Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Response to Reader

    From Dan Mage:

    Doing it again, pretending not to know what your own writing says you do. A clear understanding of class conflict, (The Divide) police misconduct and brutality and the racism that drives much of it (I Can’t Breathe), although pointing out that being “white” in the wrong neighborhood places you in danger of getting shaken down by cops who plant evidence (Again The Divide). References to the masses who I believe you compared to medieval peasants who were willing to blame their woes on anything except the nobility and royalty. A call to stop attacking each other and to focus our attention on the at the very top, only to turn around and legitimize those same elite ruling interests every chance you get. Calling an age of no accountability for criminals of state the exact opposite. Are you on meth, or just trying to get some of those reactionary dollars while they still have some value?

    From the introduction to The Divide:

    As a very young man, I studied the Russian language in …

    Read more

    0 min
  • Buckle Up, America. The Zohran Era is Here
    NEXT, THE WORLD: Zohran!

    Zohran Mamdani became New York City’s Mayor last night. At the victory party, his once-pal, podcaster Hasan Piker – who was also seen last night embracing Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez – said this in an interview:

    “We are in the heart of the imperial core*. This is the country that defeated the U.S.S.R., unfortunately.”

    Piker has said so many ostentatiously crazy things that even Mamdani had to denounce him, so he can be left aside. Look however at the beaming face of the young woman interviewing him. She has no clue what he just said. That’s why last night was a prime historical horror story.

    Like Donald Trump’s first election, Mamdani’s win spoke to the deep failures of 21st-century American politics. By 2016, Republican voters had tired of throwing votes away on McCains and Romneys and Bushes who promised to reduce federal spending and protect “family values,” but were unmasked finally as mannequins for donors who mostly brought war and exported jobs. Mamdani’s win similarly signals the beginning of the end for the old Clintonian Democratic Party, whose original formula courted Wall Street and relentlessly sought a “business-friendly” neoliberal middle, while retaining a patina of progressivism through social issues like choice.

    Both parties took their voters for granted to obscene degrees. If they and their donors had been just a little less greedy, shown a little more foresight in anticipating how difficult the transition to a global economy would be for working-class people, they’d still be in business. As it is, “never Trump” Republicans are dead as doornails and the party Hakeem Jeffries thinks he still captains has officially struck its historical iceberg. “Democratic Socialism,” the actual left, is the only political movement on that side with any energy, and looks set to take over. What does that mean? Nothing good:

    Subscribe now

    If this happened eight or even four years ago, when the Bernie Sanders campaign spoke in the language of FDR and the New Deal, this might have been a more optimistic moment. Unfortunately, just as the Democratic and Republican Party bureaucracies atrophied and grew dim-witted from overconfidence over the years, the new book-averse, Tik-Tok raised population has lost touch with history. The version of the left that’s finally ascendant in American politics is the real thing, the hearts of its followers a-flutter for the rhetoric of Che and Lenin and Marx (Mamdani gave a shout-out to Nehru last night), animated by a vision of their own country as a superpower villain of imperialist oppression.

    The major difference between Mamdani-style socialism and the leftism that swept over much of the globe in the last century is that this version is even dumber. It remade itself according to an ideology based less on class than a new intersectional theory of oppression that’s ridiculous, fantastical, grossly racist, and allows the old bourgeoisie to play leading roles. It’s hard not to admire the innovation, which solves the problem Marxists have always complained about when it comes to the United States: a consumer economy that makes life just tolerable enough to discourage the masses from revolting. Now that rich people can be revolutionaries (by claiming gender confusion or waving some other intersectional flag), there’s no longer a need to wait for deplorable support for left revolution. Anyone can be oppressed, and they’re all welcome to join the cause. It’s brilliant!

    What’s particularly ironic about last night is that the old, Clintonian version of the Democratic Party would probably be sitting in the White House right now if it hadn’t submitted to so many of the (deeply unpopular) tenets of this new ideology. The most humorous example involved last night’s loser, Andrew Cuomo, who gave Donald Trump years of ammunition when in an attempt to clown the MAGA slogan he said America was “never that great.” Trump probably wouldn’t have won many of the crucial swing states last year had it not been for the “Kamala is for they/them, President Trump is for you” ad. Similarly, Trump’s relentless attacks on DEI – a radical re-think of civil rights ideas that substituted the organic quality of equality for the bureaucratic concept of “equity” – were highly successful, and for good reason. Even the preposterous attempts to explain Trump’s success as a reaction to “whiteness under threat,” uttered by people who didn’t see anything odd about the proliferation of “whiteness studies” classes at universities, put wind in Trump’s sails.

    The 1990s version of the Democratic Party would have wasted no time in triangulating against such moronic intellectual excesses within its own voter base. In the 2010s and 2020s, however, it couldn’t afford to do that, for the obvious and sensible reason that they under-performed to a degree that made an intramural challenge like the 2016 Sanders run inevitable. Without Barack Obama’s decision to double down on George W. Bush’s 2008 bailout policies to save Wall Street, while selling out to the insurance and pharmaceutical industries in his much-ballyhooed grotesquerie of an attempt to fix this country’s health care system, the Democrats would never have lost control. They held off the first Sanders campaign in 2016, then squeaked though by a hair the second time in 2020 (employing some questionable back-room politics), but the stillborn Biden presidency was the last straw, making the beating they took last night a foregone conclusion.

    I thought long and hard about what to say when Mamdani won and concluded history is now so far in the rearview mirror, there’s nothing to say, not to this crop of new believers. Years ago I read a book called Socialism… Seriously: A Brief Guide to Human Liberation that appeared to be genuinely clueless about how past socialist revolutions unfolded. At anti-Trump protests I ran into people waving hammer-and-sickle flags and found in talking to them, they had no idea what they were celebrating. Western tourists visit places like Auschwitz en masse, but nobody goes to Solovki or Vorkuta. Like Piker, they think the Soviet Union is just misunderstood.

    To people who grew up behind the Iron Curtain, Mamdani is an immediately recognizable type, a disciple of the Leninist school of agitation that teaches effortless insincerity as a necessary means to reaching power. They would know that time and again, peasants and workers supported some general aims preached by visiting city revolutionaries but were extremely reluctant – like the mare Mollie with her ribbons in Animal Farm – to give up their hard-fought little farmhouses and slices of land, or Sunday mass, or a host of other worldly things. That reluctance is what led to the vision of Mamdani-like intellectuals like Grigory Zinoviev, who explained an educated vanguard was needed, because “the working class does not understand completely today, but will understand tomorrow.” As we all know, nothing bad ever comes from an upper-class vanguard placing itself in charge of things.

    Mamdani’s victory speech was almost Trumpian in its trolling aims. It’s impossible to believe he didn’t slip the word small into his headline quote – “We will prove that there is no problem too large for government to solve and no concern too small for it to care about” – as a way of freaking out people who were raised in societies where there was no such thing as a private conversation, let alone private property. His apparently total disdain for American history seems to be a selling point for his fans, which again speaks to the failure of the recent generation of American politicians. It also points to the corruption of universities, which apparently haven’t taught a few generations of students that most societies are too hungry and stressed to even think about “gender-affirming care,” much less spend $65 million on it.

    At minimum, the future just got a whole lot more interesting. Has Francis Fukuyama been reached for comment yet? Are we officially at The End of The End of History?

    *An earlier version of this text mistakenly used to term “whore.” It is “core.”

    0 min
  • The Best Presidential Pardon a Stablecoin Can Buy
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Presidential pardons are almost always controversial. Sometimes they are shrouded in mystery, like President Gerald Ford’s 1974 pardon of Richard Nixon. Was the pardon pre-arranged when Nixon appointed Ford as his vice president in late 1973, or did Ford grant it less than a year later to move on from a scandal that had consumed the nation?

    Sometimes pardons appear to be transactional, such as Bill Clinton’s 2001 pardon of Marc Rich, the powerful and secretive slime-ball founder of commodity trading giant Glencore. Rich fled to Switzerland in 1983 shortly before his indictment on charges of fraud, racketeering and tax evasion. Clinton pardoned Rich in the last days of his administration after lobbying from his ex-wife, who happened to give more than $1 million to the Democratic Party and $450,000 to Clinton’s presidential library.

    Add President Trump’s pardon of Changepeng Zhao to the “appears transactional” column. Zhao, or CZ as he’s known, is the founder of Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange. He served four months in federal prison after pleading guilty in 2023 to failing to maintain an effective anti-money laundering program.

    As we reported last month, the Trump family’s World Liberty Financial (WLF) scored a huge coup when its stablecoin, USD1, was used by MGX — an Abu Dhabi state-backed company — to purchase a stake in Binance for $2 billion. The use of USD1 in a major transaction not only lent legitimacy to the coin but also brought $2 billion to WLF, enabling the company to earn interest.

    Incredibly, Trump told 60 Minutes, “I don’t know who he is” and, in regard to his family’s financial connection to Binance, “I know nothing about it.”

    While not quite up there with, “I did not have sexual relations with that woman,” it’s still some top-shelf presidential bullshit.

    Subscribe now

    What did CZ and Binance do to earn that 2023 conviction?

    CZ and Binance pled guilty to violations related to the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA), failure to register as a money transmitting business, and the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA).

    Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen stated:

    Binance turned a blind eye to its legal obligations in the pursuit of profit. Its willful failures allowed money to flow to terrorists, cybercriminals, and child abusers through its platform. Today’s historic penalties and monitorship to ensure compliance with U.S. law and regulations mark a milestone for the virtual currency industry. Any institution, wherever located, that wants to reap the benefits of the U.S. financial system must also play by the rules that keep us all safe from terrorists, foreign adversaries, and crime or face the consequences.

    Binance raked in fees through illegal transactions involving users in Iran, Cuba, Syria, and Russian-occupied Ukraine.

    The plea deal announcement was damning, highlighting a company and its founder openly flaunting their indifference to aiding and abetting narco and terrorist finance. In fact, a Binance employee was quoted as saying, “We need a banner, ‘is washing drug money too hard these days - come to Binance, we got cake for you.’” CZ is also quoted as telling employees, “Better to ask for forgiveness than permission.”

    As part of their plea agreement, Binance paid $4.3 billion in penalties. CZ also had to resign as CEO, but he remains the company’s largest shareholder.

    He was released from prison in September 2024 and, lucky for him, the man WLF had described as its “Chief Crypto Advocate” was on his way to winning the presidency again.

    Trump pardoned CZ just five months after the MGX-Binance transaction involving his family’s WLF.

    Last week the Wall Street Journal brought to light something that I’d argue is even worse than the stinky MGX-Binance transaction.

    Binance built the stablecoin for WLF!

    From the WSJ report:

    It (Binance) committed a team including its Hong Kong-based stablecoin chief to build the blockchain technology for USD1, people familiar with the project said.

    (Gail) Gitcho, the World Liberty spokeswoman, said Binance provided World Liberty with so-called smart contracts, which govern how a stablecoin operates on the blockchain, “to save WLFI the headache of reproducing them, but not in exchange for anything.”

    Saying that with a straight face must have been difficult. Not to be outdone by Gitcho’s bullshit, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt took to the lectern!

    “The president is exercising his constitutional authority to grant clemency requests. And the president and the White House have a very thorough examination of every pardon request that comes to the president’s desk,” she said, adding the case was “over-prosecuted.”

    The “examination” is so thorough that Trump claims not to even know who CZ is.

    Leavitt also stated that, “Even the judge in the case admitted that the Biden Administration was pursuing an egregious over-sentencing of this individual.”

    The judge never said or “admitted” that.

    U.S. District Court Judge Richard Jones told CZ that there were a number of mitigating factors in his four-month sentence, including his cooperation with law enforcement. Jones also cited numerous letters the court had received that testified to Zhao’s character, and stated that he did not believe Zhao was likely to reoffend.

    While Jones did say that the 36-month sentence the government was seeking was unjustified, he also said that the specific violation of the federal Bank Secrecy Act was “unprecedented in terms of the volume, scale and massiveness,” and that Binance “essentially turned a blind eye” to potential terrorism financing and drug trafficking:

    You have to understand that despite wealth, power, or status, no person, regardless of wealth, is immune from prosecution or above the laws of the United States. You prioritized Binance’s growth and profits over compliance with United States laws and regulations.

    Hilariously, Leavitt also said in a written statement that there were “no identifiable victims” in CZ’s case.

    If you are moving money that aids and abets terrorists and drug cartels, there’s probably a long list of “identifiable victims.”

    In a perverse way, maybe she has a point on the egregious over-sentencing. After all, in 2012, global banking powerhouse HSBC reached a plea deal with the Obama Administration DOJ for its far-ranging money laundering operation for Mexican drug cartels. HSBC paid a $1.29 billion fine and nobody went to jail. If HSBC is the bar, then maybe four months in jail and a $4 billion payment is egregious? Or maybe there should be a few HSBC executives in prison playing dominoes with El Chapo.

    This whole thing reminds me of the hilarious Dave Chappelle SNL opening monologue in 2022.

    “Nobody had ever seen somebody come from inside of that house, outside and tell all the commoners, ‘We are doing everything you think we are doing inside of that house.’ And then he went right back in the house and started playing the game again!”

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Meet the Man Who Inspired Former CIA Director John Brennan's Viral Meltdown

    Long-serving military and intelligence officer Thomas Speciale, who served as a senior advisor to Tulsi Gabbard on counterintelligence issues, wasn’t planning on playing a starring role in a viral Internet video this weekend. The Virginia resident just happened to see a LinkedIn announcement about an event called “The Directors,” to be held at George Mason University on October 30th. It included two characters he spent a fair portion of the last years researching: former Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, and former CIA chief John Brennan.

    “I didn’t know the venue,” says Speciale. “I didn’t know who the people were that were running it. I didn’t know anything. I just went, and out of the clear blue, they’re like, ‘Yeah, we’re going to take questions.’”

    Speciale dropped a doozy on Brennan, who in turn dropped his usual mask of muttering atonal insouciance and blew up, making himself undesirably Internet-famous. It was a revealing episode about a figure rumored to be at the center of a wave of prosecutions related to Russiagate and other intelligence corruption episodes, already begun with the indictment of former FBI chief James Comey for perjury (and to a lesser extent, the indictment of former National Security Adviser John Bolton).

    Racket readers are familiar with the slew of Russiagate-related documents released this past summer by Gabbard’s Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), the Justice Department and FBI under Pam Bondi and Kash Patel, respectively, and by the CIA under John Ratcliffe. Collectively they hinted at future indictments of high-ranking former intelligence officials including Brennan, about whom news broke way back in July that a criminal investigation had been opened involving him.

    Unfortunately, the messaging around all of these releases wasn’t always clear, and while the public heard Gabbard use the phrase “treasonous conspiracy,” officials largely weren’t able to explain the breadth of the malfeasance story being investigated. Even the few mainstream efforts at covering the releases hinted at most at a series of picayune-sounding transgressions — a dubious piece of testimony here, a maybe-leak there — as opposed to the epic, years-long political espionage scam at the heart of the probe. Thanks to our Langley Softball Team of a news media, the key players also never had to answer confrontational questions in public. That streak ended with the clash of Speciale and Brennan.

    A key issue with Brennan was his approval of the use of the infamous Steele Dossier in the Intelligence Community Assessment on Russian meddling he and Comey helped build at Obama’s request. Speciale asked about this.

    Specifically he referenced a pair of emails involving NSA chief Michael Rogers, who wasn’t sure he was “100% comfortable” with the use of “underlying material” like the Steele reports, and a reply from Clapper, Brennan, and Comey which told Rogers this was a “team sport” and he needed to sign off in the spirit of “that’s OUR story and we’re stickin’ to it”:

    “A TEAM SPORT”: The crucial email in which four intelligence chiefs agreed to “stick” to a fake story of Russian collusion

    Brennan seethed and squirmed while the question was asked by Speciale — no outsider but like him, an intelligence professional — who had “access to the classified ICA.” When Speciale finished asking his question, Brennan blew up:

    SPECIALE: There was, there was there was an email that went around from General Clapper, from General Clapper to yourself and… yourself and Comey, et cetera, that basically said, ‘We all gotta get on board with this, otherwise it isn’t gonna work,’ basically. I think that that email puts everybody in the crosshairs. I would like to hear what your justification was for supporting the dossier that was known to be false being used as source material in the second ICA…

    BRENNAN: I don’t know who put you up to this.

    SPECIALE: Nobody put me up to this, sir. I’m here on my own.

    BRENNAN: I don’t know what role you played or who you are, but it’s a bunch of bullshit that you just passed on. (applause) It’s absolute…

    SPECIALE: The emails are clear, sir.

    BRENNAN: Bullshit.

    SPECIALE: The emails are clear.

    BRENNAN: Bullshit.

    SPECIALE: The emails are clear.

    MODERATOR: Next!

    SPECIALE: Second question…

    MODERATOR: Next, next, next next, next, next…

    Speciale tried to shout out a second question about Brennan’s role in signing the “51 Spies” letter about the Hunter Biden laptop story. He was shouted down, but in another unplanned encounter, Speciale got to confront Brennan about the episode after the event.

    “I didn’t expect him to come into the reception,” Speciale says. “I look over, and Brennan and Hayden are surrounded by a bunch of college students, and they’re talking, just an open conversation. So I go over and… I’m standing there. He sees me for a good full minute or two. He sees me and he’s kind of trying to get ready to leave anyway. And then I hit him with that question.”

    Speciale asked about the implication that the laptop story was Russian disinformation. Brennan, furious, poked Speciale in the chest. “You misrepresented that,” he said, insisting he never called the story disinformation. This is kinda-sorta technically true — they did use the phrase “information operation” — but there can be no doubt about the intent behind the letter, which Politico published under the headline, “Hunter Biden Story is Russian Disinfo, Dozens of Former Intel Officials Say.” Either way, Brennan’s normal cocksure cold-blooded demeanor dissolved again:

    This exchange flew around the Internet for good reason. “Wild. Guy’s not usually the poking type,” is how one Congressional source put it. Speciale was also no ordinary crowd member. His point of view is significant because he advised Gabbard and other administration officials not only about this case, but about structural failures within the Intelligence Community that led to Russiagate and other messes.

    At what possible offenses are Trump Administration officials currently looking? Why was the “this is OUR story and we’re stickin’ to it” email printed above so important? I asked Speciale this morning about these and other questions:

    Subscribe now

    I asked Speciale about the randomness of the event, particularly the second encounter in the reception area.

    “The funny thing is, I didn’t even know the guy shooting the video,” he says. “I didn’t know anybody else in the room. It was a total stranger. And when I asked my question and [Brennan] poked me in the chest, I knew it got him on a personal level… And I turned and looked, and I saw the guy with the camera and I said, ‘Hey, man, can you send me that so I can post it? And he sent it to me.”

    Speciale, who’s posted an extensive (and, for Russiagate obsessives like me, invaluable) timeline on his site, was at the Defense Intelligence Agency during the summer and fall of 2016, when the FBI and Brennan’s CIA were cooking up various schemes to infiltrate and surveil the Trump campaign. He says it’s not unusual that counterintelligence investigators might have looked at someone like Trump. “The guy’s probably a multi-billionaire. He has no political background, and he’s got hotels all over the world,” Speciale says. “These are the kinds of people that might be recruited by the Russians. It’s a possibility, at least.”

    However, Speciale says, authorities can only investigate for a short time without predication. “The law is very specific,” he says. “You could only do that for 90 days without a predicate of some kind of foreign involvement.”

    The FBI opened its “Crossfire Hurricane” investigation into Trump in July of 2016 on dubious grounds, citing an absurdly vague conversation between an Australian official named Alexander Downer and young Trump aide George Papadopoulous about “information” a mysterious not-even-Russian character named Josef Mifsud claimed Russians could deliver. The FBI quickly determined Papadopoulous was a dead end, because evidence “didn’t particularly indicate” he was in contact with Russians, and moved on to fellow aide Carter Page as a surveillance target. As has been determined by an Inspector General report and a criminal case, the FBI falsified its warrant application to use FISA spy authority on the campaign.

    “That’s where the FBI really went off the rails,” Speciale says, “If they’d have just done the initial investigation and determined that he wasn’t a source for the Russians, they should have just closed ‘Crossfire Hurricane.’ It should have just been closed. But they didn’t. They kept it going, and they lied to the FISA court, and they did all these things.”

    That might have gone unnoticed, if not for a historic curveball. “They didn’t expect Trump to win,” Speciale says. “Trump even admitted it on Joe Rogan, where he said, ‘I didn’t even know anybody in Washington.’ He didn’t expect to win either, Matt. He didn’t. He was shocked.”

    The problem with that, Speciale says, was “they had run this illegal Crossfire Hurricane investigation, and [National Security Adviser Mike] Flynn would’ve discovered that. And Flynn would’ve immediately told Trump.”

    This is the moment that has now been explained in the documents Gabbard and Patel released, but the public hasn’t really put it all together. On October 7, 2016, the first “Intelligence Community Assessment” came out, concluding the cyber penetration of the DNC was intended to “interfere with the U.S. election process.” That report, however, was narrowly focused on cyber issues.

    The emails Gabbard released this summer show that the intelligence community as of December 8, 2016 was on the cusp of issuing a similar second report, saying, “Russian and criminal actors did not impact recent US election results by conducting malicious cyber activities against election infrastructure.” However, the White House instead hastily convened a meeting of its “Principals Committee,” after which a new, broader Assessment was assigned that would come to a much starker conclusion.

    Gabbard’s office may have erred in giving the impression that the main issue was the contradiction between the later, Obama-ordered Intelligence Community Assessment of January 6th stating with “high confidence” Russia meddled in the 2016 election to elect Trump, and the “did not impact U.S. election results” report that was ready to be published on December 8th. What really happened was more complicated: the narrow cyber report was suddenly stopped, then swapped out for a much broader report. Why? Speciale, who said he was “involved” with helping set up the Principals Committee meeting, offers his thoughts.

    “Here’s what I think happened,” he says. “The cyber ICA was the foundation document, and [intelligence officials] said, ‘Mr. President, the Russians did not hack the election…’ But Comey said, ‘But, Mr. President, they ran a disinformation campaign, and did all these other things.’ And Brennan’s on board with this. Obama says, ‘Well, where’s the reporting on that? And he said, ‘I want a fulsome, whole-of-government intelligence report on everything the Russians were doing, not just cyber…’ And so Obama directed them.”

    He pauses, then goes on:

    “Here’s the real rub,” he says. “I’ve been saying this for years and years and years and trying to get traction on it. If an intelligence officer from a foreign country comes to, say, the FBI, and gives them a suitcase of bogus intel, but it all looks legit, and he’s doing it at the behest of the foreign government, that’s considered espionage. That’s considered offensive counterintelligence, essentially giving an adversary fake secrets so that they use a lot of resources to either prove or disprove them, or they make decisions based on bad intel.”

    A foreign agent giving bad intelligence, Speciale explains, is called OFCO, or Offensive Counterintelligence.

    “The dossier came from [Christopher] Steele, a trained counterintelligence agent,” he says. “It gets funneled to the FBI. The FBI reads it. They’re like, ‘This kind of sounds a little fishy, but let’s look at it.’ As soon as they picked it up and kept running with it, because they knew it was bullshit, they knew what they were doing, they knew that they were doing an OFCO. And here’s why. Because we now look at the information. The investigations were being leaked to Congress, and then the congressmen and women were leaking it to the American people and saying, Hey, there’s an investigation into Donald Trump for Russian collusion.”

    Speciale insists the operation “wasn’t against Trump, it was against everyone. It was against the entire American electorate.” The creation of the impression that the White House was compromised, the use of resources on bogus investigations, moving public opinion in a direction it largely holds to this day, was the intelligence community taking aim at the whole country. Trump was a major character, but not the whole story. As for the “team sport” emails Speciale pointed to, they’re evidence of collective guilty knowledge, for which there’s a legal term.

    “It’s damning,” says Speciale. “At the very least, seditious conspiracy.”

    Speciale, who’s ensconced in a lawsuit against Virginia gubernatorial candidate Abigail Spanberger (whom he claims issued a defamatory press release regarding his role in the J6 riots), had a lot more to say about Russiagate as well as the Hunter Biden story. The former DIA and DNI officer underscores, for instance, the bizarre fact that the ostensible key piece of evidence justifying the initial “Crossfire Hurricane” investigation of Trump, from the Maltese professor Josef Mifsud, is missing and somehow has never been found, nor has the person who planted two pipe bombs at J6.

    “We can find a goatherd on the top of a mountain making IEDs in Afghanistan and hit him with a Predator missile,” he says. “But we can’t find a guy who dropped two fucking pipe bombs in plain sight in the middle of Washington, DC, our capital? And who in the fuck is Joseph Mifsud? We don’t even know. We don’t even know who that is. We don’t even know if that’s a real person.” He pauses.

    “No way. No fucking way.”

    I asked Speciale if, given his prior advisory role, he had any insight into what kind of conspiracy charge the administration is gunning for. Espionage? Sedition?

    “I’ve had conversations, and I keep saying that I think this is just my suspicion,” he says. “My hope is that they want to have all their Ts crossed and their Is dotted before they level any public accusations of seditious conspiracy. I don’t think they’re going to go for treason. I think they’re going to go for seditious conspiracy, but I hope [Trump] puts the right person on messaging for this. Because from the White House side, not just from the DOJ, but from the White House side, their messaging has to be really, really carefully done to say, listen, ‘We don’t want revenge. We don’t want retribution. We want a restoration of the rule of law.’”

    Jim Jordan’s Judiciary Committee referred Brennan for prosecution two weeks ago. We’ll see what happens, but there’s no question that tensions are high, as last week’s encounter shows.

    0 min
  • Timeline: The Autopen Debate
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    The House Oversight Committee’s report, “The Biden Autopen Presidency,” can be broken down into two basic parts:

    1. Biden’s inner circle — or “politburo,” as the report characterizes it — worked like the two guys in Weekend at Bernie’s, constantly propping up the president to hide his declining cognitive condition from the public.

    2. As a result, Biden was often not in charge, thus the need for the administration to use the autopen multiple times.

    The report reaches a conclusion that reads like a judicial ruling: Absent evidence that Biden made executive decisions, “the Committee deems those actions taken through use of the autopen as void.” The report continues:

    Barring evidence of executive actions taken during the Biden presidency showing that President Biden indeed took a particular executive action, the Committee deems those actions taken through use of the autopen as void. The validity of the executive actions allegedly approved and signed (largely by autopen) by President Biden must be reviewed to determine whether legal action is necessary to ameliorate consequences of any illegitimate pardons granted, or executive actions implemented, throughout the Biden Autopen Presidency. The Committee finds numerous executive actions—particularly clemency actions—taken during the Biden Administration were illegitimate.

    Attorney General Pam Bondi responded the morning the report was released, saying her team was reviewing Biden’s use of the autopen for pardons.

    The Oversight Committee’s report focuses on “executive actions,” particularly Biden’s last-minute pre-emptive pardons of family members and characters such as Anthony Fauci.

    A federal appeals court said in a 2024 ruling that a pardon or commutation doesn’t require a president’s signature as long as it can be demonstrated that the president made the decision. The Oversight Committee’s report tries to make the case that proof of Biden’s executive actions is missing.

    The Biden White House’s executive decision-making procedures were so lax that the chain of custody for a given decision is difficult or impossible to establish. Documents that were used to predicate executive actions should be sufficiently traceable to ensure they reflect the will of the president. Instead, the Biden White House’s flimsy procedure appears to have been extremely vulnerable to abuse.

    Interestingly, the committee’s report does not address legislation that was signed by autopen, even though the U.S. Constitution says presidents “shall” sign bills they approve. Still, courts have not ruled whether it’s legal to sign legislation with an autopen. In 2011, President Obama became the first president to “sign” legislation by autopen. The administration relied on a 2005 Justice Department opinion for its legal justification.

    You can read more about that opinion below as part of Racket News’ timeline of events, controversies and key documents concerning the autopen.

    Subscribe now

    March 27, 1929

    Acting Solicitor General Alfred Wheat writes a memorandum that says presidential pardons do not require an “autograph,” but that “custom and propriety require that the pardoned man be given some token to show that he has been pardoned.”

    1929 Acting Solicitor General Memo4.44MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJuly 7, 2005

    The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel issue an opinion that concludes:

    The President need not personally perform the physical act of affixing his signature to a bill he approves and decides to sign in order for the bill to become law. Rather, the President may sign a bill within the meaning of Article I, Section 7 by directing a subordinate to affix the President’s signature to such a bill, for example by autopen.”

    Although the Justice Department researched the topic at the request of the White House, President Bush never signed legislation with the autopen.

    Memorandum 2005 Bush DoJ371KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMay 26, 2011

    President Obama becomes the first president to sign legislation with the autopen. The president was in Deauville, France, for the G8 Summit while Congress voted to extend provisions in the Patriot Act. They would have expired without his immediate signature.

    May 27, 2011

    Georgia Congressman Tom Graves expresses concerns about the autopen in a letter to Obama. Graves notes the U.S. Constitution says the president “shall” sign legislation he approves, and seeks clarity that Obama was fully informed of what he had the autopen sign.

    Mr. President, I write to request your confirmation that S. 990, as passed by Congress, was presented to you prior to the autopen signing, as well as a detailed, written explanation of your Constitutional authority to assign a surrogate the responsibility of signing bills passed by Congress into law.

    Tom Graves Letter35.7KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    Graves follows up in a June 17, 2011 letter to Obama that asks him to re-sign the legislation with his real signature. This time, 20 Republican colleagues also sign the letter.

    Autopenletter061711128KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJanuary 2, 2013

    The Obama administration for the second time uses an autopen to sign legislation while the president is on vacation in Hawaii. The autopen was used to sign high-profile “fiscal cliff” legislation to avoid spending cuts that would have taken effect if tax breaks were not extended.

    February 13, 2024

    The Fourth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals references the 1929 Wheat memo in a ruling that says pardons don’t require a president’s signature as long as it’s clear the president made the clemency decision.

    “…nothing in the Constitution restricts the President’s exercise of the clemency power to commutations that have been rendered through a documented writing…But such a clemency warrant or, indeed, any writing, is not required for the President to exercise this authority under the Constitution. Hypothetically, the President could proclaim at a press conference in the Rose Garden that he has pardoned a particular individual, and that would be a valid act…even absent a writing.”

    021324 Rosemond Decision204KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 14-17, 2025

    President Trump posts on Truth Social that whoever controlled the autopen was the real president during the Biden Administration. He also declares the Biden’s pardons are “VOID, VACANT, AND OF NO FURTHER FORCE OR EFFECT” because they were signed by an autopen.

    March 17, 2025President Biden’s autopen signatures, according to a Heritage Foundation analysis.

    The conservative Heritage Foundation’s “Oversight Project” determines that 32 of Biden’s 51 clemency warrants (affecting 4,245 people) were signed by two different autopen signatures. This finding was cited in the House Oversight Committee’s report.

    The Oversight Project also argues the 2005 legal opinion on the autopen was wrong, and “the Biden Administration’s apparent rampant use of the autopen reveals the very reason that OLC’s 2005 Opinion is erroneous at its core. Once the requirement for a wet signature is dispensed with, an important safeguard against fraud is removed, and an historical lawless Administration combined with a cognitively impaired President leads to the exact situation we are in—no one can be sure what actions President Biden actually authorized.”

    Oversight Project Heritage Foundation Memorandum2.44MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJune 4, 2025

    Trump writes a memo that directs his White House counsel to work with the Attorney General to investigate Biden’s use of the autopen. From the memo:

    Given clear indications that President Biden lacked the capacity to exercise his Presidential authority, if his advisors secretly used the mechanical signature pen to conceal this incapacity, while taking radical executive actions all in his name, that would constitute an unconstitutional wielding of the power of the Presidency, a circumstance that would have implications for the legality and validity of numerous executive actions undertaken in Biden’s name.

    A formal report in response to this directive has not been released.

    July 13, 2025

    Biden defends his administration’s use of the autopen, telling the New York Times that “I made every decision” in regard to the pardons and commutations he made at the end of his term. The Times also posted excerpts of its 10-minute phone interview with him.

    September 24, 2025

    A new display of presidential portraits debuts outside the West Wing, but in place of Biden’s face is a framed picture of an autopen signing Biden’s name.

    October 28, 2025

    Republicans on the House Oversight Committee release a 91-page report that alleges Biden’s “loyal senior staff” engaged in a cover-up of his declining health and “numerous instances in which the president’s approval for an executive action or the chief of staff’s approval of signature by autopen was not memorialized.”

    The report includes testimony of a Biden administration official, Anthony Bernal, who served as an assistant to the president and as chief of staff to first lady Jill Biden.

    In the video above, Bernal is asked if “any unelected official or family member of President Joe Biden execute[d] the duties of the Presidency?”

    Bernal answers by exercising his Fifth Amendment rights.

    Meanwhile Democrats on the Oversight Committee release a 14-page rebuttal. That report gives examples of Biden Administration officials testifying that Biden “managed complex policy discussions.”

    Moreover, the autopen “scandal” manufactured by Chairman Comer and House Republicans proved to be nothing more than a feeble attempt to attack the legitimacy of President Biden’s policies—a pretext to invalidate executive actions by President Biden, including valid pardons issued pursuant to his constitutional authority. After extensive witness interviews and numerous media appearances, the Majority has produced no credible evidence to substantiate his assertions, demonstrating once again his preference for partisanship over genuine oversight.

    Republican House Oversight Report 1028258.5MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadDemocratic Rebuttal 1028251020KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.