene’s fifteenth novel, was published in 1955. The novel is equal parts epitaph for Britain’s empire, love story, battlefield diary, and spy thriller (a real-life MI6 agent, Greene wrote four or five of the best spy novels ever). What makes it so uncannily relevant to the present is his merciless dissection of Pyle and his “good intentions.” Perhaps without even intending it, Greene with his seething description of the meddling American “Economic Aid Mission” adviser published one of the first portraits of a figure destined to rule the world, the managerial expert.
A brilliant prose stylist whose extensive travels gave us exotic locales for novels set everywhere from the Caribbean to Africa to Asia to Central and South America, Greene in the first part of The Quiet American spends more time on sour grapes than politics. Fowler, Greene’s aging, opium-smoking English narrator, is in love with a 20-year-old Vietnamese beauty named Phuong (which, he says, “means Phoenix, but nothing nowadays… rises from its ashes”). With the prescience of all inadequate lovers, Fowler knew the virile-if-moronic, sober, hygiene-obsessed Pyle would spot Phuong and take Fowler’s place with her the way America was then taking Britain’s place everywhere. True, Pyle had no game at all, romancing Phuong with lectures on America and the promise of Democracy while his ideas about sex seemed to come from a book called The Physiology of Marriage. Still, Pyle had the one thing Fowler never would again: power, of both the political and sexual kind.
Fowler urges Phuong to get Pyle on the opium pipe to help even the odds, but probably knowing that will fail, tries to console himself with a truism. “A man’s sexual capacity might be injured by smoking,” Fowler writes, “but [the Vietnamese] would always prefer a faithful to a potent lover.” Of course it doesn’t turn out that way, especially once Pyle promises to marry Phuong, elevating Fowler’s resentment and desperation to new levels. Will he have to kill for love in the end?
Fowler’s portrait of Pyle starts out as a humdrum compound of jealousy and Oxonian snobbery — he hates Pyle because he’s a winner and his idea of a good book is The Advance of Red China — but in his callow Euro resentment discovers the real danger of America. Pyle is an overgrown schoolboy whose belief in American know-how and can-do spirit runs deeper and is more full of absurd religious certitude than the British royalists who circled the world murdering for King and country. Greene knew the executors of European colonialism were raised from university age to be rakes and buggerers who knew more poetry than policy, which created its own set of problems but at least immunized them from the most dangerous disease of all: moral confidence. “God save us always,” Fowler says, “from the innocent and good.”
Greene reportedly spent two years in Vietnam beginning in 1951 and parts of several others before publishing in the mid-fifties. The Quiet American predicted twenty years of mayhem, death, and cultural upheaval and in 1975, when it was “all over but the writing,” American Herbert Mitgang went looking for Greene’s inspiration in what was still Saigon. He spoke to retired General Edward Lansdale, a longtime intelligence presence and “adviser on matters of pacification” who was rumored to be Greene’s model for Pyle. “I used to see Greene sitting around the Rue Catinat,” Lansdale said. “I had the feeling that Greene was anti‐American.”
He was right about that. Americans in Greene’s novels are universally savaged as blundering nitwits, from The Presidential Candidate in The Comedians who thinks he can end Haitian violence through vegetarianism to the CIA man in Travels With My Aunt who records how much time he spends urinating per day in a journal. Greene served in MI6 as a deputy under infamous double-agent Kim Philby, and like Philby, flirted with Communism in youth, and repeatedly rationalized Philby’s treason late in life. “Who among us has not committed treason to something or someone more important than a country?” he wrote, in an introduction to Philby’s memoir. Greene even wrote an unnervingly convincing novel (The Human Factor) about a British official so repulsed by America’s alliance with South African apartheid that he spied for the Russians.
In hindsight, even if Greene hated Americans for other reasons, he may have been giving the USAID-style managerial expert too much credit for “good intentions.” Nonetheless, The Quiet American nailed a new kind of world conqueror, one bursting with what Iggy Pop called “plans for everyone,” while simultaneously being too ignorant of everything outside of his American head — language, customs, local personalities — to competently run anything. Because this new character also lacked any capacity for self-doubt, he never knew when to withdraw and doubled down until he found himself blowing up women and children for the “greater good.” Maybe it’s coincidence, but we’ve never had more to fear from the Pyles of the world.
Walter and I will delve more into part one of The Quiet American at 4 pm ET today.
After a two-week hiatus, the Monday livestream of America This Week returns today at 4:00 PM ET, instead of the previous campaign-inspired evening schedule. With Harvard University at the center of the news cycle, it’s a lucky accident Walter and I chose Graham Greene’s The Quiet American as our first novel to discuss. The show will hit a few current events at the top before proceeding to the book’s first section. To access the show, click any of the links below, or watch on the Substack app:
Riverside
YouTube
Rumble
Twitter / X
As noted last week, we’re going to be experimenting with a format that will open the floor toward the end of the show, book-club style, for questions and discussion. If you want to take part, you have to access the show via the Riverside link above. If you just want to watch and listen as usual, the other links will work as before.
See you this afternoon, and apologies if we’re interrupting your holiday. Also, watch this space for a written preview of The Quiet American, to be published before the show.
America This Week will be back Monday after a two-week break. As before, there will be one live show on Monday, and one taped episode that comes out Friday morning. But there will be two changes.
First, the Monday live show will now be held at 4 p.m. Eastern Time. We’ll send out links for the episode Monday morning.
We added an evening show on Mondays with a Mystery Science Theater motif last year with the aim of summing up developments in a historic presidential race. The idea was to have live sarcastic look-ins at mainstream campaign coverage, and live commentary during or after events like debates. Two factors conspire to undermine that format. One, the mainstream press died. Second, the campaign ended. So we’re moving the time and tweaking the format.
Second: I saw speculation that we’re eliminating the short story discussions. In fact, we’re expanding to novels. The first entry will be Graham Greene’s The Quiet American, which we’ll cover in parts (a book of that length might take two weeks, or four segments). It’s asking more of ATW audiences, but each segment will include recaps, and we’re going to try opening the floor at the end, like a book club. We’ve had so much fun talking about stories, and I wanted to find a way to include great books Walter and I reference often, from Catch-22 to 1984 to Slaughterhouse-Five and beyond.
I apologize to readers for the long hiatus. Talking to my friend Walter Kirn twice a week is one of the few things that keeps me sane, and I know that for some listeners, tuning in offers a similar reprieve. The interruption is all on me, down to a story that came up suddenly that sent me on the road and made it impossible to re-start today. But we’ll be back Monday at 4 p.m., with some new bells and whistles.
Have a good weekend, everyone.