I'm sure everyone is absolutely pumped to see who wins Holiday Cheermeister this year in Whoville, but I got my money on one particular green underdog (I wish it were undergrinch and I was the one under him hubba hubba!). Alex Bigelow (@a__biggs) was scared of the Grinch so we watch him. We watch him very closely

Grab your pogo sticks and little pedal cars, babies, because Cara Meyers (@carameyers) scares us all the way to Ireland with Leprechaun! Yikes! Also Tanner brings up whether or not baptism is necessary for salvation for a third time on the podcast (and this time Erin DOESN'T edit it out). Luckily, Cara doesn't try to convince us all to leave and Tanner doesn't kill a mouse, otherwise we may have missed a visit from the Leprechaun (Allyson Phillips (@allyson.grace.phillips)), who teaches us a great deal about magic and being a father.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

It's 8pm, you're calling your mom to come pick you up from a sleepover because your friend's parents are making you go to sleep before the clock hits double-digits. On the ride home, your parents talk to you about drugs, alcohol, and tummy piercings... they've just seen the movie Thirteen. You don't listen, you shoplift this episode from the itunes store. If this scenario freaks you out, then watch out because Alan Johnson (@alanjohnson____) exposes us to some graphic content with the movie Thirteen this week. Then, thirteen year-old Evie Zamora (Stephanie Burchinow (@stephburch1)) comes over and makes everyone uncomfortable.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Yeah, Fortnite, we 'bout to get down because Derek Mari (@directorderek) has us watch Signs. It's a real spooker rated PG-13 because of TERROR!!! We also find out the mysterious origins of the Tomato Town song. Then of course we are joined by Bat Handler Patrice Slugger (Kati O'Hearn (@katiohearn)) who scares us half to death by telling us what the movie might have been like without their contributions to the project.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Grab your tiny hat and give it to your friend so they can help you escape your school! Anna Bezahler (@annabezahler) has us watch the horrifying Madeline. I almost typed Matilda, I can't get it through my head which is which. Anyway this is a movie about a bunch of girls who, according to Lord Covington (Isabella Escalante (@isabellaesc)), live in a hotel. Luckily not very much money is lost, so I wasn't scared.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Listen up fooglies, John Chapman (@chappy127) is here to have us watch Spy Kids. So grab the brand new product from Totino's: "pizza," and play this podcast backwards. Also Floop (Meredith Dillon (@meredithdillon)) comes by to talk about his egg.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Secret note: "Erin Rules" (but said like how Bill Nye says "science rules" in the intro to his show).

Hope you like big babies, because we got the biggest one since Honey I Blew Up The Kid! Bō! Sarah Bebb (@just.kissing.improv) has us watch the all time spooker, Spirited Away, and I just know all you piggies will eat it up. While I do like Sarah, I do not love her and I think I'm allowed not to, but do I love Matt Adams? Do we get to the bottom of it? What is the little ball? Will someone who IS NOT THE GUEST interject to give interesting and useful context? Who knows. Also the ghost No-Face (Ann Maddox (@mikiannmaddox)) shows up and wants friends, which I'm fine with because you can be friends with someone even if you don't love them yet.

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

What's your favorite Scary Movie Sleepover?! Better decide quick before a Weinstein changes the name to Scream Sleepover! Jake Jabbour (@wakeupwithjacob) has us watch Scream, but first he brings us Jiffy Pop (Matt messed it up somehow though so it didn't get as big as in the movie). A little behind the scenes trivia: I'm very tempted to title the episode Scream (1996) because I know it would make Matt mad. But... isn't someone knowing how to make you mad pretty much as good as them knowing how to make you happy? It means they know you and that's love, right? We'll get into more about whether or not I love Matt on the next episode. For now, we need to talk about popcorn, Lillard, and if Tanner's legal pad is normal-large or comically-large. Also if you press your head up against the bathroom stall you may even hear Ghostface himself (May Darmon (@maydarmon)) being strangely affectionate towards one of the hosts of the pod!

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover Letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Sound effects used under CC BY 4.0 by ondrosik and InspectorJ.

Wake up all you tub-sleepers! Our main man Truman Burbank is here thanks to Bri Rodebaugh (@brirodebaugh) who has us watch The Truman Show. Do we think the whole world is watching us? Is there a whole bar themed after us? Is a man in a tub splashing with joy at our actions? We try and figure it out and we almost figure it out over a nice cool Coors Lite (as seen in Scream VI) talking to townsperson Jason Venice (John-Michael Sedor (@2names1man))

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover Letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.

Welcome to Primetime, listener! Lehr Beidelschies (@lehrbeidelschies) absolutely spooks out the Brave Boys by having us watch the spooker A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors! So don't fall asleep, otherwise you'll piss yourself (if you are able to piss yourself... let us know, we're conducting a census like the famous census from Women Talking). Unfortunately, Matt dozes and Freddy Krueger (Erin Smith (@erinonainen)) shows up and is honestly pretty rude and hates James Wan?

Follow Tanner on Letterboxd as tabner and find Matt by searching through who Tanner follows. Or follow the Scary Movie Sleepover Letterboxd account!

Our editor/producer is Erin Kelly Smith.