Saints Or Sinners - St Kilda FC Fans Podcast

Former Saint Robert Eddy joins us to discuss his playing days at St Kilda, what made the successful Saints sides so strong, and how he views the club's current position in 2026.

After a disappointing loss to Hawthorn, Chef Joz delivers a fiery edition of Not Acceptables, while Coach Proc surprisingly urges Saints fans to show some patience and perspective.

We break down the Hawks loss, discuss where the Saints sit at the halfway point of the season, and ask the big question:

Are we being too harsh on St Kilda, or not harsh enough?

Plus our usual segments, listener discussion and plenty more Saints chat. 🔴⚪⚫

The Saints are officially at the halfway point of the season… so where do we really stand?

After our loss to Fremantle, we break down what went wrong, what’s still giving us hope, and whether St Kilda has actually improved this year or not.

We also asked YOU on Instagram:
“Are you happy with the Saints’ season so far?”
…and the responses were seriously divided.

We chat:

• The Dockers loss and key moments
• The huge clash coming up against Hawthorn
• Whether finals are still realistic
• Which players are standing up
• What the second half of the season needs to look like
• And whether this list is genuinely moving forward

The easy part of the fixture is over.
Now the season gets serious.

The Saints got the job done against Richmond, but there’s a lot to unpack. Hugo Garcia and Max Hall brought serious energy, TDK showed some really promising signs in the ruck, and now St Kilda heads into a brutal 3-week stretch that could shape the season. We break down the win, the selection decisions, Mason Wood being sent to the reserves, and whether Ross Lyon has finally found the right mix moving forward.

This week on Saints Or Sinners, the boys review St Kilda’s loss to the Gold Coast SUNS and break down all the key performances and moments from Darwin.

Coach Joz asks the question plenty of Saints fans are wondering — why isn’t Tauru getting a game in the firsts? The boys also chat about Tobie Travaglia and where he currently sits, while Coach Proc runs another chaotic edition of trivia 😂

Plus plenty of laughs throughout the episode, and Joz also addresses some family business in a genuine moment for the pod!!

Another classic family episode of Saints Or Sinners.

#StKilda #AFL #SaintsOrSinners

St Kilda take down Carlton in a dominant performance — but it wasn’t the usual suspects leading the charge.

This week we dive into:

• The unbelievable impact of Rowan Marshall & Tom De Koning (5 goals between them)
• How the Saints’ third quarter completely flipped the game
• Max King’s latest injury concern and what it means going forward
• Brad Hill’s elite season and why he’s flying under the radar
• Fan reactions — the best takes from social media

A statement win with some serious talking points.

A dominant performance from St Kilda with a 101-point win over West Coast.

We cover the key takeaways:
Hugo Garcia’s impact, Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera returning to his best form, the effectiveness (or ineffectiveness?) of the ruck combination, and why Callum Wilkie is the competition’s best defender! All the action plus trivia, fan calls, and more, on this weeks episode of SAINTS OR SINNERS!

A one-point loss to the Crows… but is there more to this story?

A game that slipped away, yet showed genuine signs of progress. Ross Lyon believes the Saints are trending in the right direction at 2-4… but are we buying it?

We dive into:

• The key moments that cost us the game
• The elite patches of footy that show what this team can be
• Who stood up when it mattered (and who didn’t)
• Whether this “improvement” narrative actually holds up

Plus — the coach drops a bold (or bizarre?) call suggesting West Coast could beat us next week… is he playing mind games or is there real concern?

Plenty to unpack after a tough loss — but is this the turning point or just more false hope?

A much-needed win over Port Adelaide — but are the Saints actually building something? 👀

We break down the performance, make the big call on Cal Wilkie as the best defender in the comp (and AA captain talk), and dive into JSOS’ impact down back!

Plus, strong signs from the young core with Mattaes Phillipou & Hugo Garcia, and Nas showing his best again.

Full game breakdown + a retro trivia trip back to the 90s 🎙️

Follow the pod & drop a rating — it helps get us in front of more Saints fans ❤️

#saints #afl #stkilda

After the loss to Brisbane, we break down what’s really going wrong — and why we think Choco Williams could be the missing piece at St Kilda. Coach Proc doesn’t hold back, calling on Nasiah to lift, and we dive into the key moments from the Lions clash.

Plus trivia, fan questions, and plenty more.

🎙️ Saints or Sinners — the honest St Kilda podcast.

The Saints get the job done against GWS… but it wasn’t exactly comfortable in those dying moments 😅

A strong first half had us in control, playing some of our best footy — but things tightened up late and we were forced to hang on. Was it a sign of growth… or did we get away with one?

We break down everything from the game — what worked, what didn’t, and what it actually means for us going forward.

We’re also joined by Amber (the “Saints knock knock girl” 👀), who jumps on for a call — and yes, we put her into the hot seat!