We learn who the two returnees will be, but that's not the only twist in store in the Pearl Islands today. Scott and Brandon talk merge, reveal all 10 voting confessionals, and celebrate a big milestone for the podcast!

The biggest twist in Survivor thus far is here, and Scott has reactions to it all. We talk about all the different firsts from Part 1 of the episode and look ahead to who Scott thinks may return to the game in the beginning of Part 2!

Island of Misfit Toys

It's an attempted mutiny on Drake when they lose their third Immunity challenge in a row. Can Rupert's social connections keep him safe? We also talk about the what-ifs for Drake if they hadn't thrown the challenge several episodes ago, along with a very special Survivor-themed birthday!

With Rupert starting this episode over at Morgan, things continue to turn for the two tribes. We discuss Shawn's attempt to convince Drake he disliked Burton, Rupert's new human and reptilian friends, and which player Scott is feeling good about after the latest tribal council!

Drake's members are getting tired of each other and each takes a different route to the same plan for the Immunity challenge. We also hear about Scott's unfortunate Thanksgiving and fortunately realize what not to do if we want his Christmas to be better.

The steamrolling continues in this episode, as Drake appears to be unbeatable. It is an epic immunity challenge, though, as the strongest members of each tribe do battle for over two hours. The losing tribe's leader makes a promise before tribal that he fails to keep, which irritates the voted-out castaway.

After two episodes in the Pearl Islands, Scott has started to have a strong tribe preference. We explore why that is, while Rupert explores the ocean for some precious lost treasure.

Survivor: Pearl Islands gets off to a fast start in the premiere, with the contestants heading to a local market in order to get all the materials they will need for the rest of the game. One tribe is much more together during this surprise challenge, while the other is frantic. Their lack of unity is on full display throughout the episode.

At the end, Scott will make his initial winner pick for the season!

It's a very special episode of the show, as Brandon's wife Caroline joins to discuss the Survivor: The Amazon reunion, compete against Scott in trivia, and give her thoughts about the season as a whole. There is a big reveal for Scott along the way and a surprise unlike you've ever heard on Scott Survives Survivor!

Caroline's Instagram

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to Rob Has A Podcast

After Heidi was voted out, Jenna is all alone and expecting to be the next person gone. But there is always the question of who will win the immunity challenges. Is Jenna up to the task? Or can Rob close the deal on his dominant strategic performance with the season victory? We spend a lot of time breaking it all down and adding a new season and a new winner to our working rankings.

Scott's Current Rankings

Season

Winner