With Jody McDonald filling in for Bill Reiter, the show opened with Jody reacting to the MLB playoff action as the Yankees kept their season alive while the Mariners took a 2-1 series lead with their win over the Tigers. Jody then highlighted the parity that has engulfed the NFL through the first five weeks of the season. Start/Bench/Cut was next was Jody ranked the best quarterbacks in the NFL this season and the MLB superstar he trusts the most in a big playoff spot. Hour two kicked off with CBS Sports MLB writer Matt Snyder joining the show to react to the postseason action from Tuesday night and previewed all four elimination games on Wednesday. Buy or Sell was next as Jody answered if the Yankees will force a Game 5, if the Bengals upgraded their quarterback room after trading for Joe Flacco and if the Ravens are still his pick to win the AFC North. The show ended with Jody taking a call on NFL parity and if a salary cap would make more teams in baseball competitive.

With Sean Levine filling in for Bill, the show opened with Sean discussing who the best team in the AFC is after the Jaguars upset the Chiefs on Monday Night Football. Sean then discussed why James Franklin isn't the biggest problem with Penn State before giving his Week 5 NFL power rankings. CBS Sports NFL reporter Jeff Kerr joined the show to kick off hour two to discuss whether the Chiefs are in trouble and who is MVP frontrunner is. Buy or Sell was next as Sean answered if Phillies manager Rob Thomson was wrong to bunt in the 9th inning and if Bill Belichick's tenure at North Carolina is more embarrassing than Urban Meyer's run with the Jaguars. The show ended with Sean touching on some of the biggest NFL storylines.

Ryan Hickey Filling In for Bill, 5 biggest takeaways from Week 5 in the NFL, Penn State and Texas are at a New Low, 5 Things you need to know, Garrett Podell joins the show and reacts to NFLs Week 5 games, Buy or Sell

Bill opened the show by praising 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan for finding a way to win despite all of the injuries San Francisco suffered heading into Thursday night. Bill then reacted to the three elimination playoff baseball games before making playoff predictions for the rest of the postseason. Hour two opened with 92.3 The Fan afternoon drive host Nick Wilson joining the show to discuss how he views the Guardians season and his expectation for Dillon Gabriel on Sunday. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the 49ers have a quarterback controversy and if at least two MLB teams with a bye will fall in the division series. The show ended with Bill crowning the Bum of the Week.

Bill opened today's show by explaining why Shedeur Sanders pantomiming answers to the media proves that he is not a franchise quarterback before discussing how much blame Deion Sanders deserves for his son not handling the moment with maturity. Bill then laid out the MLB history that is awaiting the Thursday playoff slate. Would You Rather was next as Bill decided between the Cubs losing in the playoffs or winning Bum of the Year and if he would rather be hot and bad at his job or ugly and good at his job. Hour two started with Substack's Dennis Dodd breaking down the Big Ten's interest in private equity and whether Bill Belichick or Dabo Swinney have more to lose this weekend. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the Rams losing to the 49ers would be the worst loss of the NFL season, if AJ Brown is the most important Eagles offensive player and if Dodgers manager Dave Roberts made the right decision to make a pitching change in the middle of an at-bat. The show ended with Bill taking a call defending Ryan from being named Bum of the Year before wondering if it's socially acceptable to ask his friend if he's related to a famous actress.

Bill opened the show by explaining why the Baltimore Ravens are in trouble and why their season could already be over if Lamar Jackson is unable to play in the next few weeks. Bill then reacted to the Browns benching Joe Flacco for Dillon Gabriel before playing audio to cement Ryan's Bum of the Week crown this week. Start/Bench/Cut was next as Bill ranked the head coaches he trusts most in a fight, the best fall foods and the rookie quarterback that will win the most games this season. Hour two opened with former NFL quarterback Steve Beuerlein joining Bill to discuss his expectations for Gabriel, why CJ Stroud has struggled after a fantastic rookie year and if the growth Caleb Williams is showing is legit. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the WNBA needs a new commissioner, if referees favor good teams and if the Spurs should pursue Steve Kerr. The show ended with Bill and Ryan naming the NFL team that they think has the best chance of drastically turning their season around.

Bill opened the show by breaking down how the Cincinnati Bengals demonstrated in their blowout loss to the Broncos on Monday night that they are one of the worst run organizations in football. Bill then used New York Jets head coach Aaron Glenn and their 0-4 start to highlight how difficult it is to find an elite head coach before giving his Week 5 NFL power rankings. Hour two kicked off with GoLongTD's Ty Dunne joining the show to discuss his concern level with the Ravens and where Jalen Hurts ranks among quarterbacks in the NFL. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if he has an issue with how Ben Johnson handled his halftime interview and the MLB Wild Card series he is most intrigued by. The show ends with Bill saying that Aaron Rodgers won his breakup with the Jets.

Bill opened the show by discussing how the Kansas City Chiefs proved to everyone that they are back after their trouncing of the Baltimore Ravens on Sunday. Bill then reacted to the Cowboys and Packers tying on Sunday Night Football before crediting the Steelers for starting 3-1. Ryan then explained to Bill how he had the worst sports weekend in history before getting into 5 Things You Need To Know From College Football Week 5. Hour two started with former Georgia quarterback Aaron Murray joining the show to discuss why Kirby Smart can't beat Alabama and the biggest issue for Penn State when they play great teams. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if America embarrassed themselves in the Ryder Cup and if he's concerned about the Eagles offense. The show ends with Bill previewing both Monday Night Football games.

Ryan Hickey Filling in for Reiter opens up the show by previewing one of the biggest weekends in College Football, Seahawks are a legit NFC Team, Chiefs and Ravens matchup which team needs this win more? Trey Wallace joins the show to talk College Football, Buy or Sell, and Hickeys version of Bum of the Week.

Bill opens the show by reacting to Tom Brady's newsletter about calling NFL games for Fox while owning a part of the Raiders. Jerry Jones continues to be petty towards Micah Parsons. Would You Rather? Brady Poppinga joins the show. Buy or Sell. Bum of the Week.