
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


There are still two months left in 2025 but unless something intergalactically stupid happens soon, the collapse of First Brands Group Holdings will take home the prize of 2025’s most embarrassing moment of the year for Wall Street.
First Brands, an owner of 24 auto-supply companies, including Fram oil filters, Anco windshield wipers, Autolite spark plugs, and Centric brakes, managed to create a financial disaster that might exceed $10 billion in losses. Major players in commercial bank lending, private credit lending, investment banking, fund management, credit insurance and public accounting have taken a bite of the rotten apple.
First Brands built its auto parts supply empire over the past 11 years in no small part by tapping the private credit market. I wrote about private credit over the summer and asked:
Has PC become just another way to feed Wall Street’s Private Market deal beast and overload the economy with debt?
First Brands may prove to be the poster child of private credit gone wild.
Private credit is essentially commercial bank lending, without the stringent regulatory capital requirements of federally and state chartered banks. Instead, they are backed by investor capital. Private credit funds, sometimes called Business Development Companies, are usually managed by companies that have a private equity arm as well. Companies such as Bain, KKR, Apollo, and Carlyle manage multi-billion dollar private equity and private credit funds.
Subscribe now
The sales pitch for private credit firms is that they are more nimble and more knowledgeable than banks for specialized lending. Unlike banks, private credit funds do not take deposits and are not subject to the same safety and soundness checks as federal and state banks are, and hence, can take more risk.
Interestingly, Moody’s recently reported that commercial banks have increased their exposure to private credit funds as they have lent nearly $300 billion to private credit companies (described in the report as Non-Depository Financial Institutions (NDFIs). According to Moody’s:
Over the past decade, non-bank lenders have steadily expanded their footprint in the US corporate loan market, often stepping in where traditional banks have pulled back because of tighter credit standards and regulatory capital constraints.
Unwilling or unable to loosen credit standards in light of these constraints, banks have responded to the loss of loan market share to non-banks by increasing their lending to these same entities — making loans to NDFIs the fastest-growing category in US banking. Loans to NDFIs are now roughly 10.4% of total bank loans, nearly three times the 3.6% of a decade ago.
One of the chief criticisms of private credit is its opaque nature. Public companies have more stringent financial reporting requirements than private ones. Investors have access to timely regulatory financial disclosures, as well as multiple levels of regulatory oversight. Private companies, on the other hand, are not subject to the same requirements, which can prevent potential investors and lenders from getting a true and timely picture of their financial condition.
First Brands’ finances were opaque enough for its primary backer, Jefferies Financial Group, to completely whiff on the amount of debt that was “on” and “off” First Brands’ books. From The Wall Street Journal:
First Brands’ unraveling has raised questions about who could have seen it coming. Jefferies had worked with First Brands for several years without issues when its bankers set out to help the company refinance corporate loans over the summer. Jefferies initially told prospective lenders that First Brands had roughly $5.9 billion of debt, according to materials viewed by The Wall Street Journal. First Brands’ bankruptcy advisers have since said its debt actually exceeds $11.6 billion.
This is what happens when money pours into both the private and public credit markets by the billions, seemingly every month. Whether it’s a private credit lender, a collateralized loan obligation (CLO) manager, a high-yield loan fund manager, or a hedge fund, the need to invest all that new money in order to earn management and performance fees is paramount. Due diligence more or less flies out the window, “hot” deals are chased and we end up with a First Brands.
At least we are getting some good dark comedy out of this debacle. The Financial Times produced perhaps the best headline of 2025:
Raistone, one of First Brands’ largest creditors and a self-described “Non-Bank Trade Finance Provider,” has claimed that $2.3 billion owed to them by First Brands “has simply vanished.”
Also, we had a bit of a bank versus private credit pissing match last week between JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon and business development company (fancy name for a private credit company) Blue Owl CEO Marc Lipschultz. JP Morgan is not caught up in First Brands’ collapse, but said in an earnings call that it should serve as a warning of what’s to come: “I probably shouldn’t say this, but when you see one cockroach, there are probably more.”
Still, on JPMorgan’s earnings call, Dimon narrowed in on some risks from non-bank lenders. If the economy starts to falter, there could be “higher-than-normal downturn-type of credit losses in certain categories,” he said, highlighting business development companies, a popular fund structure for housing private credit.
Au contraire, countered Lipschultz:
Banks might want to look at their own books for any “cockroaches,” Blue Owl Capital Inc.’s co-chief executive officer, Marc Lipschultz, said on Tuesday, standing in fierce defense of private credit. “I guess he’s saying there might be a lot more cockroaches at JPMorgan, I’m not sure I know what he’s saying,” Lipschultz said. “It’s not a private credit issue. It’s a liquid credit market.”
What did First Brands do to create such a mess?Formed in 2013, CEO Patrick James built First Brands (then called Crowne Group) by gobbling up auto supply companies in private transactions.
James tapped into the red-hot high yield loan market and the booming private credit market to fuel his company’s expansion. With regard to the latter, the private credit markets afforded First Brands what is called “off-balance sheet” financing, which generally involves a company selling short-term receivables, or invoices, from customers such as Walmart to a third party to immediately receive payment. This is often referred to as “invoice factoring.” Here is a theoretical example:
1. First Brands sells windshield wipers to Walmart and invoices them. Walmart promises to pay First Brands in one month. This creates a receivable for First Brands. Let’s assume the receivable is $100,000.
2. First Brands wants its cash today as opposed to a month later. First Brands will go to a financier, often a private credit company that specializes in receivable financing. The financier pays First Brands $98,000 for the invoice. The $2,000 is essentially the financing charge that First Brands is paying.
3. On the invoice due date, Walmart pays the financier $100,000.
This type of business has been done for centuries so that companies such as First Brands can manage their supply chain cash flow timing. Because the transactions involve the sale of an asset (the receivable or invoice), the transaction is not recorded as debt, hence, “off-balance sheet financing.”
It has been alleged but not proven yet that First Brands “double pledged” invoices. This would be akin to pledging your house as collateral to two or more different mortgage lenders, with each lender unaware of the other’s lien on the property.
And it gets worse. Again from the Financial Times:
Investors in some funds claimed they were unaware how much of their exposure was linked to James’s patchwork of auto-parts makers. Firms such as UBS O’Connor and Point Bonita said the risk primarily lay with the many blue-chip customers named on its invoices, such as Walmart. But after the bankruptcy, Raistone and Point Bonita revealed that they never received funds from such customers directly. Instead, the funds were returned to them via First Brands.
It appears that alarms should have been ringing loudly for O’Connor, Point Bonita and Raistone once the first invoice payment came from First Brands as opposed to the blue-chip companies such as Walmart. Many of the invoice factoring transactions had double-digit yields, which may have helped muffle these financiers’ alarm bells.
First Brands also used a borrowing strategy referred to as supply chain financing (sometimes called “reverse factoring”) whereby the financier pays First Brands’ payables (bills) directly, and then receives the payment invoice from Walmart later. I’m really not sure how that doesn’t end up as a liability on the balance sheet, but it doesn’t.
First Brands also had a large amount of debt labeled as off-balance-sheet inventory, which seems like something that could have been dreamed up by Enron’s infamous CFO Andy Fastow. Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) housed a portion of First Brands’ inventory and were then borrowed against with the lenders being private credit firms. Because the inventory was sold to the SPVs, the approximately $2.3 billion was not recorded as debt on the balance sheet.
Meanwhile, CEO James seems to have all the trappings of a fraudster. The Financial Times reports:
Lawsuits and local newspapers from the 2000s are littered with accounts of closed plants and bankruptcies, leaving aggrieved lenders chasing him through courts to seize his assets. Worthington Steel, one of Ohio’s largest steelmakers, claimed James put $1.2mn of his personal wealth on the line in 2005, in exchange for “forbearance” on an alleged default. Worthington leveled fraud allegations against him after his business allegedly defaulted once again, including that he had “instructed employees” to “shred” books and records to hide his “gross mismanagement”.
It’s probably no surprise that James lives the lifestyle of a Roman emperor. His estate in Chagrin Falls, Ohio, includes five houses and two tennis courts. He also has two farms with stables of prized horses, oceanfront homes in Malibu and the Hamptons, a fleet of vintage cars and a private security team made up of ex-military to provide around-the-clock protection for James and all his goodies.
DownfallJamie Dimon’s cockroaches came pouring out from First Brands’ floorboards this past June when Jefferies began marketing a new $6 billion loan for First Brands to refinance an existing loan of around the same size. First Brands’ outside auditor, BDO, gave the company an unqualified opinion or a clean bill of health in March. Existing investors in First Brands’ loan asked for and got a “Quality of Earnings” review from public accounting firm Deloitte, and that review made it apparent that First Brands had nearly twice the level of debt than what was represented on its financial statements. Things quickly unraveled from there as First Brands declared bankruptcy September 29th and Patrick James stepped down as CEO October 13th.
It is still too early to tell what the final loss total is for First Brands. With nearly $12 billion in debt, the losses will be substantial and will hit CLO managers, private credit fund managers, insurance companies, which insured some of the off-balance sheet transactions, investment banks (primarily Jefferies), and public accounting firms (BDO). All will get a dose of pain and humility.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Joe Biden’s famously obtuse former chief spokesperson has a lot to say about last year’s election season, but none of it makes any sense. Wow, is this book bizarre!
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 10/22/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
A guest essay from friend-of-Racket and former “Moscow Times” editor Matt Bivens, who writes at The 100 Days.
A big noise was heard in the dark forest,
and a roar echoed.
All the animals ran
to the boyar, the Bear.
Large animals came.
Small ones came.
Captain wolf came,
showing his sharp wicked teeth,
and greedy eyes.
Then came the beaver, that visiting merchant.
He, the beaver with the fat tail.
The noble weasel arrived.
Little princess-squirrel arrived.
Came the church clerk-fox, that treasurer.
Then the filthy peasant-rabbit,
poor rabbit, grey rabbit.
The hedgehog-tax collector came,
all huddled up, how he bristles …
All to the bear then bowed,
and the bear told his story, crying:
Judge how I have been wronged!
I had an old shoe, of woven basket, torn,
for many years it lay unused.
Gray geese flew over it one day,
they took it and tore it to shreds,
then scattered the pieces in the open field.
How am I to endure this bitter wrong?
Who will comfort my brave heart?
Aren’t we going to declare a war on birds?
And they went to war, and went to war,
and bravely led the army.
That’s fighting there in the distance!
— from Rimsky-Korsakov’s Opera “The Tsar of Saltan”, playing this fall in St. Petersburg’s Mariinsky Theater
MOSCOW — The U.S. State Department said not to come here. They have a Level 4 warning against Russia travel, which is the fastest they can hyperventilate.
The warning cites free-floating peril associated with the war in not-so-distant Ukraine, “the risk of harassment or wrongful detention,” and the American government’s “limited ability to help” if you get in trouble. It concludes in bold-face:
Do not travel to Russia for any reason.
Seventeen grim-sounding bullet points follow. If you do go to Russia, State says, you should, among other things:
Prepare a will …
Discuss a plan with loved ones regarding care and custody of children, pets … funeral wishes, etc.
Leave DNA samples with your medical provider …
Make funeral arrangements!
I seriously doubt a primary care doctor would know what to do with my “pre-travel DNA samples.”
State Department’s travel advisory scale.‘Do not travel to Russia for any reason.’But Americans are traveling here every day. There are no direct flights anymore, and international sanctions have closed European and American airspace to Russian airlines. But Turkish Air among others has stepped up eagerly, and Istanbul Airport is humming with activity.
We had many reasons to travel to Russia. We needed to reconnect with friends and loved ones, and tend to various family matters. My older daughter wanted her fiancé to meet her Ukrainian-Russian grandparents, and to see the places she remembered fondly from her kindergarten days, when I worked in Russia as a journalist (before I came to my senses and went to medical school).
As a card-carrying member of International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, I also wanted to meet with like-minded international physicians, to discuss, yes — nuclear war, the prevention of. And I wanted to take Russia’s temperature. It’s a place I know well but hadn’t visited for some years.
There were downsides to such a trip. One was leaving coastal Massachusetts at my favorite time of year. (Sailboat season!) Another was anxiety among family and friends, who have a media-nurtured fear of all things Russian. When I telephoned my father about our planned trip, I could hear my mother in the background call out, “Don’t get captured!”
Don’t get captured? Did we need to worry about that?
Amnesty International does say more than 20,000 ordinary Russians have been arrested and fined, and many dozens at least have received long prison terms for voicing anti-war criticism. We were just tourists visiting family, not anti-government activists. But there are no guarantees: Two years ago, a young woman from Los Angeles — a ballerina from Siberia, with American-Russian dual citizenship (just like my wife and daughters) — went for a visit home to Russia, and at passport control was interrogated about her views. Her phone was searched, and she was charged with treason (!) over a Venmo donation of $51.80 to a New York-based charity raising money for Ukraine. She was convicted, and sentenced to 12 (!) years. (She was released in April as part of a prisoner swap.)
Then there were the drone attacks. All summer, there were multiple Ukrainian-sponsored drone attacks on St. Petersburg’s Pulkovo Airport — the same airport we’d fly in and out of. One day after I left in September, Pulkovo was shut down for a full day by another large drone attack. My wife followed a few weeks later — the same day Russia shot down 46 drones headed for Moscow alone.
The only difference between these drones and terrorist car bombs are that the drones fly, and are apparently guided to target by sleeper agents of Operation Goldfish, who were trained by the CIA and spread throughout Russia.
(As an aside: imagine if American airports, residential buildings and other infrastructure were attacked by flying car bombs, month after month — even as, say, Iran bragged publicly about having secret “Operation Goldfish” sleeper agents spread through our country to guide the bombs to their targets. Would our government also start locking people up over $51 Venmo donations to the wrong people?)
This was all context for our planned trip, and it gave us pause. But by late summer, the geopolitics, which had been awful for years, looked cautiously promising. Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump had just met cordially in Alaska. It seemed a window for safe and hassle-free travel.
Since we were introducing the fiancé to Russia — and also don’t know what the future holds — we decided to treat ourselves to the full tourist experience. We would attend the Rimsky-Korsakoff Opera mentioned above, a meandering collection of Alexander Pushkin’s fairytales that revolves around the imaginary city of Tmutarakan. We’d go mushroom hunting in the woods outside of St. Petersburg, indulge in a full-day Russian banya (steam sauna) complete with the traditional massage-by-whackings-with-oak branches, ride the elegant overnight sleeping car train to Moscow, explore the Tretyakov and Hermitage museums, and have feast after feast — in fancy Russian restaurants, in Georgian restaurants, and best of all at home with the in-laws, where everyone oohed and aahed and took photos of the home-cooked Ukrainian fare, from borshch to blini.
Shashlyk (a.k.a. shish kebob) and Georgian wine at my in-laws’ dacha (country house). Photo by Matt Bivens.Spoiler alert, it was a wonderful trip, and no one was “captured.” I won’t bore you with most of it. Instead, I hope to reacquaint you with ordinary Russian people at this moment in time. As I pondered this idea, I remembered a 1949 classic by the novelist John Steinbeck, “A Russian Journal.” I occasionally thought of this slim book as we took our Red Square selfies, or struggled to talk politics over dinners with friends. Then, on the last day of our trip, with a pleasant jolt of recognition, I saw my own long-lost copy on my father-in-law’s bookshelf.
I took it down, and read Steinbeck’s opening account of how he and his photographer colleague Robert Capa conceived their collaboration in the late 1940s, while sitting in a New York hotel bar drinking absinthe-and-crème de menthe cocktails, and complaining about the sad state of international affairs:
Willy, the bartender, who is always sympathetic, suggested a Suissesse, a drink which Willy makes better than anybody else in the world. We were depressed, not so much by the news but by the handling of it. …
Willy set the two pale green Suissesses in front of us and we began to discuss what there was left in the world that an honest and liberal man could do. In the papers every day there were thousands of words about Russia … by people who had not been there, and whose sources were not above reproach. And it occurred to us that there were some things that nobody wrote about Russia, and they were the things that interested us most of all. What do the people wear there? What do they serve at dinner? Do they have parties? What food is there? How do they make love, and how do they die? What do they talk about?
Good questions then and today.
For anyone skeptical about a non-hostile examination of Russia amidst the carnage of Ukraine: Steinbeck the author, Willy the bartender, and many others were open to such an inquiry in 1949 — when the Soviet Union was ruled by Josef Stalin (!), had just taken over Czechoslovakia in a surprise coup, had blockaded West Berlin, and had detonated its first atomic bomb; while the Chinese Communist Party had just driven the nationalists out to Taiwan, and Senator Joseph McCarthy’s Red Scare and the U.S. war in Korea were just a year away.
For anyone still indignant, and angrily aware that far more than 1 million young men on all sides have been killed or maimed in a war Russia alone chose to launch; or, for that matter, that Russia’s recent drone attacks on the Ukrainian power grid have imposed nationwide blackouts; I can only say that I deplore the suffering everywhere — we have family on all sides of the conflict — and the war could end tomorrow if Lockheed Martin and RTX (Raytheon) America stopped fueling it and negotiated a NATO-free Ukrainian future.
Thanks for reading Racket News! This post is public so feel free to share it.
Share
Don’t Mention the WarIt was simultaneously everywhere and nowhere. There’d be ads in public transport encouraging enlistment (but alongside ads for all kinds of other jobs; demand for workers is high). There was a steady stream of quietly sober news reporting about the war Special Military Operation on television, which everyone seemed to mostly ignore. The city streets in Moscow and St. Petersburg were spotless, and ride-sharing taxis were easy to find via the Yandex Go app (but no more Uber, which left Russia in protest after the invasion). The police or security presence never felt very oppressive — but GPS-based location apps were at all times slightly unreliable, and sometimes stopped working entirely, because the Russian state jams GPS signals to make drone attacks harder to guide.
“We will be worthy of our ancestors! Service by contract in the military forces of the R[ussian] F[ederation].” A typical flier on a bus. Photo by Matt Bivens.There was a marked lack of the usual migrant workers from Central Asia and the Caucasuses, who in past would be seen hawking goods in markets and Metro station underpasses — and a complete absence of visible homelessness or loitering. The context for this, too, was the Ukraine war: Migrants had been rounded up, coerced into “volunteering” and shipped off to the Donbas front. No doubt the homeless and other idlers were offered similar treatment.
Interestingly, it was easier to research some of this once I was back home. When I’d go on-line in Russia, media from YouTube to Twitter wouldn’t work.
Steinbeck asked, “What do they talk about in Russia?” Well, not Ukraine. At least not very much, or very openly, to me. Sometimes, to kick-start a conversation I’d volunteer my own view that Russia’s invasion, while a terrible crime, was something America would have done in Russia’s situation. My friends or acquaintances might listen with respectful skepticism, or with intense interest, but either way, few reciprocated by sharing their own cards.
One evening, I brought up the war to a friend over dinner — no one brings it up on their own — and I shared my anger about America’s role in provoking and then metastasizing this catastrophe. My friend had his own take, involving anger at Putin, concern about the vastly wealthy Russian military industrial complex driving Kremlin policy, and fear of hundreds of thousands of PTSD-scarred veterans taking huge pay cuts upon their return to Russian civilian society.
“But the war could be stopped quickly if the West stopped funding it, and stopped trying to push NATO and CIA into Ukraine,” I said.
“Maybe,” he replied with skepticism, looking down at his dinner plate, already unhappy with continuing the conversation. His wife leaned over and said quietly, “We don’t talk about the war.” She meant because it’s too emotionally upsetting, and indeed, I could see my friend was suffering. We’re all processing this in our own way, even as none of us feels any control over these events.
Share
‘Judge How I Have Been Wronged!Four years ago this fall, the Kremlin and the White House were gearing up to massively escalate their joint project of wrecking Ukraine. A long civil war — with one side armed by Washington and the other by Moscow — had already left13,000 Ukrainians dead. Ending the civil war had been one of the two main pledges of Ukraine’s new president, Volodymyr Zelensky (the other was to rein in organized crime in a land oft-described as “the most corrupt country in Europe”). Peace in the Donbas in those days was, according to RFE/RL, “a goal that polls have shown Ukrainians want to see accomplished more than anything.”
Now, instead of peace, the Kremlin was moving troops to the border and threatening a full-scale invasion — unless Washington would discuss a proposed treaty that, among other things, would freeze the eastward march of NATO and keep Ukraine militarily neutral. The White House dismissed this as “simply non-starters,” reiterated that it was not Russia’s business who NATO decided to invite in, and threatened to meet any invasion with all-out economic warfare (including an explicit threat by President Joe Biden to destroy Russia’s new natural gas pipeline to Europe).
Rimsky-Korsakoff might have summarized matters thus:
“Judge how I have been wronged!” (said the Bear to the international community).
“I had an old shoe (called Ukraine), of woven basket, torn,
for many years it lay unused.
Gray geese (from America) flew over it one day,
they took it and tore it to shreds,
then scattered the pieces in the open field.
How am I to endure this bitter wrong?
Who will comfort my brave heart?
Aren’t we going to declare a war on birds?”
Of course, that’s just some doggerel adapted from a nearly 200-year old Pushkin poem. A true-to-today fable would involve those Gray Geese moving offensive military weaponry into the open field, driving right over and crushing those old shoes, so as to better threaten Bear’s den; while Captain Wolf, Merchant Beaver, and Clerk-Treasurer Fox all slyly take their cuts of the billions of unsupervised dollars sloshing back and forth.
When the Soviet Union fell apart there were 16 NATO members. Today there are 32. Image adapted from Wikimedia Commons, original by Hasancelikbilek35.Russia invaded, and the West retaliated: by delivering billions of dollars of new death tech, in amounts that dwarfed that of the civil war years; and by waging the all-out economic and cultural assault we’d warned the Russians to expect.
We seized everything we could, from $300 billion of the Russian government’s foreign bank accounts to the yachts, jets and homes of individual wealthy Russians. Nor were only oligarchs targeted. Many ordinary Russians back then relied on the Western payment systems, from credit cards to cell phone-based payer apps like Google Pay and Apple Pay. They woke up one morning in 2022 and none of that worked. Suddenly, many of them could not access their money or pay their bills. All of this happened instantly, without even a pretense of legal process. (In a similar orgy of wanton, extralegal behavior, we celebrated when the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline exploded and innocently pretended not to know who was behind that.)
Side-by-side came a berserker-rage hate campaign against Russian people. Russian tennis players were banned from Wimbledon, soccer players from the World Cup, hockey players from international competition. To this day, Russian athletes are only allowed to compete in the Olympics if they renounce their home nation and agree to compete in a dreamt-up category of “Individual Neutral Athletes.” (Wimbledon also now allows Russians to compete again, provided they sign “neutrality declarations” and formally agree “not to support” Russia or Vladimir Putin.) In my home of Massachusetts, about 20 ordinary people, none of them professionals but all of them Russian (or Belarussian), were banned from the Boston Marathon that first year (and told not to expect back the $280 entrance fee), while Russian medical school graduates were told they could not study in America.
Orchestras cancelled planned performances of symphonies by Pyotr Tchaikovsky — the “1812 Overture,” about the victorious expulsion of Napoleon’s army, was particularly targeted as too celebratory. Ballet companies in New York and London struggled to defend their decision to proceed with traditional Christmas performances of Tchaikovsky’s “Nutcracker”, while the celebrity Russian conductor Valery Gergiev was fired from multiple Western orchestral positions for refusing to publicly condemn the war. (As late as this summer, a concert venue in Italy invited Gergiev to conduct a symphony but then reversed itself.) American delis renamed the Russian salad dressing used on their reubens, Russian mustard was removed from display, and restaurants in Canada and France renounced the poutine, a traditional fries-cheese-and-gravy mash-up (“poutine” is Québécois for “mess”), because it sounded too much like “Putin.” An Italian university canceled a course on the novels of Fyodor Dostoevsky (then reversed itself when critics pointed out Dostoevsky was a subversive who did time in Siberia). The International Cat Federation banned Russian cats — defined as cats owned by Russians, or bred in Russia — from competition.
Fedya, the “permanently startled” Russian cat, rescued in 2021 in Rostov.It’s important to note that this unprecedented financial and cultural break with all-things Russian was occurring in the first weeks of the invasion, a time when Russia and Ukraine were both in a panic to end the crisis — had entered into intense, emergency negotiations — and had even signed provisional peace deals!
But as we were seizing bank accounts and foreign homes, and canceling tennis matches and orchestral performances and mustards and cats, and pouring in billions of dollars in death tech, we in the West also repeatedly vetoed every peace deal. That’s right: All of the long years of brutal butchery since those first few weeks were continued at American insistence.
We could have brokered a peace. Instead, our leaders told Zelensky to get back into that olive green T shirt and sell more war. Even today, as Donald Trump asks angrily why Putin won’t stop, Trump also does not offer to meet Putin’s one consistent, core demand: that we rein in NATO’s expansion.
Does this excuse the Russian government from starting a war that’s killed hundreds of thousands of young Slavic men, and displaced more than 10 million people from their homes? Of course not. But it’s valuable context, right? In the early days of the war, Russians were likely shocked at the worldwide condemnation, and alarmed at the amount of American military support Ukraine was able to field. The Russian invasion faltered, the Ukrainians pushed back valiantly, and there was talk of Ukraine turning the tables entirely — seizing Crimea, maybe even seizing neighboring parts of Russia, maybe provoking such a crisis that Putin’s rule would collapse. But predictably, when we rejected peace overtures, Russia started talking grimly about last-ditch use of small battlefield nuclear weapons. This essentially halted the Western triumphalism immediately (and Thank God for that).
In the nearly four years since, we’ve engaged in kabuki theater — buffing our yellow-and-blue lapel pins and bragging about sending 31 Abrams tanks to Ukraine, for example, in a war that has involved thousands of tanks on each side. Russia, meanwhile, has doggedly fielded hundreds of thousands of new recruits and built up its military industrial base. Its armies are larger and stronger than before the war began. By contrast, Ukraine’s youth continue to flee the country, the Ukrainian army is filled with middle-aged conscripts (the average soldier’s age is 43), and volunteers aged 60 and up are now being sought.
Russia doesn’t need our help to end the war on its own, favorable terms.
Ukraine, however, does, as President Trump this past weekend apparently again explained in another White House shouting match with Zelensky.
“If [Putin] wants it, he will destroy you,” the Financial Times quoted Trump telling Zelensky, angrily adding that he was “sick” of seeing battlefield maps of Ukraine that Zelenksy had brought, and throwing the maps aside.
“This red line [on the map], I don’t even know where this is,” Trump reportedly complained angrily to Zelensky. “I’ve never been there!”
I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. Three weeks ago, Trump was “Truth-Socialing” (I can’t bring myself to call what he does on his Twitter knockoff “Truthing”) about Ukraine having “Great Spirit”, and being poised to seize back all the territory it had lost. He’s got no idea what we’re doing there. Do any of us?
Next time, Part II: Billions of dollars for Raytheon, but a boycott for Brawny paper towels!
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Politicized distribution of hurricane aid money before the 2024 election was no “isolated incident,” a Homeland Security follow-up report sadly concludes
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 10/20/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:
There are two things you learn about Portland from this Activism, Uncensored video. 1) It has a high ratio of gas mask-wearing protesters, and 2) they’re accompanied by a lot of inflatable animals. As Ford Fischer of News2Share notes, the inflatables are an attempt to soften their image. Perhaps it’s not a terrible strategy. I’ll admit I laughed when I saw this:
Then again, those cute inflatables don’t overshadow a protester yelling at ICE officers: “So when is someone gonna fucking murder you guys? It would do the world so much — I have a fantasy of beating your heads in.”
Ford spent three days in Portland covering nightly ICE protests and Saturday’s “No Kings” march. Thankfully, there weren’t the antics of a few weeks ago when throngs of people rode their bikes while naked (but wearing helmets!) to protest ICE. However, Portland’s flair for the unconventional was still on display.
Subscribe now
Independent, the new tell-nothing tell-all by former Joe Biden spokesperson Karine Jean-Pierre, is framed in the introduction as the patriotic diatribe of a once-loyal Democrat who’s now “free to speak for myself” and “eager to say what I think,” thanks to a dramatic decision:
After being a party insider for twenty years, I now believe I can fight harder for my country from outside the Democratic Party than from within it. From here on, I am politically an independent.
Just a few pages later, however, Jean-Pierre claims she only noticed something wrong with Biden once, during his infamous debate performance last June 27th. “Whoa.. He must be sick,” she deadpans, then reframes Independent as an answer to a book she hasn’t even read:
CNN anchor Jake Tapper kicked off the debate. He later wrote a supposed tell-all about Biden, Original Sin… accusing [Biden] of a cover-up of his mental decline and how his aides quashed concerns. I was technically a part of the president’s inner circle and saw Biden every day and saw no such decline. I never read Tapper’s book and don’t ever plan to because that does not track with what I saw in the White House.
It’s all entertaining stuff (the “technically” is hilarious). Jean-Pierre announces she’s finally free to tell the truth, but begins by declaring that Tapper’s Original Sin — another book marketed as “the full, unsettling truth… told for the first time” — was wrong not because Tapper was lying about how long it took for him to notice Biden’s problems, but because Biden never had any problems to notice.
Jean-Pierre is generating significant negative Internet wattage this week, battered everywhere for insisting she never saw anything concerning in Biden’s private behavior. In a wild exchange with Gayle King of CBS, she doubled down on a book passage claiming she didn’t even see an issue with Biden before the critical debate, even though she traveled to it with him on Air Force One (“Maybe I was too nervous… to notice whether or not he was sniffling?”). Apparently, that trip was a rare instance in which Jean-Pierre not only didn’t talk to Biden on the plane, but didn’t have conversations with anyone who did. “I had no clue Biden had a cold and was off his game,” she wrote, “until he began to speak at the debate.”
Independent reads like an oxygen-deprived sequel to Tapper’s book. The humorous premise of Original Sin involved Tapper’s sources insisting Biden “stole an election” because if he’d stepped aside earlier, the party might have had a “robust primary” — exactly the scenario they spent years fighting to avoid, savaging Dean Phillips and Marianne Williamson and smearing Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. into the arms of Trump. The CNN man insisted “insiders” who had a “better window into Biden’s condition than the general public” saw things that “shocked them” before last June’s debate, when the truth finally became obvious even to media. But according to Tapper, the problem wasn’t that insiders lied, but were lied to. His first chapter was titled “He totally fucked us,” a quote about Biden by Kamala Harris aide David Plouffe.
Never mind that the world could see Biden was in drool-cup mode as far back back as 2019, or that Special Counsel Robert Hur made it legal record that Biden likely couldn’t be convicted because a jury would see him as incompetent, an “elderly man with a poor memory.” No, the problem was, “Biden fucked us.”
That was funny as hell, but Jean-Pierre just one-upped Tapper by insisting nothing was wrong with Biden and that — get this — the real problem was that the press undermined the president, and not after the debate, but all along! “Pretty much since the day he’d stepped into the White House,” Jean-Pierre wrote, “the press had taken every opportunity to imply Biden was too old or mentally unfit for the job.” She is referring to the same press corps that insisted Biden was “sharp as a tack” for four and a half years, while he was serially sternum-poking voters, staring into space, walking off set in the middle of interviews, and turning every public ceremony into a potential Chevy Chase routine:
Still, the idea that nothing was physically wrong with Biden was merely the introductory absurdity of Independent. Scenes like the bit with Gayle King will get the viral energy, but the book purported to have a larger purpose, and that is where the real hilarity lay. Jean-Pierre in her “Declaration of Independence” introduction announced herself free to level criticisms at the Democratic Party that “defined my life.”
What criticisms, you ask? I made a mental top-ten list of guesses during the introduction, and the only one I got right was, “Will say some shit about Nancy Pelosi.” The rest? It’s like one of Kevin Spacey’s diaries from Seven, only the author is on the loose and getting green-room invites:
Subscribe now
Take the titular premise that Jean-Pierre is now an “independent.” In Chapter 3 Jean-Pierre argues, seemingly sincerely, that the two-party system in America is flawed compared to the “range of parties” offered in European parliamentary democracies, where a person can identify as anything from a Communist to a “far-right Rassemblement National.” In America, the closest thing to such diversity is the ability to register as an Independent, which she hails:
While some of those alliances may garner only a few seats in the legislative body, the fact that they are viable parties offers an option to a vast range of voters, whether they are socialists or citizens with protectionist, even xenophobic views. Given that the United States lacks such variety, registering as an independent may offer many the purest, most authentic political fit.
A few pages later, Jean-Pierre says that as much as “I completely get” the frustration with entrenched parties, she’s not looking to add new options, and is only choosing Independent status as a way to more effectively influence/aid Democrats.
Being an independent does not necessarily mean you need or want to vote for a third party... In fact, I want to encourage people not to. While I completely get the frustration many have with both the Democrats and the GOP… in my lifetime I’ve watched third parties hand the White House to Republicans twice… We have to be realistic about the fact that choosing a third-party candidate who has little to no possibility of garnering enough popular or electoral votes to win the office can result in a more dangerous dominant party claiming victory.
Near the top of the list of “mistakes” Jean-Pierre says the Democrats made was that “The Democratic Party, my party, didn’t know how to win.” She pointed a finger at Pelosi and other senior Dems who failed to “summon enough know-how to help an intelligent, accomplished attorney” in Kamala Harris “defeat an ignorant former reality TV star.” In choosing her, Biden had “showed how loyal and strategic” he was, “passing the baton to mend his broken party while making sure Harris got the opportunity that was rightfully hers.”
Jean-Pierre then complained on more than one occasion that Pelosi and others had gone so far as to privately express doubt that Harris should be the candidate, even suggesting — horror of horrors — that voters participate in the process:
Nancy Pelosi never went on television and said, “We don’t want Kamala.” But the congressperson who first told me Pelosi believed Biden had to go also said Pelosi was explicit in declaring she didn’t want Harris to replace him. Many party insiders speculated that Pelosi preferred Newsom, California’s charismatic governor and her fellow San Franciscan… Instead, an anonymous strategist here, an unnamed insider there would periodically pipe up in the press and say that with so much talent in the wings, the party should throw the convention gates open and let the voters decide.
A few pages later, Jean-Pierre described her feelings after Trump won re-election, saying she wasn’t surprised at all, because America was too racist and sexist to elect Kamala Harris:
Finally, about 1 a.m., I tumbled into bed. When I woke up, it was over. Harris had lost. I received calls from friends who were distraught or numb with disbelief. But I wasn’t surprised by the outcome. The truth was, I never really believed Harris could win. I’d been in the body of a Black woman all my life. I’d stood at the podium in the White House briefing room, traveled in my chocolate skin through rural towns, and all my experiences of blistering stares and racist assumptions left me unable to see this country electing a president who looked like me.
Recapping: Jean-Pierre is leaving the Democratic Party because it “didn’t know how to win,” proof of which being its relentless efforts at “softening the ground beneath Harris’s feet” by saying in private that Kamala Harris “shouldn’t be a shoo-in” to take Biden’s place in the ticket. In passage after caterwauling passage Jean-Pierre rips the leadership for failing to show true belief in Harris as a candidate, only to cap off all these arguments by saying she herself never thought Harris could win!
Trying to work through this logic is tough, like untangling a monkey’s fist with mittens on. If Jean-Pierre never believed Harris could win (much like Biden, whom I strongly suspect felt the same way, announcing Kamala as a final fuck-you to the party), what exactly is she saying, given that one of her complaints is the Democrats “don’t know how to win”?
She also left out the inconvenient history that Biden and his family were far from sold on Kamala as a running mate in 2020, especially after she Molotov-bombed him as a probusing racist in a primary debate. It was the very Democratic leadership Jean-Pierre rips in this book that forced Biden’s hand in his choice of VP — all four of the finalists he was given to choose from were women, two black, reportedly from a larger pool of a dozen women. But the major theme of the book turns out to be that the Democratic Party betrayed women in general and black women specifically.
“Democratic leadership also failed us, first when it disregarded Black women’s voices by shoving Biden aside, and then when it hesitated initially to fully support Harris,” Jean-Pierre wrote. Odd, but this was the killer passage:
Black women are tired of being used, overlooked, and taken for granted… That we will take on the extra tasks at work without pay, assume the lion’s share of labor in our communities without fanfare, and do it all without complaint. Indeed, we are leaders in our cities and households, matriarchs who fight for rights and policies that benefit the whole of society… In 2024, the nation could have finally begun to repay what it owes us and benefited itself by giving the top leadership role to Harris, who could bring the talents embodied by so many Black women to the nation’s highest office — as exemplified by her having to step into the breach with less than four months to campaign, doing so tirelessly and with grace. We’d given our all, put forth our best, and we were rejected in favor of a man who represents all the nation’s worst qualities…
Jean-Pierre mentions a half-dozen times that she’s the “first black and openly queer White House press secretary.” It sounds like an accomplishment the first time she says it and a complaint by the end, since her gripe is that Democrats decided mid-race to adopt the defeatist attitude that something was wrong with Joe Biden, instead of continuing to insist, as Jean-Pierre did, that he was “thoughtful, clearheaded, and well-informed.”
As a result, the party merely put Kamala Harris on the precipice of the presidency, without actually securing the office for her. For Jean-Pierre, who again was also upset that the press didn’t do more to ignore Biden’s health issues during the first three and a half years of his term, this was a bridge too far. If “You couldn’t just give us the presidency?” isn’t the lead exhibit in the “I’m so tired” wing of a future Woke History Museum, there’s no justice.
The core complaint in Independent is that apart from a “brief reprieve” in 2020, when the summer of Floyd saw “literature such as White Fragility by Robin DiAngelo gaining in popularity,” America has shown itself to be simply too backward to recognize the essential superiority of candidates like Harris. Even so, Jean-Pierre insists, Democrats could have done more to help. “When critics said Harris didn’t know anything about foreign policy,” she wrote, “Democrats should have emphasized how she’d worked closely with our partners in Asia as well as African nations like Ghana, Zambia, and Tanzania.”
Democrats could have spent $100 billion a second on ads emphasizing Kamala’s cooperation with Zambia and Tanzania, and they wouldn’t have been able to compete with videos like the one below:
Jean-Pierre’s thesis is also just wrong. Trump was far from a juggernaut. He left office in 2021 with a 62% disapproval rating and trailed Captain Dodderpants for virtually all of 2022 and 2023. If Harris had been a good or even a middling candidate, she easily could have won. However, she was handcuffed both by her own peculiarities and the huge Gobstopper-sized zit in the middle of the Democratic Party’s forehead, which grew out of years of denials that the chief executive was a vegetable. Videos featuring Jean-Pierre figured heavily in the growth of that Gobstopper.
She raged at reporters, not even conservatives, for asking rational questions. The scene below took place in July last year, in the wake of a post-debate New York Times report that Biden saw a neurologist. Jean-Pierre had been caught not telling the truth about this, and when correspondents like AP’s Zeke Miller and Ed O’Keefe of CBS pushed her, she flipped out. Her evasions were comical, implying Presidents might have casual contact with a physician more easily than a layperson because the doctor is just down the hall as opposed to a “public transportation” ride away, while acting like reporters were being unreasonable in not accepting that a “verbal check-in” with a neurologist specializing in Parkinson’s Disease is different from a “medical exam.” Watch how calm and accommodating Miller in particular is (he’s the first reporter in the video), yet Jean-Pierre eventually rips even him for “not okay” questioning:
Jean-Pierre had over a year to think about what to say about all this, and instead of writing the book the whole world wanted, the true story (complete with photos of Biden’s used-bib collection and pictorial toilet guides) of her frustration at having to be the public face of one of the most obvious and legally perilous cons in American political history, she denied there was anything to cover up, much less that she had responsibility for it. Then she announced she was “fed up” with a country too racist to accept a cabbage-president, before offering her prescription for success in politics. “People,” she wrote unironically, “want authenticity.”
For sure, there are seriously goofy Trump administration characters. There continues however to be a massive underappreciation for the number of true lunatics escaped from the just-completed Biden period. The whole issue of Biden’s competence is under investigation and may eventually become a criminal matter, making it even more amazing that someone like Jean-Pierre would write a memoir at all, much less one this detached from reality. Is politics just a jobs program for crazy people? I don’t know how to read this book and conclude anything else.
Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live.
Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
See you soon!
Last November 8th, on the Saturday after Election Day, one of the more bizarre post-scripts to Donald Trump’s re-election emerged in the form of a Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) decision to sideline one official accused of telling FEMA workers to “avoid homes advertising Trump” while canvassing for victims of Hurricane Milton in Florida. The Daily Wire spoke to multiple FEMA officials who produced screenshots of entries like “Trump sign, no contact per leadership”:
The most painful confirmation, however, came from then-FEMA Administrator Deanne Criswell, who testified after the election that the episode was an “isolated incident,” as well as “unacceptable” and “heartbreaking,” suggesting the problem was limited to one eventually-terminated Disaster Survivor Assistance crew leader named Marn’i Washington, adding: “I do not believe that this employee’s actions are indicative of any widespread cultural problems at FEMA.”
Washington didn’t take the CYA maneuver lying down. She made a series of aggressive media appearances, saying repeatedly “my orders come from my superior” from above when instructing subordinates to avoid homes that made some FEMA workers “uncomfortable” by featuring Trump paraphernalia:
The Democrats generally maintained that decisions to skip over houses featuring Trump signs or signs about guns were legit and safety-based. Republicans blasted FEMA workers for comparing Trump voters to “vicious dogs” and suggested instructions like “Per leadership no stop Trump flag,” and “Trump sign, no contact per leadership” were indicative of a wider problem.
A year later, the Privacy Office of the Department of Homeland Security is releasing a review of that episode, the broader issue of using disaster relief work to collect political intelligence on voters, and the potentially withholding of benefits from some with the wrong beliefs. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the new administration found more than just one “isolated incident,” describing violations of the Privacy Act of 1974, which with a few exceptions bars collection of information about First Amendment-protected speech, like political signage. Most tellingly, though, DHS investigators found — in a near-exact parallel to trends in pro-censorship programs — that a lot of the political controversy surrounding FEMA aid grew out of the vague way in which the agency’s Disaster Survivor Assistance Field Operations Guide was written.
The Field Operations Guide instructed FEMA workers to “Remove yourself from the situation if you feel threatened” when dealing with “hostile” individuals, the only problem being, as the new report notes: “The Disaster Survivor Assistance Field Operations Guide does not define the term ‘hostile.’”
“The way the guide was written, FEMA employees had leeway to skip outreach to a house if its signs made them feel uncomfortable,” one Washington-based First Amendment lawyer put it last week. “So it’s basically the same concept of a harm or distress standard we’re seeing in Europe with speech issues, where the emotional response of the observer is what matters legally, as opposed to a concrete rule.”
The DHS report doesn’t describe a huge number of instances, but does list examples of FEMA workers from various relief efforts taking down political information well before the incident that actually made the news. FEMA’s actions were “not limited to the Hurricane Milton disaster relief efforts in 2024,” and in fact, “FEMA impermissibly collected prohibited information at least dating back to the Hurricane Ida disaster in September 2021.”
Some examples cited: October, 2021: “Homeowner had sign stated… this is Trump country.” September, 2021: “A lot of political flags, posters, etc. ‘Fuck Joe Biden,’ ‘MAGA 2024,’ ‘Joe Biden Sucks’ ‘Trump 2024’ We do not recommend anyone visiting this location.” November 2024: ‘There was a political flyer so I didn’t leave a FEMA brochure.” Neither Criswell nor Washington responded to requests for comment.
The DHS report lists several recommendations for changing procedures to make both political information-gathering and subjective aid delivery harder, but the problem the report identifies suggests a broader, hairier problem. Federal aid workers empowered to withhold relief based on what they consider “hostile” signage in either direction creates an opening for a federalized version of the old “walking-around-money” operation pioneered by ward-heelers in city elections, in which petty cash made it into the hands of one party’s potential voters. The number of incidents in the new DHS report don’t come close to suggesting an election-altering phenomenon (the most controversial instances came last year, but still totaled under 100 episodes), but as one official who worked on the report noted, the phenomenon still “really escalated in the last administration.”
The DC-based lawyer said the mere fact that FEMA aid can be politicized should worry members of both parties enough to do something about it. “People hate the government enough as it is. If it’s known that disaster relief can be politicized and nobody fixes the problem, imagine how mad people will be one or two cycles from now.”
From the publisher's feed