
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


The prosecution of James Comey is the latest End of Democracy panic, so press mania is expected. A group letter signed by 42 retired judges, however, takes a grotesque step, turning Comey into a speech martyr:
For the first time in American history, the bedrock First Amendment right of American citizens to disagree with their president and their government and to express their views and opinions on any matter they wish — including their president — is under unprecedented attack by the President of the United States.
The Trump era being a time of soaring virtue-signaling and boundless partisanship, there’s been no shortage of open letters. Our own Greg Collard put together a painstaking compilation earlier this year. A few already earned places in history books for sheer dishonesty (the “51 Spies” letter comes to mind), but this new effort shatters the Guinness shamelessness record.
Judges stayed quiet as colleagues handed down sentences after the government charged people like John Kiriakou, Daniel Hale, Terry Albury, and Chelsea Manning with the Espionage Act for talking about torture, war crimes, our “targeted killing” drone assassination program, and other minor state peccadilloes. Apparently Justices also had to keep mum when thousands were removed from the Internet for disagreeing with the previous administration on issues like Covid. But trespassing on the “speech” of James Comey was a bridge too far.
What these justices are calling “First Amendment” activity is concocting pretexts for investigation, leaking classified information, perjury, and false accusation. They’re arguing officials should be able to smear with impunity. Recapping Comey’s “speech”:
Subscribe now
Long before Trump had time to view Comey as a “perceived” political enemy (as judges describe him), the former FBI head in late 2016 was signing applications to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court asking for monitoring of former Trump aide Carter Page. These applications relied on the dossier of paid Clinton campaign researcher Christopher Steele, which Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz later called “central and essential” to the granting of those warrants.
Comey signed three separate applications, including after the FBI terminated Steele “for cause” for talking to the media, and after the Bureau learned his primary claims were false or unfounded. Comey still told Senators under oath in 2020 that “in the main,” the investigation was conducted “by the book,” and he was “proud of the work.”
Comey’s “speech” therefore included taking part in an ongoing deception of judges, clearly an important principle for the 42 retirees. Later that same year, in December of 2016, Comey worked with CIA Director John Brennan and National Intelligence Director James Clapper to assemble an “Intelligence Community Assessment” that would conclude Russia and Vladimir Putin meddled in the 2016 election after developing a “clear preference” for Trump. Despite an absence of evidence serious enough that NSA Chief Michael Rogers threatened to pull out, Comey signed off on that document, too, which was published on January 6, 2017.
Comey wrote memos about his interactions with President-elect Donald Trump that included scenes of him telling his soon-to-be-boss on January 6th, 2017 that “we were not investigating him”:
“VERY CLOSE-HOLD”: Comey told Trump he wasn’t being investigated and promised to keep the pee tape material “close-hold.” It hit the papers three days laterIn Comey’s lofty A Higher Loyalty, he described how the idea of telling Trump he wasn’t under investigation went over with FBI General Counsel Jim Baker. After all, the “Crossfire Hurricane” probe that Comey would announce to great fanfare was still open:
After extensive discussion with my team, I decided I could assure the president-elect that the FBI was not currently investigating him. This was literally true. We did not have a counterintelligence case file open on him. We really didn’t care if he had cavorted with hookers in Moscow, so long as the Russians weren’t trying to coerce him in some way.
The FBI’s general counsel, Jim Baker, argued powerfully that such an assurance, although true, could be misleadingly narrow: the president-elect’s other conduct was, or surely would be, within the scope of an investigation looking at whether his campaign had coordinated with Russia. There was also the concern that the FBI might then be obligated to tell President Trump if we did open an investigation of him. I saw the logic of this position, but I also saw the bigger danger of the new president, who was known to be impulsive, going to war against the FBI.
Comey told Trump “we’re not investigating” him, then told himself this was “literally true” because the conversation was about prostitutes and Comey didn’t care about that, “so long as the Russians weren’t trying to coerce him.” Yet he was memorializing Trump’s answers and sending them not just to his Chief of Staff Jim Rybicki, but other FBI personnel like Andrew McCabe who were part of the “Crossfire Hurricane” probe (McCabe even signed the fourth Page warrant application after Comey was fired). In other words, Comey’s meeting with Trump was part of the ongoing investigation of Trump. Some of the first words he spoke to his future boss were lies, like that theirs was a private conversation, not written down within five minutes of the meeting’s end and e-shared for investigatory purposes:
A “PRIVATE CONVERSATION.” Except for the comprehensive memo I’m about to send FBI personnel investigating youWhen Comey said “we’re not investigating you,” he was lying about past and present. In an August 17th, 2016 national security briefing Trump received as a major-party candidate, an FBI agent was detailed to watch Trump and National Security aide Michael Flynn as part of the “Crossfire Hurricane” investigation. In other words, even though “Crossfire Hurricane” had been launched on the thinnest of pretexts and Trump himself had never done anything that remotely justified making him the subject of undercover FBI surveillance, Comey’s FBI was already spying on him, in the summer of 2016:
The FBI dolts who decided to use a national security briefing for “investigative purposes” before a presidential election were asked if it ever occurred to them that such activity might have a “chilling effect” on future briefings, if the episode ever became public. Former General Counsel Jim Baker told Horowitz’s office that “he did not recall that issue being discussed.” This was one of many issues Horowitz took issue with in his report, in addition to the 17 “significant” inaccuracies and errors with the FISAs Comey was “proud” (in the main) to have signed. Regarding the fake briefing:
The FBI’s use of such briefings for investigative purposes potentially interferes with this expectation and could frustrate the purpose of future counterintelligence briefings.
Recapping:
The FBI under Jim Comey repeatedly submitted phony research created by Hillary Clinton researcher Christopher Steele to FISA judges in order to obtain electronic surveillance of a presidential candidate. The Bureau fired Steele as a source for talking to the media after the October 31, 2016 publication of a Mother Jones story hinting that Trump had been “cultivated” by Russians for five years and subject to “blackmail,” but waited a year to punish the other FBI source for that story, Baker. Comey then signed off on placing the same bogus information in a highly classified annex to the January 6, 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment, which afforded him the opportunity to brief President-Elect Trump about its existence.
Days later, news organizations that had the Steele reports but until then had sat on them as unconfirmable bullshit reported the “blockbuster” news that the same material had been presented to Trump by four of the nation’s top intelligence chiefs, including Comey. Now the material was printable, no longer bullshit but “allegations” that “Russian operatives claim to have compromising personal and financial information about Mr. Trump.” Shortly after that, in testimony before the House Intelligence Committee, Comey announced that he had been “authorized” to disclose what he had not in his first meeting with Trump: that the FBI was “investigating the nature of any links between individuals associated with the Trump campaign and the Russian government.” He didn’t tell Congress or anyone else that the material that was sending the world into chaos — that Trump was in the thrall of blackmailing Russians — had by then been determined by FBI agents interviewing the original source of those stories to be “rumor and speculation” and “just talk.”
Not content to smear only one side, Comey also attempted to deflect criticism from Democrats that he’d dealt too harshly with Hillary Clinton.
In a 2017 Senate hearing, Comey testified that he asked “a friend of mine to share [information] with a reporter.” Also, FBI memos from its “Arctic Haze” leak investigation show the Bureau knew “Comey also hired Richman so Comey could discuss sensitive matters, including classified information… Comey also used Richman as a liaison to the media.”
One of the stories the FBI investigated was in the New York Times and published just before Trump fired him. Called “Comey Tried to Shield the F.B.I. From Politics. Then He Shaped an Election,” one passage quoted Richman as saying “Jim sees his role as apolitical and independent,” while another disclosed the hottest of hot stuff:
The Times found that this go-it-alone strategy was shaped by his distrust of senior officials at the Justice Department, who he and other F.B.I. officials felt had provided Mrs. Clinton with political cover. The distrust extended to his boss, Loretta E. Lynch, the attorney general, who Mr. Comey believed had subtly helped play down the Clinton investigation.
His misgivings were only fueled by the discovery last year of a document written by a Democratic operative that seemed — at least in the eyes of Mr. Comey and his aides — to raise questions about her independence. In a bizarre example of how tangled the F.B.I. investigations had become, the document had been stolen by Russian hackers.
This passage referred to documents covered in Racket earlier this summer that were somehow obtained by Russians that was supposedly written by then-DNC chair Debbie Wasserman-Schultz. One passage read, “the political director of the Hillary Clinton staff, Amanda Renteria, regularly receives information from Loretta Lynch of the Department of Justice, on the plans and intentions of the FBI.”
Comey was deeply concerned this document might leak out, telling interviewers from the Inspector General’s office:
I could picture emails rocketing around the Internet of… someone at the Atlantic Council saying, “I just had lunch with Debbie Wasserman Schultz. She told me Loretta Lynch is controlling Jim Comey.”
Comey told the IG his decision to make such an early statement about the “Midyear Exam” investigation into Hillary Clinton’s email server was fear that this document might come out. He was so concerned, in fact, that according to two FBI witnesses — Comey’s Chief of Staff Rybicki and Principal Deputy General Counsel of National Security and Cyberlaw Trisha Anderson — that Comey drafted his soon-to-be infamous “exoneration” statement of Clinton “in the spring” or in “May” of 2016, before his team interviewed her.
There is every reason to believe, in other words, that classified information was leaked to let Democrats know Comey hadn’t just said a few unkind things about Hillary’s email practices in the summer of 2016, but in fact been a good boy and sat on much more damaging material about Loretta Lynch.
Meanwhile, according to Comey’s own testimony, he had his “friend” speak to the media about Trump’s alleged comments saying “I hope you can let this go” with regard to the Flynn investigation, in the hopes it would “prompt the appointment of a special counsel” in the Trump case. Mueller was indeed appointed, assigned to continue the Comey investigation into “any links and/or coordination between the Russian government and individuals associated with the campaign of President Donald Trump” — an investigation that to date produced zero evidence of collusion, and lasted as long as it had only thanks to fraudulent FISA applications, whose contents were also leaked to the public.
Comey was a key player in the production and dissemination of phony evidence that created a false national security crisis in which the world was led to believe a sitting president was a stooge of Vladimir Putin. There is no “free speech absolutist” alive who’d count perjury and classified leaks as protected First Amendment activity. In Comey’s case there’s the additional novelty of classifying false information that was then leaked, to produce a desired political effect. This was comprehensive abuse of federal investigative machinery, and Trump was not the only victim. If there was such a thing as defamation of the entire United States, Comey would be liable.
I testified earlier this week that Americans have become numb to surveillance, but we’ve also gotten used to the spectacle of security officials lying their faces off to Congress and parachuting into cushy sinecures with networks or think-tanks after they finish their public deceptions. That’s insulting enough, but listening to judges wrap such behavior in the First Amendment is beyond obscene. They just keep finding new floors, don’t they?
A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:
Protests outside an ICE facility in Broadview, Ill., have intensified since the agency launched Operation Midway Blitz three weeks ago.
“This ICE operation will target the criminal illegal aliens who flocked to Chicago and Illinois because they knew Governor Pritzker and his sanctuary policies would protect them and allow them to roam free on American streets,” says an ICE press release in announcing the operation.
Prizker said Monday that ICE’s immigration enforcement is a “pretext to deploy military troops” in the region, and warned that 100 military personnel are on their way.
“People of Illinois, we need your help. Get your cell phones out – record what you see. Put it on social media. Peacefully ask for badge numbers and identification. Speak up for your neighbors. We need to let the world know this is happening – and that we won’t stand for it,” Pritzer said in an X post.
Many of the protesters at Broadview are willing to do that, and much more. Demonstrations have included intense pounding on government vehicles while trying to block them and ICE officers. Ford Fischer of News2Share first documented these interactions in a video we posted last week. Ford returned to Broadview last weekend and found the protests to be larger, longer, and involve repeated firing of riot munitions from weapons that resemble paintball guns.
Subscribe now
Ahead of Tuesday hearings on the subject, the Senate’s Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee (HSGAC) obtained documents showing three members of Congress, all Republicans, were followed under the TSA’s just-discontinued Quiet Skies program, which became infamous last summer when whistleblowers revealed bomb-sniffing dogs and Air Marshals were assigned to follow former Hawaii Congresswoman and future National Intelligence Director Tulsi Gabbard.
The members’ names have not yet been publicly released, but they were turned over to the Committee by the Department of Homeland Security, along with “TSA” notes explaining how they ended up on the list. Two of the three members made it onto the list before being elected, but as the Committee notes, “a cursory review would have revealed them to be a member of Congress, or a decorated U.S. veteran or service member.” The list below looks like four entries, but the second and third are the same member:
Three current members of Congress in addition to Tulsi Gabbard were recently chosen for “Quiet Skies” surveillanceA wealth of other information — not just about Quiet Skies but other questionable TSA practices — has been produced to the Committee chaired by Kentucky Senator Rand Paul. Among the revelations:
Documentation showing the TSA approved “enhanced screening” and watchlisting for individuals merely “suspected of traveling to the National Capital Region” in conjunction with January 6th, and who are “believed to pose an elevated risk” but for whom “there is a current lack of specific information relating to unlawful entry into the U.S. Capitol”;
At least 24 people were put into the program for being associated with a group the protested mask mandates, and 12 were placed on a watch list for removing their masks in-flight. The latter act was described in one memo as being “an act of extreme recklessness in carrying out an act that represents a threat to the life of passengers and crew”;
Confirmation that Gabbard was indeed surveilled for eight flights last summer, as UncoverDC and Racket reported. The ostensible justification? She was listed as a “possible affiliate” of a member of the Terrorist Screening Database (TSDB), which at last count contained over a million people. Internal correspondence also shows that after the story was made public, “TSA is looking into the incident with regards to people with access to this information”;
Confirmation that the TSA pulled a web screenshot of Gabbard’s Congressional bio and not an official Passport or other government photo, as would be standard;
Confirmation that the TSA put Christine Crowder, wife of a Federal Air Marshal and upcoming witness Mark Crowder, under “Special Mission Coverage” due to “association of traveling on the same itinerary as a KST,” or Known or Suspected Terrorist. The TSA mistakenly believed Mrs. Crowder entered the Capitol on January 6th, and eventually conceded the episode was a case of “mistaken identity.”
Racket readers will recall a fiasco that spilled into public last August 4th, when UncoverDC (a site run by well-known online journalist Tracy Beanz) ran a story citing travel dates titled “Federal Air Marshal Whistleblowers Report Tulsi Gabbard Actively Under Surveillance via Quiet Skies Program.” When I reached out to Gabbard, she told me “The whistleblowers’ account matches my experience,” and told of a series of intrusive searches dating to July 23, 2024, just after she’d criticized eventual nominee Kamala Harris on The Ingraham Angle, saying she “does not have the strength to stand up to the Military-Industrial Complex.”
Despite reports containing on-the-record sources in UncoverDC and Racket, and a letter to Congress sent by the well-known firm Empower Oversight on behalf of “multiple Federal Air Marshal whistleblowers” complaining about the episode, only Fox, The Hill, and the Washington Examiner and Times among legacy outlets covered the story. The fact-checking site Snopes waited a month to declare it unconfirmed and in need of “more research.” Only after Donald Trump was re-elected and news broke that Gabbard was his likely choice for the DNI position did the mainstream press bound into action — not to question surveillance of a high-profile politician, but to raise questions about Gabbard’s character.
CNN, for instance, wrote “the episode has raised eyebrows among security officials, who point to Gabbard’s history of unusual relationships overseas.” The New York Times waited almost six months, until January of 2025, to say there was no indication Gabbard “did anything wrong” in her overseas trip, but the episode “raised questions about the extent to which Mr. Trump’s nominee to serve as the nation’s top intelligence official adequately weighed the implications of her foreign travels and associations.”
New York Times, January 28, 2025Quiet Skies became known to the public in 2018, when The Boston Globe exposed that the TSA was following 30 people a day (later reports put the number closer to 50), despite the program never once leading to an arrest or preventing a terrorist incident. The program was both intrusive and wasteful, to extreme degrees. Each “selectee” was followed by three (and now, we learn, possibly more) members of the Federal Air Marshal Service (FAMS), in addition to being subject to special searches and examination by bomb-sniffing dogs. A 2019 report of the Homeland Security Inspector General found an astonishing $394 million — nearly half the Air Marshals’ $803 million budget — could have been “put to better use.”
If you were chosen for Quiet Skies coverage, Marshals trained to prevent terrorists from rushing cockpits would instead be asked to try to listen to your in-flight conversations, register the type of smartphone you used, even mark down “what exact times you went to the bathroom, so they could figure out the frequency,” as formal Marshal Robert MacLean put it.
At the time, this was not a partisan issue. The Globe’s hometown Senator, Ed Markey, grilled then-TSA chief David Pekoskie about why his agency would “monitor Americans who aren’t suspected of any crime” and “does the TSA monitor whether Americans go to the bathroom during flights?”
Over the years, however, party interest in Quiet Skies became curiously divided. In 2023, then-Democratic Chair of the same Homeland Security Committee Gary Peters released a report showing a number of concerning details likely unknown to most Americans. For instance, “U.S. travelers may be screened for at least 22 different reasons” (likely 21, now that Quiet Skies has been eliminated). The Peters report however stressed the notion that “certain communities — Muslim, Arab, and South Asian Americans in particular — claim they have been unfairly targeted,” at a time when the program was targeting all sorts of people, including people protesting mask mandates.
Meanwhile, the Trump administration and DHS Chief Kristi Noem ended the program because “since its existence has failed to stop a single terrorist attack while costing US taxpayers $200 million a year,” citing also episodes and documents that “highlight the inconsistent application of Quiet Skies and watchlisting programs, circumventing security policies to benefit politically aligned friends and family at the expense of the American people.”
In 2023, William “Billy” Shaheen, husband of New Hampshire Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen, also triggered a Quiet Skies rule by scheduling a flight with a “KST,” meaning a Known or Suspected Terrorist (reportedly immigration lawyer Celine Atallah). After two enhanced searches, Senator Shaheen contacted then-TSA administrator David Pekoske, after which Mr. Shaheen was excluded from Quiet Skies.
The TSA throughout the Gabbard affair maintained that entry into “Quiet Skies” only took place if a person was “matched to a risk-based rule.” The new documents do bear this out, showing for instance in the cases of the three members of Congress that each was put in the program after triggering a rule, identified by a multi-digit numeral. The “rules,” however, are in many cases just arcane combinations of demerits. While we’re unable to disclose the exact “derog” info that might entail, a hypothetical example might be: “A person who falls in a certain age range and traveled to the U.S. from a particular NATO Country and who traveled to one of four Middle Eastern countries in the last two years.”
Gabbard was ostensibly placed in the program because, as the Times reported, she attended an event “at the Vatican that was organized by a European businessman who appeared on an F.B.I. watch list.” Marshals were told this was the reason. The DHS documents include text exchanges between Marshals assigned to cover Gabbard from July 22 of last year. One section describes her as an “affiliate” with a member of the Terrorist Screening Database:
so Gabbard is an affiliate with a TSDB, and since she’s no longer in Congress that’s probably why she hit for the rule.
Yeah I talked with [redacted] about it and that’s the conclusion we came to as well.
cool cool
This explanation isn’t exactly seamless, however. Other well-known Americans should have triggered the same rule and did not. The use of Gabbard’s Congressional photo instead of an official one suggested to multiple former Marshals that there was at least human review of the episode.
“Obviously,” one former Marshal explained, “there is a way for human beings to influence the decision tree above our level.”
Quiet Skies wasn’t just a 9/11 anachronism that wasted taxpayer money and created a high risk of politicized use of federal enforcement resources. MacLean describes how the program complicated ordinary anti-terrorist surveillance, because Marshals were often seated in the backs of planes to watch members of Quiet Skies lists, and terrorists do not rush cockpits from rear seats. In a refrain that’s become common among current and former FBI agents as well as other enforcement or interdiction agents, MacLean complained, “The air marshal’s job is to protect the cockpit and the pilots. Let somebody else do the intelligence and criminal investigative work.” A Merit Systems Protection Board judge dismissed the complaint in early 2020, but the DHS IG agreed with MacLean later that year.
“For those flights covered by Federal air marshals,” it wrote, “seating positions on the aircraft, as well as aircraft layout, impeded sightlines and may have prevented air marshals from visually identifying potential threats.”
Another serious issue involved Marshals being asked to follow selectees all the way out of the airport to see who, if anyone, picks them up. They are asked to do this even overseas. “You’re basically telling air marshals to conduct foreign surveillance,” MacLean said. “It’s crazy.” He pointed to an incident in 2010 in which two Air Marshals had to flee Brazil on “alternate documents.” It wasn’t over Quiet Skies, but it underscores the risk of sending people not trained to operate overseas into the field abroad.
The elimination of Quiet Skies, along with programs like the Global Engagement Center, shows the administration is serious at least about eliminating the most obviously abusive and indefensible security programs. However, as I’ll be testifying this morning in the Senate, there are more. And they need to be reevaluated, and in many cases defunded. Thanks to Senator Paul and his staff for retrieving these documents.
Last year, former Hawaii Congresswoman and Presidential Candidate Tulsi Gabbard was placed in a surveillance program called Quiet Skies by the Transportation and Security Administration. Across eight flights she was subject to intrusive searches, followed by bomb-sniffing dogs, and trailed by three Federal Air Marshals per flight, who if they were following procedure were attempting to listen to her conversations, following her to airport exits to see who if anyone met her, and even recording how often and at what times she went to the bathroom.
To cover the story I contacted the TSA. They no-commented the main question – “TSA does not confirm or deny whether any individual has matched to a risk-based rule,” they said – but they added, as if in mitigation: ”Simply matching to a risk-based rule does not constitute derogatory information about an individual.”
In other words: “We can’t say if Ms. Gabbard was in the program, but if she was, don’t draw conclusions, because we do this even to innocent people.”
Before Quiet Skies was discontinued by this administration, it was a symbol of the steep decline of federal enforcement since 9/11. The government spent $200 million a year following up to 50 people a day for a program that in its history never once led to an arrest, or thwarted a single criminal act. Despite its demonstrated inutility and grave civil liberties concerns it was re-funded year after year because this is what our government does now: it gathers information on its own citizens as an end in itself.
In a week in which the question of whether federal security officials always tell the truth to Congress is back in the news, it’s worth noting that it’s been 13 years since then-National Intelligence Director James Clapper answered, “No, sir,” and “Not wittingly” when Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon asked, “Does the NSA collect any type of data at all on millions, or hundreds of millions of Americans?”
Clapper later explained that he’d responded in the “least most untruthful manner.”
That episode solidified the principle that if you lie about mass surveillance programs in America, even under oath, you not only get to keep your job, you get to be hired as a professional truth-teller after retirement, a National Security Analyst for CNN. If you try to tell the truth about the same issues, your options are prison or leaving the country forever.
In those 13 years since, Americans became numb to surveillance. It was once a core principle that government couldn’t or shouldn’t spy on citizens without predication. Now much of the country accepts as inevitable the idea that every move we make is being recorded and analyzed.
We know emails and phone conversations are being collected passively, via programs of dubious legality, and the mountains of data we leave behind as our lives move online– from geolocations of cell phones to GPS tracking to travel, banking, and medical records – are increasingly fodder for overt and covert acquisition by federal analysts. As Google admitted last week, federal officials partnered with companies not just to monitor speech but to suppress it on a grand scale.
A lot of these changes have their roots in War on Terror programs that exchanged predication for a pre-crime theory out of Minority Report. Quiet Skies was the paradigmatic example of a program that could take endless liberties with the Constitution because it was secret. When you gather information with no intention of going to court, as the TSA did with Quiet Skies, you never have to justify yourself to a judge. This leads to a lot of what one court called “the exact sort of ‘general, exploratory rummaging’ that the Fourth Amendment was designed to prevent.”
This is a betrayal not just of the public but of people we trained at taxpayer expense to do real and important work. Former Marshal Robert MacLean put it best when he said “The air marshal’s job is to protect the cockpit and the pilots. Let somebody else do the intelligence.”
Similarly in the last decade current and former FBI agents – fellow witness Tristan Leavitt’s firm has represented a number of them – have talked about how since 9/11, the FBI spends less time building cases but does more generalized spying, much of it political. One agent I interviewed said “The distinction between people who believe bad thoughts and people who do bad things” has been “completely lost” on our government since 9/11.
Once you start down the road of collecting information on innocent people, it creates the intellectual justification for doing it again and again. From a contracting perspective, this is the proverbial self-licking ice cream cone, a spiral of endless expense. Morally, all this information-gathering reverses the natural political order, giving elected officials undeserved and unearned power over their bosses – the voters. These programs all need to be reevaluated. A lot of them have to go. People who lie about them in this chamber need to be fired.
Let’s hope the elimination of Quiet Skies is just the beginning. Thank you.
Listen to Episode 152
Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: I’m Walter Kirn. I almost forgot.
Matt Taibbi: You’re in your cabin, Walter, right?
Walter Kirn: Yeah, I’m in my cabin. You can see out behind me that there’s wilderness, but there’s also wilderness in front of me when I look past Matt. A lot of the time when I’m podcasting from the cabin, what I’m really doing is alerting to bears and intrusions of major predatory wildlife. I haven’t seen a mountain lion yet. But often I look past and I see wild turkeys, deer, elk, other critters. So it’s a great contrast because we’ve become futuristic in our podcasting, because the world has become futuristic. It’s a Philip K. Dick novel now. And the reassurance of a bear wandering by to eat berries off a tree keeps me grounded.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah, I’m very glad for all the wild animals outside my house. It makes me feel happy that I’m farther away from people than I could be. Yeah, another week that just makes me never want to mix with human beings again. It’s just been absolutely atrocious, the events of the last few days. I don’t even know where to start. Let’s start with an easy place. I believe it was Tuesday, Google sent a letter in response to the House Judiciary Committee to Jim Jordan and the group of investigators he has. He has a very good group of investigators on his staff, who’ve looked into everything from the Stanford Internet Observatory to Facebook, to Twitter, to the DHS, to all kinds of things. And they had sent out subpoenas and interrogatories to Google about censorship during the COVID period. They got back, I would say an extraordinary letter. We’ve already had the Twitter file, so Twitter has already made admissions in the Elon Musk era about its censorship role. Mark Zuckerberg last year talked about Biden officials who yelled and screamed when they were pressuring them and used the word censor. So, Meta has already made admissions.
2025 09 23 Letter To Hjc1.26MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadNow Google has come out. Google is the biggest bear of all in this group. This document that came out that was sent to the House Judiciary Committee, it’s packed full of serious admissions. The biggest ones are, I think the eighth, ninth, and 10th paragraphs. You can see here before that, it says in seven, it says, “The COVID-19 pandemic was an unprecedented time in which online platforms had to reach decisions about how to balance freedom with responsibility.” All that Spider-Man stuff, with great power comes great responsibility. Then they go to eight and they say, “Senior Biden officials, including White House officials, repeated and sustained outreach to Alphabet and pressed the company regarding certain user-generated content related to COVID-19 that did not violate its policies. Administration officials continued to press the company to remove non-violative user-generated content.”
And then it goes farther. The next paragraph, it names the president. “As online platforms, including Alphabet, grappled with these decisions, the administration’s officials, including President Biden, created a political atmosphere that sought to influence the actions of platforms based on their concerns regarding misinformation.” 10, “It is unacceptable and wrong when any government, including the Biden administration, attempts to dictate how the company moderates content.”
Now, it goes on to say other stuff. It goes on to complain about Europe. It goes on to talk about fact checking. It goes on to talk about reinstating the thousands of people that were removed for various reasons, from COVID to electoral integrity under its policies. But the big thing is, this is a major admission. Now, why did they make this admission now? There’s some speculation that this was because they were trying to send a message to the Trump administration that lying about how it’s bad when any president does it, maybe they’re releasing it now as a way to-
How to cover a crime story, network style
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/25/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
As Google becomes the latest company to admit to mass censorship, the mania over Jimmy Kimmel has morphed into a grotesque propaganda campaign
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/25/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
The Financial Times reported September 12, 2025, that:
The documents, seen by the Financial Times, appear to contradict allegations by Federal Housing Finance Agency director Bill Pulte, a Trump ally and frequent critic of the central bank, that Cook had claimed the Atlanta condo and another property in Michigan were both her principal residences. The first document, a letter from the Bank-Fund Staff Federal Credit Union dated May 28 2021, shows estimates of costs associated with the purchase of a $625,000 property in Atlanta, Georgia. The loan estimate states the property would be used as a vacation home. The second document, an SF-86 supplemental questionnaire dated December 3 2021, shows that, when asked to list all of her interests in real property, Cook listed the Atlanta address as her second home. The government uses the SF-86 to conduct background checks for positions deemed important for national security.
Vindication? I don’t think so.
Pulte alleges that she represented in her mortgage agreement for both houses, within two weeks of each other, that she would move into them within 60 days as her primary residence for at least one year. If that’s true, the documents referenced above don’t necessarily override those representations.
CNBC also threw its hat into the ring of dumb reporting with a different angle on the “vindication of Lisa Cook” when it reported:
The rates on Cook’s two mortgages show Cook didn’t enjoy discounts compared with prevailing rates available to borrowers when she negotiated the loans in 2021.
Her rate on the 15-year loan on the Michigan property was 2.875%, versus a prevailing national rate in that period ranging from 2.23% to 2.45%, according to Freddie Mac data. And her rate on the 30-year loan on her Atlanta property was 3.25%, versus a prevailing rate at the time ranging from 2.93% to 3.04%, according to Freddie Mac data.
This take is meaningless. The Freddie Mac data comes from their Primary Mortgage Market Survey Rate (PMMS). Here is Freddie’s description of the PMMS:
“Lenders surveyed each week are a mix of lender types – credit unions, commercial banks and mortgage lending companies – is roughly proportional to the level of mortgage business that each type commands nationwide.”
The Freddie Mac PMMS rate is a weighted survey that publishes one rate on the Thursday of each week. From the description above, the survey is weighted by lender type, non-bank mortgage originators (such as Rocket Mortgage), commercial banks and credit unions. In 2021, non-bank mortgage companies originated 63.9% of first lien home mortgages, with banks and credit unions making up the difference, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Cook received her mortgage on the Atlanta residence from Bank-Fund Staff Credit Union. Since the PMMS is a weighted average, Cook’s mortgage rate of 3.25% could very well be where her credit union was lending to borrowers purchasing a home as their primary residence.
Did Cook get a rate that would be associated with a loan on a primary residence or a secondary one? It should be relatively easy to find out if the rate she received on her Atlanta mortgage was at a “discount” by having Cook’s credit union show what rate they were charging on conventional mortgages on primary residences on the day or the week Cook was given her mortgage. If the rate they were charging was significantly lower than 3.25% (0.25% or more), she didn’t receive a discount, and if it was 3.25% or higher, she did.
However, whether she got a discount or not, the thing to keep in mind is that making false statements on the mortgage deed of trust is a felony. That seems to be getting lost in this argument.
President Trump cited “false statements on one or more mortgage agreements” in firing Cook last month, but courts are letting her stay on the job while she argues he doesn’t have the authority to take such action. The Trump administration is seeking an order from the U.S. Supreme Court to let the firing take effect.
Cook’s attorneys argue in a Thursday filing that her removal “would signal to the financial markets that the Federal Reserve no longer enjoys its traditional independence, risking chaos and disruption.”
This filing came after a group of former Fed chairs, treasury secretaries and White House economic advisers — Bloomberg calls them “economic luminaries” — filed a brief that urges the Supreme Court to let Cook remain a Fed governor while her lawsuit proceeds:
Granting the government’s request to remove Governor Cook from the Board immediately would upset these longstanding protections and the essential functions they serve. Doing so would expose the Federal Reserve to political influences, thereby eroding public confidence in the Fed’s independence and jeopardizing the credibility and efficacy of U.S. monetary policy. Maintaining the status quo while the lawfulness of the termination is adjudicated, in contrast, would serve the public’s interest by safeguarding the independence and stability of the system that governs monetary policy in this country.
Does a Federal Reserve Board governor defending herself from accusations of mortgage fraud damage the Fed’s credibility? Most of the media and the “economic luminaries” seem to be cruising right past that question.
Cook was not a Fed governor when she took out the loans. Should that matter? I don’t think so. Given the Fed’s influence, its governors and presidents can’t be seen as getting a pass on alleged financial crimes, as they have in the past. Last year, the Fed’s Office of Inspector General found that former officers didn’t disclose trades they were making in 2020 while they were deciding an emergency interest rate cut as the economy was shutting down due to the Covid pandemic.
In addition to Fed officials, we have federal judges and government officials trading on material non-public information, also known as insider trading.
And of course, members of Congress just happen to make a killing while in office. There are even ETFs tracking the trades of Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi and Sen. Ted Cruz under the tickers NANC and KRUZ!
Additionally, our fearless leader Mr. Taibbi wrote a piece back in 2017 taking former Senator Bob Corker to task for his multi-million dollar day trading operation.
Remember the uproar all this reported crime caused?
No?
Me neither.
An imperious talk show host won the love of Hollywood and the ACLU, but to stop government pressure on companies, speech defenders need to recognize Alex Berenson
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/23/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
From the publisher's feed