In this episode of Sci-Fi Graveyard, Joseph, Jeremy, and Josh travel to Arrakis to review David Lynch’s 1984 adaptation of Frank Herbert’s Dune. Released to mixed reviews and box office disappointment, the film has since gained a cult following for its bizarre imagery, unique production design, and star-studded cast including Kyle MacLachlan, Patrick Stewart, and Sting.
The discussion delves into the film's chaotic production, noting that David Lynch considers it the only real failure of his career and refuses to release a director's cut. The hosts debate the effectiveness of the "inner monologues" used to convey the characters' thoughts, a technique rarely seen in modern cinema. They laugh about the weirdness of the Harkonnens (floating fat man, heart plugs), the practical effects of the sandworms, and the infamous scene of Sting in a winged speedo. The crew also compares the 1984 version to the 2021 Denis Villeneuve adaptation, noting how Lynch tried to cram the entire dense novel into one movie, resulting in a rushed and sometimes confusing narrative. Despite its flaws, they appreciate the film's ambition and unique style, ultimately voting to let it "Rest in Peace" as a singular, if imperfect, vision.
Key Highlights
[03:41] David Lynch's Regret: Joseph shares trivia that David Lynch considers Dune the biggest failure of his career and refuses to revisit it or create a special edition, citing the painful production experience.
[10:01] Sting Trivia: A funny story about Patrick Stewart not knowing who Sting was on set, asking if he was a solo artist and being told he was in "The Police," which Stewart mistook for a police band.
[13:04] "Marshmallows": The crew points out a weird detail where the characters refer to marshmallows as "marshmelons," a joke from the novelization that accidentally made it into the movie script.
[29:00] The Floating Baron: A discussion on the grotesque Baron Harkonnen (Kenneth McMillan), whose suit required him to be suspended by wires to simulate his anti-gravity suspensors, adding to the film's unsettling atmosphere.
[34:02] The Shield Fight: The hosts express disappointment that the early shield fight between Gurney Halleck (Patrick Stewart) and Paul (Kyle MacLachlan) didn't foreshadow a similar mechanic in the final duel with Feyd-Rautha (Sting).
[40:00] 21 Books?!: The crew is shocked to learn that the Dune book series expands to over 20 novels (including those by Brian Herbert), highlighting the immense lore that the 1984 film tried to condense.