Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Do Your Own Research: Liber-net's Misinfo Grant Database
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Andrew Lowenthal is a familiar name to many Racket readers. He worked with Matt on the Twitter Files and played an instrumental role in developing Racket’s top 50 list of organizations that are part of the Censorship-Industrial Complex.

    We’ve reconnected with Lowenthal in the last few weeks because of an impressive new searchable database developed by his nonprofit group, liber-net, on U.S. government grants awarded to groups to fight mis/disinformation. We first reported on the database here.

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    It breaks down government grants in the mis/disinformation space going back to 2010. It gives the amounts, of course, but also descriptions and commentary about the grants with links to official information on USAspending.gov, plus a ratings system of one to five flags for each grant. Roughly 100 of 867 grants since 2016 have at least four flags.

    Lowenthal also writes about what he’s learning from the database on his Network Affects Substack. Last week, for example, he analyzed which organizations and countries received the most U.S. mis/disinfo grants.

    For journalists, this database is a treasure trove of information. It doesn’t tell you the whole story about the grants, but it provides a thread for journalists and anyone else to do their own research. I asked Lowenthal about that:

    I think there's actually several dozen stories in there for anyone. And this would be a invitation to anyone out there… what was this project? Who are these people? What were they doing during this time? Each one actually deserves a thousand words on it, or at least half of them do, because there’s some really bizarre kind of thinking around a lot of the activities that people were undertaking.

    One example of bizarre: a $637,000 NIH grant to the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai last year to address health misinformation in marginalized communities. A component of the grant is to develop an app “especially designed for hairstylists and barbers who are known influencers in communities of color. The app will give these community influencers easy access to understandable, reliable, and timely health infographics they can share with clients.”

    Just what you want when you sit down for a hair cut: your barber hitting you up with government-funded health care talking points. The grant was given a rating of five flags.

    I reached out to the medical school’s project leader and the NIH representative listed on the grant, but did not hear back.

    Here’s more of my conversation with Lowenthal about his database and about him, edited for clarity and brevity.

    Greg Collard: How did you get involved in this type of work?

    Andrew Lowenthal: I’ve been involved in it for a really long time because I essentially founded and ran an NGO that worked on these issues for almost two decades. But then there was this drift that I saw starting a little bit before [the first term of] Trump and Brexit, and then once Trump and Brexit happened, it really went into full swing. Essentially all the work politics, speech repression and the safety culture, etc. A lot of eggshells got laid like landmines around the spaces that I was in, and once Covid hit, it really took off. And a lot of spaces that were meant to be defending free speech and expression, not only did they say nothing during the censorship during Covid, but it turns out they participated in the censorship.

    GC: So you experienced censorship in the organization where you worked?

    AL: Well, not in my organization, because I was the director. But I was self-censoring for sure because if I had been honest — or if I'd been direct about what I thought about the pandemic and the Covid censorship — probably half the staff would've left and probably half the funders would've stopped funding us.

    GC: I worked in public radio for years, so I know about self-censoring for sure. So, this database, how did it come about and how long did it take to develop?

    AL: Well, we first started with this policy project, which was about what a new administration could do to essentially dismantle the censorship industrial complex. That started in October last year, and in November we decided to build a database of all the federal grants. And then of course there was this huge two-week period where USAID and DOGE became kind of the talk of the town, but we weren’t actually ready for it. That's when it should have gone out or beforehand, but we were trying to be very careful about what we included and didn't include. Part of the later motivation was to counter what for us seemed like a little bit of [DOGE’s] carpet-bombing approach to defunding this stuff, which generates a huge amount of backlash. We want to provide something a little more precise.

    GC: You recently wrote about the top 30 countries that received grants to address the misinformation. One thing that surprised me is that Ukraine didn’t make the top 30 in either the total amount or the number of awards. Why is that?

    AL: My theory is that a lot of it's hidden because of security considerations. Also, there are not a huge number of organizations that have the capacity to take money for this. The ones that do are really big and it's being included in much larger grants, where Ukraine [mis/disinfo] only represents a small percentage.

    GC: This database is obviously a tool for journalists. Do you see it as a tool for the general public?

    AL: Yes, to a degree, because I also think there are advocates and et cetera out there that would find it useful to know who is actually getting the funding, and potentially more for journalists to kind of understand what was being funded. Because the other thing about this database is we're not saying this is all censorship work, which is why we have the ratings and the flags. If you look at some of the one-flag things, they're quite innocuous and you wouldn't kind of go, hey that sounds like a deeply problematic project. We wanted to capture more broadly what was happening in the grants space. There are a lot of bad awards that are, I think you could say, advancing a kind of censorship system, but not all of it is. So you have to be quite careful to not throw the baby out with the bath water.

    But I think journalists, people who are free speech advocates, would definitely find it quite useful to get a clearer understanding of what actually happened. The narrative that this was all censorship work, that doesn't fit. And the narrative that huge amounts of this were going out to foreign initiatives— there's a certain amount, but it's not the majority of the money. And the narrative that it's all USAID I would say is also not correct. It's actually much more the Defense Department in terms of pure amounts of money, and it's the State Department in terms of number of grants.

    And I should also say this is not a complete picture. For sure there's stuff that we missed. And there are a lot of grants that seem to us very banal, like combatting misinformation around vaping. We didn't include those because we didn't think they seemed in any way controversial. There are 100 or more like that. If we had included them, it would skew to present that maybe the majority of this stuff isn't deeply problematic, but there's a chunk of a third or more that is really a problem. I would hope that one of the reactions to this is, here's a more accurate tool that we can use to define problem areas and actors, rather than just let's destroy this entire department.

    GC: The ratings liber-net gives to grants are subjective. Has there been pushback from any groups about how you rated them?

    AL: Yes, they are definitely subjective and we're clear on what our methodology is. And essentially the more it's something that looks like censorship — so something that's flagging content for take-down is something that's also involved in very high levels of surveillance of citizen speech — those go up to the top [and get rated four or five flags]. But it's subjective in the same way as some place that rates restaurants. You're getting their version of what the best or worst restaurants are. We've basically gone and ranked what we think are the worst restaurants.

    We did have a project reach out to us and argue that their rating was wrong. We listened to them and they made some good arguments, and we dropped them down a couple of flags from four to two. There are 27 with five flags and 77 with four flags. There are really bad ones, but I think it's more this whole kind of group-think that's happening about how to deal with a very messy internet. The overall response to a very turbulent information environment is to consult experts and impose a top-down cleanup operation as opposed to more grassroots and bottom-up solutions, which is a huge flip for that space. One of the things that attracted me to the digital rights space is that its ethos was very much about the people and grassroots. Early internet culture was actually generally a progressive, California-type culture that thought very highly of everyday people for the most part.

    And this [new model] thinks extremely poorly of everyday people. It thinks everyday people are a really big problem. And so it's essentially extremely elitist in how it comes up with these solutions. At some point they went, “Oh, these kind of icky people have gotten on the internet and we don't like them.” Suddenly the “deplorables” got on the internet and they all changed their tune about how fantastic this was all going to be and how much this kind of large scale participation in the democratic process was going to be a good thing. And they went, “Oh, this is bad. Now we have to justify imposing order on the Internet.”

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • ATW Livestream Tonight at 8 PM ET/7 PM CT

    Happy Cinco de Mayo! On tonight’s livestream, Matt and Walter will take a closer look at Trump’s new executive order ending taxpayer subsidization of NPR and PBS. (For a detailed look at the history of those entities and their funding, check out Racket’s timeline on the subject.) They’ll also discuss the sold-out Luigi Mangione musical that’s set to open in San Francisco next month.

    Please tune in at 8:00 PM ET on the Substack App, Rumble, and YouTube:


    Or visit Matt or Walter on Twitter.

    0 min
  • No, State Media and Democracy Don't Go "Hand in Hand." Just the Opposite

    The press watchdog Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting, or FAIR.org, which I read regularly as a young reporter, weighed in on the NPR debate:

    One could look at this threat as part of Trump’s general distrust of major media and desire to seek revenge against outlets he believes have been unfair to him… Going after public broadcasters is also a part of the neo-fascist playbook authoritarian leaders around the world are using to clamp down on dissent and keep the public in the dark, all in the name of protecting the people from partisan reporting. That’s largely because strong public media systems and open democracy go hand in hand.

    Titled “Cuts to PBS, NPR Part of Authoritarian Playbook,” the above is either satire or written by someone consciously ignoring the history of state media. Yes, Car Talk and the MacNeil/Lehrer report were cool, but outlets like Neues Deustchland, Télé Zaïre, and Tung Padewat more often went “hand in hand” with fingernail factories or firing squads than democracy. It’s bizarre to see Americans trying to whitewash this.

    The office of my first full-time reporting job with the Moscow Times was in the Pravda building. I used to spend lunch hours walking through the doors shown in the photo above, beering up in a cafeteria with writers from the sports section of Komsomolskaya Pravda, at the time the Guinness Book record-holder for world’s largest circulation. With over 21 million readers, “Komsomolka” sure as hell qualified as “strong public media,” but hardly went “hand in hand” with democracy. Like the rest of ex-Soviet media, its owed its circulation to decades of forcing insane lies on readers, like cheery dispatches about the “Doctor’s Plot” purges of 1953:

    “Spies and Killers Caught Red-Handed,” Komsomolskaya Pravda, 1953

    The Russian muckrakers of the 1990s threw themselves into the job like superheroes once they got a whiff of freedom, which in their case usually meant being disentangled from the state. That period, like the lives of many of those folks, didn’t last long. Vladimir Putin sent masked police into the last independent TV station on May 11, 2000, capping less than ten years of quasi-free speech. “Strong state media” remained, but actual journalism vanished.

    People who grew up reading the BBC or AFP may imagine a correlation between a state media and democracy, but a more dependable indicator of a free society is whether or not obnoxious private journalism (like the Russian Top Secret, whose editor Artyom Borovik died in a mysterious plane crash) is allowed to proliferate. As for those once-storied European networks, most have now become parodies, operating in concert with multiple official review operations like BBC Verify or the “Trusted Flaggers” of the EU’s Digital Services Act. This layered messaging system essentially guarantees favorable coverage of public policy and is more dangerous than asking the listeners of stations like NPR to pay for media they like.

    As anyone who’s read Hate Inc. knows, I was until recently a proponent of public incentives for journalism, which is necessary but hard to fund. The Post Office Act of 1792 charged publishers fractions of normal postage rates. Western expansion was aided by gratis rides on the Pony Express for “newspaper slips,” and the Communications Act of 1934 helped birth broadcast news by requiring licensees of public airwaves to operate in the “public interest, convenience, and necessity.” After the Public Broadcasting Act of 1967 passed, we enjoyed an imperfect system that left room for public and private innovations, from Sesame Street to Radical Chic. Which was great, but how nuts do you have to be to think “strong state media” doesn’t have a dark side? Is the history of this stuff just not being taught?

    0 min
  • Racket Rewind

    Welcome to Racket Rewind, a recap of everything we’ve published over the past week. Thanks for reading!

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    We know inboxes can get cluttered, so if you’d rather not receive Racket Rewind but still want other emails from us, you can update your preferences anytime in your account settings.

    0 min
  • In Profile About John Fetterman, New York Times Combines Neurology and Politics

    The New York Times ran a piece about how Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman could be “backsliding on his recovery from a mental health crisis”:

    The former chief of staff to Senator John Fetterman, Democrat of Pennsylvania, was so alarmed with his ex-boss’s erratic behavior last year that he wrote a lengthy letter to his doctor… “I’m worried that if John stays on his current trajectory he won’t be with us for much longer,” Adam Jentleson, the former chief of staff, wrote on May 20…

    An avid Fox News watcher, Mr. Fetterman even seriously considered voting to confirm Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, a former weekend host on “Fox & Friends,” according to a former aide. The vote would have signaled a green light to a cabinet appointee who faced accusations of excessive drinking and abusing women…

    It’s not clear to everyone who has worked closely with him that Mr. Fetterman’s political transformation, or his current challenges, is directly related to the mental health crisis... But in his letter, Mr. Jentleson describes unstable behavior he says could be a result of the senator’s failure to follow the medical plan…

    Per the Times, when Fetterman “seriously considered” voting for Pete Hegseth, it might have been evidence of brain damage, on par with “dangerous driving habits,” also described at length. Man, political analysis is getting weird in this country…

    0 min
  • NPR Should Be Axed Because it's Anti-Thought, Not Anti-Trump

    After reading Madame Bovary in college I bought the unfinished novel Bouvard and Pécuchet, one of the last things Flaubert wrote. It’s a furious satire about two bourgeois clerks with no ideas of their own who come into a fortune, travel the world and live through great events, and ultimately return home having learned nothing, despite seeing everything. In American terms, it’s Dumb and Dumber for pseudo-intellectuals. I was too young to appreciate it (it was an older man’s final middle finger to the world’s unrepentant stupidity) but there was a prize at the end.

    The Dictionary of Received Ideas is often tacked to the back of the novel. It’s believed Flaubert meant to publish it either as an appendix, or as a fictional creation of the book’s two idiot-heroes, whose conversations are just exchanges of clichés (“In the long run, solitude is very sad,” or “The beautiful is the beautiful, the sublime the very beautiful”). The “dictionary” is just a monster collection of these empty sayings, sometimes written as instructions on how and what to say in society, as in:

    • AMUSING – Must be attached to all remarks: “How amusing!”

    • HEAT – Always unbearable.

    More often, entries explained what views to hold:

    • DISSECTION – An outrage against the majesty of death.

    • ICE CREAM - It is dangerous to eat it.

    • LEGALITY – Legality is killing us. With it, no proper government is possible.

    Flaubert was nearly driven mad by these ear-piercing snippets of conventional wisdom. He said he wrote Bouvard and Pecuchét to “vomit back onto my contemporaries the disgust they inspire in me.” To be trapped in a world of clichés would seem tyrannical enough to that kind of mind, but what if all those dead phrases and canned non-thoughts were mandatory? What if they were factory-produced as part of a state enterprise? What if “received ideas” were dumped on the public with military regularity, and in conjunction with prohibitions against saying anything else?

    From a Friday story about National Public Radio in the Washington Post:

    President Donald Trump signed an executive order on Thursday evening seeking to prohibit federal funding for NPR and the Public Broadcasting Service (PBS). The order, which could be subject to legal challenge, called the broadcasters’ news coverage “biased and partisan…”

    An NPR spokesperson said early Friday that “NPR’s editorial practices and decision-making are independent and free from outside influence…”

    The zany, sociology-prof-on-molly vibe at NPR is no longer the big story in America. Donald Trump’s unprecedented “assault on our most fundamental rights” is. Just ask NPR, which of course is the problem.

    Once a great American institution, NPR has become a state-sponsored version of Flaubert’s nightmare. Why it has to go:

    Subscribe now

    The station doubtless thinks it’s engaged in “public service journalism” by cranking out piles of stories with headlines like Trump nominee gives misleading testimony about ties to alleged ‘Nazi sympathizer’, Trump cuts demolish agency focused on toxic chemicals and workplace hazards, Asian American voters backed Trump in Nevada. Here’s how they feel about him now, The U.S. set the global order after WWII. Trump has other plans, A legal architect of Guantanamo questions Trump’s El Salvador plan, and on, and on. Its editors either don’t realize they’ve built an abjectly partisan political operation, or, more likely, they’ve been at this so long, they believe ideological uniformity is truth, and by extension, just “the news.”

    It would be depressingly easy to create a 2025 edition of the Dictionary of Received Ideas just by tweaking NPR texts:

    • JOURNALISM - Advances the conversation. Stands out for its thorough research, diverse sourcing, fairness, and fact-checking. George Clooney says the press has a duty to “always question authority.”

    • THIN - It’s back in, but did it ever leave? It’s easier for thin people when it comes to employment and education. With fatphobia, why are so many people comfortable saying the quiet part out loud?

    • RACISM - A public health issue. The accumulated stress from institutional racism has documented effects. Mentorship for Black medical students is crucial as they navigate a healthcare system that is not always welcoming. There’s a new computer algorithm that more accurately illustrates Black hair. If we don’t keep talking about it, whiteness becomes the default for everything.

    • AWKWARDNESS —Part of our lives whether we like it or not. But what if we put the embarrassment aside and embraced our awkward selves?

    If Flaubert had access to NPR’s search tool, he could have a sequel book in six hours. The only challenge would be figuring out how to limit the most important entry:

    • TRUMP - Poses a global threat to democracy. Conspiracy theories about Covid fueled his support among Christian nationalists. He’s a convicted felon now, but what comes next? Meet the conservative women who are keeping their votes for Harris a secret. Instead of a final plea for unity, embraced racist jokes about Latinos. Meet former Obama ethics czar Norm Eisen. His assault on the First Amendment is historic…

    About that: for every unnerving addition to the censorship toolkit that’s come out of this presidency (like the reported expansion of “anti-BDS” rules), there remain dozens of federally funded entities that exist for one of two reasons: to promote groupthink, or stamp out the absence of it. NPR is at the top of the list. Its problem isn’t that it’s anti-Trump, or that it retains its weird addiction to stories like “Bringing diversity to Maine’s nearly all-white lobster fleet” or “Fat Phobia And Its Racist Past And Present” (though that stuff is nuts), but because it’s the most visible symbol of a thought-suppressing bureaucracy that’s not really compatible with our system of media or government.

    The $535 million the Corporation for Public Broadcasting doles out to stations around the country isn’t a lot, in the scheme of overall federal spending. I’d argue the state should feel queasy about spending any amount of the taxpayer’s money on efforts to propagandize against his or her political choices, and that the CPB would properly be shut down overnight if it was as near-exact a mirror of Fox or the RNC press page as NPR is to Democrats.Org. Even if one stipulates it’s too small to need squashing, NPR has come to represent that far larger system of subsidized conformity, infused in everything from Internet search algorithms to AI to academia, whose scale is only beginning to become visible.

    Old friend Andrew Lowenthal’s non-profit liber-net recently published a database of 867 awards issued by the U.S. government related to “mis-, dis-, or malinformation,” completing a painstaking effort at mapping the anti-disinformation sector we could only start at Racket years ago. His accomplishment got significant buzz thanks to another old friend, former Washington Examiner writer Gabe Kaminsky, who along with Madeleine Rowley not only wrote up its publication at The Free Press but quoted a State Department official as saying the administration was “just getting started” on a “spree” of program cancelations. A number of high-profile figures from the anti-disinfo world expressed disgust with the project.

    As Andrew noted in a follow-up this week, those 800+ grants created a field that really hadn’t existed before 2016. Casual news consumers were told these programs supported apolitical activities like “fact-checking,” or were simple service contracts to do things like give out laptops to the disadvantaged. Even I’d have bought it once, but years spent under the hood of “media literacy,” “cyber hygiene,” and “counter-disinformation” initiatives left no doubt that whatever else these programs are about, their essence is about training populations to recoil from some narratives, while embracing others.

    Just to take a few examples: the Department of Justice gave Youngstown State University $449,897 to study “misinformation, extremism, and conspiracism,” via a study that involved scanning social media discussions about topics like QAnon and MAGA. They asked questions like, “To what extent is religious discourse turning militaristic?” and “What is hypermasculinity, and how is it influencing extremist discourse?” Findings were shared with “security-related professionals” so a discussion could begin about finding “possible responses to online radicalization.” Andrew’s list also includes a National Science Foundation grant to the University of Illinois to track the spread of “dubious” Covid-19 misinformation. Racket similarly just received FOIA documents showing DHS officials pondering some of the same issues, as well as broader questions about how to restore faith in institutions.

    NPR is the official media arm of these ideas. If you look (as I did this week), you’ll find that any ideological fixation we spent millions promoting through the State Department or Department of Commerce or National Science Foundation is virtually guaranteed to have been the subject of one or more segments on All Things Considered or Fresh Air.

    I didn’t know what “hypermasculinity” was before reading the aforementioned Youngstown grant, but NPR sure does. They’ve run essentially the same feature on the topic multiple times, profiling the gay rodeo in Colorado that’s a place to “challenge hyper-masculine expectations,” the gay wrestler who revolutionized lucha libre (which until then was sadly rooted in hyper-masculinity), and the young black photographer who used his camera as a weapon against poverty and pressures of hypermasculinity. They’ve likewise covered “online radicalization” (in a series called “Untangling Disinformation”), extremism (in a “News Literacy” series) and conspiracism (UFOs to RFKs: How conspiracy theories went mainstream).

    It’s uncanny. If a federal agency promotes awareness about “health equity,” you’ll be sure to find “health equity” experts quoted by NPR in stories like New Zealand’s Indigenous people are furious over plans to snuff out anti-smoking laws, or WHO renames monkeypox as mpox, citing racist stigma, or Heat makes health inequity worse, hitting people with risks like diabetes harder (because “marginalized communities often have fewer trees”). If there’s a federal grant to battle Covid disinfo, you’ll find NPR denounced the “dubious” messaging in Virus Researchers Cast Doubt On Theory Of Coronavirus Lab Accident, or How Vaccine Skepticism May Affect Efforts To Combat The Coronavirus Pandemic. Once I saw in FOIA documents that the DHS huddled with academics to find solutions to a “crisis of faith in key institutions,” I knew NPR had to have run a piece like ‘A Time To Build’ Author On Restoring Faith In U.S. Institutions. It never fails.

    Creepier still is the fact that not much has changed in the attitudes of affluent urbanites since the days of Flaubert. Especially since Trump arrived on the scene, America’s chattering class has begun to speak the language of the skittish 19th century Parisian bourgeoisie. There must be a gene that’s passed down across centuries to allow Flaubert’s observations to fit so perfectly. Examples include “VACCINATED - Frequent only vaccinated persons,” “POLICE - Always in the wrong,” and “COLONIES (our) - Affect a mournful countenance when they are discussed,” but I thought this was the most amazing:

    • LIBERTY – O liberty! What crimes are committed in your name! We have all the liberties that are necessary. Liberty does not mean license (phrase for conservatives).

    The theme of struggling to find the right “balance” of political or religious or academic freedom against bigotry or extremism or threats to LGBTQ rights was one of NPR’s main themes for years. The station was particularly angry about “liberty” and letting people “make their own decisions” during the pandemic, when it ran story after story with themes like America Relied On ‘Individual Decisions’ To Slow The Virus. It Didn’t Work. Until recently these discussions all tilted in one direction, but “freedom of speech” has recently re-acquired positive connotations. Either way, it’s remarkable how similar French upper-class groupthink was to ours on many fronts.

    That NPR is a wasteland of mindless convention and pseudo-intellectual gibberish isn’t a reason to kill it, though. It has to go because it’s already begun to be remade in the image of state media of the more infamous kind, in which the people running it (like CEO Kathleen Maher or COO Ryan Merkley) sound and act more like political officers than journalists. It’s a free country and media outlets can have one point of view, even relentlessly, but those places can’t be publicly funded. We’re not trying to build a monoculture. Or are we?

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, May 2, 2025: "Are 'AI Friends' the Ultimate Surveillance Tool?"

    Listen to Episode 133

    Matt Taibbi: All right. Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: Walter, you are back at home base.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah, I’m back in the land of society and marriage and all the things that moderate one’s latent psychotic tendencies. And my wife has determined that I speak differently than I did when I last saw her a few weeks ago. And my mouth makes different sounds, she said. And I said, it’s because I’ve had no practice speaking for weeks. This has been the longest I’ve gone without conversations. So if people are noticing that out there, expect it to abate.

    Matt Taibbi: I mean, did it sound drastically different? Did you sound like a raccoon when you first came back?

    Walter Kirn: Well, to me, I sound no different, of course, being quite used to residence in my own mind and mouth. But to my wife who sees me at discrete intervals when she’s traveling, there’s been a marked change.

    Matt Taibbi: Well...

    Walter Kirn: That’s always disturbing to find out that you’re making different sounds, you speak differently, may have adopted a slightly different personality all through solitude, which we’re told is a good thing. But, I’m not sure. We were going to talk about AI friends today, and I’ve wondered if having them in the meantime during this sojourn in the wilderness, this Thoreau-like writing jag I’ve been on, if AI friends prancing around the room in convincing 3D would of accelerated or retarded the process of my becoming loopy.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, it could go either way. I think it probably depends on your underlying psychological situation. But I don’t really think it makes a difference. I think if you’re inclined to go the all work and no play makes Jack a dull boy route, you’re going there anyway sooner or later.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah.

    Matt Taibbi: But as you hinted, yeah, we’re going to talk about, we’re going to do something a little different this week and it’s not like it’s not in the news, it is in the news. It’s just not the hot button partisan topic of the week. At least not yet, it’ll get there.

    Walter Kirn: It’s trending toward partisanship. It’s acquiring a partisan coding, as everything does.

    Matt Taibbi: Everything has to.

    Walter Kirn: They just haven’t quite figured out exactly in what way it’s the current administration’s fault. Exactly in what way it will lead to a fascist autocracy, but we’re getting there.

    Matt Taibbi: Right, right. Exactly. So I guess let’s start with all our old friend and former WEF Young Leader program completer Mark Zuckerberg, who has occupied a variety of roles in American culture in the last eight years. It’s really interesting, isn’t it? He’s gone from being a villain to one side to a villain on the other to being a villain back on the other side.

    Walter Kirn: Well, for me, he’s always been a villain since I saw him. But a super-villain is one who changes form slightly in order to win different audiences’ trust so he can victimize whole new groups in new ways. And when I saw him in this latest video with his chunky SoHo art gallerist glasses.

    Matt Taibbi: I love it. I love the look. Yeah.

    Walter Kirn: Yeah. So most recently, he was an MMA fighter, a participant in sort of esoteric martial arts, a guy on a one-man mission to raise his own testosterone through natural means.

    Matt Taibbi: Just ready to go bow hunting for something.

    Walter Kirn: Right, right. Yeah, exactly. Drag home a wild pig. But now this is that plus Rachel Maddow. And I think he wants to be known as an intellectual who’s leading us somewhere, a visionary. I’m sure everyone in his position has Elon envy at this point. He can’t take us to Mars, but he can take us to virtual Mars, and he seems to indicate that may be more important.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, let’s just listen to what he has to say. But you’re right. I have some thoughts about that. But he’s going to talk about computers possibly as a cure for loneliness, which is very ironic considering the origin story of Facebook to begin with. But let’s listen to what he says.

    Mark Zuckerberg: I think as the personalization loop kicks in and the AI just starts to get to know you better and better, I think that will just be really compelling. One thing just from working on social media for a long time is... There’s this stat that I always think is crazy. The average American, I think has, I think it’s fewer than three friends, three people that they’d consider friends and the average person has demand for meaningfully more. I think it’s like 15 friends or something. I guess there’s probably some point where you’re like, all right, I’m just too busy. I can’t deal with more people. But the average person wants more connectivity, connection than they have. So there’s a lot of questions that people ask of stuff like, okay, is this going to replace in-person connections?

    Matt Taibbi: Can we pause for a second?

    Walter Kirn: It’ll augment it. It always augments it, right?

    Matt Taibbi: When he says this, he’s talking about AI friends.

    Walter Kirn: Now through what dark DARPA study or Johns Hopkins research, did they come up with Americans having space or demand for 15 friends.

    Matt Taibbi: Friend demand.

    Walter Kirn: Did they study people who have 13 friends and say, I’m almost there. And then with two more, they say, stop it. Stop it. People were pushing me around. I feel crowded.

    Matt Taibbi: I have unused friend capacity.

    Walter Kirn: And then they push them up to 20 and they start fighting. It does remind you of the ‘60s, 1950s MK Ultra style programs in which they made these very specific claims about the human psyche. He doesn’t seem to question at all the research, probably because it suits him. If there are, what, 12 friends per American now and Americans are in an average deficit of 12, and he can provide, well, maybe all 12, but certainly half of them from his, I don’t know, lab or on the computer. I don’t know what kind of amplitude and reality level will constitute a human-like friend. I mean, they have to be able to do sort of electro stimulation of our skin. Can they just be a cartoon? Must they be 3D, holographic? Do they need to burst into the room at random times in the manner of independent human beings?

    Because a friend really isn’t a slave, and I suspect he’s kind of talking about slave like beings. Friends are often busy, and I have a feeling that Friend-books or whatever they’re going to call them will always be available. My joke on Twitter was, can they move your couch? Which is my test of friendship. Will they move your couch?

    Matt Taibbi: Will they move your coach?

    Walter Kirn: But he’s very optimistic and I want to hear his answer about whether they’ll replace human beings because I know won’t, not in his mind. I mean, he hopes they will. It’s his unspoken, deepest desire. But he’s going to reassure us, I have a feeling.

    Read more

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.