Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Transcript - America This Week, May 9, 2025: "Conclave: Matt and Walter Watch Vatican Smoke"

    Listen to Episode 133

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: So we’re recording on Thursday morning, technically-

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: ... Eastern Time, and very recently, last time I checked, I think it was like 28 minutes ago or something like that, this happened. Can we see the black smoke?

    Rev. Tom Reese: We were not surprised by the black smoke. We expected black smoke tonight, but we expected it a lot earlier. At the last conclave, the smoke appeared around 7:30 in the evening. This was an hour and a half later.

    Isabel Lammers: It’s a very intense prayer that the one who comes.

    Matt Taibbi: I like the way that they watch it on a screen for the uninitiated.

    Walter Kirn: Dude, people love tradition. Come on.

    Matt Taibbi: I know. I know.

    Walter Kirn: You just saw it right there why in a strange sense, conservatism is the natural state of mankind. Just having one unspoiled fricking tradition is just got everybody shivering.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. So people come out from all over the world just to watch-

    Walter Kirn: To white or black. They were expecting the black smoke tonight.

    Matt Taibbi: Yes. Yeah. Exactly. And for those who are not Catholic, don’t know, don’t care, whatever, black smoke means we came to no decision.

    Walter Kirn: In the election of the new Pope.

    Matt Taibbi: Yes.

    Walter Kirn: We came to no decision. And it also means, I think for people who aren’t Catholics, that when Donald Trump or something dresses up as a pope, it is somewhat ridiculous, but then so are tens and tens of thousands of people waiting for the color of smoke to change and crying about it. Now, I’m not saying as a non-Catholic that there’s something contemptible about that. I’m just saying that if you’re Fellini, or let’s say one of the great Italian film directors who would make movies about these spectacles, they called them surrealism.

    Matt Taibbi: Yes. I mean, popes are funny just by nature of who they are. I mean, people disagree about how funny popes are, and I should know this because my career nearly ended because I once wrote a column called the 52 Funniest Things About the Upcoming Death of the Pope and was condemned by members of Congress.

    Walter Kirn: That’s the American version of Baudrillard’s The Gulf War did not Happen.

    Matt Taibbi: But look, I can’t look at the papal hat and not laugh, and it’s only one of many hats that they have. I mean, they have many costumes for the Pope.

    Walter Kirn: We discussed at nauseam on Monday night, the couthness or uncouthness of Trump’s AI as the Pope meme. But then people deluged me with Fauci as Saint Francis, and I said, I got to say.

    Matt Taibbi: Oh yeah.

    Walter Kirn: He didn’t pretend to be a saint, just a Pope.

    Matt Taibbi: No, I know. Or Robert Mueller as Saint Francis. Right? Remember the vote Votive candle thing?

    Walter Kirn: Oh yeah. There were Fauci votives too.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. No, that was-

    Walter Kirn: And there are Luigi votives, by the way, right now.

    Matt Taibbi: Are there Luigi votives?

    Walter Kirn: Darn right.

    Matt Taibbi: Okay. So that happened, and we might as well take a live shot of nothing, check the live shot of nothing happening right now-

    Walter Kirn: Okay.

    Matt Taibbi: ... Which the world is eagerly tuning in right now to the non smoke emitting chimney-

    Walter Kirn: Right. Okay.

    Matt Taibbi: ... Which is one of the most popular live streams in the world at the moment.

    Walter Kirn: There it is.

    Matt Taibbi: What’s your color commentary there, Walter?

    Walter Kirn: Well, should red smoke appear, we know that we’ve reached the final stages. But the ability to look at, you know how you stare down the empty subway track waiting for the subway to come, and even though you know it doesn’t help, you can’t stop doing it?

    Matt Taibbi: Right. Yes, that’s exactly right.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah.

    Matt Taibbi: That’s exactly right.

    Walter Kirn: Whatever that is, this is on a cosmic scale.

    Matt Taibbi: Yep. Yep.

    Walter Kirn: Each person who’s looking also thinks delusionally in some way they won’t admit that they can cause the smoke to come or that they’re maybe causing it not to come. In other words, there is deep psychic personal involvement on the part of all witnesses that has nothing to do with rationality. And this is the greatest reminder ever of my thesis that if you think human beings are run by rational forces, you haven’t met any.

    Matt Taibbi: This joke will only probably work with NFL fans. But you know what I think should happen before the smoke comes out? I think we should hear this sound.

    So that’s the sound the NFL draft, like the pick is in-

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: ... Right, and that’s how you know that your team has chosen it’s first round draft choice.

    Walter Kirn: See, Matt, the other night, you referred to yourself as an ex-Catholic, and I said, no, Matt, there are no ex-Catholics and you just proved it. You have transferred your smoke watching papal anxiety to the NFL draft.

    Matt Taibbi: It’s so true.

    Walter Kirn: Just as the Catholic Church itself repurposed various goddesses and so on and other people to create saints. So nothing new under the sun here.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. It’s funny, I think having grown up for a significant portion of my life as a Catholic, there is a guilt/self-loathing factor that I’ve noticed is absent in people of other faiths, particularly Protestant faiths.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah. The problem with being Protestant from Germanic background is the Nietzschean cruelty that replaces that guilt. In other words, your kind of default setting isn’t like, wow, I did that, but can I just defy and maybe dominate and eliminate that person? No, it’s not worth it, your Catholic wife tells you.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. Catholicism, I’m just not sure about the utility of it as a mechanism of psychological conquest or-

    Walter Kirn: Well, how can we not joke? I mean, I should tell our audience that I’ve seriously considered at times converting to Catholicism.

    Matt Taibbi: Really?

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, I’m not kidding. So for all my levity, I’ve looked deeply into it, and I feel like now a taco bowl engagement or something. I love Catholics. They have best incense. But in any case, how can you not as an observer of human life just find this endlessly entertaining and in a weirdly grimly fascinating. Getting people to look at the roof of a building for hours and hours in the weather outside is one of the greatest achievements of human something. Spirituality, hypnotism, something.

    Matt Taibbi: And look, people go absolutely bananas for the Pope. I remember the Pope came to Boston when I was a kid, and it’s funny though. There was recently an HBO documentary about the Celtics, and they were comparing, because the two events were relatively contemporaneous, the arrival of Larry Bird to the Pope, and the general consensus is that the Pope won in Boston, but narrowly. People went bananas. I still remember that moment.

    Walter Kirn: People can correct me, but there is a great play by the playwright, John Guare, John Guare, I believe it’s called House of Blue Leaves, about the visit of the Pope to New York and how it disturbs life. And what I love about popes is that are they necessarily good or are they just powerful? It’s never clear. I know they’re supposed to be great authorities on God’s word, but do they have to be good themselves? Because popes that are interesting from history-

    Read more

    0 min
  • Listen to This Article - My Education Solution

    Stop lying, blow it up, and start over

    Text published 05/07/25:

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Listen to subscriber only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    Read more

    3 min
  • How I Almost Went to the Clink Over One Letter

    Two years ago I made a catastrophic decision to give an interview about the Twitter Files with MSNBC’s Mehdi Hasan. I made a worse decision to cop on-air to what at the time I thought was at most a minor mistake, interpreting a Slack passage reading “According to CIS (escalated via EIP)” as “According to CIS[A] (escalated via EIP).”

    The alleged error here was substituting the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, or the Homeland Security body CISA, for the Center for Internet Security, or CIS. As Mehdi put it, I’d “deliberately and under oath” made communications from a “nonprofit” look like recommendations from an “intel agency.” This episode, incredibly, led to a letter from Congress (not even sent to me, oddly) threatening a prison term of “up to five years” for “providing false information” under oath:

    I took a bigger beating for a line about the Stanford-run Election Integrity Partnership: “According to the EIP’s own data, it succeeded in getting nearly 22 million tweets labeled in the runup to the 2020 vote.” Stanford issued a spirited defense of the group’s efforts, writing, “No, the EIP did not censor any tweets or label any tweets as ‘misinformation.’” It added that platforms were responsible for “their own content moderation decisions,” and that the EIP “did not make recommendations to the platforms about what actions they should take.”

    It later came out (after a long legal fight) that the EIP did send concrete recommendations to platforms in big numbers, saying things like:

    • “We recommend Twitter remove the tweet as it is a fairly clear violation”;

    • “Hi Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter . . . we recommend it be removed from your platforms”;

    • “Recommend disabling the account at link”;

    • “We recommend you label or reduce the discoverability of the post.”

    There were many more of this type, underscoring a basic problem of the Twitter Files. With the EIP, there was significant public data about its research endeavors, but the flip side was a real-time reporting program thrown together between the platforms and the Department of Homeland Security in 2020 for the purpose of policing tweets in time for that year’s election. We knew it was important because email after email said things like “CISA received a grant to build a web portal for state and local election officials to report incidents of election-related misinformation,” and “DHS want to establish a centralized portal for reporting disinformation.” Once operational, complaints about topics came in via routes like the EIP, after which Twitter would issue quasi-automated content moderation responses in big quantities. But how big?

    Yesterday Mike Benz tweeted a new video showing an EIP partner talking about how the group “identified 20+ million tweets related to ~400 false, misleading, or unsubstantiated claims” that “functioned to sow doubt in the election.” The video doesn’t change much, echoing things written in the EIP’s report.

    I let this alone for ages because it’s a weedsy matter, because Lee Fang already addressed many of the main issues, and because players like Hasan refused to retract their own errors, even after I was threatened with jail over them. But I want to explain part of this bizarre story.

    Ben Kawaller yesterday wrote about the phenomenon of activists refusing to engage with potentially hostile media. Once, I believed journalists should never do the same. I thought reporters should always engage, even if you know you’re going to take a beating. Now, I’m not sure:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • Timeline: Beaglegate
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    There’s been a lot of celebration over NIH Director Bhattacharya’s announcement that the agency’s last in-house beagle lab is gone. Actually, announcement isn’t quite right. It was more like a matter-of-fact statement. If I didn’t know better, I would have thought he was just repeating what had already been announced.

    “We got rid of all the beagle experiments on the NIH campus,” he said in the middle of a May 4 interview on Fox & Friends Weekend as he talked about changing the culture at the agency. That was it.

    Racket News is supported by readers. Consider becoming a paid subscriber.

    But those 12 words were huge for groups such as White Coat Waste, PETA, and the Physicians Committee for Ethical Medicine.

    In the last decade, White Coat Waste (WCW) has led an aggressive campaign to end the use of dogs for medical research. It focused a lot of its energy on pressuring Anthony Fauci, who led the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) for nearly 40 years, to end the practice. The NIAID is a division of the NIH.

    “Today’s landmark victory is especially sweet as our fight to expose and close Fauci and NIH’s in-house dog labs–which slaughtered more than 2,000 beagles over the last 40 years–was the first campaign White Coat Waste started in 2016,” said Anthony Bellotti, the founder and president of WCW, the day Bhattacharya said the last lab was gone.

    But to hear WCW spokesman Justin Goodman talk, the victory is more like winning a battle in a war.

    “It was the NIH's last in-house dog lab. And it was actually the last deadly dog laboratory across all government agencies inside the agencies themselves,” Goodman says. “Unfortunately, the NIH, the Department of Defense, the FDA and other agencies are still funding experimentation on dogs and cats outside of their agencies at colleges and universities and private companies across the country. So we're hoping to export this great homegrown victory inside the government, outside to these other laboratories that are being funded with our tax dollars.”

    The dogs were primarily used to research septic shock, Goodman says. But why beagles?

    “Beagles are the victim of choice for the same reason that they make such great pets. They are well-behaved and sweet and forgiving, and that makes them easy to cage and abuse as well,” he says.

    He referenced this section of a 2023 proposal for an NIH-funded study in China. The company, Pharmaron, states why it prefers beagles.

    Gross. Here’s the entire contract and proposal for that study, followed by the timeline:

    Contract 75n95023p00683 Wm77.8MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadNovember 5, 2016

    The White Coat Waste Project publishes a report titled “Spending to Death: Wasteful Government Spending, Transparency Failures, and the Secretive World of Federal Dog Experiments.” The WCW’s report describes how, in 2015 alone, over 1,183 beagles, hounds, and mixed-breed dogs, including puppies, were “subjected to painful, bizarre and wasteful experiments inside federal agency laboratories” operated by the National Institutes of Health, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration, and the Departments of Defense and Homeland Security.

    According to the Project, the agencies in question purchased the dogs “just to cut them apart, infect them, make them sick, and kill them in taxpayer-funded experiments.” Many of the dogs were used in experiments in which they were intentionally given heart attacks, implanted with experimental technology, or had their skulls drilled.

    2016 11 05 Wcw Spending To Death Report3.61MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadOctober 21, 2021

    A bipartisan group of 24 lawmakers sign a letter to National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Director Anthony Fauci that says they have “grave concerns” that NIAD spent $1.68 million from October 2018 to February 2019 on experiments involving beagle puppies. The money was spent over a four-month period, from October 2018 to February 2019.

    Of particular concern is the fact that the invoice to NIAID included a line item for “cordectomy.” As you are likely aware, a cordectomy, also known as “devocalization,” involves slitting a dog’s vocal cords in order to prevent them from barking, howling, or crying. This cruel procedure — which is opposed with rare exceptions by the American Veterinary Medical Association, the American Animal Hospital Association, and others — seems to have been performed so that experimenters would not have to listen to the pained cries of the beagle puppies. This is a reprehensible misuse of taxpayer funds.

    The letter asks Fauci to provide a detailed rationale for the tests, which were carried out on 44 beagle puppies who were between six and eight months old.

    Six Republican U.S. senators sign a similar letter to Fauci on Oct. 29.

    10 21 2021 Bipartisan Letter To Congress737KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload10 29 2021 Senators Paul Marshall Cotton Rubio Braun Collins Letter To NIAID About Beagle Experiments452KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadOct. 28, 2021

    Fact-checkers get to work. First, Politifact reports that a photo WCW posted of beagles’ heads in mesh cages didn’t come from a NIAID-funded study and that the journal that published the study erroneously gave NIAID credit. The journal said it made a mistake and issues a correction.

    WCW cited a database of NIH-funded research “which appeared to link the agency to the study,” Politifact reports. It even marks up the photo:

    Nov. 19, 2021

    A story in The Washington Post calls it a “viral and false claim” that NIAID funded the study with beagles’ heads in mesh cages. The Post reports:

    The false claim about the funding for the beagle study, research that was conducted in Tunisia, originated with an error by scientists. Initially, the researchers mistakenly listed NIAID as a funder when they published a paper in a scientific journal in late July.

    The story says the study “does not appear in a database of NIH-funded projects.”

    The NIAID did, however, fund another study in Tunisia by the same researchers, the Post reports. It evaluated a vaccine for a parasitic disease that infects humans and dogs.

    Twelve dogs were given the vaccine and then put in a fenced-in open space outside during high sand fly season, NIAID said, to see if the dogs still became infected.

    WCW’s Justin Goodman doesn’t believe NIAID’s denial and tells the Post it’s “too convenient.”

    Dec. 26, 2021

    The Washington Post reports that in July 2021, the USDA cited a beagle-breeding facility called Envigo in Cumberland, Va. The NIH is among its clients. The Post story cites a PETA report that found Envigo and its predecessor had contracts with NIH that were “potentially worth” $1.2 million. Among the problems inspectors found, according to the Post:

    • More than 500 dogs in a building without air conditioning. The dogs were in temperatures above 85 degrees for at least five hours.

    • Roughly a dozen nursing dogs went without water for 42 hours.

    • Fight wounds on nearly 50 dogs.

    A spokesman for Envigo told the Post it would correct the problems. The company also says its dogs play an “integral role in the development of advanced pacemakers,” vaccine development, and Parkinson’s disease and multiple sclerosis research.

    May 19, 2022

    The Justice Department files a complaint against Envigo for violations of the Animal Welfare Act. The complaint (see below) says the facility had housed up to 5,000 beagles in the last year in which it received more than “60 citations for non-compliance with the AWA, which have affected thousands of beagles. More than half of those citations were deemed “critical” or “direct,” the most serious types of AWA citation.

    Nearly 150 dogs are immediately removed from the facility. In July, Envigo agrees to surrender more than 4,000 beagles and close the facility. The dogs are put up for adoption.

    Through the Freedom of Information Act, WCW obtained records of NIH doing business with that facility and others run by Envigo.

    DOJ Complaint249KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload55874 FOIA Envigo19.6MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadOffice Of Public Affairs Justice Department Secures The Surrender Of Over 4,000 Beagles From Virginia Breeder Of Dogs For Research United States Department Of Justice263KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJune 3, 2024

    Fauci appears before a hearing of the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic. While condemning Fauci, Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia holds up the photograph of the two beagles being exposed to sand flies as their heads are held in mesh cages.

    In the video above, Greene says:

    As director of the NIH, you did sign off on these so-called scientific experiments, and as a dog lover, I want to tell you this is disgusting and evil, what you signed off on. And these experiments that happened to beagles are paid for by the American taxpayer. And I want you to know Americans don’t pay their taxes for animals to be tortured like this. So, the type of science that you are representing, Mr. Fauci, is abhorrent, and it needs to stop.

    Greene shows the photograph again during another exchange about 30 seconds later, to which Fauci replies:

    What do dogs have to do with anything we’re talking about today?

    On the same day, Envigo pleads guilty and agrees to pay $35 million in fines.

    Justice Department Guilty Plea290KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadPlea Agreement30.6MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJune 7, 2024

    Fresh off of Greene confronting Fauci, the Washington Post takes a deeper dive into that picture it had earlier called a “viral and false claim.”

    The Post no longer stridently labels it a “false claim.”

    It reports that the NIH couldn’t provide proof that it didn’t fund the study involving dogs’ heads in mesh cases — it only had the word of a researcher at Ohio State who asked for a correction in 2021 after being contacted by the NIH. The editor of the journal agreed but expressed hesitation because she was also an employee of NIAID. She emailed NIAID officials that she was worried about a conflict of interest. The NIH declined the Post’s request to answer questions about the potential conflict.

    The story notes that its November 2021 article (mentioned above) said the trapped-beagles claim “does not appear in a database of NIH-funded projects.” That was true — but:

    The emails show that, while it was removed before the publication of The Post article, the study had been listed in the database for months and was still listed as of the previous month, when Fauci first asked about the controversy.

    It turns out there’s more to the story about the beagle study that NIAID acknowledged funding — the one in which the dogs were reportedly “put in a fenced-in open space outside.”

    Finally, other documents obtained by White Coat Waste suggest the Tunisia study funded by NIH was not as benign as the agency suggested. Instead of an “enclosed open space,” the study’s grant application shows a photograph that indicated that the dogs were kept in a cage as they were “exposed to sand fly bites each night through the sand fly season to ensure transmission.” The grant application also described how, separately, dogs would be sedated and placed in cages for two hours while they were exposed to 15 to 30 female sand flies.

    The story concludes:

    The emails show that NIH was not fully transparent as it tried to handle a public-relations nightmare. Perhaps there was little reason to doubt Satoskar, but officials embraced his explanation without confirming as they rushed out a statement. They made no acknowledgment that they had removed the study from the NIH grant database or that the editor of the journal that quickly issued the correction had a potential conflict of interest. Moreover, the NIH study in Tunisia that the agency said it funded was cast in a positive light that is undermined by the grant application that has since been made public.

    Meanwhile, WCW had already posted a contract and research description that it says is for the study that had the viral picture of the two dogs.

    Niaid Foiadoc Wm15.1MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    WCW also obtained emails from one of the Washington Post reporters, Beth Reinhard, who wrote the 2021 story that said it was a “viral and false claim” that NIAID funded the study. In seeking comment, Reinhard wrote she was working on a story about a “massive disinformation campaign” against Fauci.

    May 4, 2025

    During an appearance on Fox & Friends Weekend, NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya says “we got rid of all the beagle experiments on the NIH campus.” He mentions it as an example of changing the culture at NIH, not as a big policy announcement.

    White Coast Waste founder Anthony Bellotti takes credit for the decision, saying:

    As the watchdog that first uncovered and battled Dr. Fauci’s beagle tests (the biggest animal testing scandal in history), we’re proud that White Coat Waste has closed the NIH’s last in-house beagle laboratory—and the US government’s biggest dog lab.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Private Equity and Hospitals: Have They Finally Gone Too Far?
    Emergency department employees at Carney Hospital in Dorchester, Mass., wave goodbye after their final shift on Aug. 31, 2024. The hospital closed as part of Steward Health Care bankruptcy proceedings. (Getty Images)

    A long time ago when I was a kid, our local hospital was one of the rocks of our community. While it was not usually a destination of choice, you had confidence that the hospital was there solely for the purpose of taking care of you or your family when something went wrong. The hospital was a distinct entity, separate from the various businesses in town whose primary and necessary objective was to turn a profit.

    I would hazard to guess that if some speculator came in who wanted to buy the hospital, leverage it up to the hilt, squeeze every last nickel out of it by skimping on supplies, cancel vital services and risk running it into the ground, well, that speculator would have been run out of town on a rail.

    Those days are gone.

    Private equity firms are doing just that - and their tentacles in health care are growing. Last year, they owned 460 hospitals, according to the Private Equity Stakeholder Project’s hospital tracker. Now, they own 488 hospitals. That represents:

    • 8.5% of all private hospitals

    • 22.6% of all for-profit hospitals

    • At least 27.7% of private equity-owned hospitals serve rural populations, which generally have a higher percentage of financially vulnerable patients and fewer healthcare options

    The growth in PE-owned hospitals raises a myriad of ethical questions. While the bottom line is important to all hospitals, whether non-profit or for-profit, PE-owned hospitals are on a different level in emphasizing profits, and the consequences can be devastating as we are about to find out.

    Cerberus and Steward Health Care

    Steward Health Care, the nation’s largest for-profit hospital group, filed for bankruptcy in May 2024. The story of Steward is a tragic tale and is seen by many as indisputable proof that when a private equity fund, such as the one managed by PE giant Cerberus Capital Management, purchases hospitals and treats them strictly as financial assets, terrible things can and do happen.

    According to Cerberus, they were Mother Teresa, investing to save a struggling healthcare provider, while making a profit for their investors and leaving Steward in fine shape when they exited in 2020.

    Shortly before the 2024 bankruptcy, Cerberus slobbered:

    Cerberus’ initial investment in Steward in 2010 not only rescued but restored six struggling Massachusetts hospitals on the verge of closing that were critical to their communities. During our nearly 11-year ownership of Steward, we supported the revitalization of failing community hospitals into a leading healthcare system. Cerberus’ long-term investment made it possible for Steward to continue to serve its communities, employ tens of thousands of professionals, and positively impact millions of patients’ lives.

    Cerberus also felt the need to mention that an investment from a Cerberus fund was essentially an investment made possible by “millions of teachers, firefighters, law enforcement personnel, and municipal workers as well as other pension funds, universities, and endowments.”

    Salt of the earth helps salt of the earth.

    However, Cerberus danced around the important fact that they and their investors were not charities.

    The teachers and first responders (their pension funds), as well as Cerberus expected a significant return on their investment, and they expected it within five to 10 years. Therefore, it’s reasonable to ask what kind of return the Cerberus fund and its limited partners (the teachers and first responders) could expect from an investment in 37 struggling, indebted hospitals in Massachusetts, and later Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Texas.

    Struggling hospitals don’t jump out as a good private equity investment. They required significant time, money and a lot of risk. So, if you’re wondering why PE firms would buy so many hospitals, think of McDonald’s.

    In the 2016 film “The Founder,” Ray Kroc is struggling to turn a profit on the 13 McDonald’s franchises he has granted. A young man named Harry Sonneborn immediately diagnoses Kroc’s problem and reveals the magic formula that makes him a billionaire:

    “You’re not in the burger business. You’re in the real estate business.”

    The same is true for Cerberus. Hospitals are an annoyance to get what they really want, which is to use the hospital’s real estate to suck out their investment and profits.

    Many of the hospitals purchased by private equity have owned both the buildings and land with low levels of debt, some with none at all. Getting at that unencumbered real estate is where private equity hits pay-dirt using an age-old real estate strategy called “Sale and Leaseback.”

    Working hand in hand with private equity firms are real estate investment trusts (REITs), which have $185 billion in healthcare holdings. Private equity managers like Cerberus sell a hospital group’s land and buildings to the REITs and turn a huge profit.

    Meanwhile, the REIT portfolios the property, earning a steady stream of lease income from the target hospital and because they are a REIT, the income is tax free. The hospitals no longer own their real estate and are now on the hook for millions of dollars in lease payments to the REIT for years to come.

    This is exactly what Cerberus did.

    When Cerberus purchased Caritas Christi Health Care System (which would become Steward Health Care) in 2010 for $246 million, Massachusetts regulators imposed a five-year monitoring period for Steward. Cerberus would have to wait five years before selling Steward’s properties and leasing them back from the buyer.

    In 2016, after its monitoring period was over, Steward sold the real estate of its Massachusetts hospitals to a REIT, Medical Properties Trust (MPT).

    According to the Boston Globe:

    Medical Properties Trust would pay Steward a staggering sum — nearly $1.3 billion — for its nine hospital campuses in Massachusetts, roughly nine times what Steward had paid less than a decade earlier. The majority of the proceeds went to dividends and to return Cerberus’s original investment, not patient care or physical improvements. Cerberus took $719 million.

    Evil.

    Cerberus exited their investment in Steward in 2020, selling to a physicians group. The REIT MPT provided a $335 million loan financing to the buying group along with a $400 million cash infusion. Steward death spiraled under the weight of debt service and lease payments until the 2024 bankruptcy. Interestingly, another major private equity firm Apollo now owns the eight Massachusetts hospitals once owned by Steward Health Care.

    Some of the horrific low-lights on the way to financial ruin were documented by the Private Equity Stakeholder Project’s special report, “The Pillaging of Steward Health Care”:

    In the months leading up to the bankruptcy, multiple stories appeared in media outlets highlighting Steward’s many issues, including unpaid vendors, supply shortages and stockouts, understaffing, repossessed medical equipment, service cuts, and hospital closures.

    Some examples:

    • A hospital in Florida was infested with thousands of bats and their accompanying bat guano, including on the floor that housed the intensive care unit.

    • In Massachusetts, a woman who gave birth died after the embolization coil needed to stop a bleed following childbirth was unavailable. The hospital’s supply of embolization coils had been repossessed by the company that owned them because Steward had not paid its bill.

    • In West Monroe, LA, health inspectors cited Steward’s Glenwood Regional Medical Center for putting patients in immediate jeopardy three times since December 2023. In March 2024, the hospital closed its inpatient rehabilitation unit. Federal inspectors found that the hospital ran out of multiple supplies including biopsy needles, catheters, and central lines. Various radiology and imaging equipment were in need of repair, and special beds that help prevent bedsores were repossessed. One doctor quoted in the federal inspection report described the conditions at Glenwood Regional in December 2023 as “third-world medicine.”

    Steward Health Care is a horrifying and probably worst-case scenario, but it can happen again. As noted above, many private equity-owned hospitals are located in rural areas and the only game in town. Hospitals don’t make widgets; they provide life-saving health care and should not be treated as just another financial asset to be bought and sold.

    In May of last year, Senator Elizabeth Warren issued a furious statement:

    Steward Health Care’s bankruptcy is a direct consequence of Wall Street private equity vultures looting our health care system. …The next step should be a serious reexamination of whether we should allow private equity in health care. Steward is just the latest example of private equity endangering communities, and I will be introducing new legislation in the Senate to hold corporate actors accountable when they loot our hospitals to boost their profits.

    U.S. Sen. Ed Markey introduced the Health Over Wealth Act last summer that would, among other things, close tax loopholes for REITs.

    It’s made no movement. Don’t expect that to change anytime soon.

    0 min
  • My Education Solution

    From a New York Times editorial originally titled, “I Know Trump’s Plan for Universities. It Transformed My College,” by University of Florida professor Anna Peterson:

    Since [Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s] crackdown, I’ve seen my colleagues harassed and investigated for addressing topical issues, even outside the classroom. The climate of fear gives the government precisely the result it wants. Administrators and faculty members alike practice anticipatory obedience to avoid even the appearance of wokeness, stifling the sort of open and civil discussions that lead students to develop their own views.

    How can I challenge my students to ask hard questions, to follow the research wherever it goes, when I am worried about what might happen to me if I do that? And how can I follow the rules when even university administrators are not always sure of how to interpret them?

    Everyone lies about education. I find it hard to believe Professor Peterson isn’t aware this exact strategy of “anticipatory obedience” became second nature among students and professors at universities (and eventually beyond, in sectors like media and politics) over the last decade-plus, in response to government dictates at least as ambitious as the DeSantis Higher Education bill or Donald Trump’s Executive Orders on Antisemitism or DEI. What she’s describing isn’t something new, but the latest in a long chain of official actions and reactions, during which American higher education became increasingly a) expensive and b) useless.

    Peterson describes a “climate of fear.” The April, 2011 “Dear Colleagues” letter from Barack Obama’s Department of Education kicked off an era of Title IX investigations that quickly flew off the rails and became a fear-generation machine. Racket readers should recall the two harassment cases opened against then-Northwestern professor Laura Kipnis for writing an article called “Sexual Paranoia on Campus” for the Chronicle of Higher Education.

    The Obama letter empowered the DOE’s Office of Civil Rights (and by extension, huge quantities of campus administrators) to become sexual and ideological police. They opened investigations into everything from consensual relationships to dancing “too provocatively” at parties to a ballet teacher saying “I always wanted to partner a banana” in class. The accused were often not informed of charges for long periods, nor were they allowed to bring lawyers to proceedings (Kipnis was permitted a “support person”). Fear spread further when the OCR in 2013 defined harassment as “unwelcome conduct of a sexual nature” in a way that included speech, opening the door for articles to be considered harassment. These and other federal pressures contributed to the feeling expressed in a 2022 poll (reported in a much-denounced New York Times editorial called “America Has a Free Speech Problem”) showing huge pluralities of Americans held their tongues for fear of “retaliation and harsh criticism.”

    This background is necessary when bringing up assertions that Trump executive orders are threatening to “destroy” higher education, or have “created” a climate of paranoia on campuses, with an unnamed colleague of Peterson’s describing “censoring her language” for fear of reprisal. This dynamic wasn’t just born. It’s been a factor in American life for a generation, and is a big part of what got Trump elected twice. This presidency’s moves, more extreme than previous efforts, have to be understood as part of that continuum of actions, moving from the 2011 “Dear Colleagues” letter (it began earlier, but let’s say), to the rescinding of that letter by Betsy Devos in 2017, to Joe Biden’s rescinding of the rescinding, to now.

    It doesn’t bother me to read in the Wall Street Journal that concern over the DeSantis regulation meant UF employees “didn’t organize the usual welcome-back events for affinity groups.” Excuse me for not weeping that a state university in the South is hesitating to throw segregated parties. I also don’t think taxpayers need to subsidize “‘living-learning’ spaces for Black and LGBTQ students” or the LGBTQ community’s “lavender ceremony, in which each graduate is draped in a lavender boa.” Part of the problem we have with higher education is that it somehow became about nurturing hatchlings to life competence, when that should be dealt with by parents by Bar/Bat Mitzvah age, not a decade and $400,000 later.

    But the DeSantis initiative does go too far. The law for instance prohibits public expenditures for any school program that might “advocate for diversity, equity, and inclusion, or promote or engage in political or social activism.” It also bars the teaching of “identity politics” or “theories that systemic racism, sexism, oppression, and privilege are inherent in the institutions of the United States.”

    This just toggles from a system where virtually everyone teaches the Howard Zinn version of American history to one where professors will be afraid to mention its themes, much less assign the book. It’s trading one brand of groupthink for another. Professors cutting off students before they mention forbidden words like “equity” or “systemic privilege” is asinine and will also legitimize criticisms which until recently were farcical, e.g. that DEI’s elimination would lead to the end of “teaching about slavery.” Same with demands that schools like Harvard submit to external “viewpoint diversity” auditors to micro-manage the Ivies off their monoculture kick.

    American universities have become madhouses and ignorance-factories whose purpose is not to teach but produce sinecures for ed-sector dingbats. I still can’t get past reading about a 2023 College Fix survey showing Harvard employed 1,352 administrators for every 1000 undergrads. Still, I don’t want federal thought police of any stripe sitting atop them. The problem with the American educational system (I feel like a product of this) is that easy manipulation of the subsidy complex means too many institutions can thrive offering liberal arts degrees of gross inutility to suckers like me. Instead of the two parties footballing back and forth dueling theories of federal First Amendment overreach, why don’t we just:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • I Tried to Cover a May Day Protest. Antifascists Had a Problem With That.
    A screenshot of what Ben continuously encountered.

    Last week, I was hounded out of a protest by a pair of authoritarians opposing fascism.

    Billed as a “May Day” rally on behalf of workers, the event, which began in Foley Square in downtown Manhattan, was one of dozens of such protests promoted by 50501. This one was organized by a coalition of unions and other progressive groups, including the New York City chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America. I attended the rally and had spent about an hour interviewing participants and onlookers when the trouble began.

    Subscribe now

    My questioning a DSA member about the idea that private ownership was the root of our nation’s troubles had evidently aroused the suspicions of a cadre of masked, yellow-vest-clad organizers bearing arrow signs reading “Right-Wing Troll,” which they then deployed to warn any future interview subjects from speaking with me.

    Two of these people followed me doggedly, eventually driving me from the event to a nearby side street, where they continued to monitor me until I eventually whipped out my phone and made a contribution to the GOP.

    I kid. But my revulsion at the repressive behavior of folks ostensibly gathered to defend democracy was enough to remind me of how emotional our political allegiances can be. The episode brought to mind that Colin Wright cartoon illustrating the “rightward-shift” of some liberals:

    Of course, the mute soldiers of the resistance carrying out this tactic didn’t care that they were alienating me from their cause; they were acting out of a desire to protect their movement from looking idiotic. They know that journalists and social media characters can get a good deal of mileage out of speaking to activists who haven’t been media-trained, which is why protesters frequently choose to stay mum. But choosing not to speak is quite different from a concerted effort to prevent anyone from speaking. Given the prospect of looking idiotic, the movement would rather look paranoid, thuggish, and insecure.

    Those qualities would seem to be in conflict with the values 50501 seeks to uphold in their demonstrations, including a reverence for “dialogue” and “empathy.”

    I’m not sure which group the empaths I was trying to dialogue with belonged to. Only one member of the PR brigade was wearing anything identifying group membership, and of his various badges the only one I could easily make out read “Antifa,” a group I didn’t think any real person lacked the self-consciousness to identify with.

    Neither 50501 nor the DSA has returned emails asking if they were the sponsors of this yellow-vested Justice League. But the experience of being effectively forced out was reminiscent of the treatment I received at another DSA event for asking the kinds of basic questions you would expect an organization dedicated to radical transformation would be eager to answer. I understand the desire to stay on message, to avoid putting in front of the camera someone who might say something dumb. If that’s the case, why not make an effort to connect me with someone who can speak compellingly about the movement? Why instead choose to be… assholes?

    What’s ironic is that socialism is a fundamentally idealistic movement. These are people who believe collective action can topple the present hierarchies and reorganize society to serve the needs of the many as opposed to the greed of the few. What does it say about such a movement if it assumes that skeptics aren’t just skeptics, but villains? What does it say about these folks’ trustworthiness if they will only speak to outlets already sympathetic to their cause? How serious are these people if they would sooner believe in the upending of the global financial system than in a journalist’s ability to operate in good faith — or in their ability to hold their own in front of a camera?

    The kid I was speaking to before I started being followed was holding his own. He’d impressed me with both his conviction and his less-than-blind adherence to socialist orthodoxy - enough so that, if I’d wanted to produce something “right wing,” I wouldn’t have had much to work with.

    In fact, until my interviews were neutered by supposed antifascists, I didn’t have much of a story at all.

    Subscribe now

    0 min
  • Timeline: U.S.-Mexico Water Treaty and Disputes
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Research assistance by Kathleen McCook

    The Rio Grande River received a lot of attention during the border crises. Migrants frequently entered the country illegally by crossing the river along the U.S.-Mexico border in Texas. Governor Greg Abbott had a floating border installed on the river, which Mexico argued violated a 1944 water treaty between the two countries.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    The U.S. contends that Mexico was already violating that treaty, but for a different reason. Mexico is supposed to send 1.75 million acre-feet of water (1 acre-foot is nearly 326,000 gallons) to the U.S. every five years from the Rio Grande and six tributaries. In return, the U.S. gives Mexico 1.5 million acre-feet each year from the Colorado River.

    But Mexico is way behind schedule. By late April, it had only released about 531,000 acre-feet during the current five-year cycle, which ends in October. After some political hardball by the Trump administration — which included rejecting Mexico’s request for a Colorado River water transfer — the two countries agreed to a compromise on April 28: Mexico will send up to 420,000 acre-feet by October, depending on hydrology conditions. U.S. and Mexican officials will meet in July to assess those conditions, according to a State Department fact sheet.

    Even if Mexico manages to release that much water, it will still be well short of delivering 1.75 million acre-feet. To address that, Mexico agreed to an immediate release of 56,750 acre-feet from the Amistad Reservoir — which is managed by both countries — and monthly releases from Amistad and another reservoir. It also agreed to let the U.S. get 50% of the water from the six Mexican tributaries, an increase from the one-third called for in the 1944 treaty.

    The deal is related to another agreement, Minute No. 331, approved in November by the International Boundary Water Commission that allows for new strategies, says Rosario Sanchez, a senior research scientist at Texas A&M’s Water Resources Institute.

    “The problem is it is based on the assumption that there is enough water for everyone. There’s not,” Sanchez says.

    Here are 2025 water levels at Amistad Reservoir compared to the previous two years.

    Blue: 2025 Green: 2024 Purple: 2023

    Not good — and this is one of the reservoirs that’s supposed to have monthly releases under the compromise deal.

    Mexico rejects accusations that it’s been violating the water treaty. It blames drought conditions, and the treaty does allow either country to withhold water during times of “extraordinary drought.” The problem, says Sanchez, is the treaty doesn’t define what qualifies as an extraordinary drought.

    “My recommendation is to try to define what extraordinary drought is because it’s not extraordinary anymore,” Sanchez says.

    Here’s a timeline of some key moments since the treaty was signed, including the escalating tensions leading up to the April 28 compromise agreement:

    Feb. 3, 1944

    The United States and Mexico sign a treaty relating to the “utilization of waters of the Colorado and Tijuana Rivers and of the Rio Grande.” It takes effect Nov. 8, 1945.

    1944 Water Treaty1.55MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadAug. 30, 1973

    The U.S. and Mexico agree to Minute 242, which sets salinity standards for the Colorado River. Agricultural runoff increased salinity levels so high that the water destroyed crops in Mexico.

    Minute 242165KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadFebruary 4, 2020

    Hundreds of Mexican farmers occupy the La Boquilla Dam in Chihuahua in protest of the Mexican government’s plans to transfer water to the U.S. They argue that their water needs should come first, especially with the dam below capacity. Mexican President Andrés Manuel López Obrador criticizes the farmers for being too demanding, and the protesters are removed by National Guardsmen the following day.

    September 9, 2020

    Protesters return to the La Boquilla Dam, closing its sluice gates and hurling Molotov cocktails and other projectiles at Mexican National Guardsmen. Three people are arrested. Civilians attack National Guard vehicles that were transporting the arrestees. A firefight ensues, and two people die.

    October 21, 2020

    The International Boundary and Water Commission (IBWC) agrees to Minute No. 325. Mexico says it will provide the U.S. with water from the Amistad and Falcon International Reservoirs to prevent a second consecutive water cycle shortfall just days before the October 24 deadline. The U.S. agrees to temporarily assist Mexico if the transfer from the two reservoirs makes it difficult for Mexican communities downstream of the Amistad Dam to meet their water needs.

    Minute 325 International Boundary And Watter Commision234KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadNovember 7, 2024

    The IBCW agrees to Minute No. 331 to give Mexico more flexibility to meet water deliveries. It also establishes the binational Rio Grande Projects Work Group and the Rio Grande Environment Work Group.

    2024 11 07 Minute No3.74MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMarch 20, 2025

    The State Department’s Bureau of Western Hemisphere Affairs denies Mexico's request for a special Colorado River water delivery to Tijuana. The Bureau announces on X that it’s the first time the U.S. has rejected a non-treaty request for Colorado River water.

    Newsweek reports that about 90% of Tijuana’s water comes from the Colorado River. The decision is praised by U.S. Senator Ted Cruz of Texas.

    Stephen Mumme, a Colorado State professor who specializes in water policy, tells Newsweek that the decision breaks two norms:

    • Avoiding any connection between the Colorado River and the Rio Grande.

    • Not restricting urban water supplies, which take priority during water shortages.

    Sanchez of Texas A&M tells Racket the move was effective in the short term, but she worries about long-term consequences.

    “I don’t like the precedent that it created, because now Mexico can do that, too.”

    April 10, 2025

    President Trump says Mexico is “stealing the water from Texas farmers.”

    April 28, 2025

    Mexico agrees to release up to 420,000 acre-feet of water over the next six months and increase the U.S. share of water from six Rio Grande tributaries.

    State Department Fact Sheet245KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadJoint Statement Issued By Mexican Government348KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload2025 04 28 State Department Press Statement260KB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownloadMay 5, 2025

    The U.S. reverses course and agrees to Mexico’s request to release water from the Colorado River.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.