Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

All Racket News episodes

  • ATW Livestream Tonight at 8 PM ET/7 PM CT

    On tonight’s episode of America This Week, Matt and Walter will discuss the anti-Trump protests that took place across the United States and around the world on Saturday. According to The Washington Post, about 100,000 people attended the rally in Washington, D.C. Do the Hands Off demonstrations suggest that the Resistance movement will successfully renew its efforts during the second Trump presidency, or do these protests represent a more scattershot phenomenon? They’ll also take a look at the global economic fallout from the sweeping reciprocal tariffs that Trump announced during his “Liberation Day” speech on Wednesday, and they’ll explore the media’s coverage of his controversial new trade polices.

    Please tune in at 8:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or follow @mtaibbi or @walterkirn on Twitter. See you soon!

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • There Are Signs of a Category 5 Housing Crisis Forming and Coming Straight For Us
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    If there was ever a “canary in the coal mine” moment for the next housing crisis, it’s that mortgage and insurance giant Fannie Mae maintains a secret mortgage blacklist.

    The Wall Street Journal broke the news on March 17 that Fannie Mae keeps a blacklist that includes condo associations it believes have too little property insurance or need to make critical building repairs. According to the Journal, it’s a list that every major lender pays attention to.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    In other words, if you’re buying a condo in a building on that list, you’re likely not going to get a loan. However, the insurance “canary” isn’t just about condo buildings.

    If you think homeowners insurance has already skyrocketed — and it has — hold on because you’re likely about to get screwed even more. First, some background:

    The power of Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and Ginnie Mae

    These three agencies insure against losses on about 90% of all residential mortgage loans. These loans end up as mortgage-backed securities (MBS), which amount to more than $9 trillion.

    The liquidity of the MBS market is the main reason getting a home mortgage in the U.S. is relatively easy. Without agencies like Fannie Mae, our housing market would be a fraction of what it is today. When borrowers make the monthly payment on their loans — usually to a loan servicer — the monthly payment goes through the agencies and makes its way to the MBS market.

    The agencies guarantee against principal losses and collect a monthly fee called a “Guarantor Fee.” In this case, they’re acting like an insurance company to MBS bond holders by collecting premiums and paying out any losses due to borrower default. MBS are collateralized by the borrower’s home.

    Therefore, if the homeowner’s insurance isn’t paid, then the collateral (ie: the home) backing the loan is at risk. If a home that’s collateralizing a mortgage that the agencies guarantee is without insurance, and the home is destroyed, the agencies would take the loss.

    A lapsed insurance policy can be considered a default and lead to foreclosure.

    Insurance and mortgage rates are connected

    Homeowners insurance is going up. A Treasury Department report released in January found that, nationally, insurance rates rose 8.7% faster than the rate of inflation from 2018-2022.

    Of course, the agencies can’t guarantee large swaths of homes in securities unless they are insured.

    Most people’s mortgage payment includes their insurance premiums and real estate taxes. Those premiums and taxes go into an escrow account from which the loan servicer pays those bills when they are due. So, as your insurance premiums and real estate taxes go up, so does your mortgage payment.

    This is where the rubber meets the road. While the average price of insurance went up 8.7% more than inflation from 2018-2022, it went up 14.7% more than inflation in the 20 highest-risk zip codes. The consumer price index rose 20% during that period. That means a $1,500 insurance policy in those top 20 zip codes increased an average of $344, raising a monthly $3,000 payment to $3,029. Another study from S&P Global found that premium increased an average of 34% from 2017-2023:

    If you can still only pay the $3,000 a month, you’re delinquent even if you covered your principal and interest in your payment. That means you’re on the path to foreclosure.

    Often, homeowners in this situation get introduced to a dark corner of the financial world: Forced Place Insurance (FPI). When closing on a home, the borrower signs loan documents agreeing to maintain continuous homeowners insurance coverage. If the insurance policy lapses or gets canceled, the lender or servicer steps in and obtains FPI — also known as lender-placed insurance — to safeguard the property.

    FPI premiums are usually four to 10 times more — meaning even higher monthly mortgage payments and an increased likelihood of default. That’s starting to happen in the commercial real estate market.

    FPI played a big role in the 2007-2008 mortgage crises, as Rohit Chopra, the former director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, noted in this 2023 speech:

    There have been numerous lawsuits against mortgage servicers and insurance companies alleging that these entities, or an allegedly captive reinsurance company, were paid kickbacks. Even if the mortgage servicer doesn’t profit from the force-placed insurance, the mortgage servicer has limited incentives to minimize the cost of the force-placed insurance or avoid the placement. The entire price of the force-placed insurance is then passed on to the borrower.

    Foreclosures

    Look what’s happening so far in 2025:

    Foreclosures 2025
    January: +8% from previous month
    February: +5% from previous month

    While foreclosure numbers year-over-year are still below 2024, and the rate has remained relatively unchanged the previous three years, I’m concerned the uptick could become a trend because we know insurance rates have been going up since 2022, the last year covered in that Treasury Department report. The average premium jumped nearly $200 in 2023 and jumped again last year, according to this report from Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies.

    With premiums rising faster than inflation, something’s got to give. I’ll be keeping a close eye on the foreclosure report for March later this week.

    Higher insurance premiums = higher mortgage rates

    Most of the media’s attention focuses on the Fed when it comes to mortgage rates. But insurance premiums can also affect rates for a new loan.

    Any loan provider is going to look at where the agencies’ securities are trading. If they are yielding 6%, the loan provider can’t just sell the loan at that rate. They also have to add on that guarantor fee I mentioned earlier that guarantees investors won’t lose money on the loan’s principal. There’s also the loan servicing fee. That 6% rate is likely to become a 6.75% rate for the customer. The higher the guarantor fee — which is in this case affected by soaring insurance premiums — the higher the interest rates. This FHFA report released last May shows that Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae guarantor fees are going up.

    Of course, insurance premiums are on the rise in large part because of natural disasters. Let’s face it: these days it seems like most of the country is increasingly prone to fires, hurricanes, or tornadoes. If you’re in California — which has been dealing with an insurance crisis for several years — your rates are already going up because of January’s fires in the LA area.

    I don’t need to tell you that disasters increase insurance premiums no matter where you live.

    But not to worry. The Treasury Department had a remedy in that January report:

    State and federal regulators and policymakers should continue their efforts to improve public awareness about the importance of adequate homeowners insurance.

    To quote Steven Wright, “I couldn’t repair your brakes, so I fixed your horn instead.”

    Correction: This story has been updated to correct an error we made in calculating an increase in monthly mortgage payments resulting form higher homeowners insurance premiums. We also added additional information from a study that the Minneapolis Fed wrote about last year.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Racket Rewind

    Welcome to Racket Rewind, a recap of everything we’ve published over the past week. Plus, one previously paywalled article is now free to read and share.

    Thanks for reading!

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    We know inboxes can get cluttered, so if you’d rather not receive Racket Rewind but still want other emails from us, you can update your preferences anytime in your account settings.

    0 min
  • Why Do Democrats Destroy Their Own?

    On Thursday, I filed a $10 million lawsuit against California congresswoman Sydney Kamlager-Dove, who in opening remarks at a House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee hearing called me a “serial sexual harasser.”

    The instant the words hit my ears, I remembered what Gabe Kaminsky reported last year: that Biden administration officials, during a briefing about the State Department’s same Global Engagement Center we were here to discuss, told members of another Congressional committee that “unsavory conduct in Russia” meant my reporting was “not to be trusted.” This followed a New York Post report on a document showing GEC officials strategizing responses to me and Kaminsky.

    Did these members get the same briefing? Did they not know that story had been outed, or did they know it was outed and decide to proceed anyway? That would be mendacious and lazy. It went downhill from there:

    Subscribe now

    For the rest of the session members thundered about hypocrisy on speech. Pramila Jayapal of Washington State, whom I’ve covered favorably in the past (also unfavorably), called it the “height of hypocrisy” to discuss the “fabricated censorship of conservatives” when the Trump administration is “launching the largest attack on free speech” in decades.

    “Let’s talk about real threats to free speech,” she said. “This month, Secretary Rubio launched ‘catch-and-revoke,’ a horrifying program fueled by AI to monitor student visa holders’ social media accounts for pro-Palestinian views, and mark them for deportation…”

    I don’t agree with Jayapal about many or even most things, but if she’d engaged with me, I’d have noted I too opposed the Antisemitism Awareness Act and the Trump Executive Orders that use the definition of antisemitism written by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA). If asked, I’d have shared some of her concerns while pointing out many of the global censorship bodies I spent years researching (like the EU with its Digital Services Act) not only target anti-immigration protesters and nationalists, but outlaw the very causes Jayapal professes to care most about. For instance, Palestinian activism can be “illegal content” thanks to the same IHRA formula under the DSA, which still has a profound impact on speech on American platforms. It could have been interesting.

    Everything you need to know about modern Democrats, particularly so-called progressives, is encapsulated in the fact that instead of turning to the witness with a lifetime of First Amendment advocacy, Jayapal opened the floor to Nina Jankowicz, a former Homeland Security official who came within a hair of becoming America’s first “Disinformation Governance” chief.

    “Ms. Jankowicz, to clarify for my Republican colleagues,” Jayapal began (independents don’t exist in Congress, even when we sit in witness chairs), “is it true that the Constitution guarantees lawful permanent residents the right to free speech?”

    While Jankowicz answered in the affirmative, my first thought was about a 2006 case filed against the Departments of Homeland Security and State over the so-called “ideological exclusion provision” of the PATRIOT Act, which was endorsed by both parties and used to bar immigrants for speech reasons long before Trump. It was a provision politicians had a chance to change for years, and didn’t.

    Then I thought of the ACLU’s February 2016 efforts to investigate a new DHS “Countering Violent Extremism” program, and how coordination with that “CVE task force” shortly after became a responsibility of Barack Obama’s new “Global Engagement Center,” when he signed its executive order in March 2016. That was the whole point of this hearing, to ask if GEC and DHS took that authority to investigate ISIL and al-Qaeda and abused it by turning it inward, to target “peaceful protest” of Americans. But why would a progressive Democrat ask me about that, when a high-profile former DHS official was available?

    “Is it true,” Jayapal said, “that engaging in peaceful protests is protected by the First Amendment?”

    “That’s right, Congresswoman.”

    I felt like screaming: Why can’t we have both? Why can’t we protect the right to protest and get rid of this horrendous digital censorship apparatus? What is it about Democrats and this issue? The party once had civil libertarians in its ranks. Where did they go?

    Then I remembered how the hearing began. This is just who they are.

    All political groups try to neutralize their critics, but the Democrats’ habit of turning on their own supporters, and casting them as monsters and moral reprobates in elaborate PR campaigns, is unique. If you make the mistake of trying to understand it, as I did for years, it can consume your life. No longer wondering why is what allowed the quick response this time.

    Since 2017 I’ve been in a club that includes Glenn Greenwald, Joe Rogan, Jimmy Dore, Tulsi Gabbard and a long list of others, including non-Americans like Julian Assange and others whose cases are still unfolding. Commonalities include accusations of sexual indiscretion, secret affiliation with Russia or some other foreign power, and financial corruption. Enemies are always evil, not mere disagreers. That vehemence is what stands out. They don’t just excommunicate, they hate. It’s the only sincere part left. Not getting hopes up, but maybe now we’ll find out why?

    Subscribe now

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, Apr 4, 2025: "Tariffs, the Battle in Seattle, and the Triumphant Return of Thomas Friedman, Villain"

    Listen to Episode 129

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: Walter, we’re very matchy-matchy today.

    Walter Kirn: Well, we are. We’re wearing matching County Highway hats. It’s County Highway Magazine, you can subscribe online, because the logos are not particularly prominent on our hats. If you’re wondering what it is, it’s the newspaper I help edit, and Matt has kindly agreed to be twins today.

    Matt Taibbi: Well, I mean, I’m always supportive of County Highway, so I think everybody should have a copy. Also, you and I, Walter... It’s a dissident publication, and you and I have both had personal difficulties this last week, and we can’t share fully today what they are, but we will be able to next week. At least partially.

    Walter Kirn: Yours was on TV.

    Matt Taibbi: Mine was on TV, so that one’s not so much of a mystery, but the other shoe dropping to it is a little bit.

    Walter Kirn: Oh, no. Okay, I can’t wait.

    Matt Taibbi: Well, no, no, no. It’s not necessarily bad news.

    Walter Kirn: Well, mine was on TV too. We actually had video of a criminal doing something to me, and you’ll have to tune in next week. This is going to be a serial drama, and it’s a new way for us to keep and hold subscribers.

    Matt Taibbi: In fact, we may need the audience’s help to get some movement on Walter’s situation at least, because it’s so weird, but we’ll get into it probably next week. Look, obviously a lot going on in the world. There’s a lot of things we could get into, but Walter noticed a tweet that we both thought was fascinating, and that leads us down what Adam Entous would call a Warren. In other words, a rabbit hole, and it’s our old friend, Lee Fang. The first thing he says is, “There’s absolutely no way a time traveler could explain to a 1999 Seattle WTO lefty protester how the era of globalization and American support for free trade would come to an end.” Now, we’re going to have to cut away from this for a second to talk about what he means, and what he means is a series of tariffs that were announced this week. Trump is calling them reciprocal tariffs. If we could just play the beginning of this.

    Donald Trump: If you look at that China, first row. China, 67%. That’s tariffs charged to The USA, including currency manipulation and trade barriers. 67%, I think you can, for the most part, see it. Those with good eyes. With bad eyes, we didn’t want to bring... It’s very windy out here, we didn’t want to bring out the big charts, because it had no chance of standing. Fortunately, we came armed with a little smaller chart, so it’s 67%. We’re going to be charging a discounted reciprocal tariff of 34%. In other words, they charge us, we charge them, we charge them less, so how can anybody be upset?

    Matt Taibbi: Essentially, Trump is slapping tariffs on the whole world. The whole world is currently freaking out about this, but if we go back in our Wayne’s World time machine, Walter, what did it look like in 1999 when the political establishment then led by Bill Clinton was pushing for China to be put into the WTO, given most favored nation trade status, and brought into this community of free trade that was going to cause this worldwide explosion of global wealth-

    Walter Kirn: And peace, love, and understanding.

    Matt Taibbi: peace, love, and understanding as well. That’s a key part of that. We’re going to get into what some of the rhetoric was at the time. People have naturally forgotten what that was, but that 1999 decision to not only beef up the World Trade Organization, but bring China into it. A plainly undemocratic, highly repressive country was being welcomed into the fraternity of Western democratic nations for reasons that didn’t seem to make a whole lot of sense to a lot of people, but particularly the American left at the time.

    Walter Kirn: Then the American left then pledged to the robust protection and wellbeing of the American worker.

    Matt Taibbi: Right. Right, yeah. The American left that supposedly had a sacred bond with the American worker, suddenly didn’t have a problem with all of America’s jobs being moved over to China, and we’ll get into what some of those excuses were at the time, but it led to-

    Walter Kirn: Well, they did have a problem on the streets of Seattle, but...

    Matt Taibbi: Exactly, exactly.

    Walter Kirn: The cops and others got a hold of that one.

    Matt Taibbi: Yep. In fact, let’s give a brief... Let’s do our Wayne’s World time machine and go back to 1999, and if we could just see the battle in Seattle footage.

    Protester 1: Our world, our state. Our world, our state.

    Protester 2: For the most part, it was the police, it was tear gas, it was rubber bullets that were provoking all the chaos in the streets.

    Proterster 3: The criticism of the protesters right now, it’s being portrayed that there is a whole bunch of anarchists that came here just to have fun and smash stores, and there’s very few people that do that. That a lot of people are seriously working to prevent protesters to prevent violence.

    Matt Taibbi: All right, all right. We can stop there. The battle in Seattle was massively propagandized at the time as a ruckus drummed-up by leftist/communist agitators who were breaking glass and doing all these horrible things, and they hugely represented what those protests were about. Most of what the WTO battle in Seattle protesters were upset about was this idea that we were entering into trade agreements that would effectively undermine a century of pro-labor agitation in places like the United States by helping move our labor environment to unfree places where workers without rights would suddenly be competing with workers in the United States. Is that an accurate summation, Walter?

    Walter Kirn: I think it is. There were other deleterious effects to this move. We were going to not only be moving to these jobs to low-wage unfree countries, but to countries which didn’t observe the same niceties of environmental protection-

    Matt Taibbi: Exactly, pollution.

    Walter Kirn: ... and so on. But Bill Clinton, in his wisdom, made sure that goon squads, unseen even during any Trump administration, moved into the streets to get rid of these rats, these anarchists, these communists, these so on.

    Matt Taibbi: It’s really an amazing story, because the Clinton administration began... Remember, the Democratic Party before Clinton was almost entirely beholden to big labor. Big labor was how they organized, big labor was how they raised money. What happened after Walter Mondale got creamed is the party got together and said, “We can’t compete this way. We need some other source of funding,” so they went to Wall Street, and they basically cut a deal and said, “Hey, can we get some of that good nice Wall Street cheddar?” In return, they got some policy changes, the biggest one being Democratic support for a Republican-crafted law called NAFTA, right? Clinton entered the office with a huge betrayal of labor, like a historic one, passing NAFTA, and ended with a subjugation of labor protesters over the WTO in general, and the idea of China getting most favored trading nation status in particular. Now we can zoom back out.

    Walter Kirn: China, not all that many years after Tiananmen Square.

    Matt Taibbi: Right, yeah. I mean, I feel like we had just watched that when this happened. Another thing that Lee tweeted, in addition to saying it would be difficult to explain to a lefty back then, that the end of this arrangement would’ve been fomented by a person that they probably hated more than anybody else in Donald Trump, or they at least would’ve been led to believe they hated. He then linked to a conversation between two political polar opposites. Pat Buchanan, who was one of the first ever... I don’t know. Not one of the first ever, but he was one of the first insurgent nationalist candidates who made hay on the big stage. Is that accurate, Walter?

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, he was. What year again was this covered?

    Matt Taibbi: This would’ve been 2011, so it was way after that,

    Walter Kirn: Right, right.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah.

    Walter Kirn: Pat Buchanan, you know him by the insults hurled at him, “Isolationist, nativist-”

    Matt Taibbi: Racist.

    Walter Kirn: “Racist, nationalist.” I won’t adjudicate the fairness of any of those. I did meet him once, I did interview him once as a journalist when he tried to take the Reform party. I think he did get the Reform Party nomination in 2000 when he ran against...

    Matt Taibbi: Donald Trump.

    Walter Kirn: Well, no, he ran against Bill Clinton and George Bush.

    Matt Taibbi: Right, yes, but-

    Walter Kirn: I mean, Al Gore and George Bush, excuse me.

    Matt Taibbi: Yep, yep. Trump considered that nomination.

    Walter Kirn: Trump considered that, and that’s when I first met Donald Trump, too. Donald Trump and Jesse Ventura in a motel ballroom in Minneapolis or St. Paul, Minnesota when they were considering running. It ended with Pat Buchanan as the nominee, and I went to his convention down in Arlington, Texas and had a very off-the-record, explosive interview with him in which he just railed against the degenerates and the globalists and the people who were selling the US and the US worker to the lowest bidder. He was quite a character, and one thing that can be said, I think, fairly of him was that he was an enemy of what they call the rules-based international order now.

    Matt Taibbi: Exactly. He was, to his core, a nationalist. I think that is an accurate thing to say.

    Walter Kirn: He’s a guy who doesn’t think we should have gotten into World War II, necessarily.

    Matt Taibbi: Yes, and that’s another question, but there are ups and downs to nationalism.

    Walter Kirn: Right, right.

    Matt Taibbi: He explored all of those vigorously, but he’s having a conversation with another figure, Ralph Nader, who is one of the most significant third party figures in this country. He’s famous for being a consumer advocate. We have seat belts in our cars because of Ralph Nader.

    Walter Kirn: Who, ironically, in some minds, would decide the 2000 election in which Pat Buchanan ran and Al Gore and George Bush. Would decide it not intentionally, but perhaps on a practical basis for George Bush, in that he is thought to have sucked votes away from Gore.

    Matt Taibbi: He sucked my vote away from Gore.

    Walter Kirn: Interesting.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. Nader went on to become one of the first symbols of what we now call Lawfare. In his subsequent runs for president, he was continually litigated against. Every signature that he ever collected was challenged, he was struck from the ballot or disallowed from ballots over and over and over again, the Democrats did everything in their power to make sure he could not run. He has some bitterness about it, but he and Buchanan, ideologically, would seem to be opposites. In 2011, in the middle of the Occupy Wall Street protests, they have a discussion. They start to talk about things, including the battle in Seattle, and there is a moment where they both entertain the possibility that, yes, the left version of populism and right version of populism might have found middle ground.

    Patrick Buchanan: I don’t think we’ll be a country in the sense that John Jay and Federalist too described us as one unique separate people.

    Ralph Nader: Yet, you know this Occupy Wall Street effort that’s proliferating in hundreds of communities, it’s marked by a great diversity of background, cultures, religions, race united against the power of Wall Street and Washington in a desperate search for a more democratic society. Not just political, but economic. How do you explain that? That seems to be against the…

    Patrick Buchanan: That’s what I’m saying.

    Ralph Nader: Yeah.

    Patrick Buchanan: Well, I do think, I think that the measure of unity that they have, I think one of the reasons they have it is because they’re not defining their demands. I’ve seen some of their 13 demands, and I’m sure some of those folks who are Tea Party types would not be in favor of those demands. I think there’s no question about it. Well, I agree with the fundamental premise of the Occupy Wall Street folks, which is, “Look, these fellas up here played the highest stakes poker game in the world, they had a great time, they made billions of dollars, and then all of a sudden, they were wiped out, and they ran to Uncle and said, ‘Give us back our chips,’ and Uncle gave them back his chips. Now they’re playing again, and they got the bonuses, and everybody out in middle America is suffering. You got 9% unemployment and 16% probably active, unemployed, and those searching for work.” I share the exasperation and the anger and the rage at that inequity and injustice.

    Matt Taibbi: I mean, Walter, that’s a pretty significant moment, don’t you think?

    Walter Kirn: It’s a very significant moment, because there was the ability to agree on that simple premise, that the financial interests and the working interests of the country were opposed. Now, that’s pretty basic going back in American political economic history, but it has since become muddied and controversial, but there was that clear moment where they could both agree that the wellbeing of America and the American working class middle class and lower-middle class was to be esteemed at least as highly as the wellbeing of the financial class, which had one benefit the working class doesn’t, which is they can be bailed out.

    Read more

    0 min
  • Timeline: Cutbacks at HHS
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Layoff notices went out this week to some 10,000 employees of the Department of Health and Human Services.

    HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced the cuts March 27 to go along with another 10,000 who took early retirement or voluntary separation offers.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    Layoff notices were emailed Tuesday to employees — April Fool’s Day. It was no joke.

    We want to give attention to FOIA staff cuts at HHS, as public records are a key component of our Racket Library.

    Staff who fulfill public records requests took a huge hit in RFK Jr’s reorganization.

    The CDC’s FOIA office was reportedly eliminated, for example. Exactly how many of the 336 full-time FOIA staff members at HHS are affected is unclear. For example, Bloomberg reports all FOIA staff in the FDA were dismissed, while CBS reports it was two-thirds of staff.

    Racket asked HHS for a breakdown of FOIA layoffs, but only received a recycled statement about FOIA offices being “siloed.” There was no response to a follow-up question asking for a breakdown, possibly because public information officers are part of the layoffs.

    In any case, expect a much longer wait for any public records, says attorney Allan Blutstein of FOIA Advisor:

    The records that are of public interest will remain undisclosed, and for longer periods. I suspect what staff remains is likely to be focused on litigation because it’s much easier to ignore a FOIA requester than a plaintiff in court. So unless your request is in litigation, you’ll be likely further back in the processing que and the delays will just intensify.

    HHS had 51,800 FOIA requests in 2024, according to FOIA.gov — the fifth-highest of all government agencies. The top five in FOIA requests:

    1. Homeland Security: 911,535
    2. Dept. of Justice: 132,527
    3. Veterans Affairs: 105,725
    4. Dept. of Defense: 61,858
    5. Health/Human Services: 51,800

    Blutstein suspects HHS and other agencies will rely more on outside contractors to fulfill requests.

    “I assume they’re cheaper, but in my experience they’re also not as good.”

    Children’s Health Defense, an organization Kennedy founded, was a prolific filer of FOIA requests and lawsuits under his leadership, often against HHS agencies.

    Under federal FOIA law, the government must respond to FOIA requests within 20 days, excluding weekends and holidays. So, what happens if government agencies fail to respond and fulfill requests within that window because they don’t have staff?

    Blutstein says that hasn’t been answered yet, but a federal judge last month addressed the issue in a case that the Center to Advance Security in America (CASA) brought against the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).

    In a consent motion — which means both parties agree to it — USAID asked for a stay on CASA’s FOIA request and to instead provide a status report in May. The motion notes only three FOIA staff remained at USAID following massive layoffs announced Feb. 23.

    “These three employees are now responsible for processing 1002 valid FOIA requests, fifteen open litigations, three appeals, and twelve consultations,” the motion says.

    U.S. District Court Judge Randolph Moss granted the stay, but strongly indicated he would not have if CASA objected to the request.

    In the present context, the Court is skeptical that an agency can avoid its obligations under FOIA—including the obligation to process a request in an efficient and prompt manner— by simply implementing a reduction-in-force…FOIA’s demand for expedition—and, indeed, more generally, FOIA’s requirement that agencies release all non-exempt, responsive records—would be rendered meaningless if an agency could avoid these statutory obligations through the simple expedient of dismissing its FOIA staff.

    031125 Moss Order148KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    As for the FOIA staff cutbacks at HHS, an unnamed agency official told CBS that the goal is to have all FOIA staff in a central location, but a final decision has not been made.

    Below is a brief timeline of statements leading up to the layoffs, as well as reaction:

    February 13, 2025

    During his swearing-in ceremony, Kennedy vows to bring “radical transparency” to the department and its agencies. The following exchange starts at 7:13 in the video above:

    REPORTER: If I could ask you, Mr. Secretary, do you plan to fire anyone immediately? Or what are your plans on day one, which I guess is today?

    SECRETARY KENNEDY: Our plans are radical transparency and returning gold-standard science to NIH, to the FDA, and CDC – to end – ending the corruption, ending the corporate capture of those agencies, getting rid of the people on those panels that have conflicts of interest. We can do unadorned and unimpeded science, rather than the kind of product that is coming out of those agencies today.

    Remarks By President Trump And Secretary Of The Department Of Health And Human Services Robert F226KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 27, 2025

    Kennedy announces that he is cutting 10,000 employees.

    In a video posted to X, Kennedy says the Biden administration increased staff by 17% but “all that money has failed to improve the health of Americans.”

    He talks of a “sprawling bureaucracy,” and announces his plans “to eliminate an entire alphabet soup of departments at agencies while preserving their core functions….”

    A fact sheet breaks down cuts among the FDA, CDC, National Institutes for Health and the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services:

    • FDA: 3,500 full-time employees (HHS says it does not affect drug, medical device, or food reviewers, or inspectors).

    • CDC: 2,400 employees.

    • NIH: 1,200 employees.

    • CMS: 300 employees.

    Fact Sheet Hhs’ Transformation To Make America Healthy Again Hhs102KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 28, 2025

    Congresswoman Diana DeGette, D-Colorado, the ranking member of the House Energy & Commerce Health Subcommittee, issues a statement attacking Kennedy and DOGE:

    Secretary Kennedy and DOGE’s illegal assault on public health is going to harm the American people, weaken American leadership, and destroy our ability to combat diseases and research groundbreaking cures and treatments. He is circumventing Congressional authority and putting culture wars over science. His actions are going to harm our national biosecurity, stop cures for cancer, and leave everyday Americans unable to access the care they need.

    April 1, 2025

    Deputy Assistant Secretary for Human Resources Thomas Nagy sends early-morning emails to more than 10,000 HHS workers informing them that they will lose their jobs (see example below).

    The layoff notices cite an executive order President Trump signed Feb. 11 to implement the DOGE Workforce Optimization Initiative.

    Later in the day, Kennedy posts the following on X:

    Sen. Bill Cassidy, the chairman of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, and ranking member Sen. Bernie Sanders send Kennedy a letter (see below) asking him to appear before their committee to discuss his “proposed reorganization.” The hearing is scheduled for April 10.

    2025 04 01 HHS Notice of RIF195KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadExecutive Order 14210169KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload25 04 10 Kennedy Witness Invitation HHS Restructuring192KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadApril 2, 2025

    House Democrats push Republican leaders to have Kennedy appear before the Energy and Commerce Committee. Republicans only agree to a briefing from HHS staff.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • A Response to a Member of Congress

    Sydney Kamlager-Dove, a Democrat representing California’s 37th district in Los Angeles, began her opening remarks in a House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee hearing Tuesday with a comment directed to me. “To distract from the dumpster fire this administration is pursuing,” she said, the Republicans were “elevating a serial sexual harrasser as their star witness.”

    Right after the hearing, she re-tweeted the comment on X and BlueSky, writing, “After this, Republicans gave Matt Taibbi time to defend himself. It’s telling that he didn’t.”

    There is not much a person like me can say to a member of Congress hiding behind the protections of the Speech and Debate clause of the Constitution.

    One can however respond to a member arrogant enough to repeat those claims on social media. I’ve now done so, in the form of a $10 million libel lawsuit filed today in a New Jersey federal court:

    Taibbivkamlagerdove1.26MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    Rep. Kamlager-Dove, no woman has ever accused me of engaging in sexual harrassment once, let alone serially. See you in court. Please do not evade service.

    0 min