
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Late Tuesday night, I recalled the late Harry G. Frankfurt’s increasingly relevant, “On Bullshit.”
When we characterize talk as hot air, we mean that what comes out of the speaker’s mouth is only that. It is mere vapor. His speech is empty, without substance or content. His use of language, accordingly, does not contribute to the purpose it purports to serve. No more information is communicated than if the speaker had merely exhaled.
I thought of that book as I was watching Democratic Delegate Stacey Plaskett’s performance on the House floor as she defended herself on a censure resolution inspired by revelations in the Washington Post that she received coaching from world-renowned scumbag Jeffrey Epstein during a 2019 hearing, as she prepared to question former Trump lawyer and fixer Michael Cohen.
The Post story and accompanying video are damning. Of course, the revelations are a bigger story because they involve Epstein. He was still a few months out from being charged with a slew of sex trafficking offenses, but he was still a registered sex offender, as she effectively said, “Jeffrey, take the wheel.” However, this is bad no matter who was driving her questioning in real time. She was nothing more than a ventriloquist dummy, and if you haven’t seen the video, judge for yourself:
Subscribe now
Epstein was only a constituentThe censure resolution failed, but make no mistake that her performance was “Mission Accomplished”-level bull. Plaskett starts by heaping praise on herself for a “moment that went viral” earlier in the hearing during an interaction with Republican Congressman Jim Jordan. That, she claims, prompted “innumerable texts” from friends, foes, and constituents.
And I got a text from Jeffrey Epstein, who at the time was my constituent, who was not public knowledge at that time that he was under federal investigation and, who was sharing information with me.
So of all those supposed “innumerable texts,” Epstein just happened to stand out as if he were any other constituent. It was just a coincidence, then, that a few months earlier she landed $30,000 from him for the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and that he had already given maximum amounts to her own campaigns. Yes, he was a constituent, but so what? Bob Menendez also had “constituents.”
“I don’t need to get advice…”Now I heard recently from someone that I was taking advice from him. Let me tell you something: I don’t need to get advice on how to question anybody from any individual.”
This one is my personal favorite because the video from 2019 clearly shows she did need advice!
Epstein pointed out to Plaskett that “Cohen brought up RONA - keeper of the secrets.”
“RONA” is Rhona Graff, a former executive assistant to Trump. Plaskett was thrown for a loop.
“RONA ??” she texted back.
Forty-one seconds went by. She still couldn’t figure it out.
Plaskett: “Quick I’m up next is that an acronym?”
Epstein: “Thats his assistant.”
Just in time. She proceeded to ask Cohen three questions about Graff, twice referring to her as “Ms. Rona.” Plaskett grew up in Brooklyn, so I doubt she was exhibiting Southern pleasantries.
In any case, Epstein was pleased. “Good work,” he texted.
Plaskett also mentioned her experience as a narcotics prosecutor in New York and her appointment to the Justice Department after 9/11. “I know how to question individuals,” she said.
The Washington PostPlaskett takes aim at the Post, saying she questioned Cohen for five minutes. In case there’s any doubt, she waves a transcript as if to say, Proof! Plaskett then complains, “The Washington Post only shows you 30 seconds and takes from it one individual’s name that I got from Jeffrey Epstein, and didn’t know who the individual was.”
This 30 seconds claim is more nonsense. While the video shows Plaskett questioning Cohen for roughly 30 seconds, most of it shows her and the text exchanges just before her questioning begins. The text exchange concerning “Ms. Rona” spanned about 10 minutes, although not continuously. The first text exchange, however, occurred several hours earlier, before the hearing began.
In fact, there were many more texts throughout the day that were reported in the Post’s story but weren’t shown in the video, which of course Plaskett conveniently ignored. The exchanges, after all, indicated they were buddies.
At 10:02 a.m., Epstein texted Plaskett: “Great outfit”
“You look great,” he added at 10:22 a.m. “Thanks!” she replied shortly afterward.
At around 10:40 a.m., a broadcast feed cut to Plaskett, showing her moving her mouth as if she were chewing something.
At 10:41 a.m., Epstein sent this message to Plaskett: “Are you chewing”
“Not any more,” she replied. “Chewing interior of my mouth. Bad habit from middle school”
At 12:50 p.m., Epstein asks: “How much longer for you”
“Hours. Go to other mtgs,” she replied.
The intermittent exchanges spanned nearly seven hours, from 7:55 a.m. to at least 2:34 p.m. There is no substance to this twisted version of the record, just a deeper pile of bull.
“Weaponized it for Political Theater”Plaskett now presented herself as a victim of government weaponization:
“They’ve taken a text exchange, which show no participation, no assistance, no involvement in any illegal activity, and weaponized it for political theater, because that’s what this is.
This is another trait of a good bullshitter: Imply your critics are doing something they’re not. No one accused Plaskett of doing something illegal by texting Epstein. It was just a way to deflect from her actions.
Fortunately, she’s not a voting member of Congress since she represents the Virgin Islands. Obviously, though, she still has a large platform. Who’s coaching her now?
Subscribe now
From CNBC:
Former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers said Monday that he was stepping back from all public commitments amid fallout from the release of emails between him and the notorious sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.
“I am deeply ashamed of my actions and recognize the pain they have caused. I take full responsibility for my misguided decision to continue communicating with Mr. Epstein,” Summers said in a statement obtained by CNBC.
“While continuing to fulfill my teaching obligations, I will be stepping back from public commitments as one part of my broader effort,” said Summers, a former president of Harvard University…
Larry Summers is a rare perfect 10 on the celebrity-repugnance scale. He’s everything most normal people can’t stand about the current crop of “elites”: an arrogant Davos fixture whose toad face always looks pleased with his legacy of disastrous policy decisions, and who personifies his class’s habit of lavishing exalted academic titles on intellectual mediocrity.
Now he’s pioneered a new ritual, auto-cancelation. “I will be stepping back from public commitments” is cancel-culture seppuku, a way to give the mob a win before it gets going. That’s always a questionable tactic, but especially with the Jeffrey Epstein story, which is fast acquiring a familiar shape: a factually diffuse moral mania used as a disciplinary weapon by a media sector hungry for pelts.
The exchanges between Summers and Epstein are head-poundingly banal, like 99.9% of the documents in the just-released “trove” of Epstein-related documents. Summers is guilty of knowing Epstein and having pseudo-intellectual discussions with him about a mistress nicknamed “peril,” who Summers feared might stray. Epstein compared the possibility to finding life on other planets, and tried to cheer Summers up by flattering the ex-Treasury Secretary’s fascination with Bayesian statistics:
Odds are limited to binary outcomes… since you are immobile. Do some homework… I concede your point on pessimism but would under bayesian rules. Feel comfortable. As humans are biased toward bad outcome avoidance… She is never ever going to find another Larry summers. Probability ZERO
It went on. “Send peril flowers,” Epstein advised. The two men briefly discussed whether Ehud Barak would be Prime Minister (this was July, 2019). Then Summers wrote, “At cape w mother brothers kids and nephews nieces. Bit of an Ibsen play.” Then it was “better than [sic] checov.” When the two pals from there plunged into a Google-aided discussion of Lady With Lapdog, I shut the computer off.
Congress voted yesterday to compel the Department of Justice to release in “searchable and downloadable format” all files related to Epstein within thirty days. The House vote was 427-1. Though Ro Khanna, Thomas Massie, and Mike Johnson all voiced concerns, only Louisiana Republican Clay Higgins actually voted no, saying that “this type of broad reveal of criminal investigative files, released to a rabid media, will absolutely result in innocent people being hurt.”
Predictably now Higgins is being teed up as a cancellation target, as social media fills with Meet the Lone Dickhead Who Voted Against Releasing the Epstein Files-type stories, each of which lists every maybe-naughty thing Higgins has ever done. This format, seen a lot in Russiagate with dissenters like Devin Nunes and Tulsi Gabbard, usually comes as prelude to a flood of Stubborn Ownthinker Faces Calls To Step Aside pieces, another fun part of the cancelation ritual.
For the record I’m very much in favor of releasing any Epstein files. The country deserves to know whatever there is to know about this mess, and if it exposes systemic wrongdoings, those need fixing. However, it’s extremely suspicious that a story that was deader than Epstein himself for years is suddenly the Most Important Thing now that Trump is back in the White House, especially since a lot of the techniques used to drive a media panic in the first Trump term are back. The fact that some of Trump’s top officials stoked public outrage about this subject en route to higher office does change the karmic equation this time, however.
Between Epstein’s beyond-suspicious death, multiple prosecutions for sex crimes, inexplicable $600 million fortune, and breathtaking Rolodex of powerful friends, there’s a lot to be curious about. But the public’s fascination with Epstein is based on the notion that he was not only operating an organized blackmail ring, but doing so on behalf of intelligence agencies, probably Israeli. That story simply isn’t there yet, and a lot of people who should know better, myself included, have assumed it is. It could be true, which is why releasing documents is a good idea. As of now, though, it’s closer to Russiagate, in which confirmable facts are overshadowed by a mountain range of inference:
Subscribe now
The gap between what’s known about Epstein and what the press claims is known is large. His two criminal cases are, to put it mildly, strange. The much-criticized non-prosecution agreement of 2007 is a solicitation charge. The more serious 2019 case features a count for conspiracy to commit sex trafficking, and a count of sex trafficking. This is how the Department of Justice described his crimes:
From at least 2002 through at least 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and recruited, dozens of minor girls to visit his mansion in New York, New York… to engage in sex acts with him, after which he would give the victims hundreds of dollars in cash. In order to maintain and increase his supply of victims, EPSTEIN also paid certain victims to recruit additional underage girls whom he could similarly abuse. In this way, EPSTEIN created a vast network of underage victims for him to sexually exploit, often on a daily basis, in locations including New York and Palm Beach… EPSTEIN’s victims were as young as 14 at the time he abused them, and were, for various reasons, often particularly vulnerable to exploitation.
Though there are civil actions that include more serious allegations, Epstein’s last criminal case essentially accuses him of conspiracy to traffic women to himself. The lack of a formal accusation of trafficking to other men (or women, apart from Ghislaine Maxwell) might be seen as a reason to view the two cases as lacking or corrupt. Still, that absence is what it is.
One of the most aggressively publicized accusations of trafficking, made by the late Virginia Giuffre against lawyer Alan Dershowitz, was retracted. “I may have made a mistake in identifying Mr. Dershowitz,” she said, eight years after claiming in a lawsuit that Epstein “required” her to have sex with him “on numerous occasions while she was a minor, not only in Florida but also on private planes, in New York, New Mexico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.” This episode is almost never mentioned and the few reporters who do, like Michael Tracey, are treated like lepers (Tracey was even thrown out of an event for “victims and survivors” in September).
Things like this make it hard to know how to assess other stories, like Giuffre’s claims about Prince Andrew, or Thomas Pritzker, or the academic she described as a “quirky little man with a balding pate of white hair,” or any of the other enconuters described in gory detail in the posthumously published memoir Nobody’s Girl, which her own lawyers once described as a “fictionalized” account. The situation is also compounded, as Tracey has noted, by the agreement in Ghislaine Maxwell’s trial that allowed self-identified victims to testify pseudonymously, and by the vast sums of settlement money paid to victims by banks and the Epstein estate.
Half of the Epstein fascination is tied up in what NPR and other outlets freely call this “sex trafficking ring” side of the story. The other half is the “shadowy” tale of his “ties to Israeli intelligence.” As is the case with the trafficking story, there are a lot of compelling facts here, but what they add up to isn’t clear. Some of the strongest material involves correspondence between Epstein and Barak purloined by the Handala hacker group. As Ryan Grim and Murtaza Hussein point out on Drop Site, they appear to show Epstein brokering a security deal between Israel and Mongolia, while just-released Epstein calendars show an Israeli spy named Yoni Koren stayed at his house. As Grim and Hussein put it, if one puts the pieces together, “a portrait emerges of Epstein at the nexus of high-ranking intelligence officials in both the U.S. and Israel.”
It’s all fascinating stuff. It may end up in the place lots of people seem to believe it will. I see strong evidence that Epstein mistreated a huge number of women and girls and similarly strong evidence that he had close ties to senior Israeli officials, but also with American politicians like Bill Clinton and Donald Trump. What’s missing is evidence about all those things having meaning in coordination.
During Russiagate we saw mainstream press outlets regularly run a type of story old-school journalists were once warned against: the “if true…” feature. When the Steele dossier and the pee tape material came out, we regularly saw descriptions of the allegations like “if true, the president-elect of the United States would be vulnerable to blackmail by the Russians,” or “information that, if true, could be used to blackmail him or undermine his presidency.” Nobody actually had the story, but the possibility was so tantalizing that everyone ran with it, which in turn left audiences with the impression of something proven.
The same thing is happening with this story, in media that plays to left and right audiences. Smart commentators like Branko Marcetic of Jacobin are leading off articles as follows:
We know that Donald Trump was extremely close with an incredibly prolific child sex abuser, Jeffrey Epstein. But recent revelations raise another question: Was Trump’s association with Epstein used by Israel to amass political leverage and influence US policy?
These stories use a lot of the same tropes that we saw with Russiagate, like “It fits with what we know about how Russia/Israel operates” and “Trump’s servility to Putin/Netanyahu is otherwise hard to fathom.” These “if true” stories are getting a lot of purchase on the left because of a combination of #MeToo fervor and pro-Palestinian activism, while right-leaning audiences are responding to a combo of fears about secret child trafficking and oft-validated suspicions about the deep state.
Bret Weinstein suggests we posit that the “cartoon view” of Epstein as an intelligence front is true, in order to ask if the spook services have so much leverage over us that “the democratic nature of our society is a fiction.” Tucker Carlson, whom I obviously also know well, has been outspoken in saying Epstein was part of a “blackmail operation run by the CIA and the Israeli intel services.” He asks a similar question:
It shouldn’t need pointing out that “who’s really running the White House?” was a common trope of the Russiagate period. So were stories that catalogued “links,” read into tales of “secret backchannels,” or declared people “assets” of a foreign country, all practices coming back into vogue.
The Epstein story has more force than Russiagate because it has a firmer floor of compelling facts, both in the tales of sexual abuse and procurement and in the area of Epstein’s political ties. Still, verifiable reports linking these two things are almost totally absent. With Russiagate, deep-seated fears about the communist enemy helped drive the mania. Here, it looks like newswriters are depending on darker attitudes to help audiences to make the needed connections on their own. The press watchdog FAIR made a point of reminding audiences that Tucker and Candace Owens are Israel-focused because they’re attention-seeking bigots, while their own speculations are fact-based:
It’s true that far-right antisemites like Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson have promoted a conspiratorial version of the Epstein/Israel connection as part of their bigoted, attention-seeking narratives. But recent investigations by Drop Site News—the nonprofit investigative outlet founded in July 2024—into a major hack targeting Israel revealed that Epstein did play a significant role in brokering multiple deals for Israeli intelligence.
I’m all for the release of the Epstein files, whatever that means, and I wouldn’t be shocked by anything a truly full disclosure might reveal. By any standard it’s already a crazy story, a pedophile confidante of world leaders who managed “suicide” while serving time as world’s most watched prisoner on remand. But there are a lot of unknowns. Purely as a media phenomenon, Epstein mania currently has a giant hole in it where the presumed intelligence/blackmail operation should be. It could be there. But I wouldn’t bet against more prosaic truths emerging, either.
From the Washington Post:
The newly released documents from Jeffrey Epstein’s estate show that the convicted sex offender texted with a Democratic member of Congress, Del. Stacey Plaskett of the U.S. Virgin Islands, during a congressional hearing with Michael Cohen, and that those text messages may have influenced the congresswoman’s questions of Cohen, President Donald Trump’s former personal attorney and fixer.
The Post story went on to describe exchanges from February 2019 in which Virgin Islands delegate Stacey Plaskett asked for guidance on questioning in the middle of the Cohen hearing. When Cohen mentioned Donald Trump's executive assistant Rhona Graff, Epstein texted the quasi-congressperson. “Cohen brought up RONA - keeper of the secrets,” he wrote, to which Plaskett replied, “RONA??” and, “Quick I’m up next is that an acronym.” YouTube is already flooded with videos, some darkly funny, like the Washington Post’s own effort at time-coding the puppetry act. Note the “Miss Rhona” dance around the unknown last name:
The list of high-ranking politicians from both parties who traveled with or took money from Epstein — Donald Trump and Bill Clinton included (what was the latter’s “humanitarian” visit to Siberia with him about?) — boggles the mind. A character like Epstein can only thrive in a world where law enforcement and intelligence are fully intertwined with financial and sexual corruption, to the point where one has to entertain the idea that significant numbers of politicians are compromised, perhaps even in a form of systemic blackmail. That isn’t an easy thing to believe. In the words of the disgraced and disgraceful writer Michael Wolff, whose ostentatious presence at the middle of this story casts doubt on all of it, Epstein represents “the kind of insiderism that is mostly just a figment in outsiders’ fantasies.”
Except, as Wolff accurately notes, “Epstein is real.” This is certainly a momentous story about something. For a long list of reasons that includes Wolff’s insistence that it’s true, I find it difficult to believe “the central issue is Trump’s relationship with this monster.” More likely, full exposure of the Epstein saga would tune the public into a generation of indefensible official bargains and power plays, which is why the Trump administration’s summer turnaround on releases has justifiably come at big political cost. Trump campaigning last year compared Epstein to the Kennedy assassination. “Kennedy’s interesting because it’s so many years ago. They do that for danger too, because it endangers certain people,” he said, adding, “But I’d be inclined to do the Epstein. I’d have no problem with it.”
With his own Director and Deputy Director of the FBI on record questioning Epstein’s cause of death, and Trump’s daughter on record calling for “more transparency,” the sudden about-face had to involve heavy leverage somewhere. That doesn’t mean the Democrats’ braying about this issue hasn’t been ridiculous and hypocritical. If the Epstein rabbit holes are as deep for other members as they are just for Plaskett, we may have to put the whole system on suicide watch. It’s that bad:
Subscribe now
“Release all of the Epstein Files” was a siren call for the MSNOW set as recently as this weekend, but now that Trump has issued a statement calling for House Republicans to vote for their release because “we have nothing to hide,” everything is in play. The House Oversight Committee already started the avalanche with a series of releases that over the weekend had me answering TextEdit prompts like, “Are you sure you want to open 897 files?”
If you’re a Democrat, you’ve already seen the Trump lowlights: a 2011 email from Epstein saying of former Mar-a-Lago spa attendant Virginia Giuffre, “VICTIM spent hours at my house with him,” and this 2019 note to author Michael Wolff: “Of course [Trump] knew about the girls.” There are mitigating docs with both issues (Giuffre, another suicide from earlier this year, wrote Trump “couldn’t have been friendlier” in a posthumously published memoir). Still, Pam Bondi’s Epstein files pirouette earlier this year never made sense and has been driving intramural MAGA turmoil since, with Marjorie Taylor Greene now railing against the idea that “rich, powerful people should be protected.” For an administration that’s done well sending roaches scurrying in the FBI, CIA, and DHS via Russiagate and Covid investigations, Epstein stands out as an unforced error. If it’s not dirt on Trump himself, and administration sources insist it isn’t, what’s the holdup?
Democratic Party hysteria over this issue is obviously absurd because “all of the Epstein files” could have been released over the last four years. There must be reasons why the last administration didn’t take that step, and there should be scandal in MAGA-world if those reasons overlap at all with the Trump administration’s. Between Epstein’s own hysterical rants about Trump in the newly released documents (he sounds like Kathy Griffin in some of the emails) and the blue party’s seeming entanglement with Epstein from the Clintons to Larry Summers to Reid Hoffman, it’s hard to imagine where that overlap might be, unless it involves major corporate names and/or overseas relationships. Some of that is suggested in Plaskett’s story.
Plaskett was a listed recipient of campaign contributions from Epstein, and briefly also a defendant in a lawsuit filed by five alleged Jane Doe victims of Epstein. The action against Plaskett was voluntarily dismissed after her lawyers filed a motion to be removed from the suit, but the original complaint remains ugly public record. It accuses Plaskett and a long list of other figures of having “facilitated Epstein in his ongoing sex trafficking operation” by ensuring he “received preferential treatment and unfettered, unmonitored freedom” while in U.S. Virgin Islands.
Financial records of “substantial payments” to some of those defendants do appear in the exhibits of another damning lawsuit, U.S. Virgin Islands v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, to the point where it’s clear government officials in the Virgin Islands and significant Wall Street players were deeply compromised when it came to the operation of Epstein’s empire. The depository records alone make a joke of, say, the anti-money-laundering (AML) controls that ostensibly obligate banks to press pause and investigate if any of dozens of red flags pop up in connection with an account (like “unusual transfers of funds”). One paragraph from the Chase complaint stood out:
In October 2012, the Southern Trust Company—one of the companies Epstein owned— applied for economic benefits from the Virgin Islands Economic Development Commission (“EDC”) so the company could provide “cutting edge consulting services” in the area of “biomedical and financial informatics.” Southern Trust Company received a 10-year package of economic incentives running from February 1, 2013 until January 31, 2023 that included a 90% exemption from income taxes and 100% exemptions from gross receipts, excise, and withholding taxes in the Virgin Islands.
Plaskett was the general counsel for the aforementioned Virgin Islands Economic Development Commission for five years between 2007 and 2012, listed as leaving just before the deal outlined above. She was an attorney at Kellerhals Ferguson Kroblin PLLC, the firm that handled Epstein’s taxes and helped him purchase Little St. James Island. It appears that’s where she worked during an unaccounted-for LinkedIn gap of a few years between 2012 and her election in 2015. In a 2023 deposition she was asked if she did any work for Epstein or “Epstein-related businesses” while at the firm. She answered, “I don’t recall.”
When asked what she did during a visit to Epstein’s home, she said she was raising money for the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee at that time, and that the possibility that she asked for $250,000 “does not sound unreasonable.” She also suggested she’d received around $30,000 in donations from him, but that he never asked anything of her. Apparently, suggesting questions in televised hearings doesn’t count:
“YOU ASK THEM.” Stacey Plaskett on how you get people like Jeffrey Epstein to donateTwo years ago, Stacey Plaskett led a fusillade of surreal questions from Democrats when I testified in Congress for the first time about digital censorship. Epstein by then had long since been suicided, but the interrogation was both so hostile and half-assed that I wondered mid-hearing if members were being fed queries by tweet or text.
Now we learn this not only happens, but the voice spotting lines for an elected official on live TV might be the worst person in the world. Such realizations make for a wince-hard moment for the whole American population, which may have to adjust its estimation of our politicians down from totally corrupt if all these files are released. As was the case with the Russiagate documents, these releases continue an education in the rotten way things really work in this country that I suspect both parties will quickly regret voting to serve up.
Apart from the fact that there’s so much background (“It’s a lot,” is how one reporter friend put it), one of the reasons I previously hesitated to dig into Epstein is because it seemed like the kind of story where the key details would never see the light of day. Now we have a perfect storm of partisan wrangling that might change that equation. It’s always a good thing to know more, but prepare for this one to be particularly depressing if it actually pans out. More on ATW later today.
Join Walter and Matt for another episode of America This Week Live.
Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
See you soon!
Perhaps the quote that will define the next Great Financial Crisis will be this one from an executive at a former lender to the $10 billion fraud known as First Brands.
“You’re not paid to do due diligence in this market.”
There have been three high-profile Private Credit (PC) blowups in the past month. All were due to fraud, and all had telltale signs of problems ahead if anyone bothered to look under the hood. However, in the mad rush to get the deals done and put investor funds to work to earn those sweet management fees, as the First Brands lender said, “You’re not paid to do due diligence in this market.”
The same was true leading up to the 2008 subprime mortgage crisis. No one was looking under the hood of either the borrowers or the lenders. The game plan was to make your money, move on to the next deal, feign ignorance when it all blows up, get a bailout, and let others pay the price.
PC has made significant inroads into a sector of the economy known as “middle markets.” Middle market companies generally have annual revenues between $50 million and $1 billion. According to a recent report from Morgan Stanley:
The middle market represents a significant cross-section of the US economy, accounting for one-third of private sector GDP, $13 trillion in revenue and 50 million workers employed.4 Despite this, banks have largely withdrawn from the middle market as they have grown larger via consolidation and more constrained with their lending due to the flood of regulations post the Great Financial Crisis.
PC has filled that void left by commercial banks. In and of itself, investor funds using their capital to provide needed funds for this crucial sector was a good thing. However, it seems like we’ve crossed over to a point where middle market companies have become overleveraged, as the sector is, according to Asset Asset-Based Finance Journal,
… awash in private credit, fueling dealmaking at a breakneck pace as 2025 unfolds. With economic volatility—driven by persistent high interest rates, fiscal uncertainty, and a flood of complex financing—comes a pressing need to stress-test debt capacity … S&P Global Ratings reveals a stark reality: average leverage across its U.S. middle market credit estimate population hit 7x [debt to Earnings Before Interest Taxes Depreciation Amortization] in 2024.
Generally a ratio of 3x is considered relatively safe.
What this means is this vital sector of American business faces enhanced risk of a downturn in the economy and or an increase in borrowing rates. The employment picture in the U.S. economy is already showing signs of softening. A contagion in the middle markets could spread rapidly, bringing unemployment, business failures and sharp pullback in funding for the entire economy.
Then there’s the whole “fraud thing.”
Subscribe now
Since we reported in October on the First Brands fiasco, there have been two more high profile private credit blowouts. From the Wall Street Journal:
The lenders have accused Bankim Brahmbhatt, the owner of little-known telecom-services companies Broadband Telecom and Bridgevoice, of fabricating accounts receivable that were supposed to be used as loan collateral. The lenders filed suit in August. They said Brahmbhatt’s companies owe them more than $500 million.
In another recent debacle, BlackRock’s private credit fund TCP Capital Corp valued the debt it extended to Renovo Home Partners to be worth 100 cents on the dollar as late as this past September and by November, Renovo declared Chapter 7 bankruptcy and the loan was valued as zero. From Bloomberg:
It was no mystery Renovo was in a tough spot. In April, lenders had agreed to take losses and convert some of their loans into equity as part of a recapitalization that was
supposed to give the company a chance to turn its business around, the people said. In the third quarter, they also allowed for deferred cash interest payments on its restructured debt, an arrangement known as payment-in-kind, regulatory filings show. Yet at the end of September, funds managed by BlackRock and MidCap Financial were still marking the new Renovo debt at par, which typically indicates investors expect to be paid back in full.
The two biggest Hail Marys in the credit business — debt for equity swaps and deferred interest payments (payment in kind) — were being thrown at this pig, and still BlackRock and MidCap valued the loans to Renovo at 100 cents on the dollar and then valued them at zero in the span of a few weeks. Some — perhaps investors — might call that fraud, too.
Life Insurers and Credit RatingsIn the last Great Financial Crisis, the credit rating agencies S&P and Moody’s played a huge role in letting the whole subprime meltdown happen. Bloomberg News reported earlier this month that the SEC was probing rating firm Egan-Jones.
UBS Chairman Colm Kelleher flagged early signs of “huge rating agency arbitrage in the insurance business,” while the Bank for International Settlements pointed
to potential “inflated assessments of creditworthiness” by small ratings agencies last month. Egan-Jones has billed itself as the most prolific grader in the private market and last year rated more than 3,000 private credit investments — all with about 20 analysts.
But don’t worry! A company rep said it “remains in good standing” with regulators and is “dedicated” to serving clients, who happen to be the private credit fund managers. Maybe that’s the problem, guys!
We reported in July that Private Equity firms such as Apollo, Blackstone, KKR, and Brookfield were snapping up life insurance companies to get at their steady premium income and annuity businesses. They refer to their insurance company holdings as “permanent capital.” Life insurers have also been engaging in pension risk transfers, taking corporate pensions over, another rich vein of permanent capital. A good deal of this permanent capital goes into their PC funds. The insurance companies rely on rating firms to manage their risk, or perhaps more importantly, their regulators rely on the ratings to judge the creditworthiness of insurance companies. This is the “rating agency arbitrage” Colm Kelleher referred to. From the Financial Times:
What you’re seeing now is a massive growth in small rating agencies ticking the box for compliance of investment,” said Kelleher, who stressed that regulators were failing to get a handle on the industry even as they were pushing for faster economic growth. “If you look at the insurance business there is a looming systemic risk coming through because of lack of effective regulation,” he said.
In a separate article, the Financial Times noted that Egan-Janes’ ability to issue more than 3,600 ratings last year (and another 3,400 so far in 2025) with only about 20 analysts makes it “the most prolific grader of loans to individual businesses.”
Those analysts must be pretty busy.
Meanwhile, at the Fed…After being about as incurious about the potential risk posed by PC as they were about subprime circa 2006, the Fed seems to have finally woken up — sort of — since May 2024, when Chairman Powell and other Governors began to address private credit, if only to downplay the risk.
From May 8-20, 2024:
Governor Lisa Cook: “Private credit funds appear well positioned to hold the riskiest parts of corporate lending. These intermediaries generally use little leverage and are organized as closed end funds, which means that investors cannot withdraw the funding supporting the investments.”
Chairman Jerome Powell: “…many of the lending structures are not subject to a run in the way that banks have traditionally been. Their funding tends to be from limited partners who have their investment locked up for many years … It’s not obvious to me that at this point it’s a net loss to financial stability.”
Michael Barr, vice chair for supervision: “One of the things that we see in the current structure of the private credit market is that most of the funds themselves are not highly levered entities. And today, at least, they are in a form that faces no run risks, so the investors in those funds can’t exit. They’re closed-end funds.”
All seemed to have taken the attitude of no bank runs, no problems.
The Fed’s tune changed a bit in its Financial Stability Report released November 7, after the First Brands and Tricolor blowups, pointing out that:
Isolated bankruptcies of an auto parts supplier and a subprime auto lender as examples of risks from opaque off-balance-sheet funding, potentially amplifying spillovers to banks and nonbanks.
There have been two more bankruptcies (Broadband Telecom/Bridgevoice and Renovo Home) since they published the report, so maybe not so isolated? Maybe the Fed is starting to wake up but has the die already been cast?
What the Fed does not seem to be addressing is that while banks have cut back their direct lending to middle markets, they have ramped up their lending to private credit who in turn lend to middle markets. As we noted in our report on First Brands, banks have loaned more than $300 billion to private credit funds, much of it to middle market PC funds. Additionally, PC’s sister private equity (PE) has invested in approximately 15,000 middle market companies, and as we know, PE funds a percentage of each purchase with debt raised through bank funding.
The Fed is missing the possibility that middle market companies are overleveraged, and if so, could there be a reverse crisis that hits Main Street first and banks second, creating a doom loop?
Powell’s, Cook’s and Barr’s comments in 2024 showed a lack of concern for a systemic event because PC is backed by investors in structures, as Cook said, “organized like closed end funds.” However, what if a lot of those investors happen to be life insurers? Large insurers have blown up before on bad financial product investments. Executive Life went under in 1991 after gorging itself on junk bonds. I have to imagine that a major blowup in the life insurance, annuity provider sector could snowball into something quite systemic.
Blunders followed by blowups followed by financial crisis, potentially followed by bailouts? I wouldn’t bet against it.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Listen to Episode 158
Matt Taibbi: All right, welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.
Matt Taibbi: Who is not feeling well. Is that right, Walter?
Walter Kirn: I’m feeling terribly. My karma for having yelled and screamed about the ostriches and about Jennifer Welch and so on has boomeranged, and I’m now speaking to you from behind an eight-inch thick headache that isn’t visible, but I can see it from my perspective.
Yeah, I’ve got all the symptoms of, I don’t know, early winter blues, first of all, but also sinus problems and headaches. So I’m going to really sit back here like a parking meter, because I feel about as conscious as a parking meter, and I’ll just ring up violations for the rest of the show.
Matt Taibbi: Well, that’s too bad because we have an interesting, what would normally be a fun topic for us.
Walter Kirn: Oh, it’ll tempt me and don’t worry.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. So we’re going to do the BBC and we’re not going to look at it just from one angle, but let’s just start with what happened to turn BBC into a global issue this week. The overview, let’s look at SOT one.
Gordon Rayner: The BBC claims to be the pinnacle of impartial reporting, but what if there was an internal dossier that revealed that wasn’t the case? The Telegraph has seen a letter that reveals one of the BBC’s own independent advisors repeatedly warned that the broadcaster had serious and systemic problems.
A week before the US election, BBC Panorama released a documentary called Trump: A Second Chance, and in it, they played the following clip.
Donald Trump: We’re going to walk down to the Capitol and I’ll be there with you. And we fight. We fight like hell.
Gordon Rayner: But Trump didn’t in fact say this at all. The BBC spliced together two clips that took place 54 minutes apart. So let’s go through it again.
Donald Trump: We’re going to walk down to the Capitol and I’ll be there with you.
Gordon Rayner: Now, see there. Between “Capitol” and “and,” that’s a cut. Here’s what Trump actually said.
Donald Trump: We’re going to walk down to the Capitol and we’re going to cheer on our brave senators and congressmen and women.
Gordon Rayner: It’s different. It wasn’t until nearly an hour later that he then said the second part of the BBC’s version.
Donald Trump: We’re going to walk down to the Capitol and we fight. We fight like hell.
Gordon Rayner: Now, It’s true that a lot of people will still feel Trump’s claims that in 2021, the election was stolen were entirely inappropriate and unbecoming of a figure in politics. But irrespective of your personal views on Trump, the question remains, how is a national broadcaster funded by taxpayers on the premise that it’ll provide impartial reporting allowed to splice together content in a way that one of its own advisors said materially misled viewers?
And we’re not even done yet. The footage Panorama showed of the Proud Boys marching towards the Capitol building, seemingly spurred on by Trump’s rousing speech, well, that was actually taken before he’d even addressed the crowd. In fact, the BBC themselves later published a report.
Matt Taibbi: Let’s pause there because most people have probably only heard this part of the story, the Trump part of the story. For posterity’s sake, let’s look at number 24 and see what Trump’s reaction to this was.
Speaker 1: ... going ahead and suing the BBC?
Donald Trump: Well, I guess I have to. Why not? Because they defrauded the public and they’ve admitted it. And their top echelon-
Speaker 1: Director General and the CEO, both resigned.
Donald Trump: ... this is within one of our great allies. This is our supposedly a great ally, BBC. The government has a chunk of that one, I guess, but that’s a pretty sad event. They actually changed my January 6th speech, which was a beautiful speech, which was a very calming speech, and they made it sound radical, and they actually changed it. What they did was rather incredible. They’re showing me the results later on, the results of what they did, how they butchered it up, but it was very dishonest, and the head man quit and a lot of the other people quit.
Speaker 1: We’re actually going to play it. But tonight you are saying to our viewers that you will go forward and file a defamation lawsuit against the BBC?
Donald Trump: Well, I think I have an obligation to do it because you can’t get people...
Matt Taibbi: Okay, so we get that. And just lastly, before we start discussing this whole thing, the chair of the BBC, Samir Shah, responded to this central allegation about the doctoring of this one article with a totally bizarre explanation. He’s talking about the review board, and he’s saying that they “heard from BBC News that the purpose of editing the clip was to convey the message of the speech made by President Trump so that Panorama’s audience could better understand how it had been received by President Trump’s supporters and what was happening on the ground at that time.”
So this is a classic instance of a news agency not showing you what happened, but showing you what it thinks the speech meant in the minds of the most radical viewers in the audience, which is kind of not the way it works, especially if you’re editing out lines like, “We’re going to walk down and peacefully and patriotically make your voices heard.” If you’re editing that part out, it’s significantly changed. This is way worse, in other words, than the 60 Minutes edit. This is a significant conscious decision.
So Walter, first of all, what’s your response to this whole thing
?
Reviewing “Life Is a Lazy Susan of Sh*t Sandwiches,” by “I’ve Had It” podcast hosts Jennifer Welch and Angie Sullivan, prophets of the new misery gospel
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 11/12/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:
This is a wild edition of Activism, Uncensored. Ford Fischer of News2Share starts off with his fourth visit to suburban Chicago to document activism against ICE and Border Patrol agents, but this time was quite different. The action wasn’t around the ICE detention facility in suburban Broadview. It was on the streets as agents went to neighborhoods to arrest illegal immigrants. I say “action” because activists followed the agents in vehicles, blowing whistles along the way to alert the public. It got intense as ICE and Border Patrol tried to shake their tail, which included activists and media. At times it was more like a car chase, but with the agents being pursued.
Ford then flew to Portland, where protests continued at the ICE facility there. The oddities we’ve come to expect in Portland continued, such as:
A blowup pink shark being peppered with anti-riot munitions.
A transgender activist with a group called “Degenerates Against Fascism” deadpanning through a loudspeaker, “I’ve literally had fucking spicier breakfast burritos than your shit.”
Ford then traveled across the country to Washington, D.C., for a more traditional Veterans Day protest against the continued presence of National Guard troops there.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
From the publisher's feed