
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


A note from Managing Editor Greg Collard:
The assassination of Charlie Kirk has ignited a lot of debates. What should be done about social media? Who is more responsible for radicalization, the left or the right? What should the government do?
Attorney General Pam Bondi managed to outrage and unify large segments of the right and the left by saying:
There's free speech and then there's hate speech, and there is no place, especially now, especially after what happened to Charlie, in our society...We will absolutely target you, go after you, if you are targeting anyone with hate speech.
She reversed course today, saying, “Freedom of speech is sacred in our country, and we will never impede upon that right.”
Then there’s the debate over the legacy of Kirk himself, which you can see for yourself in this installment of “Activism, Uncensored,” by Ford Fisher of News2Share. Ford and his crew filmed rallies, vigils, and counter-protesters in response to Kirk’s murder.
Subscribe now
Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live.
Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
See you soon!
Listen to the Full Episode
Never underestimate the creativity of the virtue-signaling Bay State pseudo-intellectual
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/10/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Listen to Episode 150
Matt Taibbi: Hi. Welcome to America this week. I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.
Matt Taibbi: And it’s September 11th, and we’re recording on September 11th. You’ll be seeing this on September 12th. These are dark times in the United States. They have been for a while, but September 10th, Wednesday, we had another assassination. This time somebody you and I both know, Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University. And a lot of people, semi-ironically, are describing this as a turning point in American history. There’s a marked change in tone in the reactions or radicalization, I would say, on both sides. We’ll get into all of it.
Walter, do you have any initial comments before we start rolling tape and things like this, or... All I can say is that I feel, as somebody... We’re both in the same business as him, and there’s a degree of coldness and viciousness and professionalism to this that is unnerving. But we’ll get into all of it. But I do feel like this is a difference making moment for a variety of reasons.
Walter Kirn: I do too. I just have a few things to say in preface before we get into it. Number one, this is a guy who I’ve met. He asked me to be on his show recently. I declined for various reasons, mostly having to do with my schedule. He is one degree of separation from me in all sorts of ways. I know a lot of people who know him, some people who are very close friends of his there, they’re absolutely shocked as was I. The fact that this occurred on a university campus, I think is underappreciated. It also was an attack on someone who, despite what is a pretty marked dehumanization campaign on the part of his political enemies, was a paragon of a sort of old-fashioned college Republican; let’s sit down and talk, I’ll persuade you, way of doing things.
Beside the fact that he was a podcaster and a journalist, it’s an attack on civil society, on the way we do things, on our expectation that there are spaces in which we can talk and debate and disagree. So the side of me that hopes for a civilized world and world in which there are guardrails around our political and cultural discussions is absolutely shattered and disappointed by this. He’s a father. I relate to that. Two young children, a 31-year-old man.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. I was shocked to see that age. I didn’t realize he was that young.
Walter Kirn: Yeah, and I think that’s another dimension of this that is worthy of note. This was a young person, a young person speaking to young people on a place, a college campus, which is supposed to be for that very purpose. To see his posture on that stage, relaxed, sitting back in his chair, listening, engaged, suddenly disrupted by a shot to the throat is an image that too should stun and dishearten us all.
But finally, aside from all of these considerations, I think what bothers me the most is that almost instantly, and I guess we’re going to see this, this incident, was fed into a machine whose workings we’re quite familiar with now, whose operations have been used in all sorts of ways over the years, and especially the last few years. And the dehumanization of this person before he had even left the earth, truly, literally, was for me,, the most terrifying aspect of the whole thing.
Matt Taibbi: Yeah. So the first thing that came to my mind when I heard that it was Charlie who had been shot, is that his particular genre of being an influencer, being a reporter, being a commentator, is different from almost everybody else on the internet. He does a thing where he goes on campuses and he engages people, and he tries to prove you wrong or tries to pick a part your point of view. And what I thought was really interesting about it, now he comes from a background that I just couldn’t be more different from mine. He is a Christian. He’s sort of steadfastly a diehard Republican, always has been. A lot of his views are things that I probably politically wouldn’t have agreed with, especially years ago. Some of the things more recently, however I have agreed with.
But his whole shtick is to go and talk to people. And he’s not rude. He’s not abrasive or profane. Some of those conversations don’t go so well, but this is what we would hope for when we talk about free speech. We hope that people would talk to each other, confront one another, and that something would emerge out of those discussions. And so for him to be the person who is shot and killed is a message directed, not just at somebody who has a lot of political significance because Walter, as you point out, he’s really the Republican Party’s point man for engagement with youth. And they’ve had tremendous success in that area in the last few years. But more than that, to me, it’s a blow against the whole idea of speech and counter speech, that there has been a rising movement on campuses against the idea that something positive emerges from these discussions. And it started with people who were more openly provocateurs like Milo Yiannopoulos. Let’s just not have him on the campus, and that will be the better outcome. And-
Walter Kirn: And Colter, firebrands. I think you can look at a lot of cape of Charlie Kirk and realize he does one thing that a lot of these others don’t do quite so well, which is, listen. The guy is a good listener. Having been married three times, I’ve learned about the virtues of listening. And my wife will often come back from a party and she’ll say, “Oh, that guy was amusing, smart, and interesting, but he doesn’t listen.” I’ve cued into that and I see a guy whose wheels are turning, not just when he listens, not just because he wants to counter the person, but because he’s absorbing their point of view as fully as possible in order to argue it -
Matt Taibbi: Of course.
Walter Kirn: ... but not merely to argue with it. In other words... And because he was 31, I would imagine that he had change ahead of him. He had evolution. How many of us are the same person politically, culturally, temperamentally we were at 31. And so there’s a reason why the death of a youth is classically much more tragic because the change, the growth, the evolution, the dynamism that we can expect as someone moves from youth into middle age is made to never be.
From ABC News:
Tyler Robinson, the man suspected of killing conservative activist Charlie Kirk during a campus event at a Utah university, had eluded authorities for more than a day. However, after his father recognized him from photographs distributed by authorities, it led a series of events that ultimately led to 22-year-old Robinson being taken into custody…
Robinson mentioned during a dinner conversation with a family member that Kirk would be visiting Utah Valley University, according to Cox. Robinson and the family members discussed why they didn’t like Kirk and his viewpoints, and the family member stated Kirk was “full of hate and spreading hate,” [Utah Governor Spencer] Cox said.
Photos of Robinson reveal a thin young male in a purple shirt, barely a man, a boy in pajamas just a tick of the clock ago. Innocence has no staying power in the Internet age. Every parent will soon be afraid to send their kids into the world unattended.
Meanwhile an editor’s note silently appeared at the bottom of a New York Times story, “Where Charlie Kirk Stood on Key Political Issues”:
A correction was made on Sept. 11, 2025: An earlier version of this article described incorrectly an antisemitic statement that Charlie Kirk had made on an episode of his podcast. He was quoting a statement from a post on social media and went on to critique it. It was not his own statement.
Even the correction was grudging and uncharitable. The Times “described incorrectly an antisemitic statement that Charlie Kirk had made” isn’t the same as “We incorrectly ascribed antisemitism to Charlie Kirk.” I wrote this morning about the increasingly common trope of “alleging racist or antisemitic comments without elucidating them.” This is what the Times did, in its obituary in the story in question, and in others where the paper used rhetorical gimmicks like “Mr. Kirk’s own rhetoric was long cast as racist, xenophobic and extreme by groups that study hate speech.”
When you go looking for the statements the paper matches to these extreme words, they turn out to be things like advocating the use of the term “China virus” and using his platform to “decry racial equity programs.” The line that struck me said Kirk believed “Jews are trying to replace white Americans with nonwhite immigrants,” and “That ideology motivated the gunman who killed 11 worshipers at a Pittsburgh synagogue in 2018.”
This is another common technique, ascribing hate speech to a person, then saying those beliefs motivated specific acts of violence. This openly invites readers to blame the subject for the violence. That’s not only nothing new, it’s been the underlying premise for a generation of “anti-dehumanization” proposals tying “hate speech” to episodes like the 2019 Christchurch shooting, the 2019 El Paso shooting, and the January 6th riots.
My problem with these laws, always, has been that what they call “disinformation” often turns out to be true, and “hate speech” often turns out to be something not nearly deserving of the term, or false altogether:
Subscribe now
The author Stephen King was forced to apologize after he fell for what anti-disinformation folk call a “deceptively edited” video that appeared to show Kirk lauding a Biblical passage calling for gays to be stoned to death. In fact Kirk was arguing against the tendency of people to cherry-pick Biblical passages, something more than one media person hasn’t grasped yet. Accusing people of hate speech or bigotry in error, which “authoritative” sources do a lot, is an almost costless media activity, even though it can be as dangerous as the worst hate speech.
I disagreed with many things Charlie Kirk said. I was stunned when he said Martin Luther King, Jr. gave us “more race focus and less emphasis on character and conduct,” saying he was more of a “race Marxist” overall than a classical humanist. His line about how “I’m sorry, if I see a black pilot, I’m going to be like, boy, I hope he’s qualified” didn’t sit well, alongside comments about black America being better off in the forties. He seemed to like a more uncompromising Christianity than the forgiving-hippie version of Jesus and Corinthians I was taught, though I’m not religious, so what do I know?
Still, I wish papers like the Times could not just fill pages with Greatest Un-Hits and try to capture the whole person, who did have hard-edged, controversial views but also had a sincere belief in open debate, upheld decorum, and engaged antagonists with a sense of fair play. I never heard Kirk call for “gutting” political opponents, for “shanking these motherfuckers,” or “slicing ‘em up.” The fact that his accessibility got him killed also seems lost on critics, who can’t separate him from things he said they don’t like.
It’s hard to justify killing a whole human being. A caricature is different. I don’t watch the Tik-Tok videos of people cheering this or that murder, but an awful lot of prominent media figures in the wake of this assassination continue to hammer the idea that some people are just bad, by virtue of their political views — sometimes, just one political view. Which can easily have been wrongly reported. Are we really that shallow?
President Trump and the Trump family businesses have been making big waves in the cryptocurrency world since Trump took office this year. He signed the Genius Act, which provides clearer regulation of stablecoins as well as establishing a working group to, as the White House put it, usher in “The Golden Age of Crypto.” The problem is it’s in the interest of the Trump family’s burgeoning crypto business, World Liberty Financial (WLF), to do so. Led at least nominally by Don Jr and Eric Trump, WLF has been making huge deals.
Two questions come to mind:
Is Trump using the presidency for personal profit?
Will investors get screwed, like the investors in Trump-branded gimmicks such as Trump University?
To support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
World Liberty Financial made a big splash on September 1st when it began trading the company’s crypto token WLFI. Early investors were allowed to sell 20% of the holdings they received in 2024 and early 2025 when they invested in the company, and received tokens at 1.5 cents and 0.5 cents. The tokens started trading at 30 cents — cha-ching! — and WLFI trading volume averaged around $1 billion per day in its first week. It is estimated that the Trump family holdings in the token are now worth more than $5 billion.
There have been presidents who didn’t entirely give up running their business while in office. President Johnson, for example, directed business decisions on a private phone line he had installed in the White House bedroom.
Trump makes no secret of his crypto connections. He was listed as World Liberty Financial’s “Chief Crypto Advocate” when he took office. That has since changed to Co-Founder Emeritus. In the super competitive business of crypto, having a sitting U.S. President’s picture listed right at the top of the “About Us” web page probably helps a bit. Perhaps more than a bit.
For instance, there was a dinner May 22nd at Trump’s country club in Virginia. It was a reward for the top 25 investors who purchased the meme coin $Trump — launched three days before he took office. From Reuters:
The event, which the president promoted on social media as the “most EXCLUSIVE INVITATION in the world,” promised the top 220 holders of the $TRUMP meme coin an invite to a gala dinner with the president, while the top 25 will also enjoy “an ultra-exclusive private VIP reception” with the president as well as a “Special VIP Tour.”
Keep in mind that a meme coin can’t be used to purchase anything. Think of a baseball card collection that you invest in hoping it goes up in value when it becomes a collector’s item.
Still, Justin Sun invested $18.5 million in the meme coin, tops at the country club dinner. Sun also invested $75 million in WLFI last year. Sun was accused of fraud by the Biden SEC, but in February the SEC and Sun’s attorneys filed a joint motion to pause the case to “explore a potential resolution.” There is still no resolution.
But not to worry. The president is not profiting from these stunts or giving out favors, according to White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt. She lectured:
All of the president's assets are in a blind trust, which is managed by his children. And I would argue, one of the many reasons that the American people re-elected this president back to this office is because he was a very successful businessman before giving it up to publicly serve our country.
“Giving it up” was a theme Trump brought up many times in his first term. In 2019 Trump stated that being president has cost him $2 billion to $5 billion.
Unless Don Jr, Eric and Barron plan on cutting dad out of the family business, it is hard to argue that he isn’t profiting from the presidency, bigly.
For example, the terms of the initial investments made into WLFI were that 75% of the money raised went to a Trump family-owned entity called DT Marks DEFI. So of the roughly $590 million raised from the original 35,000 WLF investors, $442.5 million went to DT Marks DEFI. That is highly unusual. Money invested in a new venture typically goes to the venture itself to pay for capital expenditures, operations, marketing, etc. Not in this case.
Instead, WLF was structured more like a pure licensing arrangement, where the value created was mostly going to come from its brand, Trump. Of course, the brand and the efforts of founders are worth a whole lot of the eventual value of any company, which is why founders normally get a large equity chunk. The Trumps got that “normal” feature too (38% equity interest in the WLF holding company, and 22.5% of the WLFI token supply). And it did not end there.
ALT5 SIGMAThis August, WLF purchased a pain treatment company, ALT5 Sigma, and turned it into a crypto treasury company. The company then turned around and offered approximately $750 million in publicly-traded shares and another $750 million in WLFI. Trump’s WLF is the big winner in this odd, circular transaction.
From the Wall Street Journal:
“The deal will hand the Trump family a huge payday, around $500 million, since an entity it owns keeps up to three-quarters of any revenues from WLFI sales. This sort of circular transaction—with the same party as buyer and seller, dealing in products they themselves created—is more common in the crypto world than in traditional finance.”
The Trump family owned entity DT Marks DEFI has already received around $942m ($442.5m from initial private investments into WLF, plus $500m from ALT5 Sigma deal) in cash from this start-up. Not bad.
But wait, there’s even more!
Stablecoin USD1Stablecoins are the bedrock of crypto payment systems. The coins are built and settled on blockchains and are backed up to 100% by liquid U.S. dollar assets such as U.S. Treasury Bills. The coins are often used for business-to-business commerce and the purchase of crypto tokens on crypto exchanges.
Stablecoins are a great concept, but they are a go big or go home product, as wide usage and adoption are critical to their value. Tether is now the dominant stablecoin, with about $169 billion of its USDT tokens currently in circulation
However, it took Tether many years to establish itself as a widely used stablecoin. The stablecoin that WLF launched in March, USD1, already has about $3 billion in circulation. That is a pretty quick start. Stablecoins are great for users such as Tether and WLF because they don’t pay interest to the purchaser. The issuer, on the other hand, earns on the cash they receive from the buyers by investing in money-market instruments like Treasury Bills. Bills are currently yielding about 4% which means for every $1 billion of USD1 in circulation, the Trumps’ WLF earns about $40 million
The way WLF was able to issue $3 billion USD1 in such a relatively short amount of time is astounding. The Sunday Times reported:
Its biggest transaction came a few weeks ago when its coins were used for a $2 billion deal between MGX, an Abu Dhabi-state backed company, to take a stake in Binance, the largest crypto exchange in the world, shortly before Trump’s business-orientated visit to the Gulf state this month. MGX, an AI and technology investment firm, is run by Sheikh Tahnoon bin Zayed al-Nahyan, the Emirati national security adviser.
A couple of weeks after this deal went down, the administration announced an agreement, giving the UAE access to advanced US computer chips.
Moreover, the other party to the big Abu Dhabi company using USD1 to purchase a $2 billion stake in crypto exchange Binance is its founder, Changpeng Zhao, or “CZ.” CZ happens to be in the market for a presidential pardon after serving four months in a U.S. prison. CZ signed a plea deal with the Department of Justice in 2023 for running a large-scale money laundering operation with his crypto exchange.
Binance has not sold any of its USD1, effectively giving key fundamental support to the token and its growth prospects.
Back to the first question I asked at the top:
Is the President using the Oval Office to benefit his family business?
Well, instead of using the profits to invest in WLF, the president’s share is going to a blind trust. Does that mean he’s not using the influence of his office to build the wealth of that trust with the help of ultra-rich investors who have ulterior motives?
If you believe the answer is no, then you might just be Karoline Leavitt!
As for average investors in WLF tokens and stablecoins, I worry they could be in for a shock. What happens to the value of these products once Trump leaves office? The Trumps and their close associates will have already made tremendous amounts of money if WLF crashes, as many crypto assets tend to do. Average investors won’t be so lucky.
WLF, WLFI and the rest of “TrumpCryptoWorld” are very different from other crypto projects because Trump-related companies are more about the brand than about any new technological or financial innovation. That brings inherent starting value while Trump is in office, but I’m skeptical that it will continue after he leaves. There are perhaps some parallels with the Clinton Foundation, which raised $2 billion while the Clintons were highly influential — including when Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State — but donations nosedived after 2016 when she lost to Trump. Like the Clinton Foundation, it is easy to see a future where TrumpCryptoWorld comes under regulatory and political attack if the Democrats retake control of government.
As Wall Street’s Gordon Gekko said, “If you’re not inside, you’re outside.”
The average investor is most definitely outside on this one, although insiders aren’t immune to experiencing problems. Sun, the $75 million investor in WLFI, complained on X last week that he couldn’t access his tokens!
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
The New York Times obituary of Charlie Kirk, “Charlie Kirk, Right-Wing Force and a Close Trump Ally, Dies at 31” will go down as an infamous entry in the genre for many reasons. It’s an obvious understatement/provocation to write “Dies at 31” in a headline about a man assassinated by rifle round to the neck. The Times also leaned on the worn trope of alleging racist or anti-Semitic comments without elucidating them (“He tweeted relentlessly with a brash right-wing spin, including inflammatory comments about Jewish, gay and Black people”), a tendency that’s been common in coverage today. Then there was this:
Mr. Kirk rose even further into the conservative stratosphere during the early days of the pandemic, when he was quick to attack the World Health Organization — which, in his typical fashion, he called the “Wuhan Health Organization” — accusing it of hiding the source of the Covid virus and claiming that it had emerged from a Chinese lab in the city of Wuhan. He later rallied opposition to school lockdowns and mask mandates.
He was so vocal in his willingness to spread unsupported claims and outright lies — he said that the drug hydroxychloroquine was “100 percent effective” in treating the virus, which it is not — that Twitter temporarily barred him in early March 2020. But that move only added to his notoriety and seemed to support his claim that he was being muzzled by a liberal elite.
The notion that Kirk was “so vocal” in his willingness to spread “unsupported claims and outright lies” that it led to his temporary banning on Twitter seemed a strange thing to emphasize in an obituary. The quote about hydroxychloroquine being “100 percent effective” notwithstanding, Kirk wasn’t wrong (or demonstrably wrong, anyway) to criticize the WHO, lockdowns, or mask mandates. The Times also likely should have been more circumspect about its own performance in contemporaneous stories like “For Charlie Kirk, Conservative Activist, the Virus is a Cudgel,” when the paper complained about his use of phrases like “China virus” and his tweeting of a list of pre-Covid diseases named after the location of the first cases (Zika, West Nile Virus, Ebola, etc). But was Kirk “muzzled by a liberal elite”?
According to Twitter Files documents, “muzzled” might be a strong word, but “targeted” would be accurate. One episode, in which an effort was made to remove Kirk and Benny Johnson just before the 2020 Presidential Election, stands out. Twitter understood this was a high-profile decision and copied the top executives in the firm, as well as Twitter’s “US GOV TEAM,” on its decision-making process. In the most damning sequence, Twitter went from having zero interest to actioning hundreds of accounts linked to Kirk within hours, after receiving a query from The Washington Post. Though the firm had a tough time linking Kirk himself to wrongdoing, he was recommended for removal, despite reservations by Trust and Safety executives. At the last minute, he was given a reprieve, only to be removed just before the election over a tweet about missing mail-in ballots.
In all, Twitter fielded at least three high-profile press queries about taking Kirk down just before the election, and one finally stuck. There’s no suggestion of an intelligence role, but it’s worth noting that a former CIA official was put in the “lead” of one of Kirk’s investigations:
Subscribe now
As the Times obituary notes, Kirk had a tweet deleted in March of 2020 about hydroxychloroquine. We don’t have emails about that sequence in the surviving Twitter Files. However, there are many references to Kirk elsewhere, including a photo of his “Do Not Amplify” status, and a series of exchanges in September and October of 2020, just before the election between Donald Trump and Joe Biden.
Kirk’s page was one of the first things Bari Weiss and I saw when invited to interview the temporary head of Trust and Safety at Twitter, after Elon Musk’s arrival, in the first week of December 2022:
Elsewhere, we have emails referring to an incident involving an (allegedly) Kirk-affiliated group called Rally Forge, which was quickly dubbed an “election troll farm” in the press. This exchange shows one of the worst examples of what one Twitter executive called “the model that works.”
This was a technique developed during Russiagate by NGOs and some state actors to use the threat of negative press to induce platforms to quickly remove accounts. During the time period of the Twitter Files, nearly all of these incidents involved conservatives.
How it worked: Twitter would receive “incoming” (i.e. an unwanted query) from a reporter at a high-profile publication. Typically, Twitter would be asked whether or not it planned on taking action against accounts the reporter claimed were tied to “hostile foreign actors,” “extremists,” “disinformation,” or “inauthentic activity.” Crucially, the story was almost always essentially finished by the time Twitter got its fateful email from a reporter, often on the morning of a day on which the story was scheduled to run. Immediate comment would be demanded.
Using research that originated with the Labour Party-aligned Center For Countering Digital Hate, the Financial Times sent an email in March 2021 about a story it was planning on the so-called “Disinformation Dozen” of the pandemic. Reporter Hannah Murphy told Twitter it was “welcoming any steer by the end of the day,” meaning an indication about whether or not it planned to remove Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Joseph Mercola, Rashid Buttar, and others.
“WELCOMING ANY STEER BY THE END OF THE DAY”Once Twitter received such notices, it now had a gun to its head. If it didn’t remove the accounts the press asked about, the headline that night would be, “Twitter Refuses to Remove Anti-Vax Disinfo.” If Twitter could find something to remove, fast, the headline would be less painful. As one communications executive noted in a case involving Buzzfeed and Russian bots in 2017, “Reporters now know this is a model that works.”
An early troubling example from 2017 involved the Washington Post asking Twitter to investigate “reports” of Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore’s Twitter following increasing, with many of the “new followers” alleged to be “Cyrillic accounts.” This later turned out to be a hoax, generated by Jonathon Morgan, CEO of a company called New Knowledge:
The “Project Alabama” queryThe “model that works” scams were more disturbing when the “research” originated from state actors like the Senate Intelligence Committee or the FBI, state contractors like New Knowledge, or from “academic brand names” at universities like Clemson, who made lists of Russians or other wrongdoers. These players would send lists to reporters, who in turn wrote to Twitter, which began caving to this technique at the height of Russiamania in 2017.
In 2020, it came for Kirk and fellow Turning Point USA influencer Benny Johnson. The subject was Rally Forge, reportedly a “sister” organization to Kirk’s 501(c)3, Turning Point USA.
Rally Forge was accused of being deceitful by creating accounts seemingly designed to rope in Democrats, without disclosing Turning Point support. In conjunction with the “model that works” format, actions by Twitter and Facebook were prompted by a Washington Post reporter. On September 15, 2020, reporter Isaac Stanley-Becker sent a list of 20 accounts he said belonged to “teenagers” enlisted to post on behalf of Turning Point. “It’s hard to tell whether they’re real people using fake names or automated accounts,” Stanley-Becker wrote, but would Twitter “check in to see if any of this violates Twitter’s policies?”
The letter from the Post’s Becker hit the in-box of a Twitter communications executive at 7:13 AM:
The Post LetterBy 2:57 PM, a Trust and Safety executive told the comms department that “the reporter will start to notice some suspensions taking place here,” and “We’re grabbing a data scientist to help us track down all of the accounts, and the sweep is ongoing.”
By 4:34 PM ET, the Trust and Safety department told the press office: “We perm suspended ~60 accounts and temp suspended ~250 accounts.”
By 6:05 PM ET, ninety-one minutes later, the Post ran a story noting action by Twitter in the headline: “Pro-Trump youth group enlists teens in secretive campaign likened to a ‘troll farm,’ prompting rebuke by Facebook and Twitter.” This was pure, gun-to-noggin journalism. Remove something by end of business or else:
The Post story was extraordinary in its claims. It quoted Graham Brookie of the Atlantic Council, whose Digital Forensic Research Labs not only was taking part in Stanford’s dubious Election Integrity Project, but advised Facebook on some of the earliest “influence operations” removals in 2018, after the Senate recommended the platforms needed outside help. “In 2016, there were Macedonian teenagers interfering in the election by running a troll farm and writing salacious articles for money,” Brookie told the Post. “In this election, the troll farm is in Phoenix.”
The Post also referred to a Senate Intelligence Committee report on Russian trolls prepared by the firm New Knowledge — the same company whose CEO was outed after the publication of this Senate report in a scheme to tie fake Russian accounts to Alabama Senate candidate Roy Moore — in asserting that in 2016, “the Kremlin-backed Internet Research Agency amplified Turning Point’s right-wing memes as part of Moscow’s sweeping interference aimed at boosting Trump.” New Knowledge cited “the use of Turning Point content as evidence of Russia’s ‘deep knowledge of American culture, media, and influencers.’”
Twitter didn’t appear to see anything like a Macedonian troll farm or a Russian internet attack brought home. In fact, they weren’t even sure suspensions were warranted. Kirk himself was not removed, nor was Turning Point sanctioned. Still, from the start, Twitter’s “US Gov Team” was copied on all communications involving Turning Point and Kirk:
Even though the Post story was able to claim in the headline that its investigation prompted a “rebuke” by Twitter, not everyone was happy. Within two days, Twitter’s communications team asked the Trust and Safety analysts “why we would not be taking action on Charlie Kirk”:
A few days later, a Twitter Trust and Safety reviewer complained about the pressure to suspend Kirk. Noting that the case involving Turning Point was similar to a copypasta violation from February in which the platform had sanctioned the campaign of Michael Bloomberg — not exactly a Macedonia or Russia-level horror — the analyst noted that “suspension is not where we’d go first” in this case, and “this is not so different from the common trend of how influencers are paid to post things”:
“SUSPENSION IS NOT WHERE WE’D GO FIRST”Nonetheless, by the end of September 2020, momentum was gathering toward a second story that was supposed to end with Kirk and Benny Johnson suspended. The key email comes from Trust and Safety chief Yoel Roth, who on October 4th says he’s “leaning” toward recommending suspension later that year.
“We do not yet have a final recommendation about whether or not to take action on Charlie Kirk,” he wrote on October 4, 2020. “We’re aiming to have something final here by midday tomorrow (Monday). At this time, though, we are leaning towards recommending suspension, given the clear and long-running ties between Kirk, Rally Forge, and inauthentic activities coordinated by Rally Forge to amplify Kirk.”
“Rally Forge have continued to operate many fake accounts on Twitter, playing both sides of the political spectrum, largely in service of advancing views favorable to the Republican Party,” Roth wrote.
Roth again explains that “[Facebook] comms are working VERY closely (their words) with the Washington Post on this investigation.” It’s also worth noting that one of Twitter’s CIA veterans, Patrick Conlon, was “lead on this investigation” for Twitter’s Site Integrity department.
“A CALM AND RELAXING WEEK”: Twitter prepares to ban Charlie KirkBy the next day, October 5th, 2020, Roth proposed action against Kirk, Rally Force CEO Jack Hoffman, and fellow influencer Benny Johnson. This decision came at a fraught moment for Twitter, just before the 2020 election. In fact, at that same time, they were also planning to release data about labeling of “election-related tweets” that would inspire complaints about bias.
Doing both at the same time, one communications executive noted, might lead some to suspect “we changed our recommendation algorithms to hurt conservative voices at a critical moment in the election.” This, the executive speculated, could lead to “politicized legal challenges and a major battle in the media,” among other things:
We also need to be mindful of how the week's various strands and narratives all interact with each other, e.g. it will likely be positioned that on the same day we suppressed prominent Trump-supporting voices on the service, we changed our recommendation algorithms to hurt conservative voices at a critical moment in the election..
The highest executives in the company, including Vijaya Gadde, agreed to a 5:30 ET meeting to discuss the question. By 10:58 p.m., word came down: Twitter decided not to suspend Kirk and Johnson, “pending further investigation of the strength of the ties between those accounts and the RallyForge network,” while it would remove Hoffman and 262 associated accounts. There is a notation about sending a “final warning” text to Hoffman and Johnson, but then just after one executive asks for a “comms review” of the warning letter, “we can expect that to be tweeted/made public.”
It’s not clear a warning text was ever sent. I asked Benny Johnson if he received a warning.
“No I did not,” he said last night.
The next day, comms official Trenton Kennedy sent a tweet to senior executives expressing satisfaction with the Washington Post, whose story claimed Rally Forge was “creating the appearance of a social media groundswell in support of Trump.” Quoting Facebook’s Nathaniel Gleicher, the piece said they used tactics “designed to evade the guardrails Silicon Valley put in place to limit disinformation of the sort Russia used during the 2016 presidential campaign.” It quoted the now-defunct Stanford Internet Observatory, which prepared a report on what it called an “astroturfing” operation, accusing the pro-Trump group of “secret coordination or unearned amplification.”
In a subsequent discussion Twitter execs noted the problem of not being able to ban an account that is merely deceptive politically or unclear. In vague terms they discussed the problem of not being able to directly connect people like Kirk to bad behavior, or the issue of how to categorize activity that might otherwise be common advertising: paying users to boost accounts. Facebook, in announcing its parallel decision, called for more “broad” legislation against “information operations, which would make life easier for the platforms, as it would be much easier to “action” behavior against the law.
Twitter execs admired the strategy. “Interesting twist on the whole thing. We couldn’t take more action because we need to be regulated first,” wrote Roth.
After being rebuffed twice that fall, Twitter finally relented and banned Kirk over a tweet in which he reportedly claimed, “Pennsylvania has just rejected 372,000 mail-in ballots.” That seemed to be the end of that episode, until a year later, when a Washington Post reporter claimed in a tweet Hoffman had resurfaced on the platform under a new name. Twitter lacked a “technical link” to the old account, but what’s interesting is one official said, “I’m holding off the reporter from writing but I have a feeling this might spark more digging on others included in our action from last fall.”
There are several major issues with the platforms’ behavior toward Kirk.
One is that while there are examples in the files of Twitter’s Trust and Safety department taking action against a Democrat-aligned group or individual engaged in “inauthentic activity,” there are also numerous examples of the company not doing so, the most conspicuous being the case involving alleged Russian bot-detecting dashboard Hamilton 68. “We have to be careful on how much we push back… publicly” then-Twitter-employee Emily Horne, once of the National Security Council, said about Hamilton 68, who just this summer had her security clearance pulled by Tulsi Gabbard.
Perhaps more damning, when Twitter took action against Democratic-aligned accounts or discovered issues with the methodology of Democratic-aligned NGOs or research facilities, it frequently did not involve the press. Twitter’s Trust and Safety Department kept its frustration with the Clemson Media Forensics Hub to itself, for instance, to a degree that may even have had an impact on Kirk. Just before the first query about Kirk from Isaac Stanley-Becker in September 2020, the same Post reporter worked with Craig Timberg on a story about alleged fake accounts targeting black voters and the #WentDemtoRep campaign. The story cited Clemson research and so impressed an FBI Counterintelligence official that he wrote to San Francisco Field Office agent Elvis Chan, who in turn asked Twitter to look into the matter:
Chan wrote to his “Twitter Folks,” asking for help in looking into the matter:
When Twitter was deciding what to do about “WentDemToRep,” one exec recalled that it was similar to the first time they’d actioned Kirk: though they took action early, they often didn’t really have a lot of information until later. The early action was clearly done for the sake of the media:
“This is similar to what we said in the early stages of the Turning Point USA investigation.”Kirk was banned once, then finally actioned again, and again, with groups like the DFRLabs and New Knowledge working with the Washington Post and other outlets to advertise the action.
Efforts to remove Kirk aren’t urgent background to his assassination, but the episodes do play a part in the overall story. Unquestionably, antagonists of Kirk and Donald Trump recognized that he was an important Internet voice, and the repeated actions sent a signal that he needed to be removed — either for spreading “disinformation” or for more dubious claims of “inauthentic” activity. That there were repeated efforts to go after the same person before the 2020 election also speaks volumes. No other figure in Trump’s orbit had the kind of reach with young people and the same Internet savvy. Stanley-Becker hasn’t responded, and it’s doubtful he would or could answer, but it sure would be interesting to know what source proposed Turning Point and Rally Forge as targets for removal.
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
The era of mandatory opinion once again rears its head
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 09/08/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
From the publisher's feed