
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Ella Zane was young, talented, and beautiful. In September of 1903, she was found in the Ohio River, not far from her family’s mansion on Wheeling Island. There was no water in her lungs, and murder was suspected. Before the investigation could begin, her influential family had the case closed as a suicide by drowning.
There was a rumor of hereditary insanity in Ella’s family. When her distant cousin Lila Zane killed a friend, her lawyers used it for an insanity defense.
The mystery of Ella’s death was never solved. If it had been, it would have exposed the impossibility of Lila’s defense.
On September 21, 1907, 19 year old Lila Zane orchestrated the murder of 16 year old Charles Bennett on Wheeling Island in West Virginia. She tried to get her underage husband sent to the gallows for it . Her lawyers chose an insanity defense, unaware that they were probably right. Just not in a way that could be understood at the time.
Labor Day week of 1899, a mysterious young woman named Mrs. Ed Palmer was found dead in a hotel in Washington, Pennsylvania. It seemed like a simple locked-door suicide, but the body had been manipulated after death, and there was no sign of her husband. There was no sign that Ed Palmer even existed.
We visited the former Ma's Tea House in Key West, Florida for this episode. It used to be a brothel owned by longtime local madam Alice Reid. Almost exactly 85 years before we arrived, resident Cecelia Thompson Tunks had been murdered with her own undergarments. The exact same incident happened again 6 months later in Philadelphia. Yet one case went cold, and the other didn't. We explore the crimes of human trafficking, prostitution, vagrancy, and murder.
On Christmas Eve in 1963, Lucille Chester shot her husband Elmer in the small town of Jeanette, Pennsylvania. What kind of woman spends Christmas Day in jail? I'll tell you what kind, and where that kind came from.
Before Bonnie and Clyde, there was a less sexy duo of robbers. Irene and Glenn had clean records then quickly escalated to crime once they met. They killed their way to the electric chair, and Irene became the first woman in Pennsylvania to die by one. The mystery remains: what motivated them suddenly?
On our latest visit to Sleepy Hollow, New York, we researched the village's second most popular ghostly resident. Isaac Van Wart Buckhout killed his wife Louisa and neighbor Arthur Rendall on New Year's Day in 1870. He was hanged and has become a part of the region's haunted folklore.
In Clearwater, Florida in 1915, the charred remains of 19 year old Susie Eliot and her mother Bessie were found in a car that had been set on fire. The chauffeur pointed the finger at the Citrus King of Pinellas County, John Mendenhall, who pointed the finger right back at the driver. The investigation revealed a story of misogyny, immorality, and all three traits of the dark triad.
In September of 1959, Kitty Harrig killed her husband and his mistress in their apartment in the Catskills. The town was shocked because Howard had been philandering for years, and Kitty had always handled it well. What made such a lovely person snap?
From the publisher's feed