Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Timeline: The Case Against John Bolton

    John Bolton launched a plan to document and transmit classified information before he even started his job as President Trump’s national security advisor, according to the federal indictment against him.

    Two weeks later, he made his first transmission using the encrypted messaging app to two people, a 25-page document “which described information” that Bolton learned in his first few days on the job, the indictment says. The indictment doesn’t identify those people, but the New York Times reports they were his wife and daughter.

    For the next 17 months, Bolton regularly sent “diary-like” entries to them about what he saw and heard that included classified information. From the indictment:

    BOLTON wrote many of these diary-like entries by transcribing his handwritten notes from his day’s activities into word processing documents, which he then electronically sent to Individuals 1 and 2 through a commercial non-governmental messaging application. On other occasions, BOLTON used his personal non-governmental email accounts, such as email accounts hosted by AOL and Google, to email information classified up to TOP SECRET/SCI level to Individuals 1 and/or 2 at their personal email accounts."

    Some examples of that classified information, which was also found in his home:

    • Revelations of a “liaison partner sharing sensitive information with the U.S. intelligence Community

    • A foreign adversary’s plans for a missile launch and the sources and methods used to gain the intelligence.

    • Covert action planned by the U.S. and a covert action that was conducted by the U.S. and another country.

    • A foreign country’s intelligence describing an adversary’s planned attack on a facility

    Why would Bolton do this? To write a book. The indictment includes excerpts of a letter from his agent stating that it was “with enthusiasm” that they were “again exploring a book” with Bolton while he was still National Security Advisor.

    About three months after leaving the White House (Trump says he fired him, Bolton says he resigned), Bolton sent a manuscript to the National Security Council for review as required. He was told to remove “significant amounts of highly classified information,” the indictment says.

    The book, “The Room Where It Happened: A White House Memoir,” was published in June 2020. The indictment says none of the classified information cited in the indictment was included in the book.

    Bolton pleaded not guilty on Friday, a day after his indictment. His attorney, Abbe Lowell, said the accusations were previously resolved.

    Like many public officials throughout history, Amb. Bolton kept diaries — that is not a crime. We look forward to proving once again that Amb. Bolton did not unlawfully share or store any information.”

    Lowell is also the attorney for New York Attorney General Letitia James, who was indicted this month on charges of mortgage fraud. He was also Hunter Biden’s defense attorney and is representing Fed Reserve Governor Lisa Cook.

    Subscribe now

    Here’s a short video compilation of some of Bolton’s statements in which he criticized others for their handling of classified material. Some of the comments in the video were referenced in the indictment.

    Below is a timeline of events leading up to the indictment.

    June 16, 2020

    The first Trump administration sues Bolton to stop the June 23 release of his book, arguing that he is violating non-disclosure agreements and that he abandoned an ongoing government review of the manuscript. That review resulted in revisions, but the administration, as of June 11, contended that the latest version it was reviewing still had classified information (as noted above, the Justice Department says none of the classified information cited in the indictment was disclosed in the book).

    A federal judge ruled against the administration because so many copies were already distributed, but expressed concern that the book was published before the government’s review cleared it.

    2020 Doj Lawsuit Against Bolton210KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJune 21, 2020

    In an interview with ABC News, Bolton says the book would have been 500 pages longer if it contained classified information, and that he wrote the book to “reveal a picture of the president that people can draw their own conclusions from.”

    My conclusion is clear. I don’t think he should be president. But I didn’t wanna write a book that was argumentation or that was being an amateur psychoanalyst or coming up with pigeon holes or categories or put the president in.

    I wanted people to see him as he operated. Now, there’re people who say that somehow, this is a breach of trust. I don’t see it that way at all. I think there’s an obligation to let the American people know what it’s like in the White House and what their leader is doing. I’m prepared to take the grief that this book will cause because I think the greater loyalty should be to the Constitution and the country.

    The video above is a condensed version of the interview. Here’s a PDF of the transcript taken from ABC News’ website:

    Transcript John Bolton Interview With ABC News' Martha Raddatz 6.39MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadSeptember 23, 2020

    An attorney for the White House staffer in charge of reviewing Bolton’s manuscript writes a letter to the court that says the Trump administration exerted political pressure on her to keep it from being cleared for publication. From the Associated Press:

    [Ellen] Knight said that when she advised NSC lawyers on April 28 that she was prepared to clear the manuscript for publication, she was told to take no action. Knight said NSC lawyers told her to tell Bolton that the process was “ongoing.” She says she was once told that COVID-19 issues were delaying the process.

    A Trump spokesperson said the letter confirms that Bolton never received the required approval.

    June 16, 2021

    The Biden administration drops the Justice Department’s lawsuit against Bolton, exactly one year after the Trump administration filed it. The Associated Press reports that the Justice Department also dropped a grand jury investigation.

    July 6, 2021

    The indictment reveals that Bolton’s emails were hacked. A representative for Bolton notified the FBI and said that it was believed a representative of Iran was responsible.

    July 28, 2021

    A representative for Bolton informs the FBI that both of them received an email from someone “associated with the hack of Bolton’s account,” according to the indictment. Another message was received on August 5, 2021

    January 20, 2025

    On his first day in office, Trump signs an executive order that revokes the security clearance of Bolton and 50 other former intelligence officials who signed a letter in 2020 that said Hunter Biden’s laptop “has all the classic earmarks of a Russian information operation.”

    The executive order singles out Bolton and his book.

    National security is also damaged by the publication of classified information. Former National Security Advisor John R. Bolton published a memoir for monetary gain after he was terminated from his White House position in 2019. The book was rife with sensitive information drawn from his time in government. The memoir’s reckless treatment of sensitive information undermined the ability of future presidents to request and obtain candid advice on matters of national security from their staff. Publication also created a grave risk that classified material was publicly exposed.

    January 21, 2025

    Trump cancels the Secret Service security detail that had been assigned to Bolton since late 2021 when the Justice Department learned that someone from Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard tried to hire someone to kill him.

    In charging the Revolutionary Guard official (who remains at large), the Justice Department said it believes Bolton was targeted in retaliation for the Trump-ordered killing of Qasem Soleimani, the commander of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps – Qods Force. That occurred in January 2020, nearly four months after Bolton left the White House.

    August 22, 2025

    The FBI searches Bolton’s home in Bethesda, Md., and his office in Washington, D.C. The search began at about 7:00 a.m. At 7:03, FBI Director Kash Patel posts on X:

    Later that day, Trump says he wasn’t told that the searches would take place before calling Bolton a “low-life.”

    August 25, 2025

    Bolton makes his first comment about the searches in an op-ed in the Washington Examiner. He uses the searches as an analogy to describe Trump’s Ukraine policy:

    President Donald Trump’s Ukraine policy is no more coherent today than it was last Friday when his administration executed search warrants against my home and office. Collapsing in confusion, haste, and the absence of any discernible meeting of the minds among Ukraine, Russia, several European countries, and America, Trump’s negotiations may be in their last throes, along with his Nobel Peace Prize campaign.

    October 10, 2025

    Several media outlets report that Bolton is expected to be charged the following week.

    October 16, 2025

    Bolton is indicted on 10 counts of unlawful retention of national defense information (NDI) and eight counts of transmission of NDI. In the video above, Trump is informed by a reporter that Bolton was indicted.

    “I didn’t know that, you’re telling me for the first time, but I think he’s, you know, a bad person. I think he’s a bad guy. Yeah, he’s a bad guy, it’s too bad, but that’s the way it goes,” Trump says.

    October 17, 2025

    Bolton pleads not guilty. He makes no comment as he leaves the federal courthouse in Greenbelt, Md.

    Subscribe now

    0 min
  • Note to Readers

    I apologize for Racket readers for my recent absence. I had an accident at the end of the last week, taking a fall after losing keys and trying to break into my own house. I was unconscious for a few minutes. Apparently upon waking I knew my date of birth and name, but not the current President (!). EMTs and a nearby hospital took good care of me, ruled out uglier possibilities, and sent me home with a concussion.

    I thought I’d be right back, certainly in time for this week’s chats with Walter, but an attempt to come back last weekend queered things, and it took four days lying in a dark room to get the pain down from a surprising 7-8 level to a 2. I can type now and be the slower half of a conversation with my ten-year-old, but Walter and I have agreed to re-start America This Week Monday, not tomorrow. Apologies to Racket subscribers, but the worst is past and there’s more to come perhaps sooner than later, as I still owe a book review among other things.

    My lesson from this week: if you’re older and have kids, act like it. Beware of thoughts like, “When I was 22 I could make this jump without a problem.” You’re not 22, you’re one of earth’s most dangerous animals, middle-aged and delusional. Apologies for being that person, and thanks to friends and family for their indulgence and care through this less-than-fun ordeal. See you all soon.

    0 min
  • Gain-of-Function Monetary Policy
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    As we saw during the covid pandemic, when lab-created experiments escape their confines, they can wreak havoc in the real world. Once released, they cannot easily be put back into the containment zone. The “extraordinary” monetary policy tools unleashed after the 2008 financial crisis have similarly transformed the U.S. Federal Reserve’s policy regime, with unpredictable consequences. The Fed’s new operating model is effectively a gain-of-function monetary policy experiment.

    That was Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent last spring in a piece for The International Economy magazine under the headline, “The Fed’s New ‘Gain-of-Function’ Monetary Policy.”

    It was timely considering the recent histrionic calls to keep the Fed “independent” over the attempted firing of Federal Reserve Board Governor Lisa Cook and President Trump’s name-calling of Fed Chairman Jerome “Too Late” Powell. Maybe it’s time to ask: should the Fed get to do whatever it wants? While it’s true that presidents appoint board members, who are then approved by the U.S. Senate, should that also mean the central bank can play God with the nation’s economy?

    Subscribe now

    Bessent argues that the Fed’s policy response to both the 2008 financial crisis and the 2020 pandemic amounted to “gain of function” experiments that escape the lab.

    The Fed deployed a combination of sustained, near-zero short-term interest rates (Fed Funds) and a practice known as quantitative easing (QE) to “save” our economy. Unfortunately, perhaps like the Covid mRNA vaccines, the Fed had little idea what the long-term effects would be from this untested cocktail of policy medicine. Also, like the Covid vaccine, the Fed has turned its unconventional emergency response into just another tool in its kit.

    The Fed’s actions had major ramifications, both positive and negative, yet they were made with relative ease. Then-Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson coordinated with the Fed in 2008, but there was no pushback or internal levers to stop their major policy decisions. Unlike the Supreme Court, where members can issue strongly-worded dissent opinions, it’s only by reading the minutes of Fed meetings that we can get a sense of what little dissent there is, as was the case in 2010, when Thomas Hoenig was the lone member to object to continuing near-zero interest rates.

    The Policies: ZIRP and QE

    The Fed pretty much maintained ZIRP (Zero Interest Rate Policy) until 2017 and then again from 2020 to 2022 in response to the pandemic. This punished people who put their money in savings accounts, money market accounts, and CDs — particularly retirees who need relatively risk-free interest income.

    Meanwhile, it was manna from heaven for the highly leveraged players: the hedge funds, private equity funds, leveraged buy-out funds and financial institutions. Borrowed money is their oxygen. Private equity and its kissing cousin, private credit, would not be the colossuses they are today without it.

    Then there’s quantitative easing. This is where the Fed boldly went in 2008 where it had never gone before. Until then, the policy was dismissed because it’s similar to a central bank printing money, which is what Germany’s Weimar Republic did, if that tells you anything.

    The difference with QE is that instead of printing money, the Fed creates digital reserves to buy assets.

    In 2008, however, after the Fed failed to recognize the subprime mortgage crisis that turned into a financial and economic catastrophe, it embarked on QE by buying trillions of dollars of U.S. Treasury notes and bonds, and Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae mortgage-backed securities (Agency MBS). The Fed did two major buying rounds of QE, first beginning in 2008 in response to the financial crisis and then again in 2020 in response to the pandemic. At its height, the Fed owned more than $8.5 trillion in Treasuries and Agency MBS — 20% of the Treasuries market and one-third of Agency MBS!

    Federal Reserve Balance SheetRed = U.S. Treasury notes and bonds; Green = Agency MBSQuantitative Easing Explained

    Yes Virginia, the Fed created new money, and lots of it.

    The way QE worked, also known in Fedspeak as POMO (Permanent Open Market Operations), was the Fed on most mornings would ask both U.S. Treasury and Agency MBS dealers (i.e., big banks) to offer them say, $3 billion of Treasuries and $2 billion of Agency MBS. By late morning, the Fed was the proud owner of another $5 billion in bonds. Wash, rinse and repeat every day. The Fed paid for these daily gargantuan purchases by electronically “printing” money and wiring it to the banks’ reserve accounts at the Fed. The Fed paid interest to the banks to encourage them not to withdraw this “new money” they were paid. It was the first time the Fed paid interest on what it calls “excess reserves.”

    The Fed’s massive buying pushed up prices of these bonds. When prices go up, yields go down. The first chart below shows the immediate effect QE had on Treasury yields (represented by the 10-year Treasury yield). The second chart shows Agency MBS yields (represented by the Fannie Mae 30-year Current Coupon yield).

    These important yields remained historically low until 2021. The 10-year Treasury yield averaged 2.28% (source: Bloomberg) during this period, compared to an average yield of 5.70% from 1990 to 2008

    The Fannie Mae 30-year Current Coupon yield averaged 3.04% from 2008 to 2021, compared to 6.91% from 1990 to 2008.

    Bringing these rates down to never-before-seen lows and keeping them there for years created both a Wall Street fantasy land and a bout of inflation in 2022 that we are still dealing with three years later.

    TINA - There Is No Alternative

    Treasury notes and bonds are considered “risk-free” and serve as the basis for many other financial products. When combined with ZIRP, which drove short-term yields on risk-free money market instruments to near zero, investor funds that would normally go into low–risk assets became starved for yield and were forced into riskier assets such as corporate bonds and loans, stocks, emerging markets and commodities. This phenomenon was coined as TINA, There Is No Alternative.

    Long-term asset buyers like life insurance companies, pension funds and endowments, who would normally buy risk-free or near-risk-free bonds with long maturities (over 10 years) to meet their long term obligations, were pushed out of these markets. Their yields were too low. This very important investor class found yield in riskier places such as private equity funds, which in turn experienced explosive growth and minted private equity manager billionaires by the dozen.

    In a perverse way, many of the Wall Street firms that caused the 2008 financial crisis, followed by the Great Recession, were first bailed out by the government and the Fed and then profited like never before from the Fed’s emergency policies that ended up being long-term. Firms made a fortune by underwriting, trading, selling, or managing stocks and risky assets.

    However, for the many who didn’t have substantial assets such as stocks and bonds, recovery from the Great Recession was painfully slow and for many, non-existent.

    The most popular American mortgage instrument, the 30-year fixed rate mortgage, is directly tied to the yields on Agency MBS. Therefore, when the Agency MBS yields dropped to record lows, the rates charged on mortgage loans hit record lows as well.

    The first period of QE, 2008 to 2018 did have one positive outcome.

    Thirty-year mortgage rates dropped from 6% to under 4% sparking a huge mortgage refinancing wave. If a borrower refinanced a $350,000 6% mortgage into a 4% 30-year mortgage, the net savings was about $427 a month. Additionally, lower financing costs helped increase home affordability. According to the National Association of Home Builders, construction and consumer spending on housing contribute 15%-18% to our GDP.

    Unforeseen Consequences

    However, the second round of QE buying that began in 2020 helped stoke the painful inflationary conundrum we currently find ourselves in. The Fed’s buying drove mortgage rates to new record lows, sparking another wave of mortgage refinancing. Similar to the earlier round of QE, refinancing put additional hundreds if not thousands of dollars into millions of mortgage borrowers’ pockets every month. These savings from refinancing, combined with government Covid stimulus and supply chain disruptions, created our most serious inflation bout since the 1970s.

    Inflation in the U.S. began rising in the spring of 2021 at an alarming rate. The Fed at first believed the inflation spike was “transitory,” kept up its pace of QE buying until late 2021, and didn’t stop new purchases until March 2022. Raging inflation forced the Fed to raise the Fed Funds rate at a rapid pace, and in response to both the Fed slowing QE purchases and surging inflation, 30-year mortgage rates went from 3% to 7% in the course of a few months.

    This huge increase in mortgage rates created a huge, unforeseen problem. The refinancing wave QE put millions of homeowners in historically low-rate mortgages, of 2.5% to 3.5%, creating a lock-in effect. Homeowners who would like to move often don’t because they cannot afford to go from a 3% mortgage to a 6% mortgage. The lock-in effect has disrupted the natural supply flow of the housing market as existing homeowners keep their houses off the market. The combination of higher mortgage rates and lack of existing homes for sale has driven housing affordability to record lows. As housing is vital to our economy as well as personal wealth building, this unforeseen development is having major consequences.

    Before 2008, the Fed had a tremendous amount of power and influence over the lives of every American. After 2008 their use of ZIRP and QE allowed them to play God with all our lives, unchecked. The independence of the Fed isn’t all or nothing. While I don’t think the President should be able to force the Fed into raising or lowering interest rates, there needs to be some sort of circuit breaker that requires a sign-off from constitutionally elected government officials before using extraordinary policy measures like ZIRP and QE.

    Last year, Stephen Miran and Dan Katz of the Manhattan Institute published a paper, “Reform the Federal Reserve’s Governance to Deliver Better Monetary Outcomes.” Interestingly, Trump appointed Miran last month to the Federal Reserve’s Board of Governors.

    Miran and Katz proposed shortening the terms of Fed governors, currently 14 years, and increasing the influence of the 12 Federal Reserve banks by allowing their presidents to vote at each Federal Open Market Committee meeting. Currently, only five can vote on a rotating basis. The proposal also calls for state governors in each bank’s district to appoint their boards of directors. The thinking is these changes would make the Fed more democratic and provide more accountability.

    Perfect? Maybe not, but we definitely need more thoughtful conversation and action on the subject. The status quo isn’t working.

    Subscribe now

    0 min
  • Note to Readers: No Livestream Today

    There won’t be our regularly-scheduled livestream today. Matt took a bad fall last week and is still suffering from a concussion. He apologizes for the inconvenience and promises to make up for the lost time. Thanks for your understanding.

    — The Racket Team

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, Oct 10, 2025: "American Psychos"

    Listen to Episode 154

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: And Walter, you know what? I was having a terrible week. I still am sick, I’ve been sick, been kind of down. I was so down that I watched an episode of Mike Tyson Mysteries and didn’t laugh.

    Walter Kirn: Whoa.

    Matt Taibbi: And I was really in a funk. And then this whole Katie Porter phenomenon happened, and I caught a little bit of it online, and it’s like the gift that keeps on giving. I’m wearing a tie today. My wife suggested, she’s dressing me today. She said, “Look good, feel good. You know?” So I’m wearing a tie instead of dressing like a 14-year-old with money, but this is to go along with-

    Walter Kirn: It’s weird, now you look like a guy in his 50s who doesn’t really have money, like a guy who had a tie in case of birthdays, parties, or some reason, and you just threw it on. It does match. I mean, there’s a jacket.

    Matt Taibbi: That’s legitimately a Half-Windsor knot, I can tie one of those.

    Walter Kirn: Really?

    Matt Taibbi: I think, yeah.

    Walter Kirn: Well, see, nobody knows what those are anymore, so it doesn’t impress people as much as it did, but.

    Matt Taibbi: I can’t do a Pratt Knot and I can’t do a Four-in-Hand.

    Walter Kirn: But you see, the problem, Matt, is the cap. The cap, man. The cap doesn’t-

    Matt Taibbi: I know, I know.

    Walter Kirn: You take it all away with the cap. It’s like, choose, okay? Are you’re going to be just a guy with a cap? You’re going to be this man with a Windsor knot?

    Matt Taibbi: It’s just, it’s too glaring and it’d be like the Star Trek episode with the guy with the giant head who says, “Exterminate,” all the time. It’s too distracting. But anyway, I feel buoyant a little bit today, at least temporarily, because this story, it’s just genuinely funny, this person, Katie Porter. Did you know a lot about Katie Porter before this week?

    Walter Kirn: No, I didn’t. And here’s the thing, when I found out that she was the leading gubernatorial candidate, just after seeing that first video, I thought, what is California politics? I mean, how do you become that repulsive? And you’ve obviously been that way your whole life. I mean, even in high school, you were the person people hated. And yet, you get to be the leading gubernatorial candidate? Is there some backroom process or set of protocols that has nothing to do with appeal, nothing to do with, I don’t know, eloquence? Or maybe she’s accomplished amazing things. I don’t know. If she has, it’s because people just say yes and want to get out of the room. I mean, that is the person who you just vote yes during the meeting because they want you to, so you can get the hell out there.

    Matt Taibbi: She does have some skills, politically.

    Walter Kirn: Is she a lawyer?

    Matt Taibbi: One of them, she is a lawyer. She can be very confrontational in, let’s just say in a politically entertaining way with CEOs, executives from Wall Street. She has a shtick that everybody knows, which is writing on a whiteboard, explaining complex issues in a way that’s accessible to some people, and she’s reliably orthodox on all the progressive issues of the day.

    The problem is that her personality, and let’s just watch the clip. This is her being interviewed by CBS’s Lori Watts, and it’s for a series of interviews with all of the California gubernatorial candidates. The point is, this is pretty standard political fare where it’s almost like political speed dating. You’re being asked a series of questions that every other candidate is getting the same stuff, and the whole point is to read off a pro-former response and then move to the next thing and get the fuck out, right? That’s what it is. It’s a free commercial, CBS is basically giving free commercials to all the candidates, right?

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: And this happens.

    Read more

    0 min
  • Note on Katie Porter

    I want to apologize to Racket readers. I’ve been sick and in a funk for days. How bad? I watched an episode of Mike Tyson Mysteries and didn’t laugh once. Then I saw the Laurie Watts CBS interview with California gubernatorial candidate Katie Porter and finally laughed, which in turn led to reading court filings with quotes like “she then took the ceramic bowl of steaming hot potatoes and dumped it on my head” and “Are you so fucking stupid that you can’t make jello?” and “This is pornography. Only a terrible person would watch this!” (about season 4 of Californication). I then stayed up last night reading the 2023 memoir, I Swear: Politics is Messier Than My Minivan.

    The book is less funny, but still fascinating as a field guide to a newly prevalent personality type. This is the person who simmers with nuclear rage while scrupulously cataloguing all the mistakes the vast flawed universe of Other People make in delaying his or her obviously deserved success. As I’m about to record America This Week with Walter Kirn the review isn’t finished, but it is forthcoming.

    One of the reasons I’m proud to be an American is that ours is a country where entertainingly crazy people get to thrive. Porter’s best strategic move is to embrace the viral craze created by the Watts exchange and go full DNC-Mothra from here, but… well, I have to prep for the show. Anyway, never doubt the humor Gods, they always come through. Also, is deepfake software (I think Kling is responsible for this one?) beginning to fulfill its potential? More on the book to come.

    0 min
  • James Comey Was Sure He Was Above The Law. Supporters Hope He's Right

    While social media and legacy press raged over Bari Weiss, and Republicans thundered over new documentation showing Special Prosecutor Jack Smith monitored the phone records of eight GOP Senators, Iowa’s Chuck Grassley released a disturbing document as part of his opening statement to a Senate Oversight hearing. He revealed that on March 2, 2017, FBI agent Timothy Thibault — part of a now-disbanded political investigation unit called CR-15 — wrote a draft letter detailing interest in investigating Donald Trump:

    Somehow a FBI HQ DAD at CD side received information CR-15 was leaning toward open a case on the Trump campaign… What we are doing: Aggressively seeking out open-source information, HUMINT info that could predicate a case.

    Aggressively seeking… info that could predicate a case.

    “Obviously, everything is reversed here,” a spokesperson for Grassley’s office said. “You’re supposed to follow a lead to start a case, not start a case in search of a lead.”

    The letter was released before former FBI Director James Comey today pleaded not guilty to charges of lying to Congress. Organic support for the hulking ex-FBI chief at the courthouse was faint. A few protesters held signs reading SHOW TRIAL and WEAPONIZATION OF GOVERNMENT, and media focused unironically on whether or not Trump is “using the justice system against his adversaries.” Comey, the once-mighty FBI chief who interfered with two presidential campaigns in 2016 (although he only conducted intrusive surveillance of one), is now going to argue for dismissal on the grounds that his prosecution is “vindictive.”

    Nobody seems to care now, but Trump faced multiple secret investigations at the hands of the FBI under Comey’s watch even before Special Counsel Robert Mueller was appointed to conduct his epic “links and/or coordination” probe. “Crossfire Hurricane,” the first, was absurdly predicated on a conversation between Australian Alexander Downer and Trump aide George Papadopoulos that “suggested the Trump team had received some kind of suggestion from Russia” (a suggestion of a suggestion!). The newly disclosed effort by Thibault openly grasped for predication.

    A little-discussed third FBI probe, launched a day before Mueller was appointed in May of 2017, claimed to be seeking to learn “if President Trump is or was directed by, controlled by… the Russian Federation.” No predication has even been released or asserted in that case, as in yet another grotesque joke on the public, the document released in response to a FOIA request was pretty much entirely redacted:

    The document above was composed one week after Comey’s firing. If that wasn’t a “vindictive” investigation, initiated in response to Comey’s dismissal, the unredacted document should say so. The Trump administration would be smart to release it.

    Anyone tempted to feel sorry for Comey need only read the New York Times account of the hearing today, portraying a “lopsided power dynamic” in favor of the great man:

    An uninitiated observer might even have mistaken the defense for the prosecution on Wednesday, given the lopsided power dynamic. To the judge’s right stood Mr. Comey, the former head of the F.B.I. and the Manhattan U.S. attorney’s office, and Mr. Fitzgerald, a former federal prosecutor known for winning convictions in major terrorism and public corruption cases.

    On the left, at the prosecutors table, sat Lindsey Halligan, who was making her second-ever appearance as a prosecutor after she was hastily installed by Mr. Trump as the U.S. attorney in the Eastern District of Virginia last month.

    That portrait properly frames the Comey trial, scheduled for January 5th. Comey and his supporters see themselves as a wronged government-in-exile, facing off against “vindictive” trespassers who’ve “eroded the rule of law” by prosecuting an innocent intelligence chief. That propaganda is succeeding. Even commentators who seemed to understand the story in the moment seem to have lost enthusiasm for any case that might redound to the benefit of a currently gloating White House occupant like Donald Trump, forgetting that the identity of Comey’s target is the exact reason this case matters so much.

    Anything you can get away with doing to an elected billionaire president can be done to everyone. If you get away with breaking attorney-client privilege for Trump, no conversation with any lawyer is safe; if you test-a-lie your way to Trump surveillance warrants, anyone can be spied on; if FBI goons can target the president for criminal investigation first and hunt for predication later, any FBI chief can cook up any case he or she pleases. The prospect of this particular ex-FBI chief walking is outrageous since no one, not even former CIA chief John Brennan, lied so frequently, fluidly, and with such absolute assurance of getting away with it as James Comey:

    Subscribe now

    One of the charges Comey faces is that he lied when asked if he had authorized someone to be an anonymous press source on his behalf. It’s not disputed that he communicated with media through Columbia law professor Daniel Richman, since Comey testified that he asked “a friend of mine to share [information] with a reporter.” Even so, Comey’s self-assurance in coloring outside those lines is remarkable.

    Comey composed seven memos about his interactions with Trump and took home four. He told Inspector General Michael Horowitz it “never occurred to him” to put them through a classification review. When asked why he didn’t compose the memos on an FBI computer — like for instance the one in the Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility (SCIF) the FBI had installed in his house — Comey told the IG that he just “wasn’t thinking about” the memos belonging to the government, but rather, “this is for me.” Meanwhile, his Chief of Staff James Rybicki told Horowitz that, “when Comey finished each Memo, he gave Rybicki an original of each, which Comey initialed in blue ink, so that Rybicki could maintain originals of the Memos at the FBI.” An example:

    Comey signed his memos in blue ink to mark originals, which were to be maintained at the FBI — even though they were “for me” and not official, according to him

    Comey also showed at least four of the memos (including one he brought home) to Crossfire Hurricane investigators, per former FBI operative Lisa Page’s account to the IG. She said Comey met with the Crossfire team “conducting the Russia investigation” after his January 6, 2017 meeting with Trump — this is the one in which Comey told him “the Russians allegedly had tapes involving him and prostitutes” — and both told them about that first memo and forwarded it “to members of the team, to upload into the case file” because it was “central to investigative activity.”

    Page was so sure of the memos’ sensitivity that she kept them in a safe, in her office, which itself was a SCIF. FBI General Counsel James Baker, meanwhile, said he “assumed [the Memos] were Government records, because they’re related to official business.” But Comey artlessly told the IG he just assumed those memos were “for him,” like “a personal aide-mémoire,” or “[his] diary,” or “like [his] notes.”

    Translation: Comey was running a one-man, off-books investigation into his boss, deciding on the fly what rules did and did not apply to him, with the aim of keeping what amounted to a private kompromat file in his house. Not even J. Edgar Hoover tried this, and not even Comey’s closest colleagues backed the move. As Horowitz noted, “none of the members of Comey’s senior leadership team agreed with or defended Comey’s view that these Memos were personal in nature.” It was obvious these documents were “investigatory in nature,” and Comey made the “aide-mémoire” claim so he could pass notes to Richman and leak a Special Counsel case into being.

    Comey appeared completely unconcerned with getting caught. Take the issue of the FBI’s spying on the Trump campaign. This is not a lightly documented activity. There is a colossal Inspector General’s report on the subject of the FBI’s misuse of the FISA process to gain access to information about the Trump campaign. There are also hundreds of pages of declassified documents showing how Comey’s FBI paid informants like Stefan Halper $70,000 to spy on people like former Trump aide Carter Page, one of five “Crossfire” investigative targets (Page was “Crossfire Dragon”) who were the subject of human surveillance.

    The document below refers to a meeting right after a Yahoo! story came out falsely calling Page a Kremlin cutout, and just after Page wrote a letter to Comey denying the charges. The FBI responded to Page’s letter by having the informant Halper invite Page to his home in the hope that the “intimate setting” might get him to open up about his “interactions with the campaign” and, of course, conspiratorial relations with Russia.

    Bear in mind that the FBI would later claim that what Halper and other “sources” did was not “spying” because they didn’t formally join the Trump campaign, but merely gained their confidence in “intimate” settings to “elicit information.” As the Washington Post put it, “Because the FBI had someone talking to his campaign, Trump is pushing the narrative that the FBI was spying on it.”

    Comey would later be asked about this multiple times, most infamously on April 11, 2019. By then, the FBI’s abuse of the FISA process was no longer a secret and information about Halper and “campaign spying” had reached even the legacy press. Yet Comey had the stones to say on television of FISA surveillance, “I’ve never thought of that as spying,” because after all, what he did was “court-ordered electronic surveillance.” This is someone who knows the FISA court was lied to, in documents containing his signature, and also knows this information is going to come out. Yet listen to the confident delivery:

    Another Comey trick is to try to sneak out a non-fact and then step back and suggest it was a good-faith error if called on it. In an April 2018 interview with Bret Baier he tried to push the old saw that Christopher Steele was “funded first by Republicans”:

    This wasn’t true and moreover Comey had to know this wasn’t true, because he signed three of the four FISA applications, in which the motives of the “identified U.S. person” who hired Steele were a major issue. Comey either lied to the FISA court when he signed the document below, or he lied on the air:

    From the Carter Page warrant application

    There are more instances than one can count of Comey responding with faux-outrage after being busted himself. His reaction to the “Nunes memo” outlining the abuse of the FISA process impressively complained that Devin Nunes “damaged [sic] relationship with the FISA court” — after the FBI serially lied to the court:

    If readers detect a note of frustration it’s because messaging around the Comey affair has succeeded in masking the enormity of the offenses in question. The consequence of years of headlines like the New York Times piece, “F.B.I. Used Informant to Investigate Russia Ties to Campaign, Not to Spy, as Trump Claims,” has left a significant portion of the public unmoved by the now-undisguised reality of the FBI ordering political surveillance of a major-party presidential candidate, then attempting to prosecute using invented evidence. Every conceivable detail must be lied about to uphold the principle of impunity for such behavior. Old friend Ken Dilanian even went with an amazing whopper on MSNBC in coverage of the trial, claiming “it’s not entirely clear” what Comey’s being charged with:

    Just baldly untrue… The indictment is clear that Comey is charged with answering in the negative when asked if he “authorized someone else at the FBI to be an anonymous source in news reports.” Zero doubt what this means, but lie about it they must. Characters like Comey can’t just ride off into sunsets of inflated book deals and teaching gigs anymore. They can’t all get away with it, can they?

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.