Sugar Coated Murder

By sugarcoatedmurderComedy True Crime Arts Food

Sugar Coated Murder episodes

October 26 Who Was Colleen Slemmer and a Recipe for Caramel Apple Cobbler
In this episode, Karen bakes a Caramel Apple Cobbler while Anne unpacks the case of Colleen Slemmer, who was brutally tortured and murdered by Christa Pike and Tadaryl Shipp. Recently, Christa was scheduled for execution by the State of Tennessee, but after 2 attempts, the execution failed and Christa eventually was returned to prison. We wanted to remind our listeners that while Christa's plight is unusual and ghastly, her devilish deeds far outweigh her outcome! We still want to five Colleen her voice so she is not overshadowed by recent events and does not get lost in the headlines. Please take time today to say Colleen's name so she feels the love and recognition she deserves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
1 hr 2 min
October 08 Scamalicious and Faux Twix
In this episode, Anne whips up some unbelievable copycat Twix bars that put the real ones to shame! You are going to want this recipe for your arsenal of easy-to-whip-up treats. While the chocolate treats are chilling, Karen spills the details about the scam that almost tricked her out of thousands of dollars! If you have ever been victim of a scam (financial, romantic, etc), let us know your story! Email us at: murder.sugarcoated.com
We still have KillaVanilla for sale. Email us for details.
#copycatrecipe #candybar #recipeswap #chocolatecandy #homemade #fromscratch #annevarner #karendevanie #killavanilla #truecrimecommunity
Buy our books on Amazon:
https://a.co/d/0fPlYvwT
https://a.co/d/02CqwcBE

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
54 min
May 22 The Victimology of Gertrude McCabe and a Recipe for Brown Butter KillaVanila Wafer
In this episode, Karen takes her turn behind the mixer and unleashes a batch of Brown Butter KillaVanilla Wafers—cookies so good they’ve risen to legendary status in our kitchen. They’re buttery, they’re bold, and they’re now officially our signature cookie!
While Karen is elbow‑deep in vanilla‑scented bliss, Anne walks us through a devastating California true crime mystery involving the violent loss of 88‑year‑old Gertrude McCabe. It’s a story that shakes you, stays with you, and deserves to be told with care.
If today’s episode fed your soul—whether with cookies or cold‑case chills—don’t forget to subscribe, leave a 5‑star rating, and write a review.
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
50 min
May 04 Teresa Brantley: The Story Behind ‘Deadly Route’ | Sister Speaks Out (1982 Murder Case)
In this deeply moving episode, Anne and Karen sit down with Amanda Seagal, the sister of Teresa Brantley, whose life was tragically taken in June of 1982. Teresa—portrayed as “Georgia” in Deadly Route, part of the Same My Name Series—was so much more than the violence that ended her story.
With honesty and grace, Amanda shares who her sister truly was: her spirit, her memories, and the life she lived before that unimaginable day. This conversation goes beyond the headlines and the crime—it’s about love, loss, and the enduring humanity of a life that deserves to be remembered in full.
We believe every victim’s story deserves to be told with depth, dignity, and heart—not just for how it ended, but for how it was lived. It is with profound respect and gratitude that we welcome Amanda to share Teresa’s story.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
39 min
April 06 Recipe for Strawberry Biscuits and a Sinister Office Grudge
Anne storms into the kitchen this week like a sugar‑dusted superhero, armed with strawberries and zero intention of behaving. She’s whipping up Strawberry Biscuits so fluffy, so radiant, so aggressively delicious they might actually file a restraining order against your self‑control. These little clouds of Spring sunshine don’t just melt in your mouth… they detonate with flavor. And because Anne refuses to stop at “heavenly,” she drenches them in a glossy Strawberry Glaze that could probably convince a grown adult to do her taxes for free.
Meanwhile, as Anne is turning her magic in the kitchen, Karen unpacks the frustrating case of a misplaced, sinister office grudge. When Janet Houser goes out of her way to help out an office friend, her world is shattered and she ends up in a deadly fight for her life. It’s messy. It’s maddening. It’s the kind of story that makes you side‑eye your coworkers for the rest of the week.
So grab a biscuit, clutch your pearls, and dive into the chaos. Listen wherever you get your favorite podcasts — or watch the full, glorious circus on YouTube at Sugar Coated in the House.
Email us at [email protected] for the recipe or just to say Hi.
#officegrudge #Strawberryrecipe #StrawberrySeason

This episode is copyrighted: Sugar Coated Media, LLC

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
54 min
February 12 The Victimology of Sandi Johnson and a recipe for Pawley's Island Pie
On April 26th 1996, in Washington State, a loving mother of 2 left her home to run errands in preparation for her son's 5th birthday. She never made it to her son's party. She was never seen again. In this episode, Anne gives us the victimology and case of Sandi Johson. It's Karen's turn in the kitchen and she bakes up a yummy local favorite - Pawley's Island Pie. It's like if a chocolate chess pie and a walnut pie fell in love and made ooey, gooey goodness and they named it Pawley's Island Pie.
Don't forget to like, follow, and subscribe to our podcast and our social media.
Our latest book, Deadly Route, is out now and available on Amazon. Get your copy today!
Email us at [email protected] to order your Killa Vanilla
#PawleysIslandPie #homemadepie #pierecipe
This podcast episode is Copyrighted

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
33 min
January 30 Anything But Murder Shorty!
In this Anything But Murder Shorty episode, the sisters take a break from murder and baking. Instead, they divulge their beauty secrets and kitchen gadgets.
This episode is copyrighted.
For links to any of these products, email us at:
[email protected]
Sugar Coated Murder is not affiliated with any of these products and receive no profit from discussing them.
#beautysecrets #anythingbutmurder #miniepisode #kitchengadgets #gizmos

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
27 min
January 26 Homemade Peppermint Patties and a Family Annihilation
In this long-awaited new episode, Anne takes her turn in the kitchen. She whips up easy and delicious Peppermint Patties. Of course she breaks out the Killa Vanilla! Unfortunately, she forgot where she found the recipe so you will need to email us to request it for yourself.
Karen unravels the tragic story of a family erased. In October 2014, evil visited the Champion family in Cadiz, KY. It's a bizarre and twisted tale of betrayal, sibling rivalry, and greed.
The sisters wrap it up by talking about their new book,
Deadly Route, now available on Amazon. It's the second book in their 'Say My Name Series'.
This episode is copyrighted.
For sources used in the research, email us:
[email protected]

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
48 min
September 02, 2025 Recipe for Blueberry Almond Pound Cake and the Murders of Richitelli and Altman
It's Karen's turn in the kitchen and she is on a mission to bake her son's birthday cake. As she constructs a gorgeous and delicious Blueberry Pound Cake with an Almond Glaze, Anne lends her perspective on the senseless murders of Emily Richitelli and Ashley Altman. The sisters provide updates on some court cases they have been following, and there are British Bloody Marys involved as well!
Come for the Baking; Stay for the Murder!
Indie podcast spotlight:
Witches Talking Tarot
The Movie Wire podcast

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
1 hr 2 min
August 08, 2025 Where is Crystal Rogers, what's going on in Bardstown, and Chocolate Sugar Cookies with Vanilla Icing
While Anne bakes up yummy Chocolate Sugar Cookies in the shapes of Buffalo and Cowboy Boots topped with vanilla icing, Karen unravels the mysterious disappearance of Crystal Rogers, mother of 5. Bardstown, KY, has a handful of unsolved murders on the books, but in July of 2025, the case of Crystal Rogers was finally solved and justice served!
Anne's recipe hails from our obsession - Sally. There is also a peak into the KillaVanilla factory.
Watch us on YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCHVU8uh8JcVJpeAToW7QBCw
Listen on Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/5qTBuizGMVa3VCpXyHHKQE
Listen on Apple - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/sugar-coated-murder/id1494022162
Indie Pod promo:
Super Familiar with the Wilsons - Josh and Amanda cover it all in an upbeat podcast that explores coupledom and family.
Follow them on InstaGram - https://www.instagram.com/superfamiliarwiththewilsons/
Listen to them on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4xOVZE7hhcQB81gqI9BMVm
#crystalrogers #killavanilla #BardstownKY #chocoatesugarcookies

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
56 min