Saints Or Sinners - St Kilda FC Fans Podcast

After a frustrating 0-2 start to the season, emotions are running high on this week’s episode of Saints or Sinners.

Chef Joz lets loose with a passionate rant about the Saints’ skill errors and missed opportunities, while Coach Proc tries to keep things grounded, reminding us it’s still early in the season.

We break down the loss to Melbourne, look at what’s going wrong on the field, and discuss whether it’s panic stations or just early-season rust.

Plus:
• A fan caller Manny goes into the hot seat
• Our St Kilda trivia challenge returns (stat-themed)
• Honest reactions from the Saints community
• What needs to change before next week

If you're a Saints fan feeling the frustration, this episode might be therapeutic listening.

The Saints are 0–1 and the Saints or Sinners therapy session is officially open.

We break down the Round 0 loss to Collingwood, where things went wrong, and whether there were actually any positives to take from the game.

We also look ahead to next week and discuss potential line-up changes Ross Lyon might make, plus we open the lines for fan call / SOS fan mail to hear what Saints supporters really think after the opener.

And of course we host our weekly Saints trivia.

Win, lose or draw… there’s always plenty to talk about.

We break down the Saints’ preseason clash with the Bombers and the emerging Nas + Flying Ryan connection 👀

Chez Joz reviews Trac’s cooking methods... Gee from Red White Black Chat enters the hot seat, and fan mail is BACK.

Plus - Round 0 vs Collingwood.

We’re tipping a win.... oh my.

St Kilda beat Gold Coast in an unofficial pre-season hitout… and Saints fans are already planning the parade.

Tonight we unpack the overreactions, put Z in the hot seat with some Would You Rather questions, fire up a Saints “Who Am I?” trivia segment, and Chef Joz breaks down Ross Lyon’s chat with Damian Barrett.

Plus, we couldn’t resist a cheeky dig at Christian Petracca’s cookbook.

Pre-season win. September vibes. Classic Saints.

#saintsfooty #saintsorsinners #saintsaflpodcast

Season 2 of Saints or Sinners kicks off and the full panel is back - and we’re back with a MASSIVE call… could Nas be on track to become the greatest player in St Kilda history?

This episode introduces new segments including Fan Call Mel in the Hot Seat, while bringing back fan favourites like trivia and the Chef's Knife! We recap the Origin game early, break down what the Saints need to do to win this year, and set the tone for a huge season ahead.

Expect big opinions, honest debates, laughs, and pure Saints energy as we welcome you back for Season 2.

👉 Follow @saintsorsinnerspod for exclusive content, giveaways and weekly episodes.

We’re back for a relaxed December episode as the Saints or Sinners crew checks in, catches up on life post-season, and breaks down everything that happened during St Kilda’s off-season.

We chat through the trade period, the backstory behind the Leek Aleer situation, and how the conversation around it unfolded. We look at Liam Ryan’s marketing moves, the direction of our VFL team, and what all of this means heading into 2025.

Plus, we finish with some early season predictions and a chat about who we’re excited to watch next year.

A chill off-season episode to keep you in the Saints loop over summer.

From new signings to captaincy changes, this trade week episode has it all! We discuss every Saints move, the Marshall-to-Geelong rumours, Steele stepping down as Captain, the arrival of Sam Flanders and what a 2026 premiership plan looks like. Oh, and of course there’s trivia — trade week style.

Join us for our annual Grand Final preview as we dive into the Geelong vs Brisbane matchup and share our predictions. Of course, it wouldn’t be complete without a few Saints references along the way. Coach Proc breaks down the Liam Ryan trade, and we record our first-ever live show from Queen of Margherita in Bentleigh. It’s a little chaotic, but that’s exactly the vibe we love.

We break down St Kilda’s rollercoaster season with our highs, lows, and Sainter of the Year! Plus, we dive into the big trade talk—Leek Aleer, Flying Liam Ryan, Sam Flanders, Cam Mackenzie and more potential signings on the radar. Don’t miss our unfiltered take on where the Saints must go next!

Crawf gives us glowing feedback after last weeks pod, Darcy Wilson lights up with five goals, and we break down the Saints’ season — the highs, the lows, and who needs to step up next year. Trenna wraps things up with his fantasy finish, plus we chat through the last game of the season (but not our last episode). Don’t miss this one!