Real Debate

Real Debate

Download on the App Store

Real Debate episodes

  • Portland, Trump, and Probable Cause

    The panel (all together for the first time in 3 weeks) discusses the riots in Portland and the legality of the Trump Administration response.  Greg notes that federal law permits use of federal officers to defend federal property, noting that Trump’s actions (so far) are legal but are ill-advised.  Jeff decries Trump’s inflammatory deployment of “secret” police in nondescript uniforms without insignia or name badges.  Jim argues that ongoing riots threaten public safety and might well be a form of domestic terrorism, supporting the extension of these efforts into other cities.  Jerad, who has friends and family in Portland, contends that the federal response has made the situation worse, and that Trump’s action recklessly inflamed a situation that was otherwise improving.  The panel draws a distinction between undercover police surveillance, which require anonymity, and police openly suppressing riots in anonymous camouflage; and concludes with a debate about federal intervention in local police issues. 

    1 hr 5 min
  • The State of the Diss-Union - a Mid-Year Check-Up

    Returning from a break over the Fourth of July holiday, Jim, Jerad, and Greg take a mid-year look at the state of the country.  Greg runs through the current situation for the coronavirus pandemic, the economy, and the presidential election; Jim gives a behind-the-scenes look at congressional appropriations on under-the-radar issues like research funding for ALS and rural broadband access; and Jerad laments that we continue to drift into the darkest of timelines with no uniting directives from the Executive Branch. The panel concludes with a debate over presidential leadership in a time of crisis, and specifically if Trump’s response to the pandemic can be compared to Obama’s response in Syria or Bush going into Iraq as a response to 9/11.

    54 min
  • Consistently Inconsistent — the Supreme Court, Chief Justice John Roberts, and June Medical Services v Russo
    We take a broad look at the Supreme Court’s recent decision in June Medical Services v Russo, which struck down a Louisiana law requiring doctors at abortion clinics to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals.  Greg opens with an overview of how the Supreme Court binds itself to its previous rulings; and discussed why Chief Justice John Roberts felt bound to strike it down this year, even though he voted to uphold a nearly-identical Texas law only four years ago in Whole Woman’s Health v Hellerstedt. Jim observes that judicial nominations do not generate the attention you would think, at least on the House side of Congress.  Jeff talks about public perception of legal issues, or the lack thereof.
    59 min
  • Slip Slidin’ Away: Toppling Statues, Cancel Culture and Social Media
    A passionate debate erupts among the panel on the topic of the “Cancel Culture,” Social Media, and the recent anti-police protest movement.  Greg suggests that a line may have been crossed but also that it’s hard to justify using deadly force in defense of Confederate statutes.  Jim contends that an increase in crime and on-going protests and destruction of statues must be contained, or we risk a complete break-down in public safety and societal norms.  Jeff pushes back hard on Jim’s “slippery slope” argument, asserting that going from attacking symbols of oppression to the decline of civilization is a huge and unjustifiable leap.  Jerad contends that the push back on racism has been a long time coming, and is a huge concern for younger Americans.  Greg contends a “law-and-order” backlash has not occurred because, thanks to cell phone cameras, white America finally saw the truth in what black America has been saying for years: that cops are abusive and lie about it when challenged.     After Greg pokes a little fun at Jim, the episode concludes with a virtual group hug to let Jim know that we love him.
    1 hr 16 min
  • The NeverEnding Story: COVID-19

    Unlike most of America, the COVID-19 pandemic did not take three weeks off to protest police violence.  Chris Colby returns to the pod as the COVID-19 expert, and gives updates on the pandemic, including new hot spots in Alabama, Arizona, Florida, and other places with medium-density population centers.  Chris and Greg discuss whether wearing masks is effective (SPOILER: They protect other people, wear them).  Jeff and Jerad describe the social pressure to avoid mask wearing, and how mask wearing has become a political football.  Jim closes out the COVID-19 discussion with a concise and efficient discussion of the politics of the pandemic.  In the final ten minutes, the panel discusses the revelations in John Bolton’s new book, concluding that even if Bolton’s allegations are true it won’t change anyone’s mind about Donald Trump. 

    1 hr 5 min
  • A Modest Proposal: Defunding the Police

    After last week’s intense discussion of racism, the REAL DEBATE panel (Jeff, Jerad, Jim, and Greg) focuses on the practical questions of police reform. Greg describes a reform bill authored by Democrats in the House, and Jim gives an early handicap on its prospects. Jerad and Jeff contend we should take the slogan “defund the police” seriously, arguing for a complete reset in community police relations.  Greg suggests that replacing part of the police function with a social service function will *improve* police effectiveness by taking away duties that police are ill-equipped and unmotivated to perform.  The panel concludes that a sea change of public opinion is happening, and that big changes are afoot.  

    1 hr 13 min
  • The No-Win Scenario: Addressing Racism in America
    Greg opens by describing a scene from Star Trek - where characters are tested by how they handle the “no-win scenario”; and asks if the nationwide protests and violence are Donald Trump’s own No-Win Scenario.    The panel, however (Jeff, Jim, and Jerad) quickly moves on to a bigger discussion of racism and crime in America; Jerad focuses on the threat of explicit white nationalism; Jeff, as the whitest man in America, gets emotional while arguing structural racism and the legacy of slavery are crippling the country; while Jim counters with statistics about racial involvement in criminal behavior, contending that unarmed blacks are not killed by police in greater proportions than unarmed whites.    Greg points out that human beings learn by experience and not through statistics; and that black Americans have long learned to fear the police, with justification, based on their experiences.  Greg notes the War on Drugs has also had an unjust and disproportionate effect on people of color.     The panel concludes with a passionate debate over systemic changes needed to address the deep issues exposed by the protests and riots.
    1 hr 9 min
  • Police Violence in Minneapolis and the Way Forward

    The Real Debate panel discusses the death of George Floyd and protests erupting in Minneapolis.  Greg describes the dark history of police violence in Minneapolis, and why it persists in one of America’s most progressive cities.  Jim finds parallels between the Minneapolis riots and the Rodney King riots in Los Angeles; Jerad argues the divisive and explosive rhetoric of the Trump era is a factor leading to violence; Jeff admits he himself has problems with police despite being the whitest man in America. 

    1 hr 8 min
  • It Wasn’t Over When the Germans Bombed Pearl Harbor

    The panel takes stock of America’s standing in the world on this Memorial Day weekend, with a raucous debate in which Greg is outnumbered 3-to-1.  Jim, Jeff, and Jerad recite the litany of mistakes the US has made over the last several decades, creating an opening for China. Greg erupts in response, pointing out that nearly all of America’s problems are self-created, and if it can get out of its own way, the US is still unmatched in its ability to project power, solve problems, and spread peace and prosperity around the globe. Greg concedes that the American political system is holding the US back, and Greg and Jim have a dialogue about how foreign powers exploit our political problems for their gain.

    57 min
  • Going Through Hell to Get to Heaven

    Can the Center Hold in the age of Cable News and Social Media?  This week's panel (Jeff, Jerad, Jim, and Greg) bemoans the state of political debate in the age of cable news and social media. Greg describes the forces that pull the new media to the extremes at the expense of the middle.  Jim and Jerad discuss the philosophical implications of the modern media world - can argument produce synthesis or does it just push people away?  Jeff argues that the ambiguity of language is a powerful tool that most people use without knowing it, and that they trap themselves into artificially rigid positions.  Greg concludes by going (or trying to go) positive, arguing that Americans will get practical when they need to, Jim predicts we will muddle through, and Jerad thinks it needs to get worse before it gets better. 

    1 hr 3 min

About Real Debate

From the publisher's feed

Gregory Abbott hosts this roundtable discussion on the hottest political news of the day. The Real Debate team is focused on finding the truth among a sea of diverging opinions and media perspectives.