
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
NBC News just ran a 1,012-word article titled, “Former FBI Director James Comey indicted.”
Here are all the words about the substance of the charges:
The charges stem from testimony Comey gave on Sept. 30, 2020, during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing. Asked by Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, about testimony he gave in 2017 asserting that he did not authorize leaking information regarding the FBI’s investigations into President Donald Trump or former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, Comey said, “I stand by the testimony.”
Comey’s deputy, Andrew McCabe, has said that Comey authorized him to leak information to the press, according to a 2018 Justice Department inspector general’s report. But the report also found that McCabe made multiple false or misleading statements.
The rest is about politicization of the Justice system, objections to the case from within the office of Acting U.S. Attorney from the Eastern District of Virginia Lindsay Halligan, Donald Trump’s social media posts, the notion that Comey has been in Trump’s crosshairs since he “launched an investigation into Russian election interference in the 2016 presidential race,” John Durham’s failure to charge Comey previously, and other matters.
NBC’s sole reference to Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz’s report on “James Comey’s Unauthorized Disclosure of Sensitive Information and Handling of Certain Memoranda” concerned statements by Andrew McCabe. It did not mention sixteen other witnesses, nor the conclusion: “We have previously faulted Comey for acting unilaterally and inconsistent with Department policy. Comey’s unauthorized disclosure of sensitive law enforcement information… merits similar criticism.”
NBC does not mention the name of Columbia University professor Daniel Richman, about whom recently released FBI memos disclosed: “Comey instructed the FBI to hire Richman as a Special Government Employee (SGE)” and “grant him a Top Secret clearance with access to Sensitive Compartmented Information” in 2015, so he could “discuss sensitive matters, including classified information, with someone outside of the FBI’s regular leadership.”
Finally, NBC also does not mention the name Michael Schmidt, the New York Times reporter who used Richman as a source in stories describing Comey as “apolitical and independent.”
Schmidt is the husband of MSNBC anchor Nicolle Wallace.
Google this week sent a letter to the House Judiciary Committee:
Senior Biden administration officials, including White House officials, conducted, repeated and sustained outreach to Alphabet and pressed the company regarding certain user-generated content related to the COVID-19 pandemic that did not violate its policies.
While the company continued to develop and enforce its policies independently, Biden administration officials continued to press the company to remove non-violative user generated content as online platforms, including Alphabet grappled. With these decisions, the administration’s officials, including President Biden, created a political atmosphere that sought to influence the actions of platforms based on their concerns regarding misinformation.
It is unacceptable and wrong when any government, including the Biden administration, attempts to dictate how the company moderates content, and the company has consistently fought against those efforts on First Amendment grounds.
Along with the Twitter Files and Mark Zuckerberg’s admission about Biden officials who would “scream” or “curse” about removing content, the Google letter caps the trifecta of major Internet platforms who’ve admitted to partnering with the government in systematic censorship in the pre-Trump period.
YouTube removed thousands of people from its platform at the government’s behest during the pandemic. Tens of thousands more were deamplified or labeled, often incorrectly. Even before letters like the one above, this was no secret. When reporters like me called to ask YouTube, Meta, or Twitter why this or that person had been sanctioned during the pandemic, they told us flat-out they were following parameters laid out by government. Google announced this publicly, in statements like:
Prevention misinformation: We do not allow content that promotes information that contradicts health authority guidance on the prevention or transmission of specific health conditions, or on the safety, efficacy or ingredients of currently approved and administered vaccines.
Google, Facebook, and Twitter didn’t just suppress information that contradicted “health authority guidance,” information which incidentally was often true (as in the cases of people like Jay Bhattacharya, Alex Berenson, and Harvard’s Martin Kulldorff). They made conscious decisions to leave up government misinformation. While YouTube was removing critics of the vaccine, it was leaving up a CNN Town Hall featuring President Biden saying that if you get the shot, “you’re not going to die”:
Before this year there were entire federal bureaucracies devoted to policing speech, from the State Department’s Global Engagement Center to the FBI’s Foreign Influence Task Force to the White House Office of Digital Strategy. State agencies also partnered with “private” NGOs (often, funded by government) to create secondary bureaucracies charged with policing speech, like the now-defunct Stanford Internet Observatory, which denied making content recommendations until forced to turn over documents showing they did just that. The FBI and Department of Homeland Security were having monthly (in some cases weekly) meetings with upwards of two dozen Internet companies, funneling “guidance” on content on a range of topics, from Covid to Russia to Iran to “U.S. Elections.” Like a parolee, Facebook had to send a “bi-weekly Covid content report” to Surgeon General Vivek Murthy.
Whether you blame this on the administration of Joe Biden, Barack Obama, or the first term of Donald Trump (during which some of these bodies flourished), it’s now undeniable that federal pressure or “jawboning” to suppress dissent was systematic long before Jimmy Kimmel got a few days off.
How did politicians and the U.S. media respond to confirmation that the last administration engaged in wholesale censorship not of one jerkwad talk show host, but the entire world? They pretended it didn’t happen:
Subscribe now
The New York Times ran hundreds of stories about Covid-19 during the pandemic, including many that repeated inaccurate claims and remain uncorrected, along with countless editorials decrying Covid “misinformation” or reporting about an “onslaught” of “toxic” content. How much space did it give the Google announcement, which touched on all these things?
347 words.
From “YouTube to Reinstate Accounts Banned Over Content Related to the Pandemic and 2020 Election”:
YouTube will create a process to reinstate the accounts of content creators whose profiles were banned in recent years because they violated rules that limited misinformation about Covid-19 and the 2020 election.
This is an all-time example of burying the lede. Google couldn’t have been clearer that it was not only subject to “repeated and sustained” pressure, but that the pressure involved material that “did not violate its policies.” This was particularly shocking since as noted above, Google’s policies included the entire universe of things that might “contradict” official guidance.
What could possibly not violate Google’s broad policies but still fall afoul of the Biden administration? We know from other lawsuits and investigations that the Biden White House was upset about everything from a joke meme about future vaccine lawsuits to theories about lab-leak origin to a Tucker Carlson video that Facebook said didn’t violate its policies. The world is now losing its mind over one incident involving Brendan Carr that took place in public and ended with the “victim” back on air. The Biden White House “jawboned” Facebook into reducing by 50% the traffic to a cable segment by one of the country’s most-watched newscasters:
The Carlson video that was ripped at the time as “illogical conspiracy” wondered why the Biden government was saying, in April 2021, that you still need to wear a mask or socially distance, if the vaccines work. His was one of countless reports suppressed that were not violative and contained true information. Yet America’s paper of record in the lede of its thimble-sized recognition of a years-long censorship campaign focused on accounts “banned… because they violated rules that limited misinformation.” Yes, it acknowledged “non-violative” content below, but it’s become clear that papers like the Times and public figures are bending over backward to preserve the fiction that, yes, we censored, but we did it for the right reasons.
Representative Jim Clyburn in response to the Google news said it “wasn’t the same” as the Kimmel episode, because “it was a pandemic” and we couldn’t have “foolishness” and “misinformation” going on. (Note how CNN’s Abby Phillip swerves around the “non-violative” issue as well, audibling to a line about content the Biden administration “thought was disinformation.”) Meanwhile, Jake Tapper went on The Seth Myers Show and said the Jimmy Kimmel episode “was pretty much the most direct infringement by the government on free speech that I’ve seen in my lifetime”:
We’ve now moved to the stage of the Jimmy Kimmel story beyond immediate outrage and legit opposition to rank propaganda. It’s unconscionable for Tapper to say this in the same week that Google admitted submitting to “repeated and sustained” government pressure during the pandemic, pressure that happened to thousands of people instead of one and lasted years instead of days.
The pandemic speech clampdown was exactly the reason the First Amendment exists. As James Madison put it when arguing against the Alien and Sedition Acts, the state can’t use “previous restraint” to prevent criticism of its policies, because in the American system, “the people, not the government, possess the absolute sovereignty.” The obscenity of Clyburn’s point of view is in the idea that the state not only has the right to meddle with the press, but with the conversations between private citizens, and not just within the United States.
The sheer scale of the last Administration’s ambitions was breathtaking in this respect, and it’s only through a few lucky breaks (and the work of politicians like Jim Jordan) that we even know about the extent of it. For Tapper, ostensibly a news person, to look beyond such a vast amount of organized misconduct to pronounce the Kimmel episode the Worst Thing Ever is nuts.
The Trump Administration hasn’t exactly been a standard-bearer for speech. From Trump’s executive order on antisemitism to a deportations policy I join groups like FIRE in opposing to Carr’s unsubtle move on Disney (which counts as jawboning even if it wasn’t the reason for Kimmel’s suspension), this administration has bared fangs at the First Amendment more than once.
Even people who should know better, though, including some who were censored, seem to have forgotten what we escaped. What Google admitted to with regard to Covid, and what Meta and Twitter admitted to previously, represents the apotheosis of a decade-long effort to build a lavishly-funded, full-spectrum speech bureaucracy, whose vision included algorithmic “previous restraint” at the highest (e.g. Carlson) and most micro levels. That vision is in place in Europe, about which Google also complained (the Biden administration’s failure to help American companies resist laws like the Digital Services Act was another major offense). The hysteria over the Kimmel episode — Tapper’s CNN was breathlessly “counting down to Kimmel” before his return — has become a mechanism for burying that history. On speech, Trump just isn’t in the same universe as his predecessor, I suspect even Jake Tapper knows it, and the failure of people like him to admit it should worry anyone who cares about this issue.
Last week, after ABC late night host Jimmy Kimmel infuriated conservatives with a monologue decrying the “MAGA gang” for “trying to characterize this kid who killed Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them,” FCC Chair Brendan Carr railed against Disney on a podcast with Benny Johnson. “We can do this the easy way or the hard way,” Carr seethed. “These companies can find ways to take action on Kimmel or there is going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.”
Kimmel was fired by Disney, leading to an outpouring of support for the First Amendment that was heartening on one level, infuriating on another. Lame-duck comic Stephen Colbert unironically announced “We are all Jimmy Kimmel,” and 400+ Hollywood celebrities signed an ACLU letter in Kimmel’s defense, with Senators like Connecticut’s Richard Blumenthal citing an “unprecedented act of government censorship.”
It wasn’t unprecedented. A close analog to the Kimmel situation was already moving through courts in a high-profile First Amendment case called Berenson v. Biden. Just like Jimmy Kimmel, former New York Times reporter Alex Berenson was “jawboned” off a public platform. He was identified by a combination of White House officials and pharmaceutical executives as a voice they wanted to remove from Twitter for criticism of the Covid-19 vaccine. Also just like Kimmel, Berenson was actioned just after a high-profile government official made a televised complaint, in this case a July 16, 2021 appearance by Joe Biden:
Berenson was locked out of his account for the first time hours after Biden’s appearance. Weeks later, he was suspended for good. Not that it matters, but while Kimmel was threatened for inaccuracy, Berenson’s problems stemmed from being too accurate about the mRNA Covid vaccines, about everything from studies showing surprising inefficacy to potential links to myocarditis that even Biden’s CDC eventually acknowledged. Critics have gone after other Berenson statements, but the ones that got him in trouble were exactly what the Founders had in mind when they thought about speech: true statements made in opposition to an official propaganda campaign. The last straw was this accurate tweet from August 28, 2021:
It doesn’t stop infection. Or transmission. Don’t think of it as a vaccine. Think of it—at best—as a therapeutic with a limited window of efficacy and terrible side effect profile that must be dosed IN ADVANCE OF ILLNESS. And we want to mandate it? Insanity.
Berenson’s removal marked the end of a five-month campaign that involved current and former high-level officials from Pfizer and multiple government agencies. Onetime Biden official Andy Slavitt commemorated Berenson’s silencing by posting a screenshot of Berenson’s locked account. That tweet is still live:
What does this have to do with Kimmel, who’s been reinstated by Disney and returns to the air tonight in what will be hyped as the greatest First Amendment comeback since the Pentagon Papers? A lot.
First, Google just made a remarkable admission in a letter to House Judiciary Chair Jim Jordan, admitting it was censored during Covid. “Biden administration officials, including White House officials,” the firm wrote, “conducted repeated and sustained outreach” regarding “user-generated content related to the COVID-19 pandemic that did not violate its policies.” The firm added it was “unacceptable and wrong” when “any government” attempts to dictate content decisions. There were additional complaints about the “onerous obligations” of European laws like the Digital Services Act (Racket will have more on this soon).
Even though Berenson’s case is built around Twitter and not YouTube, Google’s admissions leave no doubt about the “repeated and sustained” censorship of that era, which everyone seems to be forgetting. While people like Kimmel and Colbert were swimming in bucks pumping out grotesque vaccine propaganda, the primary victims were people like Berenson.
“It’s just more evidence,” Berenson says of the Google news. “The companies can say they acted independently, but they’re acknowledging they felt pressure.”
More importantly, this case is alive and in the hands of the Trump administration. If new speech converts want to pressure this White House, this is one place to do it.
Just a few months before Brendan Carr’s outburst, Biden-appointed Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke of the Southern District of New York handed down a ruling in Berenson’s case that should have shocked speech advocates. On July 14th, Clarke dismissed the private defendants, writing:
Plaintiff lacks standing to assert a First Amendment claim against Slavitt because Berenson cannot obtain equitable relief or Bivens monetary damages against him.
This seeming throwaway line packed a wallop, as a frustrated Berenson wrote on his Substack in July.
“Clarke found that my core First Amendment claims are barred not because I couldn’t prove the White House censored me or I was injured as a result,” he said, “but because the Supreme Court has not allowed for money damages against the federal government for First Amendment violations.”
He was referring to so-called Bivens actions, which allow citizens to sue for federal rights violations only in certain circumstances (until now, not on First Amendment grounds). Paired with the problem of ordering injunctive relief in a speech case — the analogous action for Kimmel would be forcing Disney to re-hire him, which would create a new speech violation — Clarke essentially ruled that since people censored via third parties aren’t entitled to relief, his case has to be dismissed.
It was bad enough that everyone in media missed this ruling when it happened, including me, but now? Berenson has been hopping mad since the Kimmel brouhaha kicked off, and has a right to be, since his case speaks directly to the Kimmel issue, and former colleagues still won’t shine a light.
“It’s a flaw in the law and it doesn’t just apply to me. It’s wrong philosophically that you can’t get damages from the federal government for a violation of your First Amendment rights,” Berenson says. “And it would have been the same thing for Jimmy Kimmel.”
When he won last year’s election, Trump took over for the Biden defendants in Berenson’s case. After Clarke’s decision, Trump defendants are the only ones left in the case. It wouldn’t help with the gaping loophole that now appears to exist with third party censorship, but it would set a cost for violating speech rights. The administration’s hesitancy to make good with Berenson is at best curious, and Judge Clarke’s own mysterious failure to dismiss with regard to the Trump administration opens the door for a message to be sent.
For administration critics who’ll cheer their next-gen Lenny Bruce on ABC tonight, why not also push Trump to make a meaningful gesture toward the First Amendment by settling with someone he doesn’t even hate?
THEY WENT THERE: USA Today invoked Lenny Bruce in its Kimmel coverageIf the ACLU can get Tom Hanks, Meryl Streep, Ben Stiller and 400 other stars for Kimmel, they really can’t organize twenty signatures for a case right down the fairway of their historical mission? Sadly, it’s obvious why it won’t happen:
Subscribe now
When Kimmel was fired by Disney, commentators rushed to speculate about a suit, with Politico going so far as to say Kimmel “should have strong odds at the Supreme Court.” Politico’s ostensible point was that unlike the Murthy v. Missouri Supreme Court case, in which defendants like NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya were sent back down to the lower court because (as Politico put it) “they could not link anything the federal government did to the suppression of their speech,” Kimmel had a great shot. As University of Chicago law professor Aziz Huq put it, “the evidence of ‘specific causation’” with Kimmel was “plain to see.”
Berenson has a better case than either Kimmel or the Murthy defendants. The Supreme Court claimed the Murthy defendants failed to prove a “substantial risk of future injury that is traceable to the government defendants” — in other words, even if plaintiffs like Bhattacharya could prove they were suppressed, they couldn’t “trace” the suppression back to specific government action. Berenson doesn’t have that problem. The last reporter to have access to the Twitter Files, he obtained documents that firmly demonstrated causation and eviscerated the “traceability” problem that sank Murthy. This is one of the reasons why it’s important to get a settlement. If someone with such extraordinary access to the scene of the crime can’t win, who can?
As bad as the Murthy evidence was, the Berenson material was worse. As reported by David Zweig, Twitter head of Government Affairs Lauren Culbertson wrote, “one of the first meeting requests from the Biden White House was about COVID-19 misinformation” and “Biden’s staff focused on vaccines and high-profile anti-vaxxer accounts, including Alex Berenson.”
Berenson wasn’t an “anti-vaxxer.” He favored mRNA treatments for people over 70 and suggested people between 50-70 make a choice based on “personal risk factors.” To the Biden White House, he was a threat precisely because he wasn’t crazy. As an email from White House Digital Policy Director Rob Flaherty to Facebook read, the White House knew “the problem does not fit in ‘microchips’-land,” but in the “‘skeptical’… What actions are being taken on ‘skepticism’?”
In a Slack discussion the next day, Twitter employees described getting “one really tough question” from the White House “about why Alex Berenson hadn’t been kicked off the platform.” One employee noted official Andy Slavitt “really wanted to know about Alex Berenson” because of his impact on the “persuadable public.” Subsequent contacts by former FDA Commissioner and Pfizer board member Dr. Scott Gottlieb inquired about Berenson’s status and whether or not his statements earned “strikes” toward removal.
Biden meanwhile had already given his public speech about social media “killing” people and the White House separately issued statements about the platforms, saying, “They should be held accountable” for misinformation. Finally, on August 28th, Berenson was removed, leading to Slavitt’s vile digital Gronk spike.
Noting that the Supreme Court under John Roberts has “reexamined the law and Constitution on many fronts,” Berenson doesn’t think the door should be closed on speech claims of his type. Judge Clarke, he wrote, “is right that until now the Supreme Court hasn’t allowed those types of damage suits against the government. But that’s an issue I would happily raise on appeal.”
If nothing else, the Kimmel case fully revealed the prior era’s speech hypocrites. Derek Thompson, who wrote a sleazy hit piece for the Atlantic about Berenson called “The Pandemic’s Wrongest Man,” all but admitted that the Biden administration censored people, but for better reasons:
The Biden administration working with social media companies to throttle what they considered COVID misinformation might or might not have been legally principled, but it did at least pretend to have a substantive moral argument that was something like, "We don’t want people to die and we’re willing to take drastic steps to block information we believe might lead to their death.”
The moral argument for the FCC and president going around telling media companies to fire their progressive talent or else risk the wrath of the state seems to be “we believe we were treated unfairly, and now we have power, so suck it, losers,” which I understand as an emotional reaction, but… I haven’t heard anybody even pretend that there’s a deeper principle at stake here.
It’s an open admission: our censoring was better than yours, and we’ll go back to doing it when we have a chance. Can’t that bluff be called?
A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:
Ford Fischer of News2Share was in the Chicago area Thursday night when he gave me a heads-up that a protest was planned at a nearby ICE facility for the next morning. He wasn’t sure it would be a big deal, but would stop by to check it out and leave late morning to catch a flight home.
Things didn’t work out as planned. Ford changed his flight and ended up filming all day outside the facility in Broadview, Ill. Protesters attempted to block government vehicles throughout the day, prompting ICE officers to fire riot munitions and make 16 arrests on Friday and Saturday. There was also the butt-bouncing throwdown of a protester who is running for Congress, which was widely cheered by the right and condemned by the left.
Ford made it home a day late, and then got to work producing this edition of “Activism, Uncensored.”
Subscribe now
If the Trump Administration follows through on its F.C.C. threats, we'll all be robbed of the joy of legacy media failure
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/19/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live.
Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
See you soon!
Listen to the Full Episode
College students saw Charlie Kirk as the ultimate enemy, so awful he needed deplatforming or worse, but educational swindlers are the real enemies of youth
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/17/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
From the publisher's feed