The guys went against the critics on this Paul Thomas Anderson–Daniel Day Lewis triumph. Find out why Rotten Potatoes didn't love Tyler's nomination, and just know that this rating is "under protest"!

There are hardly any movies starring Tom Hanks that aren't exceptional. Scott recommended this one—yet another movie he watched 1,000 times in his underwear growing up—but will the guys agree about the Tom Hanks Rule on this film? Find out with us!

Will this "unlucky thirteen" episode stand up against the typically high ratings the guys give? Ok, the truth is, Jake nominated Napoleon Dynamite and Scott may never forgive him for it.

Do our Tots have the stomach for what is about to happen in this episode? We know one thing for sure: ol' Quint doesn't anymore.

The guys review Tyler's all-time favorite: the coming of age powerhouse Dead Poets Society. Will you seize the day and give it a listen?

The RP boys talk about the Kurt Russel/Val Kilmer dynamic duo in Tombstone. Don't worry...there's definitely still some time left to talk about Sam Elliot's mustache and caramel-y voice.

Scott recommends the Will Smith and Jeff Goldblum's tour de force, Independence Day. Did late bloomers, Zack and Jake, think it was a campy mess or a masterpiece? Spoiler: Tyler, who'd seen it plenty of times before thought it was both.

Covering what some would say is a "perfect movie" the guys may have some differences of opinion. This Fincher-Sorkin-Ross-Reznor power combo might have impressed the film buffs, but the blockbuster guys aren't so sure.

Late bloomer, Jake, may or may not like this nomination from Tyler. Scott and Zack had seen it before, but see what everyone thought about this dialouge-packed classic.

Jake nominates this shoot-em-up classic which none of the other guys had ever seen. Join the guys on a roller coaster of opinions, most of which involved this movie not aging well in terms of political correctness.