This week, Jay, Val and the Slingshot Kid watch My Bloody Valentine and discuss the murder of Tara Grant.

Jay and Val talk about one of Jay's favorite movies: Identity and the murder of Inez Kelly.

Jay and Val are joined by Bryce this week to talk about The Conjuring, The Los Feliz Murder mansion and other crimes.

Jay and Val are joined by The Slingshot Kid to discuss 2005 french horror film, High Tension and the Papin Sisters.

Join Jay and Val as they talk with Sam about the movie American Psycho and Robert Durst.

Jay and Val are joined by Sam to talk about the movie Stay Alive and the Blood Countess, Elizabeth Bathory.

This week Jay and Val are joined by Spencer (the slingshot kid) and a man who may or may not actually exist, Dan, to discuss The Fourth Kind and the murder of child actress, Judith Barsi.

This week Val rejoins to discuss Krampus and the murder of Jonbenet Ramsey.

Jay is joined by Spencer and Ryan to talk about The Rite and the death of Anneliese Michel.

This week Jay and Val are joined by friends Chante and Logan to watch The Silence of Lambs and talk about Ed Gein, the murderer that inspired many horror movie characters.