
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


On my way out of town for a story yesterday, I read “My Brush With Trump’s Thought Police” in the New York Times. Nobel laureate and former World Bank chief economist Joseph Stiglitz described having his publicly funded lecture on “The Road to Freedom: Economics in a Good Society” canceled:
A core element of freedom is the ability of each person to live up to his or her potential. A liberal education is essential for this to happen, because it helps students develop their skills and capabilities to the utmost, frees them from shibboleths and enables them to think critically. But this kind of approach is threatening to authoritarianism, which wants to impose particular views on a nation’s citizens.
In the case of the Danish lecture series, simply discussing diversity, equity and inclusion was apparently deemed threatening to the administration, which asserts that those qualities, by their very nature, are discriminatory against a majority of the population. But Mr. Trump’s “1984”-ish thought police have not stopped at D.E.I. Climate change and gender are other terms that are being expunged.
I almost spit out coffee at the last line. Probably no three terms in the English language are more associated with groupthink-truisms or “shibboleths” than D.E.I., climate change, and gender.
We saw (and are still seeing) a generation of people be censored or lose jobs or careers for failure to properly salute those terms. Seemingly half now write on Substack. Matt Yglesias was bounced from a site he co-founded, Vox, because he was one of 150+ people to sign the Harper’s Letter on open debate alongside gender villains J.K. Rowling and Jesse Singal. Biologist Colin Wright, Canadian psychologist Kenneth Zucker, Princeton classics Professor Joshua Katz, the black former DEI director for De Anza Community College Tabia Lee, data scientist David Shor (fired for tweeting a study questioning the efficacy of violent protest), and countless academics forced to write “diversity statements” (the most potent and outrageous symbol of the mandated-thought era) only begin the list of other casualties. You could fill a congressional district with people punished for lack of fealty to DEI and gender “shibboleths.”
As for climate change, see the punchline below. It’s incredible that the New York Times would have the gall to talk about someone else acting as climate change “thought police.”
The Denmark lecture episode, which as Stiglitz notes is news over there, is a textbook example of why the snowballing pile of Trump constitutional controversies is more complicated than is being let on. Some administration developments are genuinely terrifying. Kristi Noem saying habeas corpus is a “constitutional right that the president has to be able to remove people” was legit pucker-inducing. Speaking of Denmark, Donald Trump probably shouldn’t be musing about seizing Greenland (even though, again, I can’t help find the level of trolling involved in sending J.D. Vance there funny). Trump and Marco Rubio should probably compare notes before giving contradictory answers about who is and isn’t entitled to due process. On the other hand, some of the alleged “attacks on free speech” turn out upon closer inspection to mean the opposite of what’s been represented, as in this case:
Subscribe now
I once admired Joseph Stiglitz as someone who spoke with unusual candor for someone occupying lofty institutional roles. As a young reporter in Moscow in the nineties I was shocked by the I.M.F. and his World Bank, which to my novice eyes seemed to be pursuing disastrous policies, plunging Russia into debt while enriching a handful of gangster-oligarchs to act as a bulwark against Communism. Stiglitz showed guts in also publicly calling out these neoliberal policies as short-sighted, while correctly warning about blowback. I think he means what he says, which is what makes this depressing. We’ve been in a monocultural boil for so long, even some more independent thinkers can’t feel the heat anymore.
If Stiglitz thinks cutting federal funding for DEI and “gender ideology extremism” represents the “erosion of American democracy,” I have to conclude he doesn’t know the definition of either democracy or “shibboleth.”
This country was long forced to worship a list of sacred cows (about race, gender, climate, equity, and so on) before getting fed up and voting to slaughter them. The effort to “impose particular views,” as Stiglitz puts it, isn’t happening now. That was done over a decade of constant budgetary initiatives, with nary a peep from media, leaving most of bureaucratic America choked with mandatory thinking at every level. That was the outrageous free speech violation, not this (admittedly clumsy) effort to cut its funding. It’s the difference between feeding sacred cows and slaughtering them. America isn’t a theocracy. We can’t have sacred cows. But something like a religion still runs deep, thanks to a generation of propaganda.
In the last Trump presidency the Times ran a piece called “The Ignorant Do Not Have a Right to an Audience.” It quoted Herbert Marcuse’s infamous screed against the “Tyranny of the Majority,” warning of a world where “the stupid opinion is treated with the same respect as the intelligent one.” The author, a professor named Bryan Van Norden, pooh-poohed John Stuart Mill’s notion that dismissing some ideas as valueless “is to assume our own infallibility.” After all, with certain issues, aren’t we infallible? Can’t we be sure Ann Coulter has radically wrong ideas about immigration and a “D-list actor” like Jenny McCarthy is wrong to criticize “actual scientists” about vaccines? One passage was wild:
Jordan Peterson, a professor of psychology at the University of Toronto, has complained that men can’t “control crazy women” because men “have absolutely no respect” for someone they cannot physically fight. Does this adolescent opinion deserve as much of an audience as the nuanced thoughts of Kate Manne, a professor of philosophy at Cornell University, about the role of “himpathy” in supporting misogyny?
I’m not sure I agree with Jordan on that one, but the idea that converations have become less civil because there’s less threat of getting punched (whether due to gender or the other speaker is online and named Spelunk94) isn’t completely crazy. More important was the choice of Peterson in general. He’d recently been cut from YouTube for criticizing Canada’s C-16 bill, which mandated adherence to new gender theologies. His employer, the University of Toronto, warned that failure to adhere to its guidelines (including the respecting of pronouns) wouldn’t be tolerated, and he was denied a federal grant shortly after. Unlike Trump, the Canadian government didn’t blab about reasons for the denial. They just did it, saying “past funding is not a guarantee of further funding.” Whether abroad or under prior regimes, other politicians are much more clever than Trump about how they chill speech, one of two reasons that faction still scares me more.
As for “Himpathy,” the Times ran a piece by progenitor and professor Kate Manne called “Brett Kavanaugh and America’s ‘Himpathy’ Reckoning” (the Times was big on “reckonings” for a long while). Manne defined himpathy as “the inappropriate or outsize sympathy extended to male perpetrators of misogyny and sexual violence over their female victims, who are often erased in the process.” In essence, himpathy is the crime of extending too much leeway to the accused. Manne wrote:
The real problem is that the people Mr. Trump feels with and for are most frequently powerful men who have been credibly accused of serious crimes and wrongdoing… In the case of Judge Kavanaugh, Mr. Trump feels sorry for a man accused of sexual assault while erasing and dismissing the perspective of his female accusers.
I believe sexual assault accusations need to be fully investigated. Still, we consider people innocent until proven guilty for a reason. The Kavanaugh case was not a Bill Cosby or Harvey Weinstein situation. It was a fraught, emotional charge based on old accounts, and he ended up being confirmed precisely because accusers went out of their way to avoid “himpathy.” Kavanaugh’s second accuser recanted and his third, Julie Swetnick, told a story on NBC so wild (Kavanaugh spiked drinks so girls could be “gang raped” by a “train of boys”) that it made even some Democratic Senators skeptical. The whole affair ended up in legal, journalistic, and political scandal, demonstrating why presumption of innocence is necessary.
The Times in other words told us Jordan Peterson, who I believe was right to criticize the state for trying to impose controversial (well, wrong) ideas about biology on the country, is ignorant and doesn’t deserve audience, but the concept of affording the accused less than full presumption of innocence does. This leads to the second reason the other crew is still more frightening than Trump. Instead of blundering over the First Amendment en route to deporting immigrants or trolling the AP, what the sidelined political establishment was after, for years, was very concept of free speech or multiplicity of opinion.
In a few cases the Biden Administration’s flouting of the First Amendment was at least superficially utilitarian (as in the pressure on platforms to decrease vaccine resistance), but in a broader sense both the “anti-disinformation” movement and the related “moral clarity” concept in journalism were about the idea that in many cases one reality is so obvious that other opinions or contentions don’t need air. That’s what Wesley Lowery meant in another Times reckoning, “A Reckoning Over Objectivity, Led by Black Journalists,” an early jeremiad against what we used to call objectivity.
Lowery made his case in part by quoting journalist Alex Jones of Harvard’s Shorenstein Center, incidentally a major player in the “anti-disinformation” complex. Shorenstein director Joan Donovan was the intellectual standard-bearer for “deplatforming is working,” the idea that cheered everything from the removal of Trump from platforms to deamplification or removal of Alex Jones, Glenn Beck, and Canada’s The Blaze to social media to the takedown of 70,000 Twitter accounts “associated with QAnon.” (Again, people forget how extreme this all got.) In any case, Harvard’s Jones wanted to redefine objectivity to eliminate “letting advocates pretend in your journalism that there is a debate about the facts when the weight of truth is clear.”
Lowery went on to explain he’d been on a crusade to get newsrooms to “abandon the appearance of objectivity” in favor of “being fair and telling the truth,” as best you can. Lowery noted, this describes the subjective “Gonzo” style, which ironically is what I grew up under and was the default mode at Rolling Stone, where Hunter Thompson invented the idea.
But you can’t have Gonzo news sections! People have to at least see other sides, other points of view. Until about ten minutes ago, we were told over and over that could no longer be the standard. There were too many areas in which One Truth was obvious. Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Mass Communication did a study whose results came out in 2023, saying “truth-seeking news media must move beyond whatever ‘objectivity’ once meant.” Former San Francisco Chronicle Emilio Garcia-Cruz, who famously said “objectivity has got to go,” advocated a form of coverage by consensus, according to the Washington Post:
Garcia-Ruiz is among a vanguard of print, broadcast and digital news leaders who have increased their newsrooms’ diversity and created new avenues of communication among their reporters and editors to discuss issues and coverage. Some have assembled affinity groups or caucuses of staff members — for women, Blacks, Latinos, Asian Americans and LGBTQ+ people — and involved them in newsroom decisions.
This weird zone in which colleagues now had a say in whether or not your coverage was politically acceptable took hold everywhere and was a big reason, again, that people like Glenn Greenwald, Lee Fang, and Yglesias ended up on Substack and other alternative channels. The press in a short time became a vehicle for policing the aforementioned sacred cows. When the Wall Street Journal dared to print a group letter signed by 16 prominent scientists questioning some presumptions of climate science back in 2012, the Times, Forbes, ThinkProgress, the Union of Concerned Scientists and others bound into action to denounce the paper, in an early example of immune-response reporting. Ten years later, academics who violated “shibboleths” were lucky to speak at all, or keep their jobs.
Some of the academics said things that seemed offensive. University of Central Florida Professor Charles Negy reacted to the George Floyd killing by saying “Black privilege is real: Besides affirm. action, special scholarships and other set asides, being shielded from legitimate criticism is a privilege.” Tenured professor Amy Wax at UPenn was sanctioned for saying, among other things, “I don’t think I’ve ever seen a black student graduate in the top quarter of the class, and rarely, rarely, in the top half.” Concordia College professor Dr. Gregory Schultz was suspended for complaining school officials, in searching for a new leader, had “been publicly announcing their determination to have a president who exhibits a ‘demonstrated belief in and commitment to equity and inclusion.’” In 2023-2024 there began to be demands that professors be fired for pushing material in the other direction, but the bulk of suspensions, sanctions, and especially rejected grants came when academics violated sacred cows and objected to having, for instance, DEI officers in science departments or mandatory diversity statements.
There’s a view out there, increasingly popular with liberal-ish intellectuals, that Donald Trump’s election means “woke” lost or “anti-woke has conquered woke,” as New York’s Ross Barkan (a writer I like) put it. With respect, this totally misunderstands the scale of what we have lived through and still are living through, since the election hardened far more minds in realms like academia than it changed. Whatever “woke” is (I hate the word), it’s been at most a niche concern that got press because it was so absurd (Beethoven is racist! We need rainbow pedestrian crossings!). The idea that because most cancelings are on hold because the White House might withhold funds means the upper class cultural revolution is over is myopic. The real damage was done through all those years of indoctrination, leaving us with an intellectual class that increasingly resembled a Mullah State, with doctrinal ideas about race, gender, climate, equity, and a dozen other things.
In some ways we’re in the best possible situation. Trump is heavy-handed enough that efforts to establish, say, permanent “viewpoint diversity” committees will probably be challenged and fail. But cutting the cord on funding for DEI or gender and “misinformation” research has to be allowed to take place. Stiglitz himself has long recognized the dangers of the academy and the state being too intermingled. He worried about the academy becoming dependent and vulnerable to being cut off, but it should worry about that exact situation. When people vote to end ideological subsidies, that isn’t an “erosion of democracy,” as he says. That is democracy, and if even courts say otherwise, they’ve got it wrong.
Political homelessness isn't the worst thing
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 05/19/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
A major antitrust trial takes an "ancillary" detour to a chilling tour of online life
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 05/16/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Warren Buffett announced this month that he will retire from his position as CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, the fabled corporate conglomerate that made him a revered household name, at the end of 2025. Along with a mostly stellar seven-decade investment career, he carefully created an image of a down to earth midwesterner who lives in a modest home, drives a modest car and dines on Dairy Queen (he liked DQ so much he bought the company in 1997) while swigging Coca Cola (another great Berkshire investment) and dispensing sage advise the way your favorite uncle might.
I have a six degrees of separation story where I sort of crossed paths with him. In fact, I can say that I played a small part in Buffett’s dumping of one of his favorite and most profitable trades, Freddie Mac.
Racket News is supported by readers. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Up until 2000, Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway owned a big piece of Freddie Mac (he first purchased Freddie stock in 1988), and it was one of Berkshire’s top performers. Buffett has always loved insurance companies, especially ones that generate lots of float (getting cash that you may or may not have to pay out later). That is what Freddie Mac, along with its “rival” Fannie Mae, had in spades. The government-sponsored enterprises had a duopoly on insuring the credit on trillions of American single and multi-family mortgages.
The events that caused Buffett to sell his entire stake in Freddie Mac took place in 1999, right about the time that I arrived at Freddie Mac as the risk manager of one of its divisions.
In February 1999 I was called into a meeting, a top-secret one! Freddie Mac had been sore forever that it was never able to catch up to its big sister Fannie Mae and get a 50% share of the mortgage insurance business. The split always toggled between 55-45 and 60-40 in Fannie’s favor. Freddie had tried many different schemes to achieve parity, and all had failed. Now it was time to go with the nuclear option, kind of like when the Soviet Union put nukes in Cuba.
Freddie made a deal with mortgage giant Wells Fargo. The bank agreed to let Freddie securitize all Wells Fargo loans for two years.
Freddie was confident the deal would allow it to catch up to Fannie Mae. Freddie was also confident that Fannie Mae would just passively accept it.
My small role in this scheme was to approve a massive new three-month credit risk line for Wells. Honestly, the risk that Wells Fargo would go belly up with no warning in any three-month period wasn’t really an issue, so I said sure and signed off.
In the eyes of Freddie, it was a great deal for both sides. Freddie would capture the elusive market share it desired and Wells would be able to insure loans at a cheaper rate, which meant higher profits.
Freddie also made deals with other banks. Wells got the biggest discount, but all were paying less than they were before to insure loans.
Unfortunately, within about a week, Fannie burst Freddie’s parity fantasy by signing up giants like Countrywide, also for much lower insurance rates, and with that, the race to the bottom of mortgage credit insurance was on! Actually, I would say that this was the first event in what would eventually become the Financial Crisis of 2008.
Warren Buffett took one look at this insanity of a duopoly engaging in a bitter price war and sold his entire stake in Freddie Mac. Interestingly, Berkshire was also a big investor in Wells Fargo, so Buffett got to see both sides of this strategy and chose correctly to go with the recipient of Freddie’s largesse, Wells.
However, my man-crush on Buffett ended in 2008.
One additional trait that many found endearing in Buffett was he could be very candid about his occasional losses and mistakes. He would often use these instances to impart some really great advice. However, the one thing I never heard him discuss was the times he should have lost but got the kind of help regular folks don’t get.
Buffett’s long-time business partner, Charlie Munger, once said “Suck it in and cope, buddy” in response to complaints that the government did more to help Wall Street than homeowners during the 2000’s housing crisis.
The truth is, Buffett, Munger and Berkshire would have had to do a lot of sucking themselves if not for the massive government bailout of the financial system in 2008.
This part of the story started between 2003 and 2004. Berkshire made huge option bets that four major global stock indices — the S&P 500, the Nikkei 225, the Euro Stoxx 50 and the FTSE 100 — would not end up lower than they were at the time of the trade, 10 or 15 years in the future. Berkshire sold these options to major Wall Street banks and in return, the banks paid Berkshire approximately $4.9 billion in what are called premiums. If the stock indices ended lower than their current levels, Berkshire would pay the banks the difference and, if necessary, more than the $4.9 billion it was paid.
In turn, if the indices ended at or higher than current levels, Berkshire would get to keep all the money.
Normally, companies that sell these types of long-term options have to put up collateral. Berkshire did not. With Buffet at the helm, Berkshire was considered riskless. This was the key to the strategy. Berkshire could use the $4.9 billion however it wanted without having to tie up any of Berkshire’s other assets.
As long as nothing went horribly wrong, this was a genius move. Buffett would just do his usual brilliant investing with the funds and even if the stock indices ended somewhat lower when the deals expired a decade or two later, the money he would have to pay on the options would probably pale in comparison to the money he would have made with those billions in premiums he received.
Again, unless something went horribly wrong.
In 2008, global equity markets finally woke up to the fact that the subprime mortgage crisis was a giant asteroid hurtling straight for the global financial system and began to free-fall.
At first it appeared Buffett saw what was happening as a great opportunity. One of his famous folksy quotes after all was:
“A simple rule dictates my buying: Be fearful when others are greedy, and be greedy when others are fearful.”
In September of 2008, with Goldman Sachs taking on water with the rest of their Wall Street brethren, Berkshire invested $5 billion in perpetual preferred stock with Goldman. Berkshire would receive a 10% dividend as well as the right to buy $5 billion of common stock at $115 with a five-year term. On the day of the purchase, September 23, 2008, Goldman’s stock was at $125.05. Perhaps Buffett believed Goldman was already saved after AIG was bailed out the previous week. As long as Goldman survived, this could be one of the best returns Berkshire ever made.
However, despite the immediate bailout measures taken to save Goldman and the rest, the hits just kept coming with big banks like Citigroup, Bank of America, Wachovia and WaMu (which went into receivership two days later) on the ropes.
On October 10, 2008, Goldman Sachs’ stock closed at $88.80, down 29% from where Buffett made his Goldman investment just two weeks prior. Moreover, those options Berkshire sold on the four global stock indices, made a few years earlier were going against Berkshire as global stocks cratered.
Everyone needed a bailout, including Berkshire.
Interestingly, a few years after the crisis, CNBC wrote a piece, replete with the customary Andrew Sorkin boot-licking interview.
In October 2008, in the midst of the financial crisis, Berkshire Hathaway CEO Warren Buffett made a late-night phone call to then-Treasury Secretary Henry “Hank” Paulson, with an idea about how the government might be able to turn the economy around.
Paulson was asleep. He’d had a busy night working through various policy ideas with his team to restore confidence in Wall Street.
At the time, Congress had just passed the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act, or the “bailout bill” as it came to be known, and created a $700 billion Troubled Assets Relief Program to purchase assets of failing banks. But these actions were not enough to calm investors
Once he understood what was going on, Paulson says, he listened as Buffett “laid out an idea which was a germ of what we did.”
What he told Paulson, Buffett recalls, is that, “It might make more sense to put more capital in the banks than it would to try and buy these assets.”
Perhaps the CNBC piece should have been called How Warren Buffett Saved Himself During the Financial Crisis.
Remember, just a few weeks before Buffett’s phone call to Paulson, Buffett had put capital into Goldman and now he was losing his ass. The government putting capital into Goldman and the rest of the major banks, at the time, would save him.
Naturally, in a government bailout led by a former CEO of Goldman Sachs, Hank Paulson, the U.S. never exacted the price it should have for saving Goldman and the rest of the major Wall Street banks. In a fair world, the government bailout would have come with major strings attached.
Instead the government, aided by the Federal Reserve, saved the likes of Goldman and Morgan Stanley by giving them federal bank charters, life-saving capital and bailing out AIG. The bailout recipients then profited handsomely in the aftermath due to the Federal Reserve’s unprecedented emergency policies such as zero interest rate policy and the massive buying of U.S. Treasury securities and agency mortgage-backed securities, which the Federal Reserve kept until 2018.
Those bailed out then thanked the government for saving them by giving them back their capital. Incredibly, a Goldman Sachs story on its website says “…the firm had neither sought nor expected such an infusion of capital from the Treasury.” If you need further proof of how laughable this statement is, check out this email from a Federal Reserve Bank of New York official one day before Goldman was given a bank charter.
Berkshire’s large bets on Goldman and the four major global equity indices were also saved and they also ended up richer after the crisis than before.
Meanwhile, the average American was left to “suck it in,” cope and reflect on how greedy and silly they had been buying homes they couldn’t afford.
Warren Buffett was a brilliant investor and a very wise and interesting man. However, in 2008 the “Oracle of Omaha” moniker did not fit. He was just another guy who didn’t quite see just how big the bomb cyclone was that was coming right at him. He and Berkshire escaped financial ruin like all the other plutocrats by relying on Uncle Sam to come to their rescue.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
I’m having a Howard Beale moment. Mad as hell, can’t take it anymore.
The last few weeks of partisan squabbling first sent me into a depressed stupor, then I woke to a current of clarifying spleen. A voice explained: “It’s not your destiny to have friends. It’s your destiny to tell everyone, Republican and Democrat, male and female, what cunts they are.”
Cunts. Generally, taboo to say in America, but less so in England, where Tom Hardy says it once every 28.5 seconds on MobLand (co-star Paddy Considine made Dead Man’s Shoes a cult classic with one snarling use of the word). Americans call someone acting out a dick, a weak descriptor because you can fully picture it, while cunt is definitionally abstract, no one knows how deep it goes. It puts the imagination to work. No one wants to be called a cunt. But that’s what some people are.
Sorry, we were talking about politics. Recapping the last weeks:
Subscribe now
A little over a week ago, White House advisor Stephen Miller addressed reporters, explaining that “the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus can be suspended in a time of invasion.” As the administration considers the recent immigration influx an “invasion or rebellion,” the option of revoking habeas to speed deportations is “an option we’re considering at this time.”
Miller’s comments came on the heels of an Appeals Court Order in the case of Tufts University student Rümeysa Öztürk, who was released from ICE custody after being arrested and scheduled to be deported. Secretary of State Marco Rubio responded to a query about her by saying if the “reason why you’re coming to the United States is not just because you want to write op-eds” but to participate in “movements” that vandalize, harass students, and create a “ruckus,” your visa will be revoked. But the Order, among the first documents that described the government’s case, was really weak beer, considering how high-profile a move it was to forcibly remove a visa-holding Tufts student.
Öztürk was suspected of being “involved in associations that ‘may undermine U.S foreign policy by creating a hostile environment for Jewish students and indicating support for a designated terrorist organization’ including co-authoring an op-ed that found common cause with an organization that was later temporarily banned from campus.” That last part, about her affiliation with Tufts Students for Justice in Palestine, which was suspended ahead of last year’s Oct. 7th anniversary, complicates the picture a little, but only a little, especially when certain obvious comparisons are made that highlight the absurdity of her detention (more on that below).
It’s never good when an official describes a right as a “privilege.” Miller’s America First Legal foundation was the first to file FOIA suits against both the State Department’s Global Engagement Center and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency’s “Mis-, Dis-, and Malinformation” team. They filed before the Twitter Files (they were way ahead of the public) and the group’s results were a big factor in exposing a censorship bureaucracy. I remember running into a pair of their lawyers in an airport in early 2023 and being glad that someone with resources was pushing these questions, even if they seemed exclusively interested in censorship of conservatives. So what? People acting out of self-interest is generally how rights get protected, the age of Jewish liberal lawyers from the ACLU fighting tooth and nail to protect Nazi speech rights apparently being a thing of the past.
I can already hear Trump supporters explaining that suspending habeas corpus, the bar against improper detention and our oldest and most fundamental civilizational right, is necessary because we’re really in an emergency. I’m sure there are people who live in places where virtually unchecked immigration either seems like or on some level is an emergency, but after eight years of Democratic propaganda justifying the skirting of bedrock rules to drop anvils on them, conservatives should be able to smell the rancid sameness of an argument. When governments determined to take rights away explain themselves, it’s always an emergency. Covid was the classic magic bullet, sending the Bill of Rights on a three-year vacation (not just here; Human Rights Watch found at least 51 countries used it as a pretext to persecute resistance to pandemic policies). “Election claims” similarly were presented as such a boundless threat they justified sweeping suppression years after the fact. Trump supporters for eight years were blasted with facefuls of this shameless non-logic, but embraced it once the issue was deportation instead of extremism, Russia, germs or whatever.
Another trick seen repeatedly before 2025 was making a figure-with-high-negatives the face of new changes (Democrats used Alex Jones and Trump to introduce censorship), so cultural arguments become about the person, not the principle. Mahmoud Khalil was this year’s first entrant, with Öztürk close behind. The rhetorical bent of her now-famous op-ed, castigating Tufts president Sunil Kumar for seeking to un-tether the campus from official political statements, isn’t my cup of tea, but it doesn’t need to be.
How deeply in danger could America possibly be from the Öztürk subset of foreign suspect, meaning legal residents who haven’t committed crimes? How large could the population of such persons possibly be? Rubio talked about canceling 300 student visas. Is making a (failed) show of force against a handful of legal edge cases worth punting the entire civil liberties issue back to the Democratic Party? It’s the same with illegal immigration, the administration’s ostensible primary concern. Is a slow pace of deportations such an intolerable development that it’s worth musing about tearing up habeas corpus, a sound bite not even George Bush bothered to give his enemies (probably because he couldn’t pronounce it, but still)? I frequently disagree with Miller on policy, but never doubted his brains until I saw that habeas presser, where he came off like a guy who just finished blowing coke with Marc Elias.
I admit to not always understanding why people in the Trump administration do what they do, and this lack of understanding is often why I take extra time before weighing in on what they do, but to me this looks like a huge unforced error, unnecessary and dangerous.
As all this was going on, someone I know fairly well, filmmaker and podcaster Leighton Woodhouse, became roughly the 6,000th ex-sort-of friend to use me to triangulate their way to Internet higher ground. It could have been handled with a phone call, but then the world would have been deprived of “Matt Taibbi’s Willful Credulousness,” where it’s learned a “formerly dissident writer” is now a whore to MAGA and audience capture. There were many head-scratching passages, but I’ll focus on the one most representative of these pieces:
Matt has earned a reputation for being a free speech warrior. He spent the last four years exhaustively reporting on Biden’s online censorship regime. More than once, he testified before Congress about it. He was not only right to do so, but perhaps even brave… He also benefited from it, of course, building for himself a massive new audience of conservative readers and a lot of powerful allies in the Republican caucus. Those benefits were well-deserved… But they appear to come with strings attached… Things have changed quite a bit over the last few months, but Matt seems loath to admit it. Doing so would surely alienate a significant portion of his new readers and allies…
I’ve been covering digital censorship for six years, not four, starting in 2018. Until the Twitter Files in December 2022, I barely mentioned Joe Biden or the government and focused on platforms. In an apparently futile effort to get liberal reporters to care about the issue I mainly covered episodes involving figures on the left: Chris Hedges, Jordan Chariton, Canadian Real News founder Paul Jay, Mark Crispin Miller, the Democratic Socialists of America, the World Socialist Web Site, and many others.
Then there’s that “massive new audience of conservative readers.” How does Leighton know that? Did he do a reader survey? This charge is offered constantly, never with evidence, to the point where Hachette felt confident publishing a whole book called Owned about Glenn Greenwald and me whose cover reads, HOW TECH BILLIONAIRES ON THE RIGHT BOUGHT THE LOUDEST VOICES ON THE LEFT (bold language considering I never took money from any billionaires). Also on the cover? The same “strings” Leighton references, though in this case the implied puppeteers are Elon Musk and David Sacks instead of Jim Jordan:
The absence of actual payment from “tech billionaires” Higgins dealt with by asserting Glenn and I “sold out to conservative media” by moving to the “right-wing platform” Substack (where Higgins also publishes). There, “in one high-profile moment,” I squandered “decades of credibility” to do the Twitter Files story, after which I “cashed in” when my Substack “boomed because of the reporting and [Elon Musk’s] promotion on Twitter,” leading to “exploding” revenue.
None of this is right. It’s true I saw a bump in subscribers after the first Twitter Files story, lasting almost a month. After that, for the logical and inoffensive reason that the material came out on Twitter, the site lost subscribers for all of January and February of 2023. When Democrats went bananas on me in the House that March, readers returned. Then the thing with Elon happened. It’s uncanny how people who hold me up as a mercenary and grifter look past this moment, when I made a decision to say no to a volatile billionaire, knowing it would be costly (strange behavior for someone whose MO is “caping for the truly powerful”). I think Elon saw the Twitter Files as a way to build the platform as home to a new stable of high-profile “independent” journalists, so when I declined the offer to “post your articles to Twitter and enable our subscription service,” I was showing him up in ways I didn’t even know about. Still, he was pissed and I knew there’d be consequences. I’ll admit I didn’t grasp then the unique math of “consequences” on planet Elon, but the punchline is, that moment was the end of any “booming.”
Please don’t think I’m complaining, because that story was the thrill of a lifetime to work on, worth it a thousand times over. This site is also still doing fabulously better than my family and I could ever have expected. But to be clear, Racket grew 3000% in the two years before the Twitter Files, -6% the year after. We started growing again last year, but my “massive new audience” is still a net of less than 200 subscribers since that story’s end. And I don’t know if they’re conservative!
There are obviously many Trump supporters among the site’s readers, but anecdotally, it feels like our largest demographic is comprised of independents and disappointed liberals like me. I could be wrong, and I’m proud of our readers either way, but I don’t know. I mention it only because someone who’s sort of a friend and could have called and asked, instead threw out a sweeping claim just to make it possible to publicly call me a money-grubbing coward. If not for the other sort-of friends (plural) last week who asked me to plug their books (plural) while lecturing me on my moral failings vis-à-vis Trump, it would have been the most depressing thing to hit my in-box all month.
I’m often asked “What happened to you, man?” and laugh it off, but now I’d officially be lying if I didn’t admit to maybe being affected by overexposure to a certain kind of person. There are some dubious human categories I haven’t spent time around: child traffickers, makers of computer viruses, torturers, necrophiles, zoonecrophiles, I’m sure there are others. For my money though there’s no more shocking and shamelessly repulsive animal than the Righteous Progressive, particularly ones in media.
Summer, 2014. I’ve just left Rolling Stone to edit what was supposed to be the satirical sister publication to The Intercept. One night in our cavernous joint office near the Flatiron building I stay late and notice one of our first hires, someone highly recommended as a humorist by a Famous Hollywood Person, is hanging sink-washed t-shirts and unmentionables around his desk. He’s living in the office. At the sight of me, he nods and smiles, as in ‘Sup?
I do the math. Maybe the employee is flat-out and supporting two nieces with leukemia or something. Who knows? Of course, he’s put me in a spot. If I say something, he’s fired, but if I don’t, I could be. Not the nicest thing to do to someone who just gave you a cushy full-benefits job, but what throws me is an indefinable haughtiness in his expression, like he not only knows I won’t say anything, but has it worked out the situation is my fault somehow. Soon after I’m asked by corporate if I know about anyone living in the office. I wince and say no. Months after, in an apparent office coup, he works with a female employee to file a harassment complaint that includes this evidence of discrimination: upon hearing that a woman Alex Pareene and I wanted to hire chose Fox, I laughed and said, “Well, fuck her then.” I’m cleared, but told I can only stay if I give up my title and benefits. I pass. Mr. Office Laundry is still an employee. He was recently quoted in Owned, lamenting my rightward turn.
A few years later The Guardian ran a #MeToo piece comparing me to Harvey Weinstein and Bill Cosby based on one fictional book passage written by Mark Ames, timing it to the release of I Can’t Breathe. A slew of liberal publications piled on, claiming for instance that I’d “boasted of molesting teenagers.” I was quickly dumped by my publisher, losing most of my income as my third child arrived. I was so brainwashed that it took over a month before I asked: If they really think I’m a serial rapist, where’s the investigation? Neither employers nor accusing media bothered to question my female co-workers. When The Guardian’s Jessa Crispin was asked why she didn’t try to contact any of the alleged victims, she said, “I have not written about these accusations as a journalist.” (In what capacity did she write? As a cabbage?) I was forced to take at least one close friend to court and though my name was quietly tidied from these “Sexual Predator” stories, I still emerged a social leper, barred from every major publisher and agency, just in time for the first Trump presidency.
In fact I was already radioactive, but this is where Leighton says my unpopularity with liberal media began, with Russiagate, when I “took a fact-based and principled stand against the conspiracy theories that had infected the brains of half of Congress and nearly all of the establishment media.” Most of the “principle” was just caution, because stories about everything Trump-related were rushed and based on sourcing that obviously would not hold up. I was cautious in the other direction, too, not tearing into Russiagate until the Mueller report ended all suspense about Russian spying. Even after that fiasco ended, I had editors tell me Ukrainegate for sure meant “they’ve got him this time,” but I squirmed out of those assignments too because something felt off. Years later, that episode looks like it might have been more of a story in the opposite direction. Pretty much every single time, I was right to blow off those who (as Leighton put it) “badgered me endlessly to balance his criticisms of Democrats and the press with the occasional tirade against Trump.”
That was not because I liked Trump or even thought much about him, but because I didn’t see this as a normal electoral battle. Instead, I saw institutional elites unifying to rub out an irksome voter revolt. This was an extension of a disagreement I’d long had about campaign reporting. I’d covered races since 2004 and long before Trump arrived concluded the purpose of each agonizing two-year campaign of primaries, polls, debates, endorsements, Jefferson-Jackson dinners, scandals, and cable nerf-battles was to prevent establishment-unacceptable candidates (Ron Paul, Dennis Kucinich, etc.) from breaking through. The ritual the Daily Show called “Clusterf**k to the White House” was a PR snow job, designed to convince liberals opposing war was impractical and that organized labor didn’t need to support labor candidates, while conservatives were propagandized to stop wondering why their own politicians kept expanding government. The campaign press was like an immune system, there to badger to death anything off-message, even a gently antiwar run by Howard Dean.
The end goal of the show was to eliminate real politics and secure matchups like Folksy v. Wonky (Bush v. Gore), Yale v. Yale (Bush v. Kerry) or the media’s favorite, Kennedyesque v. Reaganesque (Any Democrat v. Any Republican). Races rarely saw substantive choice on that year’s chief issue (the 2004 election for instance let us pick between two Iraq War supporters). The reason I have such a long history of trashing both parties (my first book here was called Spanking the Donkey) is because I never saw them as antagonists, but as factions of the same establishment whole. They differed on minor issues while pledging continuity on major ones like war, NATO, the Fed, bailouts, criminal justice disparities, etc. Trump’s conquest of the GOP in 2016 in that sense was a major, unprecedented event (unprecedented since William Jennings Bryan anyway), when sheer voter irritation allowed democracy to overwhelm the “guardrails.” I misread Trump’s 2016 nomination, thinking he’d be blown out in a result that would shut the door on revolt. “In a two-party state, when one collapses, doesn’t that mean only one is left? And isn’t that a bad thing?” I wrote, adding:
Thirteen million and three hundred thousand Republican voters had defied the will of their party and soundly rejected hundred-million-dollar insider favorites like Jeb Bush to re-seize control of their own political destiny… It was a tremendous accomplishment that real-life conservative voters did what progressives could not quite do in the Democratic primaries. Republican voters penetrated the many layers of money and political connections and corporate media policing… designed to keep the riffraff from getting their mitts on the political process.
Trump was predicted. Pre-2016, American election satires almost always involved an unlikely deus ex machina like a plane crash (Head of State) botched suicide (Bulworth) or offhand prank (Man of the Year) lifting an incautious truth-telling outsider past the usual obstacles to expose a typical poll-guided establishment-mannequin-dipshit, like Nick Searcy’s McCain stand-in Brian Lewis in Head of State, who had only two things to say: “God bless America, and no place else,” and “I’m a war hero, and Sharon Stone’s cousin.” Squared off against this idiot, Chris Rock’s accidental nominee Mays Gilliam could point out: “You show me a grown man that’s never said shit and I’ll show you somebody that’s full of shit!” When Gilliam rose in the polls saying, “If America was a woman, she would be a big-tittied woman. Everybody loves a big-tittied woman!” the system fought back the only way it knows how: by cheating. MAYS GILLIAM, HE’S FOR CANCER was the campaign:
This plot came true with Trump, and establishment figures gave up any pretense of opposition and joined hands, We Are the World style, to sell a new matchup: All Decent People v. Hitler. That Hitler won was an epic burn, in hindsight one of the funniest things of all time. It was certainly a bigger laugh than those movies. As antagonists like Bill Kristol and Hillary Clinton or David Frum and David Corn or George Bush and Ellen DeGeneres came out as pals and backed epic cheating campaigns to excise Trump from public life, it became impossible not to sympathize with this target of lawfare, spying, and lying. HE’S FOR CANCER had nothing on the real-world ads about Trump:
I never saw Trump as a politician. He was a screeching shit-monster catapulted from hell at America’s Deserving Class. When he won last Election Night it was like watching Godzilla march through an Americanized Tokyo, squashing subway cars full of screaming MSNBC producers, stepping on the lawyers in smart glasses and Tumi bags running in terror from White & Case or Covington & Burling offices, then rearing back to send a fat blue streak of irradiated death through crowds of fleece-wearing male “allies,” Jen Psaki, and a vanishing, Japanesed Adam Schiff. Apparently now Trumpzilla’s off stomping on other things, from Harvard to Oprah to bar codes. I can absolutely think this is funny, and that most deserve this, without endorsing it.
Opponents and pundits endlessly compared Trump to Hitler but the real historical analog has always been Napoleon. Through insults to Popes and Kings he united every aristocratic faction in Europe to the point where after Waterloo, he was removed to an island in the middle of the ocean so he could no longer “disturb the peace of the world.” That was the world goal for Trump, whose similar crime was called “undermining the rules-based international order.” It’s mind-boggling how quickly “heterodox” thinkers have forgotten how ruthless, far-reaching, and authoritarian this campaign to remove the Trumpian tumor was and is. The clear endgame of speech-control laws in Europe and the aggressive moves to disqualify candidates in places like Romania and even France was to put a digital lid on nationalism and populism, and confine them to a cyber version of Napoleon’s last home on St. Helena.
I’m absolutely against throwing Öztürk in ICE detention over an op-ed, but similarly against using contempt of Congress to throw Peter Navarro and Steve Bannon in jail, a bullying tactic not used since McCarthy. I was against incarcerating hundreds of J6 protesters based on the same concept now offered by Rubio against visa-holders alleged to be harboring terroristic ideas, intent on a “ruckus.” The Bannon episode was upsetting because it was so clearly about shutting down a media voice for what Lincoln Project jackass Rick Wilson called “four vital months.” That was in addition to the five million indictments prosecutors dropped on Trump (after raiding his attorney’s office in a nod to the 6th Amendment), as well as the fact he was nearly assassinated and would likely be in jail if it were not for an election.
It’s my impression (in part through reporting) that the Trump White House feels itself in a fight for its life and is advertising its willingness to color outside constitutional lines to bring down its targets. That leaves us staring at a protracted battle between two powerful rule-breaking camps, an unprecedented situation and one I haven’t been sure how to think about. Apparently this hesitation is not genuine. Woodhouse and others who’ve raced back into the TDS camp are certain that though I was right to resist media pile-ons before, “that was then, and this is now,” because “if there’s a suffocating, hegemonic political monoculture today, it’s MAGA.”
MAGA is hegemonic? Really? Exactly the same people consider it exactly as disreputable (more, even). Google search runs in reverse now? Wikipedia bars mainstream sources? NPR isn’t still humming? Harvard isn’t still teaching “Sexual Life of Colonialism?” The unfairly accused have all received apologies? Shit Pulitzers have been given back and newspapers wrote ten billion corrections? When it’s all taken back we can talk. Trump’s in the White House, but his power base is still mostly all voters, and I’m not sure his people are wrong to think they’ve got maybe a year to smash big law, academia, the media, the DC nomenklatura, the EU, and everything else on their shit list before those entities send the hammer right back. They’re probably also right that if Trump fails, we’ll be back to where we were at the moment of the record scratch seven months ago, staring at a more organized and cynical effort at authoritarianism, with more sophisticated plans for higher “guardrails.”
That’s my personal opinion. I could be wrong, but it’s what I think. Or, it’s not what I think, but I owe Jim Jordan a favor and I’m trembling before a massive MAGA readership that a conga line of self-righteous not-at-all cunts apparently knows better than me. Ugh, fuck these people. Fuck them hard. Let’s just be straight with each other. Why does it need to be complicated?
There was no America This Week live show Monday night, and Walter and I didn’t tape one for today, either. We apologize, though this is entirely on me.
Beginning next week, we’re reconfiguring the show, likely beginning with a change of schedule. The Monday night livestream was introduced in response to mounting pre-election coverage. Those dynamics are different now. We’re likely to retain two episodes each week, but the focus and format will see changes, we think for the better. Those will be announced at the beginning of the week.
Again, apologies for multiple inconveniences in what has been a difficult week.
This week, the storied Boies Schiller law firm filed a motion alleging widespread wrongdoing on the part of Brookfield Asset Management, a private equity titan chaired by Canada’s new Prime Minister Mark Carney until a few months ago. The motion also named former deputy to Robert Mueller and federal prosecutor Andrew Weissmann, a longtime foe of Donald Trump’s and a target of the new “Weaponization Working Group” in Trump’s Justice Department.
Technically, this is just a business litigation about a privatized toll road in Peru. It’s become more than that. The case is now a key proxy conflict in the increasingly heated “lawfare” arena in which courts, police, and prosecutors are turned into political weaponry.
Prior to 2025, status quo figures openly praised lawfare tactics and embraced everything from politicized prosecutions to ballot-blocking campaigns on the grounds that extreme measures may be needed to “save democracy” from the likes of Trump. Lawfare in the context of Trump became a celebrated word, connoting “hard national security choices” an enlightened institutional vanguard might need to make to save us. When Trump failed to win re-election in 2020, “lawfare” was widely credited with saving the Republic:
In power, Trump has shifted his narrative on lawfare. On the campaign trail in the last two years, as he posed involuntarily for police sketches in his New York fraud trial and railed against what he called the “new legal system” of “weaponization,” he promised voters, “I am your retribution.” The theme was central to his run. In July of 2024, Trump operatives in Milwaukee held discussions that resulted in making a promise to “end the weaponization of government against the American people” a main element of his 15-page platform. They also loosely discussed what “ending weaponization” might look like in practice. One concept was nominating early interim officials who’d turn lawfare on its original practitioners, “wreak havoc,” and “piss off so many people they’d be unconfirmable,” before making way for nominees the Senate could countenance.
Months into Trump’s second term, it’s clear the mostly defensive approach his first administration employed has given way to a broad plan of attack encompassing large swaths of institutional America, from universities to the federal budget to the press to law firms (the Pentagon and the intelligence sector have been conspicuous exceptions). This has resulted in sharp condemnations not just from the press but politicians from both parties, with Republican Thom Tillis refusing to support the nomination of one of Trump’s most aggressive early appointees, interim U.S. Attorney in the District of Columbia Ed Martin, because of “concerns related to January 6th,” which Martin attended.
As soon as Martin was out as U.S. Attorney, he moved to a new office as the administration’s Pardon Attorney, also in charge of a “Weaponization Working Group” in the Justice Department, but upon arrival found himself under investigation by the District of Columbia’s Office of Disciplinary Counsel for alleged abuse of prosecutorial powers.
How one feels about any of this likely begins with how one views various cases and investigations. Were the 1,500 people imprisoned after January 6th terrorists, or political casualties? Was the movement to use the Insurrection Act to keep Trump off the ballot legitimate, or abusive? How about jailing people like Steve Bannon and Peter Navarro on contempt of Congress charges for the first time since the McCarthy era? Would the 100-plus criminal counts against Trump have been filed against anyone, or were they political (or are both partly true)? Was there nothing untoward in the role major law firms played in Russiagate, or did such episodes show the dangers of keeping private corporate defense firms and intelligence/law enforcement so intertwined? Is that ODC case against Martin just good regulation, or is it itself lawfare and retaliation?
If you don’t think any of those pre-2025 actions were lawfare, you’ll clearly object to the current administration’s high-handed tactics. If like me you had hopes this presidency might somehow break the cycle, you’re likely also unnerved.
Months into the new presidency, however, it’s clear officials in a White House led by a man who’d likely be in jail if he didn’t just win an election feel they’re still at war. “We didn’t make these rules, they did,” is how one voice close to the administration put it.
If politics has transformed into a ruleless rock fight, the development likely pre-dated Trump. Even though it’s now clearly part of the Trump/anti-Trump battle, the Peruvian toll road case that escalated this week started off as an early window into the chicken-egg conundrum of the lawfare era. If a whole system is crooked, to what extremes may an institutionally outmanned player, like a South American city, resort to in fighting back?
U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, like Justice Boasberg in the Facebook case, has recently become famous, in her case for for blocking Trump’s transgender military service ban. Two years ago, on December 6, 2023, she settled in for a hearing between the city of Lima, Peru and a toll road concession (“Rutas de Lima”) backed by one of the world’s largest private equity firms, the aforementioned Brookfield Asset Management. The Peruvians felt they’d been conned by Western finance conquistadors who bribed their way to an exploitative, obscenely overpriced toll deal, which they wanted vacated.
The Lima mess, as reported here, has roots in a scandal involving the Brazilian construction conglomerate Odebrecht. Like its similarly gigantoid American counterpart Halliburton, the firm was caught in a vast bribery scandal, forced to pay a $3.5 billion fine after handing out $788 million to officials around the world to win contracts. The toll deal was initially struck between Odebrecht and then-Mayor Susana Villarian (eventually sentenced to 29 years for her Odebrecht ties) in 2013, but once Odebrecht executives began getting arrested in 2015, the Canadian finance giant Brookfield snapped up a controlling stake for the discount price of $430 million (the firm would eventually place an internal valuation of the stake at $3 billion). The road connected dirt-poor Pueblos Jóvenes villages with the city center. When residents in a country with an average monthly salary of about $250 saw they’d be paying roughly $3 a day just to get to and from their homes, a period of furious protests and demonstrations commenced.
Meanwhile the Metropolitan Municipality of Lima (MML) appealed to international authorities to vacate the deal. Those efforts failed, so in 2023 Peruvian officials took an unprecedented step, filing criminal charges against the arbitrators involved, a version of nationalist lawfare all its own. No American judge was in anyone’s crosshairs yet, but at the time, just-broken news stories made it sound possible, and Reyes was peeved.
“All right,” she said at the start of the hearing, addressing Lima’s then-lawyers from the Boston-based firm, Foley Hoag. “Tell me that the article I read yesterday is mistaken… Tell me that was a gross misunderstanding and fake news.” Later, to the same lawyers: “I’m traveling internationally in February. Do I have to worry about a Red Notice being put out for my arrest?”
The Foley Hoag lawyers reassured her that no, she was safe to travel. Months later, the lawyers again felt her displeasure. Judge Reyes had at times complained about Lima’s representatives, scolding one for his seeming unfamiliarity with his own evidence and in another instance failing to understand why a witness to alleged bribery had not been made available. After more perceived stumbles, Reyes on March 18 of last year delivered a major rebuke.
Saying, “I have never experienced anything like this in all of my years of litigation” and that she had “never been up against counsel that’s acted this way,” she tore into the lawyers for the Municipality of Lima:
For a long time I thought maybe they just have a difficult client, or this is an important case and there’s a lot of ups and downs or whatever. Now I just think you all might be bad lawyers. Like that’s where we are. Because I don’t understand what else explains this… I do not understand how you all keep doing what you’ve been doing time and time and time again… I am literally — I just don’t understand it, because I know you’re not bad lawyers because you wouldn’t be where you are, at the firm where you are, handling this case if you were bad lawyers.
You’re either bad lawyers or I don’t know what, but I know you’re not bad lawyers is not something one hears from the mouth of a federal judge every day. What the ethical problem might have been was unclear at the time. This week, a possible explanation emerged, as the new lawyers for the Metropolitan Municipality of Lima, Boies Schiller, filed a motion claiming an extraordinary conflict:
For years, MML relied on Foley Hoag LLP (“Foley”) to protect its interests in high-stakes arbitrations and annulment proceedings against Rutas de Lima S.A.C. (“Rutas”) over a major toll road concession in Lima, Peru (“Concession Contract”). Yet unbeknownst to MML—until after suffering multiple losses in arbitration and before this Court—at the very same time Foley represented MML in those disputes, Foley also represented affiliates of Brookfield Asset Management Inc.—the parent company of Brookfield Infrastructure Partners, the majority stakeholder in Rutas (together, “Brookfield”).
Recapping: the Lima road was built as a result of an agreement between an admitted payoff-taking imprisoned ex-mayor and her benefactor, Odebrecht, a conglomerate that will be remembered as the General Motors of Bribery. Shortly after Odebrecht’s CEO was jailed in 2016, Jenner Block client Brookfield made an extraordinary bet on a recent Odebrecht project, not knowing if it would be subject to sanctions. Soon after that, in December of 2016, the Department of Justice negotiated Odebrecht’s $3.5 billion plea deal, noting that it paid $1.4 million to a “high-level official in the Peruvian government” while bidding on a “government transportation contract” that was “valued at approximately $400 million.” The U.S. declined to be any more specific, however, clearing the way for Brookfield to commence the cheery process of collecting tolls from Peruvians in rags.
The American official who signed the deal was Weissmann, then chief of the fraud division, who was one of Trump’s chief pursuers as Robert Mueller’s deputy. As Martin charged in a letter that was reported here in March, Weissmann had been a partner at the firm representing Brookfield when he signed the deal, a potential conflict of the type specifically warned against by the Biden Justice Department in a 2022 memorandum by Weissmann’s former co-worker, Lisa Monaco.
The Peruvians see this as all of a piece, part of a rigged game.
“The people of Lima have paid the price for a concession contract procured through bribery,” says Lima’s current Mayor, conservative Rafael López Aliaga. “It seems now that when Andrew Weissmann, a former partner of Brookfield’s law firm, resolved DOJ’s case against Odebrecht, no victims were acknowledged. In the case of Rutas de Lima, we’ve seen the consequences firsthand: Brookfield picked up a contract they themselves value at $3 billion for just $400 million risk free, while the people of Lima were left to bear the cost.”
When contacted, Brookfield sent a statement from former Florida Republican congressman Connie Mack IV, an advisor to the firm. “Mayor Lopez Aliaga’s latest legal gambit is a desperate attempt to distract from his mounting losses and the millions he has wasted of the people’s money in this case,” said Mack. “It’s time for Lopez Aliaga to get serious.” The new liberal Prime Minister of Canada, Mark Carney, was chairman of Brookfield during the period in question. Carney’s office declined to comment. Weissmann and Jenner Block also so declined.
Lima’s longshot effort to overturn the malodorous toll road deal reminds me of so many carefully negotiated screwings from the pre-Trump era: the “landmark $25 billion agreement” to help America’s five biggest mortgage servicers escape liability for a generation of robosigned (read: forged) documents, the “record” $13 billion mortgage fraud settlement for JP Morgan Chase that was really $9 billion (and really less than that), the preposterous $335 million settlement for the Pablo Escobars of subprime, Countrywide, the probation deals for Gen Re executives who likely cost shareholders more than the combined take of all bank robberies ever, and many others.
Some of these arrangements were back-of-napkin deals brokered by law firms over-empowered to help clients “self-regulate,” or advantageous settlements devised by regulators minutes from lucrative returns to private partnerships. Public frustration at the inability to crack these clubby arrangements is a big reason politics have become so radicalized.
I’m not in favor of either party using courts as weapons to take down opponents, but to me this case is a reminder that long before Trump, ordinary people — in subprime-ravaged exurbs here or in South American shantytowns — were the first victims of lawfare.
Boies Schiller Motion for MML against Rutas de Lima545KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadA month ago, on April 14th, one of the largest antitrust trials in recent memory commenced in the Washington, D.C. courtroom of District Chief Justice James Boasberg, now famous for finding the Trump administration in contempt for violating court orders on deportations. Federal Trade Commission v. Meta Platforms, Inc. has nothing to with immigration, instead asking a novel question: did Mark Zuckerberg’s Facebook/Meta operation acquire WhatsApp and Instagram for legitimate reasons, or to quash competition in search of social media monopoly?
If that question doesn’t interest you, you’d likely have been dozing when last week, on the 14th trial day, Meta Chief Information Security Officer Guy Rosen took the stand. Rosen was called by the FTC to answer questions about whether or not Facebook invested adequate resources in Instagram after its 2012 acquisition for $1 billion. In 2019, Rosen reportedly believed IG was “understaffed as an app-surface when compared to Facebook” and sought 149 more employees to handle various issues. One notable one was raised by Rosen to IG head Adam Mosseri in an email on May 16, 2018:
Harmful Behavior… e.g., grooming especially — this really worries me given we’re finding a lot of, umm, opportunity on FB, and given IG’s younger audience I bet we’ll find we have work to do there…
Email, Guy Rosen to Adam Mosseri, May 16, 2018Say what? “Grooming… really worries me given we’re finding a lot of, um, opportunity on FB” is not a common line in a legal exhibit. Brendan Benedict, who’s covering the trial for Matt Stoller’s aptly-named and excellent Substack “Big Tech on Trial,” wrote down another reply from Rosen to the company’s head of Data Analytics: “You are correct, there is a growing realization this is underfunded. This was deliberate — I explicitly had the convo with Mark at HC planning and he thought IG has another year or two to catch up. I think we are not sure that is the case anymore.” Another email read, “IG hasn’t done much on harmful content.”
The idea that FB/IG had “work to do” on “grooming,” and that certain kinds of underfunding were “deliberate,” became more explicit when an exhibit was introduced, an internal study from the next year, 2019, titled “Inappropriate Interactions with Children on Instagram.”
To be clear from the start, the mere fact that FB/IG conducted this study showed executives were concerned about the problem, and understood there was “work to do there.” However, the study suggested not only that there was a longstanding problem with “groomers” meeting minors on IG, but that the company’s algorithms were accelerating those interactions. One slide dropped four consecutive unsettling bullet points:
Overall IG: 7% of all follow recommendations to adults were minors
Groomers: 27% of all follow recommendations to
groomers were minors
We are recommending nearly 4X as many minors to groomers (nearly 2 million minors in the last 3 months)
22% of those recommendations resulted in a follow request
You can do the math yourself, but 22% of 2 million minors receiving follow requests from “groomers” over a 3-month period is not a small number. Perhaps more unsettling was a slide reading, “We may be facilitating possible groomers finding young people,” adding, “IG recommended a minor… to an account engaged in groomer-esque behavior.” Additionally, there was a flow chart demonstrating the process:
Subscribe now
Looking at this from one angle, there’s nothing necessarily unusual here. Social media algorithms are designed to match people to their likes. Cardi B enthusiasts will meet other Cardi B enthusiasts and people who like gummy bears will see gummy bears. But “the recommendation algorithms worked as intended” in the context of matching minors to “groomer-esque behavior” is unsettling nonetheless.
There was more on the subject, though according to Benedict’s story Boasberg cut off the cross, suggesting Meta was falling into the FTC’s “trap” of diving into what the judge described as “ancillary” matters. When I asked Brendan what the response was among reporters watching the trial from an overflow room, he said, “The press was shocked” and “Everybody’s been talking about it,” with some calling it the high moment of the trial.
Nonetheless, apart from Brendan, only Bloomberg did a story: “Instagram Suggested ‘Groomers’ Connect With Minors, FTC Says.” Lee Hepner of the American Economic Liberties Project tweeted about it, saying the data was “beyond disturbing” and “Meta had a designation for ‘groomers’ and recommended millions of minors to them. Front page stuff.” As Stoller noted, a lot of ink is spilled about how platforms allowed online phenomena like QAnon, so a revelation like this getting so little coverage is odd.
The presentation raised a number of questions, some of which were noted by Benedict. Was FB/IG identifying a category of people one could colloquially call “groomers”? If that was done for safety reasons, why were they still on the platform and having minors disproportionately recommended to them for so long? Then there was an issue more germane to the FTC’s suit, namely that Facebook and/or Mark Zuckerberg may have been intentionally distributing fewer resources to acquisitions, so as not to “tax” Facebook.
In one email summary of “Mark’s thoughts” on Facebook’s app “family,” Rosen wrote, “One specific thing I worry about is that supporting integrity in other apps shouldn’t be an indirect tax on the FB app.” In conjunction with a known “inappropriate interactions” problem, those lines are cringier.
I reached out to Meta about the bizarre detour of the antitrust case. Understandably, the company was not happy this came up, and helpfully took time to explain difficulties the company faced. Like Twitter (and other companies, surely), IG/FB had strict surveillance searching for child predators that led to zero-tolerance bans, but there obviously exists a category of person who doesn’t break hard rules, and merely show potential leanings or signs. It’s taken some time to develop strategies to keep “groomers” both from finding each other and from contacting minors, but they believe they’ve gotten there.
“This six-year-old research shows just one piece of the work to improve our child safety efforts, which we’ve significantly expanded since then,” a Meta spokesperson told me. “We’ve spent years refining the signals we use to detect these accounts and prevent them from finding, following or interacting with teen accounts – or with each other – and we continue to focus on understanding these evolving behaviors. Our launch of Teen Accounts last year also places teens under 18 into the safest automatic protections, which limit who can contact them and the content they see.”
It’s a good answer, and there’s no evidence that says definitively that the firm was intentionally making child exploitation a profit center or anything like that. At the same time, Instagram was acquired in 2012, the study about “inappropriate actions” only took place in 2019, and an announcement about measures “making it harder for potentially suspicious accounts to find young people” came out in 2021. The reader may judge the aggressiveness of that timeline on his or her own.
When I asked Benedict about the paucity of coverage, he mentioned a recent Wall Street Journal piece about a Meta Chatbot version of wrestler John Cena who engaged in a “graphic sexual scenario” with “a user who identified herself as a 14-year-old girl, after telling her to ‘cherish your innocence.’” Other celebrity AIs were apparently also “coaxed to highly troubling situations.” The company told the Journal it had “implemented new changes to make it more difficult for bad actors to exploit the AI personas feature for “extreme use cases,’” but as the paper noted, it’s not clear that makes up for the bizarre rollout.
At minimum, it’s odd what does and does not get coverage in the world of social media regulation. “Putting that all together,” Benedict says, “I think is really unsettling.”
It’s a busy day at Racket. We’ve been working on two stories, both of which should come out today. The second is explosive, unconnected to national politics, and weirdly undercovered. The first has connections to a huge range of national political figures and has flown under the radar for different reasons. Please bear with us as these make their way into print.
Walter Kirn and I will not be doing a live episode of America This Week tonight, as I’m not well. Please stay tuned for announcements about future scheduling. Apologies to all.