In this episode, Karen bakes delicious, warm Marshmallow Peanut butter Brownies from wwww.beyondthebutter.com.  The sisters highlight the cold case of missing person Shelton Sanders out of Columbia, SC.  They enjoy some yummy herbal tea from Plum Deluxe Tea.  Anne recounts the zany story of the murder of Frank Hilley, and the twists and turns are endless and crazy! Next, Karen unpacks the terrifying and horrendous story of Shasta Groene and her family and how they were brutalized by a serial killer that is one of the worst.