Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Transcript - America This Week, Sept 19, 2025: Kimmel, Kirk, and The Speech Crisis Strikes Back

    Listen to Episode 151

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: Walter, how goes it?

    Walter Kirn: Goes well. Nice fall day in Livingston, Montana, and I’m working hard on my book. But I have been distracted I have to admit by this whole Charlie Kirk tragedy and the ensuing affairs that touch my big issues, free speech, free expression, artistic license, and so on.

    Matt Taibbi: They can’t let us enjoy a single thing in this country, Walter. Just, I was all ready to have a nice little schadenfreude moment over Jimmy Kimmel getting whacked. And next thing you know, we have this whole brouhaha. Actually, it preceded, the brouhaha actually preceded the whacking, but I didn’t know that at the time.

    Walter Kirn: But listen, we were told a couple of months ago that Jimmy Kimmel was on his way out. And I have friends in the very small world of late night comedy hosting, of which there are less than 10 people probably. And so that before we get into the-

    Matt Taibbi: Well, you’re on one of those shows, so.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, and I go on one of those shows and I’m friends with the host. And showbiz is gossip world, and Jimmy was on his way out. And before we touch on the legal and social and political and constitutional issues, there’s nothing that an entertainer knows in their bones more completely and profoundly than when they’re about to get the hook. And he knew it in his bones, and that he chose to go out in this way. Whatever else is true of this situation tells me that he wanted to be a hero. He wanted to be a martyr. He got maybe some of that martyrdom envy from Charlie Kirk. And he also needed a launchpad for whatever his next enterprise is going to be. I think it will be a version of Abbot Costello, but it will be Lemon and Kimmel. Maybe they’ll get a funny car like in Dumb and Dumber like a van, and they’ll drive around the country, Lemon and Kimmel.

    Matt Taibbi: They could revive Herbie. That would be funny.

    Yeah. Look, his Q1 numbers this year were incredible. I’m not sure I’ve ever even seen anything quite like that before. If I remember correctly, it was some ridiculous drop off compared even to the other two. Q2 wasn’t so bad. It was 3% below Q1, but Q1 was a huge drop in itself.

    But okay, who are we talking about? We’re talking about Jimmy Kimmel. And let’s just go in the order of operations. He did a dickish thing, which isn’t surprising. I guess, let’s start with a montage that our own mystery producer put together of Jimmy Kimmel over the recent years. This is the host of The Tonight Show.

    Walter Kirn: No, it’s not called The Tonight Show. What’s it called?

    Matt Taibbi: Oh, Tonight Show. I’m sorry. The ...

    Walter Kirn: I don’t even really know what it’s called, frankly. The Jimmy Kimmel Show.

    Matt Taibbi: Jimmy Kimmel Show, right? It’s ABC. I forget. This is the one without the Titanic historical background, right? So he’s not inheriting the mantle of Johnny Carson or Letterman, but he is a huge asshole from Massachusetts.

    Is he from Massachusetts?

    Walter Kirn: I don’t know, man.

    Matt Taibbi: Anyway. Look, the different late night hosts have responded to the Trump era in different ways. Some of them have tried to become kooky, hokey propagandists like Colbert.

    Walter Kirn: Well, Kimmel’s tried that too. Vaccine Barbie and Anti-Vax Barbie. Just ‘cause he can’t pull it off.

    Matt Taibbi: Well, no, but his whole thing is nasty, right?

    Walter Kirn: Right. Right. That’s right. Yeah. Yeah. He’s nasty guy. He’s the nasty guy.

    Matt Taibbi: He’s not the kindler, gentler comic.

    Walter Kirn: Colbert is the ironist, the sort of pseudo-intellectual pointing out hypocrisy and contradiction. Kimmel is just a guy who, I don’t know, I hate to be this way, but he’s one of those dogs when you go to Central America that comes up to you at the outdoor cafe and just goes ... and you’re just not sure that it’s healthy.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, he’s definitely going for the ... It’s the mean girls act from high school. He’s the guy who picked on you in the cafeteria if he could get away with it. Look, there was always a place for these guys in media. He’s not the safe date comic that they would sometimes have in these slots. It’s a little nasty.

    But he went in such an abject political direction in the Trump years that it became a thing. I mean, it was like a game of one-up-smanship between all of them, and he went way beyond everybody else. So let’s just start with that. We put together this little montage. This is sort of the greatest un-hits of Jimmy Kimmel in the Trump era:

    Read more

    0 min
  • Jimmy Kimmel's Political Hackery

    One of the many problems with the legacy press is its consistent implication — hell, often outright insistence — that criticism from conservatives is not legitimate.

    Friday’s piece from the New York Times mis/disinformation reporter Stuart Thompson is yet another example.

    Another way to put it: The outrage isn’t legitimate because critics had to have been unduly influenced.

    Thompson starts by saying the conservative outrage turned “apoplectic” Wednesday after FCC Chairman Brendan Carr “went on a podcast and suggested the regulatory body could use its powers against the network that airs the show.” Fair enough. Now, cue the foreboding music to play underneath the following:

    But the outrage had started to grow online more than 24 hours earlier — first as a whisper, then eventually as a shout, as social media users, influencers and right-wing news outlets began sharing Mr. Kimmel’s monologue, according to an analysis by The New York Times of thousands of posts on social media and mentions on radio, television and podcasts.

    It began with a muted reaction on X on Tuesday morning after one user, whose job involves monitoring late night shows for liberal bias, posted a clip of the monologue. Conservative influencers and radio hosts started to take notice throughout the day, and Fox News hosts turned their attention to the clip by the evening. [Music turns even darker]

    Then, hours before Mr. Carr’s podcast taping on Wednesday, Elon Musk, the most-followed user on X and the site’s owner, posted that Mr. Kimmel was “disgusting” for the jokes.

    The accelerating furor reflects how online outrage does not always emerge organically, but is often the result of a small number of prominent voices redirecting their audience’s attention.

    Please, as if this is new. The difference today is the “influence” isn’t only coming from the traditional press. There are multiple reasons for that — social media and the easy access to video, for one. Another big reason is the media’s own suckery, as demonstrated by this hilarious video in which CNN’s Wolf Blitzer maintains that Kimmel didn’t say what he said Monday night and is held in check by, of all people, Geraldo.

    There are legitimate questions and concerns about the role of the FCC and the Trump administration’s influence in Disney’s decision to put Kimmel on hiatus. This isn’t about that, and there is already plenty of coverage and appropriate scrutiny of that decision.

    But what’s not being addressed enough is whether conservative outrage over Kimmel’s monologue is understandable. Unequivically, the answer is yes — but it’s not just about what he said Monday: that “the MAGA gang” was “desperately trying to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them and doing everything they can to score political points from it.”

    It’s about what Kimmel has been saying and doing for years. He is a tool of the Democratic Party. He doesn’t just use his show to push his politics, but tells people outright how they should vote. This 19-minute video from last October, titled “A Special Monologue for the Republican in Your Life,” is the height of obnoxiousness. He asks people to show the video to their Republican friends or relatives in an effort to convince them not to vote for Trump. To quote the retired football player formerly known as Chad Ochocinco, “Child, please.”

    Then there are other bits, “joking” that people who don’t have the Covid vaccine shouldn’t get treated for a heart attack, implying that people should continue vandalizing Teslas, his ass-kissing of Democratic office holders on his show and letting people know they have his endorsement. He even helped what was then the Biden-Harris campaign in 2024 raise $30 million in one night by moderating a discussion with Biden and former President Barack Obama. These and other examples are in the video at the top of this post, which was also included in “America This Week.”

    He has the right to do all this, of course (although Walter Kirn makes a compelling argument on ATW that he has violated the terms of an FCC license to broadcast on the public’s airwaves). My point is, the conservative public isn’t just pushing back against a simple comedian. They are pushing back against a partisan who has continually put them down. That’s politics, a game that Kimmel has willingly played.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • The Ultimate Reason Not to Censor

    Jimmy Kimmel, exiting stage left. From the New York Times:

    Now [Trump] is taking his campaign against free speech to a new level by using the assassination of Charlie Kirk as a justification to promise the repression of groups that he describes as liberal… The intimidation campaign is already having an effect. Federal officials have urged companies to fire workers who have criticized Mr. Kirk, and some have done so. In a direct exercise of government influence, Brendan Carr, the chairman of the F.C.C., threatened Disney for remarks that Jimmy Kimmel made on his late-night ABC show. “We can do this the easy way or the hard way,” Mr. Carr said. He also urged television stations to stop broadcasting the show. Two major station owners quickly did so, and ABC has suspended the show indefinitely.

    Don’t do it, President Trump.

    If you and F.C.C. Chair Brendan Carr follow through on threats to turn the federal government into broadcast media police, millions of Americans will not be able to enjoy the spectacle of people like Jimmy Kimmel suffering. It would be the greatest Schadenfreude robbery in history. As you like to say, “Nobody’s ever seen anything like it before.”

    If the F.C.C. were mothballed for winter, most of the “Fake News Media” would be dead by Spring anyway. Half the network anchors are already sending out applications to work chair lifts at winter ski resorts. If however Trump drops the F.C.C. on the broadcast sector, it will be like every George Romero movie ever rolled into one, with already-dispatched figures like Kimmel and Stephen Colbert reanimated and turned into martyrs. Let the dead sleep, instead of waking them and forcing citizens like me to defend them.

    The move by Carr to inject himself in the middle of Kimmel’s firing by telling Disney and ABC, “We can do this the easy way or the hard way” was and is a very serious one. This was no offhand unforced error by someone like Pam Bondi, who ran into a buzz-saw (mostly from the right) when she said the Constitution doesn’t protect hate speech. It’s not a trolling misdemeanor like the yanking of AP’s White House privileges. Now it’s clear why there was correspondence in the Twitter Files suggesting the U.S. could catch up to European censors by using F.C.C. authority. Why is the vision Carr has for the F.C.C. dangerous? Because it’s possible:

    Subscribe now

    Carr has already tried to flex this muscle and has been talking for some time about wanting to “reinvigorate” the F.C.C. public interest standard, giving an interview to PBS News Hour in July in which he made his feelings clear:

    When we license you or license a CBS station, we're necessarily denying another outlet the ability to use those airwaves. As a condition of that, broadcasters are unique. They have a public interest obligation. I think, for years, the F.C.C. has walked away from enforcing that public interest mandate. And I don’t think we’re better off for it… if you just step back and look at trust in mainstream outlets, like Gallup survey shows that it’s at an all-time low, increasingly below even the levels of trust that people have in Congress.

    So I do think it’s an important role for Congress as a sign to the F.C.C. to make sure that broadcasters meet their public interest obligations. And that's what we're trying to do.

    The public airwaves are the one piece of informational terrain over which the U.S. government can legitimately assert some authority. Pre-Internet, public broadcast licenses were the gold standard for subsidies, instantly enriching lessees and granting enormous political power. The awesome value of the licenses is why the government felt it could demand as a return condition that stations create programming in the “public interest, convenience, and necessity.” Traditionally, news stations understood that to mean they had to create content like news and interview shows, and not whore themselves for cash 100% of the time.

    I’ve been around broadcast media since I was a toddler and never understood “public interest” to mean the F.C.C. had authority to enforce factuality, or punish what they call “collateral inaccuracy.” The American news system seemed distinguished by the absence of an OfCom or CRTC-style regulator, and while the F.C.C. obviously existed, it felt like more of an afterthought, one that never touched big three broadcasters and instead spent its time harassing pirate radio stations and listening for George Carlin’s infamous seven dirty words.

    However, the F.C.C. does have authority it can invoke to act like a European-style regulator, via its “news distortion” standard, which has already come into play with Carr’s interest in 60 Minutes. A September 2021 FCC circular contained a long section about “news distortion,” saying:

    The Commission generally will not intervene in these cases because it would be inconsistent with the First Amendment to replace the journalistic judgment of licensees with our own. However, as public trustees, broadcast licensees may not intentionally distort the news. The FCC has stated that “rigging or slanting the news is a most heinous act against the public interest.” The Commission will investigate a station for news distortion if it receives documented evidence of rigging or slanting, such as testimony or other documentation, from individuals with direct personal knowledge that a licensee or its management engaged in the intentional falsification…

    The quote in the passage above comes from a 1998 Appeals Court case, Alexander J Serafyn v F.C.C. The petitioner, Serafyn, argued CBS should be denied a new station license because it had “intentionally distorted the situation in Ukraine by claiming that most Ukrainians are anti-Semitic.” Serafyn lost, but there is a long history of “news distortion” cases and it’s not difficult to imagine how the Trump administration might use this tool more, even though most “news distortion” complaints have failed.

    In 1968, for instance, famed CBS broadcaster Charles Kuralt ran an influential spot called Hunger in America. A congressman named Henry Gonzalez claimed the show had been exaggerated. The F.C.C. struck the complaint down, saying it is “not a national arbiter of the truth” and was staying out of the case because it would “involve the Commission deeply and improperly in the journalistic functions of broadcasters.”

    However, the Commission also noted “the licensee must have a policy of requiring honesty of its news staff and must take reasonable precautions to see that news is fairly handled.” The Commission over the years has repeatedly held that it does have purview over such cases, but only if there’s “extrinsic evidence,” like “written or oral instructions from station management, outtakes, or evidence of bribery” showing intent to deceive or distort. It also has to involve a “significant event” and not a “minor or incidental aspect” of the news report, but it seems like the main thing is, if they have a witness who’ll speak to intent, they can use this authority.

    This is the problem. There are stories out there of former producers for networks (more often, cable stations) admitting to bias, sloppiness, and worse. People like Kimmel have said they’re “biased” on the air, and not even really in a joking way. The sheer quantity of uncorrected wrong stories would also impress Trump’s F.C.C. But we’ve been down this road before. Once a government official starts talking about correcting “misinformation,” as Carr has already done, it means they already have a vision for using the state as a truth-deciding mechanism, which even if it leaves the First Amendment alone outside the public airwaves, hurts it implicitly by creating official truth.

    There’s one last reason for Trump to avoid pulling this fateful trigger. In doing so he would allow a generation of censorship advocates to wipe their slates clean, as the Times did in the story above, not mentioning years of other “intimidation campaigns” over speech by everyone from the White House to the FBI to the CDC. It will be forgotten that the same people raging now about firings of Kirk critics were just a few years ago insisting cancel culture didn’t exist and “we need more shaming and shunning, not less.” More than anything, though, it’s not necessary. The market is doing its job, in a big, funny way. Why put a stop to that?

    0 min
  • Note on Jimmy Kimmel

    From Variety:

    Disney’s ABC said it would take Jimmy Kimmel‘s popular late-night show off its schedule “indefinitely” after one of the biggest owners of TV stations in the U.S., Nexstar Media, said it would pre-empt airings of the program following remarks the host made about the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk… The company said it “strongly objects to recent comments made by Mr. Kimmel concerning the killing of Charlie Kirk and will replace the show with other programming…”

    In his monologue Monday night , Kimmel said that the “MAGA gang” was trying to score political points off Kirk’s murder… “We hit some new lows over the weekend with the MAGA gang trying to characterize this kid who killed Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them,” Kimmel said.

    Well, shit. This could get ugly. Just before Disney’s decision, FCC chair Brendan Carr said Kimmel’s statements were “some of the sickest conduct possible” and his agency had a “strong case” for holding the company accountable for trying to “lie to the American people” about a major news story. “This is a very, very serious issue right now for Disney,” he continued. “We can do this the easy way or the hard way. These companies can find ways to take action on Kimmel or there is going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.”

    Carr added that he wanted to “reinvigorate” the FCC’s “public interest standard.” He listed people like Joy Ann Reid, Stephen Colbert, and Terry Moran, noted that Donald Trump successfully ran against such legacy media figures, and that “their grip on the narrative is slipping.” Still, he said, the FCC still needs to make sure firms leasing public airwaves uphold their public interest obligation.

    Of all the network late night acts, Kimmel’s was the most vicious and unredeeming, continually hitting new lows during the pandemic in particular, with the aforementioned AntiVax Barbie and his “Rest in Peace, Wheezy” monologue sure to go down as cultural anti-landmarks. Virtually everything he said in the Trump era was DNC messaging with a punchline, putting him on course to spend the afterlife doing laps in media hell with Keith Olbermann. With his ratings in freefall, Disney was going to drop the axe sooner or later.

    But acting so quickly after Carr’s “easy way or the hard way” line opens a can of worms. Now the organic demise of legacy media (definitely happening, and at lightning speed too) can’t be an unmuddied story. What Carr described would reimagine the FCC as a press regulator in a full-on truth-arbiter role, in the spirit of Britain’s hated OfCom. That feels like a big jump from where the Administration was in February, when J.D. Vance lambasted Europeans in Munich for losing sight of basic tenets of democracy, including the “freedom… to make mistakes.” Either way, wild news; Walter and I will talk it through on the next America This Week.

    0 min
  • Listen to This Article: Twitter Files: The Muzzling of Charlie Kirk

    At a crucial juncture in the 2020 presidential election, the Washington Post used a tried-and-true method to pressure Twitter to remove Kirk

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Text published 09/12/25:

    Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    Read more

    0 min
  • Listen to This Article: The Trump Trap

    If you make everything about Donald Trump, as the press has for ten years, the simplest headlines quickly become tortured

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Text published 09/10/25:

    Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    0 min
  • After Charlie Kirk's Murder, Elite Arrogance Still On Full Display

    From Bret Stephens in the New York Times:

    It’s too bad that Kirk, raised in a Chicago suburb, didn’t attend the University of Chicago. It wouldn’t have hurt getting thrashed in a political debate by smarter peers. Or learning to appreciate the power and moral weight of views he didn’t share. Or recognizing that the true Western tradition lies more in its skepticism than in its certitude.

    It’s too bad Bret Stephens never debated Charlie Kirk. He’d have had to defend the idea that students at places like the University of Chicago are not only “smarter” than ignorant red-staters (and students at schools like Cambridge), but more schooled in the “Western tradition” of “skepticism,” as opposed to “certitude.”

    Does Stephens mean currently? If so, that’s rich. The cultural schism now widening under all of us in America has surely been caused at least in part by a shift in the attitudes of the very people Stephens calls “the greatest scholars.” Professors abandon skepticism for certitude in a range of hot-button issues, including a conspicuous one that may have had an impact on Kirk’s murder, transgender ideology.

    And “smarter”? Stephens needs a fresh look at what passes for instruction and re-examine whether students are really being taught to think better. He should ask if it’s not instead true that institutional America is and has been systematically ripping off its young, a question Kirk threw at students everywhere, often with devastating results. It’s not surprising that scenes of kids who casually admit they “hate books” but were welcomed to pay tuition anyway haven’t made too many of the “Kirk’s greatest misdeeds” reels currently circulating:

    This major plank of Kirk’s traveling-debate act is almost never mentioned in mainstream press rundowns of his views. Press accounts focus on alleged bigotry, xenophobia, and misogyny. However, Kirk’s schtick as a non-college graduate moving from town to town doing verbal battle with ostensibly enlightened clientele of higher education had a key subtext: college embarrasses its customers.

    His book on the same theme gives predictable focus to the ideological-indoctrination portion of liberal arts education in particular, but most of his argument centers on things I heard for years from student loan forgiveness advocates: college doesn’t prepare students to enter the workforce, does little to secure income, and is particularly devastating to seas of humanities students duped into thinking they need to mortgage their futures for careers that, like my own, often don’t require degrees.

    This part of Kirk’s act has been edited out of the public debate. Most infuriating of all has been listening to media figures at outlets like Salon denounce “Debate Me, Bro” culture as commercial hucksterism that’s “ruined civil discourse.” Not only is Kirk guilty of this, apparently, but also the likes of Joe Rogan, whose podcast is part of the regrettably rising tide of “people who don’t know what they’re talking about arguing with each other under the guise of debate.” These people have the gall to denounce The Joe Rogan Experience as an ignorance-spreading machine when the higher educational system has been gorging itself on trillions in federally-backed loans, just to crank out people with no professional skills who are also so shredded intellectually, they think they have to use terms like “birthing persons.”

    Set aside the motive of Kirk’s shooter, which will likely come out in full in time. The scene of the crime was a college, and the damage such institutions did to young brains in this country is the story that’s most visible on Kirk’s videos, but which America’s opinion-making classes are most interested in keeping hidden:

    Subscribe now

    Stephens pooh-poohs the video record of Kirk’s campus debates as “owning inarticulate liberal kids in mass audience settings.” However, it’s not selective editing or an elaborate Washington Generals act that led to the hours of online implosions, but an embarrassing premise. America’s “smarter” kids not only haven’t been taught how to handle press encounters, they’re increasingly not taught much that’s concrete at all. Beyond political solidarity against people like Kirk and a clunky vocabulary of oppression most will never use in their professional lives (if they even get jobs), our Best and Brightest are continually sent into the world armed with nothing but neurosis, self-absorption, and a Flatland view of human nature.

    Decades ago this looked mostly like a commercial scam foisted on middle- to upper-middle-class teenagers, who after the sixties began to be lent the equivalent of home mortgages the instant they hit the age of consent, then packed off to leafy luxury kennels where liquor laws are ignored, no one flunks out, and the main “coursework” is therapy disguised as academics. I once thought students who majored in intersectional basket-weaving at third-rate schools and then carried school loans to Social Security Age were the main victims. It’s now clear a country asked to revere the leadership of intellectually unequipped graduates was also seriously victimized.

    Would Charlie Kirk have had as easy a time beating up on 19-year-olds learning helicopter piloting or chemical engineering? Maybe, but it stands out that the bulk of the people who did show up to argue with Kirk were raised in the intellectual nerf-habitats of humanities faculties, where weak arguments were routinely allowed to prevail and young people were taught to take it personally when adults didn’t automatically salute nonsense shibboleths about race or gender or the latest whateverism. That’s what comes through on Turning Point’s most viral “Charlie Kirk OWNS woke dipshits” videos, which are almost always about abortion or trans rights or other culture-war minefields where students simply haven’t been taught the other sides of issues, or to just lob words like “evil” without even bothering to make cases.

    The “Is college a scam?” debates are most revealing. You see teenagers and young twenty-somethings making industry arguments against themselves, in a way they would never do if the underlying subject was Big Oil, Banks or Big Pharma. Are too many kids pushed into crippling loans? Gosh, nobody pushed us, we’re all of age. Do you need a degree to get the job you want? Absolutely, I’d never get satisfying work without this experience. Does a multi-trillion-dollar industry that’s failed its customer base and created a huge debt bubble and is massively subsidized by the taxpayer bother you? No, that’s natural.

    The biggest tell, though, is what happened when Kirk brought up non-professional jobs with high salaries. Who teaches a college student to roll her eyes at the idea of working as a plumber? Who, me? That’s learned disrespect:

    Moments like these are what made kids look “inarticulate” in these encounters. Kirk of course exploited this, but it shined through that his beef wasn’t with young people, but the adults behind the students, whom he called “the powers that run colleges.” He repeatedly argued that colleges take young, impressionable people terrified of a shrinking job market and desperate to validate family expectations and social aspirations, and shoehorn them into useless degree programs that feed them political agitprop in place of knowledge. If that agitprop didn’t directly lead to his shooting (it might have), it’s certainly alive in the sociopathic reaction of media figures and academics who seem genuinely to believe that some people just need removing.

    Stephens conveniently excised all this from his own thesis about “our vanishing culture of argument.” Center-left America (as well as civil liberties organizations like FIRE) are rightly in a panic over signals from Trumpian conservatives about a post-assassination speech crackdown. Donald Trump shared a video from a TikTok influencer calling for the establishment of a “Charlie Kirk Act” that would hold media companies and academics “accountable for… false narratives.” Louisiana Republican Clay Higgins vowed to work with tech platforms to “mandate immediate ban for life of every post or commenter that belittled the assassination of Charlie Kirk.” Attorney General Pam Bondi freaked out listeners on both sides when she said, “There’s free speech and then there’s hate speech.” Top presidential adviser Stephen Miller said the government would “identify, disrupt, eliminate and destroy” left-wing groups responsible for elevating a climate of violent intolerance.

    It’s old news that America’s political right feels rage at being talked down to by a handful of elites who for ages moved straight from the academy to jobs as architects of mass culture, occupying them as a birthright. Elections are the one major area where non-college-educated citizens get a say in determining national priorities, and it hasn’t been lost on red-state voters that whenever “deplorables” vote the wrong way, university intellectuals argue for increased digital controls to keep the rabble’s wrong decisions from bursting through even there. Donald Trump’s war on places like Columbia and Harvard clearly had roots in frustration over this exact dynamic.

    After January 6th, 2021 when Twitter inexplicably shut down 70,000 accounts associated with QAnon and joined other companies in removing Trump from social media, leading academics and policy wonks cheered. Deplatforming, said Harvard’s Joan Donovan, “is working,” while Graham Brookie of the Atlantic Council said it “rapidly curbs momentum and ability to reach new audiences” of bad actors. Papers like The Washington Post couldn’t wait to applaud a supposed “drop” in disinformation these moves brought about. In 2018, Columbia Professor Tim Wu wrote the seminal “Is the First Amendment Obsolete?” paper arguing new conditions (like deployment of “atrocity propaganda” against the likes of Hillary Clinton) required a rethink of the Bill of Rights. The biggest content-suppression farms were all tied to the most prestigious institutions: Stanford, Harvard, Johns Hopkins, even the University of Chicago Stephens fawns over. It will be the mother of all disasters if Republicans take the cheese and try to appropriate this machinery for themselves. The political gains will be temporary, but the tools for a crackdown will become permanent.

    Worse: what happens when you combine the idea that some people are too evil to deserve speech with mass instruction in crackpot ideas? Someone will get hurt, obviously, or lots of someones. Rather than admit to roles in radicalizing people against (pick one) vaccine skeptics, “deplorables,” “transphobes,” or other offenders, it will become necessary to keep describing the victim as the wrongdoer. Jimmy Kimmel, who spent Covid telling us “doing your own research” was the province of people who think “Moderna turns yer teeth Jewish!” and the unvaccinated should “rest in peace, wheezy,” now has a bit just flat-out lying about who Kirk’s shooter is, because we couldn’t possibly regret suggesting some people are better off dead. We are mass-producing frustration, ignorance, and meanness, and it’s getting harder to pretend we don’t know exactly which industry is behind it.

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.