
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


It was no surprise Monday when the Trump administration quickly froze more than $2 billion in grants and a $60 million contract for Harvard after the school refused to accept a list of demands as a condition of receiving federal funding.
But it couldn’t end there. After all, it’s well established that President Trump doesn’t like to be told no. Sure enough, he came through Tuesday morning.
It only took a day for the first reports that the IRS plans to follow through with Trump’s threat.
CNN relies on “two sources familiar with the matter,” and says a final decision is “expected soon.”
The New York Times relies on three sources who say the IRS is “weighing whether to revoke Harvard’s tax exemption,” and two of those sources say that “IRS officials have told colleagues” that the Treasury Department asked the agency to consider doing it.
Harvard has been classified as a tax-exempt 501(c)(3) organization since tax reform legislation was passed in 1969. As a nonprofit, the school has been exempt from taxes for most of its history under previous tax legislation or local exemptions, although Harvard does make voluntary payments to local governments in lieu of property taxes.
It wasn’t until 1986 that educational institutions were specifically exempt from IRS code. Here’s the justification for that from the Association of American Universities:
The educational purposes of universities and colleges – teaching, research, and public service – have been recognized in federal law as critical to the well-being of our democratic society. Higher education institutions are in turn exempted from income tax so they can make the most of their revenues.
Needless to say, a lot has happened at Harvard since Oct. 7, 2023, that has been the antithesis of that high-minded reasoning, incidents like this from Oct. 18, 2023:
It’s not exactly a closing argument that a college deserves tax-exempt status when the school tells students that using the wrong pronouns is abusive, but its president isn’t so sure when it comes to calling for the genocide of Jews just a few days after students interrupted classes to chant “Globalize the Intifada.”
It’s also not a good look for a school that received — according to a lawsuit — at least $1.3 million in federal money from 2022 - 2023 even though it has an endowment of $50.7 billion.
Harvard has made changes since the fall of 2023 to prove its antisemitic credentials. One example: last May the school gave academic sanctions to 35 pro-Palestinian protesters.
But the White House says Harvard hasn’t gone far enough. Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt says Trump “wants to see Harvard apologize, and Harvard should apologize for the egregious antisemitism that took place on their college campus against Jewish American students.”
Here’s a timeline of other events on the path to this standoff between Harvard and Trump:
Jan. 10, 2024Six students file a lawsuit against Harvard for its “antisemitism cancer.” The lawsuit says Harvard hires professors who support anti-Jewish violence and ignores Jewish students’ pleas for protection:
Those professors teach and advocate through a binary oppressor-oppressed lens, through which Jews, one of history’s most persecuted peoples, are typically designated “oppressor,” and therefore unworthy of support or sympathy. Harvard permits students and faculty to advocate, without consequence, the murder of Jews and the destruction of Israel, the only Jewish country in the world. Meanwhile, Harvard requires students to take a training class that warns that they will be disciplined if they engage in sizeism, fatphobia, racism, transphobia, or other disfavored behavior.
The lawsuit gives examples of anti-semitism at Harvard going back several years and says the school’s “deliberate indifference to, and indeed enabling of, antisemitism on its campus constitutes an egregious violation” of the Civil Rights Act.
011025 Harvard Lawsuit663KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload052824 Amended Complaint12MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 29, 2024The Muslim Legal Fund of America (MLFA) files a federal complaint against Harvard with the Office of Civil Rights on behalf of Muslim and Palestinian students.
“We have been chased, spat at, stalked, and hounded by doxxing trucks on campus, and even at our families’ homes,” says a student in a press release announcing the complaint.
The MLFA also has a complaint that’s similar to what’s in the lawsuit filed by Jewish students: “Instead of providing protection or resources, Harvard responded to the students’ requests for help with closed doors,” the MLFA says.
May 18, 2024Two Harvard graduate students are charged with misdemeanor counts of assault and battery and violating the Massachusetts Civil Rights Act over the Oct. 18, 2023, incident in which they and others surrounded an Israeli student filming protesters. Students repeatedly yell “Shame” as they surround him. The Civil Rights Act charge has since been dismissed, but the assault and battery charges remain.
May 22, 2024Another lawsuit is filed against Harvard over antisemitism. The lawsuit is filed on behalf of five students by the Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law and Jewish Americans for Fairness in Education. From the lawsuit:
Jews are fair game. Students and faculty can harass and discriminate against Jews, and they can do so openly and with impunity. Harvard will go out of its way to protect antisemitic protestors and conspiracy-theorists.
The Israeli student who was surrounded by pro-Palestinian protesters on Oct. 18, 2023, is among the plaintiffs.
“The assailants grabbed him, and one hit him in the neck with his forearm, before forcing [him] out of Harvard’s quad,” the lawsuit says.
The video of the assault is shocking. But more remarkable perhaps is that Harvard has not taken any action to date to redress both the physical assault and the clear violations of its Anti-Bullying and Anti-Discrimination Policies. Instead, it cited an ongoing criminal investigation into [the} assailants and claimed that it is “standard practice” to await the criminal process—yet another contrived excuse.
2024 05 22 Brandeis Center And Jewish Americans For Fairness V806KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadOct. 8, 2024Shortly after a vigil commemorating the first anniversary of the October 7 terrorist attacks, a vandal smashes the windows of Harvard’s University Hall and pours fake blood on the statue of John Harvard. A video of the vandalism is posted to Instagram with the following caption: “We are committed to bringing the war home and answering the call to open up a new front here in the belly of the beast.”
January 17, 2025Harvard settles the Office of Civil Rights complaint filed by Muslim students. A letter from OCR attorneys says:
OCR is concerned that the University’s Non-Discrimination Policy appears to impede its ability to meet its obligations pursuant to Title VI to provide a prompt and effective response to incidents of shared ancestry harassment that create a hostile environment about which it knew or should have known.
The OCR finds that “the Policy may preclude or dismiss complaints of a discriminatory hostile environment in violation of its obligations under Title VI” of the Civil Rights Act.
The letter says Harvard agrees to implement a resolution agreement.
011725 Ocr Letter To Harvard361KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 21, 2025Harvard settles both lawsuits accusing it of antisemitism, although the lead plaintiff in the one case, Alexander “Shabbos” Kestenbaum, refuses to settle.
Harvard agrees to:
Adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism and include examples aligned with the Office of Civil Rights in the Department of Education.
Post online a Frequently Asked Questions document that clarifies both Jewish and Israeli identity are covered by Harvard’s non-discrimination and anti-bullying policies.
Reaffirm at least annually that anti-Semitism will not be tolerated.
Acting Budget Director Matthew Vaeth directs federal agencies to temporarily freeze all federal grants and loans to ensure they comply with recent executive orders, including one that targets DEI programs.
The use of Federal resources to advance Marxist equity, transgenderism, and green new deal social engineering policies is a waste of taxpayer dollars that does not improve the day-to-day lives of those we serve.
Harvard President Alan Garber says some federal research will have to stop. He adds:
In these challenging times, our efforts will be guided by our values and commitments: supporting academic excellence and the pursuit of knowledge; championing open inquiry, constructive dialogue, and academic freedom; building a community in which people of all backgrounds, perspectives, and experiences come together to learn, grow, and thrive; and embracing the rights and responsibilities that membership in such a community demands.
The following day, a federal judge issues a ruling that temporarily blocks the funding freeze, and issues a preliminary injunction the following month.
0127 Omb Letter Funding Pause1010KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload2025 02 25 Order79.2KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload2025 02 28 Order482KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 31, 2025The Trump Administration announces that its Joint Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism will review $9 billion in federal grants and contracts with Harvard.
Secretary of Education Linda McMahon says in a prepared statement:
Harvard’s failure to protect students on campus from anti-Semitic discrimination — all while promoting divisive ideologies over free inquiry - has put its reputation in serious jeopardy. Harvard can right these wrongs and restore itself to a campus dedicated to academic excellence and truth-seeking, where all students feel safe on its campus.
Garber addresses the review in an email titled “Our Resolve” to "members of the Harvard Community.”
“If this funding is stopped, it will halt life-saving research and imperil important scientific research and innovation,” Garber writes.
The government has informed us that they are considering this action because they are concerned that the University has not fulfilled its obligations to curb and combat antisemitic harassment. We fully embrace the important goal of combatting antisemitism, one of the most insidious forms of bigotry. Urgent action and deep resolve are needed to address this serious problem that is growing across America and around the world. It is present on our campus. I have experienced antisemitism directly, even while serving as president, and I know how damaging it can be to a student who has come to learn and make friends at a college or university.
033125 Garber Email164KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 11, 2025The Trump Administration sends a letter to Garber that says Harvard must uphold civil rights and foster “the kind of environment that produces intellectual creativity and scholarly rigor” if it's to continue receiving federal money:
Harvard has in recent years failed to live up to both the intellectual and civil rights conditions that justify federal investment.
041125 Trump Admin Letter To Harvard2.52MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadThe letter sets conditions for federal funding to continue. The full list of demands is in the letter above. They include:
Governance reforms that reduce the power held by students and non-tenured faculty, and reduce the power of any professor or administrator “more committed to activism than scholarship.”
Implementation of merit-based hiring policies and cease basing any hiring, promotion, or salary based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.
Implement merit-based admissions policies and end “all preferences” based on race, color, and national origin. In addition, “all admissions data shall be shared with the federal government and subjected to a comprehensive audit by the federal government.”
Implement a system for screening international students to “prevent admitting
students hostile to the American values and institutions inscribed in the U.S. Constitution and Declaration of Independence, including students supportive of terrorism or anti-Semitism.” This demand calls for Harvard to immediately report to federal authorities any foreign student who commits a conduct violation.
Ensure viewpoint diversity:
Every department or field found to lack viewpoint diversity must be reformed by hiring a critical mass of new faculty within that department or field who will provide viewpoint diversity; every teaching unit found to lack viewpoint diversity must be reformed by admitting a critical mass of students who will provide viewpoint diversity.
Audit of programs and departments “that most fuel antisemitic harassment or reflect ideological capture.”
The letter names departments that would be subject to the audit: the Divinity School, Graduate School of Education, School of Public Health, Medical School, Religion and Public Life Program, FXB Center for Health & Human Rights, Center for Middle Eastern Studies, Carr Center for Human Rights at the Harvard Kennedy School, Department of Near Eastern Languages and Cultures, and the Harvard Law School International Human Rights Clinic.
The [audit] shall include information as to individual faculty members who discriminated against Jewish or Israeli students or incited students to violate Harvard's rules following October 7, and the University and federal government will cooperate to determine appropriate sanctions for those faculty members within the bounds of academic freedom and the First Amendment.
April 14, 2025Harvard responds to the Trump administration through a letter from its attorneys. It notes changes the school has made in the past 15 months and says the government has made demands that “in contravention of the First Amendment, invade university freedoms long recognized by the Supreme Court.”
No less objectionable is the condition, first made explicit in the letter of March 31 , 2025, that Harvard accede to these terms or risk the loss of billions of dollars in federal funding critical to vital research and innovation that has saved and improved lives and allowed Harvard to play a central role in making our country's scientific, medical, and other research communities the standard-bearers for the world. These demands extend not only to Harvard but to separately incorporated and independently operated medical and research hospitals engaging in life-saving work on behalf of their patients. The university will not surrender its independence or relinquish its constitutional rights. Neither Harvard nor any other private university can allow itself to be taken over by the federal government. Accordingly, Harvard will not accept the government's terms as an agreement in principle.
041425 Harvard Response To Trump704KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadThe Trump Administration’s Joint Task Force to Combat Anti-Semitism responds by announcing a freeze on $2.2 billion in grants and a $60 million contract.
Harvard’s statement today reinforces the troubling entitlement mindset that is endemic in our nation's most prestigious universities and colleges – that federal investment does not come with the responsibility to uphold civil rights laws.
Globalization, once hailed as a panacea, has proven to be fundamentally corrupt and needs to be blown to kingdom come
Text published 04/11/25:
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Listen to subscriber only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Two weeks ago, we wrote about private equity firms using a “dividend recap” strategy to pay themselves special dividends.
This occurs when companies owned by PE firms take out a huge loan and pay their investors with the loan proceeds, saddling the companies with high debt, but ensuring investors make their money no matter what.
We focused on Clarios International, noting how susceptible to calamity such highly leveraged companies are if something goes wrong.
President Trump’s war on globalization through tariffs has ramped up the odds of a global recession. Goldman Sachs has forecast a 45% chance of a U.S. recession — and this occurred after Trump announced a 90-day pause on reciprocal tariffs on all countries except China. Before that, Goldman’s recession forecast was at 65%.
In other words:
It’ll come as no surprise then that investors are running for the hills and trying to dump their shares in private equity. Unfortunately for investors, private equity managers have many tools to slow them down.
That’s bad news for the roughly 12 million Americans directly employed by private equity-backed companies, and the nearly 8 million who work for their suppliers.
Private equity firms rely on two main things to be successful:
Strong demand for private equity debt in the form of leveraged loans and high yield bonds
Robust demand for their companies when they need to exit
Last week, Goldman Sachs more than doubled their default predictions for leveraged loans from 3.5% to 8% and raised its estimate of high yield bond defaults from 3% to 5%. Responding to this bleak news, leveraged loan and high yield bond mutual funds as well as exchange-traded funds last week had their highest ever weekly “outflow” of investors, prompting Goldman to call it “Flowmegeddon.”
As Bloomberg News noted, there’s not much private equity firms can do in such a volatile market:
Even with a tariff reprieve, barriers to buying and selling assets remain. But buyout barons have their work cut out just operating the portfolio companies they’re sitting on. As investment realizations get pushed back yet again, the risk of business damage at their stuck-on-ice holdings increases.
Private equity companies have a well-deserved reputation for cutting expenses in the best of times. Those traditional cutbacks will pale in comparison to what private equity managers will do if they can’t sell their companies or refinance their debt in a weakening economy.
A potential recession is bad for everyone, but the risks are even higher for employees of private equity-backed companies.
With research assistance from James Rushmore
With President Trump sitting next to him, El Salvador President Nayib Bukele told reporters in the Oval Office on Monday that no, he is not going to release Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia from his country’s Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT), despite a Justice Department lawyer admitting in a court filing that Abrego Garcia’s deportation last month was an “administrative error.”
Subscribe now
No matter, said Bukele:
Bukele: Of course I’m not going to do it. The question is preposterous. How can I smuggle a terrorist into the United States? I don’t have the power to return him to the United States.
Reporter: But you could release him inside El Salvador.
Bukele: Yeah, but I’m not releasing, I mean, I’m not very fond of releasing terrorists into our country. We just turned the murder capital of the world into the safest country in the Western hemisphere, and you want us to go back into releasing criminals so we can go back to being the murder capital of the world? That’s not going to happen.
There was little doubt what Bukele would say. Attorney General Pam Bondi set the tone early on in the meeting. She explained what the Supreme Court meant last week when it said a lower court ruling “properly requires the government to ‘facilitate’ Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador.”
The Supreme Court ruled, [Mr.] President, that if El Salvador wants to return him … we would facilitate it, meaning provide a plane.
It brings to mind President Clinton’s infamous grand jury testimony when he said: “It depends upon what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is.”
Abrego-Garcia left El Salvador and illegally entered the U.S. in 2011. His status as an illegal immigrant changed after he was arrested in 2019 and the Department of Homeland Security accused him of being a member of the MS-13 gang. Abrego Garcia fought the accusation and applied for asylum. Instead, an immigration judge granted him “withholding of removal” status.
A federal judge wrote in an April 6 opinion that in El Salvador “the Barrio 18 gang had been targeting him and threatening him with death because of his family’s pupusa business.”
The Justice Department argues its hands are tied. It doesn’t matter that the U.S. is paying El Salvador $6 million a year to house U.S. deportees at CECOT.
“The United States does not have control over Abrego Garcia. Or the sovereign nation of El Salvador,” says one court filing.
Below is a timeline of the case since Abrego Garcia was arrested last month, leading up to Monday’s Oval Office meeting with Bukele.
March 12-15, 2025ICE agents stop Abrego Garcia and tell him that he is no longer under “withholding of removal” status. The Trump administration says he is a member of the MS-13 gang, which the president has designated a foreign terrorist organization.
Abrego Garcia, who denies he is part of MS-13, is sent to an ICE detention facility in La Villa, Texas, and from there he is deported to El Salvador on March 15 along with 260 others, primarily Venezuelan nationals. He is being held in CECOT, a prison that has a capacity of 40,000 inmates.
March 24, 2025Abrego Garcia and his wife, Jennifer Vasquez Sura, file a lawsuit that notes Abrego Garcia has been in the U.S. legally since 2019 under withholding of removal status, and that the designation was never lifted.
They also accuse the government of sending Abrego Garcia to El Salvador despite “knowing that he would be immediately incarcerated and tortured in that country’s most notorious prison; indeed, Defendants have paid the government of El Salvador millions of dollars to do exactly that. Such conduct shocks the conscience and cries out for immediate judicial relief.”
The lawsuit requests the court order the U.S. government to tell the government of El Salvador to release and deliver Abrego Garcia to the U.S. Embassy in San Salvador.
0324complaint3.9MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload2019 Immigration Court Hearings And Order1.3MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 31, 2025The Justice Department acknowledges in a court filing that “although ICE was aware of his protection from removal to El Salvador, Abrego Garcia was removed to El Salvador because of an administrative error.”
Still, the Justice Department argues the motion should be denied because the court “has no power” over El Salvador. Justice Department attorneys argue:
Under their (plaintiffs) logic, this Court may assume jurisdiction to decide whether the order is legal, but if the order were determined legal, then jurisdiction would disappear again.
The government also says there’s no proof that Abrego Garcia will be tortured or killed in CECOT:
Plaintiffs point to little evidence about conditions in CECOT itself (focusing primarily on its capacity for detainees), instead extrapolating from allegations about conditions in different Salvadoran prisons. While there may be allegations of abuses in other Salvadoran prisons—very few in relation to the large number of detainees—there is no clear showing that Abrego Garcia himself is likely to be tortured or killed in CECOT. More fundamentally, this Court should defer to the government’s determination that Abrego Garcia will not likely be tortured or killed in El Salvador.
03312025 Administrative Error Response1.05MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 4, 2025U.S. District Court Judge Paula Xinis orders the Trump Administration to return Abrego Garcia to the U.S. by 11:59 p.m., April 7. She writes:
Plaintiffs are likely to succeed on the merits because Abrego Garcia was removed to El Salvador In violation of the Immigration and Nationality Act…and without any legal process; his continued presence in El Salvador, for obvious reasons, constitutes irreparable harm; the balance of equities and the public interest weigh in favor of returning him to the United States; and issuance of a preliminary injunction without further delay is necessary to restore him to the status quo and to avoid ongoing irreparable harm resulting from Abrego Garcia’s unlawful removal.
April 5, 2025The Justice Department appeals the order, calling it “indefensible” that “a federal district judge ordered the United States to force El Salvador to send one of its citizens—a member of MS-13, no less—back to the United States by midnight on Monday. “If there was ever a case for an emergency stay pending appeal, this would be it.”
More from the appellate motion:
Foremost, [the order] commands Defendants to do something they have no independent authority to do: Make El Salvador release Abrego Garcia, and send him to America. That is why Plaintiffs did not even ask the district court for an order directing Abrego Garcia’s return. As Plaintiffs themselves acknowledged, a federal court “has no jurisdiction over the Government of El Salvador and cannot force that sovereign nation to release Plaintiff Abrego Garcia from its prison.” That concession is all that is needed to order a stay here. No federal court has the power to command the Executive to engage in a certain act of foreign relations; that is the exclusive prerogative of Article II, immune from superintendence by Article III.
040525 Justice Department Stay Request Appeal2.46MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload2025 04 06 Plaintiffs (Garcia) Appellees' Opposition To Emergency Motion For Stay Pending Appeal And Immediate Admin5.42MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 6, 2025Judge Xinis issues a follow-up memorandum opinion to her April 4 order:
Although the legal basis for the mass removal of hundreds of individuals to El Salvador remains disturbingly unclear, Abrego Garcia’s case is categorically different—there were no legal grounds whatsoever for his arrest, detention, or removal. Nor does any evidence suggest that Abrego Garcia is being held in CECOT at the behest of Salvadoran authorities to answer for crimes in that country. Rather, his detention appears wholly lawless.
The judge also writes that in 2019, Homeland Security “relied principally on a singular unsubstantiated allegation that Abrego Garcia was a member of MS-13.”
2025 04 06 Memorandum Opinion290KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 7, 2025A three-judge panel of Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously denies the government’s motion for a stay of Xinis’ order that says Abrego Garcia must be returned to the U.S. by 11:59 p.m. Judge Stephanie Thacker writes:
The United States Government has no legal authority to snatch a person who is lawfully present in the United States off the street and remove him from the country without due process. The Government’s contention otherwise, and its argument that the federal courts are powerless to intervene, are unconscionable.
040725 Appeals Order233KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadThe Trump Administration appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court, and Chief Justice John Roberts grants an administrative stay to give justices time to consider the case.
Following the stay, Bondi accuses Abrego Garcia of being a “violent gang member” in the video above:
We will continue to fight for the safety of Americans and get these people out of our country to make America safe.
April 10, 2025The Supreme Court rules against the Trump administration but directs Judge Xinis to “clarify” a portion of her ruling. From the Supreme Court’s decision:
The order properly requires the Government to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to El Salvador. The intended scope of the term “effectuate” in the District Court’s order is, however, unclear, and may exceed the District Court’s authority. The District Court should clarify its directive, with due regard for the deference owed to the Executive Branch in the conduct of foreign affairs. For its part, the Government should be prepared to share what it can concerning the steps it has taken and the prospect of further steps.
0410 Scotus55.7KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 11, 2025If the Supreme Court said, ‘Bring somebody back,’ I would do that. I respect the Supreme Court.
President Trump says that aboard Air Force One a day after the Supreme Court upholds a lower court ruling and says the government should “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s return to the U.S.
Meanwhile, Judge Xinis issues a new order that directs the government to “take all available steps to facilitate the return” of Abrego Garcia. In a hearing, she also makes clear her frustration with the Justice Department.
“The record, as it stands, is, despite this court's clear directive, your clients have done nothing to facilitate the return of Mr. Abrego Garcia,” she says.
Xinis also orders the administration to provide daily updates on the status of Abrego Garcia’s return. She also criticizes Justice Department attorneys in her order:
During the hearing, the Court posed straightforward questions, including: Where is Abrego Garcia right now? What steps had Defendants taken to facilitate his return while the Court’s initial order on injunctive relief was in effect…? Defendants’ counsel responded that he could not answer these questions, and at times suggested that Defendants had withheld such information from him. As a result, counsel could not confirm, and thus did not advance any evidence, that Defendants had done anything to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s return. This remained Defendants’ position even after this Court reminded them that the Supreme Court of the United States expressly affirmed this Court’s authority to require the Government “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s return. From this Court’s perspective, Defendants’ contention that they could not answer these basic questions absent some nonspecific “vetting” that has yet to take place, provides no basis for their lack of compliance.
April 12, 2025A State Department official reports to the court that Abrego Garcia is “alive and secure” at CECOT. “He is detained pursuant to the sovereign, domestic authority of El Salvador,” the State Department’s Michael Kozak says in a filing.
However, he does not give an update on the status of Abrego Garcia’s return to the U.S.
Meanwhile, Abrego Garcia’s attorneys use Trump’s statements aboard Air Force One the previous day to justify a motion for additional relief:
Yesterday, President Trump confirmed that the United States has the power to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s release from prison and return to the United States: “If the Supreme Court said, ‘Bring somebody back,’ I would do that. ... I respect the Supreme Court.”1 Of course, that is precisely what the Supreme Court did when it ruled that this Court’s injunction “properly requires the Government to ‘facilitate’ Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador and to ensure that his case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to El Salvador.
His attorneys ask Judge Xinis to order the government to:
Request El Salvador to release Abrego Garcia.
Dispatch personnel to accompany Abrego Garcia.
Provide air transportation for Abrego Garcia to return to Maryland.
Grant Abrego Garcia parole.
The motion also asks Xinis to order the government to show why it shouldn’t be held in contempt for “failing to comply with this Court’s orders,” and immediately produce documents related to the government’s use of CECOT.
041225 Abrego Garcia Motion For Addtional Relief282KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 14, 2025The Justice Department puts in writing how it interprets “facilitate” in the Supreme Court’s order:
Defendants understand “facilitate” to mean what that term has long meant in the immigration context, namely actions allowing an alien to enter the United States. Taking “all available steps to facilitate” the return of Abrego Garcia is thus best read as taking all available steps to remove any domestic obstacles that would otherwise impede the alien’s ability to return here. Indeed, no other reading of “facilitate” is tenable—or constitutional—here.
Any other interpretation, the motion argues, would “violate the separation of powers. The federal courts have no authority to direct the Executive Branch to conduct foreign relations in a particular way, or engage with a foreign sovereign in a given manner.”
041325 Doj Response To Motion120KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 15, 2025Judge Xinis approves a request by Abrego Garcia’s attorneys to depose Trump Administration officials to learn how the case has been handled and find out what’s been done to try to get him back to the U.S.
“I do need evidence in this regard because to date what the record shows is nothing has been done,” Xinis said in a hearing.
In her written order, Xinis also made clear what is meant by “facilitate.”
This Court…ordered no more than what the Supreme Court endorsed: that Defendants “take all available steps to facilitate the return of Abrego Garcia to the United States as soon as possible,” because bound within this remedy is Abrego Garcia’s “release from custody” and the assurance that Abrego Garcia’s “case is handled as it would have been had he not been improperly sent to El Salvador.
Xinis provided definitions from different dictionaries with web links.
The fallacy in the Defendants’ argument is twofold. First, in the “immigration context” as it were, id., facilitating return of those wrongly deported can and has included more extensive governmental efforts, endorsed in prior precedent and DHS publications.1 Thus, the Court cannot credit that “facilitating” the ordered relief is as limited as Defendants suggest.
Second, and more fundamentally, Defendants appear to have done nothing to aid in Abrego Garcia’s release from custody and return to the United States to“ensure that his case is handled as it would have been” but for Defendants’ wrongful expulsion of him. Thus, Defendants’ attempt to skirt this issue by redefining “facilitate” runs contrary to law and logic.
An attorney for Abrego Garcia, Rina Gandhi, says she understands why Xinis didn’t hold Justice Department attorneys in contempt.
“I think that this is a highly politicized case and the judge understood that by doing so it would only raise tempers. Would it have been appropriate? Arguably, yes. But I think it was likely ultimately the right call to actually move this case forward.”
April 16The case is getting more politicized. U.S. Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Maryland flies to El Salvador to meeting with Abrego Garcia. The government denies that request.
Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security posts documents on X that show Abrego Garcia’s wife sought a domestic violence protective order against him in 2021.
In the video above, Trump press secretary Karoline Leavitt pushes back on the media referring to Abrego Garcia as a “Maryland father.”
The Democrats and the media in this room have continually and wrognly labeled Kilmar Abrego Garcia as a Maryland father. There is no Maryland father. Let me reiterate: Kilmar Abrego Garcia is an illegal alien MS-13 gang member and foreign terrorist who deported back to his home country.
April 17, 2025Sen. Van Hollen meets with Abrego. After being told no on two consecutive days, El Salavor authorities brought Abrego Garcia to Van Hollen’s hotel.
Van Hollen says that Abrego Garcia told him he was place in a cell at CECOT with about 25 people.
He said he was not afraid of the other prisoners in his immediate cell, but that he was traumatized by being at CECOT and fearful of many of the prisoners in other cell blocks who called out to him and taunted him in various ways.
Abrego Garcia also told him that he was transfered to another prison on April 9 where conditions are better, but:
He said despite the better conditions, he still has no access to any news from the outside world and no ability to commuicate with anybody in the outside world. His conversation with me was the first communication he had with anybody outside a prison since he was abducted. He said he felt very sad about being in a prison because he had not committed any crime.
April 18, 2025Trumps posts this image and message:
The image Trump post with “MS-13” on it has spurred accusations that it was doctored, in part because the MS-13 symbols were never mentioned in court documents. Judge Xinis wrote in an April 6 memorandum opinion that in 2019, Homeland Security “relied principally on a singular unsubstantiated allegation that Abrego Garcia was a member of MS-13.”
April 21, 2025Attorneys for Abrego Garcia say the government is failing to comply with Xinis’ April 15 discovery order and request a conference with Justice Department attorneys. At issue again is the meaning of “facilitate.” Attorneys for both sides give their perspectives in the same letter to Xinis. Abrego Garcia’s attorneys write:
The Government refuses to respond to interrogatories it claims are “based on the false premise that the United States can or has been ordered to facilitate Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador,” despite the Supreme Court’s clear holding that “[t]he [O]rder properly requires the Government to ‘facilitate’ Abrego Garcia’s release from custody in El Salvador.”
They also say the government refuses to provide documents “concerning the legal basis for Abrego Garcia’s confinement,” nor provide any information about the administration’s agreement with El Salvador to hold migrants in the country’s prisons.
Justice Department attorneys counter that they’ve made a “good-faith effort” to responds, but object to some requests made by Abrego Garcia’s attorneys.
The insistence on examining “legal basis for Abrego’s confinement”is an absurdity. Upon Abrego’s repatriation to El Salvador, his detention was no longer a matter of the United States’ confinement, but a matter belonging to the government of El Salvador – which has been explained to the Plaintiffs repeatedly. Any requirement of a more detailed response by the Defendants would be wholly inappropriate and an invasion of diplomatic discussions.
042125 Request For Conference446KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 22, 2025Judge Xinis issues an order rather than schedule a conference, and she clearly not happy with government attorneys. Her order says:
For weeks, Defendants have sought refuge behind vague and unsubstantiated assertions of privilege, using them as a shield to obstruct discovery and evade compliance with this Court’s orders. Defendants have known, at least since last week, that this Court requires specific legal and factual showings to support any claim of privilege. Yet they have continued to rely on boilerplate assertions. That ends now.”
Xinis set a deadline for 6 p.m. April 23 for the government to provide all requested material.
042225 Xinis Order Discovery210KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSubscribe now
Readers, sincere apologies (especially since Walter and I intended to do tonight’s show), but an evening dental procedure for me that was supposed to fix a complication from the weekend now has me struggling to speak. Walter and I text-discussed the matter and have elected to postpone the 8:00 PM ET live show. There would be humor value in trying to follow what I say, but any “discussion” would be a net minus overall.
We haven’t missed a show yet, so I feel terrible. I’m sorry. We’ll be back later this week.
Tonight, Matt and Walter will continue to navigate the aftermath of Trump’s reciprocal tariff program. They’ll take a look at China’s decision to suspend exports of certain rare earth minerals in the hopes of undermining American manufacturers. They’ll also explore China’s response to the Trump administration’s exemption for certain electronic devices, a move that was widely seen as a carveout for companies like Apple. On Sunday, the Chinese Ministry of Commerce issued a statement that included the following:
We urge the U.S. to heed the rational voices of the international community and domestic parties, take a big stride in correcting its mistakes, completely abolish the wrongful action of “reciprocal tariffs,” and return to the correct path of resolving differences through equal dialogue based on mutual respect.
What does this portend for the trade war between the U.S. and China? Who will blink first: Trump or Xi? And how will this affect consumer prices and the future of stateside manufacturing? Tune in to America This Week to find out.
Please tune in at 8:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or, visit Matt or Walter on Twitter
Former New York Times and Washington Post reporter Taylor Lorenz, speaking about accused killer Luigi Mangione on CNN MisinfoNation with Donnie O’Sullivan:
To see these millionaire media pundits on TV clutching their pearls about someone stanning a murderer when this is the United States of America. As if we don’t lionize criminals… There’s a huge disconnect between the narratives and the angles that mainstream media pushes and what the American public feels… You’re going to see women especially that feel like, ‘Oh my God,’ right? Like, ‘Here’s this man who’s revolutionary, who’s famous, who’s handsome, who is young, who’s smart.’ He’s a person that seems like this morally good man, which is hard to find.
I know Lorenz is a human bug-zapper whose purpose is luring people to doom by drawing them to the glow of the impossibly stupid online utterance, but even by her standards this is nuts. For one thing, Lorenz is a leading advocate for dumbed-all-the-way-down media like her “beloved” Vine, which featured six-second-max videos. If someone handed her a hardcover book, she’d be a serious threat to bite it. Her invoking Flannery O’Connor and A Good Man is Hard to Find in the context of Luigi Mangione is high comedy. Regarding America “stanning” murderers because “we give them Netflix shows,” which does she mean? Americans may be fascinated by O.J. and Bundy and Phil Spector, but we don’t gush cartoon hearts at them over cable, we watch them in lurid docudramas.
In reply to co-host Walter Kirn’s deserved ribbing about the MisinfoNation being “the least organic interview in history,” Lorenz charged him with being one of those “weird men who have these outrage meltdowns when I try to talk about extremism online.” Doesn’t she mean “endorsing” extremism in this case? As for “weird,” let’s recap:
Subscribe now
When I first read Lorenz I thought she was CIA performance art, a Langley-designed version of a Tony Clifton act designed to collect the names of the 907% of readers who’d recoil in revulsion. In a 2021 Times piece called To Fight Vaccine Lies, Authorities Recruit an ‘Influencer Army,’ Lorenz described a White House effort to use TikTok influencers like Ellie Zeiler to get 12-18-year-olds to get the shot:
Ms. Zeiler quickly agreed, joining a broad, personality-driven campaign to confront an increasingly urgent challenge in the fight against the pandemic: vaccinating the youthful masses, who have the lowest inoculation rates of any eligible age group in the United States.
Writers made of lesser stuff might be troubled by questions like “Do 12-year-olds need this vaccine?” Months later, fellow Times writer David Leonhardt wrote that “for children without a serious medical condition, the danger of severe Covid is so low as to be difficult to quantify.” Others might wonder about the ethics of government end-running parents and “news” by using online jewelry and dress merchants to hype vaccines to kids. I remember finding impressive the breezy unconcern Lorenz showed for such questions.
Most interesting was the happy ending to the piece, in which influencer Christina Najjar a.k.a. “Tinx” interviewed Anthony Fauci. Questions ranged from whether or not it was safe to try to get pregnant with Harry Styles after the vax to how old Fauci thought Najjar looked:
Stories like this are what make the recent Lorenz transformation into a spokesperson for popular rage against “barbaric establishment institutions” a tough one to swallow without laughs. For years, Lorenz was a one-person global surveillance operation, hunting unorthodoxy in every corner of the Internet and investigating the dangers of “unfettered conversations” on sites like Clubhouse, where the level of freedom was such that one user “discouraged people from getting the shots.” Lurking, she heard billionaire Marc Andreessen, or so she thought, wantonly using the word “retard” while no one stopped him:
It turned out not to be Andreessen and Lorenz had to agree the issue had been “clarified” for her, which naturally resulted in a lot of chuckling in media. Glenn Greenwald described her as a “deeply unwell Swiss-boarding-school-educated neurotic who is paid by the New York Times to lurk outside teenagers’ TikTok houses.” Tucker Carlson meanwhile said she was “at the top of journalism’s repulsive little food chain.” After tweeting that the abuse she’d had to suffer had “destroyed her life,” she was the beneficiary of a whole academic study devoted to tracking the abuse she suffered after the Carlson-Greenwald meanness (I don’t remember a school offering to provide any of my friends with similar services), then went on MSNBC to discuss the results. One clip went viral:
Lorenz was mocked anew for this performance, becoming the prize subject of a wide range of Internet meme artists (the AI version of Joe Biden as crying Lorenz was disturbing). Naturally, she blamed the right people for the development: MSNBC.
Lorenz claimed the network and host Morgan Radford (the one trying desperately to be sympathetic in the video) for throwing her “under the bus,” adding, “If your segment or story on ‘online harassment’ leads to even worse online harassment for your subjects, you fucked up royally and should learn how to cover these things properly.”
This wouldn’t be relevant, except as prelude to Mangione. Pre-Luigi, Lorenz had perhaps the world’s most stringent definition of harm, identifying private use of the “r-slur,” being described as a “Swiss-boarding-school-neurotic,” and an MSNBC host failing to aggressively edit out her own embarrassing interview comments as life-imperiling behavior.
She went from the New York Times to the Washington Post to (ironically) Substack. After the Mangione murder on December 4th last year, Lorenz became Luigi’s version of Bundini Brown, telling Piers Morgan she “felt, along with so many other Americans, joy” after the murder of United HealthCare CEO Brian Thompson (she denies the murder is what was what caused the “joy”; be your own judge).
Her Substack for a while was a Luigi fan page, which makes sense now that we know that “I saw the biggest audience growth that I’ve ever seen” with Mangione text. With article titles like “The merchification of Luigi,” “Inside the CEO shooter standom,” and my personal favorite, “Why ‘we’ want insurance executives dead,” Lorenz practically lashed her business to Mangione’s public image. Overnight, we went from living in a world where calling someone an untalented Swiss-boarding-school dipshit is unconscionable PTSD-inducing unfairness, to one where shooting an insurance executive in the back is cause for giddy celebration and smiles.
When the Thompson/Mangione affair happened I laughed at the idea that there would be a counter-massaging campaign framing Mangione’s half-cocked Unabomber imitation (with its mailed-in, tweet-length manifesto) as an improvement on Trump-style underclass rage. Now, Mangione as press darling is definitely a phenomenon, and not just in publications like People and US Weekly (wildest headline: Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs Is Not Jealous of Luigi Mangione: ‘There Is No Truth to It’). Ken Klippenstein responded to news of federal efforts to seek death penalty charges by writing that “Luigi Mangione Becomes a Political Prisoner,” while the New Yorker before the New Year ran a piece comparing Luigi to Walter White of Breaking Bad and other “man of the people” American outlaw archetypes.
Mangione the rich sociopath is the opposite of that archetype, far more Leopold and Loeb than Bonnie and Clyde, and it’s telling that there are people who think this can have mass appeal. It’s one of the dumbest ideas of era, but who better than Lorenz to sell it?
Welcome to Racket Rewind, a recap of everything we’ve published over the past week. Plus, one previously paywalled article is now free to read and share.
Thanks for reading!
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
We know inboxes can get cluttered, so if you’d rather not receive Racket Rewind but still want other emails from us, you can update your preferences anytime in your account settings.
Read the Short Story
Listen to the Full Episode
Listen to Episode 130
Matt Taibbi: Welcome to America this week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kern.
Matt Taibbi: How are you doing, Walter?
Walter Kirn: Doing well. Spring is getting its very tiny claws into the turf of Montana and about to stand up on its feet, and I couldn’t be happier because I live by the sun. I’m like an orchid in a Raymond Chandler novel. I need constant heat. I don’t generate my own.
Matt Taibbi: We’re all becoming like orchids in a Raymond Chandler novel, sadly.
Walter Kirn: Yeah. But yeah, I’m well.
Matt Taibbi: Good, good. Excellent. Yeah, the seasonal effective thing also works more and more on me every year, and this year it’s still cold in New Jersey, so I’m a little bummed, but busy week and man, is there a lot to talk about. I keep saying this. I always think that I’ve seen it all, and then something happens to make you realize that there’s always another level for things to descend to. Now, there was a lot of turmoil this week. Walter, do you have any overall impressions, first of all, about the tariff controversy, which has spanned a number of different stages this week, but basically has gone from being universally condemned to suddenly people quasi accepting it, to what exactly?
Walter Kirn: Well, I mean, at the risk of repeating myself, I said on Monday night that I think Trump had found the on and off lever in American politics and finance, and it was this tariff business. It’s a power that he, as the executive, holds and he can decide to wield as he chooses. He, in his traditional form, made maximum demands or big demands. He actually characterized them as moderate, considering the injustices and imbalances that he was attempting to write or correct. But in any case, we had at the end of last week a full scale, almost COVID level panic about the world economy being destroyed by these tariff proposals.
Matt Taibbi: Specifically the equity markets. But yeah.
Walter Kirn: Yeah, specifically the stock markets, which suddenly became the focus of all democratic passion and anxiety after having, for a long time been the butt of their disapproval that America lived and died for this capitalist index that didn’t reflect well-being and the plight of the middle class and the worker. But when it went down as a proxy for Donald Trump hatred, it seemed just too perfect. They all grabbed onto it, not realizing that if you write it down, you’ll have to write it up.
And then the fabled Black Monday, Jim Kramer had all of a sudden predicted on Sunday in his inimitable inverse way, it was a buy signal basically to anyone in the know, the market stabilized for a couple of days at a lower level than they’d been. And then yesterday they shot up in a spectacular fashion and almost melt up, the funniest moment of which was I think Goldman Sachs issuing a recession advisory to its clients. And then an hour later, after it seemed that Trump was going to pause the suite of tariffs that did not apply to China, he said, “Because hey, they’ve all come to the table. They want to negotiate, they’re good people. We’re going to get deals, so I don’t need to institute these instantly.” Well, how dare he? An hour later, Goldman Sachs is withdrawing and revising its guidance about a recession. The market’s shooting up, and we have a pretty hilarious scene in the US Congress where a congressman who is grilling a trade emissary.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. So what you’re referring to Walter, there’s a Nevada Democrat named Steven Horsford who is in the middle of giving the US trade ambassador Jamieson Greer I think is his name, as they say in football, giving him the business, and suddenly word comes in that the tariffs have been paused, and now he’s pissed because he can’t yell at him about that. So let’s roll that tape.
Steven Horsford: Mr. Trade Representative, are you aware that the tariffs have been paused?
Jamieson Greer: I am, yes.
Steven Horsford: When were you made aware of that?
Jamieson Greer: I understood the decision was made a few minutes ago-
Steven Horsford: Sitting here.
Jamieson Greer: ... under discussion.
Steven Horsford: Sitting here. Under discussion. So did you know that this was under discussion, and why did you not include that as part of your opening remarks?
Jamieson Greer: So typically what I don’t do is divulge contents of my discussions with the president.
Steven Horsford: What are the details of the pause?
Jamieson Greer: Well, my understanding is that because so many countries have decided not to retaliate, we’re going to have about 90 days.
Steven Horsford: Excuse me? China increased their tariffs on the United States. Trump blinked.
Jamieson Greer: Sir?
Steven Horsford: What do you know about this pause? What are the details of it?
Jamieson Greer: Well, the details as I understand it, is that China continues to retaliate. Other countries didn’t retaliate. The president two or three days ago said we wanted to negotiate with those countries that asked for meetings. That’s what we’re doing. We’ve had discussions.
Steven Horsford: What are the details? How long is the pause? How many days? How many weeks?
Jamieson Greer: I understand it’s 90 days. I haven’t spoken to the president since I’ve been in the-
Steven Horsford: So the Trade Representative hasn’t spoken to the president of the United states-
Matt Taibbi: Because he’s here.
Steven Horsford: ... about a global reordering of trade.
Jamieson Greer: Yes, I have. I’ve just been in the hearing with you.
Steven Horsford: But yet he announced it on a tweet. WTF. Who’s in charge?
Jamieson Greer: President of the United States is in charge.
Steven Horsford: And what do you know about those details?
Jamieson Greer: Well, as I mentioned-
Steven Horsford: It looks like your boss just pulled the rug out from under you and paused the tariffs, the taxes on the American people, with no strategy.
Matt Taibbi: The taxes on the American people. Okay.
Walter Kirn: So as I said on Twitter, this has a Hitler just finds out in his bunker that tariffs have been paused quality, taking off his glasses. WTF. Whatever that is in German.
Matt Taibbi: You got to do this. Somebody has to do the downfall spoof, right?
Walter Kirn: Vat de fook.
Matt Taibbi: Exactly. Mein Führer, it turns out the tariffs have been paused. So, okay, so where they’re going with this, they’re mad about it no matter what happens.
Walter Kirn: Right.
Matt Taibbi: And we can talk about what exactly Trump is doing with these tariffs in a minute, but what’s remarkable is the response and this whole idea that the real damage here-
Walter Kirn: Why is the dude upset? Isn’t he happy now? World economy righted. He had already loaded his cannon and lit the fuse. It was too late to put it out. So he had to contextualize the blast as now being about the pause and some lack of communication that’s supposed to go on.
Matt Taibbi: How come you haven’t talked to the president?
Walter Kirn: Right.
Matt Taibbi: Dude, I’ve been sitting right here the entire time.
Walter Kirn: Well pick up your phone.
Matt Taibbi: Exactly.
Walter Kirn: Don’t you have a Neuralink?