Bill opened the show by comparing Aaron Rodgers to LeBron James by saying that both aging stars are no longer worth the headaches they bring unless they are humbled. Bill then reacted to Lions head coach Dan Campbell saying that the NFL's league office intervened with the officiating crew on Sunday night and discussed if that's a big deal or not. Would You Rather was next as Bill chose between having Tua Tagovailoa or Aaron Rodgers as his quarterback, Missouri winning a national championship or the Bears winning a Super Bowl and celebrating Halloween or Thanksgiving. Hour two kicked off with former NFL head coach Herm Edwards joining the show to discuss if the Colts are legit, if referees officiate teams based on their record and the biggest key to success for coordinators becoming head coaches. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if Florida should fire Billy Napier this weekend regardless of result, if Tua has lost the locker room and if adults are allowed to sample ice cream flavors at the store. The show ended with Bill criticizing Tua for not taking accountability.

Bill opened the show by highlighting how the Brewers-Dodgers NLCS matchup could in part decide whether there is a labor strike after the 2026 season. He outlined how the winner could set up arguments for whether a salary cap should be implemented or not before relaying a remedy for sports fans that are frustrated with their team. Start/Bench/Cut was next as Bill ranked which college football coach would win a royal rumble, the most delusional people in sports and the biggest surprises in the NFL. Hour two opened with former MLB player and Padres analyst Tony Gwynn Jr. hopping on the show to discuss whether he agrees that the Dodgers-Brewers winner could impact whether there is a lockout after the 2026 season and what the Mariners winning the World Series would mean for baseball. Buy or Sell followed as Bill answered if Kevin Stefanski's response to Mike Tomlin's comments were appropriate and if he could score a basket against a former NBA player. The show ended with Bill debating whether he wants to allow his high school friends on the show next week when they are all together in New York.

Bill opened the show by explaining how Ben Johnson proved to everyone that he is a legit head coach in the Bears Monday Night Football win over the Commanders. Bill then highlighted how the Falcons upset over the Bills shows how wide open the AFC is this season. NFL power rankings were next as Bill gave his top 5 teams heading into Week 7. Hour two started with CBS Sports college football reporter Tom Fornelli joining the show to discuss realistic head coaching options for Penn State, if Bill Belichick will survive the full season at North Carolina and the number of elite teams halfway through the season. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if Tua Tagovailoa owes his teammates an apology, if the Falcons are a playoff team and if Brice Turang should have let the pitch hit him in the 9th inning of Game 1 of the NLCS. The show ended with Bill highlighting a troubling stat when it comes to teams negatively impacting their rookie quarterbacks.

With Bill back from vacation, the show started with Bill reacting to Penn State firing head coach James Franklin and explained why it was the right move. Bill then took a call reacting to the Franklin firing before telling a funny story from his trip to Paris. 5 Things That Bill Missed While On Vacation was next as Bill reacted to the Bill Belichick rumors and LeBron's injury. Hour two kicked off with Super Bowl champion Joe Theismann hopping on the show to preview tonight's Commanders-Bears game and gave his perspective on Brian Branch's postgame skirmish with JuJu Smith-Schuster. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if Indiana had the biggest win in college football over the weekend and if Baker Mayfield is his MVP pick. The show ended with Bill using the Franklin firing to highlight how little patience there is in college football these days.

Ryan Hickey filling in opens up the show by saying the Eagles offensive struggles are very concerning, Phillies playoff run ends in shocking fashion, CFB Week 7 preview, Cole Thompson joins the show, Buy or Sell, Bum of the Week.

With Andrew Bogusch filling in for Bill, the show opened with Andrew reacting to the reports that Bill Belichick has discussed a buyout with UNC and explained why none of this should be surprising. Andrew then celebrated the Blue Jays eliminating the Yankees from the postseason before diving into Would You Rather, where Andrew decided between a hot fall or cool spring, hot dog machine or slushy machine in his home and Belichick coaching his college team or Urban Meyer coaching his NFL team. Hour two opened with NFL on CBS sideline reporter Evan Washburn joining Andrew to preview this week's Browns-Steelers game, discuss if the Ravens could make a coaching change if their season doesn't turn around and which teams have impressed him so far this season. Buy or Sell was next as Andrew answered if Baker Mayfield is his MVP frontrunner, if the Blue Jays are his World Series favorite in the AL and if the Eagles will score at least 30 points on the Giants. The show ended with Andrew defending the Browns by explaining how they are looking out for Shedeur Sanders by not making him the backup quarterback.

With Jody McDonald filling in for Bill Reiter, the show opened with Jody reacting to the MLB playoff action as the Yankees kept their season alive while the Mariners took a 2-1 series lead with their win over the Tigers. Jody then highlighted the parity that has engulfed the NFL through the first five weeks of the season. Start/Bench/Cut was next was Jody ranked the best quarterbacks in the NFL this season and the MLB superstar he trusts the most in a big playoff spot. Hour two kicked off with CBS Sports MLB writer Matt Snyder joining the show to react to the postseason action from Tuesday night and previewed all four elimination games on Wednesday. Buy or Sell was next as Jody answered if the Yankees will force a Game 5, if the Bengals upgraded their quarterback room after trading for Joe Flacco and if the Ravens are still his pick to win the AFC North. The show ended with Jody taking a call on NFL parity and if a salary cap would make more teams in baseball competitive.

With Sean Levine filling in for Bill, the show opened with Sean discussing who the best team in the AFC is after the Jaguars upset the Chiefs on Monday Night Football. Sean then discussed why James Franklin isn't the biggest problem with Penn State before giving his Week 5 NFL power rankings. CBS Sports NFL reporter Jeff Kerr joined the show to kick off hour two to discuss whether the Chiefs are in trouble and who is MVP frontrunner is. Buy or Sell was next as Sean answered if Phillies manager Rob Thomson was wrong to bunt in the 9th inning and if Bill Belichick's tenure at North Carolina is more embarrassing than Urban Meyer's run with the Jaguars. The show ended with Sean touching on some of the biggest NFL storylines.

Ryan Hickey Filling In for Bill, 5 biggest takeaways from Week 5 in the NFL, Penn State and Texas are at a New Low, 5 Things you need to know, Garrett Podell joins the show and reacts to NFLs Week 5 games, Buy or Sell

Bill opened the show by praising 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan for finding a way to win despite all of the injuries San Francisco suffered heading into Thursday night. Bill then reacted to the three elimination playoff baseball games before making playoff predictions for the rest of the postseason. Hour two opened with 92.3 The Fan afternoon drive host Nick Wilson joining the show to discuss how he views the Guardians season and his expectation for Dillon Gabriel on Sunday. Buy or Sell was next as Bill answered if the 49ers have a quarterback controversy and if at least two MLB teams with a bye will fall in the division series. The show ended with Bill crowning the Bum of the Week.